Unit 1 My Story: Student Identity and Narratives Drafted by Allyson Tintiangco-Cubales, David Leong, and Pete Hammer Unit Overview A. What is the Story of Ethnic Studies? Why is Ethnic Studies Necessary? 1. On Strike: A Student-Led Movement (150 minutes) 2. Racial Gallery (50 min)—this could also be repeated or revised for Unit 2 and Unit 5 B. What is My Story? Why is My Story Important? 1. Fragments of History: Teacher’s Document Box (50 min) 2. Here’s My Box: Peer to Peer Interview (100 min) 3. My Life’s Soundtrack (50 min) 4. Eye-dentity Maps (50 min) Homework Essay: My Story- A written narrative analyzing how race, ethnicity, and culture define them at this point in their lives. C. What are Our Families’ Stories? How and Why Do Our Stories Connect? My Family, My Self: Family Oral History Project Day 1: Day 2 and 3: Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 to 8 Day 9 Day 10 to 12 Family Oral History Project Introduction Each student creates a portfolio titled “My Family, My Self” that includes -A family tree for at least three generations -A podcast of an oral history interview of an older member of the family -A paper on the life of their family member -A digital and oral presentation summarizing their family history for at least three generations My Family Tree (100 min-with homework) Starting with What you Know: Meaningful Questions and Creating a Space for Storytelling (50 min) -Creating Questions -Doing the Interview -Transcribing -Creating a Podcast Home Wasn’t Built in A Day: Constructing the Stories of Our Families (50 min) Readings: Grandma & Granddaughter by Ursula Fung Yemen by Jamaal Ghanem (Students from Galileo Academy of Science & Technology, 2006) Model Oral History Essays by High School Students Oral History Paper -Draft should be due a day or two before the presentations begin. -Final draft should be due on one of the last days of this unit. (Both in class and for homework) Creating a Powerpoint Presentation (50 min) Oral Presentations: Activities on how to connect the oral histories (10 minutes per student) 1 Unit Purpose PROBLEM The stories of people of color and ethnic families/communities have not always been represented in the curriculum of America's system of education. The struggle for a full and representative inclusion continues and is central to a democratic society. These identities, issues, and histories/herstories have been overtly and covertly neglected and excluded in the educational system and academic scholarship. This has contributed to a multitude of social, political, economic, psychological problems that have plagued ethnic peoples, such as poverty, violence, colonial mentality, and the lack of political power. The struggle for inclusion has led to groundbreaking resistance. The Third World Strike at San Francisco State University in 1968 was a sociopolitical movement that changed the face of education. This movement established the first School of Ethnic Studies (now College of Ethnic Studies) in 1969 with the departments of African American Studies (now Africana), American Indian Studies, Asian American Studies, and La Raza (now Raza). The institutionalization of ethnic studies at San Francisco State University was a catalyst for the development of ethnic studies programs and departments throughout the nation and demanded that our voices be heard and our stories, told. Since the establishment of ethnic studies forty years ago, one of the major goals of the movement was to develop ethnic studies in K-12 public schools. Although ethnic studies has grown at the college and university level, there is still a lack of inclusion in K-12 curriculum. To insure that we address this problem, this unit aims to provide a space to study the history of ethnic studies, the identities of the students, and the stories of their families. TOPIC(s) A. B. C. D. History of ethnic studies and the centrality of race, ethnicity, and culture Student narratives Family narratives Connecting narratives and creating community CONTENT Learning Goals 1. Students will understand the concept of Ethnic Studies and the centrality of race, ethnicity, and culture to the topics the course will cover. Students will understand the role of oral history in Ethnic Studies, including how oral histories are used to maintain cultures. Students will learn the history of how race, ethnicity and culture have affected their family for the last three to four generations and at least three historical events that influenced the family. Students will identify common patterns in the family histories presented by students in the class, particularly patterns of race, ethnicity, and culture. Students will understand how a wide array of other factors intersect with race, ethnicity, and culture to define individual identity, including religion, class, gender, age, and sexual orientation. 2. 3. 4. 5. SKILL Learning Goals 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Historical Literacy: Students will learn the oral history research process, including the development of questions, interview etiquette, note-taking, and analysis of the information gathered. Historical Literacy: Students will learn to look for patterns in data (common themes in the family histories that students in the class present). Historical Literacy: Students will apply analytical concepts to define their personal identities. Language Literacy: Students will develop narrative writing skills (narrating the formation of their identity). Language Literacy: Students will develop oral presentation skills (presenting their family histories). 2 6. Technology Literacy: Students will develop cutting-edge digital presentation skills. LEADERSHIP Learning Goals Students will learn how to the build a community by sharing their personal family histories and making connections to their classmates’ histories. UNIT CONCEPTS Definition, Description, and/or History of the Concept Activity/Project that Highlights the Concept ETHNIC STUDIES AND HISTORY WHAT: What is Ethnic Studies? On Strike Movie and Activity Ethnic Studies is dedicated to the study of race, ethnicity, and culture. Ethnic Studies is a response to the charges that education has generally been focused on a Eurocentric perspective. Ethnic Studies tried to remedy this by trying to study people of color on their own terms, in their own language, acknowledging their own values. Ethnic studies particularly highlights the experiences (struggle and survival) of “Third World” peoples in the United States, people of color, or racially oppressed peoples in the United States. WHO: Whose stories are taught in Ethnic Studies? Ethnic Studies can include any racial, ethnic, or cultural group. The focus in this course is on groups that have not been adequately covered in American history, including but not limited to: African Americans, Native Americans, Latina/o Americans, and Asian Pacific Americans WHERE AND WHEN: The School of Ethnic Studies at San Francisco State College – the first ethnic studies program in the nation – [established in the Fall of 1969] was one of the demands that was actually met as a result of the San Francisco State Student Strike. The establishing of the School as “Ethnic Studies” was a compromise away from “Third World Studies” that the Third World Liberation Front and their student and AFT (American Federation of Teachers) faculty allies had demanded. Though the School of Ethnic Studies was very obviously the product of radical student, faculty and community activism… (Excerpt from Inspiration, Influence, and Intrigue: The Long Reach and Hidden Impacts of Filipino American Studies, Unpublished paper 2008) WHY: Why is Ethnic Studies important? The stories of people of color and ethnic families/communities have not always been represented in the curriculum of America's system of education. The struggle for a full and representative inclusion continues and is central to a democratic society. These identities, issues, and histories/herstories have been overtly and covertly neglected and excluded in the educational system and academic scholarship. This has contributed to a multitude of social, political, economic, psychological problems that have plagued ethnic peoples, such as poverty, violence, colonial mentality, and the lack of political power. Ethnic Studies is important because it’s aims is provide an education that is relevant, empowering, and central to it’s vision is self-determination and 3 social justice. How: How is Ethnic Studies taught? Ethnic Studies is interdisciplinary and can be taught in many ways. This course will include teaching methods from History, Social Studies, English, Creative Arts, and Psychology. This course aims to be student-centered, interactive, and will use problem-posing teaching methods, along with projects where students will be encouraged to develop and compare their narratives of their families and communities. This Ethnic Studies course also aims to provide opportunities for students to gain both academic skills and a sense of civic and community engagement. For more detail, refer the handout on the History of Ethnic Studies by Daniel P. Gonzales, one of the strikers and founders of ethnic studies at San Francisco State University. LIBERATION Freeing of oneself or a group of people from oppression. On Strike COUNTER- Narrative is a story. History is usually presented from one perspective, the grand narrative or metanarrative. Counternarratives challenge the assumption that there is only one way to present history. A perspective that is oftentimes neglected or forgotten. Drawing from the work of D. Solorzano (2005), R. Delgado (1989), and R. Lawson (1995) counterstorytelling is described as “both a method of telling a story of those experiences that have not been told (i.e. those in the margins of society) and a tool for analyzing and challenging the stories of those in power and whose story is a natural part of the dominant discourse—the majoritarian story.” “What is Ethnic Studies?” Discussion This sociohistorical/cultural construct often dictated by the state and by the mass media that artificially divides people into distinct groups based on characteristics such as phenotype, physical appearance, heritage, ancestry, and national origin. Racial categories subsume ethnic groups. Race, as an idea, was developed during the 17th and 18th centuries by European pseudoscientists who were building on work that divided the plant and animal kingdoms into various classifications. These scientists classified certain body types and skin colors into separate “races,” such as Negroid, Caucasoid, and Mongoloid. These ideas were never neutral, however, as all of these systems of racial classifications (from divisions of humanity into three groups up to more than fifty) assumed a hierarchy. It is not a coincidence that these systems were developed hand in hand with justifications for slavery, imperialism, and colonialism. On Strike, Racial Gallery NARRATIVE AND COUNTERSTORYTELLING RACE Racism is the systematic subordination of members of targeted racial groups who have relatively little social power in the United States (African Americans, Latino/as, Native Americans, and Asian Americans), by the members of the agent racial group who has relatively more social power (Whites). This subordination is supported by the actions of individuals, cultural norms and values, and the institutional structures and practices of society (Adams, Bell, and Griffin, 89). When we think about racism, we can look back at hundreds of years of acts of racism. The term “racism,” however, did not actually appear until the 1930s. NATIONALITY Identity that describes one’s citizenship or one’s allegiance to a nation or 4 Racial Gallery government. This term is often misused to refer to one’s race, ethnicity, and/or culture. ETHNICITY CULTURE A dynamic (always changing) social construct in which people are grouped together by shared language, religion, culture, national or regional origin, political and economic interests, and historical experiences, among others. People are grouped together either by state constructions of ethnicity or by their own desire to identify with others who share the same culture, values, traditions, language, and experiences. Many people confuse nationality with ethnicity. However, nationality just means citizenship. Even that is no longer as fixed as it once was as many countries, including the Philippines, are now allowing dual citizenship in our increasingly “transnational” society. Culture (from the Latin cultura stemming from colere, meaning "to cultivate")[1] generally refers to patterns of human activity and the symbolic structures that give such activities significance and importance. Cultures can be "understood as systems of symbols and meanings that even their creators contest, that lack fixed boundaries, that are constantly in flux, and that interact and compete with one another"[2] Racial Gallery Race Gallery and Oral History Project Culture can be defined as all the ways of life including arts, beliefs and institutions of a population that are passed down from generation to generation. Culture has been called "the way of life for an entire society."[3] As such, it includes codes of manners, dress, language, religion, rituals, norms of behavior such as law and morality, and systems of belief as well as the art. A critical cultural discourse includes views of how culture is both static and dynamic through the understandings of: 1. Cultural Past/Preservation: How we connect between culture and history. The efforts of reclaiming and maintaining one’s cultural heritage but also being critical about culture is defined and who has defined it for us. 2. Cultural Politics: How culture has been devalued, appropriated, commodified, and in some cases destroyed through colonialism and imperialism. How culture is related to ethnicity, race, and racism. 3. Cultural (re)Presentation: How culture is represented through literature, media, and popular culture. How media can be used to stereotype and essentialize cultural meanings. How media can be rearticulated to develop our own (re)presentations. 4. Cultural Practice/Praxis: How we theorize cultural practices and how culture is formed and transformed. 5. Cultural Production and Pedagogy: How we create and reproduce culture. How art and literature can produce new cultural meanings. How classrooms play a role in either oppressing culture or become a space for cultural liberation. 6. Cultural Power: How we use cultural work as a form of activism and service. COMMUNITY A community does not have to be a place where a person lives; it can be spread out over a city, a country, or even the world. A community is a place that people build and a place they interact-sometimes physically and sometimes virtually. Sometimes a 'real' community does not even exist, but is 'imagined': a commonly shared historical or cultural belief bonds its members together...The concept of community and the reasons why people choose to identify themselves with a particular community is tied in with complex 5 Document Box and Oral History Project issues of identity: how we define ourselves, how we define and interact with others and how others define us…It also defines who we are, supports our beliefs, gives us friends, and helps us to belong. (From http://www.youthlinks.org, accessed 8-23-06). IDENTITY Identity is not the same as heritage, though many people often conflate the two ideas. Identity is more often about who an individual identifies with rather than what an individual identifies as. Therefore, a person of mixed Filipina/o and Thai heritage may identify first as an Asian American because she feels more in common with other Asian Americans than with either the Thai or Filipina/o American communities. A person of mixed heritage is likely to have a sense of identification with more than one community, so different identities may be fore-grounded at different times. - The collective aspect of the set of characteristics by which a thing is definitively recognizable or known. - The set of behavioral or personal characteristics by which an individual is recognizable as a member or group. - The quality or condition of being the same as something else. - The distinct personality of an individual regarded as a persisting entity; individuality. (Dictionary.com) Document Box, Here’s My Box, My Life’s Soundtrack, Eyedenity Maps, My Story, Oral History Project ORAL HISTORY An oral history is a collection of personal testimonies or stories of events that occurred in people’s lives. Oral history is also the practice of passing down these stories by verbally sharing them with other people. Oral history is one of the most important ways in which we learn about our family and community history. In many cultures, people relied on the tradition of storytelling when there was no written language or when their native language was prohibited from being recorded. Oral histories were often the only means to record historical events, experiences of people, and the cultural teachings. It is an important way of remembering the lives and experiences of those people who are often not in textbooks, movies, and TV. We can also learn about how people felt and responded to historical events through analyzing how people remembered certain events and experiences. It is also a way of learning more details about the historical events and “cultural” practices we have already learned about through the lectures and literature in this course. Document Box, Home Wasn’t Built in a Day, Pod-cast, Oral History Family Project 6 Unit 1.A Lesson Plans What is the Story of Ethnic Studies? Outline of Lesson Plans What is the Story of Ethnic Studies? Why is Ethnic Studies Necessary? 1. On Strike: A Student-Led Movement (150 minutes) 2. Racial Cartoons (50 min) 3. Racial Portraits (50 min) ON STRIKE: A STUDENT-LED MOVEMENT Description: This lesson plan will introduce the History of Ethnic Studies and the student movement led by the Third World Liberation Front at San Francisco State University in 1968. They will view posters and a film that documents the history of the movement that led to establishing ethnic studies nationwide. They will be asked to critically analyze the purpose and necessity of this movement while also making connections to their current educational needs. Lesson Plan Materials: “On Strike!” Movie 1968-69 Poster Powerpoint provided by Daniel P. Gonzalez Handout-1 on the History of San Francisco State Student Strike Handout-2 on the What is Ethnic Studies Worksheet on the On Strike Movie Poster Paper Markers Lesson Plan Definition and Rationale for choosing this word, VOCABULARY phrase, or concept ETHNIC STUDIES See unit concepts for definition. LIBERATION See unit concepts for definition. SOCIAL MOVEMENT A large group of people (or community) fighting against a common enemy and for a common purpose. (Artnelson Concordia, Tibak Training 2006) Acting upon to change the wrongs in society. ACTIVISM STRIKE To stop working or attending a school/college/university as a collective form of protest against injustice. 7 Idea for pre-teaching or front-loading the concept. Poster Gallery, On Strike, Writing Assignments Poster Gallery, On Strike, Poster Gallery, On Strike, Writing Assignments Poster Gallery, On Strike, Writing Assignments On Strike PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Poster Gallery: Students will be asked to view the political posters of the 1968 Student Strike at San Francisco State University led by the Third World Liberation Front. This can be done either powerpoint or reproductions of the posters. Step 1 As the students walk in, play a song that was popular in the 1960’s or 1970’s to set the mood. Step 2 Either have a looping slide show of political posters, photos, newspaper clippings projected onto a screen or poster replicas hanging throughout the classroom to give the feel of a political meeting space. ( a slideshow adapted from a presenation by Daniel P. Gonzales will provided on wikispaces) Step 3 After about 3-5 minutes after the students have settled into the classroom ask the students to take out a piece of paper and write down 3 words that represent the images that they see. Step 4 Facilitate a brainstorm on the board with the word “movement” in the middle and write their words as they each share one on their list. Ask them to try not repeat words. At the end of the brainstorm, try to connect their words to the main concepts for the day. Step 5 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION On Strike: Students will be provided with handout about the San Francisco State Student (partially adapted from a document written by Daniel P. Gonzales, a professor of Asian American Studies in the College of Ethnic Studies at San Francisco State University). Step 1 Pass out Handout 1- On Strike- A Student Led Movement. Give them about 15 minutes to read the handout. Step 2 Have them circle words or statements that are or seem important or significant to the answer. Have them underline words or statements that they do not understand. List the words on the board and begin to define what they mean. Go through the Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How with the students about the strike to make sure that they understand the purpose of the strikers. Step 3 Step 4 Have the students take out a piece of paper and have them do a freewrite for 10 minutes, in their own words, the meaning social movement. The key question of this writing exercise is, If the strike at San Francisco State University was a social movement, what do you think social movement means?” Step 5 Ask some students to share what they wrote. Using the students word, try to come up with a collective definition of social movement. Then share the definition in the main concepts: Step 6 Social Movement: A large group of people (or community) fighting against a common enemy and for a common purpose. (Artnelson Concordia, Tibak Training 2006) Ask the students, “If we agree that this is meaning of social movement, who or what is the common enemy and what is the common purpose of the third world liberation front.” 8 Try to focus on the demands in the first part of the lesson plan. It is important to name the common enemy and common purpose in conceptual terms versus pointing the finger at individuals or white people in general. Common Enemy- Racism Common Purpose- Eliminate Racism Step 7 Pass out the On Strike Movie worksheet which basically ask students to write in their words, the Who, What, Where, When, and How of the movie. After they have completed this discussion, play the On Strike movie. It is about 20 minutes long. Dependent on your allotted class time this entire lesson plan could take between 2 or 3 class sessions. Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 After they watch the movie, which often brings out a lot of emotions, allow them an opportunity to process what they experienced. Have them explore the multiples ways that we process information. Give the students a few minutes to finish up their handout. Make sure they complete the last question on the handout. Then break them up into groups of four. Have each group draw a silhouette of a person on poster paper. Instruct them to write answers to the following within the each section of their silhouette. Each person should contribute answers in each part of the silhouette: Head: Something that made them think Heart: Something that made them feel Hand: Something that made them want to act Feet: Something that made them want to walk away-or something they disagreed with Step 11 Step 12 Step 13 Step 14 Step 15 Step 16 Step 17 Step 18 Step 19 This should take about 20 minutes. After they complete their silhouette, have each group share what they experienced with the movie. At the end of the exercise, connect the similarities and differences of the silhouettes. Have the students end with writing an essay that builds on their earlier paper on the handout. Have them re-read the handout and ask them to pick out one quote that they want to expand on. Show them how to cite the quote and how to use it in an essay. Then given them 20 minutes to write an essay answering, “What is the social movement that started ethnic studies? Why is it important to learn about this movement? And How is social movement relevant to our lives?” This can also be assigned for homework. After the students turn in their essays, make sure to conclude with a discussion centered around the questions they were asked in their essay. Pass out the What is Ethnic Studies? Handout. Have them circle words or statements that are or seem important or significant to the answer. Have them underline words or statements that they do not understand. Break up the students into 5 groups. Assign each group a different part of the handout: Who, What, Where and When, Why, and How. Have each group read their section and discuss how their section is different than their other history courses that they have taken. They should have 15 minutes to do this. Then have each group share what they discussed to the larger group. (This can also be jigsawed.) End with having the students write a journal about what they believe ethnic studies is all about including what they learned in this lesson plan. PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE 9 Conclude with having the students write a journal about what they learned in this lesson plan with regard to the history of ethnic studies. Then lead a discussion about the following: Problems/Questions of the Day: What is the story of ethnic studies? Why is it important to learn ethnic studies? Connection: How is ethnic studies relevant to our lives? Have the students remember the cultural energizer with the powerpoint of posters, and ask them, “ If you could create your own poster that would express the meaning of ethnic studies, what would be the statement that you would try to represent?” Assessment: What were the effective parts of this lesson plan and why? What parts could be improved and how? RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources SF State College of Ethnic Studies Website: http://www.sfsu.edu/~ethnicst/home3.html Barlow, William and Peter Shapiro. An End to Silence: The San Francisco State Student Movement in the 60s. New York: Pegasus, a division of the Bobbs-Merrill Company, Inc., 1971. Gonzales, Daniel. P. Inspiration, Influence, and Intrigue: The Long Reach and Hidden Impacts of Filipino American Studies, Unpublished Paper, 2008. Hare, Nathan . “A Conceptual Proposal for a Department of Black Studies.” In Shut It Down! A College in Crisis: San Francisco State College: October, 1968–April 1969, edited by William H. Orrick, Jr. Washington, D.C.: the U.S Government Printing Office for The National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, 1969. Hirabayashi, James A. “Ethnic Education: Its Purposes and Prospects.” Paper presented at the Second Annual Conference on Emerging Programs, University of Washington, Seattle, 1974. San Francisco State University, Asian American Studies Department. Dreams, Realities, and Challenges in Asian American Studies. San Francisco: Asian American Studies Department, 1998. Smith, Robert, et al. By Any Means necessary: The Revolutionary Struggle at San Francisco State. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1970. Louie, Steve and Glenn Omatsu , eds. Asian Americans: The Movement and the Moment. Los Angeles: UCLA Asian American Studies Center Press, 2000. Orrick, Jr., William H. Shut It Down! A College in Crisis: San Francisco State College: October, 1968–April 1969. Washington, D.C.: the U.S Government Printing Office for The National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, 1969. Tam, Alice. “The San Francisco State College Strike of 1968-1969: Through the Eyes and Voices of Asian Americans.” The Yellow Journal 9/10, no. 9 (Spring 2000) : 145-146. Umemoto, Karen. “Asian American Students in the San Francisco State College Strike, 1964-1968.” M.A. diss, University of California, Los Angeles, 1989. Whitson, Helene. Strike!: A Chronology, Bibliography, and List of Archival Materials Concerning the 1968-69 Strike at San Francisco State College. Educational resources Information Center, 1977. Whitson, Helene and others. On Strike! Shut It Down! A revolution at San Francisco State: Elements of Change. San Francisco: Rapid Copy Center of the J. Paul Leonard Library, 1999. 10 Notes Make sure to watch the On Strike video prior to showing it to the students to know what parts you should emphasize. Background Information for Teacher: History of Ethnic Studies Adapted from a handout created by Professor Daniel P. Gonzales, Asian American Studies Department, San Francisco State University In Pin@y Educational Partnerships: A Filipina/o American Studies Sourcebook, Volume II (2008) 1. What is Ethnic Studies? Ethnic studies is an academic discipline dedicated to the study of race, ethnicity, and culture. It evolved in the second half of the 20th century partly in response to charges that traditional disciplines such as anthropology, history, English, ethnology, Asian Studies, and orientalism were imbued with an inherently eurocentric perspective. Ethnic Studies tried to remedy this by trying to study people of color on their own terms, in their own language, acknowledging their own values. In the United States, the discipline of Ethnic Studies evolved out of the civil rights movement in the late 1960s and early 1970s, which saw growing self-awareness and radicalization of people of color such as African-Americans, Asian Americans, Latino Americans, and American Indians. Ethnic Studies departments were established on many campuses and grew to encompass African American Studies, Asian American Studies, Raza Studies, Chicano Studies, and Native American Studies. The first strike for Ethnic Studies occurred in 1968, (led by Third World Liberation Front, a joint effort of the Afro-American Student Association, Mexican American Students Confederation, Asian American Political Alliance, Pilipino American Collegiate Endeavor, and Native American Students Union at San Francisco State University); it was the longest student strike in the nation's history, and resulted in the establishment of a School of Ethnic Studies, when President S.I. Hayakawa ended the strike by taking a hardline approach, appointed Dr. James Hirabayashi the first dean of the School (now College) of Ethnic Studies at San Francisco State University) [1]), and increased recruiting and admissions of students of color in response to the strike's demands. Courses in Ethnic Studies tried to address the criticism that the role of Asian Americans, Blacks, Latinos and Native Americans in American history was undervalued and ignored because of Euro-centric bias. Ethnic Studies also often encompasses issues of gender, class, and sexuality. In general, an "Ethnic Studies approach" is loosely defined as any approach that emphasizes the cross-relational and intersectional study of different groups. (Source: wikipedia) 2. What was the political and global context in which ethnic studies was created? Ethnic Studies arose from the discourse and political action on race, class, gender, and civil rights in the United States. The polarized American Left/Right debates of the late 1950s through the early 1970s were centered on civil rights and the Vietnam War amidst contentious social and political change. From the end of World War II, anti-colonial nationalism became a global phenomenon fueled by democratic and socialist militancy. The United States was engaged in neocolonial activity in Latin America, Asia, and Africa. Conservative, “reactionary,” “hawkish”(pro-war) foreign policy was favored by the American 11 majority while progressive legal and political activists (“doves”) gained strength at home against conservative “establishment” resistance. 3. Why was ethnic studies created? The formation of Ethnic Studies as a general academic construct was the result of: a. frustration with the continuing historical contradictions between American social and political ideals and the reality of racism, sexism, poverty, and injustice; b. critical race and class analysis of higher education in the United States from the position of civil rights and Third World consciousness, values, and criteria of the post-World War II era of anti-colonial nationalist movements; and c. student-initiated activism premised on democratic inclusion, social justice, and selfdetermination. Many mainstream commentators cite racism and the struggle against it as the superior justification for the creation of Ethnic Studies. (Hirabayashi, 2) Others cite the practical and theoretical irrelevance of traditional Eurocentric education from the perspective of Third World-conscious Americans as the major rationale for Ethnic Studies. Better sources— usually writers who participated in or were close witnesses to the actual construction and implementation of Ethnic Studies at San Francisco State University—cite the drive to define their cultural and political identities as the engine that motivated the quest for educational relevance. The central paradigm (philosophical framework) of Ethnic Studies was cultural pluralism: many cultures coexisting within a larger social, economic, and political framework. (Hirabayashi, 2) Using cultural pluralism as the main organizing construct allowed for the accommodation of divergent rationales for the formation of ethnic studies, while encouraging the growth and forward motion of the ethnic-specific departments on their separate agendas. 4. How was ethnic studies created? Under the leadership of Jimmy Garrett, Benny Stewart, and Jerry Vernardo, the Black Students Union (BSU) at SF State requested the establishment of a Black Studies department in 1966. The organization chose to rename itself from the Negro Students Association, as it was founded in 1963. (Orrick, 78) A few courses with black content were developed but were offered as experimental classes in various departments rather than as an integrated, permanent curriculum. Dr. Juan Martinez was a charismatic Chicano historian and dynamic speaker who encouraged students to unite across racial and ethnic lines and take radical action to seize power and restructure the college to serve their needs and the needs of their communities. The frustration of the BSU and the TWLF with the administrations of Presidents Summerskill and Smith, self-described liberals—each of whom would resign under pressure—gave rise to the formation in 1968 of the Third World Liberation Front (TWLF) coalition of SFSC Associated Students organizations. The first two organizations to join the coalition were the Philippine 12 American Collegiate Endeavor (PACE) and the Mexican American Student Confederation (MASC). In April 1968, Dr. Nathan Hare wrote “A Conceptual Proposal for a Department of Black Studies,” a salient sociopedagogical rationale for Black Studies. Dr. Hare criticized “tokenism:” the corporate/establishment political practice of hiring individuals with “non-white” racial minority characteristics and backgrounds as proof of an apparent position against racism. He also analyzed liberalarts values and academic standards as racist—exclusionary in effect, if not intent—while underscoring the absolute necessity of community involvement and “collective stimulation”, using black/African culture as both content and medium of learning. Hare concluded by emphasizing the relevance of a Black Studies curriculum to students and the community, and the ultimate purpose of black studies: graduates applying black studies back to benefit their work in their community to effectively address and resolve real issues and problems there. His reasoning was supported and adapted by the other ethnic-based organizations of the TWLF in their pursuit of the establishment of American Indian, La Raza, and Asian American Studies departments. The Hare rationale for Black Studies became the central argument for the establishment of the School of Ethnic Studies. The BSU called for a general boycott of classes on November 6, 1968 after having served notice to President Smith of 10 original demands, including the hiring of more black and Third World faculty, the establishment of a unified Black Studies department, and the admission of all black applicants for admission to the college. The TWLF subsequently added five more demands including the establishment of an independent School of Third World Studies. The conservative “Faculty Renaissance” of SFSC was aligned with the Board of Trustees of the entire State College system, the majority of the state legislature, and then Governor Ronald Reagan in staunch authoritarian opposition to any accommodation of student demands. (Barlow and Shapiro, 228-236) President John Summerskill resigned during the volatile prelude to the strike. President Robert Smith would resign during the strike. Despite denials by the Governor and Mayor Joseph Alioto of San Francisco, SF State students—including some who were not even active participants in the strike—were victims of unnecessary, often gratuitous, and sometimes extreme violence at the hands of both local and state police. For example, police at a nonviolent sit-in demonstration in spring 1968 struck PACE leader Alex Soria, causing a bloody head injury that required emergency medical treatment. The discovery of guns and explosive devices on campus gave full rationale to the hard line law-and-order stance that increased the popularity of Governor Reagan, first to national then to international levels of heroic conservative status. After his unilateral appointment as replacement for 13 the resigned President Smith, S. I. “Sam” Hayakawa mirrored the Reagan stance and thereby earned the praise of conservatives worldwide as an uncompromising law-andorder administrator—with apparent racial minority “color” credentials—though he had little to do with the actual management of the campus. Hayakawa had no qualms about bringing police onto the campus. (Barlow and Shapiro, 248255) In spring 1969, the SFPD, the principal police presence, and visiting police units from other jurisdictions used “experimental” non-lethal weapons including long clubs that mimicked Feudal Asian swords, martial arts weapons, tear and pepper gas. During the second half of the strike, SWAT (Special Weapons and Tactics) teams and riot control squads from throughout the Western states came to SF State to “train” for “crowd control” and mass violence. Many of the martial arts weapons employed by the SFPD through the 1970s were subsequently found to be too injurious and were barred from police use. For the duration of the strike, over four-and-a-half months, sporadic violence was reported by the news media. Several frustrated attempts at the negotiation of major issues between the two sides leading to gradual movement toward compromise and resolution began in February 1969. The TWLF Central Committee and a “select committee” of local community leaders with authority to negotiate an end to the strike came to agreement on several demands. Though President Hayakawa never signed the final draft of the agreement, the agreement was implemented. 4. What were the goals and beliefs of ethnic studies? (Define) Self-determination/inclusion: Self-determination is the right and power of a people to make decisions and to take action consistent with their own best interests. The founders of Ethnic Studies believed that inclusion in social and political processes via selfrepresentation was a fundamental principle of democracy. Self-determination is a correlative element of representation that was necessary to counter the long history of misrepresentation of Third World people in the social institutions of the West, particularly the academe. Community Advocacy: Ethnic Studies was envisioned as a forum for presenting the primary experiences of Third World people, their perspectives on those experiences, and the social, economic, and political needs of Third World communities. Ethnic Studies faculty members were expected to be advocates for and representatives of the needs of communities where they had primary experience. Connection of the Community to the Academy and Community Service: Consistent with the values held by the student founders of Ethnic Studies and as stated by Dr. Nathan Hare in his rationale for Black Studies, active community involvement by 14 students and faculty is a necessary component of Ethnic Studies. Dr. Hare saw that the application of Black Studies by graduates to address and resolve community issues and problems was the ultimate goal of their program. That value position was shared by all of the departments of Ethnic Studies. What are current mission and goals of San Francisco State’s College of Ethnic Studies? In our teaching, scholarship and creative work, we specifically analyze structural forms of oppression and address the intersections of race, ethnicity, and other forms of identity and social status. Our work affirms comparative and transdisciplinary approaches to national and diasporic questions. The primary aim of the College of Ethnic Studies is to actively implement a vision of social justice focusing on social inequalities that exist on the basis of race and ethnicity. Therefore our teaching, encouragement, and mentoring of students and student organizations have the goal of developing long-term leadership skills, knowledge of self, and collaborative activist abilities within and between communities of color and indigenous peoples. In 1968-69, students of the black student union and third world liberation front, staff and faculty, as well as members from the larger Bay Area community, organized and lead a series of actions to protest systematic discrimination, lack of access, neglect, and misrepresentation of histories cultures and knowledge of indigenous peoples and communities of color within the university's curriculum and programs. Their specific demands included the establishment of our departments - Asian American Studies, Black Studies, La Raza Studies, Native American Studies - in Ethnic Studies. These demands reflected a respect for the diverse intellectual traditions and cultural expressions of the scholars, activists, and artists of communities of color and indigenous people throughout the U.S., and a fierce commitment to the concept of self-determination through education. The faculty, students, and staff of the college recognize and affirm the principles of community-based research and teaching, student leadership and activism, and the serf-determination of communities of color and indigenous peoples on which the college was founded. This affirmation includes respect for the holistic and integrative educational models, epistemologies, ecologies, and world views of our diverse communities and peoples. Reference: SFSU College of Ethnic Studies Website: http://www.sfsu.edu/~ethnicst/home3.html Bibliography: [Note: Original sources based on research, interviews, and observations made at or near the actual time of the strike and the implementation of Ethnic Studies were favored over more recent, retrospective writing, including those by Karen Umemoto and Glenn Omatsu.] Hare, Nathan (1968). “A Conceptual Proposal for a Department of Black Studies.” In Shut It Down! A College in Crisis: San Francisco State College: October, 1968–April 1969, edited by William H. Orrick, Jr. Washington, D.C.: the U.S Government Printing Office for The National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, 1969. Hirabayashi, James A. “Ethnic Education: Its Purposes and Prospects.” Paper presented at the Second Annual Conference on Emerging Programs, University of Washington, Seattle, 1974. 15 Orrick, Jr., William H. Shut It Down! A College in Crisis: San Francisco State College: October, 1968–April 1969. Washington, D.C.: the U.S Government Printing Office for The National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, 1969. Barlow, William and Peter Shapiro. An End to Silence: The San Francisco State Student Movement in the 60s. New York: Pegasus, a division of the Bobbs-Merrill Company, Inc., 1971. Settlement of the Demands of the Third World Liberation Front No. 1 Demand That a School of Ethnic Studies for the ethnic groups involved in the Third World be set up with the students in each particular ethnic organization having the authority and control of the hiring and retention of any faculty member, director, or administrator', as well as the curriculum in a specific area study. 2 That 50 faculty positions be appropriated to the School of Ethnic Studies, 20 of which would be for the Black Studies program. That, in the Spring semester, the College fulfill its commitment to the non-white students in admitting those who apply. That, in the fall of 1969, all applications of non-white students be accepted. 3 4 5 That George Murray1 and any other faculty person chosen by non-white people as their teacher be retained in their positions. Settlement a. The College would endeavor to establish a School of Ethnic Studies to begin operation in the Fall Semester 1969. The College will need additional funding for this purpose. b. The School will equal existing Schools of the College in status and structure. c. The college would establish a community board to recommend faculty appointments to the President. a. Allocation of faculty positions to the School of Ethnic Studies will follow upon Spring planning and resources acquired by the College. a. One hundred twenty-eight E.O.P. (Educational Opportunity Program) students were admitted for the Spring 1969 semester. a. The College agreed to admit approximately 500 qualified nonwhite students for the Fall 1969 semester and was actively recruiting such students. There were also to be about 400 non-white students as special admittees. b. The College committed itself to funding and staffing for an Economic Opportunity Program (E.O.P.).- Now the Educational Opportunity Program. c. The College agreed that parallel admissions standards are necessary for Third World people if the College is to fulfill its educational responsibilities in an urban environment. a. This decision would be referred to the community advisory board. The suspension of English instructor (and Black Panther Minister of Education) George Mason Murray on November 1, 1968, was the catalyst for five months of confrontation and tension. George Murray was a graduate student in English and had been hired to teach special introductory English classes for minority students admitted to the college under a special program. 1 16 Further Resolutions 1. That a committee of students, faculty, and staff, ethnically mixed, be formed immediately to advise the College on how to deal with the charges of racism at the College. A first task for this committee will be to recommend procedures for dealing with claims of racism within the college. 2. That the procedure for appointing an ombudsman be started again and pressed to as rapid a conclusion as possible. 3. The College shall establish, through its Academic Senate and the Council of Academic Deans, a small committee to expedite decision-making and action concerning all aspects of this agreement. 4. In recognition of the urgency of the present situation, we recommend that the Chancellor and Trustees expedite in every way possible the consideration of any requests for special resources presented by the College President which arise from the extraordinary needs of the College at this time. 5. In instances where differences of interpretation occur in the precise meaning of any part of this agreement, final and mutually binding decisions upon all parties shall be made by a three-man group composed of one person named by the President of San Francisco State College, one person named by the Dean of the School of Ethnic Studies and the Chairmen of the various Ethnic Studies Departments, and a third person selected by these two. 6. Staffing and admission policies of the School of Ethnic Studies shall be non-discriminatory. 7. Police should be withdrawn immediately upon the restoration of peace to the campus. 8. The state of emergency on campus should be rescinded immediately upon settlement of the strike, together with the emergency regulations restricting assemblies, rallies, etc. 9. The College shall resume planning for a Constitutional Convention and for a student conference on the governance of the urban campus. 10. The students and the administration together recognize the necessity of developing machinery for peaceful resolution of future disputes, arising from conditions or needs outside the terms of this agreement. 11. The student organizations signatory to this agreement and the College agree that they will utilize the full influence of their organizations to insure an effective implementation of this agreement.* *The above points are condensed from the March 20, 1969, document of resolution, signed by representatives of the Third World Liberation Front, the Black Students Union, and the members of the Select Committee This Handout was adapted from The San Francisco State College Strike Collection Introductory Essay by Helene Whitson handout created for the PEP Sourcebook by Dan Gonzales 17 RACIAL GALLERY Description: This lesson plan will introduce the concepts of race, ethnicity, and culture. Through a preliminary look at how these concepts are imbedded in our psyche, we will begin to uncover the relationship between oppression and resistance. Lesson Plan Materials: Photos of People from all different racial and ethnic backgrounds-draw from pop culture references (hardcopy or digital) Racial Cartoons (hardcopy or digital) Poster Paper Markers Lesson Plan Definition and Rationale for choosing this word, VOCABULARY phrase, or concept RACE See unit concepts for definition. RACISM The systematic subordination of members of targeted racial groups who have relatively little social power in the United States (African Americans, Latino/as, Native Americans, and Asian Americans), by the members of the agent racial group who has relatively more social power (Whites). This subordination is supported by the actions of individuals, cultural norms and values, and the institutional structures and practices of society (Adams, Bell, and Griffin, 89). When we think about racism, we can look back at hundreds of years of acts of racism. The term “racism,” however, did not actually appear until the 1930s. RACIAL HIERARCHY The racial hierarchy developed integrally with the concept of race implies that one racialized group is the closest to God or perfection—those defined as “white.” It is this hierarchy that causes difficulty for people of mixed heritage, as the hierarchy means that one group is always considered above another group so that a person of mixed heritage will be seen as forever torn between a lower group and a higher group—the worst situation being if the person has a “white” parent, because if he or she has any heritage “of color” they cannot, by definition, be “ white.” ETHNICITY CULTURE NATIONALITY OPPRESSION See unit concepts for definition. See unit concepts for definition. See unit concepts for defintion An unjust or cruel exercise of power or authority. Institutional Oppression: Unfair and unjust policies or laws passed by the government, schools, the judicial systems, military, and law enforcement. These institutions are used to 18 Idea for pre-teaching or front-loading the concept. protect the privileges of elites, or people in power, by withholding privileges enjoyed by the elite and/or basic civil rights from people who don’t have access to institutional power and keeping less powerful people divided. These systems are enforced by mass media, police, schools, and family values Interpersonal Oppression: Internalizing systemic or institutional oppression, which, in turn, negatively affects your behavior towards others. Internalized Oppression: Internalizing oppressive messages you see or hear in mass media, in national/state/local governments, or in such institutions as your church and family. You begin to believe, accept and live out stereotypes, lies and misinformation about yourself and your community. RESISTANCE PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Celebrity Gallery-What’s Their Race?: Description Students look at photos of celebrities to describe Step 1 Put the five photos of pop culture/political icons: Barack Obama Rob Schneider Kimora Lee Oprah Winfrey Christina Aguilera Vin Diesel Keanu Reeves Jessica Alba Lou Diamond Phillips Rihanna Tony Parker MC Solarr Alexander Dumas And … TEACHER photo _______________ (race) _______________ (ethnicity) _______________ (culture) _______________ (nationality) Step 2 Step 3 During the first ten minutes, students look at the photos and write the following for each image: 1) race; 2) ethnicity; 3) culture, and 4) nationality. Have students volunteer responses with the class. Pay attention to the different ways in which race, ethnicity, and culture intersect and disagree with what we expect. For instance, Barack Obama is multi-racial and multi-ethnic, and is persistently seen as a foreigner despite the fact that he was born in Hawaii. Additionally, we can guess about race and ethnicity through sight, but usually can’t SEE people’s culture and nationality. 19 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Racial Cartoons: Description Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Show the film Race the Power of an Illusion: The Story We Tell. Discuss the ways in which 1800s scientists used science to try and justify the racial divisions and categories they came up with. Show racist political cartoons. At each one, discuss which group is being represented, how they’re represented, and why “white” America perceived them that way. Have students write how the racist political cartoons make them feel, both political cartoons about their race, as well as political cartoons of other race as well. Discuss the context and changes between the racist depictions of yesteryear and if they see it as a past thing or something that is ongoing. Emphasize that different groups have been viewed as racially different than “whites”, and that has historically provided the basis for discrimination and violence. PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE In the last five minutes, discuss how race is only one component of who we are. It has often been applied to people without their consent, and used to justify mistreatment. Problems/Questions of the Day: How does race shape who we are? Connection: Discuss: the ways race, culture, ethnicity, and identity are not interchangeable; how we are oftentimes labeled with race, culture, and ethnicity by others; and how all of them contribute to who we are. Assessment: What were the effective parts of this lesson plan and why? What parts could be improved and how? RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources Notes Include Handouts and Worksheets. 20 Unit 1.B Lesson Plans What is the My Story? Outline of Lesson Plans What is My Story? Why is My Story Important? 1. Fragments of History: Teacher’s Document Box (50 min) 2. Here’s My Box: Peer to Peer Interview (100 min) 3. My Life’s Soundtrack (50 min) 4. Eye-dentity Maps (50 min) Homework Essay: My Story- A written narrative analyzing how race, ethnicity, and culture define them at this point in their lives. FRAGMENTS OF HISTORY: TEACHER’S DOCUMENT BOX Description: Students examine “artifacts” from teacher’s lives to develop historical thinking skills and an awareness of what creates identity. Lesson Plan Materials: Box/packet with o Childhood artifact o Family artifact o Professional artifact o Academic artifact o Hobby/personal interest artifact Lesson Plan Definition and Rationale for choosing this word, VOCABULARY phrase, or concept Idea for preteaching or frontloading the concept. IDENTITY RACE GENDER SEXUAL ORIENTATION CULTURE PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Who are we?: Students examine their teacher’s appearance to guess about what s/he is like, and look at the difference between observations and inferences. Step 1 Step 2 The teacher briefly describes the differences between “observations” (what we can see) and “inferences” (what we think it means/why it matters). Students pair up and write down their observations, matched with their inferences. 21 Step 3 After five minutes, have students share. PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Teacher’s Box: Students examine artifacts a teacher has selected to represent his/her identity. This is done to demonstrate some of the different aspects that form our identities. Additionally, students learn the process for the next lesson, in which students make their own boxes. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Divide the class into groups of 4-5 students. Distribute boxes to the groups. Students have the remainder of class to examine the boxes. Using the Teacher Box Worksheet, students will write what they infer about their teacher, making sure to include why they infer that. At the end of class, explain what each of the artifacts is, and what they mean to you. PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Lead a discussion about the following: Problems/Questions of the Day: Who are we? How do we know? Connection: Who we are is a reflection of the people around us, the things that we do, and our experiences. What would students choose to have reflect themselves? Preview the following days’ assignment on creating their own artifact boxes and interpreting each other’s. Assessment: What were the effective parts of this lesson plan and why? What parts could be improved and how? RESOURCES AND NOTES Make sure that you have the boxes assembled prior to class. To foster a full discussion and investigation, each box should contain different materials. Each box should still be from the same aspects of the teacher’s life (academic, professional, etc.). However, they should have different academic information, and different professional information. Also, make sure to label each artifact so students can compare them more easily. Examples of artifacts may include: Childhood artifact Family artifact Professional artifact Academic artifact Hobby/personal interest artifact Baby photo/childhood toy/etc. E-mail to relative/family photo/etc. Credential/paycheck/etc. Report card/old school essay/etc. Hobby magazine/movie ticket/etc. Notes from Barbara Blinick: I usually start with a lecture/discussion on how we learn/know history. In that discussion students throw out the usual suspects: letters, journals, photographs, documents, driver's licenses, etc. That is where we get the list of items they can include. I also allow a limited number of artifacts (sports medals, etc.). I ask them to bring 10 documents, but no more than two of the same type of document (letters, for example), just to get a variety. Of course, the day before I assign the activity, I model it for them. Last year I did 22 make multiple boxes of my own docs, so they could work in small groups instead of having me walk them through it in class. That worked much better. Ideally each collection of documents would be the same but lead different groups to different conclusions, so they could see how historians fight over meaning. OR, you could add documents and without labeling it, create "revisionist" histories so that students would get additional documents that might change their interpretations. Hmmm, good idea!!! Obviously, what I bring heavily influences what they bring. The suggestions is to make very clear they cannot just empty out their wallets the day of the activity. Not only would that violate the "no more than two of the same document" rule, it is boring. They also have to bring the documents in some kind of bag, box, or envelope (also helps with completion of the document collections). 23 Names: Date: Period: Teacher Box Artifact What we infer 24 Why we infer it HERE’S MY BOX: PEER-TO-PEER INTERVIEW Description: Students create their own “artifacts” boxes and examine each others to learn about each others’ identities. Lesson Plan Materials: Student Box Worksheet Lesson Plan Definition and Rationale for choosing this word, VOCABULARY phrase, or concept Idea for preteaching or frontloading the concept. IDENTITY RACE GENDER SEXUAL ORIENTATION CULTURE PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Teacher’s Box Recap: Students examine their teacher’s appearance to guess about what s/he is like, and look at the difference between observations and inferences. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Ask for a student volunteer to summarize the meaning of “observation” and “inference”. Ask for a different student volunteer to describe the process yesterday to look at the teacher’s artifacts and make inferences. Transition into the activity by describing the next two days’ assignment. PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Student Boxes: Students plan and create their own identity boxes. They exchange them and practice inferring information about their partners. Then, they debrief and check to see if their inferences were correct. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Students have one day to plan what which artifacts they will present to their partners to represent themselves. Suggest to them the same categories their teacher used: Childhood artifact, Family artifact, Professional artifact, Academic artifact, and Hobby/personal interest artifact. As homework, they must compile their artifacts to be ready for use the following day. Using the Student Box Worksheet, students have 30 minutes to analyze one another’s boxes to infer how they identify themselves. Afterwards, students have 10 minutes to discuss with their partners what each artifact was intended to represent, and what the other person inferred from it. PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE 25 Lead a discussion about the following: Problems/Questions of the Day: Who are we? How do we know? Connection: Who we are is a reflection of the people around us, the things that we do, and our experiences. What did students choose to represent themselves? Did their partners infer what they intended? Why? Why not? Assessment: What were the effective parts of this lesson plan and why? What parts could be improved and how? RESOURCES AND NOTES 26 Names: Date: Period: Student Box Artifact What we infer 27 Why we infer it MY LIFE’S SOUNTRACK Title: Description Lesson Plan Materials: Lesson Plan Definition and Rationale for choosing this word, VOCABULARY phrase, or concept Idea for pre-teaching or front-loading the concept. PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Title: Description Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Title: Description Step 1 Pass out L.I.F.E. Packet 2 Make sure everyone has a packet and writing tools L.I.F.E. Packet 2 is designed for the participants to share the songs that motivate and inspire them to think and describe about the themes of L.I.F.E. Step 2 Go Over the Acronym of L.I.F.E. Leadership Identity Future Empowerment Describe and emphasize a connection of how these themes/elements are critically infomative sense of self consciousness and awareness in various perspectives of one’s 28 story/narrative. Take a brainstorm list of artists/groups/songs that the participants are really inspired by as they listen to them. Ask the students “why” does that musician or song emobdy that them “What” is significant about that song that you feel or relate to… Step 3 Step 4 Go over each theme one at a time. 10-15 Minutes per Theme. As you go over each theme share one of your own experiences related to the theme or ask any students to share their reflections. As students are sharing a song Create a Play list for Each them that will be represented by 4 different Butcher Papers. ** If there is time participants can start designing their shoes** Conclusive Dialouge: As the workshop concludes reflect on L.I.F.E. Ask the sutdents that sometimes the way we feel and dream are expressed/inspired through our favorite songs. Let the participants know that in the next class everyone will receive a PlayList of inspirational theme songs of L.I.F.E. that everyone was able to share in class today. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 Step 11 Step 12 PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Connection: Assessment: RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources Adapted from a Lesson Plan Developed by Jonell Molina in the PEP Sourcebook, Volume II (2008). 29 Notes 30 MY EYE-DENTITY Title: Description Lesson Plan Materials: Lesson Plan Definition and Rationale for choosing this word, VOCABULARY phrase, or concept Idea for pre-teaching or front-loading the concept. PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Title: Description Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Title: Description Step 1 Do an Utak Bagyo (Brainstorm) on identity on the board. Some of the words that will probably come up are: Race, Ethnicity, Parents, Music, Friends, Neighborhood, and Gender/Sex. Step 2 Begin the Identity Map or I-Map Exercise. Give the students the following instructions, and pass out construction paper and pens. You may also want to give the students other supplies to create a more three-dimensional I-Map. This can also be printed onto a T-shirt (you would have to instruct students to bring plain T-shirts to class, or provide them with T-shirts and T-shirt paint). If you turn this into a T-shirt activity, make sure to bring some examples of the identity T-shirts such as those made by Wendell Pascual, who designed Downright Pinoy, or designs by Ed Habacon from Tribal Pinoy, or from Glenda Macatangay’s clothing/art company called Cocoa. 31 Instructions: Create an I-Map. Make a list of words that you associate with the development of your identity. The focus is on the development, rather than just one word that you identify with. Identities are infinitely complex. After coming up with a list of words, draw an identity map with these words that show how you formed your identity. It is important to see the influences and decisions that you have made about your identity through this map. You will have 20 minutes to work on your maps. Step 3 Show the students an example of your own map. You should prepare one prior to executing the lesson plan. You can also show the example in this lesson plan. Step 4 When the students are done, have them share their maps with the class. You may have to choose only a few students to share if you do not have enough time, or you can let them present the next day. Step 5 After students have shared their I-Maps, facilitate a concluding discussion on what they learned about their identity. Begin the Identity Map or I-Map Exercise. Give the students the following instructions, and pass out construction paper and pens. You may also want to give the students other supplies to create a more three-dimensional I-Map. This can also be printed onto a T-shirt (you would have to instruct students to bring plain T-shirts to class, or provide them with T-shirts and T-shirt paint). If you turn this into a T-shirt activity, make sure to bring some examples of the identity T-shirts such as those made by Wendell Pascual, who designed Downright Pinoy, or designs by from Glenda Macatangay’s clothing/art company called Cocoa. Step 6 Instructions: Create an I-Map. Make a list of words that you associate with the development of your identity. The focus is on the development, rather than just one word that you identify with. Identities are infinitely complex. After coming up with a list of words, draw an identity map with these words that show how you formed your identity. It is important to see the influences and decisions that you have made about your identity through this map. You will have 20 minutes to work on your maps. PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Connection: Assessment: RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources Notes 32 33 Unit 1.C What are Our Families’ Stories? How do our Stories Connect Outline of “My Family, My Self” Project Day 1: Day 2 and 3: Day 4: Day 5: Day 6 to 8: Day 9 and 10: Day 11 to 15: Family Oral History Project Introduction Each student creates a portfolio titled “My Family, My Self” that includes -A family tree for at least three generations -A podcast of an oral history interview of an older member of the family -A paper on the life of their family member -A digital and oral presentation summarizing their family history for at least three generations My Family Tree (100 min-with homework) Starting with what you know: Meaningful Questions and Creating a Space for Storytelling (50 min) -Creating Questions -Doing the Interview -Transcribing -Creating a Podcast Home Wasn’t Built in A Day: Constructing the Stories of Our Families (50 min) Readings: Grandma & Granddaughter by Ursula Fung Yemen by Jamaal Ghanem (Students from Galileo Academy of Science & Technology, 2006) Model Oral History Essays by High School Students Oral History Paper -Draft should be due a day or two before the presentations begin. -Final draft should be due on one of the last days of this unit. (Both in class and for homework) Creating a Powerpoint Presentation (50 min) Oral Presentations: Activities on how to connect the oral histories (5-7) minutes per student) 34 DAY 1 INTRODUCING THE “MY FAMILY, MY SELF” PROJECT Description: In this part of the unit, students will be introduced to the History of Lesson Plan Materials: Packet that Outlines the “My Family, My Self” Project Examples of Oral Histories PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Title: What is an Oral History? Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Title: Detailed description of the activity. Lesson Steps: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Why is an Oral History Project Important? RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources Notes 35 What is Oral History? Oral history is a collection of personal testimonies or stories of events that occurred in people’s lives. Oral history is also the practice of passing down these stories by verbally sharing them with other people. Why Is Oral History important? Oral history is one of the most important ways that we learn about the lives of our ancestors, family members, ourselves, etc. In many cultures, people relied on the tradition of storytelling when there was no written language to record historical events or the experiences of the people. Also, many times in books or movies, the experiences of some people are left out of the story. Oral history is an important way of remembering the lives and experiences of those people not often heard. It is also a way of learning more details about historical events we have already learned about through reading. Grading: You will be graded on the following three parts of the Oral History Project: 1. 2. 3. Oral History Paper Oral History Visual Representation Oral History Presentation If you have any questions about the Oral History Project or for additional help, ask any PEP teacher at school or through email. Please work with your mentor to complete this project. To begin your Oral History Project, follow these steps: 36 Step One: Identify your interviewee Select one member of your family who will be the subject of your Oral History Project. This person MUST BE over 30 years old. It is a good idea to pick someone who will be open and willing to share information about her/his past. Step Two: Personal Oral History Interview your family member about three significant events in their life as a Filipina/o American. Ask your family member if she/he would be willing to participate in your project. Ask her/him questions you formulated on the “Interview Question Sheet” and any additional questions you feel would be good to ask. Then, transcribe the interview. In other words, type out the entire text of the interview, including everything you said and/or asked, and all of the responses of your interviewee. You will now have a transcript, an entire, complete record, of the interview to work with and quote from. This might take a while, but the transcript is especially useful when you want to read exactly what your interviewee said. Step Three: Write your paper After your have interviewed your family member, you must write a paper in the form of a story that gives your readers insight into that person’s life. The three significant events should be contextualized in Filipina/o American History (use the notes you have taken in class and from readings that can be provided by your mentor). Although you are writing a story, your paper should still be structured in an organized fashion. We will review in class the proper way to construct your paper. Step Four: Create a Poster Your poster should include pictures relevant to your family member’s history. You can also include text, words, images, or drawings that relate to their three significant events that make up their personal oral history. Remember to take great care with her/his pictures, as they may be old and have great sentimental value. If she/he will not allow them to be glued to your poster, it is a good idea to make color copies and use these instead. Step Five: Present your oral history You will be given 5-7 minutes to present your story and poster to the class. Your classmates will be given the opportunity to ask questions at the end of your presentation. 37 Oral History Project Sample Events and Questions Sample Significant Events: Immigration (Act of 1965) WWII Huk Rebellion Education People’s Power Brain Drain Family Settlement Anti-Filipino Sentiment, Racism Gender Roles, Double Standards Wedding, Marriage Starting a Family Sponsoring Relative to Immigrate American Influence in the PI Employment (First Job in US) Poverty in the Philippines Occupational Downgrading Leaving Family in the Philippines Overseas Contract Working Living with Relatives Family Conflicts Religion American Dream Language Generational Conflict Chain Migration Race Relations Sample questions: Why did you/your family come to the U.S.? What did you expect? What were your goals (economic, social, and political)? What status did you use (1965 Immigration Act Third Preference, World War II, 1952 McCarran Walter Act, etc.) to enter the U.S.? What did you know about America? Did you have friends and family here already? What were your goals in America? What were your dreams? Did your expectations match your realities? What was your childhood like? Did you grow up in the city or the country? Were you rich, middle class, or poor? How much education did you and your family have? What did you do for a living? What job do they have, and is it the job they dreamed of? Did they have difficulties getting a job? What kinds of gender roles did your parents promote? Was there anything you could not do because you were a woman/man? Did you experience racism/sexism, and how did you react? How do you identify yourself racially/ethnically/culturally? What have been the main events that have affected their lives? Why did they choose to settle in the city in which they now live? How did he/she meet his/her spouse or partner? How many children does he/she have? What kinds of values and traditions did you want to pass down to your children? What is the role of religion in your life? What kind of community involvement do you engage in? Has his/her overall experience been positive? 38 Oral History Project Interview Question Sheet This sheet is designed to help you create questions you will ask a family member during the interview portion of the Oral History Project. At the end of class each day, you will be given time to write down questions that you will ask your family member about three significant events in their life. Remember that you will have to contextualize their experiences in Filipina/o American History. Use another paper for additional questions you might want to ask. Background Information 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Significant Event #1________________________________________________ 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Significant Event #2________________________________________________ 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Significant Event #3________________________________________________ 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 39 DAY 2 AND 3 ROOTS TO FRUIT: FAMILY TREE Description: Students create a family to develop an understanding of where they come from. Lesson Plan Materials: Family Tree Organizer Worksheet Sample family tree (overhead, on LCD projector, or hard copies) Butcher Paper Art supplies (markers, color pencils, crayons) Glue/gluesticks Lesson Plan Definition and Rationale for choosing this VOCABULARY word, phrase, or concept FAMILY Idea for pre-teaching or frontloading the concept. Who we love, and who loves us. Who is important to us, and nurtures us. In most cases, our immediate and extended relatives. PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Family Brainstorm: Students think about the meaning of the word “family”, and how people have different interpretations of it depending on their family circumstance. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Students have 60 seconds to discuss with their partners the meaning of the word “family”. Ask for students to volunteer responses. Emphasize that people have different definitions of the word family, usually depending on their family structure, and that different student family structures are equally valid and valued in the class. Transition into the assignment. PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Making Family Trees: Students will their own family trees. This will help them uncover the history of their family before they do the oral history of their family member. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Distribute the Family Tree Organizer Worksheet. Model for students how to complete it. Students have until the beginning of class the next day to have the worksheet completed. They should make sure to ask their family members for information to complete it. If some information is unavailable, that’s okay, but they should think about why that information isn’t available during the upcoming oral history project. They may also bring in photographs for their family tree for extra credit. Show the sample family tree so students know what their finished project will look like. Emphasize to them that the worksheet only covers their direct ancestors, but that the family tree should include aunts, uncles, cousins, nephews, nieces, etc. For the first 40 minutes of the second day, students draw their family tree on butcher paper. In addition to their extended families, they should include the information from the Family Tree Organizer (ethnicity, occupation, etc. for their direct ancestors). Additionally, they should include when their family came to the United States, and to San Francisco. If this was within the last 3 generations, 40 Step 6 Step 7 they can indicate on the family tree. If this was longer ago, they should write separately when that happened. With ten minutes left in the class, have students circulate and look at each others’ family trees. Due the beginning of class the next day, students are to write ½ page explaining: a) what they learned about their families from creating a family tree; and b) what they learned from looking at others’ family trees. PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Who are we? How do we know? Connection: Students’ family trees are a quick way to describe and understand about who a person comes from. The next week or so will be looking at oral histories to gain a more profound understanding of their family’s experience. Assessment: What were the effective parts of this lesson plan and why? What parts could be improved and how? RESOURCES AND NOTES It is critical to emphasize that not everyone’s family is the same. Students who are adopted, don’t know who a parent is, those with step- and half-siblings, could very easily feel isolated and like outcasts with improper instruction. Make sure to mention that family trees do not and should not all look the same, and that no one family tree structure is “correct” or superior. Also, “housewife” or “mother” or “stay-at-home father” are nothing to be ashamed of as an occupation. It requires a huge amount of work, and should not cause a sense of lesser identity. 41 DAY 4 STARTING WITH WHAT YOU KNOW: CREATING AN INTERVIEW Lesson Plan Materials: Packet that Outlines the “My Family, My Self” Project Handout on “The 10 Tips on Great Interview Stories” by Kimberly Powell Examples of Oral Histories PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Interview Circle: In this exercise, the students will interview the teacher. This will help the students develop open ended questions for their oral history interviews. Step 1 Ask the students to write down a question that they want to ask you (the teacher). Their question must fulfill the following criteria: -Not be offensive -Cannot be answered by a yes or no -Encourage the teacher to tell a story Step 2 Put the questions in a jar or hat. Tell the students that their questions will be chosen and answered at random. Step 3 Step 4 Have the students create a circle with their seats. Place your (teacher’s) chair in the middle. Choose a question from the jar and read it aloud. Ask the students if this question fits the criteria mentioned in Step 1. If it fits, then answer the question. Then ask if the students have a follow-up questions. Continue this exercise for 20 minutes. PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Peer-to-Peer Interviewing: Students will create questions that they would want someone to ask them and they will interview another student in the class with those questions. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Ask the students what they learned about asking questions to you (teacher). Find out which questions brought out the most detailed stories. Have the students pull out a piece of paper and ask them to think of one event in their life that contributed to their identity today. Have them write about the event for 5 minutes. Then ask them to write about how that event has affected their identity for 5 minutes. Then have the students reread their reflection papers. Ask them to develop three questions that their paper could answer. These questions should also fit the criteria used in the question development for the teacher interviews. After the students finish writing their questions have them get in to pairs. Have one of the student interview their partner with their own questions for 5 minutes. Then instruct 42 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 them to compare their answers to their own that they wrote in their reflection paper. Now, reverse the process and have the other person ask their questions. After they have both interviewed each other have them share out. Ask them to identify what makes a good question. And have them give examples. Also ask them what makes up a good interview. Have the students work in their pairs to come up with questions that they will ask in their oral history interviews with their family members. (5 minutes) Have some of the students share out. List on the board some the interview questions that they came up with. PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: What makes up a good interview? What types of questions make up a good interview? Why is important to construct good questions? Assessment: Did you learn how to create good interview questions? What about this lesson plan/process did you find useful and engaging? Connection: Why is it important to start with what you know about a person and yourself when you begin to construct questions for an interview? 43 Handout/Homework: Top 10 Tips for Great Interview Stories By Kimberly Powell, About.com 1. Stay Engaged People are generally much happier to share their stories when they feel that you are truly interested in what they have to say. Maintain eye contact and really listen as they speak. Show interest by leaning forward, nodding, using appropriate facial expressions, or occasionally asking relevant follow-up questions. 2. Don't Be Afraid of Silence Don't let periods of silence fluster you. The whole point of an interview is to allow your family member to tell her story. When she pauses she may just be thinking or remembering; it can take time to call up memories of events she hasn't thought of in years. Instead of jumping right in with the next question each time there is a pause, give your interviewee a little time to see if she has anything else to add before moving on. 3. Ask the Right Questions The best interview stories come from questions that ask when, why, how, where and what, instead of just requiring a "yes" or "no" response. Along with that, you may also want to ask how the event made your interviewee feel. Emotions are a big part of your family's story and something you won't generally learn from documents and records. When you ask a series of questions at once, chances are that the interviewee will only answer the first or the last. Keep your questions brief, and present them one at a time. 4. Follow up on the Good Stuff For any event or account brought up during the interview, follow up with additional questions to find out not only what the person did, but also what she thought and felt about what she did. You should also try to establish where your interviewee was and what they were doing at the time of the event. This helps you to learn how much of what they are telling you is first-hand knowledge, and how much is based on the stories of others. 5. Be Yourself If you're relaxed, then it's more likely your interview subject will be relaxed as well. Don't worry about fumbling a few questions or "doing it right." This will only show that you're human and help to put your subject at ease. 6. Don't Interrupt Don't interrupt a good story because you have thought of a new question or want to clarify a point. Instead, jot down your questions on your notepad so you will remember to ask them later. Even if your subject gets off track a little, let them finish their story before steering them back on topic. 7. Get Personal Some of the best stories come from the personal questions - the ones that are slightly embarrassing, sensitive, or elicit laughter or tears. The thrill of first love, an embarrassing memory from school, the feelings you had as you were shipped off to war. These are the questions that can be hard to ask, but they are also the ones that will give you details you've probably never heard before. Keep these types of questions for after you've established a rapport with your interviewee, however. 8. Don't Challenge Don't challenge stories or accounts that you think might be inaccurate. Your interviewee may just have a different perspective, and a challenge may put her on the defensive or even shut down the interview. Everyone wants to feel they are believed. If you know of or have heard another version of the story, you may want to tactfully mention this and give your relative the opportunity to respond. 9. Bring Props It's amazing how many memories and stories an old photograph can elicit, so just imagine the stories an entire album or home movie may bring to mind. Look for anything that might help job your interviewee's memory of places, events and people. If you don't have any such props of your own, then ask your interviewee if she has any family photos or heirlooms to show you. For photos, ask when and where the photo was taken, the reason or event, and who the people in the photograph are. For family heirlooms ask questions such as: How was it used? Who made or purchased it? Who gave it to them? Also, ask if there are any stories or special memories associated with the object or photo. 10. Try a Group Approach Some of the best stories come when a group of relative, old friends, or military buddies get together and start reminiscing, so use this to your advantage. Set up a video camera in the corner of the dining room at Thanksgiving or set up a group of chairs at the family reunion. Then ask a question or two to get the stories started and let it build 44 fom there. Any family interview should be considered an ongoing conversation, rather than a one-time gig. This doesn't mean you need to schedule a formal interview once a year, but you should try to use every opportunity to ask questions and gather new stories. You'll likely learn something new every time you ask. I still do, and I've been asking questions of my family members for over 20 years! Prepare for the Interview While it may seem silly to create a plan for talking to your own family members, it is something which will greatly improve your chances for success. Take the time to make an appointment with your family member, prepare for the interview and decide on a list of questions, ranked in order of importance. Send the interviewee a list of your questions or summary of the topics you want to cover in advance, if possible. This gives them time to think about people and events that may not have occurred to them in a long time, and can often improve the actual interview. Be prepared for your visit with a notebook, several sharpened pencils and a cassette or video recorder (including extra tapes and batteries) if you plan to use one. An oral or video record of the interview is a big plus as it means you can spend more time developing a rapport with your interviewee and less time scribbling madly. Do not plan to record the interview if this really makes your relative uncomfortable, however. You should also bring your pedigree chart (those gaps of missing information may spark memories), family photos and other information which you have collected about the family. You can also collect oral histories from distant relatives via letter, phone or even email! 45 DAY 5 HOME WASN’T BUILT IN A DAY: CONSTRUCTING STORIES OF OUR FAMILIES Description: In this part of the unit, students will be introduced to the History of Lesson Plan Materials: Packet that Outlines the “My Family, My Self” Project Examples of Oral Histories PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Title: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Title: Detailed description of the activity. Lesson Steps: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Assessment: Connection: Possible Test Questions related to this lesson plan: RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources 46 Notes Include Handouts and Worksheets. DAY 6 TO 8 WRITING THE ORAL HISTORY PAPER Description: In this part of the unit, students will be introduced to the History of Lesson Plan Materials: Packet that Outlines the “My Family, My Self” Project Examples of Oral Histories PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Title: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Title: Detailed description of the activity. Lesson Steps: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Assessment: Connection: Possible Test Questions related to this lesson plan: RESOURCES AND NOTES 47 Resources Notes DAY 9 AND 10 CREATING A POWERPOINT PRESENTATION Description: In this part of the unit, students will be introduced to the History of Lesson Plan Materials: Packet that Outlines the “My Family, My Self” Project Examples of Oral Histories PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Title: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Title: Detailed description of the activity. Lesson Steps: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Assessment: Connection: Possible Test Questions related to this lesson plan: RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources 48 Notes DAY 11 AND 12 SHARING OUR STORIES Description: In this part of the unit, students will be introduced to the History of Lesson Plan Materials: Packet that Outlines the “My Family, My Self” Project Examples of Oral Histories PART 1: CULTURAL ENERGIZER Title: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 PART 2: COMMUNITY COLLABORATION AND CULTURAL PRODUCTION Title: Detailed description of the activity. Lesson Steps: Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 PART 3: CONCLUSIVE DIALOGUE/CRITICAL CIRCULAR EXCHANGE Problems/Questions of the Day: Assessment: Connection: Possible Test Questions related to this lesson plan: RESOURCES AND NOTES Resources Notes 49 Include Handouts and Worksheets. 50