Intro to Fahrenheit 451 Lecture Notes, Background, and Themes “Anything you dream is fiction, anything you accomplish is science, the whole history of mankind is nothing but science fiction.” Ray Bradbury Ray Bradbury (1920-2012) As a child, Bradbury recalls an intense fascination with monsters, magicians, and adventure films. He began writing stories at the age of 12. He wrote for Alfred Hitchcock and The Twilight Zone. Bradbury is the author of more than 500 published literary works that include short stories, plays, novels, poetry, and screenplays. The Life of a Writer In 1940, Bradbury sold his first story. In 1942, he was able to quit his newspaper job and write full-time. His first novel was The Martian Chronicles, which describes humankind’s first attempt to colonize the planet Mars. This novel combines science fiction with social commentary—an approach that characterizes much of his work. Social Concerns Bradbury’s works explored the threat of nuclear war, censorship, racism, conformity, and the dangers of technology—issues that still concern us today. What do You Think? Despite its benefits, technology can have unpredictable consequences on our society. What are some of these potential consequences? What is science fiction? Science fiction is a form that deals principally with the impact of actual or imagined science upon society or individuals. If science concerns itself with discovery, then science fiction concerns itself with the consequences of discovery. It is a testament to the visionary nature of the form that science fiction writers predicted the advent of atomic weapons and sentient machines. Its enduring value though is in its capacity to ask probing questions of each new scientific advance, to conduct a dialogue with progress that decodes its real meaning and reveals it to us. Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 is a type of DYSTOPIC novel. That means it is about a future that is bleak, dark and dreary. The novel focuses on two central themes: 1. CENSORSHIP 2. IGNORANCE OF KNOWLEDGE CENSORSHIP: is the suppression of speech or deletion of communicative material which may be considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or inconvenient to the government or media organizations as determined by a censor. (Wikipedia) Why would something be censored? What are the dangers of censorship? IGNORANCE OF KNOWLEDGE: Bradbury focuses on the importance of learning and how it impacts our ability to make decisions. He believes that without the ability to think about what we’re doing, we’ll be led to do wrong. The Novel: The novel is a social criticism written by Ray Bradbury, a celebrated science fiction writer. It began as a short story in 1951 and evolved into a novel by 1953. The novel was written a time when the world was threatened by nuclear war, new technologies were emerging and the world was getting smaller. What is Social Criticism? Social criticism analyzes (problematic) social structures, and aims at practical solutions by specific measures, radical reform, or even revolutionary change. Fahrenheit 451 is a social criticism that warns against the danger of suppressing thought through the censorship of books. It is the 24th century. Books are considered dangerous and illegal. Nobody is allowed to own them. Most people are happy being plugged into their technology, where they do not have to think too hard. All books that are found are burned. Burning Bright An excerpt from a foreword to the fortieth Anniversary Edition of Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury February 14, 1993 “….a prediction that my fire Chief, Beatty, made in 1953, halfway through my book. It had to do with books being burned without matches or fire. Because you don’t have to burn books, do you, if the world starts to fill up with nonreaders, non-learners, nonknowers? If the world wide-screen-basketballs and footballs itself to drown in MTV, no Beattys are needed to ignite the kerosene or hunt the reader. If the primary grades suffer meltdown and vanish through the cracks and ventilators of the schoolroom, who, after a while, will know or care? All is not lost, of course. There is still time if we judge teachers, students, and parents, hold them accountable on the same scale, if we truly test teachers, students, and parents, if we make everyone responsible for quality, if we insure that by the end of its sixth year every child in every country can live in libraries to learn almost by osmosis, then our drug, street-gang, rape, and murder scores will suffer themselves near zero. But the Fire Chief, in midnovel, says it all, predicting the one-minute TV commercial with three images per second and no respite from the bombardment. Listen to him, know what he says, then go sit with your child, open a book, and turn the page.” Guy Montag is a fireman. It is not his job to put out fires. It is his job to start them. If a house is suspected to have books in it, Guy and the other firemen properly dispose of them. Most often, the whole house must be destroyed. Sometimes the people in the house choose to die with their books. The problem is, Guy is not so comfortable with the whole burning books thing. He wonders why they must be burned. What power do they have? Why would somebody choose to die for their books? It wouldn’t hurt just to take one and read it, right? Unfortunately for Guy, he live in a society where censorship is king; a society where you don’t know if you can trust your friends, or even your wife; a society in which criminals are tracked by relentless mechanical hounds that never fail to bring down their victims…. Guy used to uphold and enforce the law. Bringing home a book will cause a chain of events that not even he could have anticipated… Now here is some irony: Fahrenheit 451 is a book about the dangers of censorship. Yet this book itself has been the object of censorship. It has been banned and/or challenged in many places across the United States. Why might other books or types of media be censored? It is the practice of keeping material from being viewed by others because of objectionable or offensive material. What does it mean for a book to be banned or challenged? It means that somebody was offended by something in the book and demanded that it be removed from shelves in libraries, bookstores, etc. Not all books that are challenged in this way are banned, but some are. It depends on the community, and their policies on censorship. Historical Context Fahrenheit 451 was developed in the years immediately following World War II and leading into the Cold War. It condemns not only the anti-intellectualism of Nazi Germany (book burnings), but also America in the 1950s—the heyday of McCarthyism, and a growing fear of communism. Other influential social criticisms of the time include George Orwell’s 1984 and Animal Farm. The foundation when Fahrenheit 451 was written Communism and national security: the red menace Due to the U.S. conflict with the Soviet Union, anti-Communism moved to the ideological center of American politics. By the beginning of 1946 most of the nation's policymakers had come to view the Soviet Union as a hostile power committed to a program of worldwide expansion that only the United States was strong enough to resist. The anti-communist agenda: What transformed the communist threat into a national obsession was the involvement of the federal government. During the early years of the cold war, the actions of the federal government helped to forge and legitimize the anticommunist consensus that enabled most Americans to condone or participate in the serious violations of civil liberties that characterized the McCarthy era. The 1950s By mid-century, nearly 60% of Americans were members of the middle class; they had more discretionary income. Consumerism = Success The electronics industry became the 5th largest industry. Television had a widespread impact in American homes. The United States became an automobile culture. The increase in prosperity after the war led to an increased passivity and conformity. Jobs were plentiful and the common adage of the time period was: “follow orders, and you will succeed.” 1950’s Timeline 1950 President Harry Truman approves production of the hydrogen bomb. Ted Williams becomes the highest paid baseball player at $125,000 a year (today Alex Rodrigues makes twenty-two million dollars a year). 1951 Television begins to be broadcast nationally, coast to coast. Jackson Pollock and other American painters continued to create a new “Abstract Expressionism” style. The first nuclear test occurs at the Nevada Test Site. Julius and Ethel Rosenberg are convicted and sentenced to death for passing information on atomic weapons to the USSR. 1952 Suburbia is born in the form of small suburban communities like Levittown, PA. Many more families could now afford to own homes. A second US nuclear weapons laboratory is established in Livermore, CA. First British atomic bomb, “Hurricane” was tested at Monte Bello Islands, Australia, with a yield of twenty-five kilotons. 1953 Francis Crick and James Watson discover the double helix of the DNA. 1954 The U.S. Supreme Court wrote in “Brown v. the Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas” that racial segregation in schools was illegal. U.S. Senator Joseph McCarthy begins a televised anti-communist trials. The first deliverable hydrogen bomb is tested at Bikini Atoll. The USA threatens to use the nuclear weapons to stop Soviet aggression on Europe. The Regency TR-1 was the world's first commercially marketed transistor radio. 1955 Disneyland opens in Los Angeles. The Beat Generation of writers is launched by the publication of Allen Ginsberg’s poem “Howl” which began, “I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness… Rosa Parks refuses to give up her seat on a public bus in Montgomery, Alabama. First true fusion device test by the Soviet Union, it had a yield of one point six megatons. 1956 1957 Elvis Presley took the music world by storm with five #1 songs on the Billboard Music Chart. First British H-bomb exploded at Christmas Island. Robert Noyce and Jack Kilby invent the microchip. Britain and France each become a nuclear power. The first enclosed mall called Southdale opened in Edina, Minnesota First underground nuclear test “Rainier” occurred at the Nevada Test Site. Television viewing rapidly expands with the introduction of Cable Extensive work begins on the Federal Highway system after it was approved a year earlier. Now there are over 45,000 miles of interstate highways. The Soviet Union Launches the Sputnik, the first artificial satellite. 1958 The first US Polaris capable nuclear missile submarine enters into service. Drive-in movies were the place to hangout if you were a teenager. On December 10, 1958 the first domestic jetairline passenger service is begun by National Airlines between New York and Miami. European democracies (Italy, Germany, Belgium, Holland, France) found European Union. U.S. Constitution: First Amendment – Religion and Expression Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. Censorship As long as humans have sought to communicate, others have sought to prevent them. Every day some government or other group tries to restrict or control what can be said, written, sung, or broadcast. Almost every idea ever thought has proved objectionable to someone, and almost everyone has sometimes felt the world would be a better place if only “so and so” would go away. “Remember, the firemen are rarely necessary. The public itself stopped reading of its own accord…” Ray Bradbury on Fahrenheit 451 FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: Ballantine Books originally published the Fahrenheit 451 in 1953, but in 1967 brought out a special edition to be sold to high schools. Without informing Bradbury or putting a note in the edition, the publisher modified seventy-five passages in the novel in order to eliminate words like “hell,” “damn.” The expurgated edition was sold for thirteen years before a friend of Bradbury’s alerted him to the problem. Bradbury demanded that Ballantine withdraw the version and replace it with the original. Ballantine agreed. The publicity generated by the expurgated version of Fahrenheit 451 caused the American Library Association’s Intellectual Freedom Committee to investigate other school books and use its considerable economic clout to warn publishers about expurgations and demand that any excised versions be clearly identified. (from www.trib.com) Personal Context On a more personal level, Bradbury used Fahrenheit 451 as a means of protesting what he believed to be the invasiveness of editors, who, through strict control of the books they printed, impaired the originality and creativity of writers. FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: FACT: “The government has a history of controlling the reading habits of Americans. The FBI’s ‘Library Awareness Program’ sought to ‘recruit librarians as counter intelligence assets to monitor suspicious library users and report their reading habits to the FBI.’ When the American Library Association (ALA) learned of this, its Intellectual Freedom Committee issued an advisory statement warning that libraries are not ‘extensions of the long arm of the law or of the gaze of Big Brother…’ Another ALA memo chastised the FBI for its efforts to ‘convert library circulation records into ‘suspect lists’…’ The program was eventually ended, or so says the FBI.” Foerstel, H. Library Surveillance: The FBI’s Library Awareness Program (1991) Banned and Challenged Books “A challenge is an attempt to remove or restrict materials, based upon the objections of a person or group. A banning is the removal of those materials. Challenges do not simply involve a person expressing a point of view; rather, they are an attempt to remove material from the curriculum or library, thereby restricting the access of others.” The following page is a graphic of such books. (see graphic next page) “Censorship reflects a society’s lack of confidence in itself.” Potter Stewart/Associate Justice of the U.S Supreme Court (1915-1985) HARRY POTTER (Series) by J.K. Rowling 1997. “Censorship is advertising paid by the government.” Federico Fellini—Italian Film director Challenged and banned for its focus on wizardry and magic MOBY DICK by Herman Melville 1839 Banned from the advanced placement English reading list at the Lindale, TX schools (1996) because “it conflicts with the values of the community”. A RAISIN IN THE SUN by L. Hansberry 1959 Responding to criticisms from an Antiporn organization, the Ogden, Utah School District (1979) restricted circulation of Hansberry’s play. FAHRENHEIT 451 by Ray Bradbury 1953 Expurgated at the Venado Middle School in Irvine, CA (1992). Students received copies of the book with scores words blacked out. ANNE FRANK: THE STORY OF A YOUNG GIRL by Ann Frank 1967 Four members of the Alabama State Textbook committee (1983) called for the rejection of this title because it is a “real downer.” MUSIC 2000 – In New York the police called for the cancellation of Bruce Springsteen’s performances after he debuts a song about the shooting of Amadou Diallo entitled “American Skin.” 1958 – The Mutual Broadcasting System drops all rock and roll records from its network music programs, calling it “distorted, monotonous, noisy music.” 2001 – Clear Channel Communications (largest owner of radio stations in the US) releases a list of more than 150“lyrically questionable” songs that the stations may want to pull from their play lists. 2002 - WAL-MART BANS EMINEM Wal-Mart has banned the sale of the CD titled The Eminem Show at all of their stores. Wal-Mart's official CD sales policy states, in part: “Wal-Mart will not stock music with parental guidance stickers.” Bradbury Was Right… In Fahrenheit 451, Bradbury tries to “prevent the future,” not predict it, but he actually does anticipate the future. Seashell Radios Parlor Walls Population Explosion A reliance on technology to mediate all social experience What Else was Bradbury Right About? • A rise in violence (including gun violence) • The use of televised surveillance footage for many purposes. • Growing illiteracy • The condensation of information into what we now call “sound bites.” More & More - People clamor for technology: faster computers, faster connections to internet, computerized “chat rooms” that enable us to “speak” to faceless strangers, more comprehensive cell phone networks, pagers, more powerful cars, voice mail, palm pilots, etc. People seem petrified of wasting time. Bradbury believed that the presence of fast cars, loud music, and a constant barrage of advertisements created a life with far too much stimulation in which no one had the time or ability to concentrate. Further, he felt people regarded the huge mass of published material as too overwhelming, leading to a society that read condensed books (very popular at the time Bradbury was writing) rather than the real thing. Average time per week that the American child ages 217 spends watching television: 19 hours and 40 minutes Age by which children develop brand loyalty: 2 Years old Percentage of children ages 8-16 who have a TV in their bedroom: 56% “Television is a chewing gum for the Eyes.” Frank Lloyd Wright Number of TV commercials viewed by American children a year: 20,000 “The remarkable thing about TV is that it permits several million people to laugh at the same joke and still I feel lonely.” T.S. Eliot Themes: Censorship Censorship is defined as the removal or withholding of information from the public by a controlling group or body. Typically done by governments, religious and secular groups, corporations, or the mass media. Censorship in the Novel In the world of Fahrenheit 451, books are burned because they trigger thought and discontent, two things that are unwelcome in this “happiness oriented” society. What’s unexpected about the censorship in Fahrenheit 451 is that it seems to have originated with the people, not the government. Theme: Ignorance vs. Knowledge What does true happiness consist of? Is ignorance bliss, or do knowledge and learning provide true happiness? In this world, firemen promote ignorance by destroying books—and with them—knowledge. Theme: Technology-Deadening Human Experience Technology in Bradbury’s 24th century is highly advanced and dominates society. TV, radio broadcasts, fast cars and atomic weapons dominate people’s experiences—at the expense of things like nature, music and poetry. Theme: Dystopian Society an imagined place or state in which everything is unpleasant or bad, typically a totalitarian or environmentally degraded one. The “Dystopia” motif, popular in science fiction—that of a technocratic and totalitarian society that demands order at the expense of individual rights—is central to the novel. Dystopias Characteristics Propaganda is used to control citizens. Information, independent thought, and freedom are restricted. A figurehead or concept is worshipped by citizens. Citizens are under constant surveillance. Citizens feel trapped and struggle to escape. The natural world is banished and distrusted. Citizens are dehumanized. The society is an illusion of a perfect utopian world. Types of Control Corporate/Economic: large corporations control society through products, advertising, and/or the media. Political: red tape, relentless regulations and incompetent government officials. Technological: society is controlled by technology— robots, computers, etc. Philosophical/Religious: ideology is enforced through a dictatorship or theocratic government. Can you think of any additional examples of dystopias in film or literature? Discussion Questions Look at the importance of entertainment in your own lives or in the lives of your friends (what sorts of entertainment do you enjoy: Internet, movies, music, TV etc…) How much of your time do you spend consuming entertainment? Discussion Questions How is entertainment marketed to us and how does it affect our daily lives? Discussion Questions Is entertainment addictive? Can it serve the same purposes as drugs or alcohol? Discussion Questions The novel expresses that mindless entertainment can weaken or destroy the mind. Is there evidence of this? Discussion Questions How do stress, pressure and speed in life and effect us. (Look, for example at “road rage ”and other such phenomena.) How do addictions (drugs, alcohol, television, entertainment, etc.) relate? About Fahrenheit 451 Fahrenheit 451, the temperature at which paper catches fire. Fahrenheit 451 is a social criticism that warns against the danger of suppressing thought through censorship. Fahrenheit 451 uses the conventions of science fiction to convey the message that oppressive government, left unchecked, does irreparable damage to society by curtailing the creativity and freedom of its people. The "dystopia” motif, popular in science fiction that of a technocratic and totalitarian society that demands order at the expense of individual rights is central to the novel. Developed in the years immediately following World War II, Fahrenheit 451 condemns not only the anti intellectualism of Nazi Germany, but more immediately America in the early 1950's - the heyday of McCarthyism. On a more personal level, Bradbury used Fahrenheit 451 as a means of protesting what he believed to be the invasiveness of editors who, through their strict control of the books they printed, impaired the originality and creativity of writers. Ironically, Fahrenheit 451, itself a vehicle of protest against censorship, has often been edited for foul language. Fahrenheit 451 has sold millions of copies and established itself as a literary classic. The Library of Congress recently designated this best-known book of Bradbury’s as one of the top 100 works of American literature. Forty-nine years after it first appeared on bookshelves, Ray Bradbury’s cautionary novel remains recommended reading in high school classrooms across the country. Similarities with our society: The society Bradbury describes in Fahrenheit 451 is, in many ways, like the one we are living in right now: a technologically advanced and violent society, a busy and fast-paced world. Clarisse notices how fast people drive: “…don’t know what grass is, or flowers because they never see them slowly. If you showed a driver a green blur, Oh yes! He’d say, that ‘s grass! A pink blur! That’s a rose garden! White blurs are houses. Brown blurs are cows. My uncle drove slowly on a highway once. He drove forty miles an hour and they jailed him for two days.” (p. 9) * In Fahrenheit 451 young people are violent. Clarisse tells Montag she is: “ …afraid of children my own age. They kill each other…Six of my friends have been shot in the last year alone. Ten of them died in car wrecks. I’m afraid of them and they don’t like me because I’m afraid.”(p.30)* One needs only think of the Columbine High School massacre to note the presence of violence in our society. Like Fahrenheit 451’s firemen, Hitler was burning books in Germany. We should ask ourselves: how far are we from this fictional world? Fahrenheit 451 is disturbing precisely because it is plausible. Symbolism: Bradbury’s use of symbolism throughout renders the book moving and powerful and reinforces his ideas of anticensorship. Some symbolism to look for: · Books are burned physically and “ideas are burned from the mind.” Bradbury warns us about what happens when we stop expressing our ideas, and we permit people to take away our books. · Part one of the book entitled The Earth and The Salamander: a salamander is known to endure fire without getting burned. A salamander is therefore symbolic of Montag, because he works with fire and endures it. Montag believes he can escape the fire and survive, much like a salamander. · The symbol of a Phoenix is used throughout the novel. A Phoenix is a multicolored bird from Arabian myth. At the end of its 500-year existence, it perches on its nest of spices and sings until sunlight ignites its body. After the body is consumed, a worm emerges and develops into the next Phoenix. This symbolizes both the rebirth after destruction by fire and the cyclical nature of things. Firemen wear the Phoenix on their uniforms and Beatty drives a Phoenix car. Montag, after realizing that fire has destroyed him, wishes to be “reborn.” Granger, one of Fahrenheit 451’s characters, said: “ There was a silly damn bird called Phoenix back before Christ, every few hundred years he built a pyre and burnt himself up. He must have been first cousin to Man.” (p.163) Dualism: Book -burner / book -reader dualism: Montag burns books during his workday. At home, however, his lifestyle betrays this work ethic. Beatty and Faber represent this opposition: Montag receives totally opposing lectures from them on the innate value of books and what ought to be done with them. The fire has in itself two conflicting properties: destruction and preservation. The fire is used to burn houses and books, to destroy possessions. Fire also provides heat to cook meals, warm people, and provide light. Assignments 1) In a group, you must make a list of all characters in the novel and a brief description of who they are. Make sure you have all characters covered 2) Pick one of these characters on whom you will do a complete character sketch. This will be done in complete 5 paragraph essay, MLA format, and handed in through TURNITIN. 3) Character Sketch.docx