Vision Zero Enforcement Report
Chief Gregory P. Suhr
Commander Ann Mannix
Captain Tim Oberzeir
May 2015
Strategies for Focus on Five and
Vision Zero Enforcement:
 In January, a Roll Call Training DVD was released addressing Bicycle and Traffic
Safety.
 In February, an email was sent to each member of the SFPD explaining Vision Zero
and their role.
 Daily Enforcement:
 Focus on the Five Enforcement Operations
 Traffic Safety Enforcement Operations focusing on top collision locations
 Special Enforcement Operations:
 Senior Centers
 School Zones
 Block the Box
 Pedestrian Decoy
 Lidar
 Joint Traffic Safety Operations with our Traffic Safety Partner - CHP
 Education and Outreach:
 Bicycle and Pedestrian Safety presentations at Schools, Senior Centers and District
Station Community meetings
2
Operation Plans - 2015

Continued and expanded School Crossing Guard Program
 12 current participating schools
 2 schools recently added

Continued Education and Outreach – Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety
presentations given at Schools, Senior Centers and District Station
Community meetings

Continued Enforcement at School Zones and Senior Centers
 Increased Lidar Speed Enforcement Operations

Continued joint Traffic Safety Operations with our Traffic Safety Partner CHP

Increase the number of citations issued that focus on the five – primary
collision factors
 Stations versus Citywide

Continued collaboration with other city agencies and advocacy groups
3
Citywide Traffic Citations – 2014
Broken Down by Station
Type /
Stations
Red lights Stop signs
Ped R/W
Speeding
Fail Yield
w/Turn
Total –
Focus 5
% of
Focus 5
Cell Phone
270
224
6
1,214
12%
129
74
Ped
Offense
Bike
Offense
All Others
Total
Citations
Issued
% of all
Citations
Issued
201
265
14
8,517
10,414
8%
Unlicensed Suspended
Driver
License
Central
441
273
Southern
592
185
149
351
5
1,282
15%
189
93
180
186
165
6,531
8,626
7%
312
1,743
128
325
84
2,592
21%
344
427
735
177
91
7,936
12,302
9%
327
537
439
75
18
1,396
17%
190
363
279
537
207
5,392
8,364
6%
858
677
314
219
49
2,117
19%
531
157
184
287
151
7,688
11,115
9%
279
878
194
340
10
1,701
24%
344
74
152
31
34
4,816
7,152
6%
486
3,253
580
3,186
89
7,594
58%
298
96
107
51
43
4,910
13,099
10%
296
2,490
385
293
16
3,480
33%
464
331
252
528
62
5,458
10,575
8%
261
1,000
419
1,480
68
3,228
25%
362
159
203
49
10
8,928
12,939
10%
578
9
73
20
4
684
10%
283
73
168
3,058
416
2,310
6,992
5%
1,002
1,921
1,427
934
41
5,325
23%
2,188
297
311
752
380
14,039
23,292
18%
72
95
37
7
211
4%
192
33
48
48
18
4,177
4,727
4%
5,504
13,061
4,415
7,454
30,824
24%
5,514
2,177
2,820
5,969
1,591
80,702
129,597
100%
Bayview
Mission
Northern
Park
Richmond
Ingleside
Taraval
Tenderloin
Traffic
Tact
-
Total
390
4
Citywide Traffic Citations – 2014
Broken Down by Mode & QTR
Period
1st QTR 2014
Station /
Auto
Type
Ped.
2nd QTR 2014
Bike
Auto
Ped.
3rd QTR 2014
Bike
Auto
Ped.
4th QTR 2014
Bike
Auto
Ped.
YTD 2014 - by Type
YTD
2014
% of All Citations
Total - Total - Total – Grand Total - Total - Total–
Auto
Ped. Bike
Total Auto Ped. Bike
Bike
Central
2,366
51
1 2,303
46
2 2,666
118
3 2,800
50
8
10,135
265
14
10,414
97%
3%
0%
2,648
56
65 2,424
79
51 1,787
33
30 1,416
18
19
8,275
186
165
8,626
96%
2%
2%
2,924
35
30 3,238
51
33 3,381
33
16 2,491
58
12
12,034
177
91
12,302
98%
1%
1%
2,526
141
48 1,790
221
61 1,586
59
47 1,718
116
51
7,620
537
207
8,364
91%
6%
2%
2,420
61
39 3,175
79
56 2,508
56
30 2,574
91
26
10,677
287
151
11,115
96%
3%
1%
2,108
11
4 1,483
2
- 1,735
13
16 1,761
5
14
7,087
31
34
7,152
99%
0%
0%
2,844
15
6 3,111
14
22 3,710
11
4 3,340
11
11
13,005
51
43
13,099
99%
0%
0%
2,819
173
25 2,740
144
14 2,727
99
15 1,699
112
8
9,985
528
62
10,575
94%
5%
1%
2,553
20
2 3,211
11
8 3,445
7
- 3,671
11
-
12,880
49
10
12,939 100%
0%
0%
843
901
132
841
777
996
510
72
3,518 3,058
416
6,992
50%
44%
6%
6,117
475
140 5,512
1,269
4
2 1,023
Southern
Bayview
Mission
Northern
Park
Richmond
Ingleside
Taraval
Tenderloin
103
838
870
109
90
52 4,874
69
102 5,657
118
86
22,160
752
380
23,292
95%
3%
2%
29
7 1,032
5
1 1,337
10
8
4,661
48
18
4,727
99%
1%
0%
315 122,037 5,969 1,591 129,597
94%
5%
1%
Traffic
Tact
Total
31,437 1,943
494 30,851 1,543
409 30,289 1,373
373 29,460 1,110
5
2014 Citywide Traffic Citations
Broken Down by Type
Pedestrian
5%
Bicycle
1%
Auto
94%
6
Traffic Citations - Citywide
Q4 2013 vs Q4 2014
Type / Year
Red Light
Stop Sign
Ped Right of way
Speeding
Fail Yield W/Turn
Cell Phone
Unlicensed Driver
Suspended License
Ped. Offense
Bike Offense
All Others
Total
2013 –
4 QTR
1,114
2,316
686
933
104
1,362
390
480
436
162
16,394
24,377
2014 –
4 QTR
1,461
2,777
932
1,781
81
1,269
499
633
1,110
315
20,027
30,885
Increase /
Decrease
+31%
+20%
+36%
+91%
-22%
-7%
+28%
+32%
+155%
+94%
+22%
+27%
7
Traffic Citations - Citywide
1 QTR 2014 vs 1 QTR 2015
Type / Year
Red Light Camera
2014-1 Q
4,070
2015-1Q
3,024
Red Lights
1,702
1,445
-15%
Stop Signs
3,399
2,972
-13%
Vio Ped Right of Way
1,502
1,496
0%
Speeding
1,738
1,933
+11%
100
116
+16%
1,419
1,252
-12%
Unlicensed Driver
569
484
-15%
Suspended License
728
755
+4%
Ped Offense
1,943
1,103
-43%
Bike Offense
494
612
+24%
All Others
20,280
21,045
+4%
Total
33,874
33,213
-2%
Fail Yield While Turn
Cell Phone
Increase/Decrease
-26%
8
Focus Five Citywide Citations by Station
1Q 2014 vs 1Q 2015
Station
Central
Southern
Bayview
Mission
Northern
Park
Richmond
Ingleside
Taraval
Tenderloin
Traffic
Tact
Total
Focus Five –
1Q 2014
332
418
611
416
738
569
1687
862
651
168
1902
87
8,441
Focus Five –
1Q 2015
295
218
530
289
784
734
1,886
560
832
302
1,444
88
7,962
Change by %
-11%
-48%
-13%
-31%
6%
29%
12%
-35%
28%
80%
-24%
1%
-6%
9
Focus Five Traffic Citations by Station
Q 2014 vs 1Q 2015
Period
1 QTR
2014
1 QTR
2015
Station
Central
Southern
Bayview
Mission
Northern
Park
Richmond
Ingleside
Taraval
Tenderloin
Traffic
Tact
Total
Central
Southern
Bayview
Mission
Northern
Park
Richmond
Ingleside
Taraval
Tenderloin
Traffic
Tact
Total
Change
Red Light
105
205
79
106
269
86
129
90
61
138
410
24
1,702
135
100
77
79
278
88
105
82
68
240
166
27
1,445
-15%
Stop Sign
73
58
433
144
247
368
775
607
160
2
494
38
3,399
43
39
315
142
201
330
746
363
244
1
521
27
2,972
-13%
Ped Right of
Way
78
44
43
129
109
23
149
101
144
21
639
22
1,502
63
61
18
46
181
224
157
79
51
52
540
24
1,496
0%
Failure to
Yield
Speeding w/Turning
74
110
40
30
109
92
584
60
281
5
350
3
1,738
53
17
100
21
73
77
877
33
464
8
200
10
1,933
11%
2
1
16
7
4
0
50
4
5
2
9
0
100
1
1
20
1
51
15
1
3
5
1
17
0
116
16%
Total - Focus
5
332
418
611
416
738
569
1,687
862
651
168
1,902
87
8,441
295
218
530
289
784
734
1,886
560
832
302
1,444
88
7,962
-6%
Total - All
Cites
2,418
2,769
2,989
2,715
2,520
2,123
2,865
3,017
2,575
1,876
6,732
1,275
33,874
2,410
1,369
2,578
1,873
2,749
2,651
3,281
2,026
3,922
1,763
6,999
1,592
33,213
-2%
% of Station % of Citywide
Cites
Cites
14%
15%
20%
15%
29%
27%
59%
29%
25%
9%
28%
7%
25%
12%
16%
21%
15%
29%
28%
57%
28%
21%
17%
21%
6%
24%
7%
8%
9%
8%
7%
6%
8%
9%
8%
6%
20%
4%
100%
7%
4%
8%
6%
8%
8%
10%
6%
12%
5%
21%
5%
100%
10
Focus Five Citywide Citations by Station
1Q 2014 vs 1Q 2015
2000
1902
1,886
1687
1800
1600
1,444
1400
1200
1000
738
800
611
418
332
400
734
651
569
560
530
600
295
832
862
784
416
302
289
218
168
200
87 88
0
-200
Central
Southern
Bayview
Mission
Northern
Park
Ingleside
Taraval
569
Richmon
d
1687
1Q 2014
332
418
611
416
738
1Q 2015
295
218
530
289
784
Change
-11%
-48%
-13%
-31%
6%
Traffic
Tact
651
Tenderloi
n
168
862
734
1,886
560
1902
87
832
302
1,444
29%
12%
-35%
88
28%
80%
-24%
1%
11
Focus 5 Traffic Citations
Citywide 1Q 2015
Fail Yield While Turn
2%
Red Lights
18%
Speeding
24%
Vio Ped Right of Way
19%
Stop Signs
37%
12
Citywide Traffic Citations – 1Q 2015
Red Lights
5%
Stop Signs
10%
Vio Ped Right of Way
5%
Speeding
5%
Fail Yield While Turn
0%
Others
75%
13
Top 5 Primary Collision Causes – 2014
Broken Down by Station
Central
PCF
Percentage
Southern
PCF
Percentage
Bayview
PCF
Percentage
Mission
PCF
Percentage
Northern
PCF
Percentage
Unsafe Speed
56
33%
Unsafe Speed
108
38%
Unsafe Speed
118
51%
Unsafe Speed
89
36%
Ped R/W Violation
43
25%
Unsafe Turning
49
17%
Unsafe Turning
40
17%
Unsafe Turning
44
18%
Unsafe Speed
86
29%
Ped R/W Violation
54
18%
Unsafe Turning
43
14%
Unsafe Starting/Backing
31
10%
Park
PCF
Percentage
Richmond
PCF
Percentage
Unsafe Speed
59
47%
Unsafe Speed
60
38%
Ped R/W Violation
20
16%
Unsafe Turning
25
16%
Red Light
15
12%
FTY - Left Turn
21
13%
FTY - Left Turn
10
8%
Red Light
21
13%
Ingleside
PCF
Percentage
Unsafe Speed
143
57%
Red Light
83
28%
Unsafe
Starting/Backing
21
17%
Ped R/W Violation
30
19%
Unsafe
Starting/Backing
37
15%
Unsafe Turning
25
10%
Ped R/W Violation
23
9%
Red Light
21
8%
Taraval
PCF
Percentage
Tenderloin
PCF
Percentage
Citywide
PCF
Percentage
Unsafe Speed
118
52%
Unsafe Speed
15
27%
Unsafe Speed
852
43%
Ped R/W Violation
35
15%
Red Light
12
22%
Unsafe Turning
308
16%
Unsafe Starting/Backing
29
13%
Unsafe Starting/Backing
11
20%
Ped R/W Violation
302
15%
Unsafe Turning
25
11%
Ped R/W Violation
10
18%
Red Light
270
14%
Unsafe Lane Change
21
9%
Unsafe Lane Change
7
13%
Unsafe Starting/Backing
247
12%
Red Light
Unsafe Turning
33
20
20%
12%
Red Light
Unsafe Lane Change
46
43
16%
15%
Unsafe Starting/Backing
Stop Sign
34
23
15%
10%
Ped R/W Violation
Unsafe Starting/Backing
40
37
16%
15%
** Reported incidents when the primary collision factor has been determined.
Unsafe Starting/Backing
17
10%
Ped R/W Violation
39
14%
Ped R/W Violation
17
7%
FTY - Left Turn
34
14%
Total - Top 5
169
100%
285
100%
232
100%
244
100%
297
100%
125
100%
157
100%
249
100%
228
100%
55
100%
1979 **
100%
14
Injury Severity
Q1 2014 vs Q1 2015
Type
2014
1Q 2014
1Q 2015
Increase/Decrease
Fatal
29
9
4
-56%
Severe Injury
209
48
49
2%
Other Visible Injury
863
200
202
1%
Complaint of Pain
2024
477
514
8%
600
514
477
500
400
300
200
1Q 2014
202
1Q 2015
200
100
48
9
49
4
0
Fatal
Severe Injury
Other Visible
Injury
Complaint of
Pain
15
Questions?
16