Napoleon’s Report Card Kirk Herman Pre-IB History 10 Ms. Ripley 28 April 2008 Napoleon's Report Card Click Here for music Outline 1793 1800 Milit ary Tacti cs Polit ical Endea vors Lead ershi p of the 1801 1808 18091815 Final Grade B A C B A A C B C A A A "The main thing about Napoleon, is that he thought big.... He was outthinking his opponents at any given level." - British author Christopher Duffy Quote taken from:http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html • 1793-1800 Military Strategies B good in this time period, they While Napoleon’s tactics were very weren’t the best of his career. The reason Napoleon was so successful was that he only used what was available to him and did not experiment with new things, as demonstrated with this quote: “Bonaparte never in his entire career gave the army any new ideas. He introduced no new tactics or formations, no innovations in drill, no improved weapons and, though an artillery expert, no new types of gun. All he gave it was victory.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Instead of new tactics, Napoleon relied on speed. It was always his key to victories, and made sure everything took the least amount of time as possible, like in this quote: “He routinely allowed eight minutes for lunch and twelve for dinner...” (Foss, 2006) This is why Napoleon was so successful; he thought outside the box. These strategies allowed him to frequently win battles despite overwhelming odds, like at the battle of Rivoli, when 23 000 soldiers under Napoleon’s command defeated 28 000 Austrian soldiers in Austria’s forth attempt to recapture the fortress of Mantua, in 1797 (refer to document 3) This is why Napoleon is still remembered, because of his great tactics. Document 3, tactical map of the battle of Rivoli Taken from: http://www.lombardmaps.com/cat/napoleonic/new/rivoli.jpg • 1801-1808 Military Strategies This period of time is whenANapoleon’s military genius was really in its prime. In this spot of time Napoleon won dozens of battles, including his masterpiece, the battle of Austerlitz. During this battle, Napoleon lured the Russian army into attacking his right flank, then Napoleon attacked the Russian flank, causing 30 000 casualties, and re-established Napoleon’s power in Europe. (Refer to document 1) After this battle, Napoleon told a captured enemy combatant: “calm yourself, young man. It is no dishonor to be defeated by my army.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Victories like this helped Napoleon to bring Europe to its knees, so he could assume control. Document 1 – A tactical map of the battle of Austerlitz Taken From: www.napoleonicwargamesminiatures.com • 1809-1815 Military Strategies C An example of this is In his later years Napoleon got sloppy. Napoleon’s Russian campaign. Leadership aside, Napoleon just stopped caring about the important things. It is a if Napoleon had simply grown tired of his campaigns like a child grows tired of games, as seen in this document: “He no longer studied the facts of a situation from which to draw brilliant conclusions. He had been a conqueror, a master of men and events, for so long that the facts no longer seemed to matter. Only his will, his desires, mattered, and the facts had better fit them.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) This caused the Russian campaign to flounder and fail. Even though he captured Moscow, the bitter Russian weather and being driven back the way he came-through as plain stripped of food and resources-caused him to take severe losses, as shown here: “Of the 500 000 men who set out for Moscow, only 18 000 returned.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Then, after being forced into exile because the enemies he had made were surrounding France, he made a weak attempt to return to power and was quickly defeated. Napoleon had simply exhausted his military genius. • Final Grade Military Strategies B strategies were infallible, At some point in his career, Napoleon’s such as during the battle of Austerlitz. His dominance is proved with this quote: “At Austerlitz, Napoleon took up a deceptive position behind high ground facing a combined Russo-Austrian army of more than 80,000 men…the Allied Army marched blindly into the trap and was overwhelmingly defeated with total casualties of about 30,000…Austerlitz re-established Napoleanic domination of Europe.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) There were also points where Napoleon’s strategies were terribly unsuccessful, such as Napoleon’s Russian Campaign of 1812. During the Russian Campaign Napoleon tried to force the Russians to sign a peace treaty. The problem was that as the French advanced, the Russians retreated and the French lost more men and resources as they pursued. Eventually the French had to give up and retreat back to France but had suffered major casualties, losing about 110 000 men. If you take into account all of his battles over his whole career, you see that although his strategies were excellent at the beginning of his career, towards the end Napoleon got careless in his decisions, making him a good strategist but not a great one. Napoleon dominated the period from 1800 to 1815 so completely that the era has become known as the Napoleonic Age." - Colonel John Elting, US Army Quote taken from:http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html • 1793-1800 Political Endeavors Acoup d’état on 18 Brumaire When Napoleon formed his (November 9-10, 1799), he single-handedly masterminded a way to seize ultimate power. He used Abbé Siéyès, a man who wanted to overthrow the directory of France. He let Siéyès think that he could use Napoleon and throw him away, when in fact the opposite happened. When Napoleon had established a provisional government, he quickly outthought Siéyès, As you can see in this document: “Almost immediately Siéyès was outmaneuvered by Bonaparte, so completely in fact, that he even voted for his own displacement as Consul, and nominated two supporters of Napoleon to replace him!...His sword had turned in his hand.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Continued • Napoleon was brilliant in his political maneuvers, always manipulating situations to better suit his needs. A great example of this is when in 1799, when Napoleon made a new constitution, he consulted the citizens of France for their input. No leader had ever done this before, and the French showed their appreciation by voting it in with extreme popularity, as shown in this document: “It was approved by a vote of over three million, while fewer than two thousand opposed it.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Of course this was all a clever rouse by Napoleon to fool the people of France into giving him even more power. After that, Napoleon made sure he would always have power in France by appointing men loyal to him in positions of power in France, as seen in this document: “In February 1800, he established a system of Prefects to rule the departments into which France was divided. Never local men, and always appointed from Paris, they replaced the last traces of local democracy.” (Foss, 2006) This meant that no local politicians would be able to speak up against Napoleon. This is the reason Napoleon got to the political position he was in, he was always one step ahead of the competition. • 1801-1808 Political Endeavors A had climbed very high in This document shows that Napoleon political status: “In the spring of 1804 Bonaparte had reached the highest point of his career.” In 1804 he crowned himself as emperor of France and had full support of his subjects. He had made peace with Britain and the church and his policies were working very well. As a part of his political strategies, he introduced the continental system, a way of weakening Britain but not allowing them to trade with Europe. Napoleon was the master of Europe and was all powerful at this time. To make sure he would be able to maintain power in Europe, Napoleon appointed his family and friends in key places in Europe, shown here: “One brother, Louis, was King of Holland, another, Joseph, was King of Sicily and a third, Jerome, was King of the newly created state of Westphalia. His stepson, Eugène de Beauharnais was Viceroy of Italy. Some of his marshals had been princes, as had certain of his close advisors. His military victories and diplomatic successes had made him the most powerful ruler in the world. • 1809-1815 Political Endeavors C Napoleon had a poetical downfall during his last years. His enemies as well as his allies and his own countrymen turned hostile towards him. The French were tired of constant warring taking away their young men, and the war in Russia just made things worse, as shown here: “France, too was tired and when Napoleon raised a new army, one hundred and fifty thousand of the new conscripts were boys under twenty, to be hurried into battle untrained…Many Frenchmen worried about the cost of maintaining an empire constantly at war, surrounded always by enemies.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) • Final Grade Political Endeavors B well, starting as an officer Napoleon started off his career and becoming the first consul of France in a period of just over five years. Napoleon did this by being merciless and by always being in the right place at the right time. He used his amazing smarts to outthink his opponents and manipulate situations to benefit him. His cunning is shown in this quote: “The directory was in chaos, divided against itself and looking for a new leader, ideally a figurehead. Napoleon joined a plot that took over the regime in November. By the following month, he had outmaneuvered his colleagues; to be named first consul with a term of ten years.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Continued • Napoleon got himself into a position of absolute power, but being in this position rendered him paranoid that everyone was out to get him. He made the secret police, a force that spied on friends and enemies, in order to prevent any potential plots against him. Eventually, all the pressures of his position got to him, and he simply stopped thinking rationally. In the years of 1808-1812, Napoleon let the countries he had concurred figure out that they didn’t need him and that they could rise against France. Europe’s enlightenment is shown in this document: “The enemies, however, realizing that Napoleon’s star was finally in decline, found new strength and courage. In Germany a new spirit of national pride, a fiery patriotism, was arising; Prussia and the rest of Germany, were finding a national purpose just as Spain had done. When the Russians crossed into Germany in pursuit of the retreating French, Prussia too rose in arms, and the French garrisons were again forced to retreat westward.” Napoleon’s political follies in his later years brought down his reputation as a leader, and his status dropped from a great politician to just a good one. "Bonaparte's reception by the troops was nothing short of rapturous. It was well worth seeing how he talked to the soldiers..." - de Rémusat Quote taken from:http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html 1793-1800 Leadership of the Military • This section was very difficult toC mark. Some would argue that Napoleon’s leadership was extraordinary, considering his victories at Mantua, Vienna and Venice. Alone, these victories would have meant that whoever accomplished them was a great leader. However, theses were not the only battles Napoleon was involved in. There was also the invasion of Egypt. Napoleon decided that an invasion of England was impractical and instead decided to strike at England through Egypt. This is proved by the following document: “Napoleon was offered command of invasion forces that he considered inadequate. He decided instead to take the war to Egypt, striking at England’s imperial lifeline.” (Napoleon) In his expedition to Egypt, Napoleon, after a fairly good start, encountered many difficulties. The English fleet destroyed the French ships, marooning Napoleon and his troops, he could not capture the port of Acre, took heavy losses, morale dropped and a plague spread through his camp. Napoleon decided to give up the cause and sneak back home in the middle of the night in August 12, 1799. “The army and its new commander, Kléber did not know he was gone until the next day, when that astonished and furious officer got the letter Bonaparte had left appointing him to the command of the imprisoned army.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) No matter how good a leader is, a truly great leader never abandons his men. A great leader would stay and fight with his men valiantly to the death. They don’t abandon them. 1801-1808 Leadership of the Military • This period of time is whenANapoleon’s leadership was at its best. His pride and confidence rubbed off on his men, and it showed. Napoleon led his men to many victories, defeating the Austrians in South Germany in October 1805(the battle of Ulm), then a combined Austro-Russian army in Austerlitz six weeks later. Because of these victories, Napoleon was able to gain control of all Russian and Austrian territories. This allowed Napoleon to make a peace treaty with the Czar of Russia, giving Napoleon control of a large portion of Europe. His power over Europe is shown in this document: “The treaty of Tilsit (July 8, 1807) which followed this meeting made France the master of Europe.” Napoleon accomplished all this while losing a small amount of men, and did not abandon his troops, unlike in previous campaigns (refer to document 2). Napoleon had learned his lesson. Document 2 - The battle of Austerlitz statistics Taken From: http://www.napoleonseries.org/military/listings/c_3rdcoalition.html Troops: Losses: France Austria/Russia Napoleon Kutusov (Tsar Alexander I) 73000 85000 Total 9000 KIA+WIA 8279 KIA 1288 Prisoners 573 Total 28900 WIA+KIA 15000 KIA 7000 Prisoners 11000 1809-1815 Leadership of the Military • If there was something that never wavered in his despite his A career’s downfall, it had to be Napoleon’s leadership of his military. All strategies aside, the level of trust Napoleon got from his men was incredible. The best example of this is after Napoleon’s first exile when he came back to France to regain power. He was so confident that he made a very bold statement: “I will reach Paris without firing a shot.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) He did just that. Napoleon was so convincing in his speech, and his men were so loyal, that they disobeyed their orders to help him. The troops’ level of commitment is seen in this document: “Troops sent to stop his progress joined him in thousands, the orders of their royalist officers to shoot drowned in the thunderous cries of “Vive l’Empereur!” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) He led his men with great pride, and believed they could do anything if they fought hard enough. (Refer to document 3) Document 3- Napoleon and his men. Taken from: http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html Final Grade Leadership of the Military A of his military. He led his • Napoleon was a great leader armies with pride and dignity, and inspired his men to win battles against much larger armies. (Refer to document 1) This great leadership helped Napoleon to gain his great title and to convince soldiers sent to kill him to join him. “Troops sent to stop his progress joined him in thousands, the orders of their royalist officers to shoot drowned in the thunderous cries of “Vive l’Empereur!” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) There was the one moment of mental relapse that caused him to abandon his men in Egypt, but after that Napoleon would never betray his men. This shows a true great leader, one who inspires his men to rise to greatness. (See document 3) Battle of Marengo French victory Document 1- Battle statistics of the battle of Marengo, a decisive victory for Napoleon Taken from http://www.napoleon-series.org/index.html Countries: France Austria Commanders Napoleon Melas Troops: 24000 31000 Losses: Total 5835 Total 14000 Document 3-Napoleon leading his army. Picture taken from: http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html A leader is a dealer in hope. - Napoleon Quote taken from:http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html • 1793-1800 French Attitudes towards Napoleon There is no refuting how popularA Napoleon was at this time. This is because he stood for everything the French wanted, new ideas; he listened to the people, and protected their rights. The French loved him, as seen in this document: “It is not surprising that, these people tended to idealize the ‘Robin Hood’ figure, the righter of wrongs.” (Lefebvre, 1969). This is how they saw Napoleon. They idolized him, and would do whatever he said. He used this newfound popularity to gain more power and make new rules so by the time the French realized what he was doing, it would be too late for them to act. For the time being Napoleon was extremely powerful and popular, as shown in this document: “Bonaparte found himself welcomed everywhere as a hero.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) He was on the top of the world, so to speak. (Refer to document 3) Document 3-Napoleon as seen by the French: proud, noble, and strong. Taken from: www.wikipedia.com • 1801-1808 French Attitudes A At this point, Napoleon was at the top of his career and the French loved him. His appreciation is shown is this document: “He controlled France with full support.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) This was proved when Napoleon called when Napoleon called a plebiscite to decide if he should be declared first consul of France for life, when he was voted in with a remarkable majority, shown in this document: “The people of France approved in a plebiscite in which the vote was three and a half million in favor and only eight thousand opposed.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Napoleon controlled all media, and censored things that would hurt his image, effectively keeping French morale high because they did not know what was happening outside French borders. Napoleon had the leader of his secret police, Joseph Fouché study foreign media to know what to tell the French people. Napoleon’s censorship is shown in this quote: “Fouché read foreign newspapers-not available to the public- so that he and Napoleon would have a wider view of events than was available from the censored French press.” (Foss, 2006) These tactics made the French believe that Napoleon was really working to help them, and they really loved him. 1809-1815 French Attitudes D • In this period of time, the French people finally discovered that Napoleon had lied to them when he said he would fix the problems they wanted fixed. They made a complete change in attitude from praising him to despising him. In fact, when he was exiled, he was shown just how much he was detested, shown in this document: “The journey south to Fréjus, the port where he had landed to the cheers of the crown fifteen years ago on his return from Egypt, was terrifying and dangerous. Mobs cursed him and threw stones at the windows of his coach and he was obliged to disguise himself, even wearing the despised white cockade of the Bourbons. On April 28, he boarded the H.M.S. Undaunted to sail into exile.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Napoleon’s reign as France’s hero and savoir was over. He was as despised as Louis XVI was a few years earlier. Final Grade French Attitudes C • Napoleon started off his career in the good graces of France because he represented everything the French wanted in a time of great need. After the revolution, France wanted someone on power that would work towards a common goal with the same ideals as them. Napoleon was just that leader, as seen in this quote: “Napoleon witnessed enough of the revolution in Paris to develop a contempt for mob rule and the weakness of the monarchy…his loyalty to the revolution and his excellent training led to rapid promotion.” (Foss, 2006) After coming to be in power, Napoleon brought fame and glory to the French people by concurring foreign lands and importing exotic artwork. The people of France showed their appreciation by electing Napoleon first consul of France for life, and showering him with praise wherever he went. This all would imply a great leader that had the respect of his people, and it did, for a time. Continued • The problem was that when Napoleon came to power, he became increasingly paranoid, constantly watching his back for potential plots to overthrow him. In order to protect himself he established the secret police, a secret organization that spied on the people of France and the people of other countries. The secret police also made sure that the French people only listened to media that Napoleon approved, and arrested those who didn’t. In the end, this secrecy is what caused the French to despise Napoleon, shown in this document: “A radical revolutionary, Joseph Fouché, ran the police and the network of spies that reached though the whole of French society. Mail was routinely opened and anyone might be secretly denounced…Daily life in France became more dreary and there was a widespread sense of fear.” (Foss, 2006) All this adds up to a poor leader who tricked his subjects while silently watching them, a terrible leader. “Russia has Suvorov, England has Nelson, Prussia has Frederick the Great. The World has Napoleon.” - Anonymous Quote taken from:http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html 1793-1800 Changing Things C • At this point in Napoleon’s career he hadn’t really changed much and what he did change was for personal gain. He took over the government just so he could have more power and then lied to the people to make it look like he cared. He formed a few governing bodies to keep the people happy, but limited their power so he still had control. This is shown in this document: “the tribunate, senate, and a council of state but these organizations had no real power- they simply provided the appearance of democracy to a government that was really a dictatorship.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) 1801-1808 Changing Things A • Napoleon Bonaparte will always be remembered for the things he changed during this time period. It was during this time that Napoleon First introduced his new education system, one that would provide him with officers and civil servants. He established the University of France, which directed the education of France and whom the director of reported to Napoleon. Napoleon designed the educational system and curriculum very well so that they would train the young people to think like and support Napoleon. The effectiveness of the system is shown in this document: “This highly centralized educational system, though modified from time to time, continues in use in France today…” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Continued • Napoleon’s greatest achievement, though, was the Code Napoleon. Napoleon wanted to organize the laws of France into a sort of universal code. To do this, he appointed four experts to design the code, and then formed the code in over 100 sessions at the council of state. This new code was revolutionary in its new innovations and incites, as shown in this document: “The code was moderate in tone, and combined much of what was good in the old laws of France with the basic ideas of the evolution-equality of all men before the law, freedom of conscience, freedom of work, and separation of church and state…” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) The code Napoleon is still noted as Napoleon’s greatest achievement, and has been used as a base for many legal systems around the world, as shown in this document: “the adoption of the code in 1804 is one of the most notable events in legal history. Nothing else that Napoleon Bonaparte did has had as lasting and as beneficial effect for France and for the world. During the 19th century it served as a model for the laws of many countries of Europe and elsewhere in the world…” If a leader is defined by the changes they have made for the betterment of mankind, then not many rank higher than Napoleon in this category. Napoleon in all his glory. Taken from: http://web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html 1801-1815 Changing Things D • For this period of time, most of the things Napoleon had established became undone. The people he ruled and the countries he had allied with began to reject the ideals Napoleon had thrust upon them and make their own. His biggest failure was his continental system because he misunderstood the source of British wealth, as shown here: “Her population crowded into growing industrial cities, could only be fed if food, mostly wheat and other grains, could be imported. If this supply of food had been cut off Britain would have been in serious trouble but Napoleon not realizing the true state of affairs, permitted European, even French traders to ship grain to Britain under a system of licenses.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) The continental system’s failure allowed Brittan to thrive and attack France and her allies. This, combined with Frances new enemies who no longer accepted Napoleon’s changes, spelt disaster for France. Final Grade Changing Things A • It is in this category that Napoleon will always be remembered as one of, if not the greatest leader ever. He started off rocky, with a coup d’état that gave him control of the country, but in his early years only changed things that benefited him with more power. Also, the end of Napoleon’s career was wrapped in failure, with his continental system failing, and his exile. The true greatness of Napoleon’s changes came in the prime of his career. Continued • Napoleon started his changes with a drastic new educational system that would reform all of France’s schools. He established the new University of France that would head up the new educational system that would train young children to think like Napoleon did. The idea of the new system is shown in this quote: “In 1808 “University of France” was established. This was actually a ministry of education, whose head was directly responsible to the Emperor. It controlled all teachers in all schools, their licenses, pay, and promotion, and decided which subjects might be taught in school and what books might be used…the police made sure there were no books other than those that were favorable to the imperial rule.” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) Although the curriculum might have been questionable, the structure of the system has been the base of most of the educational systems in use in France today. Continued • The educational system may have been memorable, but the most lasting accomplishment of Napoleon’s was the code Napoleon. The code started to become reality when Napoleon realized that France’s laws were outdated and ineffective. He knew the laws were ineffective and wanted to replace them. The result was the code Napoleon, a new set of laws that pleased the people of France very much because it is exactly what they wanted as a result of the revolution. The code’s new ideals were radical and made more sense than ever before, as seen in this document: “The code was moderate in tone, and combined much of what was good in the old laws of France with the basic ideas of the evolution-equality of all men before the law, freedom of conscience, freedom of work, and separation of church and state…” (Truman, Schaffter, Stewart, Murray Hunter, 1979) These new revelations made the code extremely popular and were adopted by many other countries, and remains as Napoleon’s legacy, as shown in this document: “…the Code Napoleon was introduced in March 1804. It remains Napoleon’s most lasting achievement.” (Foss, 2006) This is why Napoleon will always be remembered as a truly great leader; he thought ahead of his time and did something that would help his nation for years to come. References • Lawford, James. Napoleon, the last campaigns 1813-15. New York, Ny, Crown Publishers, 1977. • Gwinn, Robert P. The New Encyclopedia Britannica, Volume 24. Chicago, Pan American, 1988. • Lefebvre, Georges. Napoleon: From 18 Brumaire to Tilsit. New York, Ny. Columbia University Press,1969. • “The Battle of Rivoli”, lombardmaps.com, 2006. Lombard Antiquarian Prints, 20. Apr. 2008.<ww w.lombardmaps.com/cat/napoleonic/new/rivoli.jpg> • “1805 Campaign: Austerlitz:The Battle of Three”, napoleonicminiatureswargame.com. 2003. Napoleonic Miniatures Wargame Society of Toronto, Apr. 21. 2008. < www.napoleonicminiatureswargame.com> References Continued • “The Napoleon Series”, Napoleon-Series.org. 2002. The Nafitzer Collection, Apr.23.2008. www.napoleon-series.org/military/listings/c_3rdcoalition.html • “Napoleon”, NAPOLEON_FOREVER.html. 2002. Internet America. Apr. 22. 2008. <web2.airmail.net/napoleon/NAPOLEON_FOREVER> • “Napoleon I Of France”, en.wikipedia.org. 2004. The Wikipedia Foundation. Apr.25. 2008. <en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page> • Truman, J. Schaffter, J. P. Stewart, R. J. Murray Hunter, T. Modern Perspectives. The Ryerson Press, Canada. (1979) • Foss, Clive. The Tyrants. Quercus Publishing, London, Engld.