13 Chapter-2 Ministry of Primary and Mass Education 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Skilled manpower and the development of the human resources are two basic preconditions to the overall economic development of a country like Bangladesh. Bangladesh has made significant development in achieving universal primary education related Millennium Development Goals. Completion of Primary Education Cycle of the children irrespective of boy and girl by 2015 was the target of MDG-2. In this case Bangladesh has achieved 97.30percent, 80.50percent, 78.63percent and 59.82percent respectively in net enrollment, percentage of completion of primary education cycle enrolled in grade-1, literacy rate for 15-24 aged man and women and literacy rate for 15+ man and women by the year 2013. Education does not only change skill and thinking of a person but also influences the comprehensive development of the country. Hence primary education is considered as top priority everywhere in the world. Education has been considered one of the significant sectors with a view to create an educated and skilled nation by achieving specific target and implementing the work plan that drawn in Vision-2021. The Article 17 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh has declared the primary education as compulsory and universal. As a whole, in the context of the constitutional obligation and government’s priority ministry of primary and mass education is working to ensure quality primary and mass education for all. 1.2 The major function of the Ministry of Primary and Mass Education (MoPME) is to formulate and implement policies concerning primary and mass education, implement and monitor the compulsory primary education program and mass education program through non-formal education. It also develop the curriculum for primary and mass education, prepare, print and distribute the textbook, undertake training and research activities related to primary and mass education and coordinate the activities of other Ministries, Government agencies and NGOs in the field of mass literacy and adult education. 2.0 Relevant Policies of the Ministry The ministry is engaged in the formulation of policy regarding School Management Committee (SMC), policy regarding teacher's recruitment, transfer of teachers, nonformal education policy and the stipend policy with a view to ensure universal primary education and participation of local community particularly women in different levels of primary & mass education. These policies have provided scope for the active participation of women in teacher's recruitment and transfer along with primary education management. Recruitment of 60percent female teachers has been made mandatory and in the case of placement and transfers, female teachers 14 have been given priority to have a transfer near their husbands’ home. In addition, female teachers have been given priority in teacher's training that ensures their professional efficiency. School Management Committee has been made effective in every school to ensure the decentralization of school management at the field level. Provision of two female guardians of the students in the committee has been made to ensure the effective participation of women. In addition to this provision a written instructions also issued to adopt female teachers as teacher representative in the committee of respective educational institutions and the nearest secondary educational institution. 3.0 Ministry Specific National Policy directives in relation to women’s advancement 3.1 Women Development Policy, 2011 has been prepared in the light of the Constitution of Bangladesh and CEDAW. It also consulted the national and internal policy strategies to ensure the women’s advancement. The National Plan of Action (NPA) has been formulated to implement this policy. The obligation of the Ministry of Primary and Mass Education, as mentioned in this policy and NPA, are as follows: Elimination of all forms of discrimination against girls and ensuring gender equality in all areas including within the family; Ensuring regular attendance of the girl children in educational institutions; Ensuring necessary measures so that girl children do not become victims of any sexual harassment, pornography, physical and mental abuse at any places including educational institutions and streets; Ensuring opportunity for the girl children for safe and quality recreation, sports and cultural activities; Eliminating discrimination against disabled girl children and ensuring their security in all areas; Following Education Policy, 2010 to increase the rate of education in women, to eliminate discrimination in educational opportunities between men and women and to mainstream women in the development process; Removing any discriminatory issues against women from the educational curriculum and books and upholding positive image of women; Educating and training on nutrition for women; Taking initiatives for the development of women from the ethnic groups about their own heritage and culture; Considering special education only for those who are not able to participate in the mainstream education process for obvious reasons; 15 3.2 Taking appropriate measures to get disabled women involved in all areas of life including education. Taking care of disability issues in education sector. Issues that have been given emphasis regarding women’s advancement and rights in the Education Policy 2010 are as follows: 4.0 Special fund to be established to increase the rate of female education at every level and private initiatives including private financing will be encouraged for this purpose; Measures will be taken to reduce female school dropouts and bring them back to mainstream education; Increase the number of girls enrolling for formal education. In order to inspire them for higher/professional education, various facilities will be created for females at different tiers of educational institutes; Positive and progressive image and the concept of equal rights for women will be reflected in the reading materials of primary education; More life stories on inspirational and influential women and essays written by women will be included in the reading material at the primary level; Taking measures to prevent dropout of girl students and protect them any means of harassment during school time; Establish a conducive environment in schools, and ensure separate hygiene toilets for the boys and girls; Giving priority to women in the case of teacher’s recruitment at the primary level. Strategic objectives and Activities of the Ministry in relation to Women’s Advancement Serial No. Medium Term Strategic Objectives Activities 1 2 3 Establishment of new primary schools in the villages without schools; 1. To extend universal access to primary education Construction, reconstruction and extension of classrooms and routine repair and maintenance of schools; Construction of toilets and installation of tube wells; Stipend program for poor students; School Tiffin program in poverty stricken areas; Establishment of child-friendly learning centers in all 16 Serial No. Medium Term Strategic Objectives Activities 1 2 3 inaccessible areas including char, haor, tea-estates and hill areas; Making all classrooms child-friendly (for boys, girls and children with special needs); Providing one time financial assistance to families of retired, resigned or deceased teachers from the Welfare Trust. Conducting Grade-5 completion examination; Introducing I.C.T.-based education at primary level; Implementation of School Level Improvement Plan (SLIP); Extension of primary education up to class VIII; 2. To improve the quality of primary education Skills development of teachers and students in English, Mathematics and Science at primary level; Development of training infrastructure to enhance the quality of Primary Education; Basic training-C-in-Ed-Dip-in-Ed-subject-based training for teachers; Training of personnel associated with school management. Providing post literacy and continuing education to the 15-45 years age group neo-literate people in selected areas; 3. To increase literacy rate Providing basic education and livelihood skill training to 10-14 years age group urban working children in 6 divisional cities; Implementation of basic literacy program for 11-45 years age group in 64 districts. 5.0 Identifying the Gender Gaps in the Activities of the Ministry and Addressing the Issues 5.1 To ensure the implementation of the Women Development Policy, 2011 all activities of all Ministries should be in line with the National Action Plan, 2013. For this reason, initiatives should also be taken to formulate the development projects and programmes of the Ministry in line with WDP and revise existing projects and programmes. 5.2 It is found that the development of women has drawn the focus almost in all activities and programmes of the Ministry. Women are already more successful than men in the case of teacher's recruitment along with enrollment at the primary level and completion of primary school education. But in order to reach the goal of quality primary education, few activities of the Ministry must be made more women 17 friendly. Some new initiatives should also be taken. In both cases the NWDP 2011 and the Education Policy, 2010 to be the yardstick for in designing new activities and programmes. 5.3 5.4 Some ongoing activities of the Ministry can be made gender focused in following manner: In the case of distribution of education allowance and education grants the girl child with special needs should be given priority; To improve the quality of primary education the establishment of a conducive environment in school for the girl students to be considered; In the case of infrastructure development, priority should be given to ensure separate toilets for boys and girls including facilities for disabled children; Positive and progressive image and the concept of equal rights for women should be reflected in the reading materials of primary education; More life stories on inspirational and influential women and essays written by women to be included in the reading material at the primary level; Undertake initiatives to disseminate human rights issues and women development strategies among the teachers and officers in the area of primary education; To implement the post literacy and continued education and basic literacy program and separate classrooms for the women need to be used; Training for the personnel related to the school management should include issues like regular attendance of the girl children in educational institutions and necessary measures so that girl children do not become victims of any sexual harassment, pornography, physical and mental abuse at any places including educational institutions and streets. Following activities can be initiated including ongoing ones to ensure primary education system more women friendly in line with the NWP 2011 and the Education Policy, 2010: Ensuring opportunity for the girl children for safe and quality recreation, sports and cultural activities; Eliminating all forms of violence against disabled girl children and ensure their security in all areas; Eliminating all form of violence against working women including physical, mental and sexual harassment; 18 Following Education Policy, 2010 to increase the rate of education in women, to eliminate discrimination in educational opportunities between men and women and to mainstream women in the development process; To educate and train on nutritional aspects of women; Taking initiatives for the development of women from the ethnic groups in their own heritage and culture; Taking measures to reduce the school dropouts among girls and bring them back to mainstream education; To increase the female officers/staffs in the Ministry/Directorate level to increase their scope to take part in the policy level decision making process. 6.0 Women’s Participation in Ministries Activities and their Share in Total Expenditure 6.1 The participation of women in the decision making of the MoPME: Following issues within the MoPME taken into consideration to assess how successfully the activities of the Ministry are addressing women’s advancement and rights 6.2 Women as service providers; Male-female beneficiaries of the activities of the MoPME; Gender based distribution of allocation and expenditure of the MoPME. Table-1 exhibits the male-female employment structure to better illustrate women’s participation in decision making process in the MoPME and across its various departments and agencies. Notwithstanding the pro-women policies in teacher and other recruitments, women’s participation in decision making in the Ministry is not remarkable. In 2013 only 20.9 percent of total officials employed in the primary education sector were women, as compared to 79.1 percent of male officials. In case of employees, 22.2 percent were women in 2013, which is higher than that of the previous year. The number of women officers seen highest in Primary Training Institutions and the lowest seen in the Bureau of Non-formal Education. Male and Female Employment structure by Department/Agencies Officers 2014-15 2013-14 Male Female Male Female Staff 2014-15 2013-14 Male Female Male Female Administration Secretariat 83 17 86 14 88 12 89 11 Department of Primary Education 82 18 80 20 82 18 85 15 Government Primary Schools 52 48 0 0 47 53 48 52 Primary Training Institutes 81 19 68 40 91 9 73 27 19 Officers 2014-15 2013-14 Male Female Male Female Staff 2014-15 2013-14 Male Female Male Female Upazila Education Offices 78 22 80 20 84 16 85 15 Bureau of non-formal Education 93 7 92 8 87 13 87 13 78.2 21.8 79.1 20.9 79.8 20.2 77.8 22.2 Total Source: Ministry of Primary and Mass Education 6.3 Women as Service Providers (Teachers): Table 2 shows the role of female teachers at the primary education level in terms of the male-female teachers’ ratio. It is notable that 41.8 percent and 58.2 percent of total teachers are male and female respectively which means that more than half of the total teachers are female in primary education. The percentage of female teachers among total teachers in experimental, BRAC and communityschools is 88.8 percent, 9 6.0 percentand 74.4 percentrespectively. In madrasa education the number of female teachers as compared to their male counterparts is noticeably low. Male and Female Teachers (2014) Type of institutes No. of schools No. of total teachers No. of female teachers Government Primary 38033 222652 144434 64.9 78218 35.1 New Nationalized Gov. Primary 25008 96460 47396 49.1 49064 50.9 Registered non-gov. 193 771 464 60.2 307 39.8 Non-registered non-gov. 1744 6649 4716 70.9 1933 29.1 55 282 246 87.2 36 10.8 Ebtedaye Madrasa 2673 11673 2300 19.7 9373 80.3 Kindergarten 16170 93799 54813 58.4 38986 41.6 Non-Government Organization 2512 5454 3764 69.0 1690 31.0 Community 120 405 322 79.5 83 20.5 Primary section of Madrasa 5526 19764 2812 14.2 16952 85.8 Primary section of high schools 1511 8301 4450 53.6 3851 46.4 BRAC Centre 7779 7798 7277 93.3 521 6.7 ROSC 3818 3591 2867 79.8 724 20.2 Children Welfare 133 410 277 67.6 133 32.4 Others 3262 4875 2967 60.9 1908 39.1 108537 482884 279105 57.8 203779 42.2 Experimental Total percent of No. of male percent female teachers of male teachers teachers Source: APSC 2014 (Provisional) 6.4 Male-female beneficiaries involved in activities of the Ministry of Primary and Mass Education: Three variables namely enrolment rate, completion rate and drop- 20 out rates are considered to identify the beneficiaries of primary education programme, it can be claimed based on the enrolment rate that significant gender parity has been attained at the primary level. According to the primary census report, 2012, 50.2 percent of the total students are girls, which is consistent with the Millennium Development Goals. Enrolment of Girls in Primary Education Type of institutes 2013 2014 Total Girls percent of Girl Total Girls percent of Girl 10564331 5370884 50.8 10188129 5252022 51.6 - - - 4483785 2278239 50.8 Registered non-gov. 4325894 2156108 49.8 38282 19611 51.2 Non-registered non-gov. 443724 215265 48.5 256268 127112 49.6 Experimental 11499 5630 49.0 10652 5250 49.3 Community 207526 106080 51.1 16747 8679 51.8 Kindergarten 1798500 817038 45.4 1988365 914016 46.0 N.G.O. 212212 108484 51.1 210170 107898 51.3 Ebtedaye Madrasa 344120 166443 48.4 372277 181341 48.7 Primary section of Madrasa 845438 410528 48.6 871047 427341 49.1 Primary section of high schools 467926 242888 51.9 572751 295659 51.6 BRAC Centre 214161 129590 60.5 324438 185873 57.3 ROSC 93993 47634 50.7 106884 53751 50.3 Children Welfare 11030 5796 52.5 15665 8284 52.9 Others 44618 21652 48.5 97519 48808 50.0 19584972 9804020 50.1 19552979 9913884 50.7 Gov. Primary New Nationalized Gov. Primary Total: Source: Ministry of Primary and Mass Education 6.5 It is observed in 2014 that the rate of girls’ primary level completion is higher that of boys. Girls’ Primary level Completion rate Year Primary level completion rate Boys Girls 2005-06 51.7 56.7 2006-07 47.1 53.3 2007-08 48.9 54.9 2008-09 52.9 57.0 2009-10 57.1 62.2 2010-11 59.7 60.2 21 Year Primary level completion rate Boys Girls 2011-12 67.6 73.0 2012-13 73.5 77.0 2013-14 97.88 97.97 Source: Ministry of Primary and Mass Education 6.6 Women’s Share in Ministry’s Total Expenditure Budget 2015-16 Description Total Budget Budget Revised 2014-15 Women Share Women percent 2,95,100 79,087 Revised Women Share Women percent 26.8 2,39,668 64,087 26.74 (Taka in Crore) Budget 2014-15 Budget Women Share Women percent 2,50,497 66,739 26.64 Ministry Budget 14,504 6,394 44.08 12,420 5,992 48.24 13,677 6,875 50.27 Development 5,542 3,684 66.47 4,333 3,380 78.01 5,778 4,368 75.6 Non-Development 8,963 2,710 30.24 8,087 2,612 32.3 7,898 2,507 31.74 Source: RCGP database 7.0 Achievement of Key Performance Indicators in relation to Women’s Advancement in the last three Years Indicator Unit 1 Female teachers in primary education (GPS) 2 percent 2011-12 3 61.70 Rate of completion of primary education of female students percent 97.2 Actual 2012-13 4 63.0 2013-14 5 64.9 98.5 97.97 8.0 Success in Promoting Women’s Advancement: 8.1 The National plan of Action (NPA-1) for the period of 1991-2000 has been implemented with the objective of achieving the goal depicted in the MDGs and Education for All (EFA). The ongoing NPA-2 (2003-2013) of MoPME was formulated in line with the “Vision 2021”. As envisaged in NPA-2 education for all to be achieved by 2015. T he Ministry is taking necessary steps to reach the goal within 2014. In order to realize this goal, MoPME has undertaken specific activities with a view to extending educational facilities and providing quality primary education. The Ministry has taken steps to improve the infrastructural amenities in urban areas along with constructing educational institutes in rural areas. As a result, enrollment at the primary level has increased. Simultaneously there is significant decline in the drop-out rate. 8.2 MoPME is responsible for operating more than 82 percent of the total primary educational institutes around the country. Around 90 percent of total children at primary level are enrolled in these schools. Around 50.4 percent of the students at the primary level are girls who contribute to building a prosperous future for all. The 22 policy for recruiting 60 percent female teachers has been maintained. The significant number of recruitment of female teachers in primary schools broadens the scope of employment and enhances the social dignity of women. 8.3 The Ministry also renders adults literacy and non-formal educational opportunities for men and women who were deprived of fundamental education at their early life and who dropped out of primary or secondary education. These activities provide basic education to adult women who were deprived of formal education and help them attain self-sufficiency. 8.4 The participation of women has given due priority in implementing the Universal Primary Education Programme, hundred percent enrollment and completion of the primary education cycle. To reach the goal and to create public awareness Mother's Day is being celebrated in schools and the opinion of mothersare being used to implement the activities. Besides this the female guardians are actively involved in the School Feeding Programme and Stipend Policy has been formulated taking into consideration of the stipend to be given to the mother of the female students. 8.5 The main objective of the MoPME is to ensure standard quality primary and basic education for all through expansion of facilities and improvement of quality. The medium-term strategic objectives in achieving these are - to extend universal access to primary education, to improve quality of primary education, to increase literacy rate and infuse dynamism in the post-literacy program. Following initiatives have been taken to implement the strategic objectives: The coverage of the stipend program has been extended to bring the female students under the compulsory primary education for all program of the Ministry. About 50.4 percent of total students of primary level are female. The rate of non-admission and drop-out are much higher in girls coming from poor families in comparison to boys of similar families. To minimize the number of non-admission and drop-outs, stipends (100 taka for a student and 125 taka for students having siblings) are given to more than 7.81 million students of disadvantaged families. The number of scholarships (talent pool) has been increased from 20,000 to 22,000 and the number of common scholarship has been increased to 33,000 from 30,000. Moreover, a school meal programme for more than 2.84 million children has been undertaken. All these activities are expected to contribute towards increasing enrolment of students, especially girls’ enrolment. The total number of teachers at primary level is about 449,799 of which about 261,887(58.2 percent) are female. In government primary schools 214,792 teachers are employed, of which 135,319 (6 3.0 percent) are women. According to the above statistics of 2012, it is found that the number of female teachers in primary schools is satisfactory. 23 Infrastructure development is necessary for women friendy environment. Targeted activities towards this end have been taken by MoPME. Pure drinking water supply and establishing wash block in all primary school has been initiated under the ongoing PEDP-3 project. As a direct result of these facilities, increasing number of girl child encouraged to go to school and facilitate the expansion of female education in the country. In order to ensure quality primary education teachers training on basic and subjects is fundamental. Also training for officials related to primary education and School Management Committee members are also being imparted. In addition, the 1 year long Certificate-in-Education will be converted into Diploma-in-Primary Education having one and half year duration. These trainings are expected to increase skill and efficiency of teachers and other relevant personnel in primary education system. It is also expected that women will be benefited directly from these programs. 60percent female quota in the teachers’ recruitment of primary education is being ensured. 8.6 The children learn to speak and write from their mother. The contribution of a mother to her child for their primary education along with bringing up them is not valued. The Ministry of Primary and Mass Education will take initiatives for the publicity of this sacrifice of women to create awareness for them in the society. 9.0 Obstacles to achieve targets related to Women’s Advancement: 9.1 Several initiatives have been taken to ensure the participation of women in the primary education management along with primary education in spite of limited resources. The women at the field level do not have access to all benefits of these facilities yet. The following obstacles still persist which hamper participation of girls in primary education: As the communication system is not proper in remote areas (specially hilly areas), female students of primary schools are not interested in going to school; As the benefits and facilities granted by the government do not have much publicity, expected outcome is not achieved yet; Girls in many non-government primary schools are not interested to come to school as there are no separate toilets for them; Many female students do not enroll because of the prevailing superstition in the society. 24 10.0 Progress on Recommended Activities in the Previous Year Serial No. The Recommendations of 2014-15 Gender Report for the Ministry Progress of Recommended Activities 1. There must be provisions for separate toilet (wash blocks) for female teachers and students in every primary school Under PEDP-3 project separate wash block having three toilets with running water is under process of construction. Already 4481 wash blocks have been constructed. Along with the stipend programme for female students, proper publicity should be undertaken with parents of female students so that they do not face gender discrimination at home; Stipend program has been initiated to increase female student enrollment and to prevent their dropout. The time period of stipend program has been increased for another two years to encourage the female students to enroll in primary school, ensure their attendance and to encourage them to complete the education cycle. The expansion of the coverage of the programme and expansion of the time period is under process. The stipend is given to the student's mother, s o that the mothers are encouraged to send their daughters to school. It should be ensured that the recruitment of female teachers and selection of female chairperson of school governing body is increased in backward community and small ethnic groups of the country; Like the system prevailing in the plain land, two female guardians from the backward community, have been selected in School Management Committee while females belonging to small ethnic groups of the country have been given priority to become the representative of the local people in the committee. It is mandatory that 60 percent of the teachers who are recruited must be women. Besides that, the educational qualification that is required for recruitment has been reduced for women candidates. Female teachers are given more facilities In the case of teacher's transfer and their placement in posting. In the Hill Tractareas t hese activities are implemented and monitored by Hill Tracts Zilla Parishad. 4. Necessary action should be taken to prevent drop-out and increase the admission of female students in pre-primary education; Instructions have been given at the school level to increase the enrollment rate of female students in pre-primary schools. Importance has been given to Mother's Day celebrations at school level and parents are being informed about the facilities provided by the Government. 5. In the primary curriculum the women's positive and progressive The women's positive and progressive image and equal rights have been reflected in the primary 2. 3. 25 Serial No. The Recommendations of 2014-15 Gender Report for the Ministry image should be highlighted; 6. 7. Progress of Recommended Activities curriculum. As an example both male and female names are used in the curriculum to prevent gender bias. Emphasis should be given to nutritional needs of the female students; With the assistance of the Government and Development partners, the poor female students belonging to 82 poverty stricken Upazillas are given highly nutritious biscuits every day. Besides, nutritious Mid-Day Meal is given to different schools of the country through private initiatives. The drafting of the National School Feeding Programme is being formulated to encourage private and nongovernment personnel to take these kinds of initiatives. It should be ensured that the female students do not face eveteasing inschool. The School Management Committee is taking several social awareness activities to spread awareness on eve-teasing in school. Beside, legal measures are being taken against the accused by the assistance of law enforcing agencies if any incident takes place.