FORENSIC TRICHOLOGY SFS1. Students will recognize and classify various types of evidence in relation to the definition and scope of Forensic Science b. Distinguish and categorize physical and trace evidence (e.g. … hair) SFS2. Students will use various scientific techniques to analyze physical and trace evidence. b. Analyze the morphology and types of hair. 1 ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS How can you distinguish the types and layers of hair? How can you distinguish animal and human hair? How can you distinguish the growth periods of hair? How can you distinguish one human hair from another? 2 HISTORY 1590 – First operating compound microscope 1847 – Earliest examination of hairs in criminal investigation 1861 – First forensic investigation of human hair comparison of hair found on victim to those of defendant 1906 – Documented use of hair in forensic investigations to determine identity 1910 – Microscopic studies of both human and animal hair 1951 – Use of adhesive tape to collect trace evidence 3 TYPES OF HAIRS Primordial hairs – develop from 9 to 22 wks. Lanugo hairs – fetal body hair shed by 36-40 wks. Vellus hairs – “peach fuzz” pre-pubescent hair Terminal hairs – adult hair stimulated to grow by androgens (male hormones) 4 HAIR STRUCTURE Hair is primarily composed of the protein keratin and the pigment melanin Hair is both living and dead – the living part (root) is enclosed within the follicle, while the dead part is the shaft 5 HAIR STRUCTURE 6 Cross-Section of a Hair 7 HAIR STRUCTURE Cuticle - a translucent outer layer of the hair shaft consisting of scales that cover the shaft. Cuticular scales always point from the proximal (root) end of the hair to the distal (tip) end of the hair. Not useful in individualizing human hair, but can be used for species identification 8 HAIR STRUCTURE Cuticle Structure 1. Coronal “crown-like” Rare in humans Typical of rodents. Found in hairs of very fine diameter. 9 HAIR STRUCTURE Cuticle Structure 2. Spinous “petal-like.” Never found in humans. Common in cats, seals, and minks. 10 HAIR STRUCTURE Cuticle Structure 3. Imbricate “flattened” Common in humans 11 HAIR STRUCTURE Cortex - is the main body of the hair Embedded with pigment granules that give hair its color The color, shape and distribution of the granules provide points for forensic comparison Dyed hair has uniform pigmentation in cortex and cuticle 12 HAIR STRUCTURE In humans, pigment granules are commonly distributed toward the cuticle, except in red-haired individuals. 13 HAIR STRUCTURE Animal hairs have the pigment granules commonly distributed toward the medulla. 14 HAIR STRUCTURE Medulla - a cellular column running through the center of the cortex Presence of medulla varies quite a bit: even hair to hair Useful in distinguishing among animal species MEDULLARY INDEX = diameter of the medulla diameter of the hair shaft Humans: medullary index < 1/3 Animals: medullary index > 1/2 15 Medulla Structure (Animal) 16 HAIR STRUCTURE Medullary Patterns 17 Medulla Structure (Human) 18 GROWTH AND REPLACEMENT OF HAIR Mammalian hair follicles go through three distinct growth cycles. 19 GROWTH AND REPLACEMENT OF HAIR Anagen: the active growth phase Scalp hairs spend 2-7 yrs in this phase and grow approximately 1 cm/mo. Up to 90% of the hairs are in this growth cycle Follicle is attached to the root by the papilla. The hair must be pulled to be lost. 20 GROWTH AND REPLACEMENT OF HAIR 21 GROWTH AND REPLACEMENT OF HAIR Catagen: the transitional stage Lasts two to four weeks Only 2% of the hairs are in this phase Follicle is losing blood supply and hair is retreating to the surface 22 GROWTH AND REPLACEMENT OF HAIR 23 GROWTH AND REPLACEMENT OF HAIR Telogen: the resting phase Lasts two to four months, until hairs fall out naturally or are forcibly removed About 10% to 18% of the hairs are in this phase 24 GROWTH AND REPLACEMENT OF HAIR 25 IDENTIFICATION OF HUMAN HAIR The first step of forensic identification and comparison of hairs begins with whole mount light microscopy. The hair(s) in question must be identified as to species, race and body (somatic) origin. 26 IDENTIFICATION OF HUMAN HAIR Human hairs can be readily distinguished from animal hairs in primarily by examining the cuticles and medullae. Individualizing human hairs is done by examining cortex features and by analyzing DNA. 27 RACIAL ORIGIN European Shaft: straight to wavy Shaft diameter: moderate with minimal variation Cortex: sparse to moderately dense with melanin; fairly even distribution Medulla: variable Cross-sectional shape: oval 28 EXAMPLES OF RACIAL HAIR 29 RACIAL ORIGIN African Shaft: prominent twist and curl Shaft diameter: moderate to fine with considerable variation Cortex: melanin is densely distributed and arranged in prominent clumps Medulla: fragmented or absent Cross-sectional shape: flattened 30 EXAMPLES OF RACIAL HAIR 31 RACIAL ORIGIN Asian Shaft: straight with thick cuticle Shaft diameter: coarse with little or no variation Cortex: densely distributed melanin and often arranged in large patchy areas or streaks Medulla: prominent (often broad and continuous) Cross-sectional shape: round 32 EXAMPLES OF RACIAL HAIR 33 SOMATIC ORIGIN Somatic Origin: Head Long with moderate shaft diameter and diameter variation Medulla absent to continuous and relatively narrow when compared to the structure of hairs from other body areas Often with cut or split tips Can show artificial treatment, solar bleaching, or mechanical damage Soft texture, pliable 34 SOMATIC ORIGIN Somatic Origin: Pubic Shaft diameter coarse with wide variations and buckling Medulla relatively broad and usually continuous when present Root frequently with tag Tip usually tapered, rounded, or abraded Stiff texture, wiry 35 SOMATIC ORIGIN Somatic Origin: Limb hairs (arm or leg) Diameter fine with little variation Gross appearance of hair is arc-like in shape Medulla is discontinuous to trace with a granular appearance Tips usually tapered often blunt and abraded, rounded scale ends due to wear Soft texture 36 SOMATIC ORIGIN Somatic Origin Beard or Mustache hairs Diameter very coarse with irregular or triangular crosssectional shape Medulla very broad and continuous, may be doubled 37 IDENTIFICATION OF HUMAN HAIR Somatic Origin Chest hairs Shaft diameter moderate and variable Tip often darker in color, long and fine, arclike Medulla may be granular Stiff texture 38 IDENTIFICATION OF HUMAN HAIR Somatic Origin Underarm hairs Resemble pubic hairs in general appearance, but less wiry Medullar appearance similar to limb hairs Diameter moderate and variable with less buckling than pubic hairs Tips long and fine, frequently with bleached appearance 39 IDENTIFICATION OF HUMAN HAIR Somatic Origin: Other Eyebrow: Stubby, some diameter fluctuation, saber-like in appearance Eyelash: Short, stubby with little shaft diameter fluctuation, saber-like in appearance Trunk: A combination of features of limb and pubic hairs, a transitional hair 40 IDENTIFICATION OF HUMAN HAIR As a rule, most forensic comparisons are conducted using scalp or pubic hairs. Body and limb hairs are generally considered unsuitable for comparison purposes. 41 VARIATIONS IN COLOR 42 COLLECTION AND EXAMINATION OF HAIR Always photograph the item and note its location first before collecting it. Always be sensitive to crosscontamination issues. Always wear gloves to collect evidence. Always use clean, unused paper bindles or containers. 43 COLLECTION AND EXAMINATION OF HAIR Use fingers or tweezers to collect crime scene evidence. Collect good representative exemplary (known) hairs from the scalp and/or pubic region. Collect exemplars from both the victim and suspect. Always maintain the chain of custody. 44 COMPARATIVE MICROSCOPY Skillful microscopic technique provides the forensic hair examiner with a highly discriminating means to examine and compare hair, and utilizes various types of microscopes. 45 COMPARATIVE MICROSCOPY Stereomicroscope - permits gross observations of the hairs; allows a rapid overview of the range of characteristics. Polarizing microscope - delineates the hair’s finer structural characteristics. Transmitted light microscope - allows a side-by-side comparison of the known and questioned hairs. Hairs are compared from their root end to their tip end. 46 CONCLUSION AND REPORT WRITING Forensic laboratory reports of hair comparisons normally will provide one of three answers: The hairs matched in microscopic characteristics, indicating an association. The hairs are not alike and therefore did not come from the same person. No conclusion can be drawn from the evidence. This may be due to insufficient specimen, racial mixtures, or unsuitable exemplars. 47 DNA Analysis Nuclear DNA Combination of both parents Hair root/follicle Mitochondrial DNA Mother’s lineage only Hair shaft 48