ANALYSIS OF THE LAND REGISTRATION ACT,2012 Introduction Land has remained an emotive issue for a long time in Kenya. Security of land rights has over a long time not been guaranteed in the country. This in turn has affected investments in the land sector and exploitation of land based resources as well as observed trend in the continued existence of Internally Displaced Persons (IDP) in the country. Quite importantly, a large proportion of Kenyans are not satisfied with the current status of the principle of secure land rights hence the urgent need for reforms. The promulgation of the Constitution of Kenya set the ball rolling the process of its implementation through the enactment of different legislations and setting up of new institutional frameworks as envisaged in the new Constitutional dispensation. One of the major sectors that the Constitution set out to revolutionize was the all too important land sector. Chapter Five, Part I of the Constitution is dedicated to provisions on Land matters. This particular Chapter also lays out broad principles through which land and the environment shall be managed. These broad principles are expounded in the National Land Policy (NLP) which informed the Constitutional provisions to a large extent. The Constitution has therefore caused a major shift in the land –sector by requiring the Parliament to pass various pieces of legislation and generally providing for land matters in a dedicated chapter. However, to understand the current developments in 1 the land sector, it is important to trace the genesis of the land reform agenda and the reasoned why change was desired. The Land Registration Act, 2012 will be the singular law to guide the registration of title to land in Kenya, earlier done under various statutes like the Land Titles Act Cap 282 earlier applicable to properties within the ten mile Coastal strip and the Registration of Titles Act Cap 281 earlier operated under a Centralized Land Registry at Nairobi for properties surveyed under precise boundaries. It also repealed the Registered Land Act Cap 300 which applied to most rural properties surveyed under general boundaries and some few urban properties surveyed under the “fixed boundary” provisions of the Act. This Land Registration Act also repealed the Indian Transfer of Property Act 1882 and the Government Lands Act Cap 280. The application of this law will result in a uniform land registration system and uniform registries countrywide. This will ease land transactions and land development in the country. This Act received presidential assent on 27th April 2012 with a commencement date of 2nd May 2012. Salient Features of the Land Registration Act, 2012 The Act gives effect to Article 68 of the Constitution. It provides for the revision, consolidation and rationalization of the law governing the registration of title to land, regulation of dealings in registered land and to give effect to the principles and objects of devolved government in land registration. In light of this, the repeal of the Indian Transfer of Property Act of 1882, The Registered Land Act Cap 300, The Registration of 2 Titles Act Cap 281, the Government Land Act Cap 280 and the Land Titles Act Cap 282 is recommended. The Land Registration Act 2012 is procedural in nature and serves to deal with land registration in Kenya. The Act has striking similarities to the Registered Land Act Cap 300 with only a few deviations on some provisos. Perhaps this is due to the fact that it was the intention of the Government not only to try and bring all land under the RLA registration system, but also to simplify conveyancing to the extent that the ordinary man could convey and deal with his land. Unfortunately this did not happen due to myriad of reasons key among them corruption of the land officers and lack of complete and up to date records in the district registries. The framework of Organization and Administration of Land in Kenya has been changed. The officials that shall be dealing with Land registration shall be as follows; i. The Chief Land Registrar duly appointed by the Executive through the Public Service Commission. The credentials of the aforesaid officer are outlined and include being an advocate of the High Court of Kenya of not less than 10 years standing. The Officer should also meet the Chapter Six requirements of the Constitution. ii. Any other official appointed by the Public Service Commission for the discharge of functions under the Act. 3 The Officers shall be competitively recruited and vetted by the Public Service Commission, which lies within the Executive arm of government. The said Officers shall also be deployed to various Counties. (a) POWERS OF THE REGISTRAR The Powers of a Registrar are outlined in Section 14 as; i. To request for the production of documents for dispositions and dealings with land. ii. Issuance of summons to parties involved with any land transaction to give information with respect to the disposition and dealings with land. iii. Reject registration if certain aspects of the dealings of the land are not satisfied. iv. To administer oaths or take declarations and may require that any proceedings, information or explanation affecting registration shall be verified on oath or by means of a statutory declaration. v. Order for reimbursement of costs spent by his office on behalf of persons in connection with investigations and hearings held by the Registrar. (b) ORGANISATION OF LAND For registration purposes, there shall be the creation of both Registration Units and Registries. 4 (c) REGISTRATION UNITS The National Land Commission (NLC) in consultation with the County Governments by Order may constitute area(s) of Land to be known as Registration Units. Units are then divided into Sections and Sections divided into blocks all with distinctive names, letters and Numbers. The same shall be gazetted and published in two newspapers of wide circulation. It is important to note, that the creation of such districts should take the principles of devolution into consideration. The Act also emphasizes that easy public access to these registration unit is crucial. Devolution principles have to be considered. (d) REGISTRIES There shall be maintained in each registration unit a land registry. Under Section 7 the land registry shall contain a land register in the form to be determined by the Commission. The Register shall contain; the cadastral map; parcel files containing the instruments that support subsisting entries in the land register and any filed plans and documents, which must be geo-referenced; a book, to be known as the presentation book, in which shall be kept a record of all applications numbered consecutively in the order in which they are presented to the registry; an index, in alphabetical order, of the names of the proprietors. 5 a register and a file of powers of attorney any plans which shall after the date appointed by the Commission be geo referenced Such registers shall be accessible to the Public at Large and shall take into consideration the Freedom of Information and access to Information Legislation. The newest addition to the section pertaining Registers is the provisions touching on the Community Land Registers in section 8. The Act proposes that subject to the Community Land Act, there shall be the maintenance of a community land Register, which shall contain; A cadastral map showing the extent of the community Land Name of the community Register of members of the Community The user of the community land Identity of any Group Representatives Names and members of the Group Any other requirement from an Act of Parliament. Other Key changes that should be noted and may affect the operations of your business processes are as follows; (e) OVERRIDING INTERESTS Please note that under Section 28 there has been the inclusion of spousal rights over matrimonial property; and trusts including customary trusts as overriding interests. 6 This is in addition to the other more traditional forms, such as the right of way, compulsory acquisition, installation of fundamental infrastructure such as roads, electricity poles etc. The introduction of matrimonial property as an overriding interest is a plus as it essentially ousts the Matrimonial Properties Act of 1882, which is an archaic piece of legislation. This however may cause confusion given that they are not noted in the register, leading to the question on how one can go about identifying such interests. It would be in the best interest of lenders to have this particular interest noted in the Register, to make it easier to ascertain the state of the land offered as security. (f) PREJUDICIAL DISPOSITIONS Sections 52- 54 are quite elaborate on the same. They stipulate that the Court can issue such orders as it deems fit to set aside transactions undertaken to defraud creditors. A disposition prejudices a creditor if it hinders delays or defeats the creditor’s right of recourse against property belonging to a debtor. Essentially the Act seeks to protect the creditor’s security. The new law provides that the registrar may refuse to list any such prejudicial dealings and what’s more, the creditor can apply to court to have such a transaction set aside. However, the Act also takes into consideration the innocent parties that buy such land. It outlines the court can make an order for restoration or reasonable compensation so long as such a person did not have any knowledge (actual, implied, constructive ) of the character of the disposition and bought the land in good faith. Such a provision is 7 welcome for banks and other lending institutions since their security is amply protected. (g) OWNERSHIP OF LAND BY MINORS The Act has also clarified on the issue of minors owning land. The Act under section 47 makes it clear that it is possible for a minor to have a title deed issued in his/her name but the registrar shall restrict such a child from dealing with the land. So, do note that even where a minor can own land, he or she is restricted from dealing with it given that he or she does not have the capacity to enter into various agreements/contracts with regard to land transactions. (h) CO- TENANCY Part of the Act deals with Co-tenancy (Initially referred to as Co-proprietorship) and Partition. Under this part, S.91 stipulates that any instrument made in favour of two or more persons and the registration giving effect shall show that they are either joint tenants or tenants in common. Each share that tenants in common own should also be indicated in the register. However, it is necessary to note that under S.91 (8) a joint tenancy can only be created by spouses, unless one has the leave of court to create such a tenancy. This clause is to be too restrictive. A spouse shall now have an interest in Land acquired by the other spouse, if he/she contributed to the productivity of that Land. 8 (i) LEASES Part IV of the Act involves Leases, however the more substantive provisions are contained in the Land Act 2012 as analysed in this study. Some provisions that are worth noting include; (j) SECTIONAL PROPERTIES Sectional properties registration shall be carried out in the manner prescribed in the Land Registration Act. Therefore the Sectional Properties Act (SPA) still remains the reference point for the procedural law in terms of sectional properties. However the repeal of the RLA, on which the SPA is hinged, shall make the implementation of the SPA impossible as the provisions on the same are not included on the Land Registration Act. (k) LONG-TERM LEASES Section 54(5) provides that the Registrar shall not register long-term leases over apartments, flats, maisonettes, townhouses or offices having the effect of conferring ownership, unless the property comprised therein is properly geo-referenced and approved by the statutory body responsible for survey of land. The additional requirement for survey of the long term leases therefore means that such transactions shall take a longer time and might essentially translate into more transactional costs for developers and purchasers alike. The effect on the lender is mainly where the purchaser has taken up a loan facility to purchase a property registered under this regime. The 9 new proviso effectively means that the perfection of such a security might take a longer time and might discourage the lenders from accepting such leases as forms of security during the initial purchasing period, to the detriment of the borrower. There shall be some advantages however, given that these properties shall now be on record and one shall be able to carry out relevant due diligence searches on individual units. (l) CHARGES Part V of the Act outlines the provisions on charges. As stated earlier, there has been a change of terminologies with regard to instruments used to create an interest in land or a lease securing the payment of money to a lender. The settled terminology is now “charge” Every instrument shall be in prescribed form. However, the Act does not provide for variation of these prescribed forms with the approval of the Registrar, as found in section 108 of the RLA Cap 300. This essentially has the effect of curtailing novel approaches in land transactions in the creation of charges in different scenarios. The Charge shall be completed by its registration and shall be noted as an encumbrance on the register. If registration is not done, such will fall within the realms of a contract which deprives parties of the powers and remedies of a Chargee or Chargor as outlined in the Land Act. A Charge shall not be registered unless proper rent and rates clearances and consents are sought and produced to the Registrar before registration. 10 m) CHARGES ON MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY Section 93(3), states that if a spouse(s) who holds land or a dwelling house in his or her name alone, and wants to undertake a disposition of that land or dwelling house, by offering for instances the land or dwelling house as security to secure a loan. Such a lender must make inquiries as to whether the other spouse has consented to the disposition. The land Act is emphatic on the form of this Consent. If such consent is not ascertained, then the transactions so stipulated shall be void, unless the other spouse consents to the same. Such a situation fundamentally leaves the lender without any form of recourse if such consent was not obtained as required. This provision shall have various implications on a Lender’s processes. The Processing of the loans in particular might take a longer time as it adds an additional burden of inquiring on the consent of the other spouse during the credit assessment period. (n) TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS AND SAVINGS TOUCHING ON CHARGES AND MORTGAGES Section 106 indicates that the right and liabilities and remedies of parties under a mortgage, charge and memorandum of equitable mortgage under the repealed Acts shall not be affected when the Act on the commencement of the Act. If there any discharges, re-conveyance inter alia, to such instruments, shall be done in the manner provided in the Repealed Acts. Therefore, any forms of securities that the lender holds, 11 shall not be affected by the passage of the Act into the Act, and shall continue as prescribed by the various repealed Acts namely (GLA. RLA, RTA, LTA) Section 107 (2) further stipulates that any steps that were taken to create , acquire or assign interests in a certain property before the passage of the Act, such transactions shall be done in accordance to the laws applicable - as long as the same is specifically provided for in the Land Registration Act. One can therefore rest easy, in that, any ongoing process of securitization if and when the Act passes to Law shall not be affected, and shall go on as before. Further, any instrument executed before the commencement of the Land Registration Act, where-by the disposition is permitted under the Act, maybe presented for registration in the prescribed register. However, the Registrar has the discretion to determine whether to register the same with reference to the law in force at the time of execution, or to register the document as if it had been executed after the commencement of the Land Registration Act. We opine that the Registrar should not have discretion to decide, but should be guided by a provision that is specific, to maintain consistency in the application of the rule. Section 108 states that any administrative action given prior to the coming into force of the Act shall have the same force and effect even though it was made under any repealed laws. This is so long as such orders are recognized by the LRA. (o) Savings and Transitional Clauses 12 The savings on land register are outlined under section 104. The section states that “a register maintained under any of the Repealed Acts shall on the commencement of this Act be deemed to be the land registers for the corresponding registration district established under this Act”. Transition requirements as regards titles are outlined in section 105. The section stipulates that any Grant or certificate of title registered under the repealed RLA Cap 300 and RTA Cap 281 Act shall be assumed to be registered under the Land Registration Act. All folios of the registers under the said Acts shall also be deemed to be under the Land Registration Act. Both the RLA and the RTA titles shall therefore undergo automatic conversion by operation of law. However, land owners with GLA or LTA title will have to wait until the Registrar causes the Titles to be examined. The Registrar shall thus prepare a register in prescribed form showing all the subsisting particulars affecting the parcel which shall be capable of registration under the Act. A notice shall be sent out to the proprietor(s) of the Land, of the intention to register the Land under this particular Act. The Proprietor shall thereafter, upon request, be issued with a certificate of Title or certificate of Lease in the prescribed form. The National Land Commission is supposed to further come up with regulations on the conversion of titles but no time frame is set. If that is not done, the land affected by the Act shall not undergo transfer and shall retain the old profile and hence defeat the 13 purpose of the consolidation and harmonization of the laws under the new land Acts. The Act has also not indicated as to who shall bear the costs of the transaction of this transition. Should it be the Government or the Proprietor of the Land? (p) COURT JURISDICTION ON LAND ISSUES Parliament passed the Environmental Court Act in 2010 to establish the Environmental and Land Court (ELC). The Court has original and appellate jurisdiction to hear and determine all disputes in accordance with Article 162(2) (b) of the Constitution, the provisions of the Act or any other written law relating to the environment and land. Additionally, the Court can adopt and implement, on its own motion, with the agreement of or at the request of the parties; any other appropriate means of alternative dispute resolution including conciliation, mediation and traditional dispute resolution mechanisms in accordance with Article 159(2)(c) of the Constitution. S.31 of the Act has repealed the Land Disputes Tribunal Act, No.18 of 1990 which established the Lands Disputes Tribunals. In light of the above, the Chief Justice of Kenya published practice directions in relation to all land matters that are pending before the courts and the Land Tribunals. This is in a bid to streamline operations of the Courts in relation to environment and land matters vis a vis the provisions of the ELC Act. Please note that the ELC is still in its formative stages (the Judiciary Service Commission is currently in the process of recruiting the Judges of the said court) and 14 until it has been fully operationalized, the practice notes shall serve as a guide to aid in smooth transition. In relation to this, Section 101 stipulates the Environmental and Land Court, established under the Environment and Land Court Act of 2011, as having the jurisdiction of all matters regarding land issues. This is a court of Original Jurisdiction. Therefore any disputes, actions and proceedings so instituted in terms of land issues shall lie within the exclusive jurisdiction of the aforementioned court. Matters that are presently in court touching on land issues, including debt collection proceedings, shall therefore be transferred to this particular court. The Judiciary has to seek ways to enable the court to operate at the various counties for easier service delivery of service to the public. Conclusion Having been established under the Article 68 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, the Act, is a mastermind in enabling transparency and accountability in matters of registration in all land transactions. Its implementation is yet to fully come into force but optimism is high that the Act will indeed bring out the required reforms. Bibliography Constitution of Kenya, 2010. Land Registration Act, 2012. By Dennis Deus LLB @ UON; B. Built Envt in Real Estate and Property Management @ TUK 15