ABBOTTS COLLEGE G12 HISTORY TOPIC 1: THE COLD WAR Soviet criticism of the oppressive capitalist system 1.1 The Cold War: ORIGINS OF THE WAR (source-based questions) The Cold War was the result of competition between the USA and the USSR to create areas of influence. Here the two superpowers, represented by Uncle Sam and a worker, cut the world in half. How did the USSR and USA create spheres of interest by the 1960s? Terms: political ideologies set of political beliefs and aims arms race competition to build up armed forces coup a violent change of government Iron Curtain an imaginary dividing line between communist eastern Europe and non-communist western Europe Soviet 'satellites' the countries of eastern Europe under the influence of the USSR HOW DID WORLD WAR TWO INTENSIFY THE COLD WAR? An uneasy alliance USA and the USSR temporarily set aside their differences when the Nazis invaded the Soviet Union in 1941 USA together with Britain and the Soviet Union formed what became known as the Grand Alliance to defeat Hitler but it was a "marriage of convenience" From 1941 the USSR carried the main burden in the fight against the Nazis, Soviet casualties began to mount Two years before the Americans opened up a second front, Stalin viewed this delay as a deliberate attempt to weaken the USSR The USA ended the Lend-lease programme that was providing essential supplies to the Soviet people Stalin grew more suspicious over Western secrecy of the atomic bomb, Stalin was only informed about its existence after the Nazi defeat How did the wartime conferences change the relationship between the Soviet Union and her allies? Teheran Conference, November 1943 decided that there would be no Anglo-American invasion of Germany through the Balkans This left only Soviet troops to clear Eastern Europe of Nazi forces By recognising Soviet supremacy in Eastern Europe, the Teheran Conference limited the West's participation in the post-war political decisions in Eastern Europe Yalta Conference, February 1945 to plan the post-war settlement great tension behind the official cordiality agreements reached ended up being only temporary compromises Decisions: Germany would be divided into four zones of occupation, to be administered by the USA, the USSR, Britain and France Berlin, which was situated deep in the Soviet zone, would also be divided into 4 zones USSR had occupied Poland and had installed a pro-Soviet provisional government. At Yalta, Stalin promised that free democratic elections would be held Eastern European countries were to be allowed to hold free elections to choose how they would be governed. However, Stalin's interpretation of democracy was very different from that of the other allies. They would join the United Nations whose aim it was to keep peace after the war. Stalin was determined to create a large buffer against any future German aggression because they had suffered terrible losses during the war. The Big Three agreed that Eastern Europe would be a "Soviet sphere of influence". Potsdam Conference, July-August 1945 These discussions also highlighted the differences between the Western allies and the Soviet Union. Stalin was even more uncompromising. The details of the four zones of occupation were finalized. What did the powers not agree upon? Stalin proposed that Germany be crippled, whereas Truman did not want a repetition of the Treaty of Versailles. They could not agree upon the issue of reparations. Stalin hoped to be compensated for the death of 20 million Russians, while Truman did not want to make the same mistakes that were made at the end of World War One. Although it had been agreed at Yalta that pro-Soviet governments could be set up in Eastern Europe, Truman was totally opposed to this. Many historians have emphasised Stalin's refusal to consider German re-unification and his refusal to give up wartime gains in Eastern Europe as major factors in creating the Cold War. It has been suggested that Stalin never fully understood the Western position, however it is also true to say that the West never fully understood the Soviet perspective. Therefore the misunderstanding was a two-way process. How did the Cold War start? Europe in 1949. The Iron Curtain was the border between communist eastern Europe and the countries of western Europe, which were parliamentary democracies with capitalist economic systems. The communist states of eastern Europe were often referred to in the West as Soviet 'satellites'. In this German cartoon, the banner reads: "We thank our liberators." The countries represented are Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Romania and Bulgaria. Why was Stalin so interested in Eastern Europe? wanted it to act as a buffer between Germany and the USSR saw it as vital to the development of the Soviet economy. These countries would be a source of cheap goods and raw materials. They would also be forced to trade with the Soviet Union Some historians believe that Stalin's interest in Eastern Europe was part of a pattern of conquest. Others believe that Stalin would have been happy to allow coalition governments to continue, but hostility from the West forced him to impose a harsh regime in this area. "Iron Curtain" West grew increasingly alarmed at the situation in Eastern Europe saw Stalin as a dictator who had eliminated his opposition prompted Winston Churchill to make his famous speech in Fulton, Missouri (USA) in March 1946 declared that "an iron curtain" had descended across Europe from Stettin in the Baltic to Trieste in the Adriatic. He basically stated that Europe was now divided into separate halves by Soviet policy On the one hand in the West, there were free democratic states, while in the East, behind the "Iron Curtain", were the countries under communist domination subject to the Soviet Union He called for a Western alliance to combat the threat of communism Stalin was angered by this speech and accused Churchill of trying to stir up war against the Soviet Union The speech certainly widened the gap between the USSR and the West, but did little to combat communist expansion in Eastern Europe. Economic spheres of influence: containment 'dollar diplomacy' using economic pressure to promote American interests Truman Doctrine the basis of American foreign policy aimed at stopping the spread of communism Marshall Plan American economic aid to Europe to rebuild war-damaged economies Cominform (1947) Communist Information Bureau : to co-ordinate communist parties in Europe (control over satellites) Comecon Council for Mutual Economic Aid: USSR dominated Do not sow seed, I will sell you maize. Do not build new shipyards. I will sell you old ones cheaply. Why do you want to strengthen your currency? Why don't you try mine? It is difficult to carry out your you’re policy? Carry out ours. The first confrontation: Berlin The post-war division of Germany and Berlin. 'Berlin Blockade' 'Berlin Airlift'. In June 1948, the USSR closed all surface routes - road, rail and canal - linking Berlin and the West, cutting off the two and a half million citizens in West Berlin. The West responded to this by launching the 'Berlin Airlift'. Stalin had not closed the three air lanes through to Berlin, and so for nearly a year the West supplied West Berlin with all it needed. Formal division of Germany After the Berlin Blockade ended (’49), Germany formally divided into two separate states: three western zones became the German Federal Republic (or West Germany), with Bonn as capital; and Soviet zone became the German Democratic Republic (or East Germany), with East Berlin as its capital. Most notorious symbol of the Cold War: The Wall 1961 1961 about 2 thousand people a week were 'voting with their feet' and opting for the higher standard of living and greater freedom of the West. The USSR viewed this as another challenge to Soviet control in Eastern Europe. In August 1961, the East German authorities, with Soviet backing, built the Berlin Wall to divide East and West Berlin. This high, fortified wall, with its machine-gun posts and searchlights, stopped the flow of refugees. West Berlin: island of capitalism and democracy surrounded by East Germany. Alliance blocs emerged as a result of the Cold War The tension between the superpowers led to the creation of two military blocs. NATO USA formed military alliance with its western European allies, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization Headquarters: Paris later Brussels 1966: France withdrew Warsaw Pact Military alliance between USSR and the eastern European Hungary(1956)+ Czechoslovakia(1968) tried to withdraw (revolts crushed) Brezhnev Doctrine defined a Soviet bloc country as a socialist one-party state belonging to the Warsaw Pact. It spelt out the right of the Warsaw Pact to intervene in any member state which threatened to break away from the bloc and thus endanger it. The spheres of influence of the superpowers stretched beyond Europe SEATO Other newly-independent The West formed other anti-communist Asian states refused to be alliances. Three Asian nations (the drawn in. Philippines, Thailand and Pakistan) joined USA, Britain, France, Australia and New Zealand to form the South East Asia Treaty Organization) in 1954. CENTO In the Middle East, (the Central Treaty Organization) formed in 1955, included pro-Western states such as Iran, Iraq, Pakistan and Turkey, together with the USA and Britain. Science and technology as part of the Cold War nuclear weapons: arms race drop first atom bomb first Soviet atom bomb was at Hiroshima , Second World War produced in 1949 in 1945 - clear advantage hydrogen bomb arms race (1960s) enormous quantities of nuclear weapons.and long-range missiles MAD each hoped that knowing this would be enough to stop the other side from attacking first (or Mutually Assured Destruction) SALT talks about reducing the arms race - or Strategic Arms Limitations Talks SALT1: agreement, signed in 1972, first step in slowing down the arms race espionage CIA (Central Intelligence Agency) Spy plane (U2) satellites KGB (Soviet Committee for State Security) satellites space race Americans began to question 1957, the Soviet Union launched the work of their scientists the first satellite into space and the quality of their education. called 'sputnik' (which means President ordered scientists to speed 'fellow traveller'). up work on America's own Seemed USSR was ahead in space programme. science and technology 1961 Yuri Gagarin became the first human being to orbit the earth and return safely. US concentrated on being the first to land a human on the moon (1969) first country to send a woman into space contrast in lifestyles consumer goods, material wealth, poor living standards leisure time, prosperous living standards How did the superpowers make their citizens follow Cold War ideologies? citizens to be loyal, not only to their country but to an ideology both sides were taught to believe the other side was evil Politicians, government propaganda, the education system and popular culture all reinforced this message. The Red Scare totalitarian control early 1950s - a period of hysterical No criticism or opposition anti-communism, allowed, independent thought US Congress set up a committee repressed, thousands sent to to investigate 'Un-American Activities! Labour camps, executed McCarthyism Senator Joseph McCarthy headed a fanatical witch-hunt for communist sympathizers in government departments series of public enquiries was held, to investigate communist sympathies of prominent Americans totalitarianism in satellites police spies, any attempt to break away was crushed e.g. Hungarian Uprising, people crossing Berlin Wall shot Peace Corps Humanitarian projects in Asia, South America and Africa. To gain support for the US Support programs Asian, African to study at Patrice Lumumba University in Moscow Support programs 1960s - the New York newspaper The Tribune pay for bright school children from Europe, Asia and Africa to spend time in the US Radio Moscow SA (Afrikaans, Zulu and English) used for propaganda Voice of America Propaganda radio 'Radio Free Europe' broadcast to the countries of eastern Europe behind the lron Curtain popular culture forms of popular entertainment, such as music, radio, and films also reflected the Cold War 2.1 EFFECT OF THE COLD WAR ON WORLDWIDE CONFLICTS: CASE STUDY: VIETNAM (Essay question) Tension between USA and USSR made conflict in other parts of the world worse. Examples where local conflicts became worse: Vietnam Cuba Angola Middle East Conflicts made worse by intervention of superpowers – directly or through supply of weapons / finance. Effect of Cold War on Vietnam Civil war became Cold War conflict. USA : involved to prevent communists from coming to power. Origins of war in Vietnam Before WW II : Vietnam part of Indo-China (French colony). During war : occupied by Japan, strong anti-Japanese resistance by Viet Minh (communist). After war : Democratic Republic of Vietnam under Ho Minh. War between France and Viet Minh for control over Vietnam. Viet Minh supported by China – USA feared communist plot to take over East Asia. USA supported France financially. 1954 : France defeated by Viet Minh guerillas, Vietnam gained independence. Why did USA get involved? After French defeat: Vietnam divided in North / South until elections. USA helped to set up anti-communist Republic of South Vietnam. Ho Chi Minh set up communist state in North. USA prevented elections in South. South Vietnam: Oppressive and corrupt government Police state Unfair land distribution Peasants supported Viet Cong Dependant on economic and military aid from USA Viet Cong: National Front for the Liberation of South Vietnam, communist resistance group, supported by North. 1964: full-scale military involvement from USA. US air force - massive bombing of North Vietnam to stop supply of weapons through Ho Chi Minh trails USA unable to defeat Viet Cong. Public opinion grew increasingly critical of USA involvement. Nixon wanted to withdraw without looking like defeat. American troops returned to USA, promised aid to South Vietnam. Aid and support never happened. Saigon defeated by communist forces. 1975: North and South united under communist government. INTERPRETATIONS OF THE COLD WAR 1. The 'Truman'/ Western view • promoted at first by Churchill and acted on by Truman According to this view: • The USSR can be blamed for trying to destabilize the post-war world and thereby undermining peace efforts - Stalin wanted to extend communism and would not be stopped. His first step was to take over Eastern Europe. - He wanted to increase his 'sphere of influence' and did not care what was needed to do this. - Stalin blatantly undermined the ideals of the UN and used the USSR's veto power to block its effectiveness. - Once his wartime alliance with the Western powers no longer suited him, he just dropped it. • It was the job of the free world to resist the spread of communism - This was done by the Berlin Airlift, the formation of NATO and the decisive action in Korea 2. The 'USSR - we need security" view • promoted Soviet control of Eastern Europe, but was supported by some American and British statesmen According to this view: • The Soviet Union needed to protect itself from invasion - Russia/USSR had been invaded many times via Eastern Europe, therefore the Soviet takeover of eastern Europe was not expansionist, but defensive. - The USSR had suffered severely in the Second World War and therefore needed to make sure this did not happen again. - Promoting communism was less important than protecting Soviet land. - The USSR had no interest in taking over the rest of the world. 3. The 'Revisionist' view • America is blamed for causing the Cold War by its aggressive capitalism - America was the undisputed power of the world and would no longer be isolationist. - It had the atom bomb. - Its standard of living was the highest in the world. It produced a lot of consumer goods. - American businesses wanted to expand their investments in the world market. - American wealth and the CIA influenced foreign governments to follow policies favourable to the USA. - America manipulated the UN and propaganda around freedom to suit its own ends. Although the Western interpretation usually supports the Truman' view, most historians acknowledge that aspects of each of these theories could be applied in different situations. The last view, discussed below, is generally seen as too simplistic to explain the Cold War tensions. 4. The'Communist Conflict' view • The West is completely to blame and the USSR is the victim in the Cold War - Capitalism is the only cause of conflict between people. - Socialism is based on brotherhood and cooperation and therefore no socialist country could cause a war. The West used the Cold War to attack Soviet policies that it did not like. This is the view that was published in Soviet school textbooks. Grade 12 THE COLD WAR: Historical concepts Make sure that you can explain / define and also apply the following concepts: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. political ideology communism capitalism superpower bloc Grand Alliance zones of occupation atomic bomb reparations sphere of influence annex satelite coup Iron Curtain isolation containment guerillas Truman Doctrine Marshall Plan Subjugation Secretary of State Comecon Cominform dollar diplomacy free enterprise Berlin Blockade Berlin Airlift flashpoint NATO Treaty Defence alliance Warsaw Pact Breznev Doctrine one-party state space race arms race MAD SALT popular culture brinkmanship / statesmanship nationalist movement liberators sharecroppers Comintern Domino Theory persecution 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. detention martial law conscription defoliant napalm ambush veterans