GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC) GENERAL BIBLIOGRAPHY: Berard, C., et.al., A City of Images (1989). – iconography and iconology, typical of the French school approach Boardman, J., The History of Greek Vases. Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) – thematic approach Boardman, J., Athenian Red Figure Vases: The Archaic Period (1985) – brief text, very useful images Boardman, J., Athenian Red-Figure Vases: The Classical Period (1989) - same Carpenter, T.H., Art and Myth in Ancient Greece (1991). Good introduction to Greek myths with many images Cook, R.M., Greek Painted Pottery (ed. 3) (1997). Denoyelle, M. & M. Lozzo, La céramique grecque d'Italie méridionale et de Sicile: productions coloniales et apparentées du VIIIe au IIIe siècle av. J.-C. Manuels d'Art et d'Archéologie antiques (Paris: Picard, 2009) – the most up-to-date introduction to western Greek pottery styles Lissarrague, F. Greek Vases: The Athenians and Their Images (New York 2001) – emphasis on iconography, typical of the French School/approach Oakley, J.H., ‘Greek Vase Painting. State of the Discipline’ American Journal of Archaeology 113 (2009) 599-627. Article reviewing advances in the study of vase painting with much recent bibliography, available in JSTOR Richter, G.M.A., Attic Red-Figure Vases: A Survey (1958). – out-of-date but still useful Robertson, M., The Art of Vase-painting in Classical Athens (1992). – detailed discussion of vase-painters and their style Simon, E., Griechische Vasen (1981) –good quality illustrations. Sparkes, B.A., Greek Pottery, An Introduction (1991). – excellent introduction to the topic Sparkes, B.A., The Red and the Black. Studies in Greek Pottery (1996). Trendall, A.D., Red-figure Vases of South Italy and Sicily (1989). – on south Italian wares Woodford, S., Images of Myths in Classical Antiquity (Cambridge UP 2002). SHAPES & NAMES Richter, G.M.A. and Milne, M.J., Shapes and Names of Athenian Vases (1935). – still the most useful book on the subject Kanowski, M.G., Containers of Classical Greece (St. Lucia, 1984) Sparkes, B.A. and Talcott, L., Black and Plain Pottery of the 6th, 5th and 4th centuries BC., The Athenian Agora XII (1970). Shapes of everyday pottery- mostly black-glaze from the Athenian Agora Tsingarida, A. (ed.), Shapes and Uses of Greek Vases (7th-4th centuries B.C.). . Proceedings of the Symposium held at the Université de Bruxelles, 27-29 April 2006. Études d'Archéologie 3. (Brussels 2009) – collection of articles on specific shapes & their use TECHNIQUES: Cohen, B., Jones, R.E., Koch-Brinkmann, U., Lapatin, K. (ed.), The Colors of Clay: Special Techniques in Athenian Vases (Malibu 2006) - exhibition catalogue of recent exhibition at the Getty with great pictures and good introductory texts Greek and Cypriot Pottery, a Review of Scientific Studies (1986) Polychrome Bilder auf weissgrundigen Lekythen: Zeugen der klassischen griechischen Malerei. (Munich 1999): for images of colour on w-g lekythoi Papers on Special Techniques in Athenian Vases (Malibu 2008) – various articles on special techniques Noble, J.V., The Techniques of Attic Painted Pottery (1966) – the classic, well illustrated guide Schreiber, T., Athenian Vase Construction (1999) – complements Noble CONNOISSEURSHIP: Beazley, J.D., ‘Citharoedus’, Journal of Hellenic Studies 42 (1922) 70-98 Beazley, J.D., The Kleophrades Painter (1933 and 1974). Kurtz, D.C.K, ‘Beazley and the connoisseurship of Greek Vases’ Greek Vases in the J. Paul Getty Museum 2 (1983) 237-250. on Beazley method Oakley, J.H., Whitley, J. ‘Why Study a Greek Vase-Painter?—A Response to Whitley’s ‘Beazley as Theorist.’ Antiquity 72 (1998) 209–213 ‘Adopting an Approach’, in Rasmussen, T and Spivey, N (eds.), Looking at Greek Vases (Cambridge, 1991) 1-12 Approaches to the study of Attic vases: Beazley and Pottier (Oxford, 2001) ‘Beazley as Theorist’, Antiquity 71 (1997) 40–47. CATALOGUES: Corpus Vasorum Antiquorum (www.cvaonline.org) Robertson, C.M., Rouet, P., CHRONOLOGY: Cook, R.M. ‘The Francis-Vickers Chronology’, JHS 109 (1989) 164-170 Francis, E.D., and M. Vickers. ‘The Agora Revisited: Athenian Chronology c. 500–450 B.C.’, BSA 83 (1988) 143–67 Shear, T.L., Jr. ‘The Persian Destruction of Athens: Evidence from Agora Deposits’, Hesperia 62 (1993) 383–482 TRADE & DISTRIBUTION: Osborne, R. ‘Pots, Trade and the Archaic Greek Economy’ Antiquity 70 (1986) 31-44 Osborne, R. ‘Why Did Athenian Pots Appeal to the Etruscans?’ WorldArch 33 (2001) 277–95 Reusser, C., Vasen für Etrurien: Verbreitung und Funktionen attischer Keramik im Etrurien des 6. und 5. Jahrhunderts v. Chr. (Zurich 2002) – the best account & interpretation of Attic pottery in Etruria Rouillard, P., and A. Le vase grec et ses destins (Munich 2003) – collection of articles focusing on vases in context Villanueva Puig, M.-C., F.. Lissarrague, P. Rouillard, and A. Rouveret (eds), Céramique et peinture grecques: Modes d’emploi. Actes du colloque international, École du Louvre, 26–27–28 avril 1995. (Paris 1999) Paléothodoros, D. “Commercial Networks in the Mediterranean and the Diffusion of Early Attic Red-Figure Pottery (525–490 BCE).” Mediterranean Historical Review 22(2) (2007) 165–82 COLLECTIONS OF ARTICLES: Brijder, H.A.G. (ed), Ancient Greek and Related Pottery (Amsterdam 1984). Christiansen, J. and Melander, T. (edd), Ancient Greek and Related Pottery (Copenhagen 1988). Giudice, F., and R. Panvini, eds. 2003-7. Il greco, il barbaro e la ceramica attica: Immaginario del diverso, processi di scambio e autorappresentazione degli indigeni (Rome: L’Erma di Bretschneider) – articles in Italian but also other languages on various aspects of production and iconography Marconi, C. (ed.), Greek Vases: Images, Contexts and Controversies (Leiden 2004) Moon, W.G. (ed), Ancient Greek Art and Iconography (1983) Neils, J. (ed), Goddess and Polis (1992). On Panathenaia and Panathenaic amphorae Oakley, J.H., W.D.E. Coulson, and O. Palagia (eds), Athenian Potters and Painters: The Conference Proceedings (Oxford 1997) Oakley, J.H., and O. Palagia (eds), Athenian Potters and Painters. Vol. 2. (Oxford 2009). Rasmussen, T. and Spivey, N. (eds), Looking at Greek Vases (1991). Schmaltz, B., and M. Söldner (eds), Griechische Keramik im kulturellen Kontext: Akten des Internationalen Vasen- Symposions in Kiel vom 24. bis 28.9.2001 veranstaltet durch das Archäologische Institut der ChristianAlbrechts-Universität zu Kiel. Münster: 2003 EARLY RED FIGURE: Williams, D., ‘Vase-Painting in fifth-century Athens, I. The invention of the redfigure technique and the race between vase painting and free painting’ in T. Rasmussen and N. Spivey, Looking at Greek Vases (Cambridge 1991) 103-118. (for the Pioneers) Rotroff, S. “Early Red-Figure in Context.” In Athenian Potters and Painters. Vol. 2, edited by J.H. Oakley and O. Palagia, (Oxford 2009) 250-60. GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 1: Setting the picture: Techniques, Methods & Approaches, Dating Methods and Approaches: i. Technique: making, decorating, firing in the kiln ii. Shapes and uses: (recently conference by Tsingarida) III. Decoration: Style -- J.D. Beazley (1885-1970) & Connoisseurship: attribution to vase-painters iv. Francis and Vickers: pottery as imitation of metal vessels; proposed review of chronology. iii. Iconology & Iconography – City of Images & the Paris-Lausanne School: use of anthropology and structural linguistics to interpret images. Imagery as a system of communication that reveal Athenian values v. Provenance: study of trade/distribution patterns (Reusser; Marconi) vi. Scientific Analysis vii. Reception ‘SIGNATURES’: a) Egrapsen: wrote or drew (painter) b) epoiesen: made (potter or workshop owner) DATING: Absolute and Relative chronology Absolute: A. Scientific methods B. Archaeological-Historical: (relation to other better dated cultures/Egypt; information about colonies’ foundations; Some Externally Dated monuments 1. Before 525 SIPHNIAN TREASURY, DELPHI Marble caryatids, friezes, pediment Herodotus 3.57-58 (date); Pausanias 10.11.2 (identification of building) 2. Before 480 PERSIAN SACK, ACROPOLIS Votive marbles (esp. korai) and other material Herodotus, 8.53 (480 BC) and 9.3 (479 BC) 3. Before 478 THEMISTOCLEAN WALL, ATHENS Funerary stelai and relief bases re-used as building material Thucydides 1.90-93 4. 477/6 TYRANNICIDES, ATHENIAN AGORA Public bronze monument to Harmodios and Aristogeiton, known in Roman scale versions in marble Marmor Parium: FGH IIB 239 A54 (precise date); Pausanias 1.8.5 (location) 5. 478 or 474 CHARIOTEER, DELPHI Fragmentary bronze chariot group, victory dedication of Polyzalos of Gela Inscription: Fouilles de Delphes IV.5.267 6. 470-457 TEMPLE OF ZEUS, OLYMPIA Marble metopes, frieze and pediment groups Pausanias 5.10.2-10; Meiggs-Lewis 36 7. 447-432 PARTHENON, ACROPOLIS Marble metopes, frieze, and pediment groups IG I.13 436-51; Meiggs-Lewis 59 (inscribed accounts) 12 438/7 ATHENA PARTHENOS STATUE Known in reduced Roman versions, shield in scale versions Philochoros, FGH 328 F121 (dedication date); Meiggs-Lewis 54 (accounts). 13 425 PURIFICATION OF DELOS The grave assemblages of Delos buried in large pits on the island of Rheneia Thuc. iii.104; Diod. Xii 59.6-7 14 424 Grave of the Fallen at Delion, at Thespies 15 394/3 DEXILEOS’ GRAVESTONE – Epigram IG II-III 6127 RED FIGURE A. Definition Red figure technique: inversion of Black-figure. Figures are left in the colour of the clay and the background is blacked in. Details are put with a brush (or other instrument allowing for a fluid line) instead of graver. Steps: i. Preliminary sketch (as slight indentations along the lines of the figures, or diverging from them), and ii. outline of all the figures with a band of black: the ‘eight-of-an-inch-strip’: allows the painter to see the background. iii. Three stage firing process: a) Initial oxidizing stage, rich in air, allowed minerals in both the clay pots and the slip on their surfaces to form compounds yielding a reddish-orange colorations (iron hematite) b) Second, reducing phase: depleted of air – oxygen – introduction of organic material: the red orange compounds converted to black (rich in iron magnetite). In this phase: the blackcoloured gloss from the slip had sintered and become impermeable, losing its ability to be altered. c) Third, oxidizing stage: reintroduction of air/oxygen rich environment – still porous surfaces reabsorb oxygen and revert to red orange. The pots returned to red but the gloss, now in almost glassy state, remained black. B. Causes & ‘Inventors’: a) internal necessity of art/craft – easier to convey narrative, emotion when drawing with a brush than graver. b) Vickers: imitation of metal vessels: silver with gold figures c) Imitation of colour schemes of reliefs: light coloured images in dark background d) Part of the experimentation in the Kerameikos: Six’s technique – Nikosthenes, Psiax, Sappho & Diosphos Painters Coral Red – Exekias (540s), Kachrylion & Euphronios, Oltos, White-ground – Nikosthenes’ workshop? Psiax. SOME NAMES: Andokides Painter: c. 530-515 BC –First to use red-figure regularly; collaborates with potter Andokides. Many bilingual amphorae of type A bilingual amphorae of Type A (the black-figure side probably drawn by another painter: ascribed by Beazley to Lysippides Painter). Psiax: experimentation with techniques, mostly works in black-figure; some of the earliest red-figure Worked with potters Menon, Hilinos, Andokides and Nikosthenes. Nikosthenes: pottery for Etruria; special shapes; numerous techniques Epiktetos and Oltos: bilingual eye cups GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 2: Vase painting in late 6th century Athens: The Pioneers, c. 520-500/490 BC Some suggested reading: Boardman, J., The History of Greek Vases. Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) Boardman, J., Athenian Red Figure Vases: The Archaic Period (1985) Euphronios und seine Zeit: Kolloquium in Berlin 19./10. April 1991 anlässlich der Ausstellung Euphronios, der Maler. Staatliche Museen zu Berlin (Berlin 1992) Euphronios, der Maler: eine Ausstellung in der Sonderausstellungshalle der Staatlichen Museen Preußischer Kulturbesitz Berlin-Dahlem, 20. März–26. Mai 1991 (Fabbri, Milan 1991) – exhibition catalogue – useful for images Himmelmann, N., ‘Narrative and Figure in Archaic Art’ in W. Childs (ed.), Reading Greek Art: Essays by N. Himmelmann (Princeton 1998) 67-102: on synthetic narrative – very useful Lynch, K., The Symposium in Context: pottery from a late archaic house near the Agora (Athens 2011) – investigation on sympotic ware found in a late archaic house in Athens; very careful discussion of pottery in context Murray, O. (ed), Sympotica: A symposium on the symposion (Oxford 1990) – useful on all aspects of the symposion Neer, R., Style and Politics in Athenian Vase-Painting: The Craft of Democracy, 530-460 BC (Cambridge 2002). Robertson, M., The Art of Vase-painting in Classical Athens (Cambridge 1992). Schefold, K., Gods and Heroes in Late Archaic Art (Cambridge 1992) Williams, D., ‘Vase-Painting in fifth-century Athens, I. The invention of the red-figure technique and the race between vase painting and free painting’ in T. Rasmussen and N. Spivey (eds.), Looking at Greek Vases (Cambridge 1991) 103-118. Williams, D., ‘The Drawing of the human figure on early red-figure vases’ in D. Buitron-Oliver (ed.), New Perspectives in Early Greek Art (Washington 1991) 285-302. GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 2: Vase painting in late 6th century Athens: The Pioneers, c. 520-500 BC 1. THE PIONEERS: Euphronios 1. Calyx crater in Paris (Louvre G103): Herakles and Antaios 2. Calyx crater, formerly in New York: A: Sleep and Death carry the body of Sarpedon, B: Youths arming 3. Calyx crater in Munich (Antikensammlungen 8935): Symposium 4. Calyx crater in Berlin (Altes Museum): Athletes training 5. Calyx crater signed by Euphronios (New York, Shelby White Leon Levy collection): Herakles and Kyknos 6. Signed psykter (St Petersburg, Hermitage 644): hetairai at the symposium Phintias 1. Neck hydria in Munich (Antikensammlungen 2421): Shoulder: Hetairai playing kottabos (one toasts Euthymides). Body: Music lesson (youth with lyre named Euthymides) 2. Psykter from Orvieto (Boston, MFA 01.819): Athletes wrestling, trainers, acontists 3. Amphora Type A from Vulci in Paris (Louvre G 42): A: Abduction of Leto by the giant Tityos; B: Athletes training 4. Hydria signed by Phintias as painter, from Vulci (London BM E159): Shoulder: men reclining at symposion. Body: Men at the fountain 5. Phintias, Neck hydria in Munich: Shoulder: Satyrs; Body: komos Euthymides 1. Amphora Type A from Vulci, (Munich J378): A: Hector arming between Priam and Hecuba; b) Komasts 2. Amphora Type A from Vulci signed by Euthymides as painter (Munich, J374) : Youth (Thorykeion) arming between two archers 3. Amphora Type A (Munich J410) A: Theseus abducting Helen; B: Man & two women fleeing (Korone, Antiopeia) Smikros 1. Stamnos in Brussels (A717): Symposium 2. Neck amphora in Berlin (signs as painter): satyrs CUP PAINTERS: Onesimos: 1. RF cup from Cerveteri in Paris (Louvre G104). Interior: Theseus and Amphitrite; Exterior: deeds of Theseus (Euphronios as potter; attributed to Onesimos) 2. Cup showing The Sack of Troy in the interior: (formerly in Los Angeles, Malibu). Inscription: Euphronios epoiesen, drawing attributed to Onesimos Peithinos: Cup in B Berlin: Interior: Peleus abducting Thetis; Exterior: Men and women in embrace 2. TECHNIQUE: full potential of R-F – use of relief line, dilute wash/line 3. STYLE: • interest in anatomy, depicting human form in challenging poses • Monumental compositions 4. SHAPES: large pots: amphorae Type A, Calyx craters, psykters (wine coolers), pelikai 5. INSCRIPTIONS: • Pioneers sign their vases as painters and most as potters too • they acknowledge each other in their works, putting each other’s names on their vases • Kalos names – Leagros SUBJECTS: Myth: Trojan circle, Herakles, Dionysus, Theseus ‘High Life’: the world of the palaestra and the world of the symposium GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 3: Late Archaic: c. 500-470 BC READING: Beazley, J.D., The Berlin Painter (1932 and 1974). Beazley, J.D., The Kleophrades Painter (1933 and 1974). Boardman, J., Athenian Red Figure Vases: The Archaic Period (1985) – brief text, very useful images Buitron-Oliver, D., Douris: A Master-painter of Athenian Red-figure Vases (Mainz 1995) Cambitoglou, A., The Brygos Painter (1968). Cohen, B., The Colors of Clay: Special Techniques in Athenian Vases (Malibu 2006) -for w-g, relief vases and rhyta Kunisch, N., Makron. Kerameus 10. (Mainz 1997) Kurtz, D.C.K, The Berlin Painter (1989). Mertens, J., Attic White Ground-its development on shapes other than lekythoi (1977). Murray, O. (ed), Sympotica: A symposium on the symposion (Oxford 1990) – useful on all aspects of the symposion Neer, R., Style and Politics in Athenian Vase-Painting: The Craft of Democracy, 530-460 BC (Cambridge 2002). Robertson, M., The Art of Vase-painting in Classical Athens (Cambridge 1992). Schefold, K., Gods and Heroes in Late Archaic Art (Cambridge 1992) GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). LATE ARCHAIC: Lecture 3: Late Archaic: c. 500-480/470 BC General features: Simplification of technique, except for use of white ground Growing realisation of how objects in the round can be rendered in linear style Less attention to minor anatomical details; more interest in pose and composition Dress: stack of folds with neat zig-zag hems; less angular patterns than in earlier period Foreshortening of objects and occasionally heads Subsidiary decoration: nearly all red figure. Maeander bands as borders become frequent. Shapes: as before; new in popularity: small Nolan amphora; pelikai. New range of figure scenes 1. KLEOPHRADES PAINTER: (c. 505-475 BC) Name from potter Kleophrades (son of Amasis) who signs two cups in Paris, 50 cm wide (‘parade cups’). Technique: Both R-F and BL-FG (Panathenaic amphorae; loutrophoroi) Style: Early on: close to Euthymides (shapes, composition, drawing); Typical for: statuesque figures – interest in full compositions, action scenes. Details: incised hair contours; eyes open in front, often with pupil painted brown; S-curve for nostrils; often outlined lips Shapes: Amphorae Type A (early), craters, amphorae; pelikai, stamnoi, kalpides-hydriae Themes: Early: Dionysiac and komos themes; later: genre and athletic. Myths: interest in Theseus, Herakles; especially Trojan Circle (Iliad). Some vases: 1. Vivenzio hydria-kalpis (Naples, Archaeological Museum): Sack of Troy 2. Pointed amphora from Vulci in Munich. H: 56 cm. Neck: athletes. Body: Dionysiac scene 3. Calyx crater from Vulci (Paris, Louvre): Return of Hephaistos 4. Stamnos from Vulci in London (BM E441). A: Theseus and Prokroustes. B: Theseus and Minotaur 5. Amphora of the Panathenaic shape in Boston (MFA): A: youth with wreath. B) youth with stick, hare and fillets 6. Neck amphora from Vulci in London (BM E270): A: Draped man singing. Inscriptions: HODE POT EN TYRINTHI; KALOS EI. B: Youth playing pipes; music contest? 2. BERLIN PAINTER: 500-460s More than 300 vases attributed to him. Shapes: Amphorae (belly: type A & C; neck-amphorae and later: Nolan amphorae and of Panathenaic shape); volute and bell craters; stamnoi; pelikai; hydriae; lekythoi; oinochoai Characteristic maeander border: paired units interrupted by boxed X’s or chequer. Style: emphasis on accuracy of drawing and perfection of lines; Lighter figure- carefully drawn, subtle use of relief line; interest in combining two figures in one contour. Details: dot rosette nipples; triangles in linear patterns on chests; blond boys; feel in ¾ views from front and back; dot on circle earrings for women; Dress: from archaic stacked folds to all over verticals Favourite figure scheme: single figures on either side of the vase (even when action continues); reduction of subsidiary ornament Themes: less adventurous than Kleophrades P: genre scenes; Olympians; Nikai; animal studies Some vases: 1. Name vase: amphora in Berlin (Antikensammlung): A: Hermes, Satyr and fawn; B: Satyr with kantharos and lyre 2. Bell crater in Paris (Louvre): Ganymede 3. Belly Amphora, Type C in New York, MMA. A: Kitharode; B: Trainer 4. Volute crater from Cerveteri in London, BM. A: Achilles and Hektor between Athena and Apollo. B: Achilles and Memnon between Thetis and Eos 5. Volute crater in Karlsruhe: A. Demeter and Triptolemos 6. Stamnos from Vulci in Paris, Louvre: A: infant Herakles and snakes 7. Hydria- kalpis in Oxford Ashmolean Museum: Europa on the bull 8. Neck amphora in Oxford, Ashmolean: A: Sacrifice; B: athletes? 9. Oinochoe in London (BM ): Nike with incense burner and phiale by altar MYSON: 1. Calyx crater in London BM: A. Struggle for the Delphic tripod. B: Rescue of Aithra 2. Belly amphora in Paris, Louvre: Kroisos on the pyre 3. LATE ARCHAIC CUP PAINTERS: More than 50% of the production of red-figure in early 5th c is on cups Shapes: Type B and C [eye cups go out of fashion] New borders inside the cups: Maeander bands Use of white ground, mainly in the interior of the cups, with drawing in the outline technique. Themes: Dionysiac, Symposia, genre, erotica, Myth (Theseus, Trojan Circle) BRYGOS PAINTER: 480s-470s Named after potter Brygos who signs about 11 cups. Over 200 vases attributed to Brygos P. Shapes: kylikes type B & C; also: skyphoi, head kantharoi, rhyta; lekythoi. RF & white-ground. Expressive figures . Symposia and athlete scenes with portrayal of everyday gestures. Heads: flat tops, high brows, narrow eyes, long nose line; often hairy chests for men; shading in shields and objects. Original myth scenes: Ajax and Tekmessa; Ransom of Hector; Quarrel over armour of Achilles. Some Vases: 1. Skyphos in Vienna (Kunsthistorisches Museum): Ransom of Hector 2. R-F cup in the Louvre: Exterior: Sack of Troy. Tondo: Briseis & Phoinix 3. Cup (Type B) in Malibu. ‘Tondo: Tekmessa and Ajax. Exterior B: vote for the weapons of Achilles; A: Fight over the armour of Achilles 4. W-G Oinochoe in London, BM: Woman spinning 5. Kylix in Munich. Exterior: Dionysos and his Circle. Interior (w-g): Maenad dancing 6. Kylix in Würzburg. Exterior: komos. Tondo: youth vomiting 7. Cup in London (BM E68): Symposium DOURIS: c. 500-460 Some 300 vases survive; 39 signed by him as painter; one as potter. Collaborates with potter Python. Kalos names: Chairestratos; Hippodamas Shapes: kylikes; an aryballos; lekythoi; psykter; rhyta R-F and W-G Slim, round-headed figures; transparent drapery; thick black hemlines; interest in back view of symposiasts; Scenes: drinking parties; youths & athletes; warriors; school; studies of women. Myth: some original scenes (dragon regurgitating Jason) Some Vases: 1. Kylix in London (BM E49). Exterior: symposium. Tondo: komast 2. Cup in Florence: Exterior : symposion. Tondo : Single symposiast 3. W-G lekythos with outline drawing, Los Angeles, Malibu. Two youths are arming in the presence of a boy & woman 4. Signed psykter from Caere in London BM: Satyrs 5. Cup in Berlin (Antikensammlungen): school scene 6. Cup from Vulci in London (BM): Tondo: woman in interior space (couch, kalathos (wool basket) mirror). Exterior: A: men and women interacting. B: Youths and women (hetairai?) 7. Signed cup in Boston (MFA): Eros & youth 8. Kylix (Type C) in Paris (Louvre), signed by Douris as Painter & Kalliades as potter. Tondo: Eos and Memnon. Exterior: A: Duel of Paris and Menelaos; B: Hektor vs Ajax 9. Cup from Vulci, London (BM): Deeds of Theseus, c. 480 BC MAKRON: 480s-470s. More than 350 vases attributed survive. Works with potter Hieron. Skyphoi Heavy figures; low brow; detailed decoration; careful rendering of female dress; Mostly myth (Trojan circle); genre scenes; Dionysiac; symposium. 1. Skyphos signed by Makron (painter) and Hieron (potter), from “Brygos Tomb” today in London (BM). A) Triptolemos; B) Gathering of gods 2. Skyphos from tomb at Suessula (signed by Makron and Hieron) in Boston (MFA). A) Paris leading away Helen from Sparta. B) Menelaos and Helen at Troy 3. RF cup in Berlin, Makron (painter) and Hieron (potter): Exterior: Cult of Dionysos. Tondo: Dionysos and Satyr 4. RF Cup in Boston, MFA. Tondo: man walking. Exterior: Satyrs and female figure (maenad) 5. Cup in Boston (MFA). Tondo: Man & woman at symposium. Exterior: Men & women conversing (hetairai?) GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 4: Early Classical – High Classical: c. 480/470 BC-430/420 BC General reading: Boardman, J., The History of Greek Vases. Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) – thematic approach Boardman, J., Athenian Red-Figure Vases: The Classical Period (1989) Carpenter, T.H., Art and Myth in Ancient Greece (1991). Good introduction to Greek myths with many images Lissarrague, F. Greek Vases: The Athenians and Their Images (New York 2001) Robertson, M., The Art of Vase-painting in Classical Athens (1992). Simon, E., Griechische Vasen (1981) –good quality illustrations. FURTHER READING: Burn, L., ‘Honey pots. Three White-Group cups by the Sotades Painter’, Antike Kunst 28 (1985) 93-105 Bothmer, D. von Amazons in Greek Art (Oxford 1957) Bundrick, S.D., “The Fabric of the City: Imaging Textile Production in Classical Athens.” Hesperia 77 (2008) 283–334 Castriota, D., Myth, Ethos and Actuality: Official Art in Fifth Century BC Athens (Madison 1992) ch. 2 (Kimonian Athens) Cohen, B., The Colors of Clay: Special Techniques in Athenian Vases (Malibu 2006) - for Sotades and white ground Felten, K.F., Thanatos-und Kleophonmaler: Weissgrundige und rotfigurige Vasenmalerei der Parthenonzeit (Munich 1971): for images of vases of the Kleophon and Thanatos Painters. Kavvadias, G., Ho Zografos tou Sabouroff (Athens 2000): for images of vases by the Sabouroff Painter Koch-Brinkmann, U., Polychrome Bilder auf weissgrundigen Lekythen: Zeugen der klassischen griechischen Malerei. (Munich 1999): for images of colour on w-g lekythoi Kurtz, D.C.K, Athenian White Lekythoi: Patterns and Painters (1975). Kousser, R., ‘The World of Aphrodite in the Late Fifth Century B.C.’ in C. Marconi (ed.), Greek Vases: Images, Contexts and Controversies. Columbia Studies in the Classical Tradition, 25 (Leiden 2004) 97112. Kreilinger, U. “To Be or Not To Be a Hetaira: Female Nudity in Classical Athens.” In Images and Gender: Contributions to the Hermeneutics of Reading Ancient Art, edited by S. Schroer, Orbis Biblicus et Orientalis 220. (Fribourg and Göttingen: 2006) 229–37. Lezzi-Hafner, A. Der Eretria-Maler. (Mainz 1988) – for images of vases by the Eretria Painter Mannack, T. The Late Mannerists in Athenian Vase-Painting (Oxford 2001) Matheson, S.B., Polygnotos and Vase Painting in Classical Athens (University of Wisconsin Press 1995) – On Polygnotos and vase painting in the time of the Parthenon. Mertens, J., Attic White Ground-its development on shapes other than lekythoi (1977). Neer, R., Style and Politics in Athenian Vase-Painting: The Craft of Democracy, 530-460 BC (Cambridge 2002). Oakley, J.H., The Phiale Painter (Mainz 1990) Oakley, J.H., The Achilles Painter (Mainz 1997). Oakley, J.H., Picturing Death in Classical Athens (Cambridge 2005) – on the iconography of white ground lekythoi Shapiro, H.A., “Theseus in Kimonian Athens: The Iconography of Empire”, Mediterranean Historical Review 7 (1992) 29-49 – on Theseus GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 3: Early Classical – High Classical: c. 480/470 BC-430/420 BC EARLY CLASSICAL (c. 480-450 BC): Major painting: Polygnotos from Thasos, Mikon from Athens. Mood: dignified, austere - similar to sculpture (for example: T. of Zeus at Olympia) Dress: looser, more realistic folds; when stack of folds, not zigzag but grouped in parallel lines. Peplos more popular than chiton Anatomy: careful observation of pattern, more impressionistically; eye profile rendered properly with pupil to the front and longer upper lid. Attempt at foreshortening and ¾ views are common Niobid Painter: fine figures; dress and anatomy pattern; monumentality. Epic scenes: Amazons, giants or centaurs; and pursuits, warrior departures. Name vase, calyx crater in Paris (Louvre): influence of wall-painting. (ground lines in white; modest floral embellishment) Some large-figure friezes on single ground line, often encircling the vase: Achilles leaving for Skyros Likes large vases; volute, calyx and bell craters, and some medium-sized such as: pelikai, neckamphorae, hydriai. Splits craters in two 2 narrower friezes: calyx crater in London BM: Birth of Pandora, Satyr dances and Dionysiac themes Painter of Woolly Satyrs: composition with fluctuating ground lines; cut-off figures and Amazonomachies with daring postures. Variable ground lines, and texture of figures Volute crater in New York (MMA): Centauromachy and Amazonomachy P. of Bologna 279: Volute crater from Spina (Ferrara): Above: Herakles and Bousiris; Below: Seven against Thebes Volute Crater in Basel: Symposion; Amazonomachy Pan Painter: conservative, probably trained in the workshop of the Berlin Painter. Mannierist: Name vase: bell crater in Boston, MFA: Pan chasing a youth; Artemis and Aktaion R-F Lekythos, Boston MFA: youth as huntsman Column crater, Naples (Archaeological Museum): Sacrifice scene Hydria-kalpis, London, BM: Perseus and Medusa Villa Giulia Painter: Few craters; mostly pelikai, stamnoi, hydriai. Quiet compositions, harmonious. The reverses: less interesting but more revealing for style of vase painter. Occasionally white-ground. Stamnos in Boston: Worship of Dionysos White Ground Cup: Libation scene Bell crater in London, from Nola: Hermes and infant Dionysos Sabouroff Painter: cup painter: youths and figures. Mostly lekythoi in white ground WG Cup from Vulci in Munich: Hera Pistoxenos Painter: delicacy and quality. Mostly cups, often in white ground with outline drawing. Original story telling. WG cup from Athens, Acropolis: Death of Orpheus WG cup from Locri, Taranto: Maenad and Satyr WG cup from Kameiros, in London BM: Aphrodite on the goose Penthesilea Painter: name vase: influence from Painting (composition fits better on a rectangle; opaque washes of colour). Often careless style, quite miniature in small vessels. Name vase: cup from Vulci in Munich: Achilles and Penthesilea RF cup from Spina in Ferrara: Theseus’ deeds (c. 460-50 BC); Dioskouri W-G pyxis in New York (MMA): Judgement of Paris Hermonax: ‘National myth’ Stamnos in Munich: Birth of Erichthonios Pelike in Villa Giulia: Boreas and Orytheia; Erechtheus and Orytheia Sotades Painter: novelty figure vases with red figure decoration; animal heads; whole figures. fluted phialai. Cups with merry-thought handles decorated by Sotades Painter, in white ground with outline drawing from the so-called Sotades tomb in Athens, bear interesting scenes related. All in London, BM. CLASSICAL: c. 450-420s BC: ‘Parthenon period’ Idealised style; echoes of the Parthenon-style of rendering dress and anatomy. Effective rendering of different poses and anatomy; still preference for ¾ faces. Favourite shapes: bell craters, amphorae, stamnoi Wide-spread use of white ground for lekythoi. Iconography: similar to previous generation. Quiet, dignified mood. Increase in scenes of Centauromachies and Amazonomachies that often hint at an influence by the Parthenon. Newly popular themes: Warrior taking leave; sacrifices and scenes from religious life in Athens Towards the end of the period: introduction of Personifications and Erotes and added white. New interest in the Life of women and their role in cult. Achilles Painter: 460s-430 Trained in Berlin Painter’s workshop (favours Nolan Amphorae with 1-2 figure compositions). Studies of gods, Nikai, pursuits, warrior taking leave. Quiet style, sombre mood; idealised features. Name vase: Amphora from Vulci in the Vatican: Achilles Stamnos in London, BM: Warrior taking leave WG lekythos from Eretria, Athens, NM: warrior taking leave Nolan amphora in London, BM: horseman & woman Phiale Painter: Similar to Achilles Painter; more narrative. Calyx craters in white ground WG calyx crater from Acragas: Perseus and Andromeda WG calyx crater from Vulci in the Vatican: Infant Dionysus taken to Sileus by Hermes Polygnotos and his group: Large craters, especially bell craters. Amazonomachy scenes. ¾ view poses, occasionally large friezes with variable ground lines. Stamnos in Oxford: Dioskouri Stamnos in London, BM: Cult scene Stamnos with Centauromachy Neck amphora in London, BM: Amazonomachy Kleophon Painter: large shapes. Formal compositions; quiet scenes Volute crater from Spina in Ferrara: Sacrifice procession to Apollo; Return of Hephaistos Stamnos from Vulci in Munich: Warrior taking leave Bell crater in Copenhagen: Chorus at a Maypole (Athenian festival) Peleus Painter: Calyx crater from Spina, Ferrara: Wedding of Peleus and Thetis Neck amphora from Vulci, London, BM: Muses Eretria Painter & Washing Painter interest in women; beginning of ‘Rich style’; Personifications Epinetron in Athens, NM from Eretria: Abduction of Thetis by Peleus; Preparation for Wedding; Alkestis, Harmonia Squat lekythos in New York: Prothesis of Patroklos & armour of Achilles; Amazonomachy Pyxis in the BM: women’s quarters Codrus Painter: Cup in London, BM: Deeds of Theseus Dinos Painter: new interest in multi-level compositions, love of Dionysiac and narrative groups. Few central figures. The style begins to show floridity of last quarter of 5th century. Use of added white Stamnos in Naples from Nocera: Worship of Dionysos GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 5: White-ground Lekythoi and Late Classical Attic Red-figure Late 5th-4th century: Boardman, J., The History of Greek Vases. Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) – Boardman, J., Athenian Red-Figure Vases: The Classical Period (1989), ch. 5ff. Burn, L., The Meidias Painter (1988) Carpenter, T.H., Art and Myth in Ancient Greece (1991). Lissarrague, F. Greek Vases: The Athenians and Their Images (New York 2001) Robertson, M., The Art of Vase-painting in Classical Athens (1992). Simon, E., Griechische Vasen (1981) –good quality illustrations. Taplin, O. (ed.), The Pronomos Vase and its Context (Oxford 2010) White Ground and funerary iconography/vases: Beazley, J.D., Attic White Lekythoi (1946) [very short and useful introduction on lekythoi] Boardman, J The History of Greek Vases Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) 226-234: on lekythoi and funerary iconography Cohen, B., The Colors of Clay: Special Techniques in Athenian Vases (Malibu 2006) - for Sotades and white ground Felten, K.F., Thanatos-und Kleophonmaler: Weissgrundige und rotfigurige Vasenmalerei der Parthenonzeit (Munich 1971): for images of vases of the Kleophon and Thanatos Painters. Kavvadias, G., Ho Zografos tou Sabouroff (Athens 2000): for images of vases by the Sabouroff Painter Koch-Brinkmann, U., Polychrome Bilder auf weissgrundigen Lekythen: Zeugen der klassischen griechischen Malerei. (Munich 1999): for images of colour on w-g lekythoi Kousser, R., ‘The World of Aphrodite in the Late Fifth Century B.C.’ in C. Marconi (ed.), Greek Vases: Images, Contexts and Controversies. Columbia Studies in the Classical Tradition, 25 (Leiden 2004) 97112. Kurtz, D.C.K, Athenian White Lekythoi: Patterns and Painters (1975). Kurtz, D.C.K, ‘Vases for the Dead, an Attic Selection: 750-400 BC’ in H. A.G. Brijder (ed), Ancient Greek and Related Pottery (Amsterdam1984) 314-328 – iconography of funerary vases from Geometric period onwards Mertens, J., Attic White Ground-its development on shapes other than lekythoi (1977). Mösch-Klingele, R., Die loutrophóros im Hochzeits- und Begräbnisritual des 5. Jahrhunderts v. Chr. in Athen (Bern 2006) – doctoral dissertation on the usage of loutrophoroi – for images Oakley, J.H., The Achilles Painter (Mainz 1997). Oakley, J.H., Picturing Death in Classical Athens (Cambridge 2005) – on iconography of lekythoi Sabetai, V., ‘Marker vase or Burnt Offering?: The Clay Loutrophoros in Context’, in Shapes and Uses of Greek Vases (2009) 291-306 Shapiro, A., ‘The Iconography of Mourning in Athenian Art’ American Journal of Archaeology 95 (1991) 629-256 Sourvinou-Inwood, Ch., ‘Reading’ Greek Death To the End of the Classical Period (Oxford 1995): excellent discussion of the terminology and mentality of grave monuments GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 5: White-ground Lekythoi and Late Classical Attic Red-figure White-ground lekythoi Bl-fig: c. 510 onwards Outline technique: c. 470-400 BC Contexts: Athens, Eupheros Tomb & Kerameikos Vergina/Aigai: ‘Queens Cluster’ Themes: Mythological Domestic: mistress and maid, farewell scenes; women with children Funerary themes: Prothesis (laying out of the dead) Visit to the tomb; lamentation Charon (& Hermes) leading the deceased Sleep and Death carrying the deceased People by the tomb monument Conflation of scenes: Charon & visit to the tomb; battle by the tombside; hunt by the tomb Vase Painters: Achilles P.; Sabouroff P.; Inscription P.; Bosanquet P., Thanatos P., Quadrate P., Women Painter; Reed P. and Group R; Group of Huge Lekythoi Late Classical, c. 420-370s : Rich, ornate style Characteristics: added gold, colour; softness of rendering; luxurious surroundings (artefacts; clothing; jewellery). Smaller shapes: pelikai, pyxides, hydriae-kalpides. Also volute and bell craters Up and down compositions with multi figure scenes on finer vases; figures in registers; more flowing figures Less emphatic drawing; sketched anatomy instead of sharply defined; short lines; emphasis on corporeality; foreshortening; clinging, transparent dress. Added colour; gilt relief detail; Increase in image of Erotes. Vase Painters: Meidias P.: careful drawing; Rich style. Hydria, London BM: Rape of Leukippides; below: Herakles and Eusperides Hydria in Florence: Aphrodite with Adonis Squat lekythos in the Manner of Meidias P., London (BM): Aristophanes: scenes of battle; more monumental than Meidias Cup in Tarquinia: Gigantomachy (interior); Exterior: Artemis, Zeus and Athena attack giants Aison: Cup in Madrid: Theseus Cycle Squat Lekythos in Naples: Amazonomachy (references to Parthenos shield) Nikias P.: Bell crater: End of torch race Oinochoe: Herakles and centaur chariot; comic scene Calyx crater in Virginia: Birth of Erichthonios Suessula P., Neck amphora in the Louvre: Gigantomachy (dense composition; up and down) Pronomos P., Name vase: Volute crater in Naples from Ruvo: theatrical scene; Dionysos and Ariadne Pelike found in Tanagra, now in Athens, NM: Gigantomachy (up and down composition) Calyx crater near the Pronomos P. from Ruvo, in Ruvo: Gigantomachy Talos Painter: Name vase: Volute crater from Ruvo, in Ruvo. Death of Talos; Argonauts: variable ground line; effects of painting LATER 4th CENTURY: Deterioration in drawing; mostly Erotes; Amazonomachies; griffins and Arymaspoi; small vases; fish plates; Added use of colour and relief. Export in the northern Aegean and Black Sea and Iberian Peninsula Kerch style: more careful. Xenophantos Painter: Squat lekythos in the Hermitage: Persians; a hunt. Relief decoration Marsyas Painter: Pelike in London, BM: Peleus and Thetis Lebes Gamikos in the Hermitage: Wedding preparations Calyx Crater in the Ashmolean from Al Mina: Apollo and Marsyas Eleusinian Painter: Pelikai with religious themes. Apollonia Group: Hydria in London from Cyrenaica: Adonis festival Squat lekythos from Apollonia in Thrace, in Berlin: Adonis festival GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 6: LOOKING AT IMAGES: WOMEN ON ATHENIAN VASES Reading List: Beazley, J.D., Attic White Lekythoi (1946) [very useful introduction on lekythoi and their iconography] Berard, C. et al., A City of Images: Iconography and Society in Ancient Greece (Princeton 1989) Blundell, S Women in Ancient Greece (Harvard, 1995) Boardman, J., The History of Greek Vases. Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) 209 chs. 5-7 Boardman, J., Athenian Red Figure Vases: The Archaic Period (1985) – brief text, very useful images Boardman, J., Athenian Red-Figure Vases: The Classical Period (1989) - same Bundrick, S.D.. ‘The Fabric of the City: Imaging Textile Production in Classical Athens’ Hesperia 77 (2008) 283–334 Davidson, J., Courtesans and Fishcakes: The Consuming Passions of Classical Athens (London 1998) ch. 3: women and boys; ch. 4: hetairai Ferrari, G Figures of Speech: Men and Maidens in Ancient Greece (Chicago: 2002). Kousser, R., ‘The World of Aphrodite in the Late Fifth Century B.C.’ in C. Marconi (ed.), Greek Vases: Images, Contexts and Controversies. Columbia Studies in the Classical Tradition 25 (Leiden 2004) 97-112. Kreilinger, U. ‘To Be or Not To Be a Hetaira: Female Nudity in Classical Athens’, In S. Schroer (ed.), Images and Gender: Contributions to the Hermeneutics of Reading Ancient Art, Orbis Biblicus et Orientalis 220. (Fribourg and Göttingen 2006) 229–37. Kurtz, D.C.K, ‘Vases for the Dead, an Attic Selection: 750-400 BC’, in H. A.G. Brijder (ed.), Ancient Greek and Related Pottery (Amsterdam1984) 314-328 – iconography of funerary vases from Geometric period onwards Lewis, S., The Athenian Woman: An Iconographic Handbook (London 2002) – most recent discussion of women on athenian vases Lissarrague, F. Greek Vases: The Athenians and Their Images (New York 2001) Oakley, J.H. and R.H. Sinos, The Wedding in Ancient Athens (Wisconsin 1993). Oakley, J.H., Picturing Death in Classical Athens (Cambridge 2005) – on iconography of lekythoi Nielsen, I., ‘The Sanctuary of Artemis Brauronia. Can architecture and iconography help to locate the settings of the rituals’ in T. Fischer-Hansen and B. Poulsen (eds), From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast. Acta Hyperoborea 12 (Copenhagen 2009) 83-116: on the krateriskoi from the sanctuary of Artemis in Brauron and their iconography Reeder, E., Pandora, Women in Classical Greece (1995): many different articles on the lives of women with many good illustrations Sabetai, V., ‘Marker vase or Burnt Offering?: The Clay Loutrophoros in Context’, in A. Tsingarida (ed.), Shapes and Uses of Greek Vases (Brussels 2009) 291-306 Sabetai, V., ‘Aspects of nuptial and genre iconography in Fifth Century Athens: Issues of Interpretation and Iconography’, in J. H. Oakley, W. D. E. Coulson, O. Palagia (eds.), Athenian Potters and Painters (Oxford 1997) 319-335. Sabetai, V., ‘Women and the Cycle of Life’, in N. Kaltsas and A. Shapiro (eds), Worshiping Women: Ritual and Reality in Classical Athens, New York: Alexander Onassis Public Benefit Foundation (USA) (2008) 286-297. Sabetai, V., ‘The Poetics of Maidenhood: Visual Constructs of Womanhood in VasePainting’ in S. Schmidt, J. H. Oakley (eds.), Hermeneutik der Bilder. Beiträge zur Ikonographie und Interpretation griechischer Vasenmalerei, CVA Deutschland Beiheft 4 (Munich 2009) 103-114 Shapiro, A., ‘The Iconography of Mourning in Athenian Art’ American Journal of Archaeology 95 (1991) 629-256 Stewart, A.F., Art, Desire and the Body in Ancient Greece (Cambridge 1997) ch. 8.1: on erotica – sex scenes. Sutton, Jr., R.F. ‘Family Portraits: Recognizing the "Oikos" on Attic Red-Figure Pottery’, Hesperia Supplements, Vol. 33, ΧΑΡΙΣ: Essays in Honor of Sara A. Immerwahr (2004), 327-350 Williams, D., ‘Women on Athenian Vases: Problems of Interpretation’, in A. Cameron and A. Kuhrt (eds.), Images of Women in Antiquity (Detroit: Wayne State University Press 1983) 93-106 GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 7: SOUTH ITALIAN RED FIGURE: An Introduction Reading: Boardman, J., The History of Greek Vases. Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) 109-122 Carter, J.C. et.al., The Chora of Metaponto : The Necropoleis (University of Texas Press, Austin, 1998) – the publication of the cemeteries with pottery in context. ‘Prolegomenon to the Study of Apulian Red-Figure Pottery’, American Journal of Archaeology 113 (2009) 27-38 (JSTOR) Carpenter, T.H., D’Andria, F., ‘Scavi nella zona del Kerameikos’, in Metaponto I, Notizie degli Scavi di Antichità, Suppl. XXIX, 1975 (Rome 1980) 355-452 Denoyelle, M., & M Lozzo, La céramique grecque d'Italie méridionale et de Sicile: productions coloniales et apparentées du VIIIe au IIIe siècle av. J.-C. Manuels d'Art et d'Archéologie antiques (Paris: Picard, 2009): the most upto-date discussion. Although in French it has many photographs and maps. Useful for all. Denoyelle, M., ‘L'approche stylistique, bilan et perspectives’, in M. Denoyelle, E. Lippolis, M.Mazzei, C. Pouzadoux (eds), La céramique apulienne Bilan et perspectives, Actes de la table ronde organisée par l'Ecole française de Rome en collaboration avec la Soprintendenza per i Beni archeologici della Puglia et le Centre Jean Bérard de Naples, 30 novembre-2 décembre 2000, Collection du Centre Jean Bérard, 21 (Naples 2005), 103-112. ‘La céramique proto-apulienne de Tarente : problèmes et perspectives d’une recontextualisation’, in M. Denoyelle, E. Lippolis, M.Mazzei, C. Pouzadoux (eds), La céramique apulienne Bilan et perspectives, Actes de la table ronde organisée par l'Ecole française de Rome en collaboration avec la Soprintendenza per i Beni archeologici della Puglia et le Centre Jean Bérard de Naples, 30 novembre-2 décembre 2000, Collection du Centre Jean Bérard, 21 (Naples 2005), p. 125-142 – on pottery workshops in Taras ‘Representation and Reception: Athenian Pottery and Its Italian Context’, in J.B. Wilkens and E. Herring (eds.), Inhabiting Symbols: Symbol and Image in the Ancient Mediterranean, (London 2003) 175–92 I Greci in Occidente. Arte e artigianato in Magna Grecia, catalogo della mostra, Taranto 1996 (Naples 1996) – exhibition catalogue Fontannaz, D., Lewis, S. Lippolis, E. (ed.), Mayo, M.E., The Art of South Italy: Vases from Magna Graecia (1982). Montanaro, A., Ruvo di Puglia e il suo territorio: Le necropoli. I corredi funerari tra la documentazione del XIX secolo e gli scavi moderni (Rome 2007): for a presentation of S. Italian vases in context. Trendall, A.D., The Red-figured Vases of Lucania, Campania and Sicily, (Oxford 1967) –connoisseurship Trendall, A.D., Red-figure Vases of South Italy and Sicily (1989) GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 7: SOUTH ITALIAN RED FIGURE: An Introduction Major Centres: Metapontion; Lucania; Apulia (Tarentum, Ruvo); Paestum; Campania; Sicily I. EARLY ‘LUCANIAN’ – Metapontine, c. 440/430 – 380/370 BC Discoveries in the ‘Potters’ quarter at Metapontion demonstrated that the city was a major centre for early Red figure production in Italy. The Pisticci P., Amykos P., Cyclops P., Dolon P. and Kreousa P., were active in the workshops discovered in the city. As M. Denoyelle has shown, “The Amykos Painter’s workshop in Metaponto with its productivity, its technical quality, its adaptability, its large diffusion and the number of painters that have been trained there, may well have been one of the main points from where red-figure spread”. c. 380/370 – Abandonment of Metapontion workshops; artisans move closer to clients in the Lucanian hinterland, inhabited by Italic peoples Characteristics: Atticizing style; often Polykleitan postures for athletes; ¾ views Shapes: bell craters, medium-sized shapes (pelikai, amphorai, oinochoai), and some local ones: nestorides. Themes: genre: athletes, pursuits; warriors. Satyrs and Dionysiac themes; pursuit scenes. Often simple take on popular Attic scenes. Deities: generic, except for Eros and Dionysos and his thiasos. Some original myths, perhaps indicating influence of drama and epic in large vessels. Some themes seem related to Euripides (Cyclops, Suicide of Kanake, Andromeda) and later Aeschylus’ Oresteia. Warriors in local dress/armour appear in nestorides. Painters: Pisticci P.: among earliest vase painters in Italy. Imitates Attic vase painters of 460-430 BC: pursuit scenes; satyrs; genre (warrior and woman; athletes, etc); Reverse: mantled youths. Favourite shapes: bell craters; pelikai; oinochoai; hydriai; jugs. Very atticizing. Bell crater in the BM: Eos Pursuing Kephalos Bell crater in New York: satyrs by herm; youths Painter of Cyclops: c. 430-415? BC ; mostly bell craters. Polycleitan postures (contraposto) for his youths/men. Calyx crater in London, BM, c. 420 BC: Odysseus and his companions in Cyclops’ cave; with satyrs. Inspired by satyr play? Amykos Painter: c. 430-410. Among the most productive (c. 250 vases attributed to him). Wide diffusion in Calabria, Sicily; Daunia; Campania, Etruria. Style: Rounded faces; supple bodies; ¾ views; foreshortening; elaborate language in myths. Likes athletes (again adapts Polycleitan poses, with exaggerated contrapposto); pursuit and departure scenes. Shapes: craters; medium size vases: hydriai, amphorai, choes, skyphoi; nestorides. Themes: silens; genre scenes: athletes with draped women (women can hold strigils), youths, warriors Name vase: Hydria in Paris, Cabinet des Medailles: satyrs and Maenads; Argonauts and Amykos captive on a rock. Hydria from Canosa in Bari: Suicide of Kanake (Euripides’ Aiolos) Calyx crater in New York, MMA: Fight scene (local armour); mantled youths Palermo Painter: c. 410-400. Rare themes; inscribed pillars; Some were found in the cemeteries of Taras. Skyphos in New York, MMA: Marsyas and gods; Athena Karneia volute crater, from Bari in Taranto, Archaeological Museum: Two hands identified: side A: a Metapontine, close to Amykos P; side B by a painter closer to Tarentine workshops: A) Dionysos on a rock and his thiasos; B) in two registers: Perseus takes the head of Medusa, in front of Satyrs preparing to dance in honour of Apollo Karneios, by youths who wear a hat in form of kalathos. Festival of Apollo Karneios celebrated in Taras, Thurii, Herakleia. Workshop of Dolon Painter and Kreousa: identified in Metapontion installations (from c. 400 onwards): Dolon Painter: influenced by Amykos P in style and posture of figures; animated Dionysiac myth. Original treatment of myth, from Epic poetry, tragic and comic theatre; funerary sculpture. . Shapes: pelikai, nestorides, skyphoi; calyx craters. Calyx crater from Pisticci, in London, BM: Capture of Dolon by Ulysses and Diomedes. Iliad bk. 10. Style: fluid design; relaxed poses; expressive faces. . II. EARLY APULIAN: BEGINNING OF RF IN TARAS, c. 440-370 BC Context of production: Puglia; and some sites immediately outside Taras (Gravina). In the necropoleis of Taras: two zones of workshop installations; not as concentrated as at Metapontion; more dispersed. Strong Athenian influence. In the waste pits of the workshops: pottery fragments of Christie Painter and of Peleus Painter, of years 450-440: used by the potters to study and imitate the technique and style of Athenian imports. The early pottery: joint presence with Metapontine in indigenous contexts (Rutigliano); therefore both are roughly contemporary. Vases are strongly atticizing (calyx craters, amphorae); influence of Polygnotos. See emphasis on writing names, carefully, on the vases. The letters: on Dorian dialect. Two trends (Trendall): a) Ornate style: influenced by the work of major vase painters of the end the of 5th century (Cadmus Painter, Pronomos P., Talos P.), mostly volute craters in large size; complex scenes with many persons, vegetal ornamentation; ¾ view faces; rendering of volume and colour. Appears with Sisyphos P. and culminates with Dareios P. Complex mythological scenes, and naiskosthemed iconography. Mostly in indigenous necropoleis: Ceglie, Ruvo, Rutigliano. Sisyphos P. (c. 430-400): limpidity of style; solemnity of atmosphere (recalls Codrus Painter). Bell craters; volute craters. The style recalls architectural sculpture of late 5th c, Parthenon (models of Pheidias) Gravina P: Beginning of ‘Ornate’ Style; Tomb in Gravina-Botromagno found in 1974: Attic vases (Eretria P, Achilles P.) together with three vases by Gravina P.. The iconography of the group was rich, related to funerary and mythological imagery (Rape of Leukippids, Sthenebeia) stresses the theme of female passage. Volute crater, Gravina: Amorous couple. Stamnos, Boston, MFA: Abandonment of Ariadne on Naxos; B: Bellerophon, Pegasos, Proitos, Sthenonoboea P. of the Birth of Dionysos: Volute crater in Taranto, Archaeological Museum: Birth of Dionysos among deities: elaboration of formulas, beginning of Ornate style. Imitates Cadmus P. (see Ruvo) Fragmentary calyx crater: Amsterdam, Allard Pierson Museum: gathering of gods; Temple with cult statue of Apollo: perspective, realistic rendering of volume; added colours Group of Black Furies: Volute crater from Ruvo in Naples: Orestes and the Furies; Dionysos, Eros and Papposilenos a) Plain Style: c. 390-370 BC; Not so influenced by Attic vase painters; indigenous clientele. Shapes: bell craters, column craters, medium size vases (hydriai, pelikai). Themes: Dionysiac, indigenous warriors, funerary themes on stelai; phlyakes vases. Many in Tarentine necropoleis Tarporley Painter: 1st half of 5th c; isocephalic compositions of 2-3 persons. Dionysiac themes (banquets, cortege, thiasos); theatrical (phlyakes, actors in costume) and mystery (youths with thyrsoi). Ritual aspect perhaps linked to eschatological beliefs. Bell crater, New York, MMA: Dionysos with a mask in hand, & youthful Pan in front of an altar. Eumenides Group: Paris, Louvre: Orestes’ purification by Apollo in the presence of sleeping Furies, III. MATURE APULIAN RED FIGURE 370-300 BC: ORNATE STYLE Expansion of exports towards Daunia; and even further away. Technique: much added colour: white, yellow, red, gilding. Elaborate large vessels with relief appliques (esp. on volute craters). Large vessels often with open bottoms Shapes: craters (esp. volutes, often of very large size, with open bases); loutrophoroi; amphorai; pelikai; fish plates; nestorides Style: Complex compositions with figures in various registers; statuesque figures; interest in depiction of architecture (perspective rendering of naiskoi). On the necks of vessels filled with floral motifs (elaborate scrolls, volutes, palmettes) and female heads. Major painters: Ilioupersis P., Darius Painter; Underworld P, Baltimore P.: Able to render human and animal action; delineation of mood, emotion. Rendering of composition often recalls advances of major painting. Ample use of inscriptions Themes: genre; Dionysiac; female heads in profile; Rare myths often betraying influence of drama, esp. by Euripides; Costume and comedy of interest, esp. in Phlyax vases. Naiskos scenes: figures organised in registers around a naiskos painted white, inside which is a figure (male or female). Question on the status of the deceased (heroized?) and the type of funerary monument meant to evoke (compare to Tarentine reliefs and funerary monument but these vases are found in non-Greek contexts). Although the motif can be associated with loutrophoroi and hydriai, it does not appear in other types of craters. Workshop of Ilioupersis P: Sobriety of representation of human form (in tradition of Plain style) combined with ornate style: volute craters with relief figures or faces on the handles; on the neck: griffins or lions; rarely female heads in ¾ view among acanthus leaves. Volute crater in London, BM F283: neck: animals. A: Naiskos scene; B: gathering around a stele. Lykourgos P., 360-340 BC: emphatic style; see many faces in ¾ views, gestures of persons. Very rich iconographic repertoire; some references to theatre and epic; Also naiskos scenes; in some pelikai: recognition of a couple on a couch. Diffusion in Ruvo. Calyx crater, London BM F271: Madness of Lykourgos Volute crater in Karlsruhe: The Underworld Varrese P., 350-330 BC: column and volute craters; bell craters; colours: orange & purple Pseudo-panathenaic amphora from the hypogaeum Varrese in Canosa, Taranto Archaeological Museum: Niobe after the death of her children Pseudo-panathenaic amphora from Ruvo, in London BM: Meeting of Pelops and Oinomaos at the altar of Zeus; B: female figure and youth; lower row: offerings at a tomb P. of Louvre MNB 1148: Loutrophoros at the Getty: Niobe; the Tantalides: delicate handles; elaboration of shape. Niobe between two loutrophoroi in naiskos; lower part of chiton white; Around naiskos: Pelops and Hippodameia. Darius P. 340-320 BC: Myths: funerary iconography (naiskos scenes, representation of the Underworld); myths that play with destiny (Hippolytos, Phrixos), heroic destiy: Achilles; punishment of crimes: Niobe, Myrtilos, Aktaion, Ixion, liberation from death: Alcestis, Andromeda. Tomb at Canosa with many of his vases. Name vase from Canosa, Naples: volute crater Naples: Persian king in court in Persepolis; upper register: Greek gods, Victory, Deceit Volute crater from Canosa, Naples: funeral of Patroklos Loutrophoros from Canosa, Naples: with Andromeda Underworld Painter, 330-310 BC: Some rare themes: Melanippe story; Dioskouroi against Apharides. Very elaborate scenes, extreme detail; underworld scene. Monumental vases of various shapes, many found in Canosa Volute crater from Canosa in Munich: the Underworld Volute crater from Canosa in Munich: Medea’s revenge on Kreousa and Jason Baltimore Painter: 330-310 BC. Last quarter of 4th c. Problem of localization of workshops: in Peucetia/Canosa? Monumental vases in the tradition of Underworld P.; large typology of shapes; Iconography: Naiskos scenes; Pelops and Hippodameia; Bellerophon; Andromeda; Amazonomachies. Niobe; Rape of Persephone Volute crater in London, BM: The Hamilton vase IV. CAMPANIA & PAESTUM Problem of localization of production: diffusion at certain sites of vases that are ‘precursors’ of Siceliot production. Many found at Lipari. PAESTUM Asteas: about half the production found in necropolis of Andriuolo and Arcioni. Many vases at Lipari. Calyx craters; medium size amphorae; Mannierism; love of colour. Dionysos; Phlyax vases. Decorative style; use of colour; perspective; Calyx crater in Madrid: Madness of Herakles Calyx crater in Berlin, Antikensammlung: Phlyax scene Calyx crater, formerly Getty: Europa on the bull Python: c. 370-350 BC. Signs vases; bell craters; finds from Andriuolo in Paestum (birth of Helen from Nemesis egg); Bell crater, London BM: Alkmene on the pyre Neck amphora from Andriuolo necropolis, Paestum: Birth of Helen Bell crater, London BM: Orestes and the Furies CAMPANIA Heterogeneous production; influence of Italic culture; Cumae workshops: 350-330 BC: neck amphorae; bell craters; Bail amphora (Situla amphora). Local flavor (costumes; scenes). Ixion P., 360-340: likes colour; models work along Kerch style. Likes faces in ¾ view or frontal; postures demonstrating pathos; colour Neck amphora, in Berlin: Ixion and Furies Neck amphora in Paris, Louvre: Medea murders her children – inspired by Euripides? GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 8: Myth and Theatre on Greek vases Reading: Bieber, M., History of the Greek Theater (1961). Boardman, J., The History of Greek Vases. Potters, Painters and Pictures (London 2001) Carpenter, T.H., Art and Myth in Ancient Greece (1991). Csapo, E. and Slater, W.J. , The Context of Ancient Drama (Michigan 1994), 53-88 – one of the most balanced discussions of the subject Csapo, E., Actors and Icons of the Ancient Theater (Chichester/Malden, MA 2010) – chs 1-2 (on chorus and actors in Attic and South Italian pots) Denoyelle, M., & M Lozzo, La céramique grecque d'Italie méridionale et de Sicile: productions coloniales et apparentées du VIIIe au IIIe siècle av. J.-C. Manuels d'Art et d'Archéologie antiques (Paris: 2009) Giuliani, L. 'Rhesus between dream and death: On the relation of image to literature in Apulian vase-painting', BICS 41 (1996), 71-86 Giuliani, L. 'Sleeping Furies: Allegory, Narration and the Impact of Texts in Apulian Vase-Painting', Scripta Israelica 20 (2001), 17-38 Green, J.R. 'On seeing and depicting the theatre in classical Athens', Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies 32 (1991), 15-50, on Athenian vase painting Hart, J.L. (ed.), The Art of the Ancient Greek Theater (Malibu, Los Angeles 2010) – various articles by specialists on theatre and its representation to accompany an exhibition. Lippolis, E. (ed.), I Greci in Occidente. Arte e artigianato in Magna Grecia, catalogo della mostra, Taranto 1996 (Napoli,1996) – exhibition catalogue Mayo, M.E., The Art of South Italy: Vases from Magna Graecia (1982). Shapiro, H. A., Myth into Art. Poet and Painter in Classical Greece (London 1994) chapter 4. Taplin, O. Comic Angels and other Approaches to Greek Drama through Vase Paintings (Oxford 1993), on South Italian vase painting Taplin. O., Pots and Plays: Interactions Between Tragedy and Greek VasePainting of the Fourth Century B.C. (Los Angeles 2007) Trendall, A. D., ‘Farce and Tragedy in South Italian Vase-Painting’ in T. Rasmussen and N. Spivey (eds.), Looking at Greek Vases (Cambridge 1991) 151182. Trendall, A.D. and Webster, T.B.L., Illustrations of Greek Drama (1971). Tends to see theatrical inspiration for most mythological scenes. Very well illustrated Trendall, A.D., Red-figure Vases of South Italy and Sicily (1989) GREEK VASES, 800-300 BC, PART: II (c. 530-300 BC). Lecture 8: Myth and Theatre on Greek vases ATTIC VASE PAINTING: Komos vases – Dionysiac: c. 560-480 BC: choruses of men costumed as animals, or costumed men riding animas, often with piper. Dolphin dancers Tragic chorus: Attic RF column crater in Mannierist Style, c. 490 BC: Basel: three ranks and 2 files of men dancing in formation in front of an altar (note: diadems; dance; OS from their mouths) Attic RF crater fragment from Olbia, c. 430-420, Kiev: piper, boy assistant and two masked choreuts. Comic chorus: Attic RF calyx crater, formerly Malibu, c. 425 BC: two dancers dressed as fighting cocks and piper Attic RF pelike, c. 425 BC, Atlanta, Emory Museum: Dancers dressed as fighting cocks. Choregic art: The Pronomos crater: from Ruvo, in Naples, c. 400 BC: A: Cast of satyr play celebrating victory. B: Dionysos and his thiasos. Comedy & actors: RF chous of the P. of the Perseus dance, formerly Vlastos Collection: Athens, NM: c. 420: stage & actor dressed as Perseus; audience below RF chous by the Nikias P., in Paris, Louvre, c. 410 BC: Victory and Herakles in a chariot led by centaurs & actor Fragmentary polychrome oinochoe, Athens, Agora excavations, c. 410: two padded actors labeled – onysos and –Phor- SOUTH ITALIAN: Hydria attributed to the Amykos Painter, from Canosa in Bari: Suicide of Kanake (Euripides’ Aiolos) Dolon Painter: influenced by Amykos P in style and posture of figures; animated Dionysiac myth. Original treatment of myth, from Epic poetry, tragic and comic theatre; funerary sculpture. Shapes: pelikai, nestorides, skyphoi; calyx craters. Calyx crater from Pisticci, in London, BM: Capture of Dolon by Ulysses and Diomedes. Iliad bk. 10. Style: fluid design; relaxed poses; expressive faces. Stamnos, Boston, MFA, Sisyphos P.: Abandonment of Ariadne on Naxos; B: Bellerophon, Pegasos, Proitos, Sthenonoboea Group of Black Furies: Volute crater from Ruvo in Naples, c. 380: Orestes and the Furies; Dionysos, Eros and Papposilenos Bell crater by the Tarporley P., New York, MMA: Dionysos with a mask in hand, & youthful Pan in front of an altar. Eumenides Group, c. 380 BC: Paris, Louvre: Orestes’ purification by Apollo in the presence of sleeping Furies, Calyx crater by the Lykourgos P., London BM F271: Madness of Lykourgos P. of Louvre MNB 1148: Loutrophoros at the Getty: Niobe; the Tantalides Darius P. 340-320 BC: Name vase from Canosa, Naples: volute crater Naples: Persian king in court in Persepolis; upper register: Greek gods, Victory, Deceit Volute crater from Canosa, Naples: funeral of Patroklos Loutrophoros from Canosa, Naples: with Andromeda Underworld Painter, 330-310 BC: Melanippe story; Volute crater from Canosa in Munich: Medea’s revenge on Kreousa and Jason Baltimore Painter: 330-310 BC. Pelops and Hippodameia; Bellerophon; Andromeda; Amazonomachies. Niobe; Rape of Persephone Volute crater in London, BM: The Hamilton vase Asteas: Calyx crater in Madrid: Madness of Herakles Calyx crater in Berlin, Antikensammlung: Phlyax scene Calyx crater, formerly Getty: Europa on the bull Python: c. 370-350 BC. Bell crater, London BM: Alcmene on the pyre Neck amphora from Andriuolo necropolis, Paestum: Birth of Helen Bell crater, London BM: Orestes and the Furies Ixion P., 360-340: likes colour; models work along Kerch style. Likes faces in ¾ view or frontal; postures demonstrating pathos; colour Neck amphora, in Berlin: Ixion and Furies Neck amphora in Paris, Louvre: Medea murders her children – inspired by Euripides?