Last update: May 20th 2014 Title of the measure: IND-NLD6: Energy Tax, industry ( Energiebelasting, industrie) General description The Energy Tax (ET) is a levy on energy consumption that improves the yield of measures focussed on energy saving thereby making energy savings more attractive (by changing behaviour or by investing in energy-saving technologies). The level of the tax has been adapted a number of times (see table 1). The energy tax is levied on: • Gas • Compressed natural gas • Electricity • Renewable energy – gas • Renewable energy – electricity • Gas oil • Semi-fluid oil • Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) Before 2005 the Energy tax was called Regulating Energy Tax (REB). The REB was introduced on January the first 1996 (Staatsblad 13 December 1995, 662) as part of a “greening” of the tax system. The revenue of the energy tax is channelled back to the taxpayers through a lower tax on income (households) or wages (companies). Until 2005 the REB did stimulate the use of green energy as this was (partly) exempted from paying the REB levy. Energy distribution companies also used the revenues of the REB to lower the price of sustainable energy. Producers of sustainable energy received extra compensation for the delivered energy. Since 2004 the level of the ET is defined for a number of trenches in energy consumption for all types of customers alike. Each consumer pays a high levy for the first amount of energy use and ever lower levies for consecutive trenches. In this way the average ET per kWh electricity or m3 gas is much larger for small consumers than for large consumers. As shown in Table 1 the tax on electricity use above 10 million kWh was for the whole period € 0,50, while it increased from 2003-2014 for the smallest users by € 54,60, the medium use by € 22,40 and € 5,20. For natural gas the tax on the use above 1 million m3 increased from 2004 to 2014 by € 4,20 while this was for the smallest users an increase of € 116,70. Additional the companies that participate in the LTAs or the Benchmarking Convenant were excluded from this energy tax. The measure was included in a cross cutting measure “Energy Tax” in the Dutch NEEAP1, NEEAP2 and NEEAP3. On September 6th 2013 more than 40 organisations – including the Dutch government, employers, trade unions, NGO’s and the financial sector – signed the National Energy Agreement for a sustainable growth. This agreement focusses on energy saving, clean technology and climate policy. The agreement has to result in payable and clean energy supply, employment and opportunities for the Netherlands in clean technologies markets. As for the industrial sector, there ought to be an energy efficiency improvement by 1.5 % yearly or an energy saving of 100 PJ on the final energy consumption in 2020 with respect to the reference projection 2012 of ECN/PBL. The policy mix consists of energy saving, renewable energy, ETS and a few new instruments (such as individual agreements with ETS-enterprises (not only regarding LTA) and the EPK (an energy performance check). Netherlands Enterprise Agency, Ministry of Economic Affairs Last update: May 20th 2014 The Energy Tax will be playing an important role in the policy mix regarding energy savings. The National Energy Agreement states that loss in tax revenues due to the agreement will be compensated by and increase in the levies from the Energy Tax. Half of this increase is to be paid by citizens and the other half by companies. In the industrial sector the Energy Tax is not just an instrument to stimulate the actions on energy savings. Companies that take part in the voluntary agreements (LTA3 and LEE or LTA-ETS), are exempted from the energy tax on electricity. If the participants do not or insufficiently meet the obligations of the covenant, they can be excluded from further participation; as a consequence, they are no longer exempted form the Energy Tax. Measure Impact Level low medium high Impact evaluation (methods and results) Methods The effect of the measure on the industrial energy efficiency is negligible, because of the fact that when the industrial use is more than 1 mln m3 of gas and 10 mln kWh, the energy tax is not obliged (Jeeninga, 2002). Results The tables 1 and 2 show the tax tariffs for industries: table 1 for electricity and table 2 for natural gas. Table 1. Tax tariffs for industries, electricity €/ 1000 kWh Year < 10 MWh > 10 MWh50 MWh > 50 MWh10.000 MWh > 10.000 Mwh (business use) 1-1-2003 1-1-2004 1-10-2005 1-1-2006 1-1-2007 1-1-2008 1-1-2009 1-1-2010 1-1-2011 1-1-2012 1-1-2013 1-1-2014 63,90 65,40 69,90 70,50 71,60 75,20 108,50 111,40 112,10 114,00 116,50 118,50 20,70 21,20 26,30 34,30 36,90 37,50 39,80 40,60 40,80 41,50 42,40 43,10 6,30 6,50 8,60 9,40 10,20 10,40 10,60 10,80 10,90 11,10 11,30 11,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 Source: Ministry of Finance, Tax Office, website Netherlands Enterprise Agency, Ministry of Economic Affairs Last update: May 20th 2014 Table 2. Tax tariffs for industries, natural gas € / 1.000 m3 Year > 5.000170.000 m3 >170.0001 mln m3 > 1 mln10 mln m3 > 10 mln m3 (business use) 1-10-2002 1-1-2003 1-7-2003 1-1-2004 1-7-2004 1-10-2004 1-10-2005 1-1-2006 1-1-2007 1-1-2008 1-1-2009 1-1-2010 1-1-2011 1-1-2012 1-1-2013 1-1-2014 57,90 60,00 60,00 72,70 72,70 72,70 101,90 123,80 134,20 136,20 138,50 141,10 141,90 144,30 186,201 189,40 10,70 11,10 11,10 22,70 22,70 22,70 31,10 34,00 37,20 37,80 38,40 39,40 39,30 40,00 43,90 44,60 11,30 11,30 11,30 11,50 11,60 11,80 12,00 12,20 12,40 12,50 12,70 16,00 16,30 7,50 7,50 7,60 7,70 7,80 7,90 8,00 8,00 8,20 8,20 8,30 11,50 11,70 Source: Ministry of Finance, Tax Office, website Historical data Ex-post evaluation direct CO2 (kt) Energy (TJ) (Fuels/Electricity) Ex-ante evaluation direct CO2 (kt) Energy (TJ) (Fuels/Electricity) 1995 2000 2010 2020 1995 2000 2010 2020 Interaction of measures Mitigating interactions with: C-NLD1: Energy Tax (cross-cutting measure) IND-NLD13: Long Term Agreements with the industry, second phase IND-NLD17: Benchmarking Agreement (completed) IND-NLD19: Long Term Agreements with the industry, third phase IND-NLD21: Long Term Agreement ETS Reinforcing interactions with: none 1 Since January 1st 2013 the first two trenches (< 5.000 m3 and >5.000-170.000 m3) for natural gas have been merged Netherlands Enterprise Agency, Ministry of Economic Affairs Last update: May 20th 2014 References Jeeninga H.(2002), Honig E., Dril A.W.N. van, Harmsen R., Effect van Energie- en Milieubeleid op Broeikasgasemissies in de periode 1990-2000, ECN-C--02-004, Petten, 2002 (In Dutch) English abstract http://www.ecn.nl/library/reports/2002e/c02015.html Energy Tax, Ministry of Finance, Tax Office http://www.belastingdienst.nl/wps/wcm/connect/bldcontentnl/belastingdienst/zakelijk/overige_be lastingen/belastingen_op_milieugrondslag/energiebelasting/energiebelasting Energy Tax, Ministry of Finance, Tax Office, Tax tariffs http://www.belastingdienst.nl/wps/wcm/connect/bldcontentnl/belastingdienst/zakelijk/overige_be lastingen/belastingen_op_milieugrondslag/tarieven_milieubelastingen/tabellen_tarieven_milieube lastingen Energy Tax, Ministry of Finance, Tax Office, Exemption http://www.belastingdienst.nl/wps/wcm/connect/bldcontentnl/belastingdienst/zakelijk/overige_be lastingen/belastingen_op_milieugrondslag/teruggaafregelingen/ The Social and Economic Council of the Netherlands (SER), Energy Agreement for sustainable growth, 6 September 2013 http://www.energieakkoordser.nl/energieakkoord.aspx Netherlands Enterprise Agency, Ministry of Economic Affairs