Year 7 History Expedition photos from Jules Barthoux, 1926 Written by Editing and layout by Ann Butler Program Coordinator Melbourne Museum Barbara Wels Licensed to Queensland Museum 2013 Queensland Museum Bookings 3840 7127 (qtix schools hotline) 3840 7466 (qtix group bookings) Copyright Teachers may photocopy this kit for educational purposes. © All images supplied by National Geographic List of Contents EDUCATION KIT History Year 7 Teacher Notes Introduction 1 Pedagogical Framework 3 Curriculum Links 4 Student Activities Overview of the Period Activity 1 What Makes Afghanistan the Centre of the Ancient 6 World? Activity 2 Silk Road or Melting Pot? In-Depth Study Activity 3 Alexander the Great Activity 4 Arrian and the Legends of Alexander Activity 5 Does Alexander Deserve his Heroic Reputation? 9 15 16 20 23 Resources 40 Exhibition Map 43 Teacher Notes Introduction In 2013-14 Queensland Museum & Sciencentre is hosting Afghanistan: Hidden Treasures from the National Museum, Kabul — an exhibition of precious artefacts from four important archaeological sites. The exhibition explores the interconnections between the different societies of the ancient world and the blending of cultural influences. The Afghan Government and officials from the National Museum in Kabul agree that it is important to the recovery and future of their country that the cultural artefacts of their rich and varied history are preserved. Visit the museum website at http://www.nationalmuseum.af/ to see how this is happening. Melbourne Museum has developed a series of Education Kits (licensed for use by Queensland Museum) including this History Kit. The ‘Introduction to the Exhibition’ Kit is a great starting point for teachers. All kits can be downloaded from the Queensland Museum exhibition website. The National Geographic website is another useful resource. It includes short videos of each of the four archaeological sites featured in this exhibition. Go to: http://museumvictoria.com.au/melbournemuseum/discoverycentre/afghanistan/ and http://www.nationalgeographic.com.au/mission/afghanistan-treasures/ Learning about history from Afghanistan Afghanistan: Hidden Treasures from the National Museum, Kabul can introduce students to Afghanistan’s central place in the ancient world, both geographically and strategically. Its role as the central hub of the Silk Road allows teachers to pursue links from Begram (one of the most important cities on the Silk Road and one of the significant archaeological sites) through to the Indian, Chinese, Egyptian, Greek and Roman civilisations trading in the region. Studying the ancient world allows students to walk with archaeologists and scholars as they piece together the stories of the past. This exhibition is relevant to both the Overview and Depth Studies of Year 7 Historical Knowledge and Understanding. A study of Afghanistan through its nomad groups, early settlements and the Silk Road engages students with an exploration of what we currently know about the past and the mysteries that still remain. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 1 Teacher Notes The activities in this kit ideally serve as an introduction to the Ancient World theme. Both units of work in this kit provide opportunities for students to develop historical understanding through an examination of primary and secondary sources of evidence. Students are invited to work collaboratively to devise questions that frame inquiries. Ongoing developments in the archaeological discovery of Afghanistan create an ideal setting for students to appreciate the kind of debates that engage the experts. Activity 1 and 2 have been designed in response to the History Overview section of the Year 7 curriculum. Melbourne Museum suggest comparing with their online Unit on Mesopotamia, to take students through an understanding of the transition from nomadic life to a more settled existence, and the growth of cities and the interconnectedness of the ancient world. This works well as a launching pad into the Depth Studies. Go to: http://museumvictoria.com.au/melbournemuseum/education/education-kits/thewonders-of-ancient-mesopotamia Activities 3 - 5 present a Depth Study on Alexander the Great. A large and valuable collection of artefacts from one of the most significant archaeological sites, Ai Khanum, invites students to enter the vast world of the Ancient Greek Empires. Ai Khanum is thought to have been settled by Greek descendants of soldiers from Alexander’s army. But far from being merely ethnically Greek, they kept alive a thriving Hellenistic culture that had far-reaching influences within Afghan culture in general. Alexander’s exploits in Afghanistan and the rest of Central Asia are remarkable illustrations of the power behind empires as well as a study in heroism and leadership. The Roman historian Arrian is our main source of information about Alexander the Great. In this unit, students will interrogate the reliability of Arrian’s text by examining his stated motivation and excerpts from his history. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 2 Teacher Notes Pedagogical Framework The units of work within this kit are structured so that students are working collaboratively to undertake inquiries and share their results. The Historical Skills strand applies processes of formulating hypotheses, collecting evidence and drawing conclusions. This reflects the Australian Curriculum’s Critical and Creative thinking framework, which encourages: reasoning, processing and inquiry creativity reflection, evaluation and metacognition. It is expected that students will develop a metacognitive approach to their learning, identifying strengths and weaknesses. This is also reflected in the Personal and Social capability domain which calls on students to monitor their progress as learners. CHECK from orig THIS INSN’t CUT & P FROM ART Consequently, a reflective exercise has been added at the end of the activity. Teachers may like to encourage students to keep a Learning Log or Journal as they complete the tasks of the Unit. In this way they are better able to identify correct conceptions and misconceptions, as an important step in the learning process. Students are asked to compare content and analyse data by identifying and evaluating sources, interpret different social, cultural and historical contexts and organising their findings. Guidelines to assist with group Inquiry Learning have been devised by Melbourne Museum: http://museumvictoria.com.au/education/community-of-inquiry/. For additional exhibition resources that are ideal for classroom use, be sure to visit the National Geographic website: http://www.nationalgeographic.com.au/mission/afghanistan-treasures/ Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 3 Teacher Notes Curriculum Links Hidden Treasures and Year 7 History Historical Knowledge and Understanding Classroom Resources in Museum Education Kit Overview Depth Study Understand broad patterns of historical change. All activities An examination of the evidence for the establishment of ancient societies: The tension between nomadic and settled life. Overview of the Historical Period Activity 1 What makes Afghanistan the Centre of the Ancient World? Activity 2 Silk Road or Melting Pot? An investigation of one of the key features of ancient societies: Trade along the Silk Road, including contact with India and China. Overview of the Historical Period Activity 1 What makes Afghanistan the Centre of the Ancient World? Activity 2 Silk Road or Melting Pot? The methods and sources used to investigate historical controversies that have challenged historians. In-Depth Study Activity 3 Alexander the Great Activity 4 Arrian and the Legends of Alexander Activity 5 Does Alexander deserve his heroic reputation? Contacts and conflicts with other societies, resulting in developments such as the conquest of other lands. In-Depth Study Activity 3 Alexander the Great The role of significant individuals: Alexander the Great as a Greek hero. Contacts with other societies resulting in the expansion of trade and the spread of religious beliefs. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au In-Depth Study Activity 3 Alexander the Great Activity 4 Arrian and the Legends of Alexander Activity 5 Does Alexander deserve his heroic reputation? Activity 2 Silk Road or Melting Pot? page 4 Teacher Notes Hidden Treasures and Year 7 History (continued) Thinking Processes Classroom Resources in Museum Education Kit Reasoning, processing and inquiry Students locate and select relevant information. Inquiry tasks in all activities Students use a range of strategies of reasoning and analysis to evaluate evidence. Creativity Students explore possibilities and generate multiple options. Inquiry tasks in all activities Reflection, Evaluation and Metacognition Students use specific language to describe their thinking and modify and evaluate their thinking strategies. Reflective Learning Journal Students describe and explain changes that may occur in their ideas and beliefs over time. Personal Learning The Individual Learner Classroom Resources Students monitor and describe their progress as learners, identifying strengths and weaknesses Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au Reflective Learning Journal page 5 Student Activity 1 Introduction The Silk Road What we have come to see as separate civilisations in the ancient world were actually civilisations connected together by a series of trade routes. Long before the first century AD the flourishing civilisation of Mesopotamia was connected to Afghanistan through its demand for lapis lazuli and other precious stones and minerals. They were also trading with Egypt for gold. Conquests in war created an intermingling of ethnic groups and cultures as conquered peoples were brought back as slaves. The defeat of Babylon by the Persians and their own later defeat by the Greeks created an exchange of learning and culture. This intermingling stimulated the creativity of each of the civilisations flourishing at that time. Alexander the Great’s three year long journey of conquest through Central Asia in 320 BC, established the Hellenistic tradition in Bactria in Northern Afghanistan. There was, however, during the first century AD —the period of the early Roman Empire — intense growth in commerce. The Mediterranean basin and South Asia were connected by vast and complex networks of long distance travel and commerce. Begram in Afghanistan is positioned as a node in the vast Eurasian and Indian Ocean networks of trade and commerce. (For activities on the geography of the Silk Road please see the Hidden Treasures Geography Education Kit on the Melbourne Museum website). TIP You can download and print out a map of the Silk Road at: http://www.google.com.au/search?q=Silk+Road+Map&hl=en&safe=active&tbo=d&rlz=1T4A DSA_enAU376AU377&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=FbIZUYIao52ZBdz1gfAF&ved=0C AoQ_AUoAQ&biw=1127&bih=592 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 6 Student Activity 1 What Makes Afghanistan the Centre of the Ancient World? Task 1: Map the Silk Road Using the blank map of Afghanistan on the following page, mark the following places and features on your copy or printout, using an atlas as a guide. a) Begram b) The two rivers which meet at Begram – the Ghurband and the Panjhir c) Kabul, 80 kilometres north d) The Khyber Pass, 250 kilometres north-west e) The Panjhir River f) The Jalalabad Plains g) Bactria to the north h) The Hindu Kush i) The paths to China j) Taxila Can you see that Begram was located centrally among other ancient cultures, in the first century AD? Task 2: Map sea trade in the Afghanistan region Begram was also connected to sea trade in the Indian Ocean and the Red Sea. Mark the following places on your map. a) The Indian Ocean b) The Red Sea c) The sea ports of Barbarikon and Barygaza d) The paths from Begram to the Mediterranean Sea Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 7 Student Activity 1 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 8 Student Activity 2 Silk Road or Melting Pot? The name ‘Silk Road’ is a little misleading because it was not just one road and silk was not the only item being traded. No merchant would have travelled the whole road from one end to the other — there were trading centres along the way. The movement and exchange of goods along the Silk Road spread artistic styles and techniques across a number of diverse civilisations that were quite far apart. The artefacts in the exhibition reflect this rich crosspollination (or melting pot) of artistry and ideas. Begram was a particularly large and important trading centre, not just because of its position on the route. It was very close both to the only known source of lapis lazuli and to Bactria, which had a well-established tradition of metal smelting. The importance of Begram was first revealed to the modern world when the archaeologist Joseph Hackin discovered two sealed rooms at the site. The rooms were filled with many exotic objects which came from all over the trade routes of the time. The find caused some controversy among archaeologists. Hackin originally believed that he had found the treasure rooms of a palace but further study suggested that these were storerooms full of luxury items to be traded. Task 1: Follow the roads out of Afghanistan You’ll need to download and print out a map of the Silk Road for this task. Go to: http://www.google.com.au/search?q=Silk+Road+Map&hl=en&safe=active&tbo=d&rlz=1T4A DSA_enAU376AU377&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=FbIZUYIao52ZBdz1gfAF&ved=0C AoQ_AUoAQ&biw=1127&bih=592 a) All of the objects shown in the following pages were found in the sealed rooms at Begram on the Silk Road. Do what the archaeologists did — follow the tracks. For each object, you have been given some clues to help you discover its country of origin. b) Decide where each object (or the style of its design) came from. c) Mark each place or area on your map of the Silk Road and write the object number there. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 9 Student Activity 2 Objects 1 and 2 Clues to help you decide where the object/design/style came from: These objects are made from ivory. Both were designed as decoration for furniture — one as an insert for a chair and the other as a table leg. The wooden parts have rotted away. The woman in the statue is said to resemble the goddess Ganga. Other ivory works have been found in Uzbekistan and in Pompeii. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 10 Student Activity 2 Object 3 Clues It’s made of glass. How might the shape have been made? Analysis of the glass found it to be very similar to the kind found in Egypt and the Near East. Ancient sources mention Alexandria as a centre for glass manufacturing. Examples of this type of glass have been found throughout the ancient Roman world and in southern India. You may need to research who was in power in Egypt during the first century AD. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 11 Student Activity 2 Object 4 Clues This is made of plaster. It was thought to be a cast for making bronze medallions. Fingerprints were found on the front. They are not decorated in any way. The child is clutching a butterfly against his breast. The Greek name for butterfly was Psyche. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 12 Student Activity 2 Object 5 Clues This is made of bronze. It is a scale weight. It may have originally been used as a cosmetic jar. The figure is wearing a cuirass. It may represent the god Mars. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 13 Student Activity 2 Task 2: Connect the places, objects, materials and ideas a) Take another look at the five objects and your map. b) Draw a diagram with Begram at the centre, connecting out to the places where the objects came from. c) Next to the name of each place, list the key materials, ideas or other influences that came to Begram via the Silk Road. These elements represent the melting pot of culture found in Afghanistan’s cultural heritage and the place it is today. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 14 Student Activity 3 Depth Study Alexander the Great Background on Ai Khanum In 1961, the King of Afghanistan Mohamed Zahir Shah was out hunting when he discovered a Corinthian capital. Archaeologists subsequently uncovered the site at Ai Khanum and discovered the remains of a city founded by Greeks and evidence that they had continued to both speak their own language and maintain many of their cultural traditions until they were conquered by nomads in 145 BC. Ai Khanum was a remarkable find because it indicated that a Greek city had once existed 5,000 kilometres from Greece. For a long time, archaeologists and historians had speculated as to whether one of Alexander the Great’s legendary cities would ever be found. Alexander was said to have founded a large number of cities during his long journey through Central Asia from 331 BC but nobody was exactly sure where they were. Ai Khanum wasn’t founded by Alexander but by descendants of his troops. Many of the objects in the Museum’s exhibition Afghanistan: Hidden Treasures from the National Museum, Kabul, come from this site at Ai Khanum and are evidence of the rich culture set in place by the descendants of Alexander’s armies and the settlement he began. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 15 Student Activity 3 Alexander the Great Alexander the Great is perhaps one of the best known figures of the ancient world, especially the ancient Greek world. Although Alexander died quite young — at only about 33 years of age — he had a very eventful life. He has been the subject of many stories and a great deal of myth-making over the centuries. ‘The story of Alexander has been told and retold, part history, part legend. Specialists have devoted lifetimes of scholarship debating the ‘Romance of Alexander.’ Over eighty versions in twenty-six languages exist. Folktales about Iskander (as most Middle Eastern groups call Alexander) are still told in villages and camps of Afghanistan.’ Dupree, L., Afghanistan, Princeton University Press, USA, 1980 ‘Alexander revolutionised the East, or, at any rate, so much of it as was connected with the West by intercourse or reciprocal influence. The results of a conquest affected in ten years continued for as many centuries, and remain in some respects to the present day. The Hellenisation of Western Asia and North-eastern Africa, which dates from Alexander's successes, is one of the most remarkable facts in the history of the human race, and one of those most pregnant with important consequences. It is as absurd to deny to the author of such a revolution the possession of extraordinary genius as to suppose that the Iliad could have been written by a man of no particular ability.’ Rawlinson, G., History of Macedonia, The Colonial Press, New York, USA, 1899 Does Alexander deserve his heroic reputation? Was he an exemplary leader? How do we separate out the stories from the facts? Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 16 Student Activity 3 Task 1: Consider the idea of an exemplary leader a) Use the worksheet below to list the people you admire and think of as your own personal heroes, and identify their exemplary qualities. My personal Area/s of heroes leadership Qualities Values they Values I hold hold e.g. sport, politics, science, the arts, charity, community, school Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 17 Student Activity 3 b) Are exemplary leaders also heroes or is heroism something different? What qualities make someone a hero? c) Are all the individuals on your list men, or are women included too? d) How do you know about these people? Are your sources of information reliable? What makes a source reliable? Task 2: Define key qualities a) As a class, see if you can agree on three key criteria or qualities for each of the following ideas. Can you also come up with examples that meet your criteria? an exemplary leader a hero Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 18 Student Activity 3 b) Now, see if you can agree on three key criteria or qualities for each of the following ideas: a reliable historical source a reliable online source b) Create a list of your criteria with examples of reliable sources. Use it as a guide when researching and evaluating the reliability of different primary and secondary sources. Criteria Examples of reliable sources (historical and online) Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 19 Student Activity 4 Arrian and the Legends of Alexander Arrian, a Roman historian, is one of the main sources of information about Alexander. Arrian lived between AD 86 and 160. His family background was Greek but he was a Roman citizen who wrote his history of Alexander’s campaign almost four hundred years after the events he describes. It is difficult to believe this fact as you read his incredibly detailed descriptions of battles and other events. His history is valuable because it incorporates accounts from people who were alive when Alexander was, and whose writings have since been lost. Arrian drew on the work of: Callisthenes, a nephew of Aristotle (who was Alexander’s tutor) Aristobulus, who accompanied Alexander on his campaigns Ptolemy, said to be Alexander’s half-brother, who became King of Egypt and who also accompanied Alexander as one of his generals. Here’s how Arrian explained his reasons for writing about Alexander. ‘No prose history, no epic poem was written about him; he was not celebrated even in such choral odes as preserve the name and memory of Hiero or Gelo or Thero, or many other men not in the same class as Alexander, with the result that the wonderful story of his life is less familiar today than that of the merest nonentities of the ancient world’ ‘…there has never been another man in all the world, of Greek or any other blood, who by his own hand succeeded in so many brilliant enterprises.’ De Selincourt, A., (Translator) Arrian, The Campaigns of Alexander, Penguin Books, 1971 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 20 Student Activity 4 Task 1: Interrogate Arrian’s perspective a) What do you think of Arrian’s intentions? Would modern historians share his motivation for writing history? Why? b) Do Arrian’s motives affect the credibility of his writing? c) Does it matter that Arrian’s eye-witness sources are now lost? Why? How does this affect the text’s reliability? Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 21 Student Activity 4 Task 2: Evaluate Arrian’s sources a) Are eyewitness accounts reliable? Why? b) What vested interests might Callisthenes, Aristobulus and Ptolemy have had in writing their accounts of Alexander’s life and travels? Task 3: Identify reliable sources and their interests a) With so much information available on the internet, how do you identify reliable sources for research? b) What vested interests might individuals, groups or organisations have in putting material online? What value can their information have, and for whom? Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 22 Student Activity 5 Does Alexander Deserve his Heroic Reputation? Let’s look at what Arrian says to examine what kind of leader Alexander was. Task 1: Focus your investigation a) Organise yourselves into groups of four. Each member of the group should choose one aspect of Alexander to investigate: his personal behaviour his military tactics his behaviour towards his men his behaviour towards the people he conquered. b) Organise yourselves into new ‘expert groups’ of students who have chosen the same aspect to investigate as you. c) In these new groups, read the Background Briefing Notes on your topic and assess Alexander’s behaviour using the worksheet to guide your group discussion and notetaking. HINTS: Alexander has been the subject of a great deal of myth-making over the centuries and this can sometimes get in the way of the facts. Use the worksheet to keep track of the sources of your information and note how reliable you think the source is. Keep in mind that ethics — values or beliefs about correct behaviour — change over time. Would Alexander have earned praise today for the things he was praised for in his lifetime and in Arrian’s time? Can we ever really understand what people thought 2,000 years ago? Why? Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 23 Student Activity 5 Task 2: Consolidate and share your findings a) Now rejoin your original group where each ‘expert’ will report on their findings. Remember to listen carefully and critically to what others are reporting. b) Turn your attention to the research question: Does Alexander deserve his heroic reputation? and complete the Group Worksheet . c) In a presentation of approximately ten minutes, argue your group’s conclusion, providing the reasons for your decision and the evidence on which it is based. Make reference to the group’s values, even if there were different opinions. The two worksheets you have completed can be used to help organise and plan your presentation. Task 3: Reflect on learning Complete this when you have completed tasks 1 and 2. a) Which part of the last activity was the most difficult to complete? b) What things did you do to help you figure out the hardest part (e.g. talk to members of your group, ask a teacher, use a dictionary or search the internet)? c) Look again at the notes you recorded earlier in your log. Has your thinking and reading changed your view about who is an exemplary leader? What would you now say constitutes a hero? Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 24 Student Activity 5 Background Briefing Notes for Task 2 Alexander’s Personal Behaviour 1.1 In the battle with the Tyrians, Alexander himself was in the thick of it, fighting like the rest and ever on the watch for any act of conspicuous courage in the face of danger among his men. 1.2 Before the battle for Gaza, Alexander received a bad omen. At first he kept out of range but sighting an attack on his troops, Alexander forgot the seer’s prophetic warning. At the head of his guards, he hurried in support of the Macedonians at the very point where they were hardest pressed. He later received a serious wound in the shoulder. 1.3 When the Macedonians were attacked on their way out of Bactria by tribesmen, Alexander joined his troops in the difficult task of scaling the high cliffs. He was wounded in the leg, his fibula broken, but despite every obstacle he took his place and only 8,000 of the 30,000 enemy soldiers survived. 1.4 On the mutilation of his enemies, Arrian has this to say about Alexander: ‘I do not myself approve the excessive severity of this punishment: for mutilation of that sort is, I think, a barbarous custom. I admit, moreover, that Alexander came to emulate Eastern extravagance and splendour and the fashion of barbaric kings of treating their subjects as inferiors, regrettable too was the assumption of Persian dress and the pointed bonnet of the vanquished Persians. The splendid achievements of Alexander are the clearest possible proof that neither strength of body, nor noble blood, nor success in war, can make a man happy, unless he can win one more victory – the victory over himself.’ 1.5 At a feast in honour of Dionysius, Alexander had been drinking heavily — in drink, too, he now tended to barbaric excess. Cleitus, who was a close friend but who disliked Alexander’s move towards the east, objected to comparisons being made between the god Heracles and Alexander. Cleitus belittled Alexander’s achievements in comparison with his father, Phillip II. Alexander lost his temper and struck Cleitus, who had earlier saved his life, and killed him. Alexander was so distraught that he did not eat or drink for three days. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 25 Student Activity 5 1.6 In Sogdia, the natives had withdrawn to the Rock of Sogdiana which rose sheer on every side. When Alexander approached the natives to work out a peace treaty, they responded by laughing and told Alexander in their barbaric lingo to find soldiers with wings to capture the Rock for him. Alexander was insulted and offended so he decided to offer money to any soldier who would scale the rock. Three hundred accepted the challenge. The natives were so surprised to see Alexander’s soldiers in their fortress that they surrendered. 1.7 As thanks for his victory Alexander offered 300 full suits of Persian armour to the goddess Artemis. 1.8 He built a temple to Zeus after his victory at Sardis. 1.9 After Tyre had peacefully surrendered, Alexander made sacrifices to the Tyrian god Heracles in one of the world’s oldest temples dedicated to him. There, he presented to Heracles the Tyrian ship that was sacred to him. 1.10 In Babylon after the victory of Gaugamela, Alexander met the Chaldeans and took their advice in all matters of religious ceremony, offering sacrifices to Bel in particular according to their instructions. Source De Selincourt, A., (Translator) Arrian, The Campaigns of Alexander, Penguin Books, 1971 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 26 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au 1.5 1.4 1.3 1.2 1.1 Decision Alexander’s Personal Behaviour Qualities Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Reliable source? Student Activity 5 page 27 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au 1.10 1.9 1.8 1.7 1.6 Decision Alexander’s Personal Behaviour Qualities Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Reliable source? Student Activity 5 page 28 Student Activity 5 Background Briefing Notes for Task 2 Alexander’s Military Tactics 2.1 Before the battle of the River Granicus, Parmenio recommended a cautious approach. Alexander chose the riskier course, partly as a tactic — it would give the Persians added confidence — but also because of his personal reputation and that of his army. He claimed that ‘…hesitancy would be unworthy of the fighting fame of our people and of my own promptitude in the face of danger’. 2.2 During the battle of River Granicus, Alexander’s spear broke while he was engaged in hand-to-hand combat. One of his men threw his own sword to Alexander who then faced and killed Mithridates, Darius’ son-in-law. Rhoesaces sliced off part of Alexander’s helmet and Alexander killed him but then Spithridates came at him, his scimitar raised in his hand. Cleitus appeared and hacked off his arm. 2.3 At Miletus, against Parmenio’s advice, Alexander refused to fight the superior Persian fleet, despite a good omen of an eagle appearing. He preferred to attack the Persians on land. 2.4 After a successful siege, 300 Greek mercenaries had escaped to an island. Alexander intended to kill them but was so impressed by their courage and loyalty that he offered them places within his army instead, under his own command. 2.5 Alexander decided to disband his fleet due to lack of money and because it was no match for the Persian navy. He also did not wish to subject his men to disaster. He knew that he could disempower the Persian fleet by seizing coastal towns. 2.6 Darius sent envoys offering money and territory for peace. Parmenio advised him to accept the offer. Alexander replied, ‘That is what I should do were I Parmenio; but since I am Alexander, I shall send Darius a different answer.’ Alexander refused the offer of peace. 2.7 Alexander was advised that the city of Gaza in Palestine was too well fortified to be taken. Alexander remained firm in his belief that the more difficult something is, the more vitally important it is to do. He believed that a success so far beyond reason and probability would be a serious blow to the morale of the enemy, while failure would be an equally serious blow to his own prestige. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 29 Student Activity 5 2.8 To enter Bactria, Alexander and his troops had to cross the raging Oxus River. There was not much timber to build a bridge with. Alexander instructed his men to stuff all the tents they could find with dry rubbish and sew them up, and with the use of these all of the men crossed the river in five days. 2.9 The attack on Cyropolis was difficult due to the city’s high strong walls. Alexander noticed water channels that were dry and emerged below the surrounding wall, leaving room enough for men to crawl through. Alexander and a few of his men crawled into the town and opened the nearest gates so the rest of their troops could invade. Source De Selincourt, A., (Translator) Arrian, The Campaigns of Alexander, Penguin Books, 1971 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 30 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au 2.5 2.4 2.3 2.2 2.1 Decision Alexander’s Military Tactics Qualities Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Reliable source? Student Activity 5 page 31 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au 2.9 2.8 2.7 2.6 Decision Alexander’s Military Tactics Qualities Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Reliable source? Student Activity 5 page 32 Student Activity 5 Background Briefing Notes for Task 2 Alexander’s Behaviour Towards his Men 3.1 After each battle Alexander visited the wounded, asking them each how they had received their wounds. 3.2 Alexander had been injured by having a sword thrust in his thigh but this did not prevent him from visiting the wounded on the day after the battle, when he also gave a splendid military funeral. At the ceremony he spoke in praise of every man who had distinguished himself in the fighting. 3.3 When things settled after a long campaign, he arranged for newly married men to return home for the winter to spend time with their wives. ‘No act of Alexander’s ever made him better beloved by his native troops’. 3.4 In preparation for the assault on Tyre, the men were building a temporary bridge to the walls of the city. Alexander was always on the spot giving instructions as to how to proceed, with many a word of encouragement and special rewards for conspicuously good work. 3.5 Alexander was informed of a plot against him led by Philotas who was Parmenio’s son. Philotas was brought to trial before the Macedonians where irrefutable proof was produced. Philotas admitted knowledge of the plot but had said nothing about it despite visiting Alexander’s tent at least twice a day. He was executed. Parmenio, Philotas’ father and Alexander’s loyal general, was also executed. The reason for Parmenio’s execution may have been that Alexander could not believe that he had no share in his son’s conspiracy. On the other hand, even granting his innocence, having Parmenio live on after his son’s execution was already in fact a danger, for he was a man of immense prestige. He had great influence not only with Alexander himself but also with the army. Source De Selincourt, A., (Translator) Arrian, The Campaigns of Alexander, Penguin Books, 1971 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 33 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au 3. 5 3. 4 3. 3 3. 2 3.1 Decision Qualities Alexander’s Behaviour towards his Men Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Reliable source? Student Activity 5 page 34 Student Activity 5 Background Briefing Notes for Task 2 Alexander’s Behaviour towards the People he Conquered 4.1 After a battle, Alexander buried the dead and then granted the parents and children of the slaughtered immunity from taxes and all other dues. 4.2 He gave rites of burial to Persian commanders and Greek mercenaries. Survivors were taken back to Macedonia as slaves. 4.3 He allowed the local people to return to their homes. 4.4 He accepted the surrender of Mithrines at Sardis and treated him in a way suitable for his rank. He permitted the people to observe old customs and gave them freedom. 4.5 The local leaders at Ephesus were seeking revenge on those who had supported the revolt. Alexander put a stop to it fearing that they might kill innocents out of personal hatred and greed ‘…with the result that his popularity never stood higher that it did on this occasion by his handling of the situation at Ephesus’. 4.6 When he took over towns formerly ruled by Persians he ‘dispossessed the ruling elites and established government in their place, allowing every community to enjoy its own laws and customs’. 4.7 His sympathy was extended even to the Persian King Darius’ wife, mother and children. On inquiring about the sounds of lamentation coming from a nearby tent, he was told that it was Darius’ women crying because they thought that Darius was dead. Alexander immediately sent one of his companions to tell them that Darius was alive and had fled to safety in his war chariot. He said that he had not fought Darius out of personal bitterness but had made legitimate war for the sovereignty of Asia. 4.8 Three of the four envoys to Darius captured by Parmenio were freed because they were Thebans and were only trying to do the best for their conquered country. One belonged to the noble families of Thebes and another had performed successfully at the Olympic Games. The third he kept on his private staff because of the fame of his father’s name. The fourth was kept under arrest because he came from a hostile city but he was also later freed. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 35 Student Activity 5 4.9 Azemilcus, King of Tyre, together with the dignitaries of the town, had fled to Heracles’ temple for refuge. To all of these people Alexander granted a free pardon, while everyone else was sold into slavery — in all some 30,000 were sold. 4.10 When Bessus, the satrap of Bactria who had plotted against Darius (Alexander’s enemy) was captured, he was stripped naked and placed in a dog collar before being chained by the side of the road. When Alexander came to him in his chariot, he asked him why he had betrayed and killed Darius. Bessus replied that it was to win Alexander’s favour and save their lives. Alexander ordered him scourged and then sent away to Bactria to be executed. 4.11 Another traitor to Darius was brought before a full meeting of his officers. Alexander gave orders that his nose and the tips of his ears be cut off, and that thus mutilated he should be taken back to his home to suffer public execution before his own countrymen. Source De Selincourt, A., (Translator) Arrian, The Campaigns of Alexander, Penguin Books, 1971 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 36 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au 4.5 4.4 4.3 4.2 4.1 Decision Qualities Alexander’s Behaviour towards the People he Conquered Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Reliable source? Student Activity 5 page 37 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au 4.11 4.10 4.9 4.8 4.7 4.6 Decision Qualities Alexander’s Behaviour towards the People he Conquered Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Reliable source? Student Activity 5 page 38 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au Behaviour towards the people he conquered Behaviour towards his men Military Tactics Personal Behaviour Qualities Does Alexander deserve his heroic reputation? Consolidate your findings Values Exemplary or heroic? Shared by me? Student Activity 5 page 39 Resources Key Sources National Museum of Afghanistan, Kabul Museum website including information about collections, exhibitions, images and a map showing archaeological sites http://www.nationalmuseum.af/ National Geographic Information about Afghanistan, the exhibition and its themes, including maps and a fantastic range of videos and other resources Afghanistan: Hidden Treasures from the National Museum, Kabul http://www.nationalgeographic.com.au/mission/Afghanistan-treasures/ Melbourne Museum Museum website with information about exhibitions, education programs and online resources for teachers and students including: Guidelines on Conducting a Community of Inquiry The Wonders of Ancient Mesopotamia http://museumvictoria.com.au/melbournemuseum/discoverycentre/afghanistan/ http://museumvictoria.com.au/melbournemuseum/education/ Books Bernard, P., ‘An Ancient Greek City in Central Asia’, Scientific American, 1982, vol. 246, no.1, 148-159 De Selincourt, A., (Translator) Arrian, The Campaigns of Alexander, Penguin Books, 1971 Dupree, L., Afghanistan, Princeton University Press, USA, 1980 Hiebert, F., and Cambon, P., (editors) Afghanistan: Hidden Treasures from the National Museum of Kabul, Exhibition Catalogue, collective publication by National Geographic, Museum Victoria, Queensland Museum, Art Gallery of NSW and Western Australian Museum Rawlinson, G., History of Macedonia, The Colonial Press, New York, USA, 1899 Tanner, S., Afghanistan: A Military History from Alexander the Great to the War Against the Taliban, Da Capo Press, 2009 Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 40 Resources Websites Academia.edu — Greek influences at Ai Khanum by Rachel Mairs http://brown.academia.edu/RachelMairs/Papers/1545867/_The_Founder_Shrine_and_the_F oundation_of_Ai_Khanum_ British Museum — blog with videos of glassmaking to produce glass fish found at Begram http://blog.britishmuseum.org/category/exhibitions/Afghanistan-crossroads-of-the-ancientworld/ China Institute — comprehensive information about the Silk Road http://www.chinainstitute.cieducationportal.org/cimain/wpcontent/themes/chinainstitute/pdfs/education/fromsilktooil_pdf3.pdf ECAI (Electronic Cultural Atlas Initiative) —information about Begram http://www.ecai.org/begramweb/docs/BegramChapter5_3.htm George Rawlinson — introduction to the history of Macedonia http://www.ancientmacedonia.com/Rawlinson.html National Geographic —interactive map with information about artefacts and themes Afghanistan: Hidden Treasures from the National Museum, Kabul http://www.nationalgeographic.com/mission/Afghanistan-treasures/ Powerhouse Museum — information about the nomads of Central Asia http://www.powerhousemuseum.com/previous/beyond_silk.php University of California E-books Collection — Hellenism at Ai Khanum by Martin Robertson http://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft0000035f&chunk.id=ch3&toc.depth= 1&toc.id=ch3&brand=ucpress University of Texas — map of the Greek Empire http://www.utexas.edu/courses/fallofgreece/alexander_ai_Khanum.jpg University of Texas — photo of Ai Khanum before excavation http://www.utexas.edu/courses/fallofgreece/aikhanum.jpg University of Texas — photo of the Theatre at Ai Khanum http://www.utexas.edu/courses/fallofgreece/aikhanumtheater.jpg University of Texas — photo of Corinthian capitals at Ai Khanum http://www.utexas.edu/courses/fallofgreece/aikhanumcorincaps.jpg University of Texas —photo of the Colonnade at Ai Khanum http://www.utexas.edu/courses/fallofgreece/aikhanumcorinthcol.jpg University of Texas — photo of the Gymnasium at Ai Khanum http://www.utexas.edu/courses/fallofgreece/aikhanumgymswing.jpg YouTube Ai Khanum flyover http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=5tka9TFyWIw YouTube Documentary: In the Footsteps of Alexander — Part 1 http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=CrTS4O25Jow&feature=related Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 41 Resources YouTube Documentary: In the Footsteps of Alexander — Part 2 http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=BYR3AEWUVyc&feature=relmfu YouTube Documentary: In the Footsteps of Alexander — Part 3 http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=nAAW0BRl21M&feature=relmfu YouTube Documentary: In the Footsteps of Alexander — Part 4 http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=g5HzkRO8TGA&feature=relmfu YouTube National Geographic documentary on Alexander (2 hours) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rhNO-dJNhWQ&feature=related YouTube re-creation and analysis of the battle of Gaugamela, part of the Ultimate Battles series. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5uHe5qFJCmk&feature=relmfu YouTube 3D reconstruction of Ai Khanum http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=5tka9TFyWIw YouTube video about Alexander’s battles http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=5uHe5qFJCmk&feature=relmfu YouTube video analysing the battle of Issus as part of the Great Commanders series (44 minutes) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrNo-13ANPY&feature=related YouTube video showing some landscape and many of the products and crafts found on the Silk Road —(one hour) http://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=TAhaIX2dM_Y&feature=related Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 42 Exhibition Map Welcome to Afghanistan: Hidden Treasures from the National Museum, Kabul. For assistance and directions during your Museum visit, ask our Visitor Services Staff (black t-shirt) or Volunteers (purple t-shirt). Schools and Groups entrance/bag store: Level 0 Collectors Café: Level 2 M & F Toilets: Level 4, Level 2, Level 0. Accessible Toilets: Level 2, Level 0 Please note, there are no toilets located within this exhibition. Please recognise that some items are not permitted within this exhibition. This and other helpful information for Planning Your Visit available online for Schools and Groups. Year 7 History Teacher Kit - www.afghanistan.qm.qld.gov.au page 43