AUSTRALASIAN FACULTY OF REHABILITATION MEDICINE The Royal Australasian College of Physicians Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module Workbook 2 Gait Analysis Copyright for this publication rests with The Australasian Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine (Royal Australasian College of Physicians) 1st Edition 2003 145 Macquarie Street SYDNEY NSW 2000 AUSTRALIA PHONE: (02) 9256 5402 FAX NO: (02) 9251 7476 E-MAIL: afrm@racp.edu.au Acknowledgement The AFRM would like to acknowledge the contribution made by Dr Susan Inglis, FAFRM, in the development of this workbook. Allergan Australia Pty Ltd is an ongoing sponsor of the AFRM Vocational Training Program. CONTENTS Introduction 1 Learning Objectives 2 Knowledge 2 Skills 2 Learning Opportunities 3 Checklist for gait analysis 4 Evaluation 5 Clinical Scenarios 6 Suggested Learning Resources 10 Journal Abstracts ATTACHMENTS 1. Workbook Evaluation Form 10 Introduction The purpose of the workbook is to help guide you through a self-directed learning program on musculoskeletal (MSK) rehabilitation, in this case gait analysis. The learning objectives are designed to make clear what is expected from you. A deep approach to learning will hopefully enable you to transfer your knowledge and skills into the clinical situation and provide expert care for patients with musculoskeletal problems. How well you understand this “topic” will ultimately affect them. You can choose to work in small groups or on your own. The clinical scenarios will help guide your research as each one covers different topics of the curriculum in MSK. The skills you need to acquire are also in the learning objectives. Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 1 Learning objectives Knowledge Describe the biomechanics and physiology of normal gait (kinetics and kinematics). Describe the biomechanics and physiology of abnormal gait (kinetics and kinematics). Describe the biomechanical effects of walking aids on gait patterns (orthotics, prosthetics, canes, crutches, frames). Skills Demonstrate ability to interpret X Ray, CT, MRI, EMG, NCS in relation to gait abnormalities Demonstrate ability to formulate a physical program that addresses abnormal biomechanics and physiology of gait Demonstrate ability to educate/ inform patients of the reasoning behind the rehabilitation program Demonstrate ability to plan and participate in education sessions on gait analysis that is appropriate to the participants’ level of training Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 2 Learning Opportunities Attend prosthetic and orthotic clinics Attend a gait analysis laboratory Attend EMG and NCS laboratory (private or public) Attend Radiology meetings Faculty State Branch training sessions Peer training sessions (for you to arrange) Independent workshops/ courses Library resources / texts/ journals/ videos Describe the gait pattern of all patients that you admit Prepare videotapes of patients with different gait patterns (patients’ written consent must be obtained first) . Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 3 Checklist for Gait Analysis Introduced self to the patient Adequate exposure of patient Observed and described gait from front side behind Asked patient to perform functional tasks Squat Tiptoe Heelwalk Described components of the gait cycle Symmetry Heel strike Step length Proportional time in stance/swing Cadence Described ROM at Hip Knee Ankle If applicable Described walking aids and effect on biomechanics Described orthosis/ orthotics and effect on biomechanics Described prosthetic device and effect on biomechanics □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 4 Evaluation Always start with self-evaluation because ultimately you will be the one evaluating your own independent practice in future years. Self Videotape or use a cassette to record yourself describing gait. Have you addressed all the points on the checklist? Did you miss anything? Do you consistently miss the same point? How can you change this? Practice describing normal and abnormal gait patterns Use the checklist for consistency Peer Consultant When you feel ready ask your Consultant to evaluate your skills. Show them the checklist and ask them to use it. Ask for what you did well and what you need to improve on. You should attempt this process every few weeks to receive feedback on your performance. (Formative feedback) Supervisor This may be the same person as above. Include your MSK (in this case gait) learning objectives and be sure your supervisor is aware of your efforts. Repeat evaluations as many times as necessary until you consistently reach the standard required. There is no limit to how many times you try. You should attempt this process at least twice per term to receive feedback on your performance. (Formative feedback) Formal Examinations This process formally tests your knowledge, skills and attitudes. The checklists will be provided for examiners to use in the assessment process. (Summative assessment) Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 5 Clinical Scenarios These scenarios are suggested as they cover the main clinical areas of gait. They are designed to be starting points for discussion with peers, supervisors, and team members and to encourage further reading around each topic. They have no set or right answers and are based on “real” patients. To get the most out of these exercises it would be helpful to: Practise taking a history Practise examination technique Spend time viewing and interpreting the investigations Consider the underlying pathology and how it gives rise to symptoms Practise talking to patients about all of the above Examine the current evidence for treatment options Working in small groups at Faculty State Branch training sessions or on your own consider the following clinical scenarios: 1. Arthritis A 70-year-old man has had a painful knee (OA) over the last three months and has been mainly sitting in an attempt to minimise his pain symptoms. He now has a hip contracture of 20 degrees and a knee contracture of 5 degrees. He walks leaning towards the painful side. a) Describe the altered biomechanics and underlying pathophysiology of this man’s gait. b) Describe the physical program you would recommend for this man and provide current evidence from the literature to support/ refute your plan. c) This man asks you if a hip replacement would help him. How do you reply? (Give evidence for your comments). d) Would your plan be different if this man was 86 years old? Why? 2. Amputation An 80-year-old man tells you he “wants to walk” again. He had undergone a transfemoral amputation 4 weeks earlier because of peripheral vascular disease. He has mild cardiac disease, IDDM and minor memory impairment. a) What additional information do you need from this man’s medical history to enable you to make a decision on prosthetic use? Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 6 b) Would you order any investigations or tests? Why? c) Who else may assist you in reaching a decision about the use of a prosthesis? d) How and when will you approach discussion of prognosis with this patient? 3. Hemiparetic gait A 54-year-old woman had ischaemic stroke three weeks ago. She has a left hemiparesis with motor and sensory loss. She is mobilising with the assistance of one person on your ward. She previously worked full time in the city as an accountant. She is married with two teenage children. a) Describe her probable gait pattern with reference to altered biomechanics and physiology and explain the impact these changes will have on her chances to return to living in her own home. b) What other body impairments or altered function may have an impact on her gait pattern and how will these alter your management plan? c) What physical program will you recommend for this person? (Include short, medium and long term plans with current evidence to support/ refute each phase) d) How will approach discussion on prognosis with this patient? 3. Post polio A 55-year-old woman, who had polio as a child, attends your outpatients complaining that her right leg seems weaker over the last twelve months. She tells you she has difficulty walking even short distances and cannot use public transport now. She uses one stick and a caliper to assist her walking. a) Describe this woman’s likely gait pattern (with and without the caliper/ stick) and explain the underlying abnormalities in physiology and biomechanics. b) What is the likely energy cost of using a caliper and how does this impact on this patient now and in the future? c) What (if any) exercise program will you suggest for this patient? Why? (Include the current evidence for your choices). Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 7 4. Ataxic gait A young patient of yours has recently been discharged from a rehabilitation unit. He had survived a suicide attempt with carbon monoxide but had been left with an ataxic gait. He is concerned over the appearance of his walking. a) How will the ataxia affect the kinetics and kinematics of his gait? b) What physical program (if any) will you suggest for him? Why? (Include evidence for/ against your program). c) How will you approach the discussion of prognosis with this young man? 5. Parkinson’s disease You have been attending an 82-year-old man for the last 10 years and have been concerned over the number of falls he has experienced in the last 4 months. His use of medications has been optimised and he walks with a rollator frame. He and his wife attend the appointment. They receive assistance from community nurses and home care and are only just coping. a) How does Parkinson’s disease affect this man’s gait pattern in terms of altered biomechanics and physiology? (With and without aids) b) Described what effects therapy/ rehabilitation programs will have on the determinants of gait in this man. (Incorporate current evidence into your answer). c) Who are the other professionals that can assist you in the assessment of this man and explain their role in his management? d) Explain how you will approach discussion of prognosis with this family. 6. Paraplegia A 17-year-old youth is admitted to the spinal unit with complete T6 paraplegia. He has grade 2-3 muscle strength in his lower extremity muscles. He is eight weeks post injury and wants to “walk” out of the rehabilitation unit on discharge in three weeks time. a) What orthotic aid/s could you use to assist this man in his goal of walking and what training will the patient need to use this/ these aid/s? b) Describe the gait pattern he might achieve both with orthotic aid/s and without them. c) What is the estimated energy cost of this gait pattern be and how will this impact upon the patient? Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 8 d) What will you advise this patient about his goal to walk again? e) (Include your approach, timing and current evidence form your information and communication approach). Formatted: Bullets and Numbering 7. Orthopaedic A 74-year-old woman fell down three stairs and sustained fractures to both her ankles. She required open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF); both ankles have plaster of paris applied. She is non-weight bearing and mobilising with a wheelchair. a) What is your initial physical program for this patient and will you recommend rehabilitation on your ward? b) Her surgeon allows her to weight bear as tolerated (WBAT) with Canadian crutches. Describe the biomechanics and pathophysiology of her altered gait pattern. c) Although she has a supportive family, they all work and she will be alone during the day when you discharge her. When will you recommend discharge and what safeguards will you suggest? 8. Professional Role / Teaching The local clinical school has asked you the “teach” second year medical students about gait analysis. a) How will you approach this? (Include learning objectives, content, presentation/ teaching style and method of evaluation of your teaching). Formatted: Bullets and Numbering b)You are asked to present the same topic to Advanced Training Rehabilitation Registrars. b) How will your presentation differ? (Include learning objectives, content, presentation/ teaching style and method of evaluation of your teaching). You will need to refer to the education literature to effectively answer these questions. Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 9 Suggested Learning Resources Journal Abstracts 1. Clin Biochem (Bristol,Avon) 2001 Jul;16 The biomechanics and motor control of gait in Parkinson disease. Morris ME, Huxham F, McGinley J, Dodd K, lansek R. School of Physiotherapy, La Trobe University, 3086, Bundoora,Australia Parkinson disease is a progressive neurological condition characterised by hypokinesia (reduced movement), akinesia (absent movement), tremor, rigidity and postural instability. These movement disorders are associated with a slow short-stepped, shuffling gait pattern. Analysis of the biomechanics of gait in response to medication, visual cues, attentional strategies and neurosurgery provides insight into the nature of the motor control deficit in Parkinson disease and the efficacy of current therapeutic interventions. In this article we supplement a critical evaluation of the Parkinson disease gait literature with two case examples. The first case describes the kinematic gait response of an individual with Parkinson disease to visual cues in the "off' phase of the levodopa medication cycle. The second case investigates the biomechanics and motor control of turning during walking in a patient with Parkinson disease compared with elderly and young control subjects. The results are interpreted in light of the need for gait analysis to investigate complex functional walking tasks rather than confining assessment to straight line walking, which has been the trend to date. 2. J Rehabil Res Dev 1995 Feb;32(1):25-31 Gait parameters following stroke: a practical assessment. von Schroeder HP, Coutts RD, Lyden PD, Billings E Jr, Nickel VL. Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, University of California, San Diego 92103-1190, USA. Mechanical methods of quantifying gait are more sensitive to change than is direct clinical inspection. To assess gait parameters and patterns of patients with stroke, and the temporal changes of these parameters, a foot-switch gait analyzer was used to test 49 ambulatory patients with stroke and 24 controls. Patients walked significantly slower than controls, with decreased cadence, increased gait cycle, and increased time in double limb support. Patients' hemiplegic limbs spent more time in swing and stance when compared to controls; their unaffected limbs spent significantly more time in stance and single limb support compared to control s. Patients' hemiplegic side, when compared with the unaffected side, spent less time in stance and more time in swing. A flatfoot pattern was typically noted on the affected side. General gait parameters improved over time, with the largest changes occurring in the first 12 months. However, the percentage of time spent in Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 10 double and single limb support, stance and swing, parameters which describe the asymmetrical pattern of gait, did not change over time. Abnormal gait was due to difficulty in moving the body over an unstable limb. Gait analysis can be of importance in documenting abnormalities and determining the effects of therapeutic modalities. 3: Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1983 Sep;64(9):402-7 Plastic ankle-foot orthoses: evaluation of function. Lehmann JF, Esselman PC, Ko MJ, Smith JC, deLateur BJ, Dralle AJ. Plastic ankle-foot orthoses (PAFOs) are worn by persons with hemiplegia to correct gait abnormalities such as foot drop during swing and insufficient pushoff during stance. A PAFO should resist plantarflexion sufficiently to provide toe clearance during the swing phase of gait without excessively increasing the knee bending moment during heelstrike. It should resist dorsiflexion during late stance to raise the heel to simulate gastrocnemiussoleus muscle group function. Five PAFOs were evaluated as to the amount of plantarflexion-dorsiflexion resistance that was provided when worn by hemiplegic and able-bodied subjects. A self-aligning goniometer measured ankle angle as the subject walked, and a gait event marker system recorded occurrences of gait events. The Seattle design polypropylene orthosis which enclosed the malleoli was the least flexible; it provided the greatest plantarflexion resistance to ensure against toe drag during swing for patients with severe plantarflexion spasticity. It offered the greatest dorsiflexion resistance to provide a good substitute for the gastrocnemiussoleus during the latter part of stance as required by patients with flaccid plantarflexors and full ankle range of motion. Progressive trimming of the Seattle design polypropylene orthosis made it more flexible and comparable in function to the commercially available Engen and Teufel orthoses. The latter 2 orthoses did not provide a pushoff substitute as well as the Seattle design orthosis which enclosed the malleoli, but they did provide an adequate amount of toe clearance during swing. The more flexible orthoses would be appropriate for subjects with mild to moderate plantarflexor spasticity. 4. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1999 Jul;80(7):777- Hemiplegic gait of stroke patients: the effect of using a cane. Kuan TS, Tsou JY, Su FC. Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, National Cheng Kung University Hospital, Tainan, Taiwan. OBJECTIVE. To assess the effects of cane use on the hermiplegic gait of stroke patients, focusing on the temporal, spatial, and kinematic variables. DESIGN: Case-control study comparing the effect of walking with and without a cane using a six-camera computerized motion analysis system. SETTING: Stroke clinic of a tertiary care hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Fifteen ambulatory stroke patients were analyzed, including 10 men and 5 women (mean age, 56.9 years; mean time since stroke, 9.8 weeks). Nine age-matched healthy elderly subjects were recruited as a control group. RESULTS: Stroke patients walking with a cane showed significantly increased stride period, stride length, and affected side step length, as well as decreased cadence and step width (p <.05) in comparison with those who walked without a cane. There were no significant differences in the gait phases and the five gait events of hemiplegic gait walking with or Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 11 without a cane. Cane use thus may have more effect on spatial variables than on temporal variables. The affected side kinematics of hemiplegic gait with a cane showed increased pelvic obliquity, hip abduction, and ankle eversion during terminal stance phase; increased hip extension, knee extension, and ankle plantar-flexion during preswing phase; and increased hip adduction, knee flexion, and ankle dorsiflexion during swing phase as compared with hemiplegic gait without a cane. A cane thus improved the hemiplegic gait by assisting the affected limb to smoothly shift the center of body mass toward the sound limb and to enhance push off during preswing phase. It also improved circumduction gait during swing phase. CONCLUSION: Stroke patients walking with a cane demonstrated more normal spatial variables and joint motion than did those without a cane. Musculoskeletal Medicine Training Module: Gait Analysis 12 Attachment 1 The Royal Australasian College of Physicians THE AUSTRALASIAN FACULTY OF REHABILITATION MEDICINE Evaluation of Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation Training Workbook Gait Analysis Please take a few moments to complete this evaluation form. Your thoughtful comments will be reviewed by the Vocational Training Committee and will assist the Committee in the planning and development of future training resources. 1. Was the workbook helpful in your learning of this topic? (i.e. Did it clarify what knowledge attitude and skills you needed to reach competency in this area?) 2)2. Did you find the clinical scenarios and references helpful? 3)3. Do you feel your skills have improved as a result of using the workbook? Have you used your improved skills in the clinical setting? 4. If you have not used your new skills, what has prevented you from doing so? Formatted: Bullets and Numbering Formatted: Bullets and Numbering Attachment 1 5. What further questions about this topic remain in your mind remain in your mind? 6. Please give any additional comments about other aspects of the workbook, including requests for future workbook topics (or improvement on the existing book). 7)7. What other support do you feel the Faculty could provide to assist or facilitate your learning in Musculoskeletal Medicine? Name ______________________ date ___________ signature_________________ Thank you for your assistance. The Vocational Training Committee Please return completed evaluation forms to: AFRM, 145 Macquarie Street, Sydney NSW 2000 Formatted: Bullets and Numbering