"Using Mechanisms of Solid Phase Extraction to Improve Your Bioanalytical Results" United Chemical Technologies, Inc. 2731 Bartram Road, Bristol, Pennsylvania 19007 800-541-0559 www.unitedchem.com 1 mtelepchak@unitedchem.com 215-781-3850 2 The force known as solid phase extraction is unusually strong. 3 Types of Base Materials for SPE Packings Silica – NA and K Silicates Fluorosil® Mg Silicates Alumina Carbon Polystyrene Polystyrene – Divinyl benzene Polystyrene – N-Vinylpyrrolidone Cellulose Hydroxyapatite Fullerenes Cyclodextrin Agarose 4 MSMS EIC 20 ng/mL Salbutamol – 1 mL Urine 78:20:2 Elution Solvent (Dichloromethane:Isopropanol:Ammonium Hydroxide) RT: 0.00 - 4.00 NL: 7.80E6 m/z= 221.60-222.60 F: + c ESI w Full ms2 240.10@32.00 [ 65.00-500.00] MS 81 cerex 100 80 60 1.90 40 20 0 100 NL: 7.80E6 m/z= 221.60-222.60 F: + c ESI w Full ms2 240.10@32.00 [ 65.00-500.00] MS 81 certify 1.97 80 60 40 20 0 100 NL: 7.80E6 m/z= 221.60-222.60 F: + c ESI w Full ms2 240.10@32.00 [ 65.00-500.00] MS 81 clean scrn 1.95 80 60 CLEAN SCREEN® 40 20 1.20 0 100 NL: 7.80E6 m/z= 221.60-222.60 F: + c ESI w Full ms2 240.10@32.00 [ 65.00-500.00] MS 81 oasis 80 60 40 20 1.94 0 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 Time (min) 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 5 Benzoylecgonine Recovery Comparisons from Clean Screen and Cerex Solid Phase Columns Sample is 1 mL equine urine, Positive Control is commercially obtained CONDOA multiconstituent control 10 ng/mL Equine Urine 1 mL BEG-TMS CleanScreen PC: CONDOA BEG-TMS CleanScreen Abundance Abundance Ion 240.00 (239.70 to 240.70): 3790.D Ion 240.00 (239.70 to 240.70): 3788.D 6000000 6000000 4000000 4000000 2000000 2000000 Time--> 0 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 Abundance Ion 240.00 (239.70 to 240.70): 3793.D 6000000 6000000 4000000 4000000 2000000 2000000 Time--> 0 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 5.00 11.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 PC: CONDOA BEG-TMS Cerex 10 ng/mL Equine Urine 1 mL BEG-TMS Cerex Abundance 0 Time--> 12.00 Time--> Ion 240.00 (239.70 to 240.70): 3795.D 0 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 6 SPE Steps Condition sorbents Apply sample Wash interferences Dry sorbent Elute analyte 7 Types of Sorbent-Analyte Interactions Polar Non-polar Ion-exchange Covalent Copolymeric 8 The Real Mechanism of Solid Phase Extraction 9 Polar Extractions Also called hydrophilic or normal phase Unequal distribution of electrons Involves hydrogen bonding, pi-pi and dipole/ dipole interactions Sorbents - silica, diol, diethylamino, cyanopropyl Applications - lipids, oil additives, carbohydrates, phenols, oil soluble vitamins Analytes - amines, hydroxyls, carbonyls, aromatic rings, heteroatoms (O, S, N, P) Matrix - non-polar, organic Elution solvents - medium to high polarity 10 Non-Polar Extractions Also called hydrophobic or reverse phase Interactions between sorbent C-H bonds and analyte C-H bonds Involves van der Waals / dispersion forces Sorbents - C2, C3,C4, iC4, tC4, C5, C6, C7, C8, C10, C12, C18, C20, C30 phenyl and cyclohexyl Applications - drugs of abuse, TDM, pesticides Analytes - protonated / neutral state, aromatics & alkyl chains Matrix - biologicals, water, aqueous buffers Elution solvents - typically non-polar to moderately polar 11 Sample pH vs. Recovery CH3 (CH3) 2CHCH2 OH C C O H Ibuprofen Copolymeric DAU Column A/N Extraction Hydrophobic Retention 12 Sample pH vs. Recovery of Ibuprofen 3 4 3 4 5 5 1 2 2 1 Sample added at pH 6 1 2 3 4 5 Ibuprofen Sample Meprobamate Glutethimide Phenobarbital Phenytoin added at pH 5 13 Chain Length Effect (Recovery & Extract Cleanliness) 4 3.0e4 3 4 3.0e4 5 3 2 2.0e4 2.0e4 1 1.0e4 1.0e4 0 0 0 2 4 6 8 96% 94% 94% 96% 98% 1 0 C18 endogenous peaks: area = 71,628 5 2 2 4 6 8 C2 1 2 3 4 5 Butabarbital Amobarbital Pentobarbital Secobarbital Glutethimide 64% 87% 88% 89% 78% endogenous peaks: area = 11,257 14 Chain Length Effect (Recovery & Extract Cleanliness) 4 3.0e4 3 4 3.0e4 5 3 2 2.0e4 2.0e4 1 1.0e4 1.0e4 0 0 0 2 4 6 8 96% 94% 94% 96% 98% 1 0 C18 endogenous peaks: area = 71,628 5 2 2 4 6 8 C2 1 2 3 4 5 Butabarbital Amobarbital Pentobarbital Secobarbital Glutethimide 64% 87% 88% 89% 78% endogenous peaks: area = 11,257 15 Chain Length Effect (Recovery & Extract Cleanliness) 4 4 3.0e4 5 2.0e4 3.0e4 IST D 3 2 2.0e4 3 IST 5 D 1 2 1.0e4 1.0e4 1 0 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 0 Ct4 endogenous peaks: area = 1,336 28% 73% 84% 98% 70% 2 4 6 8 10 Cn4 1 2 3 4 5 Butabarbital Amobarbital Pentobarbital Secobarbital Glutethimide 93% 97% 98% 98% 96% endogenous peaks: area = 18,271 16 Yoda teaches Luke the ways of the tube. 17 Ion Exchange Mechanisms Ionic interactions occur between charged sorbent & analyte of opposite charge pH is manipulated to ionize analytes functional group Ionic bonds are strong & retain analyte Hydrophobic interferences washed away with organic solvents Polar interferences removed with aqueous or weak aqueous / organic washes Elute solvents containing stronger counterions or by changing pH For ionic/hydrophobic analytes, elute by simultaneously disrupting both interactions 18 Cation Exchange Extractions Cation exchange sorbents negatively charged Basic analytes manipulated to carry positive charge Opposites attract forming strong bonds Sorbents – Benzenesulfonic acid (strong) – Propylsulfonic acid (strong) – Carboxylic acid (weak) Applications include basic drugs, catecholamines, pharmaceuticals, herbicides Analytes – Amines – Pyrimidines (cations) Matrix - aqueous Basic elution solvents to neutralize analyte 19 Anion Exchange Extractions Anion exchange sorbents positively charged Acidic analytes manipulated to carry negative charge Opposites attract forming strong bonds Sorbents – – – – 1, 2 amine Aminopropyl (weak) Quaternary amine (strong) Diethylamino (weak) Applications include phosphates, acidic drugs, organic acids, fatty acids, vitamins Analytes – Phosphates – Carboxylic acids – Sulfonic acids (cations) Matrix - aqueous Acidic elution solvents to neutralize analyte 20 Copolymeric Extractions Hydrophobic & ionic retention mechanisms Reverse phase sorbent with cation OR anion exchange Acidic, basic & neutral analyte applications Matrix - aqueous Selective washes Elution solvents mixture of organics with acid or base Superior sample clean up 21 C8 vs. Copolymeric Extraction 0 4 8 12 16 20 0 4 8 12 16 Time (minutes) Time (minutes) C8 Column Copolymeric Column 20 22 23 pKa, pH & Ionization % of Compound in Ionic State Functionality Acid Base Ionization State Anion (-) Cation (+) pH units away from pKa 2< 1< at pKa 1> 2> 1 99 9 91 50 50 91 9 99 1 24 Specialty Anion Exchange Columns Ion exchange columns possess charged functional groups which allow analytes to bind upon sample application. Prior to column use, these groups require counter ions at these charged sites. The standard counter ion for cation exchangers is the hydronium ion and for anion exchangers is the chloride ion . From time to time during sample application, a charged analyte is not strong enough to displace the counter ion & therefore does not bind to the column. In cases such as these, a weaker counter ion is required. Two such columns with weaker counter ions (Quaternary amine with acetate counter ion) & (Quaternary amine with hydroxide counter ion) are commercially available. In terms of strength, the acetate ion is stronger than the hydroxide ion. CAQAX Silica Backbone Quaternary Amine anion exchanger Acetate counter ion (Standard anion exchanger carries Cl- ) CHQAX Silica Backbone Quaternary Amine anion exchanger Acetate counter ion (Standard anion exchanger carries Cl- ) 25 Relative Counter ion Selectivity Cations Larger numbers reflect greater ability of the ion to displace other ionic materials from the bonded surfaces. Strong Cation Exchanger SO-3 Si Benzenesulfonic Acid (BCX) Strong Anion Exchanger + - Si - (CH2)3 N (CH3)3 Quaternary Amine (QAX) Ba2+ 2+ Ag Pb2+ Hg2+ Cu+ Sr2+ Ca2+ Ni2+ Cd2+ Cu2+ CO2+ Zn2+ Cs2+ Rb+ K+ Fe2+ Mg2+ Mn2+ NH4+ Na+ H+ Li+ 8.7 7.6 7.5 7.2 5.3 4.9 3.9 3.0 2.9 2.9 2.8 2.7 2.7 2.6 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.3 1.9 1.5 1.0 0.8 Anions Benzene Sulfonate Citrate IPhenateHSO4CIO3NO3BrCN HSO BrO NO2 CI HCO3IO33Formate Acetate Propionate FOH - 500 220 175 110 85 74 65 50 28 27 27 24 22 6.0 5.5 4.6 3.2 2.6 1.6 1.0 Standard cation exchange counter ion 26 I. ROBINUL (GLYCOPYRROLATE) FROM EQUINE URINE BY LCMSMS (CLEAN UP® CUCCX-2) 500 mg / 14 mL CONDITION SPE COLUMN 1. Wash with 2 x 2.5 ml MeOH 2. Wash with 2 x 2.5 ml phosphate buffer (0.1m, pH 7.0) II. SAMPLE PREPARATION 1. Buffer 5 ml of urine to pH 7.0 by adding 3 mL of 0.1M phosphate buffer (pH 7.0) 2. Add (12.5 ng) of mepenzolate (internal standard) 3. Add 5 ml of water to the sample 4. Vortex or shake thoroughly 5. Centrifuge for 5 min at 800g 6. Apply supernatant to SPE column III. WASH COLUMN 1. Wash column with 5 ml of MeOH 2. Wash column with 5 ml of H2O IV. V. VI. DRY COLUMN 1. 5 min. with vacuum at 25 mm Hg ELUTE OF GLYCOPYRROLATE 1. Elute with 4 ml of methanol – 0.5M ammonium acetate buffer pH 3.00 BLOWN DOWN 1. Blown down eluent at 60°C under nitrogen and reconstitute with 0.1 mL of MeOH 27 LCMSMS of Glycopyrrolate 28 Meprobamate O NH2 C O CH3 O CH2 C CH2 O C NH2 CH3 Polar Drug Copolymeric DAU Column A/N Extraction Hydrophobic Retention 29 A/N Drug Recovery vs. Changes in Elution Solvents Hexane/Ethyl Acetate 1 Methylene Chloride 2 1 1 2 2 Ibuprofen Meprobamate 30 Amphetamine Structures CH2 CH NH CH 3 Amphetamine pKa = 9.9 2 Methamphetamine pKa = 9.9 CH 2 CH NH 2 CH3 CH 3 H H H C C N OH CH3 CH3 Ephedrine pKa = 9.6 31 Recovery vs. Different Elution Solvents 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 d-Amphetamine d-Methamphetamine PPA Pseudoephedrine Meperidine Lidocaine PCP Methadone Propoxyphene Cocaine Codeine Diazepam Nordiazepam Chlordiazepoxide 4 2 3 1 Elution: MeCl2 / IPA / NH4OH (78/20/2) 32 Recovery vs. Different Elution Solvents 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 d-Amphetamine d-Methamphetamine PPA Pseudoephedrine Meperidine Lidocaine PCP Methadone Propoxyphene Cocaine Codeine Diazepam Nordiazepam Chlordiazepoxide 2 3 4 1 Elution: EA / NH4OH (98/2) 33 Solubility Best wash solvents are those in which the compound of interest is insoluble. Example:Vancomycin Insoluble in Methanol Wash: 100% methanol Soluble in H2O Elution:80:20 methanol/H2O 34 Technical Document P-105 Purification of Small Molecule Libraries Desalting Samples Using Pharmasil™ Reverse Phase SPE Principle: The generation of small molecule libraries for screening against biological targets has emerged as an area of intense interest in the pharmaceutical industry. SPE has been demonstrated to expedite work up and purification of organic molecules synthesized in solution, and in the automated construction of small molecule libraries. Samples that have been synthesized in aqueous salt, buffer solutions, or low polarity organic solvents containing salts may require the removal of those salts prior to analysis. Pharmasil TM Reverse Phase SPE can be used to desalt these libraries. Application: This application details the use of Pharmasil™ CEC18, a highly loaded reverse phase sorbent, for desalting synthetic mixtures. In combinatorial chemistry and organic synthesis salts are sometimes present in the reaction mixtures. Once the reaction is complete, it is usually necessary to separate the products of the reaction from the salts. If the salt is not removed it can interfere with further testing as well as ruin expensive analytical equipment. This can be done using a highly loaded reverse phase SPE column to selectively remove the salt from the reaction mixture. 35 Chemistry of Pharmasil™ CEC18 Sorbent Advantages of Pharmasil™ Based Sorbents CH3 H3C Si CH3 O O Si (CH2)17 O H3C Si CH3 • Complete removal of salts • Clean background • High recoveries • High levels of purification of anaytes • Applicable to a broad range of compounds • Simple easy to develop methods CH3 CH3 36 Purification Profile This profile is based on the use of a Pharmasil™ CEC18 500 mg column (columns are available with varying volumes). This column is capable of removal of salts. The method can be scaled up as necessary by using columns of higher bed mass of sorbent and increasing the solvent volumes proportionately The following profile is meant to be a guideline for these types of purifications. Each drug class has its own specific requirements based on solubility, stability, and pKa and may require slight adjustments in methodology. Therefore think of the following profile as a beginning rather than a final method. Sample Pre-treatment Samples may or may not require pretreatment before addition. The primary concern using desalting columns is to adjust the pH of the compound of interest so that it is totally molecular. This may require the addition of an acid or base. Desalting can be done out of low polarity organic solvents such as hexane or methylene chloride as long as the compound of interest is protonated. Column Conditioning Condition the column 1 ml of Methanol followed by 1 ml of water. Column Equilibration Condition the column with buffer: If sample is a base, you want the pH to be >9 If sample is an acid, you want the pH to be<2.5 Apply the sample to the column under gravity. The salts will flow through the column and the sample will stick to the column. The volume of the sample is not important and will probably be dictated by the equipment you use. The critical factor is concentration and capacity of the sorbent. If the concentration of the compound of exceeds the capacity of the sorbent you will not get the highest recovery. If you think this is a problem use a larger bed mass. Product Purification Wash the column with 1ml of DI water or hexane. Product Elution Elute compound of interest with 1ml of methanol, ethyl acetate, or the organic solvent of your choice. 37 Technical Document P-102 Purification of Small Molecule Libraries TIN (Sn) Removal by Pharmasil™ Ion Exchange SPE Principle: The generation of small molecule libraries for screening against biological targets has emerged as an area of intense interest in the pharmaceutical industry. Ion exchange chromatography has been demonstrated to expedite work up and purification of organic molecules synthesized in solution, and in the automated construction of small molecule libraries. The advantage of ion exchange chromatography over more traditional small molecule purification modes such as flash chromatography or HPLC is that one can reliably predict the elution characteristics of a broad range of molecules solely by the presence or absence of an ionizable site on the molecule. Application: This application details the use of Pharmasil™ TAX, a highly loaded weak cation exchange sorbent, for the removal of tin catalysts from organic synthesis mixtures. In combinatorial chemistry and organic synthesis tin compounds are common catalysts. Once the reaction is complete, it is usually necessary to separate the products of the reaction from the catalysts. If the catalyst is not removed it can interfere with further testing as well as ruin expensive analytical equipment. This can be done using a highly loaded weak cation exchanger to selectively remove the tin catalyst from the reaction mixture. 38 Chemistry of Pharmasil™ TAX Sorbent COOH CH2 Si H2 C H2 C H2 C N CH2CH2 N(CH2COOH)2 Advantages of Pharmasil™ Based Sorbents • Complete removal of tin catalyst • Clean background • High recoveries • High levels of purification of anaytes • Applicable to a broad range of compounds • Simple easy to develop methods 39 Purification Profile This profile is based on the use of a Pharmasil™ TAX 500 mg column (columns are available with varying volumes). This column is capable of removal of up to50mg of tin. The method can be scaled up as necessary by using columns of higher bed mass of sorbent and increasing the solvent volumes proportionately The following profile is meant to be a guideline for these types of purifications. Each drug class has its own specific requirements based on solubility, stability, and pKa and may require slight adjustments in methodology. Therefore think of the following profile as a beginning rather than a final method. Sample Pre-treatment Samples may or may not require pretreatment before addition. The primary concern using ion exchangers is to adjust the pH of the compound of interest so that it is totally ionized. This may require the addition of an acid or buffer. Ion exchange can be done out of organic solvents such as methanol or ethyl acetate as long as the compound of interest is ionized... Tin catalysts are strong cations and are charged across the complete pH range. Column Conditioning Condition the column 1 ml of Methanol followed by 1 ml of water. Column Equilibration Condition the column with buffer: If sample is a base, you want the pH at 7-8. If sample is an acid, you want the pH at 3-4. Sample Application Apply the sample to the column under gravity. The tin will stick to the column. The volume of the sample is not important and will probably be dictated by the equipment you use. The critical factor is concentration and capacity of the sorbent. If the concentration of the tin of exceeds the capacity of the sorbent you will not get the highest removal of tin. If you think this is a problem use a larger bed mass. Product Purification Wash the column with 1ml of buffer used in column equilibration. Product Elution Elute compound of interest with 1ml of methanol. 40 Technical Document P-103 Purification of Small Molecule Libraries Palladium (Pd) Removal by Pharmasil™ Ion Exchange SPE Principle: The generation of small molecule libraries for screening against biological targets has emerged as an area of intense interest in the pharmaceutical industry. Ion exchange chromatography has been demonstrated to expedite work up and purification of organic molecules synthesized in solution, and in the automated construction of small molecule libraries. The advantage of ion exchange chromatography over more traditional small molecule purification modes such as flash chromatography or HPLC is that one can reliably predict the elution characteristics of a broad range of molecules solely by the presence or absence of an ionizable site on the molecule. Application: This application details the use of Pharmasil™ TAX, a highly loaded weak cation exchange sorbent, for the removal of palladium catalysts from organic synthesis mixtures. In combinatorial chemistry and organic synthesis palladium compounds are common catalysts. Once the reaction is complete, it is usually necessary to separate the products of the reaction from the catalysts. If the catalyst is not removed it can interfere with further testing as well as ruin expensive analytical equipment. This can be done using a highly loaded weak cation exchanger to selectively remove the tin catalyst from the reaction mixture. 41 Chemistry of Pharmasil™ TAX Sorbent COOH CH2 Si H2 C H2 C H2 C N CH2CH2 N(CH2COOH)2 Advantages of Pharmasil™ Based Sorbents • Complete removal of palladium catalyst • Clean background • High recoveries • High levels of purification of anaytes • Applicable to a broad range of compounds • Simple easy to develop methods 42 Purification Profile This profile is based on the use of a Pharmasil™ TAX 500 mg column (columns are available with varying volumes). This column is capable of removal of up to50mg of palladium. The method can be scaled up as necessary by using columns of higher bed mass of sorbent and increasing the solvent volumes proportionately The following profile is meant to be a guideline for these types of purifications. Each drug class has its own specific requirements based on solubility, stability, and pKa and may require slight adjustments in methodology. Therefore think of the following profile as a beginning rather than a final method. Sample Pre-treatment Samples may or may not require pretreatment before addition. The primary concern using ion exchangers is to adjust the pH of the compound of interest so that it is totally ionized. This may require the addition of an acid or buffer. Ion exchange can be done out of organic solvents such as methanol or ethyl acetate as long as the compound of interest is ionized... Palladium catalysts are strong cations and are charged across the complete pH range. Adjust the sample to pH 9 with buffer or ammonium hydroxide. Column Conditioning Condition the column 1 ml of Methanol followed by 1 ml of water. Column Equilibration Condition the column with buffer of pH 9. Sample Application Apply the sample to the column under gravity. The palladium will stick to the column. The volume of the sample is not important and will probably be dictated by the equipment you use. The critical factor is concentration and capacity of the sorbent. If the concentration of the palladium exceeds the capacity of the sorbent you will not get the highest removal of palladium. If you think this is a problem use a larger bed mass. Product Purification Wash the column with 1ml of buffer used in column equilibration. Product Elution Elute compound of interest with 1ml of methanol. 43 Technical Document P-104 Purification of Small Molecule Libraries TFAA Removal by Pharmasil™ Ion Exchange SPE Principle: The generation of small molecule libraries for screening against biological targets has emerged as an area of intense interest in the pharmaceutical industry. Ion exchange chromatography has been demonstrated to expedite work up and purification of organic molecules synthesized in solution, and in the automated construction of small molecule libraries. The advantage of ion exchange chromatography over more traditional small molecule purification modes such as flash chromatography or HPLC is that one can reliably predict the elution characteristics of a broad range of molecules solely by the presence or absence of an ionizable site on the molecule. Application: This application details the use of Pharmasil™ CHQAX, a highly loaded quaternary amine exchange sorbent, for the removal of acid catalysts from organic synthesis mixtures. In combinatorial chemistry and organic synthesis TFAA is a common catalyst. Once the reaction is complete, it is usually necessary to separate the products of the reaction from the catalyst. If the catalyst is not removed it can interfere with further testing as well as ruin expensive analytical equipment. This can be done using a highly loaded quaternary amine exchanger to selectively remove the acid catalyst from the reaction mixture. 44 Chemistry of Pharmasil™ CHQAX Sorbent Si H2 C H2 C H2 C + N (CH3)3OH Advantages of Pharmasil™ Based Sorbents • Complete removal of acid catalyst • Clean background • High recoveries • High levels of purification of anaytes • Applicable to a broad range of compounds • Simple easy to develop methods 45 Purification Profile This profile is based on the use of a Pharmasil™ CHQAX 500 mg column (columns are available with varying volumes). This column is capable of removal of up to 50mg of TFAA. The method can be scaled up as necessary by using columns of higher bed mass of sorbent and increasing the solvent volumes proportionately. The following profile is meant to be a guideline for these types of purifications. Each drug class has its own specific requirements based on solubility, stability, and pKa and may require slight adjustments in methodology. Therefore think of the following profile as a beginning rather than a final method. Sample Pre-treatment Samples may or may not require pretreatment before addition. The primary concern using ion exchangers is to adjust the pH of the compound of interest so that it is totally ionized. This may require the addition of a pH 7 buffer. Ion exchange can be done out of organic solvents such as methanol or ethyl acetate as long as the compound of interest is ionized... acid catalysts are strong anions and are charged across the complete pH range. Column Conditioning Condition the column with 1 ml of methanol followed by 1 ml of DI water. Column Equilibration Condition the column with pH 7 buffer. Application Apply the sample to the column under gravity. The TFAA will stick to the column. The volume of the sample is not important and will probably be dictated by the equipment you use. The critical factor is concentration and capacity of the sorbent. If the concentration of the TFAA exceeds the capacity of the sorbent you will not get the highest removal of TFAA. If you think this is a problem use a larger bed mass. Product Purification Wash the column with 1ml of buffer used in column equilibration. Product Elution Elute compound of interest with 1ml of methanol. 46 The Determination of Trace Metal Concentrations in Acid Mine Drainage By Michael W. Beneteau Advisor: Dr. Carol M. Babyak 47 TAX Column % Recovery of Pb at Various Concentrations 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 0.250 ppm 0.050 ppm 1.00 ppm 2.00 ppm 48 Metal Recoveries on Various Phases Cu (ll) Zn (ll) As (V) Sn (Vl) Se (lV) Hg (ll) Cr (lll) PSA 5.50 4.47 0.00 9.11 23.82 57.07 3.39 BCX-HL 18.01 19.21 0.00 29.43 0.62 58.97 9.81 CCX 0.67 0.03 0.00 16.99 0.00 10.66 0.55 TAX 3.73 3.58 0.00 33.69 0.00 23.97 0.55 THX 10.02 0.78 0.67 29.10 11.42 58.97 0.46 NAX 5.92 2.61 0.00 2.20 21.03 46.80 0.85 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58