BUSINESS STUDIES Grade 11 TERM 2 Business ventures and Business roles PROFESSIONALISM AND ETHICS DEFINITIONS AND DIFFERENCES Definition: Ethics and professionalism are two concepts often used in the same context. Ethics has a wider definition than professionalism which is more specific. Ethics refers to doing the right thing in general, while professionalism refers to a set of behaviour. DEFINITIONS AND DIFFERENCES Definition: Professionalism: Professionalism in the workplace refers to the way business managers and employees conduct themselves when dealing with stakeholders within a specific work environment. It includes compliance with the generally accepted manner of doing business – ethical conduct, appearance, communication, attitude, responsibility, knowledge, skill, integrity, respect, etiquette and loyalty. Ethics: Ethics refers to the moral values set mostly by society and by the business as a standard for correct behavior. It is a moral code based on set values. In the business, a code of ethics describes the appropriate behavior that is expected from employees in the workplace. It focuses on the difference between right and wrong, good and bad. DEFINITIONS AND DIFFERENCES Differences: Ethics Professionalism Doing the right thing. A set of behaviour for a particular occupation. DEFINITIONS AND DIFFERENCES Most occupations have their own codes of Ethical and Professional conduct. Ethical behaviour refers to generally doing the right thing. Unethical behaviour can take a variety of forms, for example accepting a bribe, using time at work for personal interests, making personal telephone calls from work. Professionalism is about how to behave in a certain occupation. DEFINITIONS AND DIFFERENCES In general, being professional means to: • Do what is expected for a particular occupation. • Dress appropriately. • Be on time. • Avoid making promises that cannot be kept. • Use appropriate language. • Avoid gossip about colleagues. THEORIES AND PRINCIPLES Ethics involve doing the right thing, but how do we differentiate between right and wrong? The laws of the country define illegal behaviour but every one has to decide what is right and wrong for themselves and which guidelines to use to make this decision. Example: Consequences • Some people make decisions based on the consequences of a decision. • A decision is based on the answer to the question “what if I get caught” Belief Opinion of other • Some people make decisions based on their beliefs. • A decision is based on what a person is taught to believe, or what a person chooses to believe. • Some people make decisions based on the opinion of others THEORIES AND PRINCIPLES Ethics theories can be grouped into ethics theories that guide conduct and ethics theories that guide character. Ethics theories that guide conduct: Utilitarian theory: Is linked to consequence-based theory, which focuses on the consequences of an action. According to this theory, something ‘useful’ needs to come from an ethical action. If the action results in pleasure for the majority of people, it is seen as right. If the action results in pain for the majority of people, it is regarded as wrong. Deontological theory: States that an action is morally right if it does not deviate from the rule. An example is that a businessman could set himself a rule always to be dressed in a suit and to wear a tie to make a good impression. All the employees at the business decide to wear World Cup T-shirts on Fridays for the duration of the World Cup, but he continues wearing a suit and a tie rather than breaking his own rule. THEORIES AND PRINCIPLES Ethics theories that guide character: Virtue-based theory: Focuses on a person’s character rather than that person’s actions. This theory suggests a balance between two extremes. For example, an accountant needs to find a balance between the two extremes of working fast or being accurate. Care theory: Suggests that ethics should relate to the situation. In order to decide what is good or bad in a certain situation, you need to place yourself in someone else’s position. PROFESSIONALISM AND ETHICS RELATE TO THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT Profit is the reason for the existence of most businesses to make profit. Competition in the market is tough. In order for a business to be successful it needs to do well in many areas, for example good pricing and excellent service delivery. A business will only be able to achieve these goals if employees are professional and hard working. PROFESSIONALISM AND ETHICS RELATE TO THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT Unprofessional employees will only harm a business’s image and reputation. A business with a professional image will enjoy the following benefits: A professional image which leads to customer satisfaction. A professional image which attracts customers to a business. A business with a professional image which attracts good employees. Ethics in the business environment refers to principles of right and wrong, regulating the conduct of business people and business enterprises. PROFESSIONALISM AND ETHICS RELATE TO THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT The topic of ethics is very wide and can be applied in all sections of a business. Look at the following examples: Ethics and production • Avoid unethical behaviour such as dumping waste in rivers. • Avoid unethical production processes, especially processes that harm people, for example expecting employees to work without safety gear. Ethics and public • Press releases about a business should be true. relations Ethics and purchasing • Buy from suppliers who adhere to ethical codes of conduct, for example do not support a meat supplier who is cruel to animals. PROFESSIONALISM AND ETHICS RELATE TO THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT Look at the following examples: Ethics and general management Ethics and marketing • Avoid unethical behaviour like lying to employees and shareholders about the financial position of the business. • Sometimes, managers grant themselves excessive bonuses while employees only receive small increases – this is also unethical. • Avoid exploiting people, for example people with disabilities. Ethics and • Recruitment and selection should be fair. human resources • Avoid unethical behaviour such as nepotism. Ethics and administration • Avoid leaking confidential information. Ethics and the financial function • Avoid unethical behaviour such as tax evasion, fraud (also unlawful) and bribery. PROFESSIONALISM AND ETHICS RELATE TO THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT The following four principles of ethics relate to business and could be helpful in the organisation: 1. Be trustworthy Customers want to do business with an organisation they can trust. If the organisation can prove it is worthy of the customers’ trust, the customers will give their loyalty in return. 2. Meet obligations Honour all commitments and obligations. For example if an insurance agent promises a prospective customer that he will phone back, he needs to keep the promise or the customer will lose trust in the company. 3. Community involvement Remain socially responsible to the community in which the business operates. Community involvement requires businesses expend financial and other resources. In return, this could lead to positive publicity, loyalty and respect from the community. PROFESSIONALISM AND ETHICS RELATE TO THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT The following four principles of ethics relate to business and could be helpful in the organisation: 4. Accounting control Managers have to gain control of record keeping to avoid fraudulent acts and corruption. The legal way of reducing the amount of tax due is called tax avoidance. A business should not practise tax evasion. It is the illegal way of reducing the tax liability by deducting questionable expenses or just not paying tax at all. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GOOD AND BAD DECISIONS All decisions have consequences. The consequences of a decision should be determined before a decision is made. From a business enterprise’s perspective, decisions should be assessed against criteria such as: the financial implications of the decision. the legal implications of the decision. the ethical implications of the decision. the effect the decisions will have on employees. PRINCIPLES AND SKILLS OF PROFESSIONAL, ETHICAL AND RESPONSIBLE BUSINESS PRACTICE Each business enterprise determines its own set of principles of professionalism. Examples of principles include: Maintaining high • Do not accept any form of bribery. levels of professional • A person should act within his/her area of integrity professional competency. • Avoid actions which could be perceived as a conflict of interest. Honouring • Adopt an attitude of lifelong learning. professional business • Honour all promises and agreements, practices oral and written. • Ensure that confidential information remains confidential. Respecting diversity • Show respect towards all people. • Avoid any kind of discrimination. DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES People hold different values and beliefs – this means that what one person regards as wrong, another person could regard as right. Different ethical perspectives: • Some people believe cloning animals or people is wrong, other people believe cloning is inevitable scientific development. • Some people believe bribery is wrong, while other people think bribery creates a “win-win” bookkeeping. • Some people believe tax evasion is wrong, others believe tax evasion indicates creative bookkeeping. ETHICAL BUSINESS VENTURES Ethical business ventures are ventures that firstly abide by all laws and, secondly, look for opportunities to do the right thing. Examples of ethical business behaviour: Not starting a business venture at the expense of someone else Payment of fair wages • Business operations should not harm the community, or employees. • Before an entrepreneur starts a business, the entrepreneur must consider the effects of the enterprise on the community and its employees. • Fair remuneration should be paid to all employees because employees help to create wealth for the business enterprise. • Employers must make sure that wages paid to the workers are in accordance with the minimum wages as determined by The Basic Conditions of Employment Act (No 75 of 1997) • Underpaid workers will feel unhappy and will be unproductive. ETHICAL BUSINESS VENTURES Examples of ethical business behaviour: Not discriminating against employees • All employees must receive equal opportunities and equal treatment. • It is both unethical and unfair to allow privileges to some employees and not to others. • Unfair treatment influences employee morale negatively and creates disloyalty among employees. Regular payment • Some people and business enterprises view tax of tax evasion as a way to save money. • Tax evasion is not only illegal, it is unfair towards all people and enterprises that pay their taxes regularly. • If all people and business enterprises pay their tax regularly, authorities will probably consider decreasing tax rates.