The Experience of Scots abroad, 1830 – 1939 What impact did Scots have on the ‘New World’? Activity • On A4 paper create a leaflet or poster which will inform certain Scots about the benefits or necessity of emigration • Create the leaflet/poster from the perspective of ONE of the following – A Canadian emigration agent – A Highland landlord – A wealthy philanthropist REMEMBER each document will have different arguments and different target audiences. Starter • What does the following source tell you generally about the emigrant Scots? Liberal MP Sir Charles Dilke, writing in 1888, remarked that: ‘In British settlements, from Canada to Ceylon, from Dunedin to Bombay, for every Englishman that you meet who has worked himself up to wealth from small beginnings without external aid, you find ten Scotchmen’ Patterns of emigration • Using what you have learned so far colour in your world map to show the MAIN areas in which you think Scot’s emigrated too. Remember to lable the countries! • Add coloured arrows to show that people are EMIGRATING we will be using this map later to show IMMIGRATON too!) • • • • • • Canada America India Australia New Zealand England Scots in England • What ATTRACTIONS do you think England held for emigrant Scots? – Language (at least for lowlanders) – Familiarity of land and the ways of working it – Not too far from home – Job opportunities in big cities Scots in England • In terms of numbers the emigration from Scotland to England was modest • Many Scots chose to settle in England, particularly after the 1920s. • In the period 1841–1931, around 749,000 Scots moved to other parts of the UK compared with over two million who emigrated abroad • It was during the economic depression of the inter-war years that there was a shift from emigration overseas to migration to other parts of the UK, mainly to England. • By 1931, the number of Scots in England equaled those from Ireland, whereas 60 years earlier, the Irish outnumbered the Scots by a margin of two to one. Assimilation into English society • The success of Scots in England is clear evidence of their skills, enterprise and education. They went, especially, to work in the Lancashire textile industry and to the shipbuilding and engineering trades in the North East and the Midlands • In the 1930s a Scottish steel company started production in Corby, Northamptonshire and many Scots went there to work. • Many Scots went to London where there were a variety of opportunities to prosper. Assimilation into English society • The large number of Scots who emigrated to England were less likely to set up organizations to preserve their Scottish identity. • This was probably due to the fact Scottish people were not an extensive distance from their homeland as they would be in places like Australia and they often intermarried with English people and became part of that population rather than being Scots who merely lived in England. Notable Scots in England • John Logie Baird (1888-1946) - Settled in England after time in the west indies. Most famous for the first TV picture sent between Glasgow and London in 1926. • Katherine, Duchess of Atholl (1874-1960) – In 1923 she became the first Scottish female MP. Leading critic of Fascism • David Napier (1790-1869) – built up a marine engineering business in Glasgow then moved south and developed a shipbuilding company on the River Thames • James Naysmith (1808-1890) – left Edinburgh for London. Invented the steam hammer used in iron production Activity • In your jotter write a paragraph or two describing and explaining the degree of assimilation Scot’s emigrants experienced in England. Scots in India • In 1830 India included the area of land that is modern India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka. • By 1830 Scots had a huge impact on how India was ruled and how it developed. THINK • What interests do you think the British had in the Indian subcontinent? Influence • Before 1830 Scots had been important in extending British influence in India, particularly through the East India Company (EIC) • However, from 1830 onwards, Scots became involved as general merchants with Indian interests. • They began to export jute, tea, timber, coal, sugar and indigo (a dye) as well as cotton. • Trade improved as the EIC lost their hold on the country Activity Read through your India information sheets and answer the following questions as fully as you can1. In what ways was the economy in Scotland boosted by Scottish exploits in India? Give as many details as you can, in your own words 2. What did Dalhousie accomplish during his time as Governor General? 3. Why could some of these actions be seen as controversial? 4. Give three examples of other notable Scot’s who made contributions to India in terms of science, trade or commerce. The Development of British India • Scots involvement in India was initially tied with wider British interests • The creation of the Honorable East India Trading Company and the control of the company increased British influence in India, in terms of trade, far more profoundly than any other area. • The company was formed in 1708 to trade with what was know as the East Indies. EIC - Background • The EIC had three bases in India. Each base was ruled by a Governor • Calcutta was the most important base, it’s leader was know was Governor-General – they were the leader of all British interest in India. • By 1792, Scots made up one in nine EIC civil servants, one in eleven common soldiers and one in three officers of the EIC . • The first three Governor-Generals of India were Scots • By 1784 the British government was overseeing the EIC Activity • watch this short video – TAKE GOOD NOTES • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z9DQNw1xvRU&lis t=PL97FA559076D978F9&index=6 • With the person next to you write a limerick or 6 line poem (which rhymes) which describes an aspect of the Scottish involvement in India • Eg There once was a man called Dalhousie, Who hated a practice called THUGEE He banned this act quickly And then he banned SUTEE However this caused controversy The Indian Mutiny • The Indian Mutiny broke out in 1857 and although it was very much a revolt against British rule, Scots were involved and it serves to show the tensions British colonialism created. • The Mutiny happened for a multitude of reasons but the dislike of British rule and religious conflict were important factors. • The rebellion was staged by Indian troops who had been serving in the East India Company army. • The rebellion was mainly in the north and centre of India and was crushed by 1858, but not without significant bloodshed Activity • Read the handout which gives an overview of the rebellion and its causes • Answer the questions in your jotter Scottish involvement in the Mutiny • Scottish soldiers were important to the British in crushing the rebellion; in fact most senior commanders were Scottish: Generals Colin Campbell (right), James Hope Grant, James Outram and Hugh Rose. Scot’s involvement – case study • In July 1857, during the mutiny the 78th and 84th Highland regiments recaptured the town of Cawnpore. • When these soldiers went to look for the British residents of this town they were horrified by what they found. • Most of the capture British had been murdered, including 120 women and children who had been hacked to death and thrown in a dry well • The Scottish soldiers were furious and took violent revenge against the Indians; they even forced them to lick up the blood of the murdered children. Many Indian soldiers were hung • This was only put to a stop when Sir Colin Campbell arrived. After 1857 • After the Indian Mutiny in 1857 the British government assumed direct control of India and the EIC was abandoned. • The Governor General’s title became ‘Viceroy’ • Queen Victoria accepted the title of Empress and the British ‘Raj’ was born. • Scots were influential in all areas of it’s development. Notable Scots Thomas Babington Macaulay, 1st Baron Macaulay • The son and eldest child of Zachary Macaulay, a Scottish Highlander • He went to India in 1834, and served on the Supreme Council of India between 1834 and 1838 • In the aftermath of the Indian Mutiny of 1857, Macaulay's criminal law proposal was enacted. The Indian Penal Code in 1860 was followed by the Criminal Procedure Code in 1872 and the Civil Procedure Code in 1909. • The Indian Penal Code inspired counterparts in most other British colonies, and to date many of these laws are still in effect in places as far apart as Pakistan, Singapore, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Nigeria and Zimbabwe, as well as in India itself. Notable Scots Alexander Duff • Born in Perthshire • He was the first overseas missionary of the Church of Scotland to India. • On 13 July 1830 he founded the General Assembly's Institution in Calcutta, now known as the Scottish Church College. He also played a part in establishing the University of Calcutta. • Believed in free education for all regardless of caste or creed – this revolutionised Indian society. • English became the tool through which Indians were able to understand and advance themselves through the British institutions of government. This opportunity to share in governance established one of the foundations on which eventual self-rule was built Notable Scots John Wilson • Born in Lauder, Scotland • In 1829, a year after his graduation, Wilson and his wife went to Bombay as Christian missionaries supported by the Church of Scotland • John first established an English school in 1832, and added a college in 1836 - now called Wilson College, Mumbai. With this School John was able to introduce European education, examinations and textbooks to the people of the city. • John's wife, Margaret, also influenced the education system in Bombay, and aided the female population by establishing schools for girls in 1829. • The Wilson’s were huge advocates for the preservation if Indian architecture and monuments Activity • Using your notes write two paragraphs 1. Describe the POSITIVE effects Scots had in India 2. Describe the NEGATIVE or CONTROVERSIAL effects of Scots in India Revision – the reasons for Scottish Emigration Use each topic sentence to complete a detailed paragraph – 1. Many Scots left Scotland between 1830 and 1930 due to a number of ‘push’ and ‘pull’ factors……. 2. The Highland Clearances had a significant impact on Scottish emigration….. 3. The role of the church in emigration was small but significant…. 4. Emigration Societies persuaded people to move…. 5. Each land, including England, held specific attractions…. The Scots in North America Overview • There are close on 4.9 million Americans claiming Scottish descent according to the U.S. Census of 2000. • Between 1763 and 1777, 50,000 Scots from (mainly) the west of Scotland settled in North America. • Their drive and education saw them quickly dominate the tobacco trade and other areas of economic life, such as fur-trapping in Canada. • Education and religion were other areas of cultural life where the Scottish influence was overwhelming. Overview • Although America ended its colonial status in 1783, cultural and economic links were maintained with Scotland • Such was the strength of the Scottish presence in America that 19 of the 56 delegates who signed the Declaration of Independence came from Scotland and/or Ulster • 75 per cent of US presidents, including Barack Obama, could claim some Scottish ancestry Patterns of immigration • Look at the table opposite • Why do you think the numbers of those emigrating took such a sharp rise in a) 1881 and b) 1921? What does the following source tell you about why Scots emigrated to North America and what it may have been like? “I wonder at people who go to New Zealand or into the woods of Canada where it takes a man days to clear a farm of one hundred acres. Here a man can get any amount of the best farming land the sun shines on for a moderate price and ready to put plough to it”. Settlement • Early Scottish emigrants to North America settled near the coast, but as numbers grew so did the expansion inland. • The vast swaths of land on which to farm was and undoubted attraction for many migrants, particularly those leaving crofting life in Scotland. Highlanders in Canada • Highlanders were particularly drawn to Canada rather than the more urbanised American east coast • They prioritized the companionship of their countrymen in the new world, probably due to the clan system. • They built up Gaelic-speaking communities in Cape Breton Island, the Eastern Townships of Quebec, Glengarry, and the prairie colonies of Killarney and Benbecula Lowlanders in Canada • Lowlanders, who favored Upper Canada, tended to be more cautious and commercial, were willing to work for wages at first in order to secure a better property, • they took greater care in choosing and operating their farms. • Yet although they were more likely to emigrate as individuals or families, the closeness of countrymen was a bonus, rather than a requirement, Impact on Society • http://www.bbc.co.uk/learningzone/clips/emi grant-life-in-canadas-far-north/4366.html • Take brief notes on the Scottish involvement in Canada Activity • Read the worksheet about Scot’s life in North America and complete the tasks in your jotter Source Questions How fully? • This is a question which will ask about an overall issue and wants to find out how much you know on the subject • The source will give you SOME of the relevant information but will not give the whole picture • This means you must identify relevant information from the source AND include relevant information from your own knowledge. • These have to be SUBSTANTIAL and EXPLAINED points to be credited with the marks. How to answer • There are TWO phases in answering this question – You must give the relevant points from the SOURCE and develop each point in terms of the question – YOU DO NOT NEED TO COMMENT ON THE AUTHOR,PURPOSE OR DATE! Constructing your answer • FIRST – give a General statement • Source A partly explains the reasons for the migration of the Scots between 1830 and 1939. • THEN use information from the source IN YOUR OWN WORDS – The source tell us that many Scots left their homes due to the systematic clearance of crofts in the Highlands, particularly in Sutherland. It goes on to mention how the people here often felt like they had no choice but to leave because they no longer had land to work on. The source goes on the mention how several highland landlords encouraged this emigration by party paying for the passage to new lands such as Canada and Australia. Phase 2 • You must bring in your own knowledge to show there are other points relevant to the answer • These MUST relate to the issue in the question! • –explain what is missing from the source regarding this issue. – However, the source fails to mention other key aspects around the reasons for the emigration of the Scots. The source does not mention the work of emigration agents, their job was to encourage new emigrants to their homelands by advertising at markets, holding meetings and publicising the benefits of their countries. – REPEAT THIS until you have run out of examples! Points from Marked work • You should have the overall opening statement – Source A deescibs the reasons for Scots emigration to a limited/full/certain extent • LINK EVIDENCE TO THE QUESTION – The soucre show/says…. Which may have been a cause of emigration – The source fails to mention… as a cause of emigration. (The EXPLAIN this point fully – next slide) Be specific!!!!!!! LINK TO THE QUESTION • However, the source fails to mention other key aspects around the reasons for the emigration of the Scots. The source does not mention the work of emigration agents, their job was to encourage new emigrants to their homelands by advertising at markets, holding meetings and publicising the benefits of their countries. • Furthermore the source does not mention the Gold rush in California and Australia, this encouraged Scottish emigration as many went abroad to seek their fortune. • Also, the source fails to mention that the success of Scots already abroad also encouraged people to move; people moved to join successful family members in places like Canada and Australia. TRY ONE • In your sources jotter try question 1 on your handout • Hand in your jotter once done Notable Scots in Canada • • • • • • • • • • • • • Hugh Allan (1810–1882) – financier and shipping magnate. H. Montagu Allan (1860–1951) – banker, ship owner, sportsman. Richard B. Angus – banker and philanthropist. John William Dawson (1820–1899) – scientist, educator. William Dow (1800–1868) – brewer and businessman. George Alexander Drummond (1829–1910) – entrepreneur. Hugh Graham (1848–1938) – newspaper publisher. Sir John A. Macdonald – first Prime Minister of Canada. Robert Mackay (1840–1916) – businessman, statesman. Peter McGill (1789–1860) – businessman, politician. Duncan McIntyre (1834–1894) – businessman. Henry Morgan (1819–1893) – built the first department store in Canada. Peter Redpath (1821–1894) – businessman. Notable Scots in America • • • • • • • John Macintosh, developer of the Mackintosh red apple: his father emigrated to the US from Inverness. Apple Computers have named a range of computers after him. US dentist William Morton, who pioneered the use of anaesthesia, was of Scottish descent. Distinguished US scientist Samuel Guthrie (1728-1848) was of Scots descent. He was one of the pioneers of vaccination and in 1831 discovered chloroform. Alexander Hamilton (1755-1804) is one of the most influential Scots in American history. He became the first US Secretary of the Treasury. Woodrow Wilson, the 28th President of the United States, was the grandson of a Scottish Presbyterian minister. His term of office was an exemplary one, fighting for the cause of the common man and promoting the Scottish belief in a strong education system for the people of the county. First American Secretary of War was a Scot named General Henry Knox, he was appointed in 1785. General Winfield Scott was the grandson of a Scot who fought at the Battle of Culloden. He became the commanding general of the American forces during the Mexican War of 1846-48. Andrew Carnegie Scots born Andrew Carnegie is thought to be the second richest man who has ever lived. Only John D Rockefeller was richer. Andrew Carnegie (1835-1919) was born in Scotland. It is still possible to visit the family home in Dunfermline. His father was a hand loom weaver who decided to emigrate when the industrial revolution destroyed the livelihood of the weavers. The family emigrated when Andrew was twelve, the settled in Pittsburgh in the USA. Early Life • Carnegie’s first job in America was as a ‘bobbin boy’. He changed the bobbins on textile machines. • He was 13 years old. • He earned $2 per week and worked 12 hours a day and six days per week. • Andrew Carnegie’s second job at 18 was delivering telegraphs. • He earned $2.50 per week. • But he was learning about how businesses operate. • Carnegie worked his way up in different companies gaining more and more experience. • He saved money and invested it in railway stocks and shares which did well. • Carnegie was on his way. • He rose quickly in the company due to his enthusiasm and intelligence. He was responsible for many innovations in the company such as the introduction of ‘sleeping cars’. • He was a shrewd investor and his investments paid off; they made it possible for him to buy coal- fields, iron and steel businesses and steamships. • Andrew Carnegie started up and expanded the Carnegie steel company. • This eventually became US steel. • It was the most profitable company in the world • The American Civil War meant huge profits for steel companies. This helped Andrew Carnegie build up his wealth • Andrew Carnegie sold his company in 1901 and spent the rest of his life giving his fortune away. • By the time Andrew Carnegie died in August, 1919, he had given away $350 million (this is equivalent to $4.3 billion in today’s money.) His legacy to the world! • Carnegie set up a trust fund "for the improvement of mankind." • This included the building of 3,000 public libraries worldwide (380 in Britain). In Scotland many libraries still have his name above the door • The Carnegie Institute of Technology • The Carnegie Institution of Washington for research into the natural and physical sciences. • Established the Endowment for International Peace in an effort to prevent future wars. Andrew Carnegie’s “Law” for life • Spend the first third of your life getting all the education you can • Spend the next third making all the money you can • Spend the last third giving it all away to worthwhile causes Carnegie’s final statement to the world “A man who dies rich dies in disgrace” REVISION • In pairs re read your notes about the experience of the Scots abroad • You must come up with 5 questions to give to another pair to answer. You cannot give questions which have only one word answers • Swap them with another pair at a different table – answer in jotter in pairs. Scots in Australia and New Zealand • SKETCH the flags in your jotter, around them write as many reasons as you can to explain why so many Scots might have migrated to Australia and New Zealand Compare what is said in the video clips to your mind map, amend and note down any new thoughts. • http://www.bbc.co.uk/learningzone/clips/scot tish-emigration-to-australia-and-new-zealandpt-1-2/4360.html • http://www.bbc.co.uk/learningzone/clips/scot tish-emigration-to-australia-and-new-zealandpt-2-2/4370.html New Zealand • It has been suggested that over 30% of the non-Maori population of New Zealand is of Scottish lineage. • Scots emigrated to NZ for very similar reasons as when they emigrated to Canda etc. There was an abundance of land, money to be made in industry and sheep farming Scots in New Zealand • In early 1842, 500 Scottish labourers left Lowland Scotland and helped to develop Auckland. This marked the beginning of a shift to New Zealand. • Thirty-one per cent of emigrants were agricultural labourers, 19% were domestics, 20% were skilled artisans and 10% labourers. Generally, emigrants were young, single men who came from the Highlands. • By the 1870s, some single women started to make this shift. Small families who made the transition originated from Edinburgh and Glasgow. Scots tended to settle in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch. Other settlements • Religious impulses were behind the desire to populate New Zealand and to create ‘little Scotlands’. The Otago settlement in the South Island and the Waipu settlement in the North Island were the products of two Scottish ministers. • Dunedin (Gaelic for Edinburgh) became the capital of the former and already had a university by 1869. In Waipu, Gaelic was the first language in their homes until the 1880s and many still spoke it in the 1920s. Activity • Read the hand-out regarding Scottish impact on New Zealand and complete the following table in your jotter in as much detail as possible ( you will need AT LEAST one full page) Area of Influence Politics Education Industry Native populations Agriculture Scottish Impact Life in New Zealand - recap • HOW FULLY does SOURCE A describe the impact Scots had on New Zealand between 1840 and 1930 ? (6 marks) • REMEMBER – what does the source tell you, what ELSE do you know? SOURCE A Life in Australia – Patterns of emigration • For hundreds of years Scots have packed up their families and their belongings and sailed to Australia to start a new life. When Australia needed workers between 1832 and 1850 about 16,000 Scots became ‘assisted immigrants’ (they were encouraged/helped/ paid to go). • In the same period more than 20,000 Scots travelled to Australia as unassisted immigrants. • The majority of Scottish emigrants were from the Lowlands but around 10,000 Highlanders boarded chartered ships to Australia between 1837 and 1852. Patterns of emigration continued • Between 1852 and 1857 the Highland and Island Emigration Society responded to the potato blight by sending about 4910 Highlanders, many from Skye and the Hebrides, to Australia. • In the 1920s Scots stonemasons went to Sydney. • Scots miners from Lanarkshire, Fife and Ayrshire emigrated in the 1920s and '30s. • 1929 Alexander MacRae, originally from Loch Kishorn in the Highlands, first produced the famous Australian swimming ‘cossie’ - Speedos. Activity – Scots in Australia • A mixture of Scots left for Australia, • Based on this information and what we have looked at in other areas what predictions could you make about the impact Scots had on the following areas? (YOU MUST JUSTIFY YOUR ANSWER, give specifics) – Industry – Agriculture – Native peoples Life in Australia – The Gold Rush • When a few small nuggets of gold were found in New South Wales in 1851 it started a massive gold rush that would change Australia forever. • Gold hunters poured into New South Wales and Victoria to dig for gold and try to make their fortunes. Hundreds of thousands of men came from around the world, including Scotland • Conditions, similar to those in America, were terrible for the prospectors The Gold Rush and William Arnott • Among the men that abandoned their former lives to search for gold was a young baker from Fife named William Arnott. • He arrived in Sydney on 17 February 1848. William spent the next three years working as a baker and confectioner with his younger brother David. • In 1851 William decided to leave the bakery and travel to the Turon River to hunt for gold. • William Arnott was an excellent baker but he wasn’t a very good gold hunter. He didn’t find any gold but he did make a living making pies and bread for the gold miners. • Two years later William gave up the gold fields and returned to life as a baker. In 1865 he set up a small bakery in Newcastle, New South Wales. By 1882 Arnott’s biscuits were being shipped to Sydney. • In 1894 William Arnott bought a factory in Sydney, employing hundreds of workers. • William Arnott’s biscuit factories became hugely successful. Today Arnott’s is an iconic Australian brand. • Millions of Australians grow up with Arnott’s Tim Tam biscuits (like a Penguin) and Tiny Teddies, and Arnott’s products are exported around the world. Living and working – use the Hand-outs Complete the Activities 1. Look at your predictions – were they right? 2. Write detailed notes under the following headings – take care to use your own words and keep to the relevant points, you may find it helpful to organise your notes into a table or mind maps 1. Economy and Industry (including agriculture) 2. Education and religion 3. Notable individuals Impact on native people • Think about the following questions, discuss in your groups and note down your thoughts 1. Do people migrating to another country have a right to change or influence the country they go to? If so should there be controls on what they can change? If not, why? 2. Do you think immigrants coming to Scotland now and in the future should expect to influence change? 3. Do your answers to these questions help you understand the reaction of native peoples to Scottish immigrants in the past? Native populations • There is evidence to suggest that many Scots sought good relations with the local population. Several Aboriginal communities contain surnames such as Campbell and Cameron, pointing to intermarriage between immigrants and the Aboriginal population. • However this was not always the case The Hornet Bank Massacre • Tensions over land between native populations and settlers could have bloody results. • The Hornet Bank massacre of eleven Europeans, including seven members of the Scottish Fraser family, took place about one or two o'clock in the morning of the 27 October 1857 at a station (land leased to a family/person) on the upper Dawson River in central Queensland, Australia. • It unfortunately spurred a much greater counter-massacre (led by William Fraser, son of the family who had been working in Ipswich). It is believed that as many as 300 Aborigines may have been shot in retaliation. This retaliation resulted in the extermination of the entire Yeeman tribe by 1858. The Hornet Bank Massacre • The stations on the Dawson River were on the land of the Aboriginal Yeeman people who bitterly resented the invasion of the Scots to their land, to the Scots, the Yeeman were an obstruction to the expansion of their farming land. • Cruelty towards the Yeeman people inflamed their already overwhelming sense of injustice. • Although contemporary reports of the events point to the bloodthirsty nature of the Yeeman and highlighted the kindness shown them by the Fraser family. • It has been claimed that the killing of the Frasers was in retaliation for the recent deaths of 12 Yeeman shot for spearing some cattle and for the deaths nine months earlier of an unknown number of Yeeman who had been given a strychnine laced Christmas pudding, allegedly by the Fraser family. The Attack • The Yeeman attacked the Fraser homestead between one or two o'clock in the morning of the 27 October 1857. • Those in the house were Martha Fraser, eight of her nine children, Henry Neagle (their tutor), two white station hands, who lived in a hut 1km from the station and Jimmy, an Aboriginal servant • In all eight members of the Fraser family were killed as well as two Shepherds, Jimmy and the Fraser children’s tutor.