F09-26-REIGNITE Proposal CONTROLLABLE IGNITION Proposed For: Boeing F09-26-REIGNITE Saluki Engineering Company 11/19/2009 F09-26-REIGNITE SALUKI ENGINEERING COMPANY F09-26-REIGNITE PROPOSAL Prepared For: Boeing 19 November 2009 Prepared By: Ryan Vojtech, ME (Project Manager) Ryan Affara, ME Dustin Mennenga, ME Jeremy Moyer, ME Jack Palmieri, ME Joshua Snead, ME F09-26-REIGNITE Saluki Engineering Company (SEC) Mailcode 6603 Southern Illinois University Carbondale, IL 62901 773-550-7926 vojtech@siu.edu Dr. Suri Rajan Professor - Mechanical Engineering and Energy Processes Southern Illinois University Carbondale Mailcode 6603 Carbondale, IL 62901 To whom it may concern: This letter is in response to your request for a design proposal regarding a rocket ignition system able to reignite midflight. The following proposal has been created for the purpose of designing a small scale prototype rocket to create a hybrid reignition system. The entire team as a whole would like to thank the Boeing Company for the concept, as well as the opportunity to develop a product for them. Today, studying the concept of rocket reignition is important to many companies because of the potential energy savings on the rockets. Saving energy, or fuel, equates to saving money and running the rockets much more efficiently. Our design for the system is one that will be relatively simple, but will still be able to adequately achieve all of the Boeing Company’s requirements for this project. Again, our entire team is thrilled to be working on an innovative project for a company as successful and established as Boeing. Any questions, comments, or concerns you have regarding the proposal please feel free to contact me by my listed phone number or email address. Sincerely, Ryan Vojtech F09-26-REIGNITE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Saluki Engineering Company (SEC) group F09-26 proposes to design a small hybrid rocket motor with the ability to turn the combustion process on and off while in-flight. The main objective is to be able to control thrust. Some benefits of this design include minimal impact to the environment during operation, low cost in small scale production, regulation of thrust, and reignition. Ignition in the combustion chamber will occur initially by igniting the flow of propane with a spark plug. Using nitrous oxide as an oxidizer and paraffin wax as a solid fuel grain, thrust can be controlled by varying the flow of gas and oxidizer into the combustion chamber. Manually controlled valves will be used in order to vary these flows. Testing will be conducted in order to achieve different thrust conditions. Subsystems involved with the project include combustion, heat transfer, gas flow, and safety. This proposal includes descriptions of each system and how they relate to our project. Information on pricing and other resources obtained, along with a timeline and action item list (AIL) will be included as well. Work began August 25th 2009 and will reach completion May 6th 2010. The initial cost of design is estimated to be less than $500.00. F09-26-REIGNITE RESTRICTION ON DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION The information provided in or for this proposal is the confidential, proprietary property of the Saluki Engineering Company of Carbondale, Illinois, USA. Such information may be used solely by the party to whom this proposal has been submitted by Saluki Engineering Company and solely for the purpose of evaluating this proposal. The submittal of this proposal confers no right in, or license to use, or right to disclose to others for any purpose, the subject matter, or such information and data, nor confers the right to reproduce, or offer such information for sale. All drawings, specifications, and other writings supplied with this proposal are to be returned to Saluki Engineering Company promptly upon request. The use of this information, other than for the purpose of evaluating this proposal, is subject to the terms of an agreement under which services are to be performed pursuant to this proposal. F09-26-REIGNITE TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Introduction 1 2. Literature Review 2 2.1. Existing Hybrid Rocket Systems 2 2.2. Combustion 5 2.3. Heat Transfer: Combustion Chamber 7 2.4. Gas Systems 10 2.5. Safety 12 2.6. Tests and Measurements 14 2.7. Summary 16 3. Basis of Design 16 4. Project Description 17 5. Engineer’s Scope of Work 18 5.1. Deliverables 18 5.2. Design and Testing Activities 18 5.3. Specifications 19 6. Subsystem Descriptions 19 6.1. Combustion 19 6.2. Heat Transfer 20 6.3. Fluids/Gas Systems 20 6.4. Thermodynamics 20 6.5. Safety 21 F09-26-REIGNITE 6.6. Testing 21 7. Pricing 22 8. Validity Statement 24 9. Project Organization Chart 24 10. Project Timeline 25 11. Action Item List (AIL) 26 12. Conclusion 27 13. Appendix A: Personal Resumes 28 14. Appendix B: Preliminary Drawings 36 15. Appendix C: References 38 F09-26-REIGNITE LIST OF TABLES, EQUATIONS, AND FIGURES FIGURES Figure 1: Hyperion Rocket Test 3 Figure 2: Hypertek Rocket System 4 Figure 3: Boundary Layer of Solid Fuel 8 Figure 4: Temperature and Concentration Profiles 10 Figure 5: Gas Flow System 10 Figure 6: Max Flux vs. Regression Rate 11 Figure 7: FBD of Thrust Stand 15 Figure 8: Moments and Thrust Matrix 15 Figure 9: Test Measurements Setup 16 Figure 10: Organization Chart 24 Figure 11: Test Stand with Rocket and Fuel Tanks 36 Figure 12: Hybrid Rocket 36 Figure 13: Rocket/Nozzle View 37 Figure 14: Fuel Lines Entering Rocket 37 EQUATIONS Equation 1 5 Equation 2 8 Equation 3 8 Equation 4 11 Equation 5 11 Equation 6 21 TABLES Table 1: Important Thermal Properties of Fuels/Fuel Components 7 Table 2: Temperature Distribution 9 Table 3: Properties of Propane and Nitrous Oxide 12 Table 4: Design Basis 16 Table 5: Project Costs 23 F09-26-REIGNITE 1. INTRODUCTION Hybrid propulsion is becoming a more and more common application in rocket design today. The reason for this is because hybrid rockets are cheaper to make, but also safer as well because of the fuel types used. Another reason hybrid powered rockets have been becoming more popular is the fact that there is a lot more information on them because of the recent research and development by various companies. With the numerous benefits of hybrid propulsion already discovered, and possibly more benefits still to be uncovered, there has been an increase in the number of companies looking into this and trying to be leaders in hybrid technologies. The approach Team 26 REIGNITE is taking to complete Boeing’s request is to build a small scale hybrid rocket plumbed with the necessary equipment needed for reignition. There are many reasons for making the rocket on a smaller scale; the overall cost for the materials is less, ease of working on the rocket, it allows the team to be able to test it in more areas, and it is also safer in case of something going wrong. The rocket itself will be a relatively simple design; this is because most of the team’s research is involved with the reignition system of the rocket, rather than the rocket itself. This project was chosen by the design team because we felt that we could successfully deliver on Boeing’s requests, and provide new and valuable data on rocket reigntion. The team has many of the school’s equipment and labs at our disposal, as well as a faculty advisor who has an extensive background in combustion and thermodynamics. Page | 1 F09-26-REIGNITE 2. LITERATURE REVIEW Hybrid rockets incorporate the use of a solid fuel and a liquid or gaseous oxidizer. There are many benefits of the use of hybrid rockets. They are fairly inexpensive to fabricate and exhibit minimal impact to the environment during operation. Also, regulations of thrust and reignition capabilities are very important aspects of these rockets. This technology has been used in the past and is continually looked at as an option for rockets today. Some of the major components of study for hybrid rockets include the storage and flow of oxidizer, combustion of the solid fuel and oxidizer, testing, measuring pressures, temperatures, and thrust, and the safety measures that need to be taken during fabrication and testing. This literature outlines a basic understanding of the workings of hybrid rockets and their past use. 2.1 EXISTING HYBRID ROCKET SYSTEMS While hybrid rocket reignition has not been around for a long time, there have still been a few companies who have been experimenting in this field for a while. And those companies have made enough progress for other companies and groups to compare and contrast their designs with already proven ones. Many of the companies use similar designs and change the fuel and oxidizers, if anything. So for this section, the different designs will be looked at rather than the fuel combinations. The Environmental Aeroscience Corporation (eAc) [1] is a company that has been designing and building hybrid rockets for over 20 years. They were responsible for the first hybrid/ nitrous oxide rocket to be fired, the first hybrid rocket used by NASA, as well as performing research for DARPA and the US Air Force [1]. The eAc has developed many rocket designs but the Hyperion I and II rockets really utilized hybrid rockets and reignition more than the others. The propulsion systems for these rockets were molded polymer fuel grain, and Page | 2 F09-26-REIGNITE nitrous oxide was used as the oxidizer [2]. Once the eAc had learned how to successfully use nitrous oxide in their rockets they focused on reignition for the Hyperion II. The Hyperion II uses slightly different fuels than its older brother, the Hyperion I; it has metalized solid fuel, and self-pressurizing nitrous oxide. In preliminary testing, the eAc was able to fire the rocket for 10 seconds, turn it off for 15 seconds, and reignite it for 5 more seconds. All this was done without any external reignition system, and the rocket utilized 98% of its fuel showing that reignition is not necessarily a waste of fuel [3]. Figure 1 is a picture of the eAc company testing one of their Hyperion rockets [4]. Figure 1: Hyperion Rocket Test [4] The company Hypertek probably has one of the most user friendly hybrid rocket systems that is commercially available now. This is because it is a smaller design, bringing the cost down, that is primarily made for testing at universities or other rocket enthusiasts [5]. They sell Page | 3 F09-26-REIGNITE various different versions of the rocket and also have all the drawings and dimensions of the rocket on their website. The propulsion system for these rockets uses thermoplastic fuel grains and nitrous oxide [6]. The Hypertek rockets use a Kline valve which helps distribute the oxidizer uniformly and safely. Another aspect which makes the Hypertek rocket great for universities and students is its safety features. For one, the ignition system is completely pyrotechnic free, and the fuel and the oxidizer are completely separated until ignition making the rocket much less volatile. Also, the only thing a user has to do to the rocket to re-launch it, is simply unscrew the spent fuel grain and put a new one on [7]. Shown below is Figure 2, which is a 3-D rendering of a complete Hypertek rocket system [8]. Figure 2: Hypertek Rocket System [8] Page | 4 F09-26-REIGNITE 2.2 COMBUSTION The combustion mechanism occurring in traditional hybrid rocket systems is that of a diffusion flame which occurs due to the arrangement of the combustion chamber. A diffusion flame is an artifact of the mixing process between the fuel and oxidizer which occurs due to a diffusion process in the solid fuel. This diffusion flame is supported by the gaseous oxidizer flowing over the solid fuel, which produces a velocity boundary layer whose magnitude varies in relation the local Reynolds number [9]. Diffusion flames are typically characterized by high soot production (due to the unmixed nature of the air-fuel mixture), and a burn rate limited to the diffusion rate of the solid. Diffusion in a solid [10] can be characterized by the following equation: Equation 1: ∂φ/∂t = D (∂2φ/∂x2) Where; φ: concentration of solid (mol/m3) t: time (s) D: diffusion coefficient x: length (m) The characteristic flame can be characterized by the Reynolds number, which describes the combustion flow as either laminar or turbulent, and accordingly evaluates the mixing process. Laminar flow is initiated by molecular mixing, whereas in turbulent flow mixing is enhanced by eddy currents [9]. The combustion flow process achieved in a hybrid rocket motor is a function of many factors which include: combustion chamber geometry, nozzle geometry, air-fuel flow rates, and the properties of the respective fuel and oxidizers chosen. These methods, Page | 5 F09-26-REIGNITE developed in conjunction with the Zeldovich-Novozhilov solid-phase energy conservation method, provide a calculation strategy for transient solid-propellant burning [11]. The diffusion rate of the solid fuel is a rate limiting function of the heat transfer rate occurring at the interacting surface between the solid and gaseous components. In dealing with hybrid combustion, methods have been devised which increase the heat release rate by the addition of energetic ingredients such as aluminum (Al, Li , etc.) could lead to an increase in the heat release at the fuel surface. This phenomenon occurs when the aluminum particles are oxidized to aluminum oxide which stabilize the velocity boundary layer and provide a more energetic interaction surface [12]. Common fuels utilized in hybrid rocket combustion include: Hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB), butyl rubber, polyethylene, and paraffin [13] [14]. The regression rate, and consequently the performance of the rocket is also a characteristic of the specific fuel chosen to be used and must be considered in conjunction with the relevant thermal properties. Page | 6 F09-26-REIGNITE Table 1: Important Thermal Properties of Fuels/Fuel Components [15] Thermal Properties Specific Melting Density Point (K) (kg/m3) Thermal α 106 Heat (cp), conductivity (k), (m2/s) (J/kg K) (W/mK) Aluminum oxide 2323 3970 765 36 11.9 Paraffin 300 900 2890 0.24 - Butyl Rubber (hard) 300 1190 - 0.16 - Polyethylene 403 1400 1000 0.24 0.7 2.3 HEAT TRANSFER: COMBUSTION CHAMBER Heat generated by the solid fuel and oxidizer (N2O) is an important process of the hybrid rocket. Inside the combustion chamber the reaction rate is so low at low temperatures that the heat generated is lost to the surroundings but if the temperature of the gas is raised high enough, the reaction rate becomes high enough that the heat generated exceeds losses to the surroundings and the reaction takes off. If enough nitrous oxide is used, the fuel gases liberated from the solid fuel grain will be completely oxidized and the product gases will generally have temperatures over 5000º F [16]. Page | 7 F09-26-REIGNITE Figure 3: Boundary Layer of Solid Fuel Decomposition of nitrous oxide can be ignited at temperatures as low as 1202º F. The thermal conductivity of N2O is 14.57 mW/(m.K) [17]. The thermal conductivity of C3H8 is 15.198 mW/(m.K) [18]. Figure 3 is an image of the solid fuel inside the combustion chamber and shows the heat transfer from the solid fuel to the oxidizer/fuel mixture [19]. Cylindrical systems often experience temperature gradients in the radial direction only and may therefore be treated as one dimensional [15]. To estimate the amount of heat transferred through the cylinder Fourier’s Law is applied. It is given by, Equation 2: q= -k2πrLdT/dr where k is the thermal conductivity, r is the radius, L is the length of the cylinder, and T is temperature. This will not be a completely accurate assumption because it does not take into affect heat generated inside the combustion chamber and other factors. The dimensions of the cylindrical steel tube and temperatures at the surface determine other values such as temperature distribution and thermal resistance. Thermal resistance can be used to help find the heat transfer through the wall of the cylinder for safety reasons. The equation is given by, Equation 3: Page | 8 Rt=[ln(r2/r1)]/2πLk F09-26-REIGNITE where r1 and r2 are the inner and outer radii of the cylinder, L is the length of the cylinder, and k is the thermal conductivity. Temperature distribution is useful in finding temperatures at certain points inside the cylinder. Table 2 below gives the equations to determine the temperature distribution in the cylinder with or without energy generation. Table 2: Temperature Distribution [15] Temperature Distribution without Energy Temperature Distribution with Energy Generation Generation T(r)= (Ts,1 - Ts,2) ln(r/r2)+Ts,2 ln(r1/r2) T(r)= Ts+( q r22/2k) ln(r/r1)-( q /4k)(r2-r12) r1=inner radius k=thermal conductivity r2=outer radius r1=inner radius Ts=surface temperature r2=outer radius q =energy generation Ts=surface temperature Figure 4 shows the temperature profiles when the fuel and oxidizer are near the solid fuel grain [20]. Page | 9 F09-26-REIGNITE Figure 4: Temperature and Concentration Profiles [20] 2.4 GAS SYSTEMS Figure 5: Gas Flow System In the gas flow system, shown in Figure 5, two gases are used to help ignite and oxidize the combustion in the hybrid motor, propane (C3H8) and nitrous oxide (N2O). The characteristics of these gases, such as pressure and rate at which these gases are being added, are used when Page | 10 F09-26-REIGNITE designing and making calculations. Pressure can be measured but to calculate a mass flow rate first the velocity must be calculated by using the Bernoulli equation: Equation 4: Where p = pressure, γ = specific weight of fluid, z = change in elevation, V = velocity, and g = acceleration due to gravity [21]. Then the velocity can be used to find the mass flow rate by the equation Equation 5: 𝑚̇ = 𝜌𝐴𝑉 = 𝜌𝑄 Where 𝑚̇ = mass flow rate, ρ = density of fluid, A = cross-sectional area of the pipe, and Q = volumetric flow rate [21]. Then the thrust of the engine can be compared to the mass flow rate of the gases, or like in one previous experiment, the mass flux was calculated and compared to the regression of the solid fuel [22], as shown in Figure 6 below Figure 6: Max Flux vs. Regression Rate [22] Properties of these gases are used for both calculations and safety reasons, and some properties are listed in Table 3 below Page | 11 F09-26-REIGNITE Table 3: Properties of Propane and Nitrous Oxide [17] [18] Propane (C3H8) Nitrous Oxide (N2O) Molecular weight : 44.096 g/mol [15] Molecular weight : 44.013 g/mol [16] Gas density (1.013 bar and 15 °C) : 1.91 kg/m3 [15] Gas density (1.013 bar and 15 °C) : 1.872 kg/m3 [16] Specific gravity (air= 1)(1.013 bar and 21 °C): 1.55 [15] Specific gravity (air = 1) (1.013 bar and 21 °C (70 °F)) : 1.53 [16] Ratio of specific heats (Gamma:Cp/Cv) (1 bar and 25 °C (77 °F)) : 1.134441 [15] Thermal conductivity (1.013 bar and 0 °C (32 °F)) :15.198 mW/(m.K) [15] Ratio of specific heats (Gamma:Cp/Cv) (1.013 bar and 15 °C (59 °F)) : 1.302256 [16] Thermal conductivity (1.013 bar and 0 °C (32 °F)) : 14.57 mW/(m.K) [16] 2.5 SAFETY Hybrid rockets are known to be the safest rocket motors to construct. These rockets are not as complex as liquid propellant engines, they are less expensive, and are classified as having no TNT equivalent explosive power. However, there are safety concerns that need to be discussed. The largest hazard for a hybrid rocket would be if a flame or even hot gasses were to flow back through the injector, making the nitrous oxide ignite and causing a tank explosion. This is called a “blow back” and can be caused during unstable combustion where the pressure drop is not sufficient. Other hazards from a hybrid rocket include vessel ruptures from the hot combustion gases due to an insulation failure or when too much nitrous oxide enters the combustion chamber prior to ignition it can result in a temporary over pressure once ignited [23]. The implementation of a miniature propane ignition system is possible for a hybrid rocket. Propane is an extremely flammable liquefied gas. All known extinguishers can be used in Page | 12 F09-26-REIGNITE case of a fire. In high concentrations, if propane is inhaled, it can cause loss of mobility and consciousness, but even in low concentrations, propane can cause dizziness, headache, nausea and loss of co-ordination [24]. A victim exhibiting these symptoms should be removed from the contaminated area while wearing a breathing apparatus and keeping the victim warm and rested. Flush eyes with water for at least 15 minutes if the propane is spilled. Propane should be kept in a suitable container away from oxidant gases below 50°C in a well ventilated place. Propane is conventionally stored in standard pressure vessels at 140 psi [25]. Nitrous oxide is a possible oxidizer for the hybrid rocket. Nitrous oxide is labeled as a non flammable, non toxic gas, but can be used as an oxidizing substance like in a hybrid rocket. This liquefied gas strongly supports combustion and is able to react violently with combustible materials [17]. Nitrous oxide can cause the same effects as propane from inhalation and the same first aid measures should be taken. All known fire extinguishers can be used on this oxidant. The boiling point of nitrous oxide is -88.5°C at 1 atm, and is normally maintained as a liquid at a pressure of 54 bar [23]. The main hazard is when exposure to a fire could cause this container to explode. Combustion products from a fire could produce hazardous fumes of nitric oxide/nitrogen dioxide while the propane can produce the undetectable carbon monoxide. Noise is a factor that may be overlooked when considering a hybrid rocket. According to OSHA standards, in a general industry atmosphere the maximum impulse noise allowed is 140 dB [26]. This is the decibel level when permanent hearing damage begins and is equivalent to a gun muzzle blast or a jet engine from 100 feet away. Eardrum rupture begins at 150 dB when the sound of a handgun shot at 1 foot away is 155 dB. A hybrid rocket is known to make hissing sounds but may be able to produce hearing damage so proper ear protection should be worn when operating the rocket. Page | 13 F09-26-REIGNITE With all the hazards to a hybrid rocket, the hybrid rocket is still known as being much safer than a liquid or solid fuel rocket since the fuel in a hybrid does not contain an oxidizer making an explosion far less likely. The safety of a hybrid rocket is enhanced by the control of the independently controlled oxidizer, which initiates the combustion process. Stainless steel will be able to withstand any effects of corrosion and will be thick enough to withstand the high temperature and high pressure of combustion. As long as the rocket is well designed and carefully constructed, the hybrid will be very safe. 2.6 TESTS AND MEASUREMENTS Static testing of the designed hybrid rocket will need to be done in order to collect data. Data acquisition during testing would include the measurements of thrust, gas and fluid flow, temperatures and pressures [27]. In other hybrid rocket tests, the thrust of the rocket was measured using a “strain gauge load cell” mounted in front of the motor on the “test sled” [28]. Thrust power can also be measured through the use of beam deflection. The rocket can be mounted on vertical beams with known, uniform dimensions and material properties. When the rocket is fired strain gauges on the beams could “convert strain to a voltage proportional to the thrust force” [29]. The University of Arkansas at Little Rock used a bit more sophisticated program to test the thrust of their hybrid rocket motors. The stand they use is composed of “six uniaxial force elements” [30]. Uniaxial forces are measured and using known distances between elements, moments can be calculated. A matrix can be constructed relating distances between elements, resultant forces in the elements, forces in the XYZ directions, and the moments around each axis. From this matrix, the thrust value can be calculated [30]. Page | 14 F09-26-REIGNITE Figure 7: FBD of Thrust Stand [30] Figure 8: Moments and Thrust Matrix [30] Another proposed method for measuring thrust is using a horizontal track and a spring. A spring with known spring constant will be used. The length that the spring stretches could be measured and used to measure the force applied to the spring (i.e. thrust). This relationship can be expressed as F = -ks, where k is the spring constant and s is the length of stretch [31]. Thrust can be plotted against oxidizer flow rate [29]. Pressure in the fuel chamber can be measured with a gauge mounted at the front of the motor and the pressure of the oxidizer was measured between the oxidizer tank and the oxidizer valve. Using thermocouples, the temperature of the rocket’s external casing and the temperature of the flame exiting the nozzle can be measured for analysis. In other cases, temperature Page | 15 F09-26-REIGNITE measurements were also taken within the solid fuel to help determine regression over the course of the testing [28]. The figure below shows the possible placement of measurement devices [28] Figure 9: Test Measurements Setup [28] 2.7 SUMMARY Hybrid rockets are very interesting ideas that have been studied and used for years. Their capability to be safer and more efficient rockets makes them more desirable than either solid or liquid propellant rockets. Concepts that have been explored and discussed here include combustion and reignition, heat transfer within the combustion chamber, gas flow of the oxidizer through the system, safety measures that need to be taken, and methods for accurately testing the rocket. Past ideas will be intertwined with new ideas in order to further explore the potential of hybrid rockets. 3. BASIS OF DESIGN Table 4: Design Basis SEC F09-26-REIGNITE STANDARDS Request for Proposal SEC RFP Project Description SEC RFP Design Report Deliverables Checklist SEC Policies and Procedure Manual Proposal for Project #F09-26REIGNITE Page | 16 22-Sep-09 22-Sep-09 22-Sep-09 22-Sep-09 19-Nov-09 F09-26-REIGNITE 4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION Hybrid rockets have become increasingly popular due to their safety, regulation of thrust capabilities, and the ability to stop and start ignition during flight. However, exploration into these rockets still needs to be done to completely harness these capabilities. This project seeks to design and test a small, static, hybrid rocket motor. The rocket system will require the use of nitrous oxide as the fuel oxidizer and a propane ignition system in order for the fuel to be ignited and then reignited after a period of time. The rocket’s thrust must also be controlled. Testing of a rocket system is very important to the design process. The diagram below shows the five main components involved in hybrid rocket system design. Each of these components is very general and can be broken down further. The gas system will deal with the flow of liquid or gaseous fuels and oxidizers from their respective storage tanks into the combustion chamber. Combustion will involve the thermodynamic and heat transfer properties of the fuels as they interact and burn. The rocket motor body design will also incorporate heat transfer properties to ensure that the casing will not fail. Testing and measurements can be broken up into heat and thrust measurements. GAS SYSTEM FUELS & OXIDIZERS SAFETY HEAT TRANSFER HYBRID ROCKET SYSTEM COMBUSTION ROCKET CASING TESTING & MEASUREMENTS THERMODYNAMICS & HEAT TRANSFER HEAT MEASUREMENTS Page | 17 THRUST MEASUREMENTS F09-26-REIGNITE 5. SCOPE OF WORK 5.1 DELIVERABLES Literature Review Technical description of entire system including subsystems Engineering drawings of subsystems List of materials System Specifications Data acquired during testing of rocket system Technical analysis and corresponding solutions Cost analysis Work schedule (planned and actual) 5.2 DESIGN AND TESTING ACTIVITIES Select materials, design, and fabricate rocket motor casing Select an appropriate solid fuel grain to use with nitrous oxide oxidizer Design and assemble nitrous oxide and propane storage and distribution subsystem Assemble components and test apparatus Acquire temperature and thrust measurement data from testing o Thermocouples will be used to find temperature readings of the rocket casing and the gases exiting the rocket. These will be analyzed to ensure that the casing is not in danger of melting or deforming and flame temperatures can be used to calculate thrust. o Thrust will be measured by mounting the rocket on track so the engine will move horizontally. A spring will be attached to the rocket. The force to Page | 18 F09-26-REIGNITE stretch the spring (thrust) can be calculated by measuring the spring’s deflection. 5.3 SPECIFICATIONS Casing Dimensions o Outer Diameter – 4” o Inner Diameter – 3” o Length – 9” Casing Materials: Stainless steel with a graphite inner liner Possible Solid Fuels: Polyvinyl Chloride, Paraffin Wax, or an equivalent Oxidizer: Nitrous Oxide Liquid Fuel for Ignition: Propane Thrust Capabilities: Engine will be operated at a constant, measureable thrust. The thrust will then be increased by 10%. This will exhibit our goal to control thrust. 6. SUBSYSTEM S DESCRIPTION 6.1 COMBUSTION The combustion subsystem will interface thermochemistry, combustion kinetics, combustion flame characteristics, and solid state diffusion principles to effectively control the combustion process occurring in the hybrid rocket motor. The REIGNITE project entails a controllable ignition system which must shut off and on as desired, while still possessing the ability to control thrust. Select fuels and oxidizers must be chosen in accord with acceptable fuel regression rates such that a robust combustion flame can be achieved. Important considerations Page | 19 F09-26-REIGNITE to evaluate would be achievable air-fuel ratios, flame travel in the combustion chamber, exhaust velocities, and system temperatures experienced as a result of the combustion process. 6.2 HEAT TRANSFER The heat transfer system will account for the heat transfer effects induced on the operating components as a result of the combustion process. Calculating the energy generated by the combustion of the propane (C3H8) and nitrous oxide (N2O) will allow important heat rate calculations to be made such that the heat flux experienced through the cylinder can be established, as well as the calculated temperature at desired locations throughout the cylinder to ensure that material limits are not exceeded. Also, using thermocouples at various points along the rocket motor will allow temperatures to be directly measured so that state points can be established in accord with the necessary parameters to calculate rocket motor thrust. 6.3 FLUIDS/GAS SYSTEMS The fluid subsystem aims to accurately and satisfactorily calculate and predict the miscibility of the incoming propane (C3H8) and nitrous oxide (N2O) mixture at various operating pressures and flow rates. Using continuity and momentum principles, orifice flow opening dimensions can be determined to allow volumetric and mass flow rate calculations to be made in order to provide appropriate mass balances for combustion and thermodynamic calculations which need to be made to determine the thrust produced by the rocket motor. 6.4 Thermodynamics The thermodynamic subsystem will incorporate combustion, heat transfer, and fluid subsystems to incorporate enthalpy, entropy, internal energy, pressure, and temperature at Page | 20 F09-26-REIGNITE measured point into the prescribed calculation methodology such that exhaust velocities can be established. Determining these parameters will also allow a complete thermodynamic analysis of the operating system to be formulated which will enable state points, and system characteristics to be evaluated in accord with the fundamental laws of thermodynamics. 6.5 SAFETY The safety subsystem will insure that the pressures experienced in the combustion chamber do not exceed the pressure limits of the pressure vessel. Also, a barrier system which surrounds the test stand is to be designed in order to contain the components of the rocket in case of failure. Calculations must also be devised to ensure that operating conditions are within acceptable levels with respect to the operating temperatures and pressures of the components to insure that the integrity of the rocket motor is maintained. The safety subsystem also has the responsibility to oversee that all operations are in accord with prescribed safety standards. 6.6 TESTING The measurement subsystem will integrate a measurement apparatus composed of a sliding rack and spring to measure the thrust produced by the hybrid rocket motor. The motor will be attached to the sliding rack, and will exert a force on the spring in doing so. Knowing the spring constant of the chosen spring will allow thrust to be measured according to the following relation: Equation 6: Where; F=the force exerted on the spring k=spring constant x=displacement of the spring Page | 21 F=-kx F09-26-REIGNITE It will be important to seamlessly include the thrust measurement rack with the test stand and rocket motor, so that system functionality and capability are not compromised in doing so. Temperature data will also be acquired during testing. Air and exhaust temperatures will be measured at both the inlet and outlet of the rocket engine in order to determine thermal properties. After finding the state points, calculations can be done to determine the thrust produced by the rocket. The outside temperature of the rocket engine casing will also be monitored throughout testing to ensure that the casing does not melt or deform. Thermocouples will be used to measure temperature. Nitrous Oxide Tank Propane Tank Combustion Chamber Temperature Measurements With Solid Fuel Grain Thrust Measurements The diagram above shows the flow of nitrous oxide and propane from their respective tanks into the combustion chamber where they combine with solid fuel and burns. From these processes we will measure the temperatures of the gases exiting the rocket and the thrust resulting from combustion. 7. PRICING Team 26 working on the REIGNITE Project, as part of the Saluki Engineering Company, hereby offers to perform the work, as defined in this proposal, for a cost-plus-fixed-fee price of four hundred sixty seven dollars and seventy-five cents ($467.75). Page | 22 F09-26-REIGNITE Table 5: Project Costs Source Comments 1 1 1 1 4 Price ($) 186.43 12.99 176.73 150 8.18 www.mcmaster.com www.mcmaster.com www.mcmaster.com www.mcmaster.com www.mcmaster.com Donated Sourced Donated Sourced 2 107.38 www.mcmaster.com 1 32.16 www.mcmaster.com 1 2 11.3 90.89 www.mcmaster.com www.mcmaster.com Braided Stainless Line 10ft 24.95 11 Nitrous Oxide Tank 1 200 12 AN Fittings 15 15 13 Propane Tank 1 50 14 Paraffin Wax 1lb. 3.65 15 Universal Thermocouple 4 5.59 Item Description Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 8 9 Stainless Steel Cylinder Stainless Steel Disc Graphite round Test Stand - Steel table Ball Valve Gas Pressure Regulators Stainless Stock for Nozzle Test Spring Ball Bearing Slider 10 6 7 Total Total with Donations www.summitracing.com Sourced Sourced www.summitracing.com www.summitracing.com www.idealtruevalue.com Sourced Sourced www.amazon.com 1043.09 467.75 As an addendum to the total cost with donations, resources such as gas pressure regulators and thermocouple measurement devices can be sourced from the available Southern Illinois University – Carbondale facilities which utilize this standard equipment. In addition the REIGNITE team would like to thank Dr. Dale Wittmer for donating the graphite to be used in the combustion chamber, and Tim Attig for providing the stainless steel housing to be used as the combustion chamber. These donations help to greatly keep the cost of this project to a minimum so that the completion of this project can come to fruition. Page | 23 F09-26-REIGNITE 8. VALIDITY STATEMENT Saluki Engineering Company will keep certain people available solely for this project who are well-qualified to do the work while this offer is pending. Saluki Engineering Company reserves the right to review the content of this proposal thirty (30) days from the date of submittal if no work has been awarded. After this time, modifications may be made to the proposal in order keep the proposal valid and up to date. If Boeing is unable to make a decision within thirty (30) days of the proposal submittal, Saluki Engineering Company will be willing to discuss any actions needed to be taken for a successful contract closing. 9. PROJECT ORGANIZATION CHART Figure 10: Organization Chart Page | 24 F09-26-REIGNITE 10. PROJECT TIMELINE 18Jan Activity 25Jan 1Feb 8-Feb 15-Feb Verify Specs Design Subsystems Calculations Order Parts Build Subsystems Final Assembly Testing Written Report/Docs Finalize Reports Design Reviews Orals Progress Report Design Report Poster As bid: Activity: Milestone: Page | 25 As worked: Activity: Milestone: 22Feb 1Mar 15Mar 22Mar 29Mar 5Apr 12Apr 19Apr 26Apr 3May 10May F09-26-REIGNITE 11. ACTION ITEM LIST (AIL) Activity Responsibility of: Assigned Due Extended Date Status 1 Verify Specifications RV, JM 1/18/2010 1/27/2010 - 0% 2 ALL 1/18/2010 2/24/2010 - 0% RV 1/21/2010 1/27/2010 - 0% 4 Perform Calculations Finalize meeting arrangements with FTA Update Norms and Expectations JP 1/21/2010 1/27/2010 - 0% 5 Design Subsystems ALL 1/21/2010 2/24/2010 - 0% 6 Complete Team Memo RV 1/25/2010 2/1/2010 - 0% 7 Order Parts RV, JM 1/25/2010 2/10/2010 - 0% 8 Design Reviews DM, RA 1/25/2010 2/8/2010 - 0% # 3 9 Build Subsystems ALL 2/8/2010 2/29/2010 - 0% 10 Written Progress Reports ALL 2/22/2010 3/1/2010 - 0% 11 Final Assembly ALL 2/22/2010 3/6/2010 - 0% Page | 26 Comments F09-26-REIGNITE 12. CONCLUSION Team # 26: REIGNITE would like to thank Boeing for the opportunity to bid on their project requesting for the design and testing of a small hybrid rocket. The team will design and build a static hybrid rocket engine capable of thrust control and reignition. The rocket’s means of combustion will consist of a solid fuel grain, nitrous oxide as an oxidizer, and propane as fuel source for ignition and reignition. All design, testing, and analysis will be completed in 16 weeks and will cost less than $500.00. For any questions please contact: Ryan Vojtech, Project Manager 773-550-7926 vojtech@siu.edu Page | 27 F09-26-REIGNITE 13. APPENDIX A: PERSONAL RESUMES Ryan Vojtech vojtech@siu.edu Permanent Address: Address: 5205 S. Nottingham 308 Chicago, IL 60638 62901 (773) 550-7926 College 355 Neely Drive, Allen 1 Carbondale, IL (773) 550-7926 OBJECTIVE: To attend a graduate program in the Mechanical Engineering field during Fall of 2010. SUMMARY: ● Conducted research and development work with biodiesel, optical diagnostics, and cold combustion techniques at Argonne National Laboratory. ● Worked at International Truck and Engine to develop solutions to problems in production vehicles through research and development. ● Collaborated with the Kawasaki Motorcycle Company to have two brand new ZX600 motorcycles donated for use in our Formula SAE program. EDUCATION: Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering, May 2010 Minor in Mathematics, May 2010 G.P.A : 3.848/4.0 Relevant Coursework ● Thermodynamics ● Heat Transfer ● Fluid Mechanics ● Differential Equations ● Calculus ● Numerical Methods ● Mechanics of Materials ● Chemistry ● Machine Design EXPERIENCE: Navistar Engine Group 2008 ● Worked as an intern in the cooling system department for International Truck & Engine SIU College of Engineering 2009 ● Provide supplemental instruction for various levels college of mathematics Argonne National Laboratory 2009 ● Research and development with biodiesel, optical diagnostics, and cold combustion techniques SKILLS: ● Microsoft Office (Excel, PowerPoint, & Word) ● LabView ● Mechanically inclined (aptitude with tools, lathe and mill machining, and welding) HONORS: ● College of Engineering Dean’s List ● AISIN Engineering Scholarship ACTIVITIES: ● Society of Automotive Engineers Page | 28 F09-26-REIGNITE ● Formula SAE Race Team ● American Society of Mechanical Engineers – Internal Combustion Engines Division RESEARCH WORK: Determining Specific NOx Engine Emissions When Using Oxygenated Fuels and Exhaust Gas Recirculation in Compression Ignition Engines. RYAN C. VOJTECH (Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL, 62901) STEPHEN A. CIATTI, SWAMINATHAN SUBRAMANIAN (Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL, 60439). Page | 29 F09-26-REIGNITE Ryan E. Affara Cell: (630) 639-7262 Email: ryaffara@siu.edu Local Address: 713 West College Street Carbondale, IL 62901 Permanent Address: 840 Cleburne Rd. Bartlett, IL 60103 OBJECTIVE An entry level position in an engineering industry which would allow me to develop my skills and contribute to organizational goals. EDUCATION Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering (Dec., 2010) Southern Illinois University-Carbondale, IL Major GPA: 3.3 / 4.0 Overall GPA: 3.2 / 4.0 Relevant Coursework: Machine Design, Thermodynamics, Fluid Mechanics, Mechanical Analysis. SKILLS Well experienced with AutoCAD, Interpreting constructional blueprints, Microsoft Office: Word, Power Point, Excel EXPERIENCE 2004-2009 Structural Technologies Inc. Bloomingdale, IL ■ Drew detailed elevation, plan view, and construction detail drawings of buildings and roofs. ■ Measured and evaluated construction elements for various structures. ■ Inspected masonry, balconies, and areas of reconstruction. ■ Organized project summary sheets, this includes work details, bill of materials and contractor construction and installation notes. Honors / Awards SIU Engineering and Technology Scholarship Fall 2006 - Spring 2007 Dean’s List Spring 2009 ACTIVITIES American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Fall 2007 - Present P.R. Officer Fall 2007 - Spring 2008 Responsibilities: publicizing events and meetings, design and post flyers Senior Design Project-Controllable Ignition Fall 2009 Page | 30 F09-26-REIGNITE Dustin Mennenga dm32@siu.edu Permanent Address: 2370 CR 1800 E Urbana, IL 61802 217-643-6287 College Address: 1101 E Grand Ave Apartment P3 Carbondale, IL 62901 217-979-7714 OBJECTIVE: Entry-level Mechanical Engineering position. SUMMARY of QUALIFICATIONS Outgoing, dedicated worker able to communicate well with others Experienced team leader ready for a new and challenging opportunity Achieved Dean’s List status EDUCATION Bachelor of Science degree in Mechanical Engineering, projected May 2010 Attending Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL Current Cumulative G. P. A.: 3.6/4.0 Relevant Coursework (Completed) - AutoCAD, Autodesk Inventor - Dynamics - C++ Thermodynamics - Mechanical Analysis & Design - Heat Transfer - Fluid Mechanics Mechanics of Materials EXPERIENCE Engineering Intern (Project Management) June 2009 – August 2009 Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Springfield, MO Learned process of executing a project in a large manufacturing setting Engineered 2D designs, performed cost estimates, scheduled meetings, requested and reviewed quotes, purchased equipment, planned installation schedules, worked with contractors to fulfill project scope, updated cash flow, performed checkout procedure, and executed startup Was project manager for $100M project, researched machinery, selected vendor, scheduled meetings with vendor, maintenance, production, and project engineers for Q&A, created requisition, updated cash flow/forecasted, and set up installation plan Engineering Intern June 2008 – August 2008 Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Springfield, MO Learned a great deal about the food processing industry and how it functions Was presented a problem, observed functions of machinery and operators, collected a large data set, performed a statistical analysis over the data collected and put together a presentation for upper management including why problem is there and possible solutions Waiter July 2008 – August 2008 Steak n’ Shake, Springfield, MO Improved communication skills while working in a fast paced environment Prioritized multiple tasks immediately in order to satisfy both the customers and co-workers Construction Worker May 2006 – May 2008 Wendell Wolken Construction, Urbana, IL Page | 31 F09-26-REIGNITE Demonstrated ability to work cooperatively (roofing or doing carpentry in a group of 2-6 efficiently) Gained experience working with various equipment (levelers, T-squares, nail guns, boom lift) Field Worker May 2005 – August 2005 Monsanto (DeKalb Genetics Corporation), Thomasboro, IL Revealed work ethic and dedication to company (worked overtime when needed and worked through harsh weather conditions outdoors) Performed tasks such as pollinating, detasseling, taking samples, and counting corn for research Worked cooperatively in groups of 5-20 people HONORS / AWARDS Freese Scholarship, Aisin Manufacturing Scholarship Dean’s List and SJO High School Honor Roll (all 4 years) Defensive Leadership Award (St. Joseph-Ogden, Illinois, High School Football) -- State Playoffs Spanish Club (all 4 years); Varsity Letters in Wrestling and Track ACTIVITIES Industry Representative for the American Society of Mechanical Engineers in charge of corporate recruitment Attended Leadership Conference in Madison, WI, representing SIUC ASME, Fall 2007 Intramural flag football; kickboxing; Intramural basketball; Katrina Relief Volunteer Biloxi, Dec. 2005 Volunteered at Living Word Fellowship Church as sound man for youth band (4 years) Page | 32 F09-26-REIGNITE JEREMY W. MOYER Home: 108 E. Locust St. Watseka, Illinois 60970 (815) 432-3706 School: Bldg. 5 Apt. 303C 900 E. Park St. Carbondale, IL 62901 Cell: (815)383-2113 jeremywm@siu.edu OBJECTIVE To pursue an internship that incorporates mechanical engineering in a field that allows me to work in teams and gain further knowledge through hands on experiences. EDUCATION Southern Illinois University-Carbondale Carbondale, Illinois Senior August 2006 – Present GPA- (through Spring 2009) 3.928/4.0 Relevant Course Work- (Electives and Design Classes Taken) Energy in Society, Introduction to Nanotechnology, Applied Fluid Mechanics for Mechanical Engineers, Machine Design I, Mechanical Analysis and Design (Courses planned to be completed Spring 2010) Senior Design EXPERIENCE Pence Oil Company Watseka, Illinois Attendant, Cashier, Office Assistant July 2001 – August 2008 SIUC College of Engineering Peer Mentor, Supplemental Instructor August 2007 – Present Help freshman and sophomore students adjust to college life Help Pre-Calculus students complete in-class assignments United States Public Health Service Engineering Junior Co-Step Bemidji Area IHS May 2009-August 2009 Worked for Office of Environmental Health and Engineering Reviewed and edited Energy Audits for hospitals and clinics Arranged NEPA checklists and an Environmental Assessment for ARRA projects Viewed and learned to read HVAC and building schematics. Developed Project Summary, Scopes of Services, and Requests for Proposal Documents for future construction projects. EXTRA-CURRICULARS College-American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Tau Beta Pi Awards and Honors Dean’s List for six semesters, Alpha Lambda Delta Honor Society, Tau Beta Pi SKILLS Computer experience with Microsoft Word, Excel, Power Point, and some use of Inventor, money management, creative, problem solving, working in groups or teams REFERENCES Dr. John W. Nicklow Todd M. Scofield, P.E. Associate Dean Director, DFM, OEHE College of Engineering Bemidji Area HIS (618)453-4321 (218)444-0531 Page | 33 Mike Anderson Facility Manager White Earth Health Cntr. (218)983-6318 F09-26-REIGNITE Jack Palmieri JackP35@siu.edu Permanent Address: 162 East Schick Road 55 Bloomingdale, IL 60108 630-893-4152 College Address: 905 East Park Street, Apt. Carbondale, IL 62901 630-346-5282 OBJECTIVE: To obtain an internship with your company for the summer (May-Aug) of 2010. SUMMARY Achieved Dean’s List status every semester while being active on the SAE Formula 1 Team Member of Golden Key and Alpha Lambda Delta honor societies Maintained a 3.6/4.0 G.P.A. while working 15 hours a week EDUCATION Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering, minor in Mathematics December 2010 Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL 62901 G.P.A. 3.6/4.0 Relevant Completed Coursework Heat Transfer ● C++ ● Dynamics ● Thermodynamics I and II Intro to CAD ● Statics ● Fluids ● Mechanics of Materials EXPERIENCE Student Worker, Southern Illinois University- Carbondale, IL January 2008Present Calculus I and II supplemental instructor Grader for the Department of Mathematics Painter’s Apprentice, Village Auto Body- Schiller Park, IL June 2004-August 2007 Prepped, dry sanded, and wet sanded various body panels Detailed, changed fluids, and installed parts on customer’s vehicles SKILLS Microsoft Office (Word, Powerpoint, Excel) AutoCAD Autodesk Inventor Knowledge of engines and drivetrains HONORS / ACHIEVEMENTS Dean’s List: Fall 2006, Spring 2007, Fall 2007, Spring 2008, Fall 2008, Spring 2009 Roffmann Engineering Scholarship award winner Member Golden Key- international honor society Member Alpha Lambda Delta- national freshman honor society ACTIVITIES SAE Formula One Team: Fall 2006-Present American Society of Mechanical Engineers: Fall 2006-Present Private tutor for local high school and middle school students: Spring 2008-Present Improving performance/appearance on family and friends cars in spare time Page | 34 F09-26-REIGNITE Joshua D. Snead jsnead@siu.edu 1114 West St. Louis St. Nashville, IL 62263 618-781-8947 609 East Campus Drive, Apt. 802 Carbondale, IL 62091 618-327-6674 OBJECTIVE: To obtain a job after graduation in the summer of 2010. SUMMARY Obtained the Provost Scholarship by scoring 31 on the ACT and ranking 1st in my class Achieved Deans List Status Every Semester while involved in extracurricular activities EDUCATION Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering, May 2010 Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL 62901 G.P.A.: 3.91 / 4.00 Relevant Coursework * Thermodynamics * Physics * Dynamics * Material Science * C++ * CAD EXPERIENCE Externship with Advanced Technology Services, Inc. March 9, 2009 – March 13, 2009 Learn what a mechanical engineer does at the Caterpillar Tech Center in Peoria Learn about diesel engines and how to run tests to improve them. Intramural Sports Referee and Supervisor September 2008– Present Enforce the rules and help students to enjoy their experience playing intramurals Oversee the overall running of sporting events and help teach new referees SKILLS AutoCAD Inventor C++ Microsoft Office HONORS / AWARDS Provost Scholarship, 2007, 2008 Alpha Lambda Delta, National Honor Society 2008 Tau Beta Pi, Engineering Honor Society 2009 ACTIVITIES Member ASME, Southern Illinois University Carbondale, 2007, 2008, 2009 Intramural Sports: Flag Football, Basketball, Softball, Volleyball, 2007, 2008, 2009 REFERENCES Available upon request Page | 35 F09-26-REIGNITE 14.APPENDIX B: PRELIMINARY DRAWINGS Figure 9: Test Stand with Rocket and Fuel Tanks Figure 10: Hybrid Rocket Page | 36 F09-26-REIGNITE Figure 13: Rocket/Nozzle View Figure 14: Fuel Lines Entering Rocket Page | 37 F09-26-REIGNITE 15.APPENDIX C: REFERENCES [1] "EAc." Hybrid Rockets - eAc. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hybrids.com/about.html>. [2] "EAc." Hybrid Rockets - eAc. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hybrids.com/hyperionI.html>. [3] "EAc." Hybrid Rockets - eAc. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hybrids.com/hyperion.html>. [4] "Hyperion II Testing Picture." Hybrid Rockets - eAc. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hybrids.com/hyperion.html>. [5] HyperTEK - The Easiest Access of Them All. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hypertekhybrids.com>. [6] "!" HyperTEK - The Easiest Access of Them All. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hypertekhybrids.com/products.html>. [7] "EAc." Hybrid Rockets - eAc. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hybrids.com/hypertek.html>. [8] "Hypertek Rocket Rendering" Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.hypertekhybrids.com/gallery/compgsea01.jpg>. [9] Heywood, John B. Internal combustion engine fundamentals. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1988. Print. [10] Callister, William D. Materials science and engineering an introduction. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2006. Print. [11] Geatrix, David R. "Transient Solid-Propellant Burning Rate Model." Proc. Of AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit, Sacramento, CA. 2006. Print. [12] Bradford, Michael D., Roy J. Kniffen Jr., and Bevin C. McKinney. Hybrid rocket combustion enhancement. Patent 5582001. Print. [13] Rajan, Suri. "Solid Fuels." Telephone interview. 16 Oct. 2009. [14] Strand, H.D., and R. Ray. "Hybrid Rocket Combustion Study." California Institute of Technology. Web. [15] Incropera, Frank P., David P. DeWitt, Theodore L. Bergman, and Adrienne S. Lavine. Introduction to Heat Transfer. 5th ed. New York: Wiley, 2006. Print. Page | 38 F09-26-REIGNITE [16] Jacobson, Michael D. Multi-ignition controllable solid-propellant gas generator. Patent 6250072. 26 June 2001. Print. [17] "Nitrous oxide, N2O, Physical properties, safety, MSDS, enthalpy, material compatibility, gas liquid equilibrium, density, viscosity, flammability, transport properties." Physical properties of gases, safety, MSDS, enthalpy, material compatibility, gas liquid equilibrium, density, viscosity, flammability, transport properties. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://encyclopedia.airliquide.com/encyclopedia.asp?GasID=55>. [18] "Propane, C3H8, Physical properties, safety, MSDS, enthalpy, material compatibility, gas liquid equilibrium, density, viscosity, flammability, transport properties." Physical properties of gases, safety, MSDS, enthalpy, material compatibility, gas liquid equilibrium, density, viscosity, flammability, transport properties. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://encyclopedia.airliquide.com/encyclopedia.asp?GasID=53>. [19] "Hybrid Rocket Motor." Oct. 2006. Web. 13 Oct. 2009. <http://www.tsinghua.edu.cn/docsn/lxx/mainpage/a/Web/index_files/Page349.htm>. [20] "Hybrid Rocket Propulsion for Space Launch." Stanford Aero/Astro Department. 9 May 2008. Web. 20 Oct. 2009. <http://aa.stanford.edu/aeroastro/50th/presentations/Karabeyoglu.pdf>. [21] Crowe, Clayton T., Donald F. Elger, and John A. Roberson. Engineering Fluid Mechanics. 8th ed. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2005. Print. [22] Shanks, Robert, and M. Keith Hudson. "A Labscale Hybrid Rocket Motor for Instrumentation Studies." Journal of Pyrotechnics 11 (2000). Web. 15 Oct. 2009. <http://users.rowan.edu/~marchese/rockets05/paper1.pdf>. [23] "Hybrid Rocket Science - www.ukrocketman.com." Ukrocketman.com - home. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://www.ukrocketman.com/rocketry/hybridscience.shtml>. [24] Physical properties of gases, safety, MSDS, enthalpy, material compatibility, gas liquid equilibrium, density, viscosity, flammability, transport properties. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://encyclopedia.airliquide.com/encyclopedia.asp>. [25] "Propane@Everything2.com." Welcome to Everything@Everything2.com. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <http://everything2.com/title/propane>. [26] "Noise Levels." Quiet Solution. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <www.quietsolution.com/Noise_levels.pdf>. [27] Sutton, George Paul. Rocket propulsion elements an introduction to the engineering of rockets. New York: Wiley, 1986. Print. [28] Eilers, Shannon D., and Stephen A. Whitmore. "Correlation of Hybrid Rocket Propellant Regression Measurements with Enthalpy-Balance Model Predictions." Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets 45.5 (2008): 1010-020. Print. Page | 39 F09-26-REIGNITE [29] Desrochers, Mary Fran, Gary W. Olsen, and M.K. Hudson. "Ground Test Rocket Thrust Measurement System." Journal of Pyrotechnics 14 (2001): 50-55. Web. 17 Oct. 2009. <www.hybrid.ualr.edu>. [30] Wright, Andrew B., Warfield Teague, Ann M. Wright, and Edmond W. Wilson. "Instrumentation of UALR labscale hybrid rocket motor." Proc. of SPIE 6222.622202 (2006): 1-12. Print. [31] Hibbeler, R. C. Statics and mechanics of materials. Upper Saddle River, N.J: Pearson/Prentice Hall, 2004. Print. Page | 40