Taking Lessons from Thiamine Catalytic Umpolung Reactivity of Aldehydes Louis-Charles Campeau University of Ottawa Dept. of Chemistry Center for Catalysis Research and Innovation Taking Lessons From Thiamine Millions of Years of Evolution O O NH Ph Et Me O OH OH Molecular Complexity (azaspirene) Efficient and Stereo/RegioControlled Bond Formation Enzymes Novel Methods and Catalysts 2 Taking Lessons From Thiamine Millions of Years of Evolution O O NH Ph Et Me O OH OH Molecular Complexity (azaspirene) Efficient and Stereo/RegioControlled Bond Formation Enzymes Novel Methods and Catalysts Understanding Chemical Biology 3 Taking Lessons From Thiamine O O O (S)-Proline O O O O O OH NH Ph Et Me O -H2O Millions of Years of Evolution O OH OH Molecular Complexity (azaspirene) Efficient and Stereo/RegioControlled Bond Formation Aldolase Proline Based Catalysis Organocatalysis Understanding Chemical Biology 4 Taking Lessons From Thiamine Millions of Years of Evolution O O NH Benzoin/Stetter Reactions Ph Et Me O OH OH Molecular Complexity (azaspirene) Efficient and Stereo/RegioControlled Bond Formation Transketolase Carbene Catalysis Organocatalysis Thiamine Understanding Chemical Biology 5 Overview Umpolung Reactivity Benzoin Reaction Catalytic Cycle Recent developments O O R R H 1 R' 2 OH Stetter Methodology Aldehyde Umpolung Catalytic Cycle The Early Years: Hirsutic Acid C HO2C 11 Recent developments Conclusions Acknowledgements OH H 3 2 9 O H 6 Umpolung Reactivity “Umpolung” is derived from German meaning “inverse polarity” Any process by which the normal alternating donor and acceptor reactivity pattern of a chain is interchanged, do to the presence of O or N heteroatoms. HO R This original meaning of the term has been extended to the reversal of any commonly accepted reactivity pattern. Nu H Nu Umpolung O R H Electrophilic center IUPAC Compendium of Chemical Terminology, 2nd Edition (1997). O O E R R E Nucleophilic center 7 “Umpolung Chemistry” of Aldehydes Umpolung reactivity allows chemists to look at bond disconnections in new ways O R OH 3 1 O R' R 5 R' R 1 O R' R 2 OH 1 4 R' O O O H 1 O O R' R' Aldol OM Michael R D. Seebach, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 1979, 18, 239 ? 8 “Umpolung Chemistry” of Aldehydes Umpolung reactivity allows chemists to look at bond disconnections in new ways O R OH 3 1 O R' R 5 R' R Aldol OM R' 1 R 2 H D. Seebach, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 1979, 18, 239 4 R' O R' R' Michael R 1 O O R' R' O OH O O H 1 O O O R 9 Stochiometric Methods Cyanohydrins as aldehyde umpolung Homologation and its reversal 1. HCN 2. Protection O R NC OP Strong Base R H H NC OP R R'CHO O R' R OH D. Seebach, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 1979, 18, 239 1) Deprotection NC OP R 2) Retro-Cyanation R' OH 10 Cyanohydrins as Aldehyde Umpolung O H 1) DIBAl-H O EEO 2) HCN, EtOH HO 3) 50% AcOH H HO THF H CN EEO O 1) TsCl, Py 2) CH2CHOEt, PPTS O CN H H TsO EEO HO H EEO H 2) L-Selectride THF H H 1) 50% AcOH-THF KHMDS, PhH reflux (72%) HO CN H H COOH Me HO H OH Prostaglandine F2 G. Stork, T. Takahashi, I. Kawamoto, T. Suzuki, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1978, 100, 8272 11 Stochiometric Methods Dithianes as aldehyde umpolung Heteroatom exchange O R SH HS H BF3-Et2O S R S H Strong Base O R R' OH D. Seebach, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 1979, 18, 239 1) R'CHO 2) Dithiane Removal S R S 12 Dithianes as Aldehyde Umpolung OH O OTBDPS OTBDPS CH2(CH2SH2)2 O H OTIPS O OMe O TiCl4, DCM O O S S O H i-Bu OTIPS Leucascandrolide A then... t TIPSO I O BuLi, HMPA THF -78ºC OTIPS OTBDPS i-Bu 1) PhI(O2CCF3)2 MeOH/H2O/THF O SS TIPSO OH 2) L-Selectride THF O i-Bu O O OTIPS OTBDPS TIPSO P. Wipf and J.T. Reeves, Chem. Comm. 2002, 2066 13 Catalytic Methods Introduction to the benzoin reaction Nucleophilic acylation reactions catalyzed by lyases (transketolase) in the presence of coenzyme thiamine. H2N Umpolung Catalyst O Ph H N O Ph CH3 N * Ph H3C N OH Cl S HO Thiamine (vitamin B1) D. U. Nilsson, L. Meshalakina, Y. Lindqvist, G. Schneider, J. Biol. Chem., 1997, 272, 1864 14 Nature’s Way H2N N CH3 N H3C O OH OH HO O PO3 Cl S HO OH OH N O Thiamine OH HO O PO3 Sedoheptulose-7P OH Xylulose-5P OH OH OH O H O PO3 OPO3 O OH Glyceraldehyde-3P Ribose-5P " O " HO Synthon D. Enders & T. Balensiefer, Acc. Chem. Res, 2004, 37, 534 U. Nilsson, L. Meshalakina, Y. Lindqvist, G. Schneider, J. Biol. Chem., 1997, 272, 1864 15 Catalytic Vitamins Ph O * O Ph R2 R1 N R3 S Ph H OH R2 R3 R1 O N S -H R1 N R2 Ph OH Ph R2 S R3 R1 N H O Ph H R3 R2 R1 OH N Ph R3 S S R2 R1 N R3 S OH R2 R1 N S R3 Breslow Intermediate Ph OH Ph O Ph R. Breslow, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1958, 80, 3719 T. Ukai, R Tanaka, T. Dokawa, J. Pharm. Soc. Jpn., 1943, 63, 296 O Ph H 16 Benzoin Reaction – Early Years O Ph BzO H3C H MeOH, Et3N 30ºC CH3 N S N Ph * Ph OH H3C CH3 H3C O 10 mol% catalyst H3C S N S H3C H3C N S 9% yield 12% yield 6.1% yield 78% yield 22.5% ee 0% ee 51.5% ee 7.8% ee J.C. Sheehan, D.H. Hunneman, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1966, 88, 3666 J.C. Sheehan, T. Hara, J. Org. Chem., 1974, 39, 1196 17 Triazolium Catalysts 1 (1.25mol%) O Ar Triazolium catalysts give better yield and selectivity H K2CO3, THF 22-72% Proposed Transition State O Ar Ar Si face OH ee 20-86% O H Ph N N HO ClO4 N Ph O Si attack N N N Ph O O O 1 D. Enders, K. Breuer, J.H. Teles, Helv. Chim. Acta, 1996, 79, 1217 Re attack 18 Alternative Catalysts O Ph O catalyst Ph H * Ph OH Leeper O Rawal TBSO TBSO Ph Ph N N N N S S 34% yield 19.5% ee 20% yield 10.5% ee Ts N O S 50% yield 20.5% ee R.L. Knight, F.J. Leeper, Tetraheron Lett., 1997, 38, 3611 C.A. Dvorak, V.H. Rawal, Tetrahedron Lett., 1998, 39, 2925 R.L. Knight, F.J. Leeper, Perkin Trans. 1, 1998, 1891 N N Ph 45% yield 80% ee Ph N S 52% yield 48% ee 19 New Triazolium Catalyst O O Ph N N 3 Steps NH O BF4 N 50% overall Me3OBF4 DCM quant. a) HBF4, DCM, rt b) HC(OMe)3, MeOH, 80ºC 65% N NHPh OMe O N PhNHNH2, Et3N O NH THF 77% D. Enders, U. Kallfass, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2002, 41, 1743 20 Catalyst Activity cat. (10mol%) KOtBu, THF O Ar O Ar Ar H Ph N N 8-83% cat. = N O OH BF4 80-95% ee Substrate Loading (mol%) Temperature (ºC) 10 18 81 83 10 0 61 91 H 10 18 8 95 H 10 18 83 90 Yield (%) ee (%) O H F O MeO O D. Enders, U. Kallfass, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2002, 41, 1743 21 “Cross Benzoin” Reaction O O O R1 R2 H O R2 R1 H R1 R1 OH OH O catalyst R2 Usually Observed!! O R1 R2 OH Cross benzoin adducts R2 OH Homo benzoin adducts X. Linghu, J.S. Johnson, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2003, 42, 2534 22 Inefficiency of Cross-Benzoin Methodology R1 O * O O or R2 R1 H R2 C N OH O H R1 NC H O NC OH R1 R2 NC OH Ph OH R1 NC O R2 O O or R2 H R1 H 23 Inefficiency of Cross-Benzoin Methodology O O or R1 R1 O R1 H R2 C N OH O H R1 NC O NC OH R1 H R1 There is a lack of control because the more electophilic aldehyde reacts first!!! NC OH Ph OH R1 NC O R1 O O or R1 H R2 H 24 Silyl-Benzoin Reaction to the Rescue! O O R1 H O SiEt3 KCN/ [18]crown-6 (cat.) OSiEt3 R1 R2 only one adduct!! OSiEt3 OMe O Cl R2 Cl O O OSiEt3 OSiEt3 MeO 80% yield 80% yield Me Me O O Me OSiEt3 66% yield Cl 85% yield X. Linghu, J.S. Johnson, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2003, 42, 2534 O OSiEt3 75% yield 25 Catalytic Cycle of Silyl Benzoin NC O H R1 Fast and Reversible R1CHO CN O R2 NC O SiEt3 cyanation R2 SiEt3 [1,2] Brook rearrangement Irreversible N C CN R2 OSiEt3 R2 OSiEt3 O CN NC O O R2 R1 R1 OSiEt3 retrocyanation OSiEt3 R2 1,4-silyl migration R1 X. Linghu, J.S. Johnson, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2003, 42, 2534 H NC OSiEt3 O R2 R1 26 Chiral Metallophites in Silyl Benzoin O O Ph phosphite (5mol%) n-BuLi (5mol%) H SiEt3 Ph THF, 0.5hrs MeO OSiEt3 O P EtO Li EtO Me Me 100% conv. * O P OLi R2 SiEt3 [1,2] Brook rearrangement OMe O * R2 Ar Ar O O O P O Li O Ar Ar F Ar = 100% conv. 90% ee O P O Li R1 H * OSiEt3 Chiral Nucleophile X. Linghu, J.R. Potnick, J.S. Johnson, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2004, 126, 3070 O P OSiEt3 OLi R2 H R1 O R2 R1 OSiEt3 27 TimeLine Ph BzO Me X N N S R Sheehan First Chiral Carbenes 1966 1958 Breslow Catalytic Cycle R N OH S Ar H H Leeper/Rawal Bicyclic Cat. 1974 1997-98 1996 Enders Triazolium up to 86%ee 2002-04 Johnson Cross-Benzoin O Ph R N N N Ph O O SiEt3 Enders 90%ee Benzoin O N N N Ph 28 Back To The Future!! Benzoin Methodology 1966 1958 Breslow Catalytic Cycle R N OH S Ar 1974 1976 1997-98 1996 2002-04 29 Other Electrophiles? Can other electrophiles be used to give rise to other umpolung products OH O Ph Ph R2 X Y N H R1 Electrophile O Ph E R3 Breslow Intermediate 30 Stetter Reaction O O S R2 N R4 O Ph H R3 O OH O S Ph R2 N Base R4 O R1 OR R1 OR * Ph R1 R Ph R1 R3 R1 R * O O CN Ph * CN R1 H. Stetter, H. Kuhlmann, Chem. Ber., 1976, 109, 2890 H. Stetter, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 1976, 15, 639 31 First Intramolecular Stetter Trost & co-workers published the first stereocontrolled synthesis of Hirsutic Acid C Sesquiterpene with antibiotic and antimitotic activity 7 chiral centers H Me O Me HO2C 11 MeO2C H OH H TL, 1974, 3745 (Matsumoto) 3 2 9 O H Hirsutic Acid C B.M. Trost, C.D. Shuey, F. DiNinno Jr., S.S. McElvain, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1979, 101, 1284 32 OH H Hirsutic Acid C HO2C 11 3 2 9 O H Hirsutic Acid C O O H CN O O TMS O Br LDA, -30ºC THF O KOH, MeOH 88% TMS NC 2) CO2, then CH2N2 NC NEt3 (8 equiv.) PhMe, reflux, 12h 2.5% HCl (aq) CO2Me O H 1) LDA, TMEDA THF, -78C O O PhH, reflux 6h 88% NC O 70% NC CO2Me NC 2 11 NC CO2Me O H B.M. Trost, C.D. Shuey, F. DiNinno Jr., S.S. McElvain, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1979, 101, 1284 CO2Me 33 OH H Hirsutic Acid C 3 2 HO2C 11 9 O H Hirsutic Acid C 5% Pd, BaCO3 1 atm H2 NC NC NC BrZn CO2Et H O H CO2Me EtOH/EtOAc 80% NC NaOMe, MeOH rt, 3hrs 77% H PhH, Et2O, CO2Me reflux, 15min. 1)BH3-THF, 0ºC THF H MeO2C O 9 HOOC 2) Ac2O, Py, rt 89% 1) K2CO3, MeOH 0ºC, 2hrs 79% NC H CO2Me 2) PCC, DCM OAc rt, 88% NC EtO2C O H O 1)NBS, CCl4 reflux 30min H OAc CO2Me 2) LiBr, Li2CO3, DMF, 130ºC, 20min NC H CHO CO2Me B.M. Trost, C.D. Shuey, F. DiNinno Jr., S.S. McElvain, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1979, 101, 1284 34 Hirsutic Acid C OH H 3 2 HO2C 11 9 O H Hirsutic Acid C S I NC Me H CHO Me H Me MeO2C Me Me 11 3 MeO2C H 2 9 O O O Me H O MeO2C NC (2.3 eq.) NEt3 (50eq.) iPrOH, reflux 5h 67% CO2Me H N OH Me H OH HMe O Me Me MeO2C O TL, 1974, 3745 (Matsumoto) B.M. Trost, C.D. Shuey, F. DiNinno Jr., S.S. McElvain, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1979, 101, 1284 MeO2C O H Hirsutic Acid C 35 Intramolecular Variant Ciganek & co-workers reported the first study of the intramolecular variant Enders & co-workers reported the first asymmetric intramolecular Stetter reaction R O O cat. (20mol%) K2CO3, THF CHO CO2R 44-73% Ph N N N CO2R R O ee = 41-74% E. Ciganek, Synthesis, 1995, 1311 D. Enders, K. Breuer, J. Runsink, Helv. Chim. Acta, 1996, 79, 1899 cat. = O H3C Ph O CH3 36 New Highly Enantioselective Catalyst O cat. (20mol%) KHMDS (20mol%) CHO CO2Et CO2Et xylenes, 25ºC, 24hrs O O N O N BF4 N Ph N O O N Cl N Ph N N BF4 N Ph Ph 0% yield 27% yield O N N Cl N Ph 85% yield 79% ee O N 90% ee N BF4 N Ph Ph 48% yield 80% ee 58% yield M.S. Kerr, J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2002, 124, 10298 95% ee 37 Catalyst Optimization Structural modifications were made to improve the yield of the reaction O N N N O N H N N Cl 60% yield 91% ee 58% yield 95% ee O N N N OMe 94% yield 94% ee M.S. Kerr, J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2002, 124, 10298 38 Scope of the Intramolecular Stetter Reaction cat. (20mol%) KHMDS (20mol%) CHO R X CO2R xylenes, 25ºC, 24h O CO2R R X O O Me O CO2Et CO2Et CO2Et O O O Me 80% yield 97% ee OMe 90% yield 84% ee O O O 63% yield 96% ee CO2Me CO2Et CO2Et S 95% yield 87% ee N Me 64% yield 82% ee M.S. Kerr, J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2002, 124, 10298 N CO2Me 72% yield 84% ee 39 Effect of the Michael Acceptor O N BF4 N N O (20mol%) KHMDS (20mol%) CHO EWG O xylene, 25ºC, 24h O O OEt 58% yield 95% ee N 78% yield 75% ee M.S. Kerr, T. Rovis, Synlett, 2003, 12, 1934 EWG O O NH2 0% yield 95% recovered SM O H 0% yield 0% recovered SM Et 90% yield 92% ee only 1h! NO2 0% yield 0% recovered SM 40 Quaternary Carbon Centers Can we overcome the low reactivity when forming quaternary carbon centers?? S I CN MeO2C Me N OH Me NEt3 (50eq.) iPrOH, reflux 5h 67% CHO CN (2.3 eq.) O OH H HO2C MeO2C O H Hirsutic Acid C B.M. Trost, C.D. Shuey, F. DiNinno Jr., S.S. McElvain, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1979, 101, 1284 41 Catalytic Formation of Quaternary Carbon Centers O cat. (20mol%) KHMDS (20mol%) Et O O N CO2Me Et CO2Me PhMe, 25ºC, 24h O N BF4 N O N O O N BF4 N N N N F BF4 F H OMe F 45% yield 99% ee F 80% yield 99% ee M.S. Kerr, T. Rovis, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2004, 126, 8876 F 85% yield 99% ee 42 Aromatic Series : Scope O F BF4 F F F (20mol%) KHMDS (20mol%) O R EWG X N F N N O R 2 eq NEt3, PhMe, 25ºC, 24h O O O Et O Me Et CO2Me S 96% yield 97% ee CO2Et CO2Me 95% yield 92% ee O 95% yield 99% ee O Ph O O Ph Me O 55% yield 99% ee M.S. Kerr, T. Rovis, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2004, 126, 8876 EWG X Me O 43 Aliphatic Series: Scope O N F N N F BF4 F F F (20mol%) KHMDS (20mol%) O R EWG O R 2 eq NEt3, PhMe, 25ºC, 24h EWG O O O Me O Me O i-Bu Ph O N NO2 85% yield 96% ee 90% yield 84% ee O 81% yield 95% ee O Me O Me O Me 81% yield 95% ee M.S. Kerr, T. Rovis, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2004, 126, 8876 Ph 63% yield 99% ee 44 Catalytic Cycle : Revisited Ph O * O Ph EWG N N R N N O 4 N N * Ph H N R Ph N H O EWG 1 N N N N HO * Ph Ph N 3 N Ph OH N OH 2 R EWG J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted N N R EWG 45 Re-investigating the Mechanism What is the rate limiting step? C-C Bond formation – Ketones Were Faster… O Bn D O N BF4 N N Ph O H CO2Et 20mol% CO2Et KHMDS 20mol% PhMe O H CO2Et D H H O H O dr = 3:1 kH/kD = 3.8 Primary Kinetic Isotope Effect Observed Indicates C-H or X-H Bond Cleavage at the rate determining step J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted 46 Catalytic Cycle : Reloaded Ph * O O D Ph EWG N N R N N O 4 N N * Ph D D N R Ph N D O EWG 1 Could be Rate-Limiting N N Could be Rate-Limiting N N DO * Ph Ph N J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted N Ph OD N OD 2 R EWG 3 N N R EWG 47 Deuterium NMR Studies O Bn N BF4 N N Ph D O CO2Et H H Bn N N Ph CO2Et O H J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted CO2Et TMS H + CO2Et D H PhMe H + D O 20mol% D O O PhMe N CO2Et D KHMDS 20mol% O O O 20mol% O O H N D TMS CO2Et H + D O 48 Diastereoselective Protonation TMS N H N N N TMS O TMS N DH TMS H O H N N D OEt O H O TMS H N N O D H O OEt OEt O O O H HH O O N N O D N OEt O TMS DH O OEt H O major diastereomer Accounts for presence of D-HMDS and less than 100% deuterium incorporation J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted 49 Diastereoselective Protonation TMS N H N N N TMS O TMS N D H TMS H O N N O N OEt D H D N N TMS O J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted O O OEt O dr = 3:1 N H D OD OEt H OEt TMS N N DH O H H O OEt O O O TMS H N N O HH O TMS D O H D N OEt O H N O TMS N N N TMS O H D O H OEt O 50 Diastereoselective Protonation N N N O Absence of KHMSD D OEt O H O N N N O O D H O OEt O H H O DH OEt O dr = 9:1 Potential for generating two contiguous chiral centers with one catalytic reaction !!! J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted 51 Setting Contiguous Stereocenters O CO2Et O 20 mol% cat. H CO2Et Me Me PhMe, 24h, 25ºC O Entry Catalyst 1 Yield (%) ee (%) dr (%) 85 90 3:1 N N BF 4 N Ph N N N 80 90 15:1 N N N 94 92 30:1 Bn 2 Base O KHMDS Bn 3 Bn J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted CF3 52 Contiguous Stereocenters via Asymmetric Stetter Reaction O CO2Et Bn N N N pCF Ph 3 O 20 mol% H CO2Et Bn Bn PhMe, 24h, 25ºC O O O O Bn N N N pCF Ph 3 O 80% yield 89% ee, 20:1 dr O 20 mol% PhMe, 24h, 25ºC O O Bn O O J.R. de Alaniz, T. Rovis, submitted N N N pCF Ph 3 20 mol% PhMe, 24h, 25ºC H O H O O 95% yield 90% ee, 10:1 dr O H O H O 94% yield 99% ee, 50:1 dr 53 Conclusion O H2N N N CH3 N N Ph O N H3C Enders Ar N Johnson S HO Breslow O Ar Ar OH OH H SiR3 O Stetter HO2C O H Trost Bn O R' Ph R N CO2Et R O N N Ar H O N O N N N O N N Ar D H O H Rovis OEt O 54 Acknowledgements Prof. Keith Fagnou Prof. Tom Rovis Fagnou Research Group ... And you!! Mathieu Parisien Marc Lafrance Mélissa Leblanc Valérie Charbonneau Irina Dessinova Julien Dugal-Tessier Praew Thansandote Nicole Blaquiere 55