Overview of Outsourcing May 2005 Copyright © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Accenture, its logo, and High Performance Delivered are trademarks of Accenture. Agenda • Introduction to Outsourcing • Preparing for Outsourcing • Running Outsourcing • Next Steps in Outsourcing © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 2 INTRODUCTION A Working Definition of Outsourcing Services COMPANY OUTSOURCER Organization Service Level Level Agreement Agreement Outsourcing denotes the continuous procurement of services from a third party, making use of highly integrated processes, organization models and information systems. © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 3 INTRODUCTION On the origins of Outsourcing • 50 - 70 Vertical and Horizontal Integration • 70 - 80 Foreign Direct Investment • 80 - 90 Global Sourcing • 90 - Outsourcing © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 4 INTRODUCTION Very different level of acceptance German car manufacturers: degree of vertical integration Banking industry worldwide: cost share of outsourced services 2003 100% 100% 80% 80% 62% 68% 60% 76% 20% 60% Value Creation Suppliers 40% 38% 32% 24% 1,4%: costs for outsourcing Value Creation Producer 40% 98,6% 20% 0% 0% 1980 1990 © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 2000 5 INTRODUCTION Types of Outsourcing Outsourcing models: BPO Business processes Administrative processes AMO SDO Application Development and Maintenance IT-infrastructure © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. BPO: Business Process Outsourcing APO: Administrative Process Outsourcing ASP: Application Service Provider DBRO: Design, Build, Run & Operate ADM: Application Develop. & Maintenance ITO: IT Infrastructure Outsourcing ITS: IT Services, Managed Hosting 6 INTRODUCTION BPO - Business Process Outsourcing Industrialized Customized One-to-many One-to-one medium low high Degree of industrialization Custom designed services leveraging know-how © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Similar services delivered to multiple clients Single service delivered to multiple clients simultaneously 7 INTRODUCTION AMO - Application Management Outsourcing © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 8 INTRODUCTION SDO – Service Delivery Outsourcing • Security - End-to-end security services including firewall management, intrusion detection, identity management and security policy • Data Centers - Remote and on-site managed server hosting - Data centers • Technical Support - Help desk, desk-side and self-service support - Global hubs • Network Services - Managing data and voice networks Network Management • Desktop Management and Mobility - PC, laptop, hand-held, distributed Security Operations • Supplier Management - Identifying, qualifying, contracting and managing strategic suppliers Client Operations Management Delivery capabilities Security Data Technical Network Desktop Supplier Centers Support Services Mgmt. Mgmt. & Mobility Sales Support and Mobilization Hosting Technical Support Services Desktop Management & Mobility Messaging & Collaboration © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 9 INTRODUCTION Sourcing of Outsourcing • Off-Site – Local service providers • Near Shore – Proximity cross-border service providers • Off-Shore – © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Remote Cross-border service providers 10 INTRODUCTION Geographics of Outsourcing Ireland (1) London (1) Montreal (1) Chicago (1) Cincinnati (1) Houston (1) Toronto (1) Wilmington (1) Atlanta (1) Riga (1) Prague (1) Bratislava (1) Budapest Madrid (1) Dalian (1) Malaga (1) Shanghai (1) Mumbai (3) Bangalore (3) São Paulo (1) © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Hyderabad (1) Chennai (1) Manila (8) Mauritius (1) 11 INTRODUCTION Trend is clearly towards Off-Shore © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 12 INTRODUCTION Typical Outsourcing Clients Halliburton RAG American Coal 02 (formerly BT Cellnet) LASMO plc Repsol YPF Alcatel Lyondell-Citgo Refining Rhodia Algar MOL - Hungarian Oil & Gas Siam Cement AT&T MidAmerican Energy Sithe Energies Avaya Norsk Hydro Slovnaft BellSouth Orange and Rockland Utilities Southern Company GAS Boston Scientific PPL (Pennsylvania Power & Light) Talisman Energy Ltd. BT Terasen Utility Services Cegetel Espirito Santo Sequros Thames Water Citrix GE Consumer Finance Ticona Grupo Financiero BanCrecer eBay Morgan Stanley TotalFinaElf) Total E&P UK plc (formerly Guy Carpenter Argentaria EMC Providian Immobiliere 3F Banca Italease Sonera ETS Royal and SunAlliance Infocaja BBVA Sun Microsystems Sallie Mae Banco Rio de la Plata Edgars Consolidate Stores Limited ING Group Tecnomen Santander Italian Pension Agency Alcan Bankiter Exel plc Telecom Argentina SchmidtBank Johannesburg Securities Exchange Ardent HCSC Barclays Bank plc Telecom Italia JPMChase SEC Padova Health Alliance Plan Bilbao Bizkaia Kutxa (BBK) Asahi Brewery Telefonica Argentina London Stock Exchange Losango Impregilo Achieve SEI Astilleros Espanoles, Caixa Catalunya Texas Instruments Mediolanum Interstate Brands now IZAR UBS Life International Caja Madrid Thomson Meridia KLM Royal Dutch Airlines AstraZeneca CortalConsors Universal Leven VIA Networks Levi Strauss Neptune Orient Lines Best Buy Credit Lyonnais Workers’ Compensation Board XM Satellite Radio LSG Sky Chefs Thomas Cook New Look Depository Trust & Clearing Brahma Xelion Marriott Payless Shoe Source Bristol Myers Squibb Deutsche Bank MDB Information Network DnB NOR Pfizer Campofrio Mecalux Renault Fujitsu Siemens Computers Carrefour Medicines Control Agency Resort Condominiums Infineon Caterpillar Milwaukee County Mental Health International Infostrada Multibras Electrodomesticos Whirlpool Delphi (RCI) JVC do Brasil Ltda. & Nokia Gradiente Industrial Delta Sainsbury’s O Globo Empresa Diageo Sara Lee Olivetti Tecnost DSV Group Solar Turbines Omnitel2000 eLSG SkyChefs.com Texas Medicaid QinetiQ Transnet Portnet Siemens Mobile Communications Italy UPS SITA Wärtsilä Wyeth © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Ameren BC Hydro Borden Chemical BP Britannia Operator Cogema Dow Chemical DuPont Dynegy Direct Energy Essential Home Services (DEEHS) Enbridge Gas Distribution Enbridge Gas New Brunswick Freeport McMoRan 13 INTRODUCTION Outsourcing Service Providers Off-Site One Stop Near-Shore Off-Shore • IBM • Accenture • EDS Locals • Cap • CSC • Fujitsu Pure Players • Tata • InfoSys • Guja © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 14 INTRODUCTION Key drivers for Outsourcing (Survey Results) Why do outsourcing? - Survey Results • • • • • • • • Access best in class business processes Harness leading technologies Increase efficiencies Enhance capabilities Expand service Enrich customer relations Improve supplier relations Free up management time • Decrease operating costs © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 15 INTRODUCTION Value Contribution of Outsourcing © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 16 Agenda • Introduction to Outsourcing • Preparing for Outsourcing • Running Outsourcing • Next Steps in Outsourcing © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 17 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING From Drivers to Strategic Options Outsourcing Change Drivers Defining the Burning Platform Outsourcing Options In-House Status Quo Continuous Improvement Spin-off Determine Scope In-House Transformation Co-Sourcing Captive Understand Internal Constraints Joint Venture Understand External Constraints External Outsourcing Lift-Out Shoring © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 18 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING The Burning Platform • • • • • BUSINESS CONCERNS Perceived low availability of services Perceived low level of service quality (accessibility, turn-around time etc.) No clear service reporting and service management Roles & Responsibilities not clear. Processes unclear, too slow, too many hand-offs Slow and error-prone service introduction Unsatisfactory support of remote sites & subsidiaries No service culture Cost allocation & charges unclear and cannot be influenced by business decisions … Change Drivers Management Control Service Scope & Level Budget Levels • • • Financial Flexibility IT CONCERNS Unreasonable service level expectations from business No cost & resource awareness Large number of non-standard work requests Overlarge project portfolio, paired with spaghetti development infrastructure High-level of business applications Inefficient / underutilized server platform, aging central technology platforms and complex networks Large and divers skill pool required to support infrastructure … Infrastructure Quality Skill & Capability Pool Organizational Impact Time to Benefit Client Rating © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 19 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING Outsourcing Options & Contribution Time to Benefit Organizational Impact Skill & Capability Pool Infrastructure Quality Financial Flexibility Budget Levels Service Scope & Level Spin-off Management Control Sourcing Option High Limited Limited None None None Limited Short Medium Medium Medium Limited Medium Medium Limited Medium High Medium Low Low Medium Low Medium Long Medium Medium Medium Medium Medium Medium Medium Long Lift-Out Low Strong Strong Medium Medium Medium Strong Medium Shoring Low Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Short Co-Sourcing Captive Joint Venture © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 20 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING Understand Internal Constraints • Availability of Seed Money – I need to reduce cost, this requires efficiency gains, efficiency gains require investments… • Structural Inflexibility – Your current business and application architecture may not allow for simple and low cost ICT changes • Time to Benefit – Most “quick-wins” have already been explored over the last couple of years. Major initiatives have pay-backs seldom shorter than 24 – 36 months • Business vs. IT Projects – Most projects are invisible to the normal business users and do not directly contribute to business revenue generation • Capacity & Know-How – Are there sufficient internal resources available to drive the change in a timely fashion? Will heavy external resource usage kill the business case? • Change Capacity – Can the internal organization absorb this change now (ex. Overall moral, unions, etc.) • Sustainability – Can initiatives be maintained in light of business development? © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Procurement, Financing & Quick Wins Head Count & Infrastructure Improvement Reduce External Services € Change Application & Technology Architecture ILLUSTRATIVE 6 Months ICT Budget - Illustrative - 12 Months 18 Months 24 Months 30 Months 36 Months Business Projects 20 % SWR & NSWR 10 % Discretionary Maintenance 15 % Operate & Infrastructure 45% Fixed Manage & Support 10 % 21 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING Understand Partner Constraints Criteria Assessment Financials • Service providers are mainly driven by volume, and to a lesser extend by margin and margin composition Duration of Contract • 3 years is standard, but will not allow time for fundamental transformations. • 5 years gives more room for change Scope of Technology & Services • In how far can the existing park be integrated into provider’s infrastructure & skill pool Demand Stability • In how far can demand for service delivery be accurately assessed? Scope of Control • How much insight & governance control does the client want to exert? Which service model will prevail? Transformation Potential • What are the potential synergies in terms of people, processes, infrastructure etc. What are the hand-back constraints? How will benefits be shared? Follow-up Business • What else might be offered to the client (ex. Business process outsourcing?) … … © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 22 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING Approach to Outsourcing Transformation Decision Mobilize and design Implementation Supplier selection Transition Transformation IT Opportunity Assessment Assess current environment Define Target Model and sourcing strategy Create change program Outsourcing Assess Current Environment Define Target Model and sourcing strategy “What needs to change?” “What must we change to?” Kickoff Timeframe High Level Activities Half-day Executive Workshop Create Programs Executive Meeting • Baseline the business and operating direction and strategy as applicable • From workshop, identify and build out “to-be” state • Benchmark expenses to similar industry segments across functions/processes • Define future sourcing strategy • Identify initial areas of cost savings and prioritize based on future direction • Identify 4-5 areas for focused planning • Identify Infrastructure & Operations management and organization impacts and corresponding risks • Interview key stakeholders • Understand key drivers of resource utilization to set a baseline and construct an economic model • Plan and develop material for executive workshop © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. “How will we implement the changes?” Decision • Develop high-level implementation roadmaps based on approved target operating model and sourcing strategy • Identify key stakeholders and related action plan • Define economic model for the integrated change program 23 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING Assess Operating Model Impact CLIENT EXAMPLE Application Development Management (ADM): Split-up of work steps In-house / Off-shore Outsourcing / On-shore Outsourcing / Off-shore In-house / On-shore Maintanance Development 10% Business Requirements 100% Resources on-site Concept 20% Functional Design 30% Design 40% Requirements refinement/design control 25% Acceptance test 5% Deployment 20% 30% 75% 40% Requirements, Functional Design and Acceptance 80% Build 70% Test Deploy 30% Detailed Design Technical Design 70% 25% Enhancements Product test Integration test and fixing Deployment assistance Offshore resources onshore Build, test and implementation 70% 10% Acceptance and Implementation 20% Technical Upgrades 80% 10% Acceptance and Implementation 20% Performance Tuning 80% 40% Prioritization, Escalation 20% Fix on Fail 80% © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Majority of build offshore Technical changes, as requested, assuming no new functionality Fixes and root cause analysis 2nd level support 24 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING Do not forget TUPE • TUPE stands for The Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 1981. The Regulations were introduced to safeguard employees’ rights in the event of a transfer of an undertaking, business or part of a business. This includes: – The obligation to inform and consult all employees in scope transfer – Transferee inherits all claims and statutory rights – Continuity of employment is preserved for employees – Employees transfer on their existing terms and conditions of employment – Transfer connected dismissals are automatically unfair © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 25 PREPARING FOR OUTSOURCING Key Data Components “How will we implement the changes?” Inadequate Best Practice Fundamental issues in the partnership between IT and the business Strategy Development & Planning Inadequate Best Practice Highly reactive organisation, unintegrated silos, limited coherence of vision Architecture Management Inadequate Best Practice Beyond a few well-intentioned individuals, there is little evidence of architecture leadership Solutions Development & Planning Inadequate Best Practice Major issues recognised; but change is hugely challenging. There is still a lack of partnership between SC and ISSM Service Delivery Inadequate Best Practice Legacy is reasonably stable - but are we ready for “e”? Resource Management Inadequate Best Practice Some poor financial controls; cultural issues inhibit getting best value from IT people. Governance Supports Allina Experience Improve Internal Information Improve Community Information Improve Provider Information L M M H L M L L M L H H H L M M M M L Sell Products and Services 3.1 Enable electronic enrollment… 3.2 Assemble member-unique benefits… 3.3 Manage workflow electronically… 3.4 Reinvent broker value chain… 3.5 Improve automation of buyer contracts… 3.6 Enhance underwriting capability… 3.7 Improve SSS functionality… 3.8 Enhance employer group reporting… 0.5 - 2 1 - 2 1 1 - 3 0.25 - 0.5 0.5 - 1 0.5 - 1 0.25 - 0.5 12 18 9 18 9 9 6 6 H H L H L L L L M H M H L M M L M M L H M H L L H H H H H M M H L L L L L L L L M L H M M M H H H H H M M L L L 0.1 - 0.3 0.1 - 0.3 1 - 3 0.1 - 0.3 0.5 - 1 0.5 - 1.5 0.5 - 1.5 0.5 - 1.5 3 6 18 6 9 12 12 18 L L M H H L M M L M H L M M H H M M H L M H L H L M L L M M H M M M H H M M L H M M M M H L M M H H M M H M H M 0.5 - 1 0.5 - 2 1 - 3 0.5 - 1.5 0.5 - 1 0.25 - 0.5 0.1 - 0.3 12 12 18 12 9 6 6 L L L M L L L H L H M M L L M L M M H M L L M M M L H L L L L L L L L L H H H M L H L L H L L H L Support Relationship Building and Management 6.1 Automate appeal/complaint process… 6.3 Create proactive intervention facility… 6.5 Develop life care plans for members… 6.6 Improve information distribution… 6.7 Improve access to compliance data… 6.8 Improve performance reporting capabilities… 6.9 Improve Q-Star stability… 6.10 Roll out HealthVillage… 6.11 Develop common call center infrastructure… 0.1 - 0.2 0.5 - 1 1 - 2 0.1 - 1.5 0.1 - 0.2 0.1 - 0.5 0.1 - 0.3 1 1 - 1.5 9 12 18 9 6 6 6 12 12 L M H L L L L L L L M H M L M L L L L M M L L L L L M M H H M L M H H M L M H L L L L L L L H M H H H M H L M H H L L L M H M Manage Infrastructure 7.5 Enhance communication through entire system… 7.6 Turn our data into revenue… 7.7 Solve help desk responsiveness issues… 0.1 - 0.1 0.5 - 1 0.1 - 0.3 3 6 6 L M L L M M L H L L L H L L L H L M L M L 2001 2003 913 As Is SD Budget Baseline (B) Adjustments due to Price/Performance evolution (C) Potential savings from infrastructure 3 28 (D) Other savings opportunities 0 10 934 875 (E)= (A)-(B)-(C)(D) To Be Operational costs Improve Clinical Quality Revenue Generation 2002 937 (A) 2004 925 Match with Allina IT Focus H L L H M L L L L L L L 2005 940 940 85 129 129 40 50 50 800 761 761 Included in (A) 35 74 70 40 19 (G)=(E)+(F) Total Costs 969 949 870 801 780 (H) = (A) (G) Cash Flow -32 -36 55 139 160 (H) = (A) (G) Cumulative Cash Flow -32 -68 -13 126 286 Total Revenue 937 903 903 894 894 Cash Flow -32 -46 33 93 114 Cumulative Cash Flow -32 -78 -46 48 162 (F) (I) (J)=(I)-(G) (K) © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Improve Customer Information L L L M L M L H H M M H Improve Health Outcomes L M L M L M M L L H H L Improve Provider Service M M H H L M L L M H M L Medical Cost Mgmt. L L L H L M M M M H H L Administrative Cost Mgmt. L L M H L 6 3 9 9 12 12 6 (M $) Current Infrastructure and Operations Balanced Membership Growth 12 12 6 6 3 0.3 - 0.5 0.1 - 0.2 0.2 - 0.5 0.5 - 1 1 - 1.5 0.5 - 1 0.3 - 0.5 Deliver Administrative Products and Services 5.1 Create reimbursement modeling system… 5.4 Stabilize key system availability and performance… 5.5 Create business-specific data warehouses… 5.6 Increase electronic claims submission… 5.7 Implement utilization management tools… 5.8 Improve referral/authorization/precerts… 5.10 Improve COSMOS management reporting… External Point-of-View Executive Review 0.1 - 0.2 0.1 - 0.2 0.5 - 1 0.5 - 1 0 Manage Delivery Capacity 2.1 Support pull-through strategy… 2.2 Better manage provider contract terms… 2.3 Model provider locations… 2.4 Track contracts more closely… 2.5 Innovate new reimbursement models… 2.6 Roll out provider profiling… 2.7 Enhance Q-Star to support providers Deliver Health Care Products and Services 4.1 Coordinate health improvement initiatives… 4.2 Triage members and channel them… 4.3 Develop outcomes management strategy… 4.4 Enable doctors to perform HRAs… 4.5 Develop Proactive Interventions… 4.6 Improve case management capability… 4.7 Better match transitions and transactions across Allina… 4.8 Improve disease management capability… Gap Analysis Allina Barriers to Change Summary of Issues Information Length of Project (months) Operations Maturity Model™ Performance Health Project Cost Range (Early estimate in Millions) IT Capability Service Develop Products and Services 1.1 Predict local market changes… 1.2 Assess internal execution capabilities… 1.3 Design more flexible products… 1.4 Segment population better… 1.5 Communicate during product development… Business Process Area / Change Initiatives Summary of IT Capabilities (Summer 2000) Risk of Ability to Implement Margin/Growth Target Operating Model Improve Employee Service Financial Analysis “What must we change to?” Improve Customer Service “What needs to change?” Organization and One-Time Costs 26 Agenda • Introduction to Outsourcing • Preparing for Outsourcing • Running Outsourcing • Next Steps in Outsourcing © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 27 RUNNING OUTSOURCING Framework Key Principles Common Objectives & Goals • Delivery Model is based on several key components Governance • Common objectives & goals • End-to-End governance structure Contract, SLA, OLA, KPI, MBO Methods, Standards, and Tools LOCAL Common Processes Projects Reporting & Status Tracking • Multi-level team organisation SPOC NEAR-SHORE SPOC OFF-SHORE • Leveraged core competencies and skills • Formalised SLAs, OLAs, KPIs • Forum for engaging multiple sources in the key processes of communication, coordination and integration • Optimize global resources • Encourage collaborative working • Leverage technology to enable business strategy Client Accenture Skill Pool © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. AMP +… • Establishes a single point of responsibility for entire relationship. 28 RUNNING OUTSOURCING Common Objectives & Goals © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 29 RUNNING OUTSOURCING Standard Methodology & Tools PLAN SUPPORT TOOLS ANALYZE DESIGN AAB IT & Security Policies & Standards SDM Estimator Deliverables Library & Template SBP Standards & Methods Project Deliverables Repository SBP Configuration Manual Accenture Knowledge Exchange © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. BUILD TEST DEPLOY 30 RUNNING OUTSOURCING Common Organization Model Joint Management Sample Local Deployment Teams Local Deployment Team Development Center Service Mgt & Support Office Local Project Manager Off-Site Coordinator Business Lead (Change Manager) Unit Manager Staff Functions Deployment Support Team Solution Delivery Team Functional Architect Technical Architect & Associate Manager Configuration Specialists Table Management & Application Customization Gap Management Mercator Application Integration Team Local Design & Acceptance Team Conversion Lead Operational Readiness Lead Data Migration Team Conversion Support Team Documentation Vendors Near Off Other © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Data Migration & Deployment Tools Service Delivery Partner Application Management Partner Test & Release Team Test Team Release Management Development Support Team Environment & Dev Tool Mgt. Configuration Management Client IT Security, Audit & Compliance 31 RUNNING OUTSOURCING Common Processes Local Near-Shore Off-Shore Scope Work-Stream Config. Components Configuration Workshops & Detailed Specification Management Sign Off Support & QA Specifications TP Perform Detailed Configuration Design & Prepare Work Package Functional Design Check List TP Technical Review & Interface Impact Analysis Technical Design Check List Build (Configure & Code) Support Build Process Prepare UAT Product & User Acceptance Test Support Build & Validate Test TP © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. Component Test & Documentation Work Package Check List Product Delivery Check List QA Solution Prepare Assembly & NonRegression Test TP TP Component & Quality Check Lists Execute Assembly & NonRegression Test 32 Agenda • Introduction to Outsourcing • Preparing for Outsourcing • Running Outsourcing • Next Steps in Outsourcing © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 33 Next Steps in Outsourcing • Outsourcing will continue to grow, mainly for BPO… • Services will become more standardized, creating new norms • New service providers will appear in Eastern Europe and China • Asian players will move on-shore and compete head-on with traditional local players • Local regulations will continue to be opened up to support cross-border services • Politics will start to address increasing social issues and concerns © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 34 Questions ? © 2005 Accenture All Rights Reserved. 35