Multiple Intelligences Blooms Taxonomy and Graphic Organisers Science and Technology Stage 3 Forensic Science 1 Verbal I enjoy reading, writing & speaking Mathematical I enjoy working with numbers & science Visual I enjoy painting drawing & visualising Kinaesthetic I enjoy doing hands-on activities Knowing Understanding Applying Who are forensic scientists ? Research the roles of the forensic experts Worksheet 1A Examine features of writing. Compare and rate samples from class mates. Worksheet 6B Choose a crime that involves forensics. Use your research to complete a crime library worksheet 10A Using information from hair scalpers worksheet construct a measure chart Worksheet 10C Locate information on Forensic Course at university and/or Scientist Wages Compare findings. Make a Poster Showing those unfamiliar traits label them for others to recognise. Examine yourself closely and list your individual traits Worksheet 1B Match writing on envelope to class members identify the sender Worksheet 6C Musical/Drama I enjoy making & listening to music Analysing Investigate soil types. Write a report on the various soil types. Create a find a word of Forensic Words Create a bar graphs of information gathered Human Traits 1B Lip Types 4B Analyse features class members or teacher, to construct an identikit image using online program Extension Activity 2C Take fingerprints analyse them and classify them. Worksheet 3B Creating Compare and Contrast splatter patterns on various surfaces Compare Matrix Worksheet 5C Work in small groups and as a whole class as forensic team members. Sharing information and discussing results for further research and recording. Intrapersonal I enjoy working by myself Describe the use of lip prints in forensics – and work out what pattern you are Worksheet 4A List fingerprint facts using word Example Sheet 3A Examine splatter patterns to determine change in shape/size from varying heights Worksheet 5B Using all investigation skills examine clues and solve (online) crimes Extension Activity 1B Compare shoe prints. Identify the correct shoe from the print Worksheet 8B Mind Map the key points you have learnt about Forensics Shaded cells are suggested core activities 2 Organise and conduct a debate on the value of shoeprints as evidence in court. Worksheet 8A Justify the amount of money spent on forensic investigations. Prepare a report for the class. Create an abstract artwork Using Lip Prints Extension Activity 4B Using Shoe Prints Extension Activity 8C Conduct tests to identify odour /settling time/ texture etc of soil Worksheet 9B Identify white powders using senses / reactions. Evaluate analysis ability. Worksheet 7D Write a review on the play Write and perform a ‘who dunnit’ musical play as a assembly item Interpersonal I enjoy working with others Evaluating Prepare a report for the introduction of a ‘cutting edge’ technique you have developed in forensics Write a Television advertisement for a new forensic scientist show Interview a Police Officer or Criminal Lawyer Conduct a SOWC * Analysis © Ralph Pirozzo * Strengths/Opportunities/ Weaknesses/Consequences Overview – Forensic Science – Stage 3 Things have come a long way since the days of Sherlock Holmes, when the only tools a detective had were a sharp eye and a logical mind. Now police and scientists have a vast array of technological tricks at their disposal—autopsy, fingerprints, blood typing, dental records, ballistics, chemical and fiber analysis, x-rays, computer modeling, forensic entomology and much more. This unit will provide students opportunities to gain knowledge of current applications and implications in science for society. It will also provide opportunities to improve analytical skills, conduct investigations and communicate information by both working individually and part of a team. Foundation statement for Science and Technology Investigating Scientifically, Designing and Making, The Natural Environment, The Made Environment Students independently implement aspects of a scientific investigation, such as observing, questioning, predicting, testing, recording accurate results, analysing data and drawing conclusions. They demonstrate an understanding of a fair test and identify variables. Students select and safely use equipment, computer-based technology and other resources throughout the processes of investigation. Students develop and evaluate design ideas recognising the needs of users or audiences. They implement the design process and evaluate solutions using functional and aesthetic criteria. Students select and safely use equipment, computer-based technology and other resources throughout the processes of design and production. Students identify and describe structures and functions in living things and how they interact with each other and their environment. They identify various forms and sources of energy and identify ways in which energy causes change. Students identify features of the solar system and describe interactions that affect conditions on Earth. They describe how the properties of materials affect their use. Students identify the ways built environments, products and services are constructed or produced. They use a range of techniques, media and information and communication technologies to communicate design ideas to specific audiences. Students explore the properties and uses of both natural and made materials and components. 3 Integrated Links and Outcomes English TS3.1 Communicates effectively for a range of purposes and with a variety of audiences to express well developed, well organised ideas dealing with more challenging topics. TS3.2 Interacts productively and with autonomy in pairs and groups of various sizes and composition, uses effective oral presentation skills and strategies and listens attentively. RS3.6 Uses a comprehensive range of skills and strategies appropriate to the type of text being read. WS3.9 Produces a wide range of well-structured and well-presented literary and factual texts for a wide variety of purposes and audiences using increasingly challenging topics, ideas, issues and written language features. Science INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. DMS3.8 Develops and resolves a design task by planning, implementing managing and evaluating design processes. UTS3.9 Evaluates, selects and uses a range of equipment, computer-based technology, materials and other resources to meet the requirements and constraints of investigation and design tasks. Maths M3.1 (a) Selects from a range of units and measuring devices to measure accurately and record in practical situations. M3.1 (b) Makes conversions between measurement units. WS3.12 Produces texts in a fluent and legible style and uses computer technology to present these effectively in a variety of ways. WM3.1 Extends a mathematical investigation by asking ‘what if’ questions. WM3.2 Selects and uses appropriate problem solving strategies to complete investigations. WM3.3 Uses mathematical terminology and some conventions to explain, interpret and represent mathematical situations in a variety of ways. S3.1 Recognises, visualises, describes, makes and represents three-dimensional objects. S3.5 Displays, reads and interprets a variety of graphs. N3.5 Selects and uses appropriate mental, written and calculator techniques to approximate and calculate solutions to problems involving whole numbers, money and decimal fractions H.S.I.E ENS3.6 Explains how various beliefs & practices influence the ways in which people interact with, change & value their environment. 4 Resource List Book resources Forensic Science, Fiona Rogers, Ready-Ed Publication, Perth 2005 Crime Solving Science Projects, Kenneth G Rainis, Enslaw Publishers, Berkeley Heights, 2000 Crime Scene Investigations, Pam Walker, Elaine Wood, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco. 1998 Web Resources Catch the Thief. http://realgar.mcli.dist.maricopa.edu/wiki?RaewynSmith Solving a murder - Virtual Museum Canada http://www.virtualmuseum.ca/Exhibitions/Myst/en/game/index.phtml Inherited Traits http://gslc.genetics.utah.edu/teachers/files/traits_comparing.pdf http://extension.usu.edu/aitc/teachers/pdf/heredity/traits.pdf Cyberbee – Fingerprinting http://www.cyberbee.com/whodunnit/fp.html Identikit Images- Flashface http://flashface.ctapt.de/ Lip Prints http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Atrium/5924/lipprintsbackground.htm http://www.forensic-evidence.com/site/ID/ID00004_10.html Forgery, Handwriting Styles and Counterfeiting http://www.catchathief.com/history.htm Physical Evidence http://agrippina.bcs.deakin.edu.au/bcs_courses/forensic/Chemical%20Detective/phys_evid.htm Forensic Fact File http://www.nifs.com.au/FactFiles/fact_files.html Shoe Prints http://www.promotega.org/asu30027/shoeprint.html Collecting Crime Evidence from Earth http://www.forensicgeology.net/science.htm 5 Task/s Task 1 Task 2 Task 3 Task 4 Learning Experiences Forensic Specialists Research the role of the experts who make up an Investigation Team of forensic specialists complete Worksheet 1A Would you make a Forensic Team Member ? Try and solve these crimes * Powers of Observation are extremely important – do you have what it takes to catch a thief ? Visit these online crime solving sites www.thelearningfederation.edu.au/tlf2/sitefiles/los/L387/index.html www.virtualmuseum.ca/Exhibitions/Myst/en/game/index.phtml Inherited and Other Traits Discuss inherited traits and explain terminology such as Darwins point/hitchhikers thumb/widows peak refer website http://gslc.genetics.utah.edu/teachers/files/traits_comparing.pdf Students to take a closer look themself and list interesting aspects that they may have overlooked. Remind them that some are inherited/ others are individual which makes everyone unique. Complete Inherited and Other Traits Work Sheet 2A Create a comparison bar graph Work sheet 2B See who has the same traits and if any student is unique ! Extension Activity 2C Visit online identikit website flashface http://flashface.ctapt.de/ Select from a range of head, hair, eyebrows, eyes, nose, mouth, chin and jaw options to form an identikit image of a face. Print it out or copy and paste to word to make a wanted poster. Fingerprints Brainstorming fingerprint facts http://www.cyberbee.com/whodunnit/fp.html (Example sheet 3A) List Information on Chart using Microsoft Word Students to take own fingerprints for analysis and comparison Complete Taking and Lifting prints Worksheet 3B Lip Prints Research the use of Lip prints in Forensics Identify the 5 Common patterns in lip prints Take lip prints and identify own pattern worksheet 4A Extension Activity 4B Create a Lip print abstract artwork Take a few lip prints in various shades – cut out and place on coloured paper in a pattern or abstract fashion to create an artwork Create a graph of lip types 6 Date Task 5 Task 6 Task 7 Splatter Patterns Brainstorm What splatter patterns are used forensic investigation ? (paint, dyes, oils, blood and other staining fluids) How does the shape and size of the pattern reveal information. Do all surfaces produce the same result Information Worksheet 5A Discover how the size and shape of droplets change as they fall from different heights Discover how movement either LR or RL can be revealed looking at splatter patterns. Complete Splatter Patterns Worksheet 5B Extension Activity 5C Drop liquid on varying surfaces such as tiles / carpet/material/glass and compare size and shape. Complete Splatter Compare/Contrast Matrix Worksheet 5C Investigate: Forgeries Investigate Handwriting styles – Information Sheet 6A spacing/lettersize/letter formations/slant/writing on or above lines/dotting ‘i’s’ and crossing ‘t’s’/ quality of pen Visit website http://www.catchathief.com/history.htm to gain more information Complete Identifying a Forgery Worksheet 6B asking students to write a sentence and have someone ‘forge’ their handwriting and signature. Complete a forgery rating to return to the forger. Extension Activity – Identify the Sender Worksheet 6C All students write a made up address on an envelope in their usual handwriting. Hand to teacher who will number and place into a mail bag/box. Teacher to record name and number on answer sheet. Teacher to remove envelopes one by one and ask students to identify the sender. Students to write senders name next to corresponding number on Worksheet 6C Award winner with certificate / prize ! Trace Evidence Brainstorming what is trace evidence and what senses Would you use in the identification process. See Kidspiration example 7A Teacher to set up stations with 7 white powders and a control powder for students to analyse using touch/smell/sight and re-action see White Powder Instruction sheet 7B and Station Instruction sheet 7C Students to work methodically with one powder at a time recording results as they go completing the White powder analysis matrix. Worksheet 7D Extension Activity Evaluate how well students performed using their senses with powders and how the activity could be improved. 7 Task 8 Task 9 Task 10 Task 11 Shoeprints or Footwear Prints Prepare for a debate on the value of using footwear prints as evidence Read information sheet and/or research topic Worksheet 8A Take a shoe print – choose a suspect paint the base of their shoe and make a print. have the prints placed on the floor identify the correct print to the correct shoe. Worksheet 8B (Note: Ensure a variety of shoes styles are included in activity e.g. thongs/sandals/boots) Extension Activity Plaster cast a shoe print – make an impression in dirt , spray with hair spray, collar the impression and carefully pour Plaster of Paris in impression. Wait until completely set before removing cast. Select a shoe and take a variety of coloured prints – cut and place on large art paper to make an abstract work of art 8C Dirt Analysis Brainstorm various types of soil composition – list. Students to research other soil types and the composition of soil – write a report on soil. Collect soil samples from various locations and complete a number of tests which includes testing soil odour/texture/settling time/floating material. Complete a description and record Worksheet 9A Hair Scalpers Discuss What makes up hair – types/colours of hair Refer to information Worksheet 10A conduct a verbal discussion panel Examine hairs samples of self and 2 others look at colour/length/texture/plucked/combed/cut/tapered/split end Complete comparison matrix 10C Extension Activity Hair measurement Comparison - Choose 10 friends and collect hair samples. Measure each sample and collate information including colour/length. Complete Hair Measurement Worksheet 10D SOWC * Analysis © Ralph Pirozzo Strengths/Opportunities/Weaknesses/Consequences Students write a report for the teacher on how this unit could be improved. What they would like included or what could be left out. Students also write a report on how they believe they have performed as a forensic scientist during the activities do they have what it takes. Do they have the patience or persistence to look at something for so long and in so much detail. Would they get bored, would they give up. Further Ideas Forensic Odontologists – looking at teeth D.N.A. *Looking at Bones Lie Detecting *Entomological Evidence (Insects) Chemicals *The use of Canines (Dogs) 8 Worksheets Examples and Instructions 9 Worksheet 1A Name______________ Who are Forensic Scientists Unlike Television characters, a real forensic scientist is not ‘multi-skilled’ and can not examine all the evidence themselves. They are usually highly specialised in one particular area. Some experts specialise in fingerprints others in forgeries. Because these people are so specialised they work as part of a team and may contribute a small but vital part of evidence that will end up in court. It is in court that this evidence and the testimonies from experts will make or break a case. Using your research skills find out what these forensic experts specialise in: Ballistics expert _______________________________________ Psychiatrist __________________________________________ Meteorologist _________________________________________ Pathologist ___________________________________________ Entomologist___________________________________________ Odontologist___________________________________________ Toxicologist____________________________________________ Serologist_____________________________________________ Musicologist ___________________________________________ Cryptographist ___________________________________________ Palynologist____________________________________________ RS3.6 Uses a comprehensive range of skills and strategies appropriate to the type of text being read. 10 Worksheet 2A Name ________________ Inherited and Other Traits This activity requires you to take a close look at yourself. Some of the questions may need explanation from your teacher – or someone else to take a look at you. But once you know then you will never forget. Tick the box if the answer is yes. Afterwards you will be graphing the results. Eye colour ________ A. I have detached earlobes B. I have a hitch hikers thumb C. I can roll my tongue D. I have straight hair E. I have hair on my knuckles F. I have a widows peak G. I have freckles on my face H. I have dimples when I smile I. When I clasp my hands together my left thumb is on top J. My big toe is longer than my other toes K. I am right handed L. Dimple in my chin M. Wiggle my ears Height _________ Shoe size _______ Scars ___________ Other interesting facts _____________________ ____________ INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 11 Worksheet 2B Name ________________ Comparison Graph Results Number of students with the trait After the teacher has collected the class information you will be required to graph the results into a bar graph. Use the information to answer these questions: A B C D E F G H I J K L M 1. What is the most common trait in the class ? ______________________ 2. What is the least common trait ? ______________________________ 3. Are there any traits that no person had ?__________ If so what was it ? ________________________________________________________ 4. What traits do you know have been inherited off your parents ? _______________________________________________________ WM3.2 Selects and uses appropriate problem solving strategies to complete investigations. S3.5 Displays, reads and interprets a variety of graphs 12 Example 3A Finger Print Facts http://www.cyberbee.com/whodunnit/fp.html Arches being fairly rare and Loops being relatively common. Fingerprint patterns are hereditary. They are formed before you are born, while you are still in the womb They are even around for a while after you die. Fingerprints are totally unique, and they never change throughout your life Fingerprints are formed underneath your skin Fingerprints will always come back, even after scarring or burning. Fingerprints form as our skin has moisture and oils Fingerprints are used for identification purposes Identical twins do not have identical fingerprints There are very few surfaces on which a print cannot be developed. Fingerprints can be developed on objects that have been in water. Prints can be image scanned directly into a computer AFIS - compares prints at a rate of 400,000 per second. RS3.6 Uses a comprehensive range of skills and strategies appropriate to the type of text being read. WS3.9 Produces a wide range of well-structured and well-presented literary and factual texts for a wide variety of purposes and audiences using increasingly challenging topics, ideas, issues and written language features. 13 Worksheet 3B Name __________________ FINGERPRINTING ACTIVITY Collect fingerprints one by one and place them into the correct cell below. Once you have completed collecting your fingerprints you will need to examine your print closely with a magnify glass and identify which print type you are . Note that two different methods of retrieval will be used. Use inkpad for right hand Use graphite rub and sticky tape for left hand Right Thumb Right index Finger Right Middle finger Right Ring finger Right little Finger TYPE TYPE TYPE TYPE TYPE Left Thumb Left Index Finger Left Middle finger Left Ring finger Left little Finger TYPE TYPE TYPE TYPE TYPE INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 14 Instruction Sheet Fingerprint – Inkpad Method You will need Inkpad Scrap paper 1. Roll finger on inkpad – do not press too heavy 2. Roll first print on scrap paper – often first print is too dark 3. Roll 2nd (or 3rd) print on to worksheet 4. Repeat for other fingers and thumb 5. Identify your print Fingerprinting – Graphite Rub Method You will need: Sticky tape Scissors Lead Pencil Scrap Paper 1. Have tape cut into suitable lengths ready to use 2. Rub lead pencil onto scrap paper – until dark smudge appears 3. Press finger into smudge and roll until finger turns grey 4. Place tape over finger then gently peel off – your should see you print 5. Stick the tape plus print on to the worksheet 6. Repeat for other fingers and thumb 7. Identify your print 15 Worksheet 4A Name __________________ Lip Prints The study of lip prints is called cheiloscopy. A person's lip prints are unique. The use of lip prints in criminal cases is limited because the credibility of lip prints has not been firmly established in our courts. The five basic types of lip prints used by forensic scientists are: Branching grooves My Lip Print I believe my pattern is similar to Taking Lip Prints What you will need White paper or cardboard Method 1. 2. 3. 4. Lipstick Tissue Apply lipstick to your lips Pucker up Give the paper or cardboard a quick kiss Glue your print in the box and determine your pattern INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 16 Worksheet 5A Spatter Patterns Information 17 Worksheet 5B Name ____________________ Splatter Patterns When liquid flies through the air, the pattern in which it lands can determine its track, as well as the location and position of the item that caused the splatter. Piecing together splatter patterns can give you many clues to how things might have occurred. You will need 5 pieces of white paper Preparation Method 1. Mark at the bottom of each piece Newspaper Thin red paint Syringe (without needle) Ruler and metre rule a. Dropped from 20cm b. Dropped from 50 cm c. Dropped from 1metrecm d. Dropped from Left to Right e. Dropped from right to Left 2. Place white paper on newspaper in an open areas (free from any breeze) 3. Fill syringe up to 5ml with paint and make a test squirt from 20cm on to newspaper 4. Now make a squirt on to your from 20cm on to the white paper 5. Repeat for 50cm and 1 metre (on the each of the marked papers) 6. For Left to Right and Right to Left fill syringe to 10ml and move hand quickly in direction 7. Describe Observations a. Size (measure the largest splatter across) b. Shape (oval, round, jagged edges, irregular sized) small dots, large dots, clumped together, spaced out) c. Measure distance from one side of splatter to other WM3.2 Selects and uses appropriate problem solving strategies to complete investigations. INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 18 Worksheet 5C Name ___________________ Splatter Compare/Contrast Matrix Criteria or attributes Spread easily quickly Think like a forensic scientist. Write the name of the various surfaces down the side. Write the criteria for classifying across the top: example; spread easily and quickly / round in shape/ clumped together. Mark a + for yes and a – for no in each cell Surface INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 19 Information Sheet 6A Detection of Forged Handwriting Handwriting experts are usually required to differentiate between authentic and forged signatures. Therefore, it is important to develop an objective system to identify forged handwriting, or at least to identify those handwritings that are likely to be forged. Good forgers often forge handwriting in terms of: Copying or tracing the shape and size of the authentic handwriting. are usually written more slowly than authentic writing. good forgeries are wrinklier (less smooth) than authentic handwriting. Document examination plays an important investigative and forensic role in many types of crime. While important documents require signatures to verify the identity of the writer, handwriting experts are often required to differentiate between authentic and forged signatures, and even to identify those signatures that are likely forgeries. For this reason it is important to develop an objective system to identify forged handwriting, Spacing – between individual letters and words Letter size – especially height compared to width, connecting strokes between letters Unusual letter formations – loops / curls/ combinations of printing and cursive Slant of letters – left or right and angle of slant Writing above or below the line Crossing of t’s and dotting of I’s Quality of pen – eg smooth shaky confident / jagged Spelling errors However to add difficulty: No two people write exactly alike. No one person writes, exactly, the same way twice. A writer is not able to imitate all the features of another person's handwriting or hand printing while simultaneously writing at the same speed and skill level as the writer he is seeking to imitate. 20 Worksheet 6B Name__________ Forgery 1. Write the sentence below in your usual handwriting and sign it. 2. Then pass it on to someone to copy. 3. Return it to the original owner 4. Rate the ‘forgery’ 5. Give the forger a copy of their rating Forgery is a crime ! Therefore, forensic handwriting experts are required to differentiate between authentic and forged writing and signatures. Signed __________________________ Authentic ________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ Signed Forgery _______________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________ Signed Rating Code 1 = poor 2 = not bad 3 = good 4 = really good Spacing Letter size Slant of letters Writing above or below the line 21 5 = perfect Crossing of t’s and dotting of I’s Quality of pen – eg smooth shaky Spelling errors Other ____________________ Worksheet 6C Name _____________ Identify the Sender 1. Write a made up address on the envelope in your usual handwriting plus an obscure identification mark on reverse. 2. Hand to teacher – teacher will number your envelope (teacher will also record your name and number on answer sheet) 3. Teacher will place all envelopes into a mail box or bag. 3. The teacher will remove the envelopes one by one and you are to identify the sender. 4. Write the senders name next to corresponding number on the sheet below, 5. The teacher will call the correct name and envelope number. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Student Name 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Correct answers I achieved _____Highest Score in class was ___ 22 Envelope Number Marking Student Name Envelope Number Marking 6. Give your self a score … maybe the winner will also score a prize ! Kidspiration Example 7A Trace Evidence Brainstorm Using your knowledge or information read about trace evidence list as many items as you can around the central theme ‘Trace Evidence’ From each of these list what sense you would use to identify the item. Remember the 5 senses are: 1. Sight 2 Smell 3 Touch 4 Taste 5 Hear Powders has been done for you touch smell sight Powders A comparison between two cut, broken, or torn objects to determine if they were at one time part of the same object. Acids from human touching Hairs Trace Evidence Physical matches Every person, no matter how much they try to clean up a crime scene, leaves some minute trace of his or her pres ence behind and often takes something away. Footwear impressions Tyre Impressions Paints (car and/or building) Fibres Glas s Explos ives WS3.9 Produces a wide range of well-structured and well-presented literary and factual texts for a wide variety of purposes and audiences using increasingly challenging topics, ideas, issues and written language features. UTS3.9 Evaluates, selects and uses a range of equipment, computer-based technology, materials and other resources to meet the requirements and constraints of investigation and design tasks. 23 TEACHER INSTRUCTIONS 7B WHITE POWDER ACTIVITY 1. Place all of the seven powders listed below at each station do not have any markings on the bags. (other than the letters A G) A= CASTOR SUGAR B= FLOUR C= SALT D= TALCUM POWDER E= ICING SUGAR F= BI CARB SODA G= CORNFLOUR 2. Place an additional bag marked Control Powder at each station according to list below CONTROL STATION 1 SIGHT = CASTOR SUGAR CONTROL STATION 2 TOUCH = CORNFLOUR CONTROL STATION 3 – SMELL = FLOUR CONTROL STATION 4 – REACTION = BI CARB SODA 3, Students are to perform activities according to Station instructions and complete matrix. 4. At end of session ask students to call out possible answers 5. Correct Answer key for analysis AGBF 24 Station Instruction 7C Sight Station 1 Instructions 1. Look carefully at the control powder – write a brief description. 2. Look at each of the 7 samples complete a brief description. 3. Identify which sample matches the control powder. Touch Station 2 Instructions 1. With your eyes closed rub the control powder between your fingers using only your sense of touch - write a brief description. 2. Rub each of the sample powders between your fingers – write a brief description. 3. Identify which sample matches the control powder. 25 Smell Station 3 Instructions 1. Smell of the control powder gently – write a brief description. 2. Gently smell each of the sample powders – write a description. 3. Identify which sample matches the control powder. Reaction Station 4 Instruction 1. Add a few pinches of the control powder to container 1 – add water and stir – write description. 2. Add few pinches of control powder to container 2 – add vinegar and stir – write description. 3. Complete same testing on samples and water – write brief description. 4. Complete same testing on samples and vinegar – write brief description. 26 Worksheet 7B White Powder Analysis You are required to analyse samples of white powders that have been collected from a crime scene. These powders do look the same but have different characteristics so you are to work through the samples and take notes or write points as to identify the mystery powders. As most powders are ‘unkwnown’ it is unwise to taste so to assist in identification a reaction test will apply. These will be the stations: 1. Sight 2. Touch 3. Smell 4. Reaction After you test each powder and complete the matrix you will be required to identify by the powder that matches the control powder. The final step is to identify all 7 powders correctly. Good Luck INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 27 Worksheet 7D Name __________ SIGHT LOOKS LIKE White Powder Analysis TOUCH FEELS LIKE SMELL SMELLS LIKE REACTION WATER Control Powder Description VINEGAR WATER POWDER A VINEGAR WATER POWDER B VINEGAR WATER POWDER C VINEGAR 28 SIGHT LOOKS LIKE TOUCH FEELS LIKE SMELL SMELLS LIKE REACTION WATER POWDER D VINEGAR WATER POWDER E VINEGAR WATER POWDER F VINEGAR WATER POWDER G VINEGAR 29 Results Sheet For the 4 tests on the powders I have come up with these results after testing; 1. Sight Powder matched the control powder 2. Touch Powder matched the control powder 3. Smell Powder matched the control powder 4. Reaction Powder matched the control powder The order of the letters I have recorded was : CBGA FEGB AGBF EABD DEFG CABG Something Else ____________________ List the 7 powders A =____________________ E=____________________ B =____________________ F=____________________ C=____________________ G=____________________ D=____________________ 30 Information Worksheet 8A Name __________________ Shoeprints or Footwear Evidence – Debate Material Shoeprints are left at a scene when the shoe is coated with substances. For example mud, dirt, oil and blood, but not all shoeprints are visible to the naked eye. To uncover an "invisible" or latent shoeprint the same method as dusting for fingerprints is used. After dusting a photograph is taken. Another step is to lift the print. This allows shoeprints that can be used as evidence and compared to a suspect's shoes to make a match. If the shoeprint is in blood and had been cleaned up, detectives can use a chemical called luminol to ‘uncover’ it. If the print is "visible" or moldable, for example shoeprints left in mud or snow, a cast of the print by using plaster of Paris can be made. Shoeprints made in mud or clay are called depressions. Normal everyday wear can lend a helping hand in identifying important clues, like gum stuck to the bottom of the shoe, a pebble stuck into a tread or a nail stuck in the heel. All of these clues help to make each shoeprint different from another. Interesting if the cast is too big or if a cast cannot be made investigators will take the section of surface where the shoeprint is found, in fact the FBI's forensic lab has been sent entire countertops, floors, staircases and yes even a kitchen sink all with evidence on them. In many cases, footwear evidence can lead to positive identifications of which a particular known shoe made the print. Footwear evidence can provide investigators with certain information that can assist them in locating a suspect. Most footwear evidence, when collected and preserved properly, can provide the type, make, description, approximate size, the number of suspects, the path through and away form the crime scene, the involvement of the evidence, and the events that occurred during the crime. There are four basic methods of recording footwear impressions at the crime scene. Photography 2. Documentation/Sketching 3. Casting 4. Lifting Footwear impressions are often overlooked because of: * The lack of training and education in the proper searching, collection and preservation of the evidence and; * The evidence is undervalued or not understood. * Not believing that the impressions can be found at the scene after people have walked over the scene * Incomplete searches of the crime scene; * Weather conditions; * The impression has been intentionally destroyed. TS3.1 Communicates effectively for a range of purposes and with a variety of audiences to express well developed, well organised ideas dealing with more challenging topics. 31 Worksheet 8B Name __________________ Making a Shoe Print Making Shoe Prints of a Suspect's Shoe Materials: White Paper Paint brush Black Paint Method 1. Coat a paint brush with paint. 2. Paint the entire bottom of the suspect shoe. 3. Ask suspect to stand on a piece of paper, placing all of his / her weight on the paper 4. Lift the shoe off the paper. 5. Let the shoe print dry. 6. Observe the suspect's shoe print. 7. Match the suspect's shoe print with the shoe print found at the crime scene. Extension Activity What you will need Plaster of Paris Shoe Water Hairspray Bucket or container for mixing Cardbaord Collar 10cmx40cm 1. Make an impression from a shoe into clay or damp soil 2. Arrange cardboard collar around impression 3. Spray with hairspray to make the dirt ‘hold’ 4. Mix Plaster of Paris according to packet instructions 5. Gently pour Plaster of Paris into impression – allow to completely set 6. Carefully cast and brush off excess dirt DMS3.8 Develops and resolves a design task by planning, implementing managing and evaluating design processes 32 Worksheet 9A Name ______________ Dirt Detective or Forensic Geologist Prior to starting this activity 4 samples of dirt/soil will need to be collected from different locations and different soil type. (Example: loam clay sand.) Soil will be labelled: Sample A B C and D and placed at each of the activity stations in sufficient quantities for studying. It is up to you to analyse and describe the dirt and record the details in the matrix below. Weight of ½ cup of dirt Dirt description under microscope Sample A From Sample B From Sample C From Sample D From grams grams grams grams seconds seconds seconds seconds mls mls mls mls Odour Time to settle Floating Material Water through dirt after 30 seconds INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 33 Instructions Weighing Dirt 1. Using the measuring cup to obtain ½ cup of dirt. 2. Tip into scales and note the weight in grams 3. Return the dirt back to the correct container 4. Repeat for all samples Instructions Under the Microscope/Magnifying Glass 1. Take ½ teaspoon of dirt and place under the lens of the microscope 2. Using 10X magnification focus to enable description 3. Note words to describe 4. Repeat for all other samples Dirty Words grainy, angular, coarse, fine, sandy, lumpy, woody, brown, black, grey, red, 34 Instructions Odour 1. Take the container of dirt and place it under your nose 2. Sniff dirt (gently – you don’t want it up your nose) 3. Apply a word that best describes the smell 4. Repeat for all samples Smelly Words musty, mouldy, rank, dusty, mildew, stale, salty, fresh, compost, no smell, Instructions - Time to Settle 1. Place 2 dessertspoons of dirt into beaker 2. Fill the beaker with 1 cup of water & stir 3. Record how long it takes for the sample to settle 4. Repeat for all samples 35 Instructions Floating Material 4. 1. Place 1 tablespoon of dirt into a beaker 2. Add 1 cup of water and stir 3. Record any objects that float to the surface Repeat for all samples Objects that float: leaves, small pieces of wood, grass, stalks, small insects Instructions Water through Dirt 1. Fasten a piece of cloth over the small end of the funnel attach with rubber bands or tape 2. Suspend each funnel over a measuring jar/jug 3. Empty ½ cup of dirt into the funnel. 4. Measure out and pour one cup of water into funnel. 5. Observe as the water runs down through the soil. 6. After 30 seconds how much water in mls collects in the jar? 36 Worksheet 10A HAIR INFORMATION Each hair on your body grows from a hair follicle, a tiny, saclike hole in your skin. At the bottom of each follicle is a cluster of special cells that reproduce to make new hair cells. The new cells that are produced are added on at the root of the hair, causing the hair to grow longer. The living tissue that makes your hair grow is hidden inside the hair follicle. The shaft, the part of a hair that you see, is made of cells that aren't living anymore. That's important to know when you are messing with coloring or perming or straightening your hair. If you cut yourself, your skin can heal, since it's living tissue. If you damage your hair, it can't heal. You just have to do what little you can to repair the damage or cut the damaged hair off and wait for more hair to grow back. Each hair shaft is made up of two or three layers: 1. the cuticle 2. the cortex 3. the medulla. The cuticle is the outermost layer. Made of flattened cells that overlap like the tiles on a terra-cotta roof, the cuticle protects the inside of the hair shaft from damage. Underneath the cuticle is the cortex, which is made up of long proteins that twist like the curly cord on a telephone. Try stretching a hair and you'll find that it's elastic—it stretches before it breaks. When you get split ends, you're seeing the cortex at its worst. You've worn away the protective cuticle on the tips of your hairs with harsh treatment like hard brushing or too much sun and water. In the center of some hairs is the medulla, a soft, spongy mass of tissue. Coarse hair generally has this layer, while fine hair usually doesn't. To fill the gaps between the protective cuticle cells and to keep your hair shiny and flexible, glands adjacent to the hair follicle produce a kind of natural hair conditioner called sebum. Unfortunately, that sebum, which is an oil, also makes dirt stick to your hair. When you shampoo your hair, you wash away this protective oil and the dirt that clings to it. Gray hair is a mixture of pigmented and unpigmented hair. As you age, the melanocytes in your hair follicles slow down or stop working altogether and your hair goes gray or white. 37 Why do we have hair ? Hair serves a number of different functions. It provides insulation from cold weather and, in some species, from particularly hot weather. Because hair is often pigmented, it provides coloration. This might serve to camouflage an individual; in some mammals, the pigmentation changes with the seasons, becoming white during the snowy winter, for example. Hair can also provide some direct protection against injury, such as head hair that buffers impact to the skull. Why does hair on your arms stay short and hair on your head grow long ? Each hair on your body grows from its own individual hair follicle. Inside the follicle, new hair cells form at the root of the hair shaft. As the cells form, they push older cells out of the follicle. As they are pushed out, the cells die and become the hair we see. A follicle will produce new cells for a certain period of time depending on where it is located on your body. This period is called the growth phase. Then it will stop for a period of time (the rest phase), and then restart the growth phase again. When the hair follicle enters the rest phase, the hair shaft breaks, so the existing hair falls out and a new hair takes its place. Therefore, the length of time that the hair is able to spend growing during the growth phase controls the maximum length of the hair. The cells that make the hair on your arms are programmed to stop growing every couple of months, so the hair on your arms stay short. The hair follicles on your head, on the other hand, are programmed to let hair grow for years at a time, so the hair can grow very long. How fast does hair grow ? Human hair seems to grow at a consistent rate of about half a millimeter or so per day. It may grow faster or slower depending on your age, your genetics and your hormonal state. This means that the maximum growth rate for hair is about 15 cm per year. Why do we have eyebrows ? We know that eyebrows help keep moisture out of our eyes when we sweat or walk around in the rain. The arch shape diverts the rain or sweat around to the sides of our face, keeping our eyes relatively dry. Thickness Brown hair is intermediate in thickness between (thinner) blonde and (thicker) black or red 38 Worksheet 10B Name _________________ Hair Scalpers Activity 1 1. To feel the cuticle, just pinch a single long hair between your fingers starting up near the root. 2. Pull the hair between your fingers and feel how slick and smooth it is. As you move from root to tip, you're running your fingers in the same direction as the cuticle layers. 3. Now start at the tip of the hair. In this direction, the hair may feel rougher; it may squeak as it passes between your fingers. You're running your fingers against the grain, and you're bumping into the edges of all those flattened cuticle cells. Activity 2 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Gently comb your hair over a piece of blank paper. Count how many hairs fell on to the paper. Use a small piece of sticky tape and place in on to the sample box (see your sheet). Now gently pluck one hair from your head and tape it next to the first hair. Using a magnifying glass examine each hair and make a general statement/description. Activity 3 1. 2. 3. 4. Collect samples from 3 other people (plus yourself makes 4). Tape them into your sample boxes. Examine each hair using the magnifying glass. Complete the table on your work sheet. Activity 4 1. 2. 3. 4. Pat your clothes with sticky tape. See how many hairs are stuck on you. Are they all yours? Are they a dog/cat or other persons? Place the sample on the worksheet. INVS3.7 Conducts their own investigations and makes judgments based on the results of observing, questioning, planning, predicting, testing, collecting, recording and analysing data, and drawing conclusions. 39 Worksheet 10C Hair Scalper Results Name __________________ When I combed my hair _____ hairs fell on to the page. My Hair samples Combed hair sample Plucked hair sample Comparing Hair samples Sample from my hair Sample 1 from --------------------Sample 2 from --------------------Sample 3 from ---------------------- My Hair Sample 1 Sample 2 Colour Length (mm) Texture: (wavy/straight) Plucked/combed Cut/tapered/split ends Sample of hair and fibres from my clothes Description of what I ‘picked up 40 Sample 3 Activity 10D Name ____________ Hair Measurement Activity From the records obtained in activity 10C choose 10 different people and obtain the length of their hair. Read all instructions first 1. 2. 3. List name List colour of hair next to name List measurement in cm from shortest to longest Answer questions 1. Who had the longest hair ? _____________________ 2. Who had the shortest hair? ____________________ 3. How many people had approximately the same length of hair ? ____ 4. Did any one hair colour dominate _______ what colour ? ________ 5. What was the difference between the longest and shortest hair length 6. What was the longest length for i.Blonde _________ ii.Brunette/Brown _______ iii.Black ________ iv.Red _________ 7. What was the shortest length for i. Blonde _______ Brunette/Brown_______ Black_______ Red_______ WM3.2 Selects and uses appropriate problem solving strategies to complete investigations. 41 Name ___________ Evaluation Worksheet SOWC ANALYSIS © Ralph Pirozzo Forensic Science Unit of Work Students are given the opportunity to list as many viewpoints as they can in the columns below as an evaluation of the Forensic Science Unit of work. Any viewpoints are to be taken as both positive and constructive criticism for future improvements to this unit. Strengths Opportunities Weaknesses Consequences 42 43