New York Institute of Technology School of Architecture and Design Judith DiMaio, Dean Design Fundamentals 1 Program for Fall 2004 Faculty: Central Islip Campus: Frances Campani, Angela Amoia, Orla Smyth Diane Neff, Chair Old Westbury Campus: Jonathan Friedman, William Palmore, Joshua Davis, Jan Greben, Richard Lucas, Robert Brock Manhattan Campus: Rudolfo Imas, Michele Bertomen (Coordinator, Fall ‘04), Gernot Reither, Jamie Palazzolo, Jeremy Carvalho William Palmore, Chair David Diamond, Chair Table of Contents Welcome Explorations Remarks: Seeing, Communicating, Making Policy: Preparation/participation, Supply list, Sketchbook, Portfolio, Grades 1 Be Here Now: Observe and Describe a Space in Its Context (2 -3 1/2 weeks) 3 Laboratory/Ecologist: (8 -9 weeks) 5 2 Final reviews and portfolio preparation (1 1/2 weeks) Schedule Images on this page are from Architectural Graphic Standards, Ramsey and Sleeper, 6th Edition, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York 1970 p.2, 70,71 Some suggestions for places to explore or to use for the first project: Aluminaire House Albert Frey / Lawrence Kocher 1931 Central Islip Sunburst Building Grant’s Tomb Riverside Drive at 122nd Street John H. Duncan 1897 mon-sun 9-5 212 666 1640 Cooper Hewitt Museum 2 East 91st Street Babb, Cook and Willard 1903 tues-fri 10-5, sat,sun 12-6 212 849 8380 Midge-Carr Fine Arts Building Old Westbury Campus Rotonda Gallery 33 Clinton Street in Brooklyn Smith-Miller / Hawkinson 1991 tues-fri 12-5 sat 11-4 718 875 4047 Seaman’s Chapel 241 Water Street Polshek Partnership 1991 Storefront for Art + Architecture Kenmare + Centre Streets Vito Acconci / Steven Holl 1993 wed-sun 11-6 212 431 5755 Red Hook Community Center 110 West 9 Street (Brooklyn) Hanrahan + Meyers 1998 2nd Stage Theater Box Office 307 West 43 Street OMA / Richard Gluckman 1999 tues-sat 12-6, sun 12-4 carole rothman 212 246 4422 Pier 11 Ferry Station Wall Street + FDR Drive Smith-Miller Hawkinson 2000 Glass 2001 287 10th Avenue Thomas Leeser mon-sat 5-2 212 904 4422 Austrian Cultural Institute East 53 Street Raimund Abraham 2001 Folk Art Museum East 53 Street Williams / Tsien 2001 Symphony Space Box Office 2537 Broadway Polshek Partnership 2002 tues-sun 12-7 212 864 1414 1. Remarks Studio The core of architecture education resides in the design studio. Design Fundamentals is a studio course. For many entering students, the studio presents an unfamiliar learning environment. To begin, it is a communal effort. Work is frequently discussed collectively and interaction with classmates contributes significantly to intellectual growth. The other unusual aspect of the studio is the lack of finality. Unlike a chemistry lab where the identity of a mystery substance can be ascertained by its physical properties, architecture is more elusive. Thus the studio is more like a debate in that arguments are made, evaluated, often disputed and adjusted, sometimes abandoned. There are no answers, only choices. This new environment will require initiative, inquisitiveness and perseverance. Seeing Above all, an architecture student must learn to see The difficulty of this task is compounded by the fact that a principal medium of architecture is invisible. As important as steel and glass or wood and stone are to its creation, the essential ingredient of architecture is space. Of the numerous definitions for space listed in the American Heritage Dictionary, two stand out: 3b. Blank or empty area. 6. Sufficient freedom from external pressure to develop or explore one’s needs, interests, and individuality. Communicating Plan, Section Northeast Elevation L. Fruchter House 1951-54 Philadelphia, Penn. Louis I. Kahn from Louis I. Kahn: Light and Space Urs Buttiker1994 Birkhauser Berlag Basel, Boston Although it is not tangible, space does have form. The task of the architect is to imagine and project spatial form. To project, the architect relies on devices, in particular drawings and models, that serve as notations for reality. Moreover, an architect must describe a spatial proposition that does not yet exist. Precise, well crafted drawings and models are the basis for these communications. Making In the coming semester, we will enter into a negotiation between imagination and reality. Explorations in the fall will consider our first definition, concentrating on the physical nature of space, its description, and transformation. The heart of the semester will expose students to different methods of composing form and space. We will conclude with a design exercise intended to synthesize earlier experiments. Policy Unlike a lecture course, the architecture studio relies almost exclusively on dialogue. Interaction between students is as important to the success of the studio as the student-faculty relationship. Absence from class affects the entire studio, not just the missing student. For this reason, class attendance is mandatory. Arriving more than 15 minutes late to class will count as an absence. With the exception of family or medical emergencies, final grades will be adjusted to reflect any absences. Preparation / participation are also crucial aspects of a successful studio. During freshman orientation, a supply list was distributed to incoming students. It is expected that all students have purchased these items prior to the second studio session after consultation with your professor. Without proper tools, students will not be able to complete this course successfully. In order to work during class time, students will need either to store their equipment in studio or to bring it with them. Finally, in order to sustain a communal environment, cell phone use and headphones are prohibited during studio. A sketchbook is a vital component of the curriculum. During the course of the semester, students should record their own thoughts and sketches in the sketchbook, as well as reading notes, faculty lectures and comments. Pasting newspaper articles and found objects into this studio diary is also encouraged. It is recommended to carry this notebook at all times in order to catch inspiration when it strikes. If done properly and thoroughly, the notebook will provide a significant record of material learned during the semester. Selected, edited material from this notebook is a required component of the portfolio submission. A portfolio for the course will be prepared during the last two weeks of the semester. The portfolio is an ongoing record of the semesters’ work. It includes your writings, excerpts from readings, diagrams showing your thought processes, photographs of study models and final models and, most importantly, well crafted, legible drawings of your spatial propositions. Portfolios must be submitted in both digital and hardcopy format. Digital format should be submitted on a labeled CD, should be at least 360 dpi and should include both portfolio pages and individual scans of images used for the portfolio. Hard copy portfolios must be no more than 81⁄2” x 11” and may be submitted in either horizontal or vertical format. The book may either be constructed by hand or purchased from an art supply store. Any materials submitted in a 3-ring binder will be rejected. The written portion should include a title page identifying the course, the date and the critic. Brief descriptions of each displayed project are also helpful. Students will need to store all drawings and models throughout the semester in order to assemble their portfolio. Suggested supply list and approximate prices: purchase only after consultation with your professor. rotary pencil pointer (2) clutch pencils micron pens .005 .01 .03 .05 8” adjustable 45° triangle X-acto knife (no.11 blades) or olfa knife 24” x 36” drafting board elmers / sobo glue 18” cork-backed metal ruler compass white plastic eraser erasing shield pencil leads HB 2H 4H 12” architect’s scale 12” x 50 yd roll of tracing paper 24” x 20 yd roll of vellum 8” x 10” sketch book Drafting brush 9” x 12” cutting mat scissors white-out push pins color pencils STRONGLY RECOMMENDED: Lockable portable tool box drafting lamp Bicycle chain and lock 6” chain 4ft board cover Inexpensive digital camera with USB $6.38 $16.28 $9.60 $12.00 $14.65 $72.95 $2.19 $5.60 $8.92 $0.69 $0.79 $6.60 $7.30 $5.25 $13.90 $20.00 $2.89 $7.50 $4.60 $1.50 $0.99 $10.70 $7.95 $15.00 $20.00 $33.60 $125.00 To produce the portfolio, you need only to scan, print and carefully compose images and writings on pages. Elaborate desktop publishing is not necessary, but may be helpful. It is your responsibility to learn to photograph, scan and print and to store your work digitally throughout the semester. Students may submit these portfolios to be considered for the Fellman Prize, a cash award granted to an outstanding Fundamentals student. A grade will be issued at the conclusion of each assignment, so students may track their progress. Grades will be scaled according to the following criteria: The final grade will be calculated from the following: -inventive, well crafted work that displays initiative A (4.0) -work that attempts invention and meets the requirements of your professor B (3.0) -work that meets requirements C (2.0) -work that struggles with requirements with limited success D (1.0) -unacceptable work F (0.0) notebook 10% participation / preparation 15% design / drawing assignments 50% portfolio 25% 2. “If I were to define architecture in a word, I would say that architecture is the thoughtful making of spaces.” Louis H. Kahn Be Here Now : Observe/Transform 2 - 3 1/2 weeks Observe and describe,a space in its context. Introduce/explore/invent techniques for description and representation. Introduce craft. Encourage imagination based in a perceivable, tangible world. In groups of two and not more than three persons, observe and document a space in its context.. Space suggestions (also see page 1): Central Islip: Aluminaire House living area and stair, Sunburst studio adjacent to corridor, SAC entrance stair to nowhere Old Westbury: Stairwells including between stairs, Cafeteria area including stair, entrance and skylights adjacent to Library, stair adjacent to 2nd floor Men’s room Manhattan: NYIT lobbies at 60th Street or Broadway, Subway entrance under Trump Tower, portions of Columbus Circle lobby, library stair and vicinity Find ways of measuring the space to gauge proportions. You might use your foot, a floor tile or another person. Re-draw these drawings to scale. 1/4”=1’0” or as suggested by your professor “the openness of the different places is just as fundamental as their separateness...” Lessons for Students in Architecture Herman Hertzberger 1991 Uitgeverij 010 Publishers p. 202 (diagram and quote) Produce a set of legible, accurate orthographic drawings of the space and its adjoining spaces. Produce a monochromatic model of cardboard and glue of the space and adjoining spaces. Suggested scale: 3/8”=1’-0” Minimally, the set of drawings should include plans and sections and should legibly depict space. The drawings should be to scale, should reference orientation and should include portions of adjoining inside and outside spaces. Include spaces that are above and below your space. Each drawing should include a graphic scale, the polar coordinates and the date. Show a scale figure that is proportional to yourself in these drawings. Menu of possible explorations and transformations: Organization, orientation, parti. Walk around the space and into all other spaces in proximity including spaces above and below the space. Create a drawing that shows how you understand this space is organized in relation to all the other spaces in the vicinity. Diagram this organization. Using your original drawing as a base, produce a new drawing to propose how eliminating, transforming OR adding one simple element could change the nature of the organization. Paul Klee Italian Town 1928 “Transparency ...simultaneous perception of different spatial locations.” “Transparency: Literal and Phenomenal” Colin Rowe, Robert Slutzky The Mathematics of the Ideal Villa and Other Essays, Colin Rowe, MIT Press, 1976 p. 161 3. Threshold, spatial clarity and ambiguity Observe carefully how spatial areas are conditioned and defined through arrangements of walls, windows, ceilings and light. Using your orthographic drawings as a base, make a map of all the instances where you can’t quite figure out if you are in one spatial enclosure or an other. Overlay this with a map of zones where you appear to be in two or more spaces at the same time. Produce an orthographic drawing that proposes how you would introduce a perceivable additional zone or threshold in the space by eliminating, transforming or adding to it. Above, below, section, stairs Find a place in the vicinity of your explorations where you can see a friend from above or below a space or spaces. Draw a legible section showing the spatial relationship between you and your friend as well as the path you must take to be in the same room or implied space together. Construct an accurate model of the horizontal and vertical sequence of space, including stairs, that you must take in order to be in the same room together. (You may NOT take an elevator in order to visit one another.) Study how to transform this sequence of experiences so that the journey to visit your friend is as meaningful as the visit. Construct a scaled model of monochromatic cardboard and clear glue of this proposition. Procession, promenade, sequence, vista mapping. Using your orthographic drawings as a base, create a map of the motion of people through the space during two different times of the day or night. Make another drawing to show how your proposition has changed this pattern of use. Overlay of circulation and movement diagrams,Universal Exposition of 1989: East Site Paris 1983 OMA-Rem Koolhaas Architecture 1970-1990, Ja cques Lucan, Princeton Architectural Press 1991 New York p. 105 Create a series of stills to depict what you would see as you move towards, through and beyond the transformed spaces. Day, night light Create perspective drawings from inside and outside the space showing how light influences perception of the space during different times of the day and night. If you photograph the spaces to show this, re-draw over the photographs or play with brightness contrast in Photoshop to depict the effect of light. Record the year, day and time of the day on each drawing. Film stills Society of the Spectacle, Guy Debord, Black and Red, Detroit 1983 Night and Day Cineac Cinema, Amsterdam’ J. Duiker 1933 Speculative exercises (what is “here”?) Establish a time when everyone can be in remote rooms yet be interconnected via cell phones, text messaging and the internet. Each room should also have a TV and you should watch the same channel. Communicate your experience to all for 1/2 hour and take photographs of yourselves doing it. E-mail the photographs to all. Map this experience spatially. One group gets on a train and travels to multiple destinations. One group gets in a car and drives to multiple destinations. One group walks around the neighborhood. Call and talk to one another on cell phones and/or use text messages. Involve your professor. (Note: the driver of the vehicle is prohibited from talking on the cell phone and driving at the same time.) Take photographs of each other while this commuication is taking place. Indicate the day, hour, minute and place where the photograph was taken. Put the photographs on the internet and e-mail them to the entire studio. Construct a graphic time line associated with a map of the territory you covered and present this in studio. Summing up: Devise a powerful, organized, provocative presentation from all these models, drawings and collages to present to the studio. Each part of the presentation should be captioned: Use portions of readings or other visual precedents to explain your thinking. Credit the authors or artists properly. Develop a strategy so that your verbal and visual presentation encourage thought and discussion. The discussion should address ways in which architectural intervention can affect space. Collage alluding to “psychogeography. Guy Debord c. 1959 The Situationist City ,Simon Sadler MIT Press Cambridge, Mass. 1998 frontispiece Readings: The Voices of Space in The Ethical Function of Architecture by Karsten Harries “Michelangelo’s Ricetto of the Laurentian Library” in Art Journal XXVII by Robert S. Jackson Parliament Building, Chandigarh, India Le Corbusier 1962, image from ” Lessons for Students in Architecture Herman Hertzberger 1991 Uitgeverij 010 Publishers p. 265 “ A plan of a building should be read like a harmony of spaces in light. Even a space intended to be dark should have just enough light from some mysterious opening to tell us how dark it really is. Each space must be defined by its structure and the character of its natural light” Louis.I. Kahn, from Wurman, R. S.: What will be has always been. The words of Louis I. Kahn MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass, and London, England, 1973 4. On the internet, search for Dr. John Todd and the New Alchemy Institute as well as “new arks, living machines, rain gardens” Laboratory/Ecologist: Make Ecology-from the Greek oikos (“household”)- is the study of the Earth Household. More precisely it is the study of the relationships that interlink all members of th Earth Household.” Fritjof Capra, The Web of Life A New Scientific Understanding of Living Systems Anchor Books, New York 1997 p.32 Explore and invent repertoire of operations. Understanding of program essentials: light, air earth, water. Introduction to cultural programme. Use of repertoire to accomplish a spatial proposition. . Opportunities to transcend stated problem goals and to challenge the game. You are an ecologist unhappily working in a large office. Secretly you experiment with techniques to create and/or transform place and space in a sunlit, small corner of your office cubicle. Screen from Fatehpur Sikri: City Why? Louis I. Kahn, Lawrence Memorial 1962 and Citadel “In all buildings special attention seems to have been paid to sun and light control as well as ventilation” Plate 42, 29 Formal Structure in An unknown benefactor has given you money and land on Indian Architecture, Klaus Herdeg 1967 , reprinted which to build a demonstration laboratory. Since you don’t know by Tanagraphics, Inc. 1977 where your land is yet, you spend your spare time doing pure research; studying how to make a wonderful complex of spaces in which you and a participating public will observe, study and demonstrate the power of the natural world. You explore spatial possibilities with material at hand: paper, cardboard, plastic bottles and bags, soda cans, string, wire, styrofoam and other found objects. At intervals you purchase more exotic materials from the hardware or art supply store so that you can re-present your experiments as polished models and drawings to sympathetic colleagues. Adalaj: a step-well Formal Structure in Indian Architecture, Klaus Herdeg 1967 , reprinted by Tanagraphics, Inc. 1977 Kahn and Tyng, project for Philadelphia City Hall, 1952-7, Model- image from Modern Architecture: A Critical History, Kenneth Frampton, Oxford University Press, 1980 New York, p. 244 Because you are a scientist, you meticulously, precisely document each of your experiments in plan and section and other, appropriate venues. In addition you use your sketchbook, photography, scans and other recording and analytical tools to keep track of your process. You mark each record with the polar coordinates, a graphic scale, an indication of human scale and the time and date. Sometimes you refer to previous experiments and work done by others. When you do, you note this persons work and the place (article, book, internet address, author, date, publisher and page number) where you found it so that others can trace your steps and so that you give proper credit. Because you are an ecologist you are very, very neat and never leave any mess for others to clean. You are extremely careful with your water and plaster experiments. To start, you purchase a tiny watering can so that you can be the “rain” for your plants and model the action of water. You locate your experiments so that sun and wind are available. Gravity is an invisible protagonist in your laboratory. 1) Vivarium: Gather seeds for small plants that give sustenance. Try to obtain these from food that you have eaten. Menu of possible experiments: 2) Vessel/container: Create numerous, diverse approximately 1 1/2” by 1 1/2” containers by cutting, folding and transforming found objects. Plant your seedlings in earth from the ground (not from Home Depot!) in these vessels Each container must be designed for drainage and overflow so that the plants will not be over-watered. Each container must respond to the maturing seedling. Create a temporary drainage pan to hold the water overflow. 3) Carve/cast/carve: Pick up a large piece of styrofoam from the garbage. Carve it to hold pools of water dripping from the plants. Try to carve it so that each pool is a different depth and width and so that water, dripping in to it, has a different cadence and sound. Record the sounds that your carving makes with the water and create a rhythmic backdrop to your verbal presentation. Visual references: Chapel, Ronchamp, France 1955 Le Corbusier, Alhambra, Granada, Spain 14th Century A.D., Mosque, Cordoba, Spain 786-1009, Salk Institute Louis Chernikov 1930 5. I. Kahn, Falling Water, Frank Lloyd Wright Understand this as a landscape visited by people. Carve steps so that they can reach the water during both dry and wet seasons. Re-create your model using plaster. 4) Frame: Create a stable, orthogonal frame from found sticks and wire to support your seedlings based on a water path from plant to plant. Produce additional pieces that contain water so that the water pools, drips, falls etc. as it travels from plant to plant. Map the path of the water. Produce a stable frame using an alternative geometry to support a people path. Make stairs so that people can get to different levels. Gregg Lynn Cliff House, Stanley Saitowitz, Transvaal South Africa, 1983 Image from Green Architecture, James Wines, Taschen, Milan,2000, p. 188 Produce a third, hybrid frame so that the journey of water and the journey of people intersect. Model steps to show how people travel vertically. 5) Fold/roll Screen/direct/reflect Fold and cut one piece of 8 1/2” by 11” paper using simple rules that you devise. Create folds it so that it will stand. Place it in front of a window and map the various intensities of shade/ shadow it produces at different times of the day. Establish areas of opacity, transparency and translucency. Direct or reflect light from one place to the other with the screen. Modify vista with the screen: for instance: create a screen that lets you look in one direction when seated and in another direction while standing. Other references: Robert Irwin Two Running Violet V Forms, 1983, 1234 degrees 1992, Fold, tie and/or cut one flattened soda can or waxed cardboard (from a milk container) using simple rules that you devise. create screens to modify the path of water, wind or light. Neil Denari Create a 16” by 1” tube out of folded or rolled paper. Attach small , light strips of paper (1/16” wide, 3⁄4” long) to the inside of one edge of the tube. Orient the tube so that the strips of paper are down and place the end of the tube without the pieces of paper next to a fan. What happens to the small pieces of paper? 6) Clump and bind Mash and attach portions of soda cans or rocks with wire or chicken wire or rubber bands to form permeable, thick screens using simple rules that you devise. Use these to create a landscape support to hold your earth and plants with space above and below that filters and modulates sunlight. Map the sunlight patterns below at different times of day. Place a piece of construction paper under this construction and observe the pattern of the water on the construction paper after you water the plants. Make a time map of the water dripping. Additional precedents and reading material: Silent Spring, Rachel Carson Houghton Mifflin 2002 (1962) Cradle to Cradle: Remaking the Way We Make Things William Mcdonough, Michael Braungart. Farrar, Straus and Giroux 2002 Works of Malcolm Wells Works of Glenn Murcutt Works of Hassan Fathy Rainforest Showroom SITE Hialeah, Florida USA 1979 Soft and Hairy House Ushida-Findlay Partnership Tsukuba City, Japan 1994 Brunsell Residence, Obie Bowman, Sea Ranch, California USA 1987 Phillip Merrill Environmental Center, SmithGroup, Chesapeake Bay Architecture 2001 Feb. v. 90 London City Hall, Foster Associates, Arup and Partners Architectural Record 2003 Feb. Study of movement of air from An Architecture for People: The Complete Works of Hassan Fathy, James Steele Thames and Hudson, 1997, London, p. 176 Study model and diagrams Diocesan Museum 1996, UN Studio Imagination: liquid politic, Ben van Berkel and Caroline Bos UN Studio and Goose Press, Amsterdam 1999p. 276 Filtered sunlight in covered walkway. Dominus Winery, Yountville, California, USA 199698 Herzog & De Meuron from Herzog & de Meuron Wilfried Wang, Birkhauser Verlag, Boston,1998 p. 167 6. Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 7. Studio Session M/Th T/F 1 September Thursday 9 Friday 10 2 Monday 13 Tuesday 14 Be Here Now observe, walk around, studio protocol plans, sections, explorations 3 Thursday 16 Friday 17 plans, sections review, re-do 4 Monday 20 Tuesday 21 explorations 5 Thursday 23 Friday 24 explorations 6 Monday 27 Tuesday 28 REVIEW 7 October Thursday 4 Friday 5 8 Monday 7 Tuesday 8 vivarium +vessel/contain 9 Thursday 11 Columbus Day Friday 12 cast/carve 10 Monday 14 Tuesday 15 cast/carve 11 Thursday 18 Friday 19 frame 12 Monday 21 Tuesday 22 frame 13 Thursday 25 Friday 26 frame REVIEW portfolio session 14 Monday 28 Tuesday 29 fold 15 November Thursday 1 Friday 2 fold REVIEW 16 Monday 4 Tuesday 5 clump 17 Thursday 8 Friday 9 clump REVIEW-intro make portfolio 18 Monday 11 Tuesday 12 make 19 Thursday 15 Friday 16 make 20 Monday 18 Tuesday 19 make 21 Thursday 22 Friday 23 make 22 Monday 25 Thanksgiving Tuesday 26 Thanksgiving make 23 Thursday 29 Friday 30 make 24 December Monday 2 Tuesday 3 make 25 Thursday 6 Friday 7 make 26 Monday 9 Tuesday 10 Final REVIEW 27 Thursday 13 Friday 14 Portfolio 28 Monday 15 Tuesday 16 Portfolios due Laboratory/ Ecologist intro/vivarium portfolio session session One copy for professors only- do not staple to package. 7) Make Finally, your benefactor comes through. You visit the site of your laboratory and, at first, you are horrified. Your land is two adjacent parking spaces, each 10’ by 20’ in a parking lot filled with cars! How can you possibly create a place to demonstrate the power and beauty of nature here? Program with approximate areas: Entry and orientation area: 125 square feet A garden home or homes for your seedlings: 200 square feet total. A rivlets, pool(s) and cistern for rainfall and recycled water. 200 square feet pool total water area, 100 cubic foot cistern A wind scoop Four tiny workstations with carefully designed vista and lighting dedicated to the study of the sun, stars and planets, the wind, the earth and water respectively @50 square feet One gathering area where you understand how your spatial proposition relates people to earth, sun, air and water and where you understand the spatial organization of the project. One area should protect from sun and rain. 300 square feet A public promenade through the entire complex, from the very top to the very bottom. Create a presentation that is both conceptually and literally precise to communicate your proposal. Land is “space itself….. (including) water and the beds under it, the radio spectrum, docks, rights of way, aquifers, ambient air, falling water, wild fish, game, and vegetation” all of which, are intrinsically interrelated.” Mason Gaffney, “Land as a Distinctive Factor of Production” C. 1995 Lincoln Land Institute working papers code WP95MG1