Religion 203 Dr. Vande Kappelle E-mail: rvandekappel@washjeff.edu W & J College Office: Old Main, Room C Phone: 724/223-6186 (office) ACQUIRING WISDOM: A STUDY OF BIBLICAL WISDOM LITERATURE Through their inspirational teachings, the sages of the biblical wisdom tradition offer time-honored advice about some of life’s most difficult questions, including the problem of the suffering of the innocent, the nature of evil, and how to deal with the uncertainties of life. They also address such themes as friendship, virtue and vice, marriage and the choice of a spouse, decision making, life priorities, child rearing, illness, and death. The insights offered in the biblical tradition and the efforts of the biblical sages to integrate faith and reason as well as revelation and human wisdom rival those of the renowned philosophical schools of ancient Greece. Our survey of biblical wisdom literature will include an examination of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Job, Song of Solomon, Daniel, and selections from the Gospels as well as from the book of Psalms. In addition, we will study two extraordinary wisdom writings that are included as scripture by Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox, namely the book of Sirach (also known as Ecclesiasticus) and the Wisdom of Solomon, the latter written only a couple of decades before the birth of Jesus Christ. The course examines the well-known story of Job, in which a righteous man struggles to understand why he suffers loss, illness, and despair. This account is used to probe one of the most compelling themes of the biblical wisdom tradition: What is the cause of suffering? Should we interpret suffering as a punishment for wrongdoing (as implied in Genesis 3 and in the Christian doctrine of “original sin”)? Or is suffering sometimes a test, designed to shape our character? The suffering and death of Jesus suggests yet another possible understanding of the problem of evil, of suffering, and of death. STUDENT LEARNING OUTCOMES Upon completion of this course, students will be able to: 1. Demonstrate an understanding of the Biblical Wisdom Literature and its message in the original setting; 2. Demonstrate an understanding of the varied approach to wisdom utilized by Israel’s sages; 3. Utilize a variety of modern interpretive approaches to this literature; 4. Explain how the wisdom material relates to the rest of the Bible; 5. Understand, appreciate, and carry out acceptable and effective biblical exegesis (reading “out of the text” its intended meaning instead of imposing on the text one’s own biases and presuppositions); 6. Apply the teachings of the Biblical Wisdom Literature practically to contemporary issues and concerns as well as to their daily lives 2 TEXTS Richard J. Clifford, The Wisdom Literature (Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press), 1998; [ISBN 9780687008469] A Study Bible with the Apocrypha. The bookstore has ordered copies of The New Interpreter’s Study Bible (Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press), 2003 [ISBN 9780687022959] Another valuable resource is The Catholic Study Bible, Second Edition [The New American Bible version], edited by Donald Senior and John J. Collins (New York: Oxford University Press, 2006) [ISBN 9780195282795] Students will read one of the following books, give a brief presentation, and participate in a class symposium (see below for additional information). Robert Gordis, The Book of God and Man; John Paul II, On the Christian Meaning of Human Suffering (Boston: Pauline Books), 2005 (available online) Harold S. Kushner, When All You’ve Ever Wanted Isn’t Enough; ––––When Bad Things Happen to Good People; Madeleine L’Engle, The Irrational Season C. S. Lewis, A Grief Observed ——The Problem of Pain; Philip Yancey, Disappointment with God; ——Where is God When it Hurts? REQUIREMENTS 1. Student Presentation on Secondary Readings – Students will read an assigned book, give a 15-minute overview, and participate in one of the two symposia days as noted in the “class schedule” below. The presentation is expected to last approximately 15 minutes (make sure you allow time for discussion of the topic) and should address the following items: (a) A brief summary or overview of the book, including its major theme(s); (b) its contribution to the topic of human suffering and/or to biblical wisdom; (c) and its place and overall contribution to Jewish/Christian theology and morality (that is, its relevance and place in faith and practice) and a concluding statement concerning what you felt were the most significant insights you gained from reading the text and why. 3 2. Participation – Each student is expected to attend class regularly and participate in class discussions. Participation includes attendance, evidence of preparation when called upon for a response or comment, and level of insightfulness when contributing to class discussion. Bring the Study Bible plus the assigned text to class daily. 3. Final Paper – In lieu of a final exam, student will write a formal 8-10 page paper, consisting of a critical study of a topic or biblical passage related to the course material. Topic selection is due by November 18 and must be approved by the professor. At least three references should be consulted and noted in the bibliography; an opening “thesis statement” and a conclusion are required. Bibliographic references and other citations may be included within the body of the paper. The paper will be based on content, originality of research, logical reasoning, and grammatical correctness. The paper is due in class on the final day of class (December 4). GRADING 1. 2. 3. 4. individual and group presentation participation and homework quizzes final paper 25% 25% 25% 25% A NOTE OF CLARIFICATION: In the “Class Schedule” below, you will notice that the topics and books we will cover in class often include the following technical phrases: contextual analysis, textual analysis, and thematic analysis. The following explanations clarify what these mean: Contextual Analysis – these classes will provide background and/or introductory information on a particular book or unit, including but not limited to author, audience, cultural, historical, and theological context; Literary (Structural and Textual) Analysis – these classes will examine the structure (outline) of the book and supply exegetical commentary, including but not limited to literary observations, theological insights, textual problems, flow of the argument, and connections between the section and the rest of the book or unit; Thematic Analysis – an analysis of key themes from the book or unit will provide the class with an understanding of the ancient and contemporary relevance of those themes and their importance to the book, the author, and the original audience. 4 CLASS SCHEDULE: Topics and Presenters (T, H Schedule) The assignment for each day includes reading the related material from the Clifford text and the assigned section from the Bible. Additional assignments are listed below. Sept. 2 1. Introduction to the Course and to Biblical Wisdom Literature 4 2. Book of Proverbs: Introduction Read Clifford, chapters 1 and 2; (worksheet, questions 1, 2, 5) 9 3. Book of Proverbs: Contextual, Literary and Thematic Analysis Read Clifford, chapter 3; (worksheet, question 4) 11 4. Book of Proverbs: The Personification of Wisdom (Lady Wisdom/Folly) Questions on Proverbs due today (worksheet, question 3, parts A and B) 16 5. Book of Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth): Contextual Analysis, Pt. I Quiz # 1 18 6. Book of Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth): Contextual Analysis, Pt. II Questions on Ecclesiastes due today (worksheet) 23 7. Book of Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth): Textual Analysis, Pt. I 25 8. Book of Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth): Textual Analysis, Pt. II 30 9. Book of Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth): Thematic Analysis, Pt. I Oct. 2 10. Book of Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth): Thematic Analysis, Pt. II Presentation on Harold S. Kushner, When All You’ve Ever Wanted Isn’t Enough 7 11. Book of Job: Contextual Analysis Quiz # 2 Contextual Questions from Book of Job worksheet due today 9 13. Book of Job: Literary Analysis (Overview) and Thematic Analysis Textual Questions from Book of Job worksheet due today 14 14. Book of Job: Textual Analysis: Part I 16 15. Book of Job: Textual Analysis: Part II 21 16. FALL BREAK 23 17. Symposium on the Meaning of Suffering and Pain, Pt. I Presentations due today 5 28 18. Symposium on the Meaning of Suffering and Pain, Pt. II Presentations due today 30 19. Song of Solomon (Song of Songs) Quiz # 3 Nov. 4 20. Sirach (Ecclesiasticus): Contextual Analysis 6 21. Sirach (Ecclesiasticus): Literary and Thematic Analysis Select a topic from the Ben Sira handout and write a one to two-page response, summarizing Ben Sira’s views and your reactions; due today. 11 22. Book of Daniel 13 23. Wisdom Psalms Quiz # 4 Read Psalm 1, 8, 13, 49, 73:1-3, 119 (skim); 139 18 24. Wisdom of Solomon: Contextual and Textual Analysis Topic for Final Paper due today 20 25. Wisdom of Solomon: Textual and Thematic Analysis 25 26. Jesus as Sage/Divine Wisdom: Contextual and Textual Analysis Read John 1:1-18; Phil. 2:6-11; Col. 1:15-20; Eph. 2:14-16; I Tim. 3:16; Heb. 1:1-18; I Peter 1:20; 3:18, 22 27 27. THANKSGIVING Dec. 2 28. Jesus as Sage/Divine Wisdom: Textual Analysis, Pt. I Read Gospel of Matthew 4 29. Jesus as Sage/Divine Wisdom: Textual Analysis, Pt. II Final Paper due today