The Fire of Charism Introduction Brothers, the general chapter of 2006 invited us to undertake a pilgrimage of hope on the road to communion: “descending into the interior life, nourishing our interpersonal relationships, and lighting the fire in the sanctuary of mission.” (A Pilgrimage of Hope, p. 17) It was the wish of the chapter that we brothers, together with our partners in mission, make this pilgrimage, and thus “become signs of hope for our wounded world and for its children.” (Ibid.) Having, in the first four circulars, dealt with the themes of interior life and interpersonal relationships, it now falls to me not to delve into the theme of mission, an integral part of our own charism. Persons with distinct vocations (religious, lay, priests, etc.) are called to mission, but animated with the same charism they are also called to realize that mission in communion. Before dealing with the notion of sharing the charism and the mission, or rather of communion in the charism, it would be important to articulate the meaning of the words charism and mission, and define our own specific charism and mission as exemplified by Father André Coindre’s lived experience of the Spirit, an experience continually transmitted to his disciples over course of the history of our institute. May this exercise lead us to love our vocation and to live it in fidelity to Christ in dynamic fidelity to the original charism – the Spirit’s gift to us all. It may be that within these pages come upon ideas that I have already developed in preceding circulars. It is said that even the best authors only write one book, and they repeat themselves in those that follow. If that is true for good writers, it just may be that the same dictum applies to me. Nevertheless, brothers, I make bold to present to you my reflections on this theme, conscious of my limitations and trusting in your brotherly indulgence. 1 CHAPTER 1. THE CHARISM, A GIFT FOR SERVICE Why Speak of Charism? Why begin with charism and not deal straightaway with the theme of mission? The latter is, I must admit, a rather broad topic in itself, and I will need a lot of pages to deal with it. But no one can speak of mission without first speaking of charism, because the two are intimately linked. In point of fact our mission of today flows directly from the one that Father Andre Coindre initiated almost two centuries ago now. It is an integral part of the grace or the charism that the Spirit granted to our founder and which we, his followers, have in turn never ceased to receive and to cause to bear fruit. Mission is a service, and is integral to this all-encompassing gift that we call charism. A charism is, therefore, a grace that breathes life into the mission and includes the mission itself. Another reason for spending these initial pages delving into the topic of charism is that our own experience of that gift and its development teaches us the importance of an ongoing updating of our understanding of the mission of religious life, which is to serve the Church and the world. This adaptation, which is so essential for assuring the future of religious life, consists in constantly finding new and authentic responses to the needs of every time and place. On the topic of authentic responses, some time ago I came upon the following brief anecdote. A pilot of a small plane developed engine trouble as he was flying over a forest. The aircraft was forced down, and the pilot ended up at the top of a tree. “Where am I? he shouted down to a friar passing by below. - At the top of a tree, replied the man. - Are you a monk? - But of course. How can you tell? - Well, everybody knows that monks tend to say grand truths that on first consideration don’t seem to make much sense,” replied the stranded pilot in a critical tone of voice. Brothers, please take no offence at this little story, it is not intended to wound, but to teach. New and authentic answers, renewal and adaptation, returning to the origins, refoundation, incarnation of the charism… Haven’t we spent a good deal of time talking about the same old things? Shouldn’t we to turn the page? I don’t think so. To me at least, at the very heart of Christian and religious life there is only Love, a Love which puts this question to us each and every day: “Do you really love me?” And a constantly renewed love replies, “My Love, you know I love you.” Crossing an enormous mountain range like the Andes requires a hike of several days. Nevertheless the adventure offers the climber a variety of climates, lush vegetation and breathtaking landscapes, along with peaks covered in “eternal snows,” stretches of heather with their abundant reserves of water, and the depths of the valleys below. Add to all of that the likelihood of coming across simple and hospitable locals, the experience will invariably prove to be a most enriching one. However, that same adventure still remains quite daunting. For each morning climbers has to make up their minds yet again to continue the hike, despite their increasing weariness. Isn’t this a fair analogy of what happens in the Christian and 2 the religious life, in which every morning greets us with yet another challenge to keep on going with renewed enthusiasm? In this life it is never sufficient to say “yes” to Christ once and for all. The zeal of our “yes” must be rekindled every single day. Likewise, the vitality of an institute of religious life demands that each of its members and each of its local communities renew every day their commitment to live the charism, which is the soul and the raison d’être of that institute. In religious life today, as in the past, it is not so much new things that we need, but rather a dynamic fidelity to the charism. Charism in Secular and Religious Language The word “charism” comes from the Greek kharisma (χαρισμα), which means grace, gift or favor. It is found in the New Testament especially in the letters of St. Paul. Used initially in the language of theology, it has recently found its way into current secular language. It is, for example, used to express the fascination, the superiority or the magnetism that one person can bring to bear over others. Charismatic persons have a way of arousing and maintaining the interest of others as much by what the former say or do as by their very way of speaking or acting. In the language of theology, the word “charism” refers, in the broadest sense, to every gift conferred by God. In the pages that follow, the word “charism” will assume the meaning that St. Paul intended for it in his letters, that is, the gratuitous gift or gifts that the Spirit grants to a person for the good of the community. In the words of the Apostle of the Gentiles, charism is “a manifestation of the Spirit given for the sake of the common good.” (1 Co 12:7) There is a diversity of charisms: wisdom, knowledge, faith, the gift of healing, the power to do miracles, prophecy, discernment of spirits, the gift of tongues, the gift of interpreting the latter, etc. (Cf. 1 Co 12:8-11) The person who receives charisms does not receive them for himself/herself, but for the building up of the Body of Christ, which is the Church. In other words, charisms are given in order to build up the Kingdom or the community of those who live according to Gospel values. Charism in Religious Life The Second Vatican Council decreed that consecrated life is not part of the hierarchical structure of the Church, but rather is it a divine gift which concerns her life and holiness, and consequently, its deepest sacramental nature and its essence issue forth from the free initiative of the Spirit. (Cf. Lumen Gentium, §§ 43-45) The Council did not use the word “charism” when referring to religious life, itself. However, the charismatic character of this state of life appears clearly in the dogmatic constitution, Lumen Gentium and in the decree Perfectae Caritatis. This decree affirmed that: “The adaptation and renewal of the religious life includes both the constant return to the sources of all Christian life and to the original spirit of the institutes and their adaptation to the changed conditions of our times.” (§ 2). The terms “charisms of your founders” and “charisms of religious life” appeared for the first time in the apostolic exhortation Evangelica Testificatio, published in 1971 to implement the teachings of the Council on the renewal of religious life. In it we find the following: 3 Only in this way (unity between contemplation and the apostolate) will you be able to reawaken hearts to truth and to divine love in accordance with the charisms of your founders who were raised up by God within His Church. Thus the Council rightly insists on the obligation of religious to be faithful to the spirit of their founders, to their evangelical intentions and to the example of their sanctity. In this it finds one of the principles for the present renewal and one of the most secure criteria for judging what each institute should undertake. (Cf. Lumen Gentium, § 45 and Perfectæ Caritatis, § 2) In reality, the charism of the religious life, far from being an impulse “born of flesh and blood” (Jn 1:13) or one derived from a mentality which “conforms itself to the modern world” (Rm 12:2), is the fruit of the Holy Spirit, who is always at work within the Church. (§ 11) Despite the fact that this text may be considered somewhat archaic, in reality it still is topical. We must bear in mind, of course, that it deals not only with the charism of founders, but equally with the charism of religious life. Both were inspired by God through the action of the Holy Spirit, who is continually at work in the Church. In order to truly understand this quotation from Evangelica Testificatio it is important to bear in mind the paragraph that precedes it. (§ 10) A great deal of emphasis is placed on the importance of religious men and women to seek the Lord above all else, as they maintain an equilibrium between contemplation and apostolate. Regarding contemplation in love, religious adhere to Him with all their hearts and minds; regarding apostolic love, they associate themselves to the work of redemption and the expansion of the Kingdom (Cf. Evangelica Testificatio, § 10; cf. R 177). Consequently, the message of paragraph 11 of Evangelica Testificatio is that the union between contemplation and action is indispensable for the renewal of religious life, which consists principally in reawakening “hearts to truth and to divine love in accordance with the charisms of your founders.” And so, to use a word that was coined over two decades ago, it is a matter of the “re-foundation” of religious life in each institute in the light of the charism of its founder. And this, of course, implies being faithful to his spirit, to his Gospel-inspired intentions and to the example of his holiness. It is to be noted that the text is an invitation to the reawakening of hearts and not of minds. As St. Ignatius of Loyola affirms, “It is not the acquisition of great knowledge that refreshes and satisfies the soul, but truly feeling and tasting things interiorly.” (Spiritual Exercises, 2) Of course, knowledge is always necessary, but life is not essentially about filling one’s head with theoretical knowledge. To awaken hearts to the truth and to divine love, only knowledge that leads to love is worthwhile. In point of fact, very few men and women founders of institutes of religious life could be said to have been persons of singular knowledge; others, even less. Nevertheless, all of them were great-hearted persons. Just consider our own beloved founder, Father André Coindre, and of course, Brother Xavier and Brother Polycarp who followed in his footsteps, and who remain for us constant examples of generous service. 4 CHAPTER II. THE CHARISM OF FOUNDERS In this chapter, I’m going to present the charism of founders, and in the next I’ll speak specifically of the charism of our own founder. CHARISM IS A GIFT… The document Mutuæ Relationes defined for the first time the charism of founders. This document was published in 1978 by what was then called the Sacred Congregation for Religious and Secular Institutes. In it we read: The very charism of the Founders (cf. Evangelii Nuntiandi, § 11) appears as an "experience of the Spirit," transmitted to their disciples to be lived, safeguarded, deepened and constantly developed by them, in harmony with the Body of Christ continually in the process of growth. "It is for this reason that the distinctive character of various religious institutes is preserved and fostered by the Church" (LG, § 44). This distinctive character also involves a particular style of sanctification and of apostolate, which creates its particular tradition, with the result that one can readily perceive its objective elements. In this hour of cultural evolution and ecclesial renewal, therefore, it is necessary to preserve the identity of each institute so securely, that the danger of an ill-defined situation be avoided, lest religious, failing to give due consideration to the particular mode of action proper to their character, become part of the life of the Church in a vague and ambiguous way. (Mutuæ Relationes, § 11). …spiritual and gratuitous As we read the preceding text carefully, several aspects become glaringly obvious. To begin with, it would seem that the notion of charism of founders turns our thoughts to that movement of the Spirit that these persons underwent and which was then transmitted to their respective followers. This experience of the Spirit was characterized by their way of seeing and of living a particular aspect of the mystery of Christ. By the very fact that it is defined as an experience of the Spirit, that charism is a spiritual and gratuitous gift which does not emanate from human nature. It is worth underscoring yet again that a charism corresponds neither to a simple intellectual knowledge nor to a mere philanthropic sentiment which might lead a person to establish a benevolent work, for example. As specified in Mutuæ Relationes, a charism is an experience, which is to say something lived, a reality that a person lives through in an intense way in every dimension of his or her being: body, heart, soul and mind. …personal and collective Again in the text cited above we read that the Spirit grants a charism to founders and then, in turn, to each of their immediate disciples and to all those who will follow after. The charism of a founder is therefore not a mere historical event with a sentimental or romantic connotation; quite the opposite, for through it the Spirit makes that charism present each day by granting it to each member of an institute throughout the history of their institute. The charism of an institute is the concrete way in which members are able to live the charism of the founder. We can equally define charism as the particular gift that each 5 of the members receives from the Holy Spirit in order to take on a specific mission in the service of the Church and the world. Usually this mission is realized through the carrying out a function or role that we call a ministry. The charism is therefore, both a personal and a collective gift. It is personal because it is a particular grace of the Holy Spirit granted to an individual, the founder, and to a group of persons who identify with him in order to realize a shared vision (life project). ….constantly alive Let us consider now something that, to my way of thinking, represents the overall meaning of the above quotation taken from Mutuæ Relationes.“‘The very charism of the Founders’ appears as an ‘experience of the Spirit,’ transmitted to their disciples to be lived, safeguarded, deepened and constantly developed by them, in harmony with the Body of Christ continually in the process of growth.” (§ 11) The charism of the founder is and experience of the Spirit with a view to foundation. As a result, the particular charism does not encompass all the graces of founders, but only those that the latter lived and which were later to be transmitted to the members of the respective religious families that they founded. Here I emphasize the fact that a charism is a reality that is lived and that is guarded as a precious treasure, for the lived experience gives the true meaning to existence. That is to say, that the experience allows the recipient to experience a sense of fulfillment despite life’s inherent difficulties. …ecclesial The text Mutuæ Relationes (§ 11) asserts that a charism is lived, is guarded, is deepened and is developed “in harmony with the Body of Christ”, that is, in communion with the Church. And a charism is lived out with deep love for the Church, and can never be understood or justified except in the Church, for the Church and by the Church. It is the Church that confirms the various charisms as it declares and confirms their authenticity. Charisms are always given to accomplish a particular service, and the ultimate end of every Gospel service is the building up of the community of the Kingdom, where all may live as brothers and sisters in the dignity of children of God. Now, the Church is the sacrament of the Kingdom. And thus charism, takes on an ecclesial dimension because through the person of the founder and his successors, that charism is offered to entire Church community, for its welfare, for its growth and its fulfillment. …for a service The experience of the Spirit that the founder undergoes consists in holding fast to the person of Christ, seduced as he/she is by a particular aspect of His ministry. This specific aspect can be compassion, mercy, poverty, obedience to the Father, intimacy with Him in prayer, etc. This holding fast to, this intimacy with the person of Jesus by a founder is translated at the same time by a deep love for the Father and for all his well-beloved children. And it is precisely the love for the well-beloved of the Father that drives founders to live in close union with them, to detect in one or another essential needs, to experience a great interior desire to satisfy them, and with boundless creativity, boldness, and tenacity to undertake a concrete work to that end. The perceived need 6 can be great spiritual or material poverty, lack of education or lack of adequate care, physical, mental, etc. In other words, the harsh reality that a founder discovers begins to be changed in the light of a fundamental reading of the Gospel, which tends to highlight particular features of the person of Christ. And from the “binomial” Gospel-reality an apostolic service is born for the sake of the Church and humanity, a service which takes substance through the life of the religious community. ...dynamic A charism is an energy that emanates from the Spirit; it is a life-giving power which must be communicated to others. In other words a charism can never be static, but is always dynamic. It is thus that the words from Mutuae Relationes: “experience…safeguarded, deepened and constantly developed” must be understood. It is always possible to live out the charism with greater depth or intensity, to develop it, to live it with greater radicality, and use it to bring new answers to new situations. Therefore, a charism is not to be identified with the work of founders, and by means of which he responded to the needs of time and place; rather is it contemporary; it is the breath of the creative Spirit spurring on those who seek to find creative answers to the need of the here and now. We must not conceive of the founding charism as a thrust whose initial motivation would, still today, allow the religious family to, in a sense, freewheel its way though life. “No! The grace of the charism of foundation is daily renewed and given to us Brothers, not individually, but corporately, in as much as we are all linked together.” (René Sanctorum, Father Andre Coindre’s Founding Charism, Alex, France, June 18, 1995. General House Archives, Brothers of the Sacred Heart, Rome, J14.352.02b) ….which determines the character of an institute A charism is the profile that each religious institute takes on as it seeks to follow Christ. This implies the practice of common principles of the Christian life, that all of the faithful are called to live, as well a certain specific aspects which characterize each religious family. The teaching that especially stands out from Mutuæ Relationes is that the charism of the founder determines the character or the specific nature of each institute, that is to say, its constituent elements, the style of life of its members, the way they live out the Evangelical counsels or their “particular style of sanctification and of apostolate”. In other words, the charism implies, simultaneously a specific end for the institute and the style of spiritual, human and social life of its consecrated members. We can compare the charism of an institute of religious life to the genetic code or DNA of a person. Just as the latter contains all the characteristics of an individual, the charism of an institute encompasses all the elements that determine its specific identity. This identity is a rich spiritual patrimony, not only of the past, but equally of the present. For as was said above a charism is not something static; it is constantly evolving. Finally, it is important that each institute preserves its specific identity. Were an institute to lose its identity, the entire Christian community would be the poorer. For stripped of its reason for existence, that erstwhile institute would have nothing specific to contribute to the Church and to the world. 7 Dimensions of Charism A few years ago at a meeting of religious men and women, I caught the drift of the following exchange between two sisters: “What is the charism of your institute? asked the first one. - Well, that’s not easy to say, replied the other. - Ours is very straightforward: education,” declared the first, without the slightest hesitation. Having overheard this exchange, I began to ask myself a few questions. Is education really a charism? Or is it a mission? Or is it simply a profession or a service? Is it really that easy to define the charism of an institute? Can charism be reduced to simply a mission? Considering everything said earlier in this chapter, we can conclude that education in itself cannot be understood as a charism. The reality is that it is not necessary to receive a special gift from the Spirit to be an educator. Later on when we deal with the topic of mission, we will see that education in itself is not a mission either. Demonstrably, charism cannot be identified with mission. The charism of the founder, and consequently the one his followers inherit, may be said to have three dimensions: - The specific aspect is that intimate relationship that the founder has with God, which is born of the fascination which he/she experiences for the person of Christ and the attraction which the founder feels for a particular aspect of His mystery. Simultaneously, this special relationship with God colors every other relationship that the founder has with the people around him, and it enlivens and motivates all his activities, this is the spiritual dimension (spirituality). - Fraternal life in community means a fraternal life in which brothers share the grace of following Christ as they try to take on His style of life is the brotherhood dimension. - Responding to the needs of one’s contemporaries means a response born of a desire to identify oneself with Christ who did not come into this world to be served but to serve, this is the mission dimension. Spirituality, brotherhood and mission are the three dimensions of this unique reality that we call charism. By making such a statement, I do not disregard the fact that, according to the exhortation Vita Consecrata and our Rule of Life, the fundamental dimensions of religious life are consecration, brotherhood and mission. Yet, I prefer to stick to the outline of the ordinance of our last general chapter. I wish to stress that our relation with the Lord (spirituality) is like a perfume permeating all our life, that is the way we are, communicate with others and act. We can thus say that spirituality and consecration are related notions. Actually, spirituality, or the special relationship with the God of Love that the Holy Spirit reveals to us in Jesus, urges us to dedicate ourselves to God with what we are and what we have. Each one gives life to the other two, and, in turn, receives life from them. They may be compared to the interplay between the head, the heart and the lungs, for example. No single one of these three organs can do without the other two. Likewise, each dimension of a charism gives life to the other two, all the while receiving life from the others. The three are in total harmony and inter-dependent, which means that the 8 equilibrium among them is indispensable for living an authentic and truly prophetic religious life. 9 Chapter III: The Charism of Father André Coindre, the Charism of the Institute We all have an identity, that is to say external features and a way of being that characterize us. Sometimes it is difficult to recognize people that we have not seen for a while because, of course, with age people do change. Other times the outward change is starker, even dramatic. There was a young mom I knew who used to take her son to our school every day. She always seemed to be so pleasant, and so recognizable. I would see her most mornings, and whenever I saw her I would always greet her. Once, I had not noticed her and so she said, “What no greeting, this morning?” I turned round and, as she was had a new “look,” I replied, “Well, Madam, are you really the same person I saw yesterday?” In these days of cosmetic surgery and makeovers anything is possible. With all due respect to women, young or less young, I am reminded of the gentle chiding that Cyprian of Carthage gave women with his tongue-in-cheek humor, “Don’t put on too much make-up, otherwise it just might happen that the Lord may not recognize you when you arrive at the gates of Heaven.” A charism is not something superficial. Quite the opposite, for it encompasses the graces that determine the underlying identity of a founder in his capacity as founder, and the graces he bequeaths to his disciples as they gather together as an institute to realize a shared vision for a specific Gospel work. It goes without saying that, acquiring such an identity is a very demanding and a long-term exercise. Nevertheless, in this chapter we shall endeavor to familiarize ourselves even more with the charism of André Coindre and that of the institute, and hopefully thereby become more aware of who we are and what we are called to be. The Charism of Father André Coindre “How can anyone who is already old be born again?” And Jesus replied: ‘In truth I tell you, no one can enter the kingdom of God without being born through water and the Spirit’.” (Jn 3:4-5) I can hardly call myself an expert either in religious life or in the charism of our founder. And so I must admit feeling that as I delved into the area of charism I was to a certain extent treading on unknown territory. Nevertheless, I ventured tentatively on that path, relying especially on documents I found in our own, many of which are the result of research by brothers far better informed on the matter. The latter are brothers who, from the early nineties served at the André Coindre International Center (CIAC) in Lyon – the very site of our foundation. They really lived the experience of our founder and, armed with the results of their research, they tried to spread their findings on the early days of our institute to the brothers at large, through books, articles, conferences, retreats, renewal sessions, etc. I want to give credit where credit is due, and express my deep gratitude to them for their generous work. I’m sure they will forgive me if, given my own limitations, I do not manage to translate clearly and succinctly enough their knowledge and insights on our charism. I also ask them to be indulgent with me if I do not manage to transmit sufficiently well to you the fire of André Coindre and the essence of his legacy to us. Led by the Spirit One of the personal charisms of Father Coindre was that of preaching. So how can we account for the fact that he ended up by founding two institutes (one for men and one for women) dedicated to the education of children and young people? Here’s my attempt at an answer. A little earlier on I said that a charism is an experience of the 10 Spirit. Father Coindre, in the midst of his daily faith journey, allowed himself to be led by the Spirit. And the Spirit led him to discover day after day, and each time with even greater clarity, the Heart of God. And as he contemplated that Heart, a fire of love was kindled into an ever brighter flame in his own heart. It was this same fire that impelled him to give him self to God and to the children and young people whom he met it in the prisons and on the streets of Lyon. And a little later on he was to include in his vision of a Gospel work, children and young people from rural areas. The Lord’s work We know that a few months before the foundation of the Institute, most of the brothers from Valbenoîte separated from the group to return to the pastor of the Valbenoîte parish. Likewise, we are aware of the tremendous efforts of Father Coindre in securing and establishing the Monistrol site as a formation center for his Missionary Priests of the Sacred Heart, and for his own brothers. Unfortunately, the project was soon to fail because the Local Ordinary repeatedly re-called priests responsible for the formation of the seminarians, in order to appoint the most gifted of them as pastors of parishes in his diocese. The surprising equanimity with which Father Coindre accepted each of these reversals is an evident sign of his docility to the Spirit and his trust in Providence. He saw himself as a simple laborer in the Lord’s vineyard, and that no matter what happened, the work of God would be realized one way or another. Dimensions of the Charism We saw above that the charism of a founder appears “as an ‘experience of the Spirit’, transmitted to their disciples” (Mutuæ Relationes, § 11) A Charism is, therefore, a gift that the Spirit bestows on founders for them to experience and live out for themselves, in the first instance, and then in turn, to bequeath to their followers so that they too may share in and live a similar spiritual experience. It follows that the charism of a founder and the charism of an institute are intimately bonded together. That is why I will link them together in the following paragraphs, as I make a brief presentation of their dimensions. Spirituality “The Heart of Jesus beats for us with love and compassion.” (Translated from Notes de prédication du Père André Coindre, 1787-1826, Rome 1963, p. 52) The spirituality of Father Coindre was born of his contemplation of the open side of Jesus crucified, the sublime expression of a love full of the compassion, gentleness and mercy of the Heart of God. Father Coindre was a man with a heart overflowing with goodness and compassion. Brother Jesús Ortigosa maintains that in his letters to Brother Borgia, Father André Coindre, “appears as the best of fathers and the kindest of men, as a person imbued with deep faith and gifted with a practical sense, positive and full of confidence in people. The saying, ‘a mother could not have more tenderness for her children,’ expresses well Father Coindre’s own affection for his brothers.” (Jesús Ortigosa, The Concern, the Attachment and the Love of Father André Coindre for his Brothers, Lyon, May 19, 1998, pp. 10-11. General House Archives, Brothers of the Sacred Heart, Rome, J14.373.1) The spirituality of the open side shows through in Father Coindre’s letters to Brother Borgia. In Brother René Sanctorum’s view, “We can discern that our founding father 11 had a heart open to all. He shared in the joys and in the sorrows of each brother. He would continually urge them on, and encourage them, inviting them to gentleness, patience and tender love.” (Translated from René Sanctorum, Le charisme du Père André Coindre, notre fondateur, Alex, June 18, 1995, p.6. General House Archives, Brothers of the Sacred Heart, Rome, J14. 352.02a ) In a similar way as in the case of our founder, the spirituality of our institute is born out of a contemplation of the open heart of the Crucified One, which manifests the love of God for all men and women. The entire life of a brother must therefore be a response to this same love, as he identifies with Christ gentle and humble (cf. R 14), and in a love for his brothers (cf. R 15) and for all men and women. (Cf. R 16) That is why the charism is not primarily a mission which is concretized in an educational or charitable work. The charism is, first and foremost, a gazing upon Christ, eyes focused on his open side, and it is a life that witnesses to this contemplation. Brotherhood “Let our brothers never be motivated in their work by self-interest; the greatest misfortune would be division.” (André Coindre, Writings and Documents, 1, Letters 1821-1826, Letter no. III, p. 61) In September 1821 Father Coindre preached a community retreat for ten men, who at its conclusion were to pronounce private vows, and thus become the first members of our institute. We thus see that from its very foundation our institute and our charism were endowed with a community dimension. Our founder intended that, even from the earliest days of the institute, its members were to be brothers living in a community of brothers. He might have chosen to send his brothers as coadjutors to his missionary priests, for example, but such was not his desire. His letters bear witness to an unremitting concern for unity and honest relationships among the brothers. In letters XI and XXIII he manifests a good deal of reluctance to sending brothers to any apostolic work whatsoever, where the brothers would not be able to live in a community setting. Our institute emphasizes the importance of fraternal life among the brothers. They share a community life marked by a spirit of simplicity, acceptance, family spirit, and close relationships, and all regardless of the positions of authority they might exercise either inside or outside community. (Cf. R 15) Mission “‘Those who teach others will shine as stars for all eternity,’ says the prophet.” (André Coindre, Writings and documents, 1, Letters 1821-1826, Letter no. VII, p. 85) André Coindre’s listening to the Spirit is manifested through his concern for others. That is why he focused his attention on the needs of the deprived children and young people of Lyon, and then later, on those of youngsters in rural areas. And it was in this way that the missionary dimension of his charism took shape. Brother René Sanctorum has this to say on the subject: “A work of formation and of human advancement, especially for the poorest youngsters – abandoned, orphaned, wretched, delinquent, illiterate – with the intention of evangelizing them, that was 12 (Father Coindre’s) goal: a human advancement for, and in a certain way, through evangelization, the two aspects always being linked closely together.” (René Sanctorum, The Way Evangelization and the Founding Charism of Father Andre Coindre, Lyon, November 6, 1997, p. 21. General House Archives, Brothers of the Sacred Heart, Rome, J14.352.05b). In the next chapter we shall develop the theme of the mission of the institute. Article 13 of the Rule of Life provides us with a kind of précis of it. Everything begins with a recognition and knowledge of the love of God for us, that is to say, of spirituality. Obviously we are not referring here to intellectual knowledge, but to the gradually deeper and deeper mark which the experience of our intimate relationship with God leaves upon us. This experience which fills us to overflowing is something that we cannot keep to ourselves, and we feel a need to share it with others. It is principally through our state of brothers and by our service for the advancement of humanity within the framework of education that we work together towards our common objective of evangelization. In dealing with the theme of mission we will see that even the practice of charity itself through our efforts on behalf of a given service is already an evangelization. Obviously our mission also requires that we commit ourselves to establishing within our field of ministry a Christian community which lives the Gospel of Jesus. Specific Identity Father Coindre’s intuition was that his young religious family did have an individual charism, a specific identity, and in consequence, its own particular contribution to make to society and to the Church of its day. That is why he was diametrically opposed to merging our institute with that of the Marists, for example. This had been the intention of Mr Cattet, one of the vicars general of the diocese of Lyon. At the beginning of the last letter that we have written in Father Coindre’s hand, our founder criticizes the proposal of the vicar general, in these terms: “Anyone who considers such mergers knows precious little about the workings of men and God. It is as if all families had to be fused together to make a single one, or all the countries of the world merged together to establish a single nation”. (André Coindre, Writings and documents, 1, Letters 1821-1826, Letter no. XXIII, p. 144) An integrated life As already underscored above each of the dimensions of charism – spirituality, brotherhood, mission – is life-giving to the other two, and conversely receives life from the former. Therefore, no authentic mission is possible without spirituality and community life. The work of Father Coindre on behalf of forsaken youth was born of his spirituality of compassion and his experience of community life with the Missionaries of the Cross of Jesus (the Chartreux). And his lived experience teaches us that his founding of the institute did not consist solely in the gathering together of a few men who sought to realize a humanitarian task on behalf of abandoned youth. Institutionalization of a charism In adapting the first sentence in Genesis to our theme, we could well say that “In the beginning was charism,” a charism which was to last. In order to guarantee the future of that charism Father Coindre began by establishing a structured community of brothers, an organization with a leadership and authority that promoted unity among the members of the group and fidelity to the original idea or vision, a rule that set out 13 the way of living the charism, the implantation of works to confirm an apostolic activity relying on sound infrastructures and reliable organization, etc. With the passage of time institutes run the risk of losing their charism. The result is that structures become like bodies without souls. And the danger is that those who exercise authority are reduced to playing public-servant-like roles; the rule ends up becoming a dead letter, and apostolic activity becomes a matter of efficiency and profitability. The sole objective becomes supremacy of the individual, even though this may be on the backs of the others in the group. So that in the end, it just may happen that the charism which breathed life into the members of an institute in its early years, eventually becomes shrouded in the mists of distant memory. Charism always remains living It is not only in turning towards Father Coindre that we must seek our institute’s charism. We must pay attention as well to the history of the institute, especially to those key moments, such as the election of Brother Polycarp as superior general, his decision to send brothers to America, the dissolution of the institute in France in 1903, and the institute’s admirable missionary expansion early on in the twentieth century, etc. At all times and in all places we must remain attentive to the Spirit so that our charism does not die. Such was the continual attitude of Brother Polycarp, himself. After his election as superior general in 1841, he embarked upon new and prophetic initiatives like the drafting of the new Rules, opening several schools, and the foundation in America. These initiatives and so many others constitute more than sufficient evidence that Venerable Brother Polycarp advanced the work of the Founder. And inspired by these realities, Brother Jesús Ortigosa writes: “What Brother Polycarp said and did challenges us today to return to the original charism of our institute. (Brother Polycarp’s) reverence for Father André Coindre is indisputable. As a legislator, as the founder of new schools, and as the one who launched our works in the United States of America, Brother Polycarp proved himself always faithful to the charism of the Founder, and contributed decisively to the development and increase of the grace of our original charism on behalf of children and young people in the Church.” (Translated from Jesús Ortigosa. Le Frère Polycarpe et sa fidélité au charisme du Père André Coindre. Lyon-Rome, mai-juin 2004, p. 5. General House Archives, Brothers of the Sacred Heart, Rome, J14.373.2) New times and new situations call us to incarnate our charism with renewed faith, trust, availability, and boldness, as we seek to find new and authentic answers to the needs of children and young people, and the Church and the world of today. Here is what Brother Jesús Ortigosa writes on this theme: “The end of the 20th century is a time when the future of the Brothers of the Sacred Heart as a religious congregation is being tested. It is a time when Jesus is calling us to stir up our faith and to have confidence in Him. It is a time when Father Andre Coindre invites us to keep listening, to continue the way of history, to make our way, to have courage, to begin new projects, to dream, to struggle, to open up new ways.” (Jesús Ortigosa, The Concern, the attachment and the Love of Father Andre Coindre for his Brothers, Lyon, May 19, 1998, p. 12. General House Archives, Brothers of the Sacred Heart, Rome, J14.373.1)) 14 CHAPTER IV In this chapter, relying on the writings of our founder and on the traditions of the institute, but especially on our Rule of Life, I will endeavor to present our mission in congruence with the charism. Some while ago one brother mentioned to me that to his way of thinking the chapter of the Rule that deals with the apostolate is incomplete, lacking in breath and depth of inspiration. In reality it is not only in this particular chapter that the theme of mission is dealt with. Of the first 208 articles contained in the Rule, some 60 refer to mission. What’s more, as we shall see later on, the concept is amply dealt with and in a good deal of depth and clarity. The Goal of the mission Helping to discover the meaning of life We saw earlier on that the charism is a gift of the Spirit to a specific person or to each of the persons endeavoring to advance in common a Gospel-based work for the service of the community, that is to say the Church or the world. I put it to you that this service consists in responding to the needs of people and that this response must be continually adapted to the circumstances of times and places. Now, just what are the needs of today? Over the course of these past three years I have made several trips to visit our local communities around the world. It is quite rare to come across empty airport, as was the case when I arrived in Harare, the capital of Zimbabwe, at the beginning of 2009. It has come to a point where only a handful of people can offer themselves the luxury of travelling by plane, whereas thousands of people now invade the bus and train terminals. When I see this great throng of people on the move, I can only wonder at the passion which drives so many among them on to new horizons reveals about them, perhaps their desire to give meaning to their lives, to discover in some far-flung corner of the world the paradise that they can not find “back home”. In all likelihood theirs is a journey in search of some sort of meaning and a share of happiness which eludes them. Most young peoples from developing countries have not had an opportunity for a life that adequately responds to their dignity as human persons. They grab hold of life as they struggle to get the best out of it, but more often than not, they simply lack the means or the know-how to succeed. Moreover, especially in developing countries, many of these youngsters lead lives of emptiness and futility. Too many of them grope about in the cavernous gloom of their lives trying to find a way out. But far too often they fall into the abyss of alcohol and drugs, sexual depravity, etc. This goes some way to explaining the very high rate of suicides among the young in these countries. As we contemplate this reality our mission today, both as Christians and as religious, our efforts must be oriented towards trying to help young people, as well as adults, to find a meaning for their lives, helping them to see that their lives are not meaningless, that do have purpose, that they do have worth, that they are gifted with a unique dignity, and that they are called to achieve great things in this world. People will only come to realize this truth when they feel affirmed, valued and loved, and when they respond to the affection that they receive. But this human love is not 15 an absolute guarantee nor does it always manage to slake the great thirst for human love. That is why that the question, “Do you really love me?” constantly re-echoes around us. In the God of Jesus, the Christ It is only when we feel loved by God that we can find true meaning in our life. The Spirit helps us to discover this immense and rock-solid love. It is this discovery that we experience the sublime love of God for us, a love which day after day, accompanies us on our way as we continue our pilgrimage towards that ultimate and blessed communion with Him. It is especially through Christ that God manifests himself to us. That is why we can say that in Him our life finds meaning. He is truly “the Way, the Truth and the Life.” (Jn 14:5; Cf. R 1) In the final communiqué from the Conference of Bishops of Latin America and the Caribbean held in May 2007 in Aparecida, Brazil, we read. “The best gift that we can receive is the gift of knowing Jesus; the best thing that can ever happen to us is that of having met Him, and our greatest joy is to make him known through our words and deeds.” (Translated from Aperecida, § 29) In order for a mission to be truly realized it is essential to experience an encounter with God through Christ. (Cf. R 2) For, it is in Him that we come to know the compassionate God, who cares for the poor and is overflowing with gratuitous love. It is of this very experience that Paul the great Apostle of the gentiles speaks when he says: “It is not I who lives, but it is Christ who lives in me.” (Ga 2:20) All of Paul’s letters speak of his love for Christ and of his identification with Him. Proclaiming the Gospel that is Christ, Himself Our mission is to proclaim the Gospel that is Christ, Himself. This is what the Aparecida declaration affirms: Throughout the story of human kind played out before his compassionate gaze reveals that God never forsakes his own. God so loved the world that he gave it his Son. He is the one who proclaims the Good News of the Kingdom to the poor and to sinners. And that is why we, as disciples of Jesus and as missionaries desire to proclaim the Gospel which is Christ, Himself. We proclaim to the peoples of the world that God loves them, that his existence does not represent a threat to humanity. With the saving and liberating power of His Kingdom God is very near to us. In times of adversity God constantly stirs up our hope in the midst of all kinds of trials. (Translated from Aparedica, § 30) Our Rule of Life declares that our mission consists in spreading the love of God, (cf. R 13) of kindling on the earth “the fire of redeeming love whose source is the Heart of Christ,” (Decree of Approbation of the Rule of Life, p. 12) of bringing “everything together under Christ, as head,” (Ep 1:10; cf. R 16) of realizing the Ametur Cor Jesu, (cf. R 12) of responding to the love of Jesus by loving our brothers and sisters and the young people entrusted to our care, (cf. R 118) of making love the inspiration for our apostolic and missionary activities, (cf. R 12 and 149) and of contributing to “the Church's educational mission of manifesting the real and effective presence of the Incarnate Word.” (R 63) These are very straightforward expressions, but abounding in meaning. But I do not have the luxury of being able to linger and wonder at them any further; I entrust you with that gratifying duty. 16 Building up the Kingdom Our mission is to contribute to the building up of the Kingdom of God, (cf. R 1) “which is the unity of all human beings in Christ.” 1 In other words, it is a matter of cooperating in the building up of a fraternal world, of an ever-increasing community living by Gospel values, that is to say the values of Jesus, Himself. Brothers, it is precisely Gospel values that anchor both our brotherhood and our community mission. And these values bear witness that communion is the vocation par excellence, and that the Church is the People of God and community. At the same time these values foster unity of objectives by placing diverse talents at the service of the Gospel. Living in brotherhood requires, among other things, that we be willing to affirm and value those who share our daily lives. I remember one brother, who, not long before his death, confided to another brother: “Brother, you’ve done a good job.” These were the last words anyone heard him speak. They were not simply a casual comment, rather were they the distillation of his way of living and of communicating over a lifetime. In the light of all of this we are able to better understand the importance of realizing our mission in communion with the Church. The Rule of Life invites us to be deferential towards the pastors of the Church, to follow their directives, (cf. R 8) to develop our apostolic actions in harmony with the pastoral goals of diocesan and national synods. (Cf. R 9 and 10) It seems to me opportune to reiterate here that that it is in the name of God and of the Church that we realize our mission. In the final analysis, like St. Paul we are simply instruments (cf. 1 Co 3:6-7) who, trusting in God who is always faithful, (cf. Rm 8:31-32) stirred on by our love for Christ, (cf. 2 Co 5:14) and sustained by his grace, (cf. Ph 4:13 and Rm 8:26) we co-operate in joy (cf. Ph 4:4) in the realization of the divine plan. Realizing the mission is to … …cultivate spiritual life. To begin with I would say that we realize our mission much more by what we are and who we are than solely by what we do. The spiritual life is the fundamental character and source of our ministry because it is part of our deepest identity. On the one hand our apostolic dynamism is born of our spirituality. More specifically, it is born of our intimate relationship with the Lord who gives shape and structure to all our relationships and all our activities. On the other hand, it is we who bring these relationships and these activities to Him in our intimate exchanges with Him. This dual movement can be translated as those of prayer of life and life of prayer. Our prayer is the expression of our love for God and for neighbor, and it is this very love that helps us to discover the “paths of prayer.” (R 133) 1 Translated from Timothy Radcliffe, Je vous appelle amis, Paris, Cerf, 2001, p. 184 17 Our own spirituality is centered on the contemplation of the open side of the Crucified One, through which we are enabled to glimpse the boundless love of the Heart of God for us. The Spirit helps us to discover this love, and spurs us on to respond, that is, to love God by committing ourselves to the mission for the sake of our fellow men and women. That same Spirit sustains us in our apostolic difficulties by bolstering our faith and trust. (Cf. R 152) What is more, the Spirit urges us on to accept in a spirit of reparation, “the hardships inherent in our lives as consecrated men and apostles.” (R 117) Our Rule of Life might be summarized thus: As brothers, we are united and consecrated in the Heart of Jesus for service in prayer and in ministry. And so clearly, prayer is a service of inestimable value to the Church and to the world, and comparable to even the most apostolic and generous of works. Ministry and prayer go hand in hand. Our Rule of Life tells us that in the midst of our apostolic tasks and our difficulties “we will sometimes need to show courage to establish interior silence, to retreat into solitude, and to persevere in prayer.” (R 133) In another article, the Rule reminds us that in order to orient young people to the person of Christ, we must possess a “dynamic relationship with the Lord.” (R 158) Our celebration of the Eucharist and our devotion to the Blessed Sacrament constitute the basic nourishment we need to undertake and persevere in our ministry. The very act of gathering together around Jesus for the Eucharist, the body of blood of Christ, broken and shared, is a sharing in God’s service and in the service of neighbor. (Cf. R 24) And that is why in our houses the chapel is the venue par excellence where we offer Jesus our ministry and ask him to make it prosper. (Cf. R 43) … bear witness to “One picture is worth a thousand words,” goes the saying. And this notion is very much in line with a reality of our ministry. The witness of the apostle’s zeal tends to remain etched ineradicably in the minds and in the hearts of those around committed religious, and spurs them on constantly to confront with courage and confidence every material, emotional and spiritual challenge. There is no lack of anecdotes to support the above contention. For example, even after 40 or 50 years many people still remember Brother Angel Moraza (Julian). Founder of our institute’s works in Colombia. He was a man gifted with good sense, human and spiritual. He was a good man, full of compassion especially towards the poor. A self-made man with an enviable degree of competency, Brother Angel was filled with and vivified by a spirit of humility and true brotherhood. He had been appointed regional superior, and at the end of the 70’s he was the dean of the community and bursar of one of our schools. A former student told me once that every morning after community prayer and Mass, just when the early birds were arriving at school, he would go down to the school yard, and armed with a broom and dustpan he would proceed to gather up the “little gifts” that passing dogs had left during the night. 18 The former Master of the Dominicans writes that, “apostolic life is not so much what we do as what we are.” 2 In other words, we must become a living word for others rather than limiting ourselves to saying important words . In that same vein, the Rule of Life declares that “the brothers carry out their mission by the example of their lives.” (R 163; cf. R 18) Elsewhere, the Rule underscores that elderly and ailing brothers, through their union with the Heart of the suffering Jesus, through their serenity and their courage in dealing with their illness, and through their prayer are a genuine support of their brothers engaged in the active ministry. (Cf. R 161) We are called to be witnesses to the infinite love of God for his children. And for that, as Father Radcliffe suggests, it is not necessary to do anything extraordinary. “Being a witness does not involve having to do any propaganda, or even of actively seeking to convert people, but simply being a living mystery. This means to live in such a way that our lives would have no meaning if God did not exist.” 3 ….of fraternal life The source of Brotherhood is to be found in the love of God. Father Radcliffe puts it this way: “Saint Thomas Aquinas taught that at the heart of God who is love, there is friendship, an indescribable friendship between the Father and the Son, and this is the Spirit.”4 Brotherhood is the distinctive sign of every genuine religious community, but this relationship does not exist solely for its own sake. Forming community is not a matter of establishing somewhere “out there”, in splendid isolation, a kind of haven of tranquility and bliss. We must not yield to the self-absorbed temptation of living together in a mutual admiration society. Quite the opposite, community life exists only in order to advance and realize the objectives of an institute. Fraternal life in community exists only as a means to the mission, though there are those who might consider community an obstacle to mission. One day in Colombia we had a visitor who said to us at table “Brothers, I know you reasonably well, I can see and appreciate your qualities and I am convinced that you could be far more effective than you are already. All you would have to do is send all your brothers to be principals of schools instead of running a single school staffed by a community.” This view flies in the face of the spirit of the document Fraternal Life in Community. In it we read, “all of the fruitfulness of religious life depends on the quality of the fraternal life lived in community,” and that “fraternal communion is in itself already a ministry; that is so say that it contributes directly to the work of evangelization.” (§ 54) Fraternal life in community is not only important to the mission, it is an essential element of the mission, since it renders the evangelical call to brotherhood credible. (Cf. Jn 17:21) 2 Id., ibid., p. 204. Translated fromTimothy Radcliffe, Pourquoi donc être chrétien? Paris, Cerf, 2005, p. 9. 4 Translated from Timothy Radcliffe, Je vous appelle amis, Paris, Cerf, 2001, p. 215. 3 19 The same document goes on to make clear that the love that unites the members of a community is the same that “urges communities on their path of mission, whether this be contemplative, proclamation of the Word or ministries of charity.” (Fraternal Life in Community, § 56) First and foremost, religious life proclaims the Gospel of brotherhood by the very fact that it is itself a true brotherhood. Religious life is, therefore, at one and the same time a sign of the Trinity, and its members are disciples of the Lord (cf. Jn 13:35) who calls them all to communion. Religious life is also a sign of the Kingdom, of the Church and of what the world is called to be. It proclaims the inviolable and primordial dignity of the human person, and anticipates eschatological communion. (Cf. Religious Life in Community, §§ 54, 55) But that is not all. I once heard a priest who was working in a very poor city say that the objective of every ministry is the formation of community. In order to tend towards such an end, a prophetic commitment on the part of a community is fundamental. Moreover, quality community life constitutes a help to its members to live their respective vocations authentically and is an aid to perseverance in it. Thus, the first beneficiary of the ministry of a community is the community itself, a community which periodically to periodically meets to review, willing to examine their community attitudes and actions, their apostolic objectives, projects, and availability. (Cf. R 27) Finally, our Rule of Life emphasizes repeatedly the intimate relationship that exists between fraternal life and mission. The Rule reminds us that we live in community to share our lives and our mission, (cf. R 15) to show concern for the needs of the world and spurs us on to action by the gift of ourselves. It invites us to mutual support, and to bear witness in our ministerial mileu. (Cf. R 15) The Rule further calls us to develop a team spirit as we realize our ministry by giving preference to community works, (cf. R 49) and to witness to charity and “the nature of the Christian vocation.” (R 153) …of consecration The consecrated life is in itself already and apostolate, for it proclaims the love of God and is an expression of that love. In reality, the life of a consecrated person has no meaning except in the light of this love. In other words, the prophetic and atypical life style of the consecrated person can only be understood as a loving response by one who has been seduced by the one who is all-Loving. The Rule of Life authenticates that our consecration is itself a form of ministry. The Rule teaches that in consecrating ourselves in exclusive service to the love of Christ (cf. R 117) we proclaim the love of God and we recall the vital importance of conversion and universal brotherhood. (Cf. R 5) By our consecration we reveal the compassionate countenance of the Lord, (cf. R 152) the solicitude of Christ for all men and women, (cf. R 118) and we are witnesses to the spirit of the beatitudes. (Cf. R 64) Through the Rule we commit ourselves to exercise a ministry in congruence with the mission of the institute and the Church, (cf. R 67) we render ourselves more available for the service of love, (cf. R 60) we bear witness to a life offered totally to God for the sake of men and women, (cf. R 48) and we awaken them to the heavenly realities. (Cf. R 62) 20 The Rule also establishes the apostolic character of each of the vows. Thus, through consecrated chastity we embrace the Jesus’ life style, and we consecrate ourselves to the service of the Gospel. (Cf. R 68) Through chastity we witness to an authentic love for young people, and are a call to spouses to fidelity. (Cf. R 70) Through consecrated poverty we assume the common condition of all human persons through the daily charge of building up the earthly city, (cf. R 83) of serving the world, especially the most needy, (cf. R 80) of being in solidarity, (cf. R 84) and challenge the false values of money and power. (Cf. R 85) Finally, through consecrated obedience we dedicate ourselves to an unselfish apostolic service, (cf. R 101) and we discover together the will of God, relying on the mediation of our superiors who are the promoters of unity and of the apostolic spirit. (Cf. R 102) In a world that has, in good measure, lost sight of the meaning of life, a world where so many desperately pursue power and popularity, consecrated persons who give authentic witness of simplicity, joyful, generous and gratuitous service to God and to humanity, shine with dazzling light. …serve children and young people “Following Jesus as brothers of the merest little ones, we want to spread in a more intense way the preference of André Coindre for children and youth, poor and without hope, as well as his educational heritage marked by compassion and trust.” (A pilgrimage of Hope, p. 25) The fundamental aspiration of our lives as brothers is not self-aggrandizement, but the service of God and our brothers. It is in this sense that our mission is a service for the advancement of the human person, and it is primarily for the evangelization and education of young people that we develop our talents. As has been made clear above, this advancement is not merely for the sake of evangelization, but already constitutes in itself genuine evangelization. It is evident that explicit evangelization implies that we are well prepared to dedicate ourselves to education in the Faith, whenever and wherever the circumstances allow. The mission that I referred to in the preceding paragraph is part of our founder’s charism and part of ours, too, for we are his followers, after all. Father Coindre turned his compassionate gaze toward the many abandoned children and young people of Lyon. Some of them were simply wandering the streets aimlessly; others were in prison paying the price for their delinquent acts; and some had already completed their prison sentences. In the prospectus for the Pieux-Secours foundation Father Coindre says of those young people: Guilty at an age when boys tend to be reckless rather than wicked, impetuous rather than incorrigible, hope or their transformation must never be lost. They must be surrounded with every possible help in order to form them to good habits…What therefore is to be done? They are rejected wherever they go. Honest employers are unwilling to hire them. All the religious establishments refuse to admit them, despite the fact that substantial sums have been offered to cover the cost of apprenticeships. Are they to be left to return to their former ways? Are all the noble 21 expectations for them to perish, due to an inability to provide suitable accommodations for them? No, such a thing would be out of keeping with Christian charity. A safe haven must be found for them provided with workshops where they can be taught and honest trade. (André Coindre, Writings and documents, 3, Pieux-Secours, pp. 29-30) Between 1816-1821 Father Coindre, moved to the core of his being at the plight of young people, responded to their needs by setting up not only Pieuse-Union, but two other providences; he also founded the institute of the Religious of Jesus and Mary, and our own institute. Thanks to the many missions that Father Coindre gave with his missionary companions he discovered the educational needs of children in rural areas. In his letter of January 10, 1822 he writes: “If I open another foundation [Brother Augustin] will go there as a teacher.” (André Coindre, Writings and documents, 1, Letters, Letter no III, p. 57). On January 21 of the same year, he returns to the same idea: “Should we found a second house, it will be to teach reading and writing to children, as do the Brothers of the Doctrine [Brothers of the Christian Schools].” (Ibid. Letter no IV, p. 64) Beginning from that moment and until his death in 1826 he undertook to found several schools in various rural areas, even going beyond the bounds of his own diocese. Just as did the followers of Father Coindre, we realize our mission principally through the education of children and young people (cf. R 158) with a preferential option for the neediest children. There are many articles of the Rule of Life that confirm this: “The Institute of the Brothers of the Sacred Heart owes its origin to the apostolic zeal of Father Andre Coindre for instructing neglected youth and bringing them to the knowledge and love of God.” (R 11) The Rule of Life adds that the brothers take part in the mission of Evangelization of the Church, (cf. R 18 and 157) and they realize it in communion with Her, (cf. R 150) in their state as religious educators, “especially through their ministry in Catholic schools,” (Decree of approbation of the Rule of Life, p. 11; cf. R 13 and 162) through their teaching of subjects both profane an religious (cf. R 163), through education in the Faith (cf. R 164 and 168) and through appropriate campus ministries. (Cf. R 150) I would like to emphasize that our educational commitment is not simply a philanthropic work or a humanitarian service to society, but a genuine mission. We are speaking here of a definite mission, according to a specific charism. Even in those works where we do not actually evangelize in an explicit manner, we are still truly evangelizers. For through these works we make visible the love of God through the human and Christian quality of our service. If our educational service were to be only a social work, it would amount to nothing more than being a supply teacher, pure and simple. And we could call a halt to it all when the State eventually came to a point that it was able to meet all the educational needs of society. But such is not the case. It is precisely because the State does not want to fulfill the mission of evangelization that we are called to guarantee it in the works that we direct. This said, we should not hang on at all cost to works that are entrusted to us at a given moment in time, as if there were meant to be ours till the end of time. They 22 meet concrete needs in a particular time and place, according to our particular charism. None of our works is meant to last forever; it is the charism that must endure in perpetuity. I would like to emphasize yet again, that our service is part of a specific mission. We are not speaking, therefore, of a mere job or task. In our discipleship of Father Coindre this conviction must spur us on to ask ourselves continually what is our particular contribution to the works that we direct, and what concrete services must we take on in order to facilitate and increase this contribution. We must also evaluate the works we do have to see if they are in conformity with our charism and adequately meet the needs of today. As we have seen, the Rule of Life affirms that we realize our mission principally through the service of education. (Cf. R 162) What is more, we are invited to make a preferential option for the poor. Fidelity to the poor, in whom God is present, is the sign of our fidelity to God himself, and a sign of God’s preference for them. The Rule presents them to us in different guises: the destitute, (cf. R 82) those who suffer material or spiritual want, (cf. R 152) the oppressed and the forsaken, (cf. R 50) those who suffer injustice, (cf. R 150) underprivileged children, and inhabitants of less favored regions. (Cf. R 155) In addition to challenging us to seek the face of the poor, the Rule invites us emphatically to realize with them the designs of the Father, (cf. R 50) to serve Christ in them, (cf. R 10) and to serve them as Christ would. (Cf. R 80) The Rule commits us to show them compassion, (cf. R 10) and conscious of our own poverty, to cultivate a special sensitivity towards them. (Cf. R 152). The Rule wants us to be concerned with helping them concretely, (cf. R 82) and to promote their natural and supernatural advancement. (Cf. R 150) As followers of Father Coindre we realize our mission today mainly through formal education in schools of all kinds, in centers for tertiary education, in teachers training centers, etc. But we do so equally through informal education as we accompany groups, sharing our life and faith with them, (cf. R 159) We can even do so by helping to set up projects for human and Christian advancement and/or by sensitizing them to the ecological wealth of the earth, or by welcoming and supporting children and young people forsaken by society, those who are humanly challenged in any way, by organizing services of rehabilitation on behalf of people struggling with addictive behavior, by organizing leisure time activities, etc. We realize our mission in day schools, boarding schools, young people’s hostels, summer or winter camps, etc. In the exercise of our mission we keep our hearts full of compassion for all, especially for the neediest and most neglected. This predilection for the poor spurs us on to give both an affective and effective support that is concretized by our commitment to live for the poor, with the poor or like the poor. In all our works, even those where we are at the service of people who are financially well-off, we are to give preferential attention to those who are least in the eyes of others, and to develop in all a concern for those who are less gifted, and to develop in all a sense of social justice. Secondly in those works situated in poor regions or sectors we can live with the poor, in their very midst. Finally in other cases---an area reserved for those who are called to a special vocation, we will live 23 like the poor, accepting privations and working side by side with them. We are called to live an evangelical poverty wherever we are through generous work, fraternal sharing, and the selflessness of those who make do only what is absolutely necessary. Nevertheless, it would be a grievous error to claim that those who do not accomplish explicitly the duty of evangelization or who do not work directly in the service of the poor are not true evangelizers. Because so long as a ministry of whatever hue is exercised through prayer, community discernment, and in concurrence with legitimate authority, than that ministry is in conformity with the charism of the institute. (Cf. R 162) We have a single mission, but we exercise various ministries, and in diverse works. This diversity is a great wealth. Each local community gives life-giving breath to its ministries, but at the same time the brothers must appreciate and affirm through words and deeds the service rendered by other brothers committed to other and different ministries in other local communities, other than those in their own provinces or countries. Finally, I wish to emphasize that the Rule of Life is the hallmark of missionary spirit. For, it invites us to respond in generosity to the missionary needs of the Church (cf. R 51) so that the world may be built upon the foundation of Christ. (Cf. R 6) This invitation is for us an incitement to participate in the expansion of the Church in the transmission of the Good News in accessible language, (cf. R 153) in a spirit of enculturation, (cf. R 154) in willing dialogue, and always seeking to meet and interact with people of different ideologies. All the brothers of the institute, through their prayer, their relations with missionaries their help and availability must involve themselves in whatever way they can in this missionary enterprise, even to going to countries where the Church and the institute may call them. (Cf. R 165) 24 CHAPTER V: A Brothers’ School with André Coindre’s Charism Before delving into my next topic I would like to offer a word of explanation about the title of this chapter. To begin with, as articulated earlier on, the founding charism of André Coindre is the movement of the Spirit that he experienced at a signal moment in his life, and that was later transmitted to his followers. And so, our charism [as brothers of the Sacred Heart] is a gift of the Spirit received as a consequence of following in the footsteps of our founder. Again, let me underscore that the charism is a gift to persons and not to institutions. In our case it is not any particular school that receives the charism but rather those who are realizing the educational mission, each according to their own vocation. Clearly, of course, an individual school does benefit from this gift, a gift that causes the grace of communion to bear fruit in plenty. I do recognize that the expression “communion in the Charism” probably deserves a more in depth explanation, but unfortunately I won’t be able to develop the concept in this circular. I will, however, return to it in the next. You have doubtless noted that my chosen title is “a brothers’ school and not “brothers’ schools.” There is a difference, of course. The former is an educational work characterized by a predominating spirit of brotherhood, or to put it another way, by its family spirit---its community spirit. All members, independently of their respective vocations, live in open fraternal relationship with all, mutually recognizing their equal dignity. The latter might easily give the impression that charism and mission are the sole and exclusive property of a particular local community, which, as we shall see, is not the case. A more comprehensive explanation of this notion will be given in the next circular. In this chapter, my intention is to highlight in broad lines the particular hallmarks of an authentic brothers’ school---hallmarks which must be shared by and subscribed to by all those who labor within its walls. Though I am very much aware that most of our brothers in active service realize their mission and ministry in a formal educational setting, the word “school” as utilized here indicates mission in all its forms of ministry, as discussed in the previous chapter. Therefore, no brother, whatever his ministry, need feel excluded. During our visits to the various sectors of the institute, as members of the general council, many principals of our schools and those in charge of our other educational works ask us to address their respective faculties and staffs so as to underscore the importance of the mission and express our deep gratitude to them for the singular service that they provide [to children and young people]. The hallmarks that I am going to underscore in the next few paragraphs are the fruit of sharing sessions with our many collaborators in the mission on their commitment to the educational mission. They shared their ideas on the flame of the charism, on the spirit which breathes life into the mission with which they have been entrusted as well as into them personally, on their own vocation as educators, on the way in which they respond to that calling, given their own identity as lay people, and on the challenges for the mission in today’s world. Our collaborators in the mission have been exposed to these experiences of the charism for some years now. They include, the Coindre Leadership Program in the United States, the Tutelle (Trusteeship) in France, formation programs for our educators in Spain, in Latin America and elsewhere. You have probably heard of some of them or even participated in them yourselves. 25 They have been and continue to be a wonderful grace for our religious family. That is why I would encourage you to pursue enthusiastically and full of hope, the paths that you have already taken or others that you may soon begin to follow, though I must caution on the ad experimentum nature of the latter. None of this is about theories for the sake of theories, but rather is it a matter of sharing and celebrating life, of journeying together in the present so as to be better able to venture into the future. And, of course, in all of this the pedagogical dictum,”learning is doing,” remains quite valid. It is all well and good to develop and draft beautiful position papers on our mission, but none of this will amount to very much if they are not the fruit of what we have discovered by working, sharing, realizing, experimenting, evaluating, deepening, celebrating and planning together. Conscious of what I have just asserted, I would nevertheless like to underscore a few fundamental characteristics by which our educational works can be identified. In what follows, most of the subtitles are drawn from the synthesis developed in the Coindre Leadership Program, a curriculum drawn up to present the essential elements of our educational tradition. This is, in my view, an excellent and faithful presentation of who we are, in which I for one, can easily identify. Those of you who are familiar with the content of the program will note that for my own purposes I have opted for a different, more personal order of presentation. Some of the features of our apostolic works are common to all Catholic educational works; others are specific to us because we give them a particular nuance. You will also note that I make no distinction between the terms “school,” “educational work” or “establishment,” etc. each one tends to echo the other, in the various modalities of our mission to the exclusion of none. The school font of knowledge The word “school” as a place of learning calls to mind, almost immediately, images such as a focal point or a font of knowledge, if you will. In this sense it is a place set aside for pupils or students to learn what is known about the world and the creatures in it, at the same time as they acquire the skills necessary to be able to discover in the future what still remains unknown. Our human knowledge has contributed greatly to the outstanding scientific and technological advancements in our world, and to the development and invention of a diverse range of machines and tools. It is undoubtedly very important to pay very close attention to the teaching of both the sciences and the arts in our educational establishments so that our students can achieve a high academic standard. But it is equally important to acknowledge that knowledge is not, in itself, the end of education. Knowledge, no matter how extensive, can never fully satisfy the tremendous aspirations of the human spirit. Knowledge can be turned either to the benefit or to the detriment of humanity, and this is a fact to which history repeatedly bears witness. All of which lead one sage to declare “Knowledge be damned, if it does not lead to wisdom.” The school guide to wisdom The meaning that I intend here for the word “wisdom” corresponds to that found in Holy Scripture. The wise person is not presented as one who is necessarily learned, possessing a wide-ranging, acquired knowledge. Rather, the wise man is seen as living in a way that is pleasing to God, that is, as a child of God, as a brother and/or sister to all. Jesus, God made man, is the paragon of wisdom. No other human 26 person had a greater awareness of being Son of the Father and brother to all. No one ever before or since has ever lived in such a consistent and coherent way, the dimensions of Sonship and brotherhood. And this is why Jesus must be the fundamental reference point in our educational works that see themselves as schools of authentic wisdom. And for this, Jesus Christ, himself, must always be at the heart of our schools. Spirituality of the Heart of Christ Therefore, it is essential that all our institutions facilitate those vital encounters between children and young people and the humanizing message of Jesus of Nazareth. (Cf. Mission Statement of Schools in Spain) In our own schools and centers, the objective is an encounter with the Heart of Christ, the symbol par excellence of the love of God---the God who desires to share entirely our human condition. The spirituality of the Heart of Christ, the expression of the compassion of God for humanity, breathes life into every aspect of our school communities. This spirituality is manifested especially if the hallmarks of our interpersonal relationships are recognized as those of compassion, affection and respect. For, in large measure education is a matter of establishing and maintaining good human relationships. Formation of the whole person (Holistic education) The humanizing message of Jesus highlights the extraordinary dignity of the human person. After God, himself, nothing, neither person, nor even the Sacred Law, surpasses man. “The Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath.” (Mk 2:27). Faithful to the Gospel which proclaims this dignity, our schools opt for exclusive service to their pupils and students, journeying with them and supporting them in every aspect of their human growth, moral, spiritual, physical, intellectual. (Cf. R 168) In essence, therefore, the objective [of education in a brothers’ school] is to create an environment that fosters the formation of the entire human person (cf. R 149 and 151) through academic, recreational, sporting, artistic, pastoral activities, etc. In order to attain this goal, it is particularly important to develop a common vision for the promotion of values like sincerity, openness, respect, solidarity, community spirit, commitment, (cf. R 157) justice, concern for the environment, accountability, (cf. R 159) good work ethic, etc. The wealth and genuine value of our educational institutions is to be found in the persons who labor in them. And I offer the following anecdote by way of illustration. In one ultra-modern educational establishment directed by the brothers, equipped with all the latest didactic gadgetry and replete with wide-open spaces for recreation and sport, one pupil made so bold as to ask the principal: “Is it true that our school is one of the best brothers’ schools in the whole world?” After a few moments of reflection, the brother-principal replied tentatively, “Well I have worked in schools in rural areas and in big cities, in poor areas and in rich ones. And for me the best schools are not those that have the latest and best equipped and most modern buildings, and best sports fields. It’s true that such things are important, but there’s more to a school than its equipment and buildings. The best school is the one that has the best students, the best parents, the best teachers, in other words the best people in it. And God alone is the judge of that. So, tonight I’m going to ask God what he thinks of the people in our school. You do the same, and tomorrow we’ll compare notes. O.K.?” “It’s a deal,” said the boy, “I’ll get back to you tomorrow.” 27 Congruence between faith and life The comprehensive formation of the human person must encompass growth in the faith and congruence between faith and life, since faith is revealed by actions as the Apostle James declares so emphatically: “Show me your faith without works, and I by my works I will show you faith.” (Jm 2:18) Community Spirit The love of God and of neighbor summarizes the Law and the Prophets. (Cf. Mt 22:40) All of which means that the Gospel of Jesus is the Gospel of brotherhood. And so, another hallmark of our schools is community spirit, that attitude of life that is revealed especially by our close relationships to one another, (cf. R 156) by our openness, our concern for the welfare of others, by our spirit of hospitality, by the warm and friendly atmosphere we create in our local community houses, (cf. R 160) by our communion in the charism and in the mission, and by our teamwork. Another particularly distinctive sign of this spirit is the understanding and collaboration that exists between the teaching staff and the parents who are, after all, the primary educators of their children. Preference for the poor and commitment to justice It is especially through service that a person truly experiences love for others. The school is a privileged venue for the provision of a formation that will contribute to building a better world, a more human world, more livable, and more just. Service to the poor and commitment to justice must be two other pressing concerns of those who teach in brothers’ schools. We must be committed to justice. And, as with charity, justice too, begins at home, it begins wherever we exercise our ministry. It takes tangible effect in the special attention we give those persons in our establishments who are experiencing the greatest difficulty. In other words, service to the poor encompasses a sensitization of the members of an educational community to the situation of the people in their very midst. (Cf. R 159 and 169) Such sensitization implies a formation to justice and the initiation of imaginative and creative solutions and programs that pave the way to a better future. Education in compassion and in trust Holistic formation requires a particular pedagogy, that is to say a way of education adapted to, and in coherence with, our charism. Our pedagogy is the pedagogy of Jesus. It is pedagogy of the heart, one born of the spirituality of compassion. As Brothers of the Sacred Heart we must have an overwhelming and authentic love of the children and young people entrusted to our care. Anyone who truly loves affirms and values the one(s) loved. The person who loves, trusts others, and in this way helps them to feel valued, and to learn self-confidence. Our pedagogy is, therefore, a pedagogy based on trust, and that trust is translated principally by our acceptance of children and young people, by our respect for them, by our faith in their capacity for change and growth, whatever difficulties they might encounter. This pedagogy equally requires a genuine presence and availability---being present to young people through a presence founded upon watchfulness, kindness, openness and a concern for providing them with the accompaniment and support they need. A pedagogy based on trust is also pedagogy of listening, and of dialogue, (cf. R 160) of healthy relationships, (cf. R 158) and of prudent and reasonable 28 expectations. Finally, underpinning all of this the school should to be able to rely upon the services of a competent and experienced team of guidance persons. Atmosphere of good order and organization The final hallmark of a Brothers’ school is the atmosphere of good order and organization which reigns within. As emphasized in the “Coindre Leadership Program,” this kind of environment is vital “to lean and experience the love of God, the love of others and the love of study.” We brothers want our pupils and students to be shaped by and to value, both respect for authority and self-discipline. Formation to discipline implies and requires a respect for the dignity of all. It also means establishing mutual relations of trust, (cf. R 159) and cooperation, without discrimination or preference. The organization of the school is summarized and articulated in a mission/charism statement and amplified in its organizational vision. Everyone involved in the administration of the school, either directly or indirectly can take ownership of these two instruments because they all contribute to its drafting. (Cf. R 156) Beginning with its declaration of identity, and recognizing the particular conditions of the milieu, the statement of the educational philosophy of the school articulates specific objectives, defines its organizational structures, both pedagogical and didactic, prepares a flowchart, outlining and delineating clearly the duties and responsibilities of each member of the school community, decides on a management structures, and agrees upon and determines programs for ongoing formation of its faculty. This organizational vision must be reviewed and updated periodically. It must also be accompanied by an equally comprehensive pastoral plan which includes formation to values, integration of faith, culture and life, and the process of growth in the faith, (cf. R 158) so that at its heart the institution will be transformed into an authentic Christian community that witnesses to a Gospel-motivated life and vision. The pastoral element of the educational plan might be said to be its heart, soul, and its very marrow. All the members of the educational community according to their respective vocation recognize that they are at the service of the school, and depending on the particular service that they are called upon to render, support the educational plan and the pastoral plan by what they say and what they do. [They really ought to “walk the talk.”] A sound integration of the educational plan, the educational philosophy, the pastoral plan and the school organization pave the way to attaining the school’s objectives and fosters a greater unity of action among faculty. The end result of all of this is that the entire school community will be soundly evangelized, and will itself become in turn a better agent for evangelization. For everything must lead to a better service of the mission. In the next circular, I will highlight the person of the educator in a Brothers’ school, as I endeavor to sketch the profile of those who work in our schools and who espouse and endorse our educational mission. 29 CONCLUSION Our mission as disciples of Father Coindre and heirs of Brother Xavier and Brother Polycarp, and of all our predecessors is to do whatever we can so that the world of today, especially its children and young people, will find a renewed taste for life, feel comfortable within themselves and learn through their daily experiences that life is indeed worth living. Our role and our objective are to teach our students that life only finds meaning in the God of Jesus, and that true happiness lies in grateful acceptance of the gifts they receive, and in response to offer themselves to God throughout the length of their days. This mission flows from a particular experience of the Spirit. It consists in discovering the compassionate love of God through the Heart of Christ, whose open side reveals that he loved us to the end. (Cf. Jn 13:1) Our mission also implies that we must imitate to the best of our ability this same compassionate love for the people of God, particularly through children and young people. This gratuitous action of the Spirit within us, this gift given to each one of us, thanks to our state as members of a religious family for the service of our community, the Church and the world, we call charism. One of the risks of our consecrated life at the service of education is that we restrict ourselves to being men practicing a mere trade, however effectively and efficiently, in a specific milieu, and as such we end up by doing what everybody else does, a job (profession), with nothing to distinguish us, nothing specific to offer, without a specific identity of our own. Were this to be the case, it would signal the death knell of our charism, and the loss of our reason for existence. To be authentic signs means to be different, to be distinct, perhaps even unique. To be signs means to have our own identity with hallmarks that are recognized by those around us, and that enhance elements that we share with our lay colleagues. Every religious family in the Church has its own specific charism, which is its “salt” to give taste and “light” to illumine. (Cf. Mt 5:13-14) In order to truly return to the essentials of the consecrated life we must constantly draw the pure and fresh water to be found in the wellspring of our original charism. It is thus that our consecration will be revitalized and find resurgence. Brothers, today more than ever, we need to center our religious life on the charism of our founder, Father André Coindre, as did our predecessors. Relying always on the grace of the Lord we have the responsibility of rediscovering our charism, and use it to respond to the glaring needs of the world of today, by discerning and embarking upon well-considered and well-adapted courses of action. The next circular will deal principally with communion in the charism and the mission shared between religious and lay collaborators, and the necessary formation to live the mission in truth. But before dealing with these two topics I will present the lay vocation and the vocation of the brother as a religious-educator. In closing, my prayer for us all is that through the intercession of Mary, that faithful virgin, mother and educator, the Lord grant us the gift of fidelity to our charism, so that we may be witnesses of hope on the way of communion. 30 QUESTIONS FOR PERSONAL REFLECTON AND COMMUNITY SHARING N B: Though the questions are set in the plural, as though they were to be used for community sharing, they may be answered personally, as well. And, of course, you are welcome to add others. 1. What enlightenment does this circular provide? 2. Are we living our religious life in a balanced way, incarnating adequately each of the dimensions of the charism? In other words, are we living our charism fully? 3. What can we do in order to make progress in living our charism more fully? 4. In order to better live our charism, how can we remain more attentive to the conditions of people around us, their concerns, their suffering, their needs, their struggles, their hopes? 5. What are the signs that can identify our actions as not simply a job (profession) but an authentic mission? 6. As consecrated persons what must be our specific contribution to our apostolic works? 7. What services --- teaching, campus ministry, guidance, administration, leadership, etc. ought we to prioritize in contributing to our apostolic works? 8. What are the commitments to which our charism seems to be drawing us today? Introduction Chapter I: The Charism, a Gift for Service Why speak of charism? Charism in secular and religious language Charism in religious life Chapter II: The Charism of Founders Charism is a gift... ... spiritual and gratuitous ... personal and collective ... constantly alive ... ecclesial ... for a service ... dynamic ... which determines the character of an institute Dimensions of charism Chapter III: The Charism of Father André Coindre, the Charism of the Institute The charism of Father André Coindre Led by the Spirit The Lord’s work Dimensions of the charism Spirituallity Brotherhood Mission Specific identity An integrated life 31 Institutionalization of a charism A charism is always living Chapter IV: Our Mission The goal of the mission Helping to discover the meaning of life In the God of Jesus, the Christ Proclaiming the Gospel that is Christ, Himself Building up the Kingdom Realizing the mision is... ... cultivating spiritual life ... bearing witness to... ... fraternal live ... consecration ... serving children and young people Chapter V: A Brothers’ School with André Coindre’s Charism The school font of knowledge The school guide to wisdom Spirituality of the Heart of Christ Formation of the whole person Congruence between faith and life Community Spirit Preference for the poor and commitment to justice Education in compassion and in trust Atmosphere of good order and organization Conclusion 32