Germany’s Great Depression (Unemployment) { Japan’s Great Depression (Unemployment) { Great Britain’s Great Depression (Unemployment) { United States Great Depression (Unemployment) { FDR Hoover 5 6 Roosevelt’s 100 days was very successful….FDR and Congress went to work providing for direct relief, recovery and reform. From March of 1933 to June of 1933, Roosevelt sent 15 proposals to Congress and all 15 were adopted Congress and President tried anything reasonable to overcome the Great Depression. 100 days Govt. programs which provided direct relief to suffering Americans through govt. spending……… NEW DEAL CARTOON Renew democracy Restore confidence in the banking Stimulate economy Social Engineers Put people back to work. Brain Trust Restore self confidence How? FDR’s 3 R’s Relief: ease suffering of the needy Recovery: begin economic growth Reform: help prevent future economic crises Finance: Baruch Politics: Howe Professors: Tugwell Labor: Perkins Agriculture: Wallace Interior: Ickes Treasury: Morgenthau Jr. FDRs Advisers and “Brain Trust” • Series of radio addresses by FDR • 30 total between 1933 to 1944 • FDR used these to calm American people down. • CLICK on the radio to link to hear the 1st chat on the Bank Crisis 10 People w/d $$; banks fail “Banking Holiday” Emergency Banking ReliefAct Fireside Chat Glass-Steagall Act Creates the FDIC Conservative An example of Recovery and Reform The Banking Crisis Goals of New Deal Program 1. Relief Help people right away 2. Recovery Get the US out of the Depression 3. Reform Make sure another depression does not happen 12 New Deal: Relief Federal Emergency Relief Association (FERA) Civil Works Administration (CWA) Public Works Administration (PWA) Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) Farm Credit Association (FCA) Homeowners Loan Corporation (HOLC) Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) 13 New Deal: Recovery Works Progress Administration (WPA) National Recovery Administration (NRA) Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA) National Youth Administration (NYA) Federal Housing Act (FHA) 14 New Deal: Reform Federal Deposit Insurance Company (FDIC) Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Wagner Act (NLRB) Social Security 15 RECOVERY: Begin Economic Growth AAA / 1933 Agricultural Adjustment Act •Protected farmers from price drops and over production.. • US Govt. Paid farmers (subsidies) •not to grow wheat, cotton, corn, hogs, rice, tobacco, dairy products •AAA told farmers how much they should produce alphabet { Yay! Rise in prices after 1933 1933: $2 billion 1935: $5 billion Mixed Results { Boo! Favored large landowners Tenants & sharecroppers kicked off land S. Court finds AAA unconstitutional in 1936 Modified in 1936 and 1938 RECOVERY: Begin Economic Growth NIRA / 1933 National Industrial Recovery Act •Created NRA to enforce codes of fair competition, minimum wages, and to permit collective bargaining of workers. alphabet Companies would cooperate Set limits on production Prices Codes of fair competition In exchange, labor would get concessions Max hours Minimum wages Collective bargaining NRA: The Ideal Codes poorly written Huge bureaucracy Large producers dominated codewriting process No enforcement mechanism to enforce Section 7(A) Production actually decreased 1935: Supreme Court declares it unconstitutional NRA: The Reality RECOVERY: Begin Economic Growth TVA / 1933 Tennessee Valley Authority •Federal government built a series of dams to prevent flooding and sold electricity. •First public competition with private power industries. alphabet TVA MAP alphabet RELIEF: Ease Suffering of the Needy FERA / 1933 Federal Emergency Relief Act Distributed $500 million of direct aid to unemployed workers such as food, clothing and grants of money to cities. Repaired bridges, built highways, constructed public buildings W/I 30 days: 2.6 million men and women employed 1934: 4 million Civil Works Administration (CWA): 1933-34 alphabet RELIEF: Ease Suffering of the Needy CCC / 1933 to 1942 Civilian Conservation Corps •Sent 3 million young men to work camps to build bridges, replant forests and other conservation tasks. •Develop job skills and improve environment. • Removed surplus of workers from cities, provided healthy conditions for boys, provided money for families. Civilian Conservation Corps 32 alphabet RELIEF: Ease Suffering of the Needy HOLC / 1933 Home Owners Loan Corporation Prevented mortgage foreclosures. US Govt. bought up mortgages and refinanced them so that homeowners could pay their mortgages. REFORM: Prevent Another Depression SEC / 1933 Securities and Exchange Commission Regulated stock market and restricted margin buying, and frauds. alphabet Criticisms of New Deal US government and President too powerful Violated laissez faire Supreme Court declared NIRA and AAA unconstitutional Critics: American Liberty League Father Charles Coughlin Dr. Francis Townsend Huey Long Deficit spending: Govt. spends $$$ to stimulate the economy and help people even if it means US Govt. goes into debt. Welfare state----Created a population of Americans who relied on the US Govt. to live 100 days Liberty League FDR had gone TOO FAR with the New Deal. Interfering with business and peoples lives. Government was taking away freedoms from Americans. 39 •Economic system based on cooperation rather than competition • Believes in government ownership of business and capital •Government controls production and distribution of goods. •Opposite of laissez faire and capitalism •A Roman Catholic priest. •Radio Priest in Detroit Michigan. •Criticized FDR in weekly radio program. •10 million listeners. •Criticized FDR’s farm program •Believed an international conspiracy of bankers existed and FDR was influenced by them. •He called for the nationalization of banks and utilities. (US Govt. controls banks, Socialism) •Fascist; Anti-Semitic overtones. •He wanted the government to help older citizens. •Retired California Physician. •Suggested a $200 per month pension for people over 60. •Open jobs for the younger unemployed. •Spending all $200 would also be required to boost economic demand. •Townsend Clubs created all over the nation. •Influenced FDR’s creation of Social Security Senator Huey Long FDR was NOT doing enough for the poor. Long pushed his “Share Our Wealth” program. Take all income over $1,000,000 to give: House Car Annual Salary For all Americans 44 The Second New Deal & the Redefining of Liberalism { 1935-38 Emphasis on Social justice Social safety net Use the power of the govt to guarantee economic security and welfare of old, disabled and unemployed Welfare state Second New Deal REFORM: Prevent Another Depression Wagner Act / 1935 National Labor Relations Act Reaffirmed labor's right to unionize, prohibited unfair labor practices, and created the National Labor Relations Board. alphabet 1934: NIRA influence Industrial Unionism; anti-AFL All workers in one industry should be in 1 union, regardless of skill John Lewis: walks out of AFL 1936: Congress of Industrial Organizations Women, blacks Textiles, laundries, tobacco Labor Militancy Sit Down Strikes Dec. 1936 GM Detroit plants By Feb 1937: 17 GM plants Female supporters sent food/clothing Ignored police and court injunctions Governor and federal govt refused to intervene GM relents; recognizes UAW Memorial Day Massacre 1937 1937: 4700 strikes 80% settled in favor of unions 8 million union members (1932: 3 million) By 1941: 10 million included workers of Little Steel Unions win out REFORM: Prevent Another Depression SSA / 1935 Social Security Act It provided retirement pensions, unemployment insurance, aid to blind, deaf, disabled, and dependent children. alphabet Social Security Act of 1935 54 Social Security Unemployment Insurance 55 Old Age Pension Dependent Families + Disabled Classical Liberalism (Conservatives) Individual liberty is foundation of democracy Free market policies Weak govt New Deal Liberalism (Liberals) To preserve individual liberty, govt must assist needy and guarantee basic welfare of ppl New Deal Liberalism Works Progress Administration Harry Hopkins 110K public buildings 600 airports 500K miles of roads 100K bridges 2.1 million workers WPA { • • • • • Federal Writers Project Federal Arts Project Federal Music Project Federal Arts Project National Youth Administration 59 60 61 62 63 Court Packing…. The Supreme Court struck down several New Deal laws as unconstitutional (NRA and AAA) FDR wanted to increase the size of the court from 9 to 15. Would appoint justices who were pro-New Deal Minimum-wage law, Wagner Act and Social Security Act upheld Hurt FDR w/ southern Democrats and conservatives 67 FDR and the Supreme Court 68 Keynesian Economics John Maynard Keynes (British) Govt intervention can smooth out high and lows of business cycle Deficit spending Manipulate interest rates and money supply Limits and Legacies of the New Deal Remake American capitalism (not to be) Federal govt now a mediator b/w competing interests Govt to intervene when necessary Help/limit the power of groups “The Broker State” Not hostile, but not much to advance them Reinforced patterns of discrimination Less pay, less skilled jobs “Black Cabinet” FDR not willing to lose support of Southern Democrats African Americans & the New Deal Not outright hostile but not much to advance them Symbolic gestures Reinforced gender norms Women and the New Deal { West Received more federal funding Agricultural pgms Public works pgms Water and power { South Least developed region of country Didn’t challenge prevailing racial norms TVA New Deal in the West and South Didn’t revive/reform economy Didn’t fully embrace govt spending for recovery Didn’t end the Depression Didn’t alter the distribution of power and wealth New Deal Failures Helped elevate new groups Contributed to economic development of the West and South Increased regulatory functions of the federal govt Created the basis of the federal welfare state New Deal Impact on Economy FDR enhanced the power of federal govt Presidency became the preeminent center of authority Democratic Party domination American people had greater expectations of govt New Deal and American Politics LEFT No Govt Anarchy CENTER Socialism Democrat Green Party Communism Radical Liberal Independent Reform Moderate RIGHT Republican Conservative KKK Reactionary Dictator Fascist The New Deal walked a tightrope between the extreme positions of the left and right. Critics would claim it was unconstitutional, socialism, anti-laissez faire and went too far to the left. Others would claim the New Deal didn’t go far enough to the left…… Successes of New Deal AMERICANS IN 1939 WHO WANTED THE NEW DEAL TO CONTINUE WAS 55%….. 37% REGARDED IT AS A BAD INFLUENCE AND WANTED A NEW PRESIDENT…………... Stimulated the economy Put people back to work…. Improved morale and self-confidence of the people US Govt’s. role changes and became directly involved in helping people WWII ended the Great Depression not FDR’s New Deal 100 days