D-4 PROJECT PAPER How to Prepare Action Plan Dr. Hazrat Hussain Faculty Consultant Colombo Plan Staff College for Technician Education Manila Philippines Email: drhazrat@cpsctech.org 1. Introduction Plan is basically a scheme for accomplishing a purpose. Action plan can, therefore, be described as a set of intended actions which have been agreed upon to bring about desired outcomes. An action plan may include one or more sub-areas. Action plan is required to implement the ideas into reality. An organization or an individual may have a vision, but a vision without a supporting plan of how to achieve usually remains only a dream. The importance of the action plan derives from this fact. Planning has several roles within the organization. It helps in achieving results. It can be used to monitor progress, to maintain control, to give people responsibility, to strengthen accountability, and to build greater teamwork through a sense of involvement. In addition if the plans are well made and are made available to those outside the organization then it can attract new support for one’s cause and attract financial aid from donors. Planning is a way to ensure that everyone works together towards the same common goals. It has many uses and advantages including the potential to avert or overcome the negative effects of poor group dynamics by concentrating on the tasks and the responsibilities. Action plans are also an established way to encourage adult learners to apply what they learn in training to a real problem or goal. It is a powerful experiential learning. Its purpose is how to solve a problem or challenge by focusing on a specific problem. As its name implies, the emphasis is always on the step by step actions to be taken to reach the goal. It has been seen that organizations can often with little difficulty identify and prioritize issues of common concern. Agreeing on effective strategies that reconcile short term and long term gains as well as costs and benefits to the intended beneficiaries, however, is not easy. It is even more difficult, moreover, to translate agreed strategies into actions which can be implemented. Action planning is, therefore, perhaps the most important tool, since it links planning to implementation and hence to the actual improvement to the cause identified. Action planning is the process that guides the day-to-day activities of an organization or project. It is the process of planning what needs to be done, when it needs to be done, by whom it needs to be done, and what resources or inputs are needed to do it. It is a road map to transform agreed strategies into implementable actions. A set of actions, thoughtfully identified and sequenced in way, which if acted upon properly, will lead to the achievement 1 of the goal/purpose intended to be accomplished. The action plan makes specific both the collective and the individual responsibilities for actual implementation. It is the process of operationalizing your strategic objectives. That is why it is also called operational planning. When an action plan or an operational plan are presented as the basis for a funding proposal, or for a loan application, or to get others to buy into a process or project in some way, they are often referred to as business plans. As regards the plans for determining the training need assessment like implementation of need assessment determination in education and training it can be said that effective need assessment plan provide a framework for the authorities as they budget for establishing infrastructure and mechanisms and providing the staff development that is essential for its use. The heart of any plan to assess training needs is chart out an action plan. With the action plan, the authorities puts in writing what goals it wants to achieve and how it expects to get there. 2. The Education Leadership in ASEAN Perspective: Planning the Roadmap During the last decade, a major preoccupation of the economists has been to establish a clear understanding of the so-called New Economy; we mean two broad trends that have been under way for several years. The first is the globalization of business characterized by the introduction of market forces, freer trade and widespread deregulation around the world. The second trend is the revolution in information technologies and digitization of services creating new companies and new industries and creating novel way ways to operate traditional companies. Apart from the developed north, these trends have implications in the newly developed and developing economies. Counties in the Asia and Pacific region and ASEAN countries in particular faces a variety of managerial challenges and require different of competencies and systems according to the economic, social and technological developments. Singapore , besides, Republic of Korea and Japan are embarking on global business era, while Malaysia and Thailand are trying to establish technology-based economic systems while Indonesia, Philippines and Vietnam are installing management system to improve productivity. The wave of change and transition of the economies from developing to developed status and from brick and mortar to click and mortar economies is an ongoing process and is being observed to have been happening at different pace in different countries. To develop successful global leaders, it is more useful to reposition the education, training and development organization to fulfill the extant and future needs of the workplaces. This require fundamental changes in the ET&D organizations to make informed and conscious decisions regarding future course of action and will need a encompassing strategy for improvement . The teaching and learning strategies in ET&D organizations are needed to be adopted according to the current research based understanding on the subject and changing behavioral responses of the new millennial. 2 The knowledge is considered as a strategic asset of the ET&D organizations and needs to be managed for currency and dynamism through easy retrieval and updates. A strategic knowledge management capability should facilitate early recognition of change patterns of from which possible explanation and therefore possible expected change trajectories can be made and then monitored. The key is to understand the change reasons in order to design responsible responses taking into consideration the organization and network constraints and optimizing time and cost. A strategic knowledge management capability enables an organization to combine its knowledge on market and products with change adaptation to gain sustainable competitive advantage. However, the installation of such system for smooth functioning not only require understanding of the processes knowledge creation and capture but at the same time the appropriate knowledge ontologies, organizing and storage technologies, networking and sharing infrastructure and appropriate knowledge products that lead to organizations decision support systems. Therefore planning to install a knowledge management, it needs to be properly planned and be integrated into the overall improvement plan of the organization for a better change and improved business results. Quality of services and products is considered to be the niche of any organizations for competitive position and gaining market share. Therefore it is needed to adopt and institutionalize the new concepts and systems for quality assurance as deemed appropriate in a particular context. Any quality management system is grounded on the 'conformance to specification as definition of quality. The standards specify how management operations shall be conducted. QMS must ensure that suppliers design, create, and deliver products and services which meet predetermined standards; in other words, its goal is to prevent non-conformity. Wealleans (2000) defined QMS as a set of rules and disciplines which cover how quality is going to be managed. It is that part of the organization management system that focuses on the achievement of results, in relation to the quality objectives, to satisfy the needs, expectations and requirements of a given customer. The various components and part of the organizations management system can be integrated, together with the QMS, into a single management system, to facilitate planning, resource allocation, and role complementation and performance evaluation. With such integration, the management system can be audited against the requirements of the quality Management system. In practice, a quality management system is usually what organizations craft when they are seeking for ISO certification or any appropriate accreditation and certification. However, bringing any change to the organizations systems and culture needs to properly deliberated upon. There is a need to plan the intended change and prepare proper guidelines for making the change happen. 3 3. Purpose Of The Action Plan An action plan basically serves two purposes as listed below: A. B. To elaborate in detail the agreed courses of action An action plan translates a broadly agreed set of policy frameworks and strategies into concrete actions. It defines the necessary activities together with the responsible people and their required commitments of resources, all within a clear timeframe for implementation along with a monitoring system for overseeing the process. To reconfirm and make explicit the commitments of partners and stakeholders The action planning process requires continuous detailed negotiation amongst the various working group stakeholders, to reach agreement on the inputs necessary for implementing an agreed set of actions. This requires in turn that working group representatives inform, advocate and negotiate with, and secure commitments from their respective organizations. These commitments are often formalized in the form of a pact or memorandum of understanding. 4. Principles An action plan should be specific, measurable, achievable, and realistic and time limited (SMART). Its formulation process is based on full negotiations with the stake holders and others involved. Specific An action plan is focused on a specific issue of common concern and on a specific geographic area. It is also specific in terms of the stakeholders and their actions as well as in terms of resource inputs and activities (who does what and how). Action plans are negotiated agreements which result from an extended process of dialogue among stakeholders who demonstrate their commitment by undertaking specific individual responsibilities including sharing of costs. Measurable An action plan specifies outputs and activities that can be measured and monitored, so that the whole process can be supervised, reviewed and adjusted as necessary. Achievable One should be clear about who is responsible and make sure the person has the means to complete the task successfully. Ensure that the right person is given the right job. This is not a matter of seniority or rank, rather it has to do with who has the requisite skill and will to achieve the objective. Realistic One should not set objectives which are too ambitious. Not reaching an objective can have a negative effect on the person responsible and the whole organization. 4 Therefore, it is sometimes better to set more conservative objectives, for example “increase internet connectivity by 25 percent per year for four years” instead of “increase connectivity by 100 percent this year.” We have to consider the fact that things take time. Time limited A timescale should be set within which the objective is to be achieved. This helps you measure success and also allows you to set later objectives that are dependent on the achievement of a previous goal. Using the SMART method as a guide, you should be able to set out a series of objectives for your organization. 5. Process of Building an Action Plan There are three key areas to action planning: analysis, planning/choice, and Implementation. If one works through each of these steps he will create a plan that is strong and achievable. Planning/ Choice Implementation Analysis Step 1: Analysis The analysis phase reviews and assesses the existing situation (problems, potentials, stakeholders) in order to develop objectives from the identified problems and to select strategy (strategies) that will be applied to achieve the objectives. But before starting the action plan building exercise we have to do the following activities: 1. Set the context Action plan is the key to continuous improvement. It focuses on the efforts of the people involved onto the measurable goals. So before starting any meaningful action plan building exercise we have to set the context. It allows for a mapping out of all the tasks which need to be done and which will result in better performance. Setting the 5 context may include basic introduction about the very concept and identification and analysis of the issues or problems in the context of its implementation. The analysis should be concise, as it relates to the goal-purpose linkage in the project framework and should provide the rationale for the project; and be appropriate for the target audiences. 2. Analyze and interpret data Using data to decide on specific actions to be taken will improve the relevance of the action plan. In order to do meaningful planning one should consider a variety of data. No single piece of information tells the whole story, but analysis across different assessment can point out the whole picture of the problem. Areas of needed improvement can be derived from there. 3. Set priorities After analysis of the data and identification of some areas of need, one must be realistic about one’s ability and capacity to be effective. The best action plans are those which accurately reflect the ability and capacity of the organizations to implement them. Plans that are too ambitious are likely to fail and should therefore be “doable” which are likely to succeed. So rather than avoiding doing what is difficult, divide difficult goals into manageable parts and achievable actions. So in the case of organizations while making an action plan it is advisable to take a hard look at your organization’s capability. One can start by looking at the strengths and weaknesses of one’s organization. Analyze your organization’s capability in terms of: People One can start by seeing as to how many staff or other active people one has. What skills do these people have and how they are working in the teams? One can segregate the people in terms of their individual brilliance or their propensity to work in teams. One should be quite honest while evaluating the strengths of the people working in the organization. The action planning team includes people responsible for leading the development and implementation of the action plan. The selection of the team members is a critical part of the process. When forming a team be sure to include a cross section of skills, point of view and expertise. Action planning teams must include people with strong leadership and data analyzing skills. Finances Finance is the life blood of any organization. The budget is one of the most important components of a plan especially a technology plan. Technology is a consumable item. Equipment is usually outdated soon after it’s been purchased and installed. Plans must include an ongoing process for upgrading and/or recycling hardware and software and providing technical support and training for staff. 6 Funding for hardware, software, networking, staff development, and technical support must be items in the budget. Often, authorities buy hardware, but forget that people must have training and technical support in order to integrate that technology into the system. Without staff development opportunities and technical support, the technology isn’t likely to be used effectively. In the case of education and training staff development for teachers must occur as the authorities are buying hardware and software, and making network connections. Hands-on access during staff development for technology, as well as reasonable access to the same technology when teachers return to their classrooms, affords skills to transfer more readily into effective teaching practices and ultimately results in student outcomes. This connection between budget, hardware acquisition, and staff development is very vital to successfully integrating technology in education and training. There is no point in developing a good action plan if the resources needed to make it happen are not available. One should look at the financial status of one’s organization not only in the present times but anticipate for the future also. The sources of income and their reliability in future should also be taken in consideration. An assessment of alternative income sources should be made and strategies should be devised as to how they can be tapped. Networking and Linkages There is a need to strike effective linkages and network with the relevant organizations. But before that one must assess the present linkages so that new networks could be thought of. In addition all stakeholders have an important role to play in the information society, especially through partnerships: Government has a leading role in developing and implementing comprehensive, forward looking and sustainable national strategies. The private sector and civil society, in dialogue with government, have an important consultative role to play in devising national strategies. The commitment of the private sector is important in developing and diffusing ubiquitous technology for infrastructure, content and applications. The private sector is not only a market player but also plays a role in a wider sustainable development context. The commitment and involvement of civil society is equally important in creating an equitable information society, and in implementing ICT-and ubiquitous related initiatives for development. In addition one should look beyond one’s borders and should try to tap the international organizations, if needed, for the necessary help in terms of finances, expertise and other resources. International and regional institutions, including financial institutions, have a key 7 role in implementing the new initiatives like integrating ubiquitous technology in education and training process and making available necessary resources for building the ubiquitous society. Environmental Factors There are many examples of environmental factors which may affect the organization and that could divert attention and energy away from your stated objectives. Listing all these factors in the strategic analysis gives a complete picture of the environment which one can take into account when the organization decides on its objectives. In addition one should list all other factors that are considered to be strength for the organization as well as which are considered to be weaknesses. It would give a fair idea of where the organization stands and what ought to be done. After conducting a thorough analysis of the organization and the environmental scanning, the big picture should become clearer and one should now have a number of issues to address. We can develop a list of possible goals by analyzing these issues and what we want to do about them. The next is to separate the components of each issue and establish individual objectives, then comes the identification of different strategies to achieve objectives. Step 2: Planning/Choice Next to the ‘analysis’ phase is the planning or choice phase. The term “choice” means the act of deciding upon preferences. Choosing which goals to include in the plan is difficult because there are often too many options, insufficient time, and a level of uncertainty about what may happen in the future. Sometimes a choice is forced on us because of one reason or the other like it could be the lack of funding to do all that we identified in the analysis stage. In the choice process one identifies the main goals that he wants to achieve. Any planning activity must answer the following questions (5Ws and1H) and therefore should contain the necessary information. WHY is this action being carried out? List the goal statement as the first item on the action plan worksheet. Clearly defined goals help communicate with other members of the team why certain steps are being undertaken and what the organization hopes to accomplish after the steps are completed. WHAT actions or critical steps (objectives) will occur? Outlining each critical step or task helps in breaking down the goal into individual components. When the goal gets broken into smaller steps, the goal becomes easier to manage. Detailing the critical steps also helps the organization to plan for obstacles or barriers that might arise during each action step. 8 WHO will carry out these steps or actions? Who will be responsible for carrying out which step? This section also refers to who should be included and who is responsible for making decisions if any decisions are required. WHEN will these actions take place and for how long? This indicates the time schedule for the performance of the activities. People in general tend to work more efficiently when they are given a timeframe. Placing a timeframe also helps the organization to better strategize each sequence of steps to reach the completed target date. WHERE will these actions take place? This shows the place of the final action. It may also indicate the final beneficiary of the whole exercise. HOW will these actions take place? That shows the strategy of accomplishing the objectives. It also includes the resources which will be needed to carry out the steps? Resources may include money, time, people, locations, events, etc. Resources also refer to both internal and external but that may be required or helpful for carrying out the action step One may put all these in the below tabular form. Goal (Why) Date of commissioning Critical Steps (What actions are needed ) People involved (Who) Target Date of Completion Time Frame (When) Location Of action (Where) Strategy and resources (How) What Difficulties are Anticipated? Next Meeting Date Action planning begins with consideration of alternative courses of action, assessing them in relation to the agreed strategies, discussing their relative costs and benefits, and gauging their feasibility and suitability. In the end, action planning is about finding the right mix of interventions, as one single best option is generally not available. 9 The most important format for presenting the proposed action plan is to use the Logical Framework which not only shows the hierarchical relationship of the different activities with the overall goal of the project, but at the same shows the performance indicators, monitoring mechanisms and related risks and assumption. A sample format is presented down in matrix format. Performance Indicators/ Target Design Summary Monitoring Mechanisms Assumptions and Risks Goal Purpose Outputs Activities Inputs The logical framework is very widely used by many international development agencies and programs. For giving details of the costing, a separate detailed costing table can be prepared to determine the financial needs of the project. COST ESTIMATES AND FINANCING PLAN ($ millions) Item 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Government Consultants a. International Consultants b. Domestic Consultants Equipment and Software a. Equipment b. Software Buildings and Furniture a. Buildings b. Furniture Training, Seminars, and Conferences Research, Development, and Surveys Miscellaneous Administration and Support Costs Contingencies Total 10 Donors Total Cost 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 In addition the action plan should identify weak linkages, resource gaps, areas of uncertainty, etc., and show how these are addressed. Such gaps may include: tasks for which no clear lead person or organization is identified; financial costs for which funding source could not be identified; other resource requirements which could not be mobilized; Capacity limitations of people involved. Action planning links policy and strategy into implementation. Since it builds on negotiated agreements among stakeholders, the incidence of costs/benefits or gains/ losses accruing to different social groups are made explicit and are the subject of negotiation and consensus building. Since action planning is founded on the will and commitment of participating actors, implementation is greatly improved. The essential action plan commitments by the participating stakeholders need to be formalized through appropriate tools such as Memorandum of Understanding (MoU). Moreover, because action plans often involve multiple actors whose contributions are operationally linked, specific mechanisms for coordination must be agreed and put in place. Step 3: Implementation The action plan should be a living document; unless the steps and activities are closely monitored they may not be done. Many plans fail because they are well written but not properly monitored for implementation. This stage is the normally the most difficult part of planning. This is because it is easier to plan about something than to actually do it. Also, because plans usually mean a change from how things are at present, there are always some people who do not appreciate the need and do not want to change. Therefore, implementing of the plans require resilience, strength, tact, and a strong belief that what you are doing is right for your organization. Some basic tips for Successful implementation is outlined below: Try to involve all the relevant people. This way they will have a greater sense of shared ownership of the finished plan. The plan should have something for everyone, even if it isn’t completely and universally accepted. There should be a role for all the persons involved in the implementation of the plan. It has been observed that those who feel sidelined can become an obstacle to success. So one should go out of one’s way to ensure the active involvement of all concerned. The person in charge of the plan must always lead from the front. If some rectifications are required in the plan at some stage they may be made but one should never speak badly about any part of the plan. One should monitor all aspects of the plan’s implementation regularly. With careful monitoring, it will become clear where actions are not having the desired results and where one is loosing on time and what corrective actions need to be taken. 11 The cooperating stakeholders need also to agree on measurable indicators (for both inputs and results/outputs) and monitoring mechanisms which give an on-going over-view of the action plan implementation process, enabling feed-back for timely adjustments as necessary. During the implementation of the action plan, report the progress to the stake holders so that their continuous support is ensured. 6. Factors contributing to the Success of Action Plan If proper care is taken then the chances of the plan being successful are very high. Some of the factors which contribute towards the success of the plan are: The goals to be achieved must be set after thorough diagnosis. Strategies and activities must be well planned and defined. There should be an agreement among various stakeholders about the goals and activities as it will become the focus of their work. The plan should focus and unite all the stakeholders to attain the stated goals Commitment of the leadership is very important. Reaching agreement through consensus and basing the plan on data generally offers the best chances of success. Active participation by all group members as a team, effective communication skills, creative thinking and open mindedness during the process of planning and implementation leads to success of the plan. There should be a clear demarcation of the roles and responsibilities of various people involved. Proper audit and evaluation systems should be developed. High priority should be given to training and development of the people involved. Formation of proper management structures will facilitate the action plan planning and implementation. There should be agreement of all stakeholders about the final findings and recommendations. 12 7. Conclusion Action planning is the process that guides the day-to-day activities of an organization or project. Action planning is perhaps the most important tool since it links planning to implementation. Specifically with regard to technology plans like implementation of ubiquitous technology in education and training it can be said that effective technology plans provide a framework for the authorities as they budget for acquiring and supporting technology and providing the staff development that is essential for its use. For the action plans to be effective it is essential that they should be specific, measurable, achievable, and realistic and time limited (SMART) and their formulation process are based on full negotiations with the stake holders and others involved. Further in order to make the plans successful it is essential that great care is taken in their formulation and later on in their implementation. A good action plan lays the foundation for the successful execution of the project. References 1. Best Practices Data base; UN HABITAT, http://www.bestpractices.org 2. Clarke Gordon, Action Planning, European Hemophilia Consortium , Hemophilia Organization Development Monograph Series No. 2 December 2001, 3. Formulating Issue Specific Strategies and Action Plans, Volume 4 of the SCP Source Book Series, UNCHS & UNEP, Nairobi, 1999. 4. Herohisa Nagai (April, 15, 2008), Development of Future Asian Global Leaders: Vision, Framework, and Implications for APO Member Countries. 5. Localizing Agenda 21 Planning Guide, Chapter 4, Action Planning; UNCHS, Nairobi 6. “Managing Sustainable e-community Centers” Workshop Proceedings, 4-10 May, 2005.Agra, India, Jointly organized by Colombo Plan Staff College and Asian Development Bank Institute, 2005. 7. P Katsoulakos and Rutherford (www.kbos.net), KBOS, strategic Knowledge Management series. January, 7, 2006. 8. Stanley E. Malcolm, ©1998 “ Action Planning, A Process of Successful Projects” http://www.performance-vision.com/action-planning/art-action-planning.htm, 9. Southern Health Borad,http://www.shb.ie/content1907215515_1.cfm 10. Urban Governance Toolkit Series, ©2001, The United Nations Human Settlements Program UN-HABITAT and the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP), P.O. Box 30030, Nairobi, Kenya UNEP: P.O. Box 30552, Nairobi, Kenya 11. TJ-Tesoro Gayondato (April,2010) Quality Management Systems for TVET: ISO Principles and Standards” Regional Program for CPSC, Pokhara, Nepal 12. www.dti.gov.uk/quality/processes, Department of Trade and Industry 13