SAT Essay Prep Course Chapter 1 Writing the SAT Essay: The Basics Part 1: Introduction Imagine this nightmare: You are seated uncomfortably in a cold and inhospitable high school cafeteria, surrounded by anxiously nail-nibbling fellow teenagers. You are all being forced to prove your writing competence to a pair of inaccessible and forever anonymous evaluators who will take about three minutes to read and score your work. The authorities in charge demand an essay on a topic of their choosing, but won’t reveal it until the very moment you begin. You are given a mere twenty-five minutes to produce a paper that is intelligent, persuasive, original, and grammatically sound. All the while, you are aware that your future college options, perhaps your eventual career, depend upon your performance. What’s worse – you paid to take this test! This is not someone’s idea of a cruel joke. This is the SAT essay. Okay, maybe we’ve overdone the melodrama, but the now familiar SAT format has certainly caused many students understandable anxiety. Fortunately for you, WriteAtHome is here to help. This lesson begins an intensive two-week course that will prepare you to successfully tackle the SAT essay. To get you ready, we’ll… provide you with the most thorough instruction you’ll find anywhere on how to write impressive on-the-spot essays. We’ll explain what the essay will be like, what the scorers will be looking for, and the best strategies for scoring high. give you four practice essays just like the one you’ll have on the SAT. Practice is essential. In fact, it’s the most important part of the course. You’ll need to set aside about 30 minutes twice each week to simulate the testing experience and write the essay we’ll provide. assign to you a trained, experienced, flesh-and-blood writing coach who will not only score your essays according to SAT guidelines, but will also provide thorough feedback and specific suggestions for improving your score. There is simply no better way to get ready for the SAT essay than this class. By the time you’ve completed the course, you’ll be able to face the SAT essay with confidence. Your experience may not be a dream come true, but we promise to take some of the terror out of the nightmare. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 1 Part 2: Common Questions about the SAT Essay Why does the SAT include an essay? In 2005, the SAT was revised to include, among a number of changes, an essay writing section. The essay was added because the SAT purports to test a student’s ability to succeed in college, and writing skill is an important part of college success. Is the addition of an essay a good thing? This, of course, is a matter of opinion and some controversy. We at WriteAtHome, believe that overall the essay is a good idea, although there are two things we don’t like. First, we’d like students to have more than twenty-five minutes to write the essay. It’s hard to show what you can do in such limited time. We understand, however, that the essay is only one portion of an already long test (3 hours, 45 minutes, to be exact). The folks who run the SAT didn’t want to drag it out any longer. We get that. Second, we think writing is best learned as a process involving steps like planning, composing, revising, and proofreading. Asking students to complete a final draft in less than half an hour doesn’t allow for this process approach. That’s just a reality we have to face in a timed examination. Despite these objections, we think the SAT is as well-designed as time limitations allow it to be. We also think that space devoted to criticizing the exam is wasted in an SAT preparation course, so we’ll say no more. Like it or not, the SAT now includes an essay, so let’s just focus on helping you do the best you can. What will the whole SAT be like? The focus of this course is the essay, which is included in the writing skills section of the test, but you should be familiar with the structure of the SAT as a whole. The SAT Reasoning Test, which most people refer to simply as the SAT, is designed to test a student’s ability to think. In other words, it is not a test of particular knowledge. You won’t, for example, be asked to name state capitals nor describe the process of photosynthesis. The SAT covers three areas, each worth a maximum of 800 points: 1. Mathematics The mathematics portion of the SAT is divided into two 25-minute sections with 20 questions each and one 20-minute section which includes 15 questions. This portion of the SAT will test mathematical reasoning skills and will require basic knowledge of algebra and geometry. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 2 2. Critical Reading The critical reading portion of the test is also divided into three sections: two 25-minutes and one 20-minutes long. The 25-minute sections include 9 or 10 sentence completion questions and 15-16 reading comprehension questions. The 20-minute section includes 16 reading comprehension questions. The critical reading sections are designed to test your vocabulary and ability to understand various prose passages. 3. Writing Skills In addition to the essay, the writing skills portion of the SAT includes about 39 multiplechoice questions of three types: 1) identifying sentence errors 2) improving sentences 3) improving paragraphs These questions will test your knowledge of grammar, usage, idioms, mechanics, and stylistic elements of good writing. You will have 35 minutes to complete this section. Chapter six in this booklet will provide information that can be applied to the entire writing skills portion of the exam. The Parts of the SAT Section Type of Questions Mathematics: tests mathematical reasoning involving algebra and geometry Critical Reading: tests vocabulary and reading comprehension Writing Skills: tests rules of usage and mechanics and written communication skills general math general math general math sentence completion reading comprehension sentence completion reading comprehension reading comprehension essay identifying sentence errors improving sentences improving paragraphs No. of Questions 20 20 15 9-10 15-16 9-10 15-16 16 1 Time Limit 25 min. 25 min. 20 min. 20 min. 25 min. ± 39 35 min. 25 min. 25 min. What will the essay part be like? You should know that the essay will be the first thing you’ll do when the test begins. The other sections appear in random order depending on the test date, but Those in Charge allow you to attempt the essay while your mind is still fresh. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 3 You will have 25 minutes to write your essay. That’s it. Part two of this chapter will discuss how to make the best use of that time. The answer sheet you will be given during the test will include a lined section for the essay. You must use that sheet and you may not have additional space, so write small enough that you don’t run out of room. You will write with the pencil or pencils you use for the rest of the test. You may either print or write longhand (we recommend you print unless your cursive is particularly neat). You may be given a passage, a quotation, or a set of related quotations. You will be asked to write an essay defending your position on the idea addressed in the passage or quotes. After the passage, you will be given further clarification of the issue and be reminded to support your viewpoint with examples from history, politics, literature, science, or your own experience. Below is an example of an essay question: Sample SAT Essay Question Directions: Consider the issue presented in the following paragraph and the assignment that follows: Happiness should be secondary to moral uprightness, but ask any parent today what he most wants for his children, and he is almost certain to respond, “I just want them to be happy.” Isn’t there something more noble and important for which to aim? I, for one, hope that my children are both, but if I had to choose, I would rather they be good than merely happy. -Charles Walsh Assignment: Is seeking happiness the highest pursuit, or are there better goals to aim for? Plan and write an essay in which you develop your point of view on this issue. Support your position with reasoning and examples taken from your reading, studies, experience, or observations. How important is the essay? The writing skills section is worth 800 points out of a possible 2400 – one-third of the maximum score. The essay accounts for one-third of the writing skills section. That works out to about 11% of your total SAT score. How will it be scored? Your essay will be scored by two readers who will read your essay and give it a score between 1 and 6. The readers are experienced teachers who have been trained to score essays according to an established standard. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 4 The two scores you receive are combined to form a “raw score” of up to 12 points. To assure consistency, if the scores given by your two readers differ by more than a point, they are thrown out and your essay goes to a third reader. That reader’s score is then doubled. For example, if your essay receives a 3 from one reader and a 4 from another, you end up with a raw score of 7 for the essay. If, however, one reader gives you a 3 and another gives you a 5, that’s too much difference, so the scores are scrapped and a third reader has a go. Let’s say he gives it a 4. That score is then doubled to give you a raw score of 8. If that all makes perfect sense to you, the next part will be a cinch. Your essay’s raw score is then multiplied by an undisclosed number and combined with the raw score from the multiple choice parts of the writing skills section to give you your scaled writing skills score, which will be between 200 and 800. The unknown multiplier may differ from one test to the next because it is designed to adjust your essay raw score so that it is worth 33% of your total writing skills score. Arriving at a final SAT score is no clearly simple matter, but this course is only concerned with the essay, which is given an easy-to-comprehend score between 1 and 6 by two separate readers. That’s the part you need to remember. What is “holistic scoring?” The SAT readers will use an approach known as holistic scoring when grading your exam essay. Holistic scoring involves reading the paper quickly one time, then assigning a score based on an overall impression. Readers will require only three minutes to read and evaluate each essay. So, you’ll be going through weeks of study and preparation for an essay that a pair of teachers will speed-read and evaluate in about three minutes. That’s the reality, but don’t let it discourage you. These readers will be reading and scoring countless essays and evaluating them all according to the same set of guidelines. It might be crazy, but at least it’s fair. In that one reading, each scorer will be looking for proficiency in six broad areas: strength of position or point of view, support, organization and focus, use of language, sentence variety, and writing conventions. The chapters in this booklet focus on these assessment categories, providing instruction and suggestions for impressing the readers in every aspect of your essay. What will the scorers be looking for? Even though readers will score your essay holistically after one reading, they will have in mind six broad categories. These include: 1. Position and point of view: Readers are looking for papers that take a clear position on the topic and demonstrate critical thinking. 2. Support: The opinion you express in your essay must be sufficiently supported through clear reasoning, examples, and/or evidence. 3. Organization and focus: Essays must be logically organized, coherent, and focused. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 5 4. Sentence variety: Strong essays contain an effective variety of sentence types. 5. Language and vocabulary: Word choice should be precise, varied, and appropriate. 6. Writing conventions: Essays should contain minimal errors in usage, spelling, and mechanics (punctuation, spelling, capitalization, etc.). We’ve given you only a brief introduction to these six areas, but the upcoming lessons will focus more thoroughly on each particular area. We believe improving your writing in these five areas is the best way to maximize your score on the SAT essay. SAT essay readers will use guidelines like those below to determine your essay score: Score of 6: An essay that receives a score of six, must be exemplary. It may have a few insignificant errors, but it should reveal obvious writing proficiency. A six-point essay… Position or Point of View …takes a strong position and defends it effectively, demonstrating exceptional insight and critical thinking skills. Support …supports the position with clear and relevant reasoning, examples, or evidence. Organization and Focus Language & Vocabulary …is rationally organized and sharply focused with smooth transitions connecting ideas. …demonstrates skillful and dynamic use of language with varied, precise, and appropriate choice of words. Sentence Variety …demonstrates meaningful variety in the structure and length of sentences. Writing Conventions …contains at most a few minor errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics. Score of 5: An essay that receives a score of five must be effective. Errors may be apparent, but it should reveal consistent writing proficiency. A five-point essay… Position or Point of View …takes a strong position and defends it effectively with good critical thinking skills. Support …generally supports the position with clear and relevant reasoning, examples, or evidence. Organization and Focus …is well-organized and focused with coherent transitions connecting ideas. Use of Language …demonstrates mastery of language with precise and appropriate choice of words. Sentence Variety …displays variety in the structure and length of sentences. Writing Conventions …contains at most a few minor errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 6 Score of 4: An essay that receives a score of four is competent. Though errors will be likely, it reveals general writing proficiency. A four-point essay… Position or Point of View …takes a clear position and defends it with adequate critical thinking skills. Support …supports the position with adequate reasoning, examples, or evidence Organization and Focus …is organized and generally focused with some coherence. Use of Language …demonstrates adequate if inconsistent mastery of language with generally appropriate choice of words. Sentence Variety …displays some variety in the structure and length of sentences. Writing Conventions …contains a few minimally distracting errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics. Score of 3: An essay that receives a score of three reflects emerging writing proficiency. A three-point essay… Position or Point of View …takes a position but defends it inconsistently. Critical thinking skills may need sharpening. Support …may not be sufficiently supported by reasoning, examples, and/or evidence. Organization and Focus …demonstrates inconsistent organization or focus with vague transitions among ideas. Use of Language Sentence Variety …demonstrates emerging mastery of language with weak or occasionally inept word choice. …displays little variety in the structure and length of sentences and/or problems with sentence composition. Writing Conventions …contains noticeable errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics. Score of 2: An essay that receives a score of two is unsatisfactory. It demonstrates little writing proficiency. A two-point essay… Position or Point of View …takes a vague or weak position on the topic, reflecting weak critical thinking skills. Support Organization and Focus Use of Language … insufficiently supports the writer’s point of view with inadequate reasoning, examples and/or evidence. …is poorly organized and lacks focus. Connections between ideas are lacking or obscured. …demonstrates little mastery of language, with limited and/or erroneous choice of words. Sentence Variety …displays errors in sentence structure and little to no variety. Writing Conventions …contains errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics that weaken the clarity of writing. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 7 Score of 1: An essay that receives a score of one is profoundly flawed. It demonstrates very little or no writing proficiency. A one-point essay… Position or Point of View …takes no clear position on the topic. Support …fails to support any position or point of view. Organization and Focus …lacks organization and focus. Use of Language …demonstrates frequent errors in choice of words. Sentence Variety …displays obvious flaws in sentence structure, and little to no variety. Writing Conventions …contains significant distracting errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics that are detrimental to the clarity of writing. Score of 0: An essay that receives a score of zero addresses a topic other than the one provided on the SAT. Even an essay of superior quality, if it does not relate to the test’s writing prompt, will receive a score of zero. Note: The reason the SAT gives zeros to essays on unrelated topics is to prevent students from simply memorizing an excellent essay and transcribing it during the test. Obviously, we don’t recommend you try this. How long should my essay be? After statistics revealed that longer essays tended to score higher, some SAT critics got pretty worked up. They accused the essay readers of looking only at the length of the essay and not at the quality. The truth is, however, that high quality essays tend to be a little longer than weak ones. They more fully defend their position and demonstrate attention to structure. It seems common sense that, on average, long essays would score higher than short ones. That said, don’t assume that piling on the words will assure you a high score. The answer sheet you’ll be provided will have two sides and a total of 46 lines. You are not expected to fill it up. Readers are looking for quality writing in a sufficiently persuasive essay. That does mean you’ll need more than one paragraph — we suggest four or five. Follow the strategies we’ll provide you in the next several lessons and you won’t have to worry about the length of your essay. How important is neatness? Readers are supposed to ignore bad handwriting in their evaluations, but a sloppy paper will probably have at least a subconsciously negative effect on your score. Certainly, if a reader can’t decipher your penmanship, he won’t be able to evaluate your writing. Our recommendation, therefore, is to be as neat as you can. If your printing is neater than your cursive, then by all means print. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 8 Will the colleges I apply to have access to my SAT essay? Colleges that receive your SAT score may request a copy of your essay. It doesn’t seem likely that many schools will do this, but it could help admissions officers make borderline acceptance decisions. It’s also possible that a school might want to compare your SAT essay to your application essay. There’s really no telling how often or why colleges will ask for the essays, but we thought you should know that they can. We hope Part One of this booklet has answered some questions for you. In the next part, we’ll suggest some ways to effectively manage your time during the exam. Tips from Chapter 1, Part 1 Know what to expect. Be ready not only for the essay section, but for the whole test. Understand the scoring. Readers will give you two scores, each between 1 and 6. Know what they are looking for. Get familiar with the six areas in which your essay will REad be evaluated. Write small. You can use only the lined sheet provided for the essay. © Copyright 2006 Write on the topic. If you don’t, you will receive a zero. WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved Write enough. There’s no extra points for mere length, but effective writing will be thorough and organized. Be neat. The reader can’t score what he can’t read. Understand the topic. Be sure you know the topic you are supposed to address. Writing on anything else will get you a zero. Part 3: Managing Your Time Success on the SAT essay depends upon using time efficiently. You might be capable of writing a prize-winning essay, but if you can’t do it in twenty-five minutes, it won’t help you on the SAT. Even the strongest, most confident writers have underperformed on the SAT essay because they did not make good use of the time. That’s why this section is so important. Read it carefully now and review it often between now and test day. Below are six suggestions for using your writing time wisely. 1. Practice The best way to get used to writing an essay in 25 minutes is to, well, practice writing essays in 25 minutes! Don't cheat when writing your WriteAtHome practice essays. Stick to the 25-minute limit every time. Be strict; you’ll be glad you did. Train your brain to instinctively know what 25 minutes feels like. You want to be able to sense the half-way point and when you are getting close to the end. To really get comfortable with that 25-minute time frame we suggest you do as many timed writing projects as possible. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 9 Don’t limit your practice to WriteAtHome assignments. Several times each week, you might sit down, set your timer, and fill in a page or two of random writing. Come up with your own topics, or have parents or friends create some for you. The more practice you get, the more comfortable you’ll be come test-time. 2. Read the Essay Assignment Every second counts, but don’t skip over the instructions. The first and last sentence or two will be familiar to you from your practice essays, but the passage or quotation and the Assignment section will be brand new. It’s vital that you understand the topic, so take your time here. Remember, if you write on a topic other than the one given, you will receive a score of zero. Be sure you read and clearly understand the passage and subsequent assignment. In fact, we recommend that you read the assignment first and the quotation or passage second. The most important part of the instructions are in the part labeled Assignment. It’s possible that you could read the quotation and misunderstand what you are being asked to respond to. The Assignment section clarifies that, so pay special attention there. Sample SAT Essay Question Directions: Consider the issue presented in the following paragraph and the assignment that follows: Happiness should be secondary to moral uprightness, but ask any parent today what he most wants for his children, and he is almost certain to respond, “I just want them to be happy.” Isn’t there something more noble and important for which to aim? I, for one, hope that my children are both, but if I had to choose, I would rather they be good than merely happy. Pay special attention to this section. You should read it before the quotation or passage above. -Charles Walsh Assignment: Is seeking happiness the highest pursuit, or are there better goals to aim for? Plan and write an essay in which you develop your point of view on this issue. Support your position with reasoning and examples taken from your reading, studies, experience, or observations. 3. Take Time to Outline Because outlining takes time, many SAT takers are tempted to skip it and jump right into the essay. We think that’s a mistake. Taking a few moments at the beginning to organize your thinking in an informal outline will not only improve the organization of the paper, but will also save you time in the long run. It will help you avoid that stuck feeling when you’re midway through a paper and don’t know where to go next. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 10 It’s not necessary, of course, to craft a detailed formal outline. You won’t be turning it in; it’s for your own benefit. Jot down your thesis and two or three supporting points, in the proper order. Use bullets if you like instead of numbers and roman numerals, but map out a plan at the outset. We’ll give you more information on outlining in the lesson on organization. 4. Leave Time to Proofread Another mistake students make is leaving no time for proofreading. When you are writing under pressure and time constraints, it is particularly easy to make careless errors. Do yourself a favor and stop three minutes before time runs out to give your paper a quick runthrough. Mechanics and usage are part of the evaluation, so you’ll want to tidy up as much as possible. 5. Relax Tension and anxiety are not your friends. You will do your best if you are relaxed and sure of yourself. Completing this course will help you gain that kind of confidence. Also, remember that all the SAT essay readers are aware of the time limitations you will be operating under. They know as well as anyone not to expect polished, publishable essays. An essay doesn’t have to be perfect to receive an exceptionally high score. 6. Plan Wisely There’s no single right way to manage your time, but we think the following suggested plan gives you the best chance of success: SAT Essay Time Management Plan 1. 2. 3. 4. Carefully read the passage and assignment: Draft informal outline: Compose the essay: Proofread: Total: 2 minutes 3 minutes 16 minutes 3 minutes 25 minutes This is only a suggested guideline. If you can read the assignment and draft a rough outline in less time—great! That will leave you more time to compose the essay. And if it takes a few extra minutes to get your outline together, that’s no cause for alarm either. Just be aware that if you are seven or eight minutes into your time and still tinkering with the outline, you should leave it as is and get started writing! Keep this time management advice in mind as you complete your WriteAtHome practice essays, starting with your first essay. As you practice improving your writing, you should also be practicing time management. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 11 Tips from Chapter 1, Part 2 Manage your time by: 1. practicing writing for 25 minutes. 2. reading the Assignment carefully. 3. taking time to outline. 4. leaving time to proofread. 5. relaxing. 6. plan your time wisely. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 12 SAT Essay Prep Course Chapter 2 Content: Position and Support Part 1: Defining the Essay Now that you know what to expect on SAT day, let’s get down to the business of creating a top-notch essay. The essay prompts provided on the SAT will ask you to form and defend an opinion. That means your essay will be essentially persuasive — your job will be to win over your reader to your viewpoint on the subject. You must keep this purpose in mind as you write. No other kind of essay will get you a decent score. Defining Essay Originally, the word “essay” was used to describe any kind of written exploration of a topic (it comes from the 15th century French word, assayer). As time has passed, the definition has changed. It has become customary for teachers in all fields to require written answers to questions on tests. Regardless of the length, subject, or purpose of these kinds of questions, they are typically referred to as “essay questions.” Essay in this sense just means an answer longer than a sentence or two. The purpose of this “essay,” however, may be to inform, describe, or even narrate (tell a story). In other words, teachers have broadened the meaning of essay to cover writing of almost any kind. On the other hand, many parents and teachers have created an overly strict definition of essay. In an effort to help students create well-organized papers, they have developed what is commonly referred to as the “five-paragraph essay.” We don’t disagree with the basic concept of the five-paragraph essay. In fact, you’ll see that our suggestions in the next lesson will essentially follow the five-paragraph essay formula. But we want to be clear that a well-written essay does not always follow that structure. And just as important—not all essays that follow the five-paragraph format are well-written! So, if some have defined essay too broadly and others too narrowly, how are we to usefully define the term as it applies to the SAT? This will do nicely: An essay is a composition on a single topic, which seeks to persuade the reader toward a particular opinion. That is the meaning of essay in the minds of SAT readers. It is, by definition, persuasive in purpose. At the same time, it is not limited to any particular length or structure. It can be five Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 13 paragraphs, or two, or twelve. But we’re getting ahead of ourselves. We’ll discuss length and organization in the next chapter. For now, just get into your head what kind of paper you’ll be expected to write. Writing teachers helpfully define four basic purposes for all writing: narrative, descriptive, expository, and persuasive. SAT essays fall into the final category. Let’s briefly review the four options just to be sure you’ve got it: Narrative: Narrative writing is simply story-telling. The stories can be fictional, as in short stories, novels, plays, and narrative poetry. They can also be true stories, as in histories and biographies. Descriptive: Descriptive writing seeks to leave the reader with a sensory concept of the thing described. It “paints a picture” with words so that the reader can imaginatively see, hear, feel, smell and/or taste the subject. Descriptive writing rarely stands alone, although you can find pure description in catalogs, advertisements, and some photo captions. More often, descriptive writing is woven into narratives and other kinds of writing to bring people, places, and things to life. Expository: Expository writing informs or explains. It is the kind of writing you’ll find in encyclopedias, news articles, and textbooks. Persuasive: Persuasive writing attempts to defend an opinion in order to convince the reader of its truth or validity. Persuasive writing presents an argument for a particular point of view. We have reviewed all four purposes so that you can avoid writing that is primarily narrative, descriptive or expository. This is not to say that your SAT essay may not include a story, some description, or an explanation. It is possible that your essay will contain elements of all these, but your overall purpose must be to persuade. What You Will Be Writing About The aspect of the SAT essay that creates the most anxiety is the actual topic you’ll be asked to address. For obvious reasons, you won’t know the topic until test time. That means we can’t tell you exactly what you’ll be writing about. But we can tell you the kind of topic you’ll encounter. First, the topic is designed to be something about which anyone might have an opinion. It doesn’t require any kind of specialized knowledge. The SAT is a test of thinking ability, remember, not of academic content. That means you don’t have to worry about remembering facts from history or science to do well on the essay. So, what kinds of topics might you find? Topics on broad concepts that anyone might think about from time to time. The passage and assignment you receive might be about subjects like the following: Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 14 Possible SAT Essay Topics courage fear success honesty experience talent leadership knowledge conformity maturity imagination goals sacrifice friendship happiness challenges growing up competition keeping promises heroes dreams Now, don’t worry. You’ll get more than just a single-word like relationships or justice. You’ll get either a brief passage, a quotation, or a series of related quotations that present a particular perspective on a topic. Then you’ll be asked to write an essay agreeing or disagreeing with that perspective. Below is the example we gave you in the last chapter. You’ll see a new example with each WriteAtHome practice essay: Sample SAT Essay Question Directions: Consider the issue presented in the following paragraph and the assignment that follows: Happiness should be secondary to moral uprightness, but ask any parent today what he most wants for his children, and he is almost certain to respond, “I just want them to be happy.” Isn’t there something more noble and important for which to aim? I, for one, hope that my children are both, but if I had to choose, I would rather they be good than merely happy. -Charles Walsh Assignment: Is seeking happiness the highest pursuit, or are there better goals to aim for? Plan and write an essay in which you develop your point of view on this issue. Support your position with reasoning and examples taken from your reading, studies, experience, or observations. Part 2: Strength of Position Scoring High in Content One of the most important aspects of your essay the SAT readers will be evaluating is the your position on the topic. They want to see an essay that takes a strong position and adequately defends it. In order to earn a top score, your paper should take a strong position and defend it Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 15 effectively, demonstrating exceptional insight and critical thinking skills. your point of view should be supported by clearly appropriate reasoning, examples, and/or evidence. Here are four keys to impressing the reader with the content of your paper: Key #1: Have a Clear Thesis Key #2: Don’t Be Wishy-Washy Key #3: Don’t Overstate Key #4: Be Insightful Key #1: Have a Clear Thesis A thesis is a single sentence that summarizes the overall point of your paper. Your thesis statement is the most important sentence in your essay. It’s the anchor, the fulcrum, the central point of your paper. Every good essay has a thesis, although some writers reveal it gradually as the essay unfolds rather than stating it bluntly in one place. For the SAT essay, however, we strongly recommend that you include a simple, clear thesis statement early in your paper. As we’ve said, time is short, but it will be worth your effort to spend a few extra seconds on your thesis statement. Getting the thesis right is a giant step toward getting the whole paper right. It is like pointing the bow of a ship in the right direction at the start of a voyage. Keep the following tips in mind as you write your thesis statement. Three Tips on Crafting the Thesis: Avoid formulas. It is a common practice for teachers to recommend a formula for thesis statements. The most popular formula includes the main idea and a list of three supporting points. They all look like something like this: Parents should limit the TV-watching of their children because it makes them passive, it emphasizes entertainment above education, and it inhibits family relationships. Baseball should still be considered the national pastime because it was created in America, it reflects the melting pot of American culture, and it remains a captivating spectator sport. Dogs make better pets than cats due to their intelligence, playfulness, and loyalty. Notice the pattern? The first part of the sentence states the thesis, and the second half lists the supporting points. For the last example, the student would include the sentence in the introductory paragraph, followed by three paragraphs: one about the intelligence of dogs, one about their playfulness, and one about their loyalty. Add a concluding paragraph, and you’ve got the standard five-paragraph essay formula. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 16 We will suggest a similar pattern for organizing your essay, but we do not recommend this way of drafting a thesis statement. We think it’s bland, simplistic, and predictable. Writing that conforms too closely to a pattern like this will not impress most readers. They want to see that you can express yourself with originality and eloquence, not simply that you can conform to some predetermined formula. Keep it simple. So, how should you write a thesis statement? We think it’s even easier than the “main idea + 3 supporting points” formula. Just leave out the list of supporting points. You’ll get to those eventually anyway – in the body of the paper. We think a good thesis simply and clearly states the point you are going to defend in your essay. Check out the following improvements on the previous examples: Parents who care about their families should limit the TV-watching of their children. Football and basketball may have gained a larger audience, but baseball deserves to keep the title of America’s pastime. Dogs make better pets than cats. These are strong, tight, and clear, without giving away too much of the paper. They encourage the reader to keep going as you explain your position. They also sound natural rather than pre-packaged. Don’t assume the reader knows the topic. A common mistake among teenage essay writers is to refer to the quote or topic as though the reader is already familiar with it. This is a problem not only in the thesis statement, but anywhere in the essay: This idea is common in the world today. This may seem true at first glance, but look at what this quote is saying. It is probable that the SAT readers will be well-acquainted with the passage and/or quotation you’ll have been given, but your paper must be able to stand alone. In other words, write as though you have not been given a prompt at all — as though the idea for the paper simply occurred to you. Any reader should be able to understand your paper whether or not he has access to the prompt given in the test: It is common in the world today to believe that the best learning comes by experience. At first glance, it may seem true that knowledge is the key to success, but let’s examine the following words by Socrates… Key #2: Don’t Be Wishy-Washy Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 17 The first thing your essay reader will look for is a strong position. Taking a half-hearted or diplomatic perspective on the topic is a sure way to drop your score. Pick a side and defend it with confidence. Humility is a rare and precious virtue in our culture, but it won’t score you any points on the SAT essay. That doesn’t mean you have to be obnoxious or arrogant. It just means that you should hold unswervingly to your opinion. Below are mistakes common to the wishy-washy. Avoid them. Indecisiveness. Your first priority is to take a position on the issue presented in the quotations and assignment and defend it with confidence. Even if you are genuinely undecided about the issue, choose a side and stick to it throughout the paper. Presenting both sides of the issue will be interpreted as wimpy equivocation, not humble open-mindedness. Remember that there is no “right answer” regarding the essay (enjoy it – it’s the only part of the SAT that doesn’t have a right answer!) Don’t worry about what the reader might think about your opinion. The important thing is that you are clear and unequivocal about your position. The readers will not judge your paper based on what you think – only on how your present your case. Usually, it will be best to writ what you really believe. You are free to take either position on an issue, whether you really believe it or not, and if you feel like you can write a more convincing paper on a position you don’t sincerely hold, go for it. But in our experience, the most persuasive papers come from the heart. Instead of spending time wrestling with which side to take, it’s usually best to go with your first instinct. To Concede or Not to Concede. If you have taken the WriteAtHome Essay Writing Workshop, you will be familiar with the strategy of making a concession. Good essayists often include at least one concession to the opposing viewpoint. A concession involves admitting that those you disagree with are correct about something. For example, in a paper advocating stricter gun control laws, a concession might look like this: Although the right to bear arms is a vital mark of freedom guaranteed in the Bill of Rights, reason dictates that some restrictions are necessary for a safe, peaceful, and truly free society. The first part of this sentence concedes the importance of the right to bear arms—a right often cited by opponents of gun control. By acknowledging this point right away, the writer accomplishes two things: 1) He appears open-minded and fair. 2) He beats his opponent to the punch, stripping him of a strong point of argument. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 18 Notice, however, that the concession is brief – only half a sentence and that the "Rather, very, little, pretty — these concession is immediately followed by a are the leeches that infest the pond qualification or counter-argument. If you decide of prose, sucking the blood of to include a concession in your SAT essay, be words." sure to follow this example – keep it short and - E.B. White, Elements of Style. follow it up with a point that supports your argument. Also be sure to make your concession early in the paper (usually in the first or second paragraph). For most SAT takers, however, we recommend skipping concessions altogether. With limited time you are better off investing it in sentences that directly support your position. An additional concern is that writers unskilled in concession-making can seem to be contradicting themselves rather than acknowledging the validity of a particular point. To summarize: unless you are a confident and experienced essayist, don’t bother including a concession in your SAT essay. Unnecessary Qualifiers. Nothing weakens a persuasive paper like doubt. Papers riddled with qualifiers come across as timid and uncertain. In seeking to be humble and open-minded, writers too often dilute sentences with qualifiers like “I believe,” and “in my opinion.” Let’s make it simple: Never, ever write “I believe,” or “In my opinion.” If I say to you, “The lasagna is delicious” wouldn’t you assume that was my opinion? If you read the words, “Education is the most important factor in a successful career,” isn’t it obvious that this is the opinion of the author? This is simple: If you write it, the reader will assume it is your opinion. Therefore including the words, “in my opinion,” is always redundant and unnecessary. But there are other words to avoid as well. Subtler and more tempting ways to waterdown your prose. Words like “sort of,” “a bit,” “somewhat,” and “pretty,” wear away at the forcefulness of your paper. Check out these examples: weak: stronger: Corporate America is somewhat to blame for the current climate. Corporate America is to blame for the current climate. weak: stronger: The government’s ability to invade our privacy is just a bit disconcerting. The government’s ability to invade our privacy is disconcerting. See how these little qualifying words can strip a sentence of confidence? Qualifiers to Beware I think I believe I feel in my opinion 19 it could be argued that a little in my view a bit Copyright 2011 rather kind of WriteAtHome, Incorporated sort of pretty All rights reserved to a degree many believe somewhat quite Key #3: Don’t Overstate Don’t misunderstand – we are not suggesting that all qualifiers are bad. You should avoid only unnecessary qualifiers. Resist the temptation to sprinkle your writing with qualifying words and phrases that make you seem unsure of yourself. There are, however, appropriate occasions for using qualifiers – namely, to avoid generalizations and overstatement. Generalizing and overstating are common problems with novice writers. Examples of Generalizations: Scientists are by nature objective people. All politicians learn how to lie and distort the truth. Corporate executives don’t care about the common employee. Examples of Overstatements: Everybody knows how important nuclear power is to the armed forces. Nothing is more important than self-confidence. That’s why Hemingway is unquestionably America’s greatest novelist. When you generalize or overstate, you give a reader an easy point to dispute. It’s a simple thing to find an exception to a generalization or to disagree with an overstated point. If your argument is strong, you don’t need to exaggerate. Wisely qualifying statements will help you appear more reasonable and honest. Qualified Generalizations Most scientists are by nature objective people. Too many politicians learn how to lie and distort the truth. Many corporate executives don’t care about the common employee. Qualified Overstatements: The importance of nuclear power to the armed forces is commonly known. Self-confidence is important. That’s why Hemingway is unquestionably one of America’s greatest novelists. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 20 Key #4: Be Insightful (Not Obvious) There’s no trick to this. Stating the obvious will not impress an SAT reader. They will not reward statements like: Most people want to be happy. It is better to be a success than a failure. Responsible people do what is expected of them. Perhaps you chuckled as you read these. Obvious, right? Be careful, however; many good writers resort to this kind of needless filler when in a time crunch. And sometimes we make statements like this without even realizing how silly they sound. Don’t treat your reader like a numbskull (you don’t want to offend the person scoring your exam). Assume they know as much, if not more, than the average human being. Your greatest challenge will be to come up with something original, interesting, and insightful to say about the topic you’ll be given. You’ll want to convince the reader that you are a deep thinker. In fact, you will want to seem as though the topic is something you have pondered for years (rather than an idea you just got handed). Part 3: Supporting Your Position Your thesis contains the point of your essay –what you think about the issue given you in the essay prompt. Now you’ve got to defend your opinion. You need to give clear and persuasive reasons for thinking the way you do. The body of your paper will consist of several paragraphs that contain illustrations, examples and/or reasons for your thesis. An effective paper is not only clear, but convincing. Every sentence of every paragraph in your essay’s body should be designed to win your reader to your side. We’ll talk about this more in the next chapter, but constructing the body of your paper should be as simple as this general rule: One paragraph for each supporting point. That means if you have three supporting points, you’ll have three paragraphs in the body of your paper (add an introduction and a conclusion – that makes five paragraphs). We suggest that you shoot for precisely this: three strong supporting points for your thesis. It’s not written in stone, but the rule of three is pretty well understood in the realms of art, rhetoric and composition. Fewer than three points will seem weak (unless they are particularly strong points), and more than three will leave you with too little time to complete the essay (Remember, you’ve only got 25 minutes!). What if you can only come up with two supporting points? We’ll address this later as well, but basically, it would be better to include two and get your essay done well, than to waste so much time coming up with a third point that you don’t finish the essay. If your brain cranks out four or more good supporting points, quickly decide on the best three (and leave the rest for a future doctoral dissertation). This is a loose rule also, of course. If you can concisely defend your opinion with four winning points within the time limitations, go for it. We just think you’re better off with three and staying safe. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 21 Understand this. We are recommending that you defend your thesis with three concise supporting points. But this is not an eleventh commandment. It is certainly possible to score high on an essay with one strong, vividly expressed supporting illustration. There really is no single right way to compose an essay. What Kinds of Supporting Points? The directions instruct you with a statement like, “Support your position with reasoning and examples taken from your reading, studies, experience, or observations.” There are many ways to effectively support a position. Take advantage of the options. Your paper doesn’t have to fit a particular mold. You can support your thesis with three strong reasons, or with illustrations from something you’ve studied, read, seen or experienced. And any combination of these will work as well. What matters is that you select strong supporting points that come easily to mind, that clearly defend your position, and that effectively persuade your reader. Let’s look at different ways to build support for your thesis. Reasoning Simple logic goes a long way. You can support your position by simply demonstrating its intellectual reasonableness (why it makes sense). Supporting point for the thesis, Self-sacrifice actually leads to greater personal happiness: People who live lives of self-sacrifice end up benefiting themselves as well as others. Their continual service will be recognized and appreciated, leading their families and friends to treat them in kind. People who live to serve and make others happy inevitably enjoy the benefits too, as others return the kindness. Logic is more than just a type of support. It should be a governing principle. Your whole paper should demonstrate sound reasoning. As you provide illustrations and examples like those suggested below, be sure to tie them back to your thesis by making clear, logical connections. Personal experience Consider including an illustration from your personal experience. While this might seem an informal or subjective way to defend your opinion, the advantages of including something personal are too great to ignore. The most obvious advantage is that everyone can come up with an experience that supports your position. You don’t have to be well-read or up-to-date on current events to pull something out of your own historical archives. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 22 And what’s great is you don’t have to limit your support to your own experience. Something that happened to your father, your best friend, or your optometrist would do just as well, as long as it vividly illustrates your point. Supporting point for the thesis, Self-sacrifice actually leads to greater personal happiness: My Uncle Harry, for example, was the most giving, generous person I’ve ever known. He owned a small but successful restaurant and was famous for his free Thanksgiving feast for the homeless and his regular visits to the children’s hospital with desserts and baked goods. He loved to volunteer at blood drives and retirement homes. I can’t remember ever leaving his home or restaurant without an armload of something hot and yummy. When it comes to Uncle Harry, the only thing that stands out more than his generosity is his perpetual grin. Uncle Harry overflowed with joy and zest for life. A common question about personal experience is: Does it have to be true? Is it okay to make up your “experience?” The answer is, yes; it’s okay. At least, from the perspective of the SAT readers. They have no way of knowing what’s fact or fiction, and they honestly don’t care. As long as what you write supports your position effectively, you can feel free to fabricate. If your conscience resists the idea of making up an experience, however – if it feels more like lying than simply creative license, then please heed your heart rather than this test prep book. In fact, it’s probably something you should figure out before you take the test. Are you willing to invent an illustration or not? Knowing the answer might save you a time-consuming moral dilemma. Literary Illustrations If possible, look for an illustration from something you’ve read in a literature course. Supporting point for the thesis, Self-sacrifice actually leads to greater personal happiness: Ebenezer Scrooge, from Dickens’s classic story “A Christmas Carol” experiences a dramatic reformation after his night-long encounter with the ghosts of Christmas past, present and future. Dickens is clear about the transformation not just of Scrooge’s character, but also of his experience of life. As a money-grubbing miser, Scrooge is also miserable and alone. He lives in a cold, dark, dismal house with no one to call friend. As the book closes, however, and Scrooge has become the most generous man in town, his kindnesses pay off in exuberant joy and pleasant companionship. It’s not supposed to matter, but the greater the literary merit of your example, the more impressed your reader is likely to be. In other words, if you have the option, choose Hamlet over Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 23 Harry Potter, and Ahab over Darth Vader. But go with what you know. If you can make a strong argument using a comic book character, don’t be afraid to try it. Historical Illustrations Support your ideas with examples from history when possible and appropriate. You don’t have to have dates and details at your fingertips, just use what you clearly remember. It will have a negative effect on your reader if you get your facts wrong. Supporting point for the thesis, Self-sacrifice actually leads to greater personal happiness: Benjamin Franklin, who began his adult life as a poor tradesman, was able to translate his considerable talents into great wealth. He was known for both his philanthropy and his good nature. The University of Pennsylvania exists today because of Franklin’s concern for practical, affordable education. He can also be credited for founding the first public libraries, hospitals, and firefighting associations. Franklin himself said, “Be in general virtuous, and you will be happy.” Illustrations from Science/Technology Supporting point for the thesis, Self-sacrifice actually leads to greater personal happiness: A study by psychologist and author, Robert Brooks, has shown that one of the leading factors in a person’s happiness is regular, intentional acts of kindness. Data was collected by asking adults about their happiest memories from school days. A large percentage of respondents recalled a time when they were asked to help others as a particularly fond memory. Areas of Personal Expertise If you have a particular hobby or interest, you may be able to draw on your expertise in that area to find support for your main idea. Are you knowledgeable about automobile engines? Jazz music? Ballet? You never know when knowing something interesting and unique might come in handy. Like personal examples, distinct areas of personal interest may provide a reservoir of supporting illustrations for your essay. Other Kinds of Support There is almost no limit to the ways you can support and illustrate your position. A recent news story, a current political issue, stories from the world of sports, music, entertainment, even pop culture might fit the bill. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 24 The most important thing is that you clearly and appropriately support your thesis. Don’t try to force-fit clever or impressive illustrations. At the same time, you don’t want to take all your examples from television or pop culture. It’s not supposed to matter, but trust us, readers will be more impressed with a quote from Dante than one from Dumb and Dumber. 3 Key Qualities of Strong Supporting Points Wherever your supporting points come from, keep in mind these three descriptive words: clear, specific and memorable. 1. Clear: Don’t make your readers stretch to see the relationship between your supporting example and the thesis you are trying to defend. The point should be obvious and stated clearly. 2. Specific: E.B. White advised aspiring writers, “Don’t write about man, write about a man.” Good illustrations are not vague and general. They include names, places and details. Don’t write about something that happened “many years ago,” write about something that happened in the 1960s. Don’t write about teachers, write about Mrs. Wilson, your 3rd grade teacher. Don’t write about scientists, write about Albert Einstein. 3. Memorable: The best illustrations are surprising, emotional, or vivid. They are in some way remarkable. Making your supporting points memorable may not be as hard as you think, however. The fact that you remember them well enough to include them in your paper is a good hint that they already are memorable! To Prepare or not to Prepare You are going to need supporting examples and illustrations. Students get panicky about this. “What if I can't think of any?” It's a valid concern, so feel free to prepare yourself by reading material that might provide helpful illustrations: newspapers, news magazines, literature summaries, Reader's Digest, and so on. Just keep in mind that because you have no idea what the topic of the essay will be, there's no way of knowing what kind of examples might be helpful. It's possible that all your preparation would provide nothing to help your essay. But if you've got the time – it can't hurt. Some SAT advisors suggest memorizing a handful of quotations on a variety of topics before the test date. There’s no doubt that a poignant direct quotation would wow the readers, but we don’t recommend this strategy. It’s impossible to predict the topic of the essay, and the likelihood is too great that the time you spend memorizing would be wasted. You’d be better off spending that time writing practice essays or working on problem areas in grammar and mechanics. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 25 Tone One final note on the tone of your essay: Tone is the attitude of the writer that comes through the writing. You want your essay to sound comfortable but also thoughtful and mature. Keep the tone of your paper between the extremes of slangy and stilted. Write with words and expressions that come naturally to you, but weed out bad habits and mechanical errors. Students who try too hard to impress readers end up with overly formal, academic prose that sounds awkward and unnatural. Write like you would talk if you had lots of time to prepare your words. Slangy: Shakespeare is basically awesome. Of all the dead dudes I’ve read, Old Bill definitely tops my list. Stilted: This writer would, without hesitation, proclaim that illustrious bard, William Shakespeare, to be the undisputed master of English prose. Just Plain You: Of all the writers I’ve enjoyed in my school years, my favorite is William Shakespeare. Summary of Chapter 2 Remember, the SAT tests how well you think, not just how well you write. Readers really do care about the quality of your essay’s content, not just your skill with words and knowledge of grammar. Take a strong position on your topic and support it with good reasons and examples. That’s the heart of a strong SAT essay. In the next chapter, we’ll talk about the best way to organize your essay. In the remaining chapters, we’ll talk about how to express your ideas well. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 26 Tips from Chapter 2 An essay must persuade. Your job is not just to entertain or to inform. It’s to defend an opinion. Create a strong thesis: o Avoid formulas o Keep it simple o Don’t assume the reader knows the topic Don’t be wishy-washy o Be decisive o Don’t make concessions (unless you are practiced and confident) o Avoid unnecessary qualifiers (like “I think,” “in my opinion,” etc.) Don’t overstate or make generalizations Be insightful; don’t state the obvious Support your thesis with reasoning, examples and illustrations o Try for three o Draw from: reasoning personal experiences (fabricate if necessary) literary illustrations historical illustrations science and technology areas of expertise pop culture Make your supporting points clear, specific, and memorable Don’t memorize illustrations or quotes Keep your tone natural Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 27 SAT Essay Prep Course Chapter 3 Organization and Focus In Chapter 2, we looked at the first broad categories the SAT readers will have in mind as they score your essay: position and support. In this chapter we’ll address the next category: organization and focus. A strong thesis and convincing supporting points are the heart of a good essay. Next, you need to get your ideas into an effective order and be sure that your paper maintains a consistent focus. This chapter will help you with these issues. Take Time to Outline Some people are compulsive outliners. They crave structure and require a detailed plan before they feel comfortable enough to start writing. These people are also likely to keep their rooms neat and their closets organized. They keep calendars and to-do lists. If that describes you, you don’t need to be convinced of the importance of outlining your essay. But don’t skip this chapter; we’ve got some advice for you, too. If, on the other hand, you are the messy-room, take-life-as-it-comes type, listen up. You probably see outlining as an unnecessary waste of time (and in the SAT essay, time is precious). You’d rather jump into the project and let your natural flow of thought carry you through the essay. On many writing projects, we might encourage you to follow your inclinations. We don’t believe there is a single “right way” to write. Outliners should outline. Freeflowers should compose on the fly. Since in most writing projects you have time to reread, revise, and rework your paper, it doesn’t much matter how you get started. But, as you know by now, the SAT essay isn’t like most writing projects. Non-outliners are at a disadvantage in the SAT essay because there is no time to go back to a meandering paper and give it some structure. Your first draft needs to demonstrate organized thinking. For this reason – to put it simply – you are crazy if you don’t outline! You might think that with only 25 minutes to write the essay, there’s no time to outline. We’d say that with so little time, you can’t afford not to. The few minutes you take to sketch out a plan will save you time in the long run. It will help you set priorities so that you include the most important information even if you run out of time. So, one mistake is to skip the outline altogether. Another is to spend too much time on it. Either way, you will end up wasting time. You don’t need anything formal. Your SAT essay outline should simply include: Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 28 1) your thesis statement in shorthand and 2) your supporting points, in order of importance That’s it. Don’t worry about Roman numerals, upper case and lowercase letters, or proper indentation. None of that matters, because you won’t turn in this outline. Scribble it on your test booklet somewhere (You can write on it all you want, you know!) What does matter is that you take time to think through your paper as a whole before you put pencil to answer sheet. We suggest you take no more than 3 minutes to sketch a rough outline. If you can do it in less time, great. Keep an eye on the clock. If you hit the three-minute mark, and you haven’t completed the outline, move on. Start composing with what you have – some organization is better than nothing. Here’s an example of what an outline might look like: Thesis: “Our goal should be to do as much good as possible in life, rather than just to be happy.” 1. living for pleasure might make us happy, but is empty *use Citizen Kane example—rich but miserable 2. history remembers the good, not the happy *Mother Teresa example 3. Real happiness actually comes from doing good *example of serving in soup kitchen For clarity’s sake, this example includes more detail than necessary. If it was your paper, you might need only a few words to remind you of the thoughts you want to include. Feel free to use shorthand and abbreviations to keep it brief. The outline above might be just as effective like this: Goal: do good, not just happy 1. just happy—empty: Cit. Kane 2. history rems. good, not happy—Moth. T. 3. real happiness = doing good—soup kitchen Remember, the outline is for you, not for your readers. All that matters is that it helps you organize your points and plan your essay. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 29 The Structure of Your Essay Maybe you’ve heard the analogy before: an essay is like a sandwich. The introductory and concluding paragraphs are the bread, top and bottom, and your supporting paragraphs are the meat (cheese, lettuce, pickles, etc.) in between. introduction body with concession and supporting paragraphs conclusion Some people object to this sandwich-essay idea. They fear it will produce bland, predictable essays. These critics have a point, and there is no doubt that writing strictly according to predetermined templates can limit creativity. But the SAT has made it known that they are looking for clear, intentional organization in the essay. We therefore think it’s too risky, in this context, to experiment with form. Play around with structure elsewhere. For this essay, stick with the tried and true. Let’s take each sandwich part one at a time. The Introduction A good introduction grabs the reader’s attention and points him in the direction the essay is going. Your goal is to gain his interest from the first sentence. Here are a few practical tips for making a big splash in your introduction. 1. Keep it short and simple. Two or three sentences is all you need. In fact, one really good sentence would do fine. Resist any urge to get elaborate and detailed in your introduction. You are too likely to use up the time you’ll need for writing the body of the paper. Don’t include too much in your introduction either. Don’t begin supporting your idea. Save that for the body of the paper. All that first paragraph needs to do is introduce the thesis. 2. Place your thesis at the end of the introduction. One component of your introduction must be your thesis. By the end of the first paragraph, your reader should know where the paper is going and what position you will be defending. But that doesn’t mean you have to lead off with your opinion statement. In most Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 30 cases, it is best to start with a broad statement that introduces the subject matter of the paper and to save your thesis till the last sentence. Think of a funnel. Catch your reader with your opening sentences, and draw them down to the narrow opening at the bottom. In the following examples, the thesis is underlined. Notice how the second paragraph builds interest in the thesis before it is introduced. Adequate: Our society idealizes childhood because of the innocence that children possess. Other characteristics of children like happiness and an eagerness to learn are important but do not compare with innocence. Better: Our culture has an idealized notion of childhood as expressed in our popular art and entertainment. Children portrayed by Americana artist Norman Rockwell, for example, evoke in adults a longing for simpler times. Of all the qualities we admire in children—joy, wonder, and simplicity, for example, nothing is as appealing as child-like innocence. 3. Start strong, but don’t get too cute. Take your time with the opening line. Grab your readers’ attention with the first words. You want them thinking, “This paper is a 6” from the very first sentence. Don’t, however, make the mistake of trying too hard. You want to attract and interest your readers, not startle or offend them. You want to be the party guest who draws a crowd because of his wit and intelligence, not because he’s got a lampshade on his head. Outlandish openers often backfire. Too Cute: Warning! This essay might shatter your preconceptions of the typical teenager. Better: The stereotype of a normal teenager is a sullen, apathetic slob with an irresistible desire to rebel against authority. But as with most popular stereotypes, this is a terribly unfair and inaccurate portrayal. The Body The body of your paper consists of the paragraphs that support your thesis. There is no rule regarding the number of paragraphs in your essay body, but we recommend sticking to a simple rule of thumb: one paragraph for each supporting point. So, if you have three supporting points, expect to have three paragraphs in the body of your essay. If you have a supporting point that is complex and requires explanation or elaboration; however, don’t hesitate to break it into several paragraphs. In Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 31 general, readers prefer several small paragraphs to one or two long ones. It’s easier on the eyes. Avoid discussing two separate points in the same paragraph. 1. The Concession. In the last chapter, we noted that a common strategy for persuasive essays is to make a concession early in the paper. A concession is an admission that the other side of the debate has a point in its favor. Writers who concede a point demonstrate that they have looked at both sides of the issue. This makes them seem open-minded and fair. For these reasons, including a concession in your essay may be a good idea. But only consider including a concession if you are practiced at this kind of writing. Otherwise, we recommend you skip it. There are more important things to spend your time on. If, however, a concession seems appropriate, follow these rules: 1) Place your concession immediately after the introduction. The idea is to concede a point right away, then turn your reader’s attention to the reasons that this particular point is not convincing enough. 2) Keep it brief. Often one sentence or even part of a sentence is all that’s necessary. 3) Start with “concession words.” Common transitions that indicate a concession include: admittedly, undoubtedly, of course, undeniably, certainly, without question, etc. 4) Include a “however.” It’s not the word that matters, it’s the idea. Be sure you show that the point you are conceding doesn’t trump your argument. Your concession should convey the feeling, I admit X is true, but X isn’t enough to make me change my mind. Sample Concessions: Admittedly, stricter gun control laws would make it more difficult for criminals to acquire weapons; however, the negative consequences of this legislation outweigh this positive outcome. Of course there are lots of gloomy, unmotivated teenagers in the world, but they are increasingly outnumbered by hopeful, enthusiastic young people with big dreams and bright futures. Certainly there are times when caution is wiser than risk-taking; on the other hand, a life without any adventure is hardly worth living. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 32 2. Organize Supporting Points. Let’s back up to the outline for a moment. The outline we recommend should include your thesis and your supporting points in order of importance. Let’s talk about that last phrase. After you come up with your supporting points, think about them for a minute. Which of them is likely to be most persuasive to your reader? Is one of them obviously weaker? Number them from least to most important. Go with your gut instinct, and don’t waste too much time on this, but do it. Experience has shown that building from a relatively weak point to a strong, convincing point is the most effective way to build an argument. That’s why we recommend numbering your points in the outline. When it’s time to compose, you won’t have to wonder which point to tackle first – start with the weakest. Regardless of the number of supporting points you use, the first paragraph of your body should discuss your least convincing point, and each ensuing paragraph should address a more convincing point. Time Management Strategy You must stay aware of time. If time is running out, make an exception to the least-to-most-persuasive-point rule. If you are short on time after the introductory paragraph, skip your first (weakest) point, and start with point number 2. Or, if you finish elaborating upon your first body paragraph and find the clock ticking, skip point 2 and get to your most persuasive point. You don’t want to run out of time before you cover your best point! The Conclusion An excellent paper ends with a satisfying sense of closure. At the end of a tiring trip, it’s nice to pull into your driveway and park. An essay without a conclusion is like slamming on the brakes a block from home. Don’t introduce any supporting points or new information in the final paragraph. Use it to wrap up your essay by reemphasizing your thesis and leaving the reader with something to think about. When time is short, SAT takers often omit the conclusion, and since the readers are supposed to keep in mind the time limitations, they might overlook its absence. On the other hand, your last few words can be just as important as the first few. You want to leave your readers with a good impression. Manage your time well so that you will have a few minutes to compose a strong concluding sentence or two. Gracefully concluding an essay takes practice and instinct. There’s no formula to guarantee success. In general, however, you will do well to keep these two principles in mind: 1) Start by restating your thesis. This doesn’t mean copying your thesis word for word, or simply changing a word or two. Express the main idea in a completely different way. English is a varied and flexible language. There are countless ways Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 33 to say essentially the same thing. Here are some examples of ways to restate a thesis: Thesis The internet is the 21st century’s most effective means of advancing freedom and democracy. Restated The world will be freer and more democratic in the next generation because of the powerful influence of the internet. The most courageous people are not those without fear, but those who act in spite of their fears. Courage isn’t the absence of fear, but the will to keep going when confronted with frightening circumstances. A world without great works of art would be a sad and shallow place. Humans are artistic beings with a deepseated need to express themselves through art; thus art must be encouraged and protected. 2) Conclude with a broad concluding statement. If your introductory paragraph is funnel-shaped, think of the conclusion as an upside-down funnel (like the Tin Man’s hat in The Wizard of Oz). After creatively restating your narrow thesis, finish the paragraph with a broader statement that leaves the reader with something to think about. Example: Courage isn’t the absence of fear, but the will to keep going when confronted with fearful circumstances. Everyone knows what it is to be afraid, even the bravest among us. Coherence A solid essay is organized – built solidly brick by brick. If you follow your outline and the organizing guidelines above, you have taken an essential step toward a highscoring essay. But an excellent essay is also coherent – it holds together. There must be mortar between the bricks, or a good shove will knock the wall over. The distinct parts you created in your outline should transition naturally from one sentence to the next. A paper that is well-organized, but jumps abruptly from one idea to the next, or that is clumsy and difficult to follow will score lower than one that flows easily. That flow of ideas depends upon a wise use of transition devices. Transitions are the mortar that holds your bricks together. Never leave the reader wondering, "What does this have to do with the thesis?" Make it obvious. He should never have to ask, "Where are you going with this?" Be sure to show him. Below are some transition devices you might find handy in increasing the coherence of your essays. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 34 Key Word Repetition Sometimes you can create an effective transition by repeating a word or two from an earlier sentence or paragraph. Here’s an example: I’m a loyal sports fan. I pull for the same teams year after year. Once my favorite team has been eliminated, however, I tend to root for the underdog. The underdog in last year’s Super Bowl was the Cleveland Browns, so you know which team I was cheering on… See how repeating the word underdog pulls you from one paragraph to the next? Use this repetition technique sparingly, however. It can be awkward and distracting if used too often. Let your ear be your guide. If repeating a key word sounds uncomfortable to you, find a different way to make the transition. This Writers commonly use the word this as a transition from one idea to another. This technique is fine, but we recommend using this as an adjective, not as a pronoun. If your grammar skills are rusty, just remember this: if you use this as a transition word between sentences or paragraphs, stick a noun after it: this point, this perspective, this accomplishment, etc. Bad: Henry Aaron overcame enormous obstacles on his way to setting the major league record for career home runs. This gained him both admirers and enemies. Good: Henry Aaron overcame enormous obstacles on his way to setting the major league record for career home runs. This accomplishment gained him both admirers and enemies. This, when used as a pronoun, is too often vague, as in the bad example above. It is difficult to determine what exactly this is referring to. In the first example, this seems to refer to Aaron’s overcoming of obstacles, rather than his home run record. By using it as an adjective to modify a clarifying noun (like accomplishment above), you make things clear. Transition Words & Phrases Many words and phrases exist to join ideas and show the relationship between words and ideas. If you care about the grammar, they are conjunctions, conjunctive adverbs, and prepositions. But we don’t care if you know what they are called as long as you know how to use them. Below is a list of common transition words and phrases categorized by the kind of relationship they create. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 35 Relationship Time or Sequence Logic Similarity Degree Contrast Introducing examples Signaling emphasis Signaling more information Signaling explanation Words/Phrases before, during, after, earlier, then, later, soon, first, next, finally, once, eventually, in time since, therefore, as a result, because, inevitably, besides, consequently as, like, and, again, too, also, likewise, equally, similarly, another, moreover, in addition better, best, more, most, worse, worst, less, least, greater, greatest but, yet, not, still, nevertheless, however, in contrast, otherwise, although, on the other hand, nonetheless as, like, for example, that is, such as, namely, for instance, to illustrate, in particular indeed, in fact, in other words in addition, moreover, besides, also, furthermore, as well for example, that is, in other words You’ll notice that just about all of these transitions are common, familiar words. You don’t need to be taught how to use them, just reminded to use them! As you write your essay, cement the parts of your outline by making clear transitions between your paragraphs and sentences. Read the short essay excerpt below to see how a wise use of transition devices can strengthen the readability of an essay. Growing up in the early part of the 21st Century means being familiar with a wide variety of entertainment choices. Our greatgrandparents gathered around radios. Our grandparents saw the birth of the television age. Our moms and dads have grown comfortable with personal computing. But today’s teens can listen Transition word indicating contrast. to music from satellite radios and ultra-portable MP3 players. Only a generation ago, a movie fan had to buy a theater ticket. Today, your favorite movies and TV programs can be carried in your pocket. Video Transitional word indicating time. games provide unlimited access to fantastic virtual worlds, and internet technology allows us to chat and play with anyone anywhere in the world. The question is, does easy access to all this entertainment make us happier? I don’t think so. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 36 Transitional phrase signaling emphasis. Of course, there is a kind of pleasure in all this entertainment. It can provide escape and relaxation when used wisely and in This used as an adjective. moderation. There’s nothing wrong with having fun, after all. Too many of us, however, don’t understand the concepts of wisdom and moderation. Key word repetition. Teenagers are famous for lacking the kind of discretion needed to keep entertainment in perspective. Too many teens become so enamored with the latest movie or video game that it grows into an obsession. For example, I recently read an article on a high Transitional phrase signaling explanation. school student who dedicated so much time to an online virtual reality game that he had become an internet legend. He now ignores his school work and gets paid for coaching other teenagers in the video game. I can’t help but wonder how far that particular skill will take him… Use these simple transitional devices to guide your readers through your essay. As you practice essay writing to prepare for the SAT, read each sentence as though you were hearing it for the first time. Is it easy to follow the line of thinking? Is it obvious how each sentence contributes to the point of the paper? These questions will help you evaluate your essay’s coherence. Focus SAT essay readers will be looking for essays that are tightly focused. Wandering from your thesis is a big no-no. To avoid straying, be sure that every sentence clearly introduces, supports, or concludes your argument. If the connection between a sentence and your thesis is in the least vague, reword the sentence or delete it. Note: You will not be penalized for editorial corrections to your paper. If you decide to delete a word, phrase, or sentence after you have written it, feel free to erase it, or just cross through it with a horizontal line. Chapter 3 Summary Chapter 2 talked about the content of your paper. In this chapter, we talked about how to wisely arrange the various pieces so that your paper is most organized, most easily understood, and most persuasive. We talked about the importance of outlining, using appropriate transition words, and staying focused. In the following chapters, we’ll Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 37 Transitional word indicating time. get smaller. Instead of talking about the big picture of your essay, we’ll talk about the individual sentences and words. Tips from Chapter 3 Take the time to outline. Keep it short and informal. It is for your eyes only. The introduction: o Keep it short and simple – one to three sentences is plenty. o Save your thesis for the end of your introduction. o Catch the interest of your reader in the first sentence, but don’t get too cute. The body: o It’s probably best to skip a concession. If you must, keep it short. o Arrange your supporting paragraphs from weakest to strongest. o Watch the time and be sure to include your best point. The conclusion: o Restate, but don’t just copy your thesis. o Conclude with a broad, interesting sentence. Use transitions between ideas and paragraphs wisely. Avoid rough jumps from point to point. Maintain your focus. Every sentence should contribute to the essential point of the essay. Copyright 2011 WriteAtHome, Incorporated All rights reserved 38