Running head: CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY Case Analysis Report Mary A. Cohen Boston University MG 448: E-commerce and Web Designs Professor Jung Wan Lee, Ph.D. February 12, 2015 CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 2 Abstract eBay was an idea software engineer Pierre Omidyar came up with. The reason for this idea was so that his girlfriend could pursue her hobby of buying and selling Pez dispensers with people not only in the United States but from around the world. The internet was brand new and creative people were finding uses for this new tool. Prior to the internet you would need to visit a collectors shop or put an ad in the newspaper. You could never have reached the amount of potential buyers and sellers that you can today thanks to such sites as eBay! Pierre Omidyar didn’t know it, but he was ahead of his time. His idea would change the way people shop. Today eBay has gone beyond collectibles. Once thought of as an online yard sale is now a site to buy not only used hard to find items, but also brand new items usually at a discounted price. This paper will talk about the beginning concepts and the growing pains this company has experienced as well as the strategic business concepts they are now using to keep up with not only the large competition but new to market competition. CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 3 Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................... 2 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 4 Business Description ....................................................................................................... 4 Value Proposition ............................................................................................................ 5 Customer Description ..................................................................................................... 6 SWOT Analysis .............................................................................................................. 7 Applying and Implementing an E-Commerce Business Model to Resolve Problems in the Company: ............................................................................................................................ 10 References ............................................................................................................. 14 CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 4 Introduction This year eBay, Inc. is celebrating its 20th anniversary. Over the past 20 years, eBay has been very successful in the online auction sales, but in order to keep growing they have realized that their business model needs to change drastically. In this case analysis I will examine the changes made during its inception, growth along the way, as well as their plans for growth in the future. Business Description eBay, Inc. (short for Echo Bay Technology Group) was started in September 1995 by Pierre Omidyar. Omidyar started the company in his living room so that his girlfriend would have a way of trading her collectibles online. It did not take Omidyar long to realize that this site he started as a hobby was going to be a major corporation. Today eBay’s net worth is $16 Billion dollars. Not long after the company was started Omidyar hired some talented help needed to grow the company. Jeffrey Skolls joined in 1996. He was the first employee hired, held the position of President, and wrote the original business plan. In 1998 he stepped down and to Senior Vice President of Strategic Planning and Analysis when Margret Whitman was hired. Whitman held the position of President and CEO up until 2008. eBay is the world leader in the online marketplace, it sells $2,100 worth of items every second totaling almost $69 Billion dollars annually in 2011 (eBay, 2012) and employees 37,000. Individuals, commercial customers, and government customers buy and sell items daily. As of 2011 eBay had over 100 million active users in over 150 countries. Its primary focus was to give CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 5 sellers an online type of yard sale/flea market in the comfort of the sellers own home and be able to reach buyers all over the world. Over the 20 years eBay has been in business it has changed its business model drastically. eBay operates its business through three segments: Marketplaces, Payments, and Enterprises. Marketplace segment includes eBay.com as well as companies eBay purchase such as StubHub, Fashion, Motors, Half.com, and Skype (it then sold Skype to Microsoft making a 40% profit). The Payment segment is PayPal which allows individuals and companies to purchase products in a secure easy way by sending or receiving payments quickly. The Enterprise segment is for large Retailers. By offering this segment, it is now broadening its clients to include retailers selling new items to consumers at set prices vs. customers bidding on collectibles and other hard to find items. Most recently eBay is working with retailers to offer online buying while utilizing direct shipping options from the store directly to the consumer. By offering this solution, retailers are able to use their store spaces and retail employees for both in store inventory as well as online inventory and shipping services. Value Proposition eBay is committed to offering a convenient service that both the buyer and the seller benefits from. Ways in which this is a valuable asset is by giving buyers and sellers a marketplace which has a combination of a place to communicate, share information, and complete transactions all for lower fees than the competition. eBay is an online resource CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 6 environment which will allow the buyer and seller to become successful when using the opportunities and guidance provided. Customer Description Not only is the customer important to eBay, but the seller is equally if not more important to eBay. The reason for this is eBay wants their sellers to be loyal to eBay. In order to do this eBay feels they also need to be loyal to the seller and in order to do this they have changed their fee structure. The new fee schedule is much easier to understand. It rewards the higher sellers and also offers a flat rate for the lower sellers. Under this new fee structure most sellers (regardless if they are low volume or high volume) will pay less for each listing vs. the old fee structure. This structure also makes it easier for the seller to quickly figure out how much they are paying to sell on eBay vs. Amazon. They now list this table on the site which compares eBay and Amazon’s fees: CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 7 SWOT Analysis This analysis will center on eBay’s core internal Strengths and Weaknesses as well as eBay’s external Opportunities and Threats. By listing the Strengths and Weaknesses we will look closely at the current activities as well as the deficiencies of the organization, in other words the major strategic issues. When listing the Opportunities and Weaknesses we are looking at trends and events external to the company which is out of the control of the company. Strengths 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. World leader in online marketplace Global client base Easily Accessible Easily Identifiable Profitable Free service to buyers Opportunities 1. New Technology 2. Acquisitions 3. International Growth Weaknesses 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Privacy Fees Content Strategic Growth Strategy Technology Issues Threats 1. Competition 2. International Exchange Rate Volatility 3. Security Strengths (Internal): World leader in online Marketplace: eBay, Inc. knows their market and has made many sellers successful as well as providing many buyers with the exact products they were searching for. Global Client Base: As of 2011 eBay had over 100 million active users in over 30 countries. Easily Accessible: The eBay website is easy to use and name recognition is well known in the industry. CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 8 Easily Identifiable: The eBay logo is well known and highly recognizable. Profitable: In 2011 eBay’s net worth was $16 billion. Free Service to buyers: Buyers do not need to pay a fee on top of the selling/auction price + shipping. Weaknesses (Internal): Privacy: eBay just like other major corporations could be hacked putting their active user’s private information as well as their own company information and resources in jeopardy. eBay does have steps in place to protect its buyers and sellers privacy such as Truste Certified Privacy systems as well as documentation about privacy on their website, but as with any company these days, there is always that chance that your information could get stolen and violated. Fees: Although the service is free to the buyer, the sellers do pay a fee for listing their products on the website. These fees have recently been modified and are within the industry standards. Content: Although eBay monitors their website, there is always the possibility that illegal activity will happen. It is estimated that 10% of transactions are fraudulent. Strategic Growth Strategy: Over the 20 years in business eBay has not always made profitable decisions. There is always the chance for competition to find a newer way or less expensive way to sell products online. CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 9 Technology Issues: Working with computer equipment, servers, service providers, etc. there is always the opportunity for systems and services to fail leaving buyers and sellers unable to do business. Opportunities (External): New Technology: As more mobile devices and newer technology is developed this increases the platform for which buyers and sellers can do business. For example, with the implementation of tablets you no longer need to be sitting in front of your computer to place an order, you can now do this on your phones, tablets, mobile devices. Acquisitions: eBay has acquired companies such as PayPal and StubHub. This allows them to offer more services to their current client base as well as provide them with a growing client base. By acquiring PayPal they were able to provide their customers with a secure way of paying for items purchased. By acquiring StubHub they were able to now offer concert and event tickets as part of their services provided to their current customers as well as provide additional services to the StubHub customers in addition to concert and event tickets. International Growth: As of 2011 almost 1/3 of the people living in the United States already had an account on eBay. This means in order to grow its customer base they need to start targeting international clients as well. Since all you need to use eBay is an internet connect and a device, there is no reason why Sellers could not do business outside of the United States. CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 10 Threats (External): Competition: Amazon is eBay’s main competition. With eBay’s net worth at $16 billion and Amazon’s net worth at $89 billion (as of 2011) Amazon is in a position to target eBays clients. There are also other smaller competitors as well as more stores going online and selling direct. International Exchange Rate Volatility: A big factor when selling into the international market is the value of the dollar. Depending on which country you are selling into the exchange rate could make it nearly impossible to make a profit. Security: Hackers could send emails representing eBay; private information could be stolen from both eBay as well as its clients. Applying and Implementing an E-Commerce Business Model to Resolve Problems in the Company: eBay, Inc. used the Business to Consumer Model (B2C) when it designed its website to conduct auctions. This allowed the seller (business) to do business with the buyer (consumer). They were able to create their own market segment and design the auction website in a way that was easy to use and convenient for both the seller and the buyer. Besides growing competition, Amazon being their largest competitor ($89 billion in sales for 2012) and a brand new Indian company by the name of Alibaba ($8.5 billion in sales for 2013) is gaining market share. eBay needs to continuously grow their client base, as discussed in the SWOT Analysis, as already 1/3 of people living in the U.S. have eBay accounts. This means eBay needs to provide more than just the auction service website. In order for eBay to keep CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 11 growing they will need to broaden their business model and find different niche markets to sell into. One way they are getting into different markets is with the joint venture of Simon Malls and eBay called “Connected Mall”. Simon is the leader in the brick and mortar malls. eBay and Simon are working together to find ways to get more people into malls while giving them the convenience of technology used for shopping. This technology will assist them in finding the items they are interested in, including deals and savings specifically customized for that shopper. “Simon and the Retail Innovation Division of eBay, Inc. have been working on an exclusive basis in the mall space to enhance the shopping experience and provide retailers with a new and compelling way to engage shoppers”, Mikael Thygesen, Simon’s Chief Marketing Officer. eBay Enterprise (an eBay, Inc. company) is also using a Business to Business Model (B2B) by offering their retail business partners “Store Fulfillment Solutions”. This solution allows the retailers to not only have brick and mortar locations, but also handle internet orders by storing inventory right in the store locations, thus not needing additional warehouse space. The store employee is then able to ship orders out locally to the consumer. This saves on warehouse space costs as well as shipping costs. Using this fulfillment solution, eBay clients had more than $1 billion in sales in 6,500 store and 3 continents. Considering the 8 unique features of E-Commerce, I feel that eBay does a very good job at covering all of these but “Information Richness” could be improved. The reason for this is sometimes the products do not have a good description. It looks like sometimes the same picture is used for multiple products. Especially if purchasing a used product you really want to see a CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 12 clear picture of the quality the product is in. Detailed information about the product is also important. Conclusion: The internet has changed the way we live. Most of our day to day lives now depend on the internet and sites like eBay are a part of the way life is now. Billions of dollars are spent annually on online shopping sites. We now carry around mobile devices, which allow us to go online from anywhere at any time, we are no longer tied to our home computer. eBay’s growth opportunities are unlimited. Being the leader in the global online marketplace for online auctions has already allowed eBay to change the way shopping is done. Now using creativity and social media more features can be implemented to make the process even more user friendly. Implementing a social e-commerce business could open more doors of opportunity. If users were to have chat rooms for “collectibles”, “antiques”, and an expert source of information then there would be an obligation to using eBay versus the competition. eBay has a vast network of active users who are experts in this field. They need to start reaching out to the experts for ideas. A good example of this was when eBay purchased Skype. At the time Margaret Whitman, President and CEO thought Skype would make it easier for the buyers and sellers to be able to call each other (they could be located anywhere in the world) and talk about the products being sold, find out details, and have more of a relationship with the buyer/seller. As it turned out the buyers and sellers did not want to talk with each other, communicating through email worked just fine. Skype was not a good fit for the company. If CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 13 eBay had listened to its active users they would have saved themselves a lot of time and headaches. eBay understands that they have competition. Amazon has grown tremendously compared to eBay. Amazon has its own niches in the market such as the Kindle and Amazon Fire. eBay is also finding its niche and understands there will always be competition, but you have to be able to differentiate yourself and offer specialized services not found with your competition. With the issues happening in the world today (hacking of computer system and obtaining private information not only from thieves here in the United States but also from other countries), I think eBay has to remain on top of this issue and invest heavily in the security and safety of its clients. When clients need to pick which service to go with, eBay will show dedication to the client for their safety and wellbeing. CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 14 References Business Services:; ebay inc. files SEC form 8-K, current report (jan. 7, 2015). (2015). Economics Week, , 256. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/1645252708?accountid=9676 eBay enterprise clients reach more than $1 billion in ship-from store and in-store pickup sales. (2-15, Jan 13). News Bites – Computing & Information Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/1644509604?accountid=9676 "EBay Inc." EBAY Key Statistics. N.p., n.d. Web. 12 Feb. 2015. How did eBay Start?. (n.d) retrieved Feb 09 2015, from http://ebay.about.com/od/ebaylifestyle/a/el_history.htm Market Watch Web Site: . (n.d) retrieved FEB 10 2015, from http://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/EBAY/profile Market Watch Web Site:. (n.d) retrieved Feb 09 2015, from Ebay, Inc. http://marketwatch.ar.wilink.com/?link=EBAY "Morgan Stanley Technology, Media & Telecom Conference." Investor Relations. N.p., n.d. Web. 12 Feb. 2015. CASE ANALYSIS: EBAY 15 Simon and eBay inc. launch “connected mall” at Stanford shopping center. (214, Dec 03). News Bites – Computing & Information Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/1629481586? Accountid=9676 Social Innovation, .(n.d) retrieved FEB 10 2015, from Ebay, Inc. Web Site: Http://www.ebayinc.com/social-innovation. N.p., n.d. Web. “Standard Selling Fees” . (n.d) retrieved FEB 10 2015, from Ebay, Inc. Web Site:."Standard Selling Fees”. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Feb. 2015 10 years ago, eBay changed the world. (2005, mar, 21). retrieved Feb 09 2015, from http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/news/2005-03-21-ebay-cover_x.htm