Unit I 6 days SECTIONS What is Government? 1. The Purpose of Government (1 Day) 2. Forms of Government (5 Days) Enduring understandings Government is necessary to establish order, provide security, and protect the common good. There are many forms of government-democratic, unitary, confederal, federal, presidential, and parliamentary. In a democracy the supreme political authority rests with the people and the fundamental importance of each individual is essential. Key Vocabulary: government unitary confederation federal oligarchy democracy autocratic anarchy Thematic Focus: Governance The student will understand that as a society increases in complexity and interacts with other societies, the complexity of the government also increases. Georgia Performance Standards SSCG19 The student will compare and contrast governments that are unitary, confederal, and federal governments; unitary, oligarchic and democratic governments; and presidential and parliamentary governments. Prerequisites: In 9th grade students study the structure and historical impact of several forms of government including the Greek democracy, oligarchy, and autocratic governments. SSWH3 The student will examine the political, philosophical, and cultural interaction of Classical Mediterranean societies from 700 BCE to 400 CE (Greece/Rome). SSWH17 Describe the nature of totalitarianism and the police state that existed in Russia, Germany, and Italy and how they differ from authoritarian governments. Connections: In World Literature, students will read a variety of works that take place under various forms of government such as Night, In the Time of the Butterflies, and Farewell to Manzanar. 1 Unit I 5 days SECTIONS What is Government? Culminating Unit Assessment Enduring understandings Government is necessary to establish order, provide security, and protect the common good. There are many forms of government-democratic, unitary, confederation, federal, presidential, and parliamentary. In a democracy the supreme political authority rests with the people and the fundamental importance of each individual is essential. Thematic Focus: Governance The student will understand that as a society increases in complexity and interacts with other societies, the complexity of the government also increases. Suggested Culminating Unit Assessments Have students create a short skit where they act out characteristics of each of the forms of government discussed in the unit. Students should make sure to incorporate all the unit vocabulary and answer the AIM questions. As an individual assessment, have students write a short monologue where they compare at least three of the governments discussed in the unit. Students should compare the governments and then explain which one they think is most effective. Students can create a newsletter where they report on the conditions in three fictional countries. Each country must have a different form of government. Have students report on how the type of government influences the everyday lives of the citizens, the economy, and foreign relations. Resources: Rubrics for performance assessments can be found at rubistar.4teachers.org and www.teach-nology.com/web_tools/rubrics 2 Essential Teaching Elements Unit I Section 1 What is Government? The Purpose of Government (1 Days) AIM 1: How is government defined and what is its purpose? GPS: SSCG19 The student will compare and contrast governments that are unitary, conferral, and federal governments; unitary, oligarchic and democratic governments; and presidential and parliamentary governments. Core Text: Magruder’s: American Government, pp.4-11 Vocabulary: anarchy, government Instructional Points to Teach: Discussion Questions: • Government is the institution What would life be like if no government existed? through which a society makes and enforces its public policies. Differentiation Strategies Performance Expectation: Students will use the Frayer model to understand the meaning of government and how it contrasts with anarchy. A template for the Frayer model is located in the Graphic Organizers folder on the Government Curriculum website. Accelerated Students: See lesson attached. English Language Learners: Provide students with picture examples of societies in anarchy versus societies ruled by a government. Make sure students understand the meaning of each word. Compile a class list of the characteristics of each. Have students refer to the list as a guide while they complete a collage comparing anarchy versus government. Students should use the discussion questions as prompts to write a 2-3 paragraph comparison of anarchy and government. Less Proficient Learners: Students can write an acrostic poem using the word government. In their poem they include their definition of government and why it is significant. Have several students share their poems and then use responses to create a group authored acrostic on the meaning and purpose of government. Discuss with students the benefits and disadvantages of government based on individual freedom versus the common good. To close the activity, have students answer the discussion question in a short writing. Additional Instructional Suggestions: A lesson plan on the role of government can be found at http://www.eduref.org/Virtual/Lessons/Social_Studies/US_Government/GOV003 4.html 3 Resources See the Magruder’s American Government Teacher Materials for Chapter 1 Section1 for a ready to use presentation (Presentation Pro CD). There is a short student friendly article on the purpose of government found at http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/52050/what_is_the_purpose_of_the_go vernment.html 4 We The People An Educator's Reference Desk Lesson Plan Submitted by: Debilyn Janota School or Affiliation: St. Mary Grade School, Stayton, Oregon Endorsed by: These lesson plans are the result of the work of the teachers who have attended the Columbia Education Center's Summer Workshop. CEC is a consortium of teacher from 14 western states dedicated to improving the quality of education in the rural, western, United States, and particularly the quality of math and science Education. CEC uses Big Sky Telegraph as the hub of their telecommunications network that allows the participating teachers to stay in contact with their trainers and peers that they have met at the Workshops. Date: May 1994 Grade Level(s): 5, 6, 7, 8 Subject(s): Social Studies/US Government Overview: Learning about our American History and our United States Constitution can be fun as well as educational. As a teacher, I want these areas to become alive for my students, to convince my students that everyday they are living a part of history of our country and how these historical events have effected their own lives. I do this by not only lecturing, assigning paperwork but by various activities and projects. Purpose: Why do we need a government? Lesson introduces the basic concept of the "natural rights" philosophy. After the students recognize a need for government and rules, the students will be asked to think about the benefits and problems of living in a "state of nature" where there are no laws or government. Comparing their ideas with those of the English philosopher John Locke and how his concepts are used in preparing a proper government that protects the natural rights of an individual. Note: This lesson would take a few class periods. The lesson you see is what I would do the very first day of school to help establish classroom rules. I would continue to cover concepts of natural rights, identify and state the problems of a "state of nature" and conclude with a recapitulation of what was covered and have them try and apply some of these ideas into their daily living. Objectives: At the conclusion of this lesson: Students should be able to recognize the need for rules and government. Students should be able to explain the following terms from the natural rights philosophy: natural rights, state of nature, social contract and consent. 5 Students should be able to explain the problems that come within a state of nature and their possible solutions and compare their ideas with those of John Locke. Students should be able to explain how government and laws can protect natural rights. Materials: student text paper pen Time Required: 45 minute class -- first day of school/opening day of class Activities and Procedures: Introductory Activity -- Who's the boss? Objective: To recognize the need for government. 1. The teacher writes on the board: "This is a government class. for the next 10 minutes, we shall explore government." 2. Make no further comments. Answer no questions. At the end of 10 minutes (or shorter, if the class becomes chaotic), continue. 3. Give explicit directions as to: Where they should sit Lesson assignment -- book, pages, and so on Students distribution of books (or other materials to be used) Reading assignment Materials should: a.) define government as an institution that makes and enforces laws at federal, state, and local levels. b.) describe its function to maintain social order, provide public service, provide security and to make binding decisions. 4. Discuss by stating that they had a good example at the beginning of class of what happens when there is no direction, no authority, no one to make decisions, and so on. (Let the class express feelings.) Problem Solving: Work together in groups of 5. Answer the following questions and be prepared to present your answers to the class: (Grade 5 book, page 18 student text). Questions: 6 1. What might happen in the classroom if there were no rules or laws? 2. What might happen if there were rules and laws, but no one to make sure people obeyed them? 3. What might happen if there were rules and laws, but no one to settle disagreements about them? 4. Write five (5) rules for our classroom. (Keep in mind these rules should benefit all and be accepted by the majority). The students will present and share their answers and using question #4, work as a class to establish their classroom rules. The time allotted here may have to extend to another day. If the students could at least share their ideas, think about them then come back and decide. Tying It All Together: My main purpose in using these books and teaching about our American History and our United States Constitution is to provide the students a chance to want to study the subject further and to give them a sense of pride in our American history and our past which leads to our future. The students take a more active role in learning when they are allowed to use the information given to them and be able to actively use the lesson(s) right away and see results. 7 Unit I Section 2 What is Government? Forms of Government (5 Days) Essential Teaching Elements AIM 1: How are systems of government defined in terms of who can participate? GPS: SSCG19 The student will compare and contrast governments that are unitary, conferral, and federal governments; unitary, oligarchic and democratic governments; and presidential and parliamentary governments. Core Text: Holt, Magruder’s: American Government pp.12-17 Vocabulary: autocracy, oligarchy, democracy Instructional Points to Teach: Discussion Questions: • In a democracy, supreme What are the similarities and differences between autocratic, political authority rests with the oligarchy, and democratic forms of people. government? • An autocracy is a government in which a single person holds unlimited political power. • An oligarchy is a government in which the power to rule is held by a small, usually selfappointed elite. Differentiation Strategies Performance Expectation: Students will examine the similarities and differences between autocratic, oligarchy, and democratic forms of government. Accelerated Students: Students should identify one country, past or present, that has/had each of the forms of government listed above. Students will create a short profile of each country. Finally, have students compare the extent to which citizens were allowed to participate in government. Students can present their research to the class. English Language Learners: See the lesson below. After the guided lecture, have students draw a picture that represents the meaning of each word so you can check for understanding. Complete the remainder of the lesson as described. Also, consider giving students a copy of the presentation to the night before. Less Proficient Learners: Use PowerPoint for Chapter 1 Section 2 on the Presentation Pro CD (teacher materials) to facilitate a discussion/guided lecture on the similarities and differences between each type of government listed in the AIM. Students should rank the forms of government from most participation by the people to the least participation by the people. Students should create a flow chart that illustrates this ranking. For each box, have them provide a description of the form of government in terms of participation. To close the activity, have students answer the discussion question as a class or individually. 8 Resources Additional Instructional Suggestions: Use a Venn diagram to help students compare the different forms of government. They can then use the completed diagram as a pre-writing guide to complete a short take home essay. Use the AIM question as the essay prompt. A very brief and student friendly description of oligarchy can be found at http://www.historyforkids.org/learn/government/oligarchy.htm. An excellent article that discusses Democracy vs. Autocracy? in Ethiopia and can be found at http://www.somalilandtimes.net/2003/65/6523.htm. This would be a great comparative government reading. 9 Unit I Section 2 What is Government? Forms of Government (5 Days) Essential Teaching Elements AIM 2: How is power distributed within a state? GPS: SSCG19 The student will compare and contrast governments that are unitary, confederal, and federal governments; unitary, oligarchic and democratic governments; and presidential and parliamentary governments.. Core Text: Magruder’s: American Government pp.12-17 Vocabulary: unitary, confederation, federal Instructional Points to Teach: Discussion Questions: • A unitary government has all What are the similarities and differences between unitary, powers held by a single, central confederate, and federal forms of agency. government? Which of the 3 governments has a • A confederation is an alliance strong centralized government? of independent states. Which of the 3 governments has a weak centralized government? • A federal government is one in which the powers of government are divided between a central government and several local governments. Differentiation Strategies Performance Expectation: Students will examine the similarities and differences between unitary, confederate, and federal forms of government. Accelerated Students: Use PowerPoint for Chapter 1 Section 2 on the Presentation Pro CD (teacher materials) to facilitate a discussion/guided lecture on the similarities and differences between each type of government listed in the AIM. Have students create a brochure that explains the similarities and differences among the three forms of government. Make sure students include a definition, a comparative analysis, and a picture for each type of government. English Language Learners: Explain to students the idea of strong vs. weak centralized government. Next, discuss the characteristics of each form of government using the PowerPoint for Chapter 1 Section 2. Divide students into 3 groups, one for each form of government. Have them list the characteristics that all 3 forms have in common and how they are dissimilar. Students can share their findings with the class. Have students respond to the discussion questions as a class or individually. 10 Resources Less Proficient Learners: See the lesson above. In addition, students can outline the section in the text the night before in preparation for the lesson. Take several minutes at the beginning of class ask students what they felt were the main points. Have students compare their main ideas to those presented in the presentation. Additional Instructional Suggestions: Have students reflect on the Civil War. Discuss with students how for a period of time, the United States had a confederate and federal government. Discuss the pros and cons of each form of government. An excellent Document Based Question activity can be found at http://www5.esc13.net/socialstudies/docs/era%203/8AOCLesson.pdf. It addresses confederate vs. federal governments and also introduces students to the Articles of Confederation which will be studied in the next unit. http://government.pppst.com/types.html has several presentations on different types of government. 11 Unit I Section 2 What is Government? Forms of Government (5 Days) Essential Teaching Elements AIM 3: How are governments defined by the relationship between the legislative and executive branches? GPS: SSCG19 The student will compare and contrast governments that are unitary, conferral, and federal governments; unitary, oligarchic and democratic governments; and presidential and parliamentary governments. Core Text: Magruder’s: American Government pp.12-17 Vocabulary: presidential, parliamentary Instructional Points to Teach: Discussion Questions: • A presidential government What are the similarities and differences between presidential features separation of powers and parliamentary forms of between the executive and the government? legislative branches of What are the pros and cons of government. having the legislative branch separate from the executive branch? • In a parliamentary government , the executive is selected from the majority party of the legislature. Voters do not elect officials to the executive office. Differentiation Strategies Performance Expectation: Students will examine the similarities and differences between presidential and parliamentary systems of government. Accelerated Students: Assign students the reading in the text the night before. Facilitate a discussion using the questions above. Next, allow students to conduct independent research as described in the lesson below. Students should create a 3-5 minute presentation based their findings. English Language Learners: Use the chart on p.16 to help students understand the fundamental differences between a presidential and parliamentary system. Next, identify as a class at least two other countries that use a parliamentary or presidential system. Have them compare the characteristics of the governments in each country. Use the Internet and classroom projector to involve the whole class as you model how to use the Internet to find reliable information. Less Proficient Learners: Students will need access to the internet to complete this activity. Use the website at http://teacher.scholastic.com/researchtools/researchstarters/presidents/. Guide students through the reading and have them complete the questions under Recommended Research Topics. 12 Resources Additional Instructional Suggestions: Use the slide presentation found at http://www.slideboom.com/presentations/76890/Presidential-vs.-Parliamentary to help students understand the similarities and differences between presidential and parliamentary systems of government. See lesson attached. See the presentation for Chapter 1 on the Presentation Pro. An in depth article on these two forms of government can be found at http://www.undp.org/governance/docs/Parl-Pub-govern.htm. It would be great as teacher background for lecture material or for gifted readers. A detailed PowerPoint comparing these two systems of government can be found at www.mona.uwi.edu/.../USPresidentiavsBritishParliamentary.ppt. 13 COMPARATIVE POLITICAL SYSTEMS Overview This lesson is designed to describe the government of the Republic of Hungary since the transition in 1990 from a one-party Soviet-style regime to a multi-party parliamentary democracy. This lesson supplements the study of American government by providing a comparative study of political systems. In order for students to understand the government of Hungary they must understand three interrelated concepts: Parliamentary vs. Presidential models of representative democracy; the role of Hungary’s Parliament or National Assembly; and Hungary’s unique electoral system. The underlying theme of the lesson is the importance of electoral or voting systems in determining the outcome of elections and how governments operate. The importance of analyzing the operation and political consequences of an electoral system is further explained by Arend Lijphart: Except in very small communities, democracy necessarily means representative democracy in which elected officials make decisions on behalf of the people. How are these representatives elected? This indispensable task in representative democracies is performed by the electoral system - the set of methods for translating the citizens’ votes into representatives’ seats. Thus the electoral system is the most fundamental element of representative democracy (1). The above quote is clearly illustrated in Hungary were the parliamentary system offers multiple parties the opportunity to compete for national elections versus the American two-party system. Grade Level: Secondary This lesson can be found at www.flrea.org. Objectives: As a result of this lesson, students will: Analyze and evaluate different models of democratic government; Understand the role and function of the Hungarian National Assembly; and Understand the importance of voting in a representative democracy. Materials: Handout A - Presidential vs. Parliamentary Model of Government 14 Procedure Part I: Parliamentary vs. Presidential Democracy 1. Explain that from 1946-1989, the Hungarian government was modeled on the Sovietstyle one-party system. In 1989, a "democracy package," which included trade union pluralism; freedom of association, assembly, and the press; a new electoral law; and a radical revision of the constitution including the establishment of a Constitutional Court and the deletion of the word “peoples” from the “Republic of Hungary” was implemented. A democratic parliamentary form of government was established. This mirrored similar political events throughout Central and Eastern Europe as Soviet influence diminished with the ultimate collapse of the Soviet Union as a political entity in 1991. 2. Hungary is now a representative democracy. A representative democracy is one in which the will of the majority is expressed through a smaller group of individuals elected by the people to act as their representatives. These representatives are responsible to the people for their conduct, and they can be voted out of office. This system is also known as a republic. 3. Explain that in the modern world, there are two forms of representative democracy: presidential and parliamentary. A presidential democracy is one in which the lawmaking and law-implementing branches of government are separate. For example, the United States – where Congress has the power to make laws, and the President has the power to carry them out. In a parliamentary democracy, the lawmaking and law-implementing branches of government overlap. In Hungary, as in England, the Prime Minister and the Cabinet are members of the Parliament, and they enact the laws as well as carry them out. 4. Distribute copies of Handout A: Presidential vs. Parliamentary Democracy. (Also have students reference the sections on the President and Prime Minister in the Background Note at the beginning of the resource document.) Discuss with students that Presidential democracies clearly show the separation of powers between the executive and legislative branches. The president is not a figurehead, but functions as the head of government. In Parliamentary systems, the head of state (figurehead monarch or weak president) is a separate office from the head of government. (Example: The Queen of England) The head of government in a parliamentary democracy (Prime Minister, Premier or Chancellor) is the important and powerful figure. In parliamentary systems the voters elect only a legislature; the legislature or Parliament then elects an executive from its own ranks. (The party with the largest number of seats in Parliament or the leader of a coalition of two or three parties elects its party leader to serve as Prime Minister.) Hungary’s Parliament, the National Assembly, is a single-chamber body elected for four-years and has 386 members. The National Assembly elects the President of the Republic (head of state), the Prime Minister (head of government), the members of 15 the Constitutional Court, the Ombudsman, the President of the Supreme Court and other government figures. LESSON SELECTING A POLITICAL SYSTEM After reading and discussing presidential democracy versus parliamentary democracy, students will be asked to evaluate and vote on which system they would prefer. Materials: Handouts and notes on Parliamentary vs. Presidential governments, Parliamentary Democracy in Hungary. Copy of U.S. Constitution Poster board, markers Time: 1-2 class periods Tell class that they live in a new country recently created in Europe. The people of the country have decided that they want a representative democracy as a government. However, they must still vote on whether to have a presidential democracy or to have a parliamentary democracy. There will be a rally when people can speak in support of the form of government they support, and a vote to decide which one to have. Divide class into groups of four. Half of the groups will support a parliamentary democracy and the other half will support a presidential democracy. Each group will create a campaign poster, slogan and 1 minute speech to support their political system. Each group will present their point of view in front of class before the vote. Campaign poster must contain the following items: Which democracy group supports Campaign slogan 3 reasons to support the type of democracy Colorful, neat, creative Speech must include the following: Which democracy group supports Campaign slogan Three reasons to support the type of democracy Allow each group to present their speech and poster, then have class vote on the type of democracy they want for their country. 16 Handout A Representative Democracy: Presidential vs. Parliamentary A Presidential System President elect Legislature Cabinet Ministries or Departments elect Voters Parliamentary System Coalition Selects and ousts Prime Minister Parties Parliament Cabinet guides Ministries elect Voters 17 Unit I Section 2 What is Government? Forms of Government (5 Days) Essential Teaching Elements AIM 4: What are the foundations of democracy? GPS: SSCG19 The student will compare and contrast governments that are unitary, conferral, and federal governments; unitary, oligarchic and democratic governments; and presidential and parliamentary governments.. Core Text: Magruder’s: American Government pp.18-23 Vocabulary: presidential system, parliamentary system Instructional Points to Teach: Discussion Questions: • The American concept of What foundational concepts are basic to democracy? democracy rests on these basic notions: (1) A recognition of the fundamental worth and dignity of every person; (2) A respect for the equality of all persons; (3) A faith in majority rule and an insistence upon minority rights; (4) An acceptance of the necessity of compromise; and (5) An insistence upon the widest possible degree of individual freedom. Differentiation Strategies Performance Expectation: Students will analyze the concepts that provide the foundation for democracy. Accelerated Students: Have students take each one of the points listed in the instructional points and brainstorm current issues that show the American Democracy is still a work in progress. Students should then write their own social commentary on how much progress has been made in America regarding each of the 5 concepts. Students can use current event articles to support their position. English Language Learners: See lesson attached. Students will need internet access or use your computer and projector to complete the lesson as a class. 18 Resources Less Proficient Learners: See lesson attached. Students will need internet access or use your computer and projector to complete the lesson as a class. Additional Instructional Suggestions: Use excerpts from Tocqueville’s Democracy in America (see link below). Have students create a two column chart where they list the characteristics of American democracy as described by Tocqueville. In the second column they should write whether or not the characteristic is present today and its significance. Discuss student responses as a class. http://www.tocqueville.org/ contains original writings and useful links regarding Tocqueville’s writings on democracy in American. There are also links to lesson plans. 19 Foundational Ideas and Values of American Democracy This lesson can be found online at http://congress.indiana.edu/lesson_plans/mcp_found_ideas.php on the Center on Congress website. Overview In this lesson students will examine founding-era documents and consider why it is important for diverse individuals, groups, and communities to make a common commitment to foundational ideas and values of American democracy. Students will then reflect on why all citizens should participate in civic activities and examine ways they can become civically engaged. Grade Levels 9 – 12 Objectives Students will: examine founding-era documents and find examples of the core values that allow for diverse opinions in our country and protect the minority; describe responsibilities that accompany the rights guaranteed in the U.S. Constitution; explain why it is important for all citizens to participate in civic activities; and identify ways they can become civically involved. Estimated Time 2 days Materials Needed E-Learning Module: Minority Civic Participation (optional) Internet connection with Macromedia FLASH ® enabled Projection device Copies of the U.S. Constitution Copies of founding-era documents, such as the Declaration of Independence, Virginia Declaration of Rights, Federalist Papers, or the Massachusetts Constitution Procedure 20 Day 1 1. Collaborate with students and brainstorm different groups that exist within the United States. For example, students may think of different ethnic groups or political groups. o Facilitate a discussion using the following questions: o What differences exist among these groups? o Do these groups ever have conflicts with each other? What problems do these conflicts cause? o What do all of these groups have in common in the United States? 2. Make sure students understand that all Americans share the rights and freedoms listed in the U.S. Constitution. 3. Divide the class into small groups of three or four. Have each group examine the U.S. Constitution and other founding-era documents to find examples of the core values that allow for diverse opinions in our country and protect the minority. Allow each group to share their examples. 4. Discuss the concept of civic identity with students. Students should know that equal protection under the Constitution is a key part of Americans' shared civic identity. 5. Instruct students to examine the founding-era documents and find textual evidence of provisions made for a shared civic identity. Then lead a discussion about why it is important for all Americans to make a common commitment to these values and what might happen if such a commitment were not made. Day 2 1. Review with students some of the rights guaranteed to Americans in the U.S. Constitution. 2. Lead students in a discussion about the responsibilities that accompany these rights. 3. One of the most important responsibilities that citizens have is to become civically involved. 4. Invite students to share what they think it means to be civically involved and describe ways they can become involved. 5. Use a projection device to show students the "Sources of Information" video from the Minority Civic Participation e-learning module. Summarize the various ways youth can get involved. 6. Mark Lopez encouraged students to visit the Circle Web site at http://www.civicyouth.org/. Encourage students to visit the Web site. Have them first examine Trends by Race, Ethnicity, and Gender and see how diverse populations participate in government. Guide students in considering why minority populations are not as likely to participate in civic activities. 7. Remind students why it is important for everyone to participate in civic activities. As a class think of ways that more people could be encouraged to participate in civic activities. Then have students visit other areas of the Circle Web site and find ways that they can become civically engaged. 21 Extension Activities The Minority Civic Participation E-Learning module had representatives from La Raza and the Congressional Black Caucus. Encourage students to conduct a search on the Internet and learn more about these organizations. Assessment Basic Concepts and Processes Ask your students to respond to the following requests for information and assess their knowledge of key concepts taught in this lesson. 1. Why is it important for all Americans to make a common commitment to the core values identified in founding-era documents? What might happen if such a commitment were not made? 2. Why is it important for all citizens to become civically involved? What would happen if citizens stopped participating in civic activities? 3. Describe ways you can become civically involved. 22