June 2013 FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE OFFICIAL PROGRAMME FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE Singapore, located in the heart of Southeast Asia and right between India and China, is one of the smallest countries in Asia, with a population of about 5 million. Yet it is one of Asia’s largest importers of food products. In 2011, Singapore imported US$12.1 billion worth of agricultural products, processed food and drinks, making it the country with the highest food consumption levels in Southeast Asia on a per capita basis. Language: English Number of pages: 70 Author: Orissa International Pte Ltd in cooperation with the Swiss Business Hub ASEAN Other Reports: Are you interested in Reports for other sectors and countries? Please find more Reports here: www.switzerland-ge.com/study Contents 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY _______________________5 2. SINGAPORE PROFILE & ECONOMY ____________6 5.11.1. Alcoholic Drinks ________________________ 42 5.11.2. Hot Drinks ___________________________ 43 5.11.3. Soft Drinks ___________________________ 44 5.12. Private Labels __________________________ 45 3. CONSUMER TRENDS_________________________8 5.12.1. NTUC FairPrice Co-operative _______________ 45 4. REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT_________________9 5.12.2. Dairy Farm International Holdings___________ 46 4.1. Food Industry Authorities ____________________ 9 5.12.3. Sheng Siong Supermarket _________________ 46 4.1.1. Certifications ___________________________ 9 5.13. Foodservice / HoReCa ____________________ 47 4.1.2. Labeling ______________________________ 10 5.14. Industry Trends _________________________ 48 4.2. Import Procedures _________________________ 11 5.14.1. Food Supply __________________________ 48 4.3. Tariffs ________________________________ 12 5.14.2. Food Safety and Quality __________________ 48 5. FOOD INDUSTRY ___________________________13 6. FOOD DISTRIBUTION _______________________ 51 5.1. Retail _________________________________ 13 6.1. Route to Market ___________________________51 5.1.1. Market Size ____________________________ 13 6.1.1. FairPrice Group __________________________51 5.1.2. Market Structure ________________________ 14 6.1.2. Dairy Farm Group ________________________51 5.1.3. Competition ___________________________ 15 6.1.3. Sheng Siong ___________________________ 52 5.1.4. Challenges ____________________________ 22 6.2. National Distributors ______________________ 53 5.1.5. Players _______________________________ 22 6.3. Pricing ________________________________ 55 5.2. Specialty and Gourmet Stores ________________ 23 5.3. Organic & Natural Foods____________________ 24 5.4. Functional Foods _________________________ 26 5.5. Processed / Packaged Foods _________________ 28 7. OPPORTUNITIES & CHALLENGES ____________ 57 7.1. Opportunities ___________________________ 57 7.2. Challenges _____________________________ 58 5.5.1. Frozen Processed Food ____________________ 28 8. EXPORT CHECK LIST _______________________ 59 5.6. Dried Processed Food ______________________ 30 8.1. Readiness to Export _______________________ 59 5.7. Ready Meals in Singapore ___________________ 33 8.2. Market Research _________________________ 60 5.8. Sauces, Dressings and Condiments in Singapore ____ 35 8.3. Trade Fairs _____________________________ 61 5.9. Chocolate Confectionary ____________________ 39 8.4. Regulatory – Registering Product in Singapore ____ 61 5.10. Biscuits_______________________________ 41 8.5. Finding a Distributor / Importer ______________ 62 5.11. Beverages _____________________________ 42 8.6. Regulatory – Adapting to the Local Legislation ____ 63 Contents 8.7. Logistics and Imports ______________________ 63 8.8. Product Launch__________________________ 64 9. APPENDIX _________________________________65 9.1. Trade Shows ____________________________ 65 9.1.1. Food & Hotel Asia 2014 (FHA) _______________ 65 9.2. Trade Agencies & Associations ________________ 65 9.3. Publications ____________________________ 66 9.4. Import Duties ___________________________ 66 1. Executive Summary Singapore, located in the heart of Southeast Asia and right between India and China, is one of the smallest countries in Asia, with a population of about 5 million. Yet it is one of Asia’s largest importers of food products. In 2011, Singapore imported US$12.1 billion worth of agricultural products, processed food and drinks, making it the country with the highest food consumption levels in Southeast Asia on a per capita basis. There are many reasons why Singapore would be a very compelling market for Swiss exporters. Firstly, it has a very attractive consumer base. Singapore is the richest economy within the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), and the 3rd richest country in the world1. The bulk of the population is regarded as middle income consumers who lead a comfortable lifestyle and have aspirations for fine living. They are the largest pool of active consumers and will continue to drive increased consumption of imported food, especially from countries like Switzerland. There is also the top tier of income earners comprising both Singaporeans and expatriates with an annual income of more than US$150,000 which is influencing the food and beverage market. Major retailers are increasingly setting aside shelf space for premium food and beverage products, and more world-renowned chefs are setting up fine dining restaurants in Singapore to take advantage of this growing consumer class. Finally, the large tourist numbers that visit Singapore every year are also adding to consumer demand. In 2012, Singapore attracted over 10 million visitors to its shores, as large as other famous tourist destinations in Asia like Thailand. Secondly, Singapore is one of the most open markets in the world. The 2011 World Bank “Ease of Doing Business” Index ranks Singapore as the best country in the world to do business – ahead of Hong Kong and New Zealand. The language of business here is English, so there is not much need to change labeling of products if they are already in that language. The AgriVeterinary Authority of Singapore, the regulatory authority controlling the imports of food and beverage products into Singapore, does not impose onerous import requirements, although there have been concerns expressed by foreign exporters about the difficulty of meeting Singapore’s microbiological standards for meat exports. Thirdly, Singapore does not produce much food due to limited land and resources. It imports more than 90% of its food products. Singapore’s food and beverage industry is expected to continue growing in the near future, albeit at a much slower rate. Food retail in particular, which represents 40% of total retail spending in Singapore, is expected to increase as a result of higher incomes and rising visitor arrivals. While there are many positive reasons for Swiss exporters to look at the Singapore market, there are also some challenges to consider. Given the attraction and openness of the Singapore market, competition is very stiff. On one hand, other foreign exporters globally are looking at opportunities in Asia as their own local markets slow down due to the global economic crisis, but the competition also comes from regional suppliers in Asia. This includes multinationals like Nestle which have their own manufacturing bases in countries like Thailand. Similarly than in Switzerland, as purchasing of food and beverage products becomes concentrated within supermarkets and hypermarkets, these players have very strong purchasing power, and dictate terms to exporters and distributors like listing fees and promotions. Distributors are also now more particular about the type of exporters they work with. They expect suppliers to support them in terms of advertising and promotion, and will only really prefer working with suppliers which take a long term view of the market and are prepared to put in the necessary financial and resource commitment to support their distributors. The Singapore market remains an attractive market for Swiss exporters. 1 Source: World Economic Outlook Database – Oct 2012, IMF FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 5 2. Singapore Profile & Economy Situated at the crossroads between India and China, and located in heart of Southeast Asia, Singapore is one of the smallest countries in Asia, with a population of about 5 million. Yet Singapore is one of the most open, competitive and richest markets in the world. The 2011 World Bank “Ease of Doing Business” Index ranks Singapore as the best country in the world to do business – ahead of Hong Kong and New Zealand. Singapore is also ranked third in the World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Report behind Switzerland and Sweden. It is the richest economy within the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), and the 3rd richest country in the world, according to the 2012 Forbes List of the World’s Richest Countries, just behind Qatar and Luxembourg, with a GDP (PPP-adjusted) per capita of US$56,694. In 2010, Singapore had a total population of 5.1 million, with a population growth rate of 0.8%. Approximately 60% of the total population is comprised of Singapore citizens, and the remainder comprises foreigners working in Singapore. These foreigners include professionals, managers, executives and technicians (PMETS) working on expatriate or local terms, domestic helpers (live-in maids), blue collar workers working in an industrial or construction environment and very high net worth individuals (VNNWI) who have made Singapore their home while they do business in the region. SINGAPORE DEMOGRAPHICS (2010) 5.1 MILLION POPULATION POPULATION GROWTH 0.8% 0-14 YEARS: 13.8% AGE STRUCTURE 15-64 YEARS: 77% 65 YEARS +: 9.2% 40.1 YEARS MEDIAN AGE 82.1 YEARS LIFE EXPECTANCY Source: Singapore Statistics The ethnic composition of Singapore citizens is mainly Chinese, at 76.8% of the population, with a smaller presence of Malays (13.9%) and Indians (7.9%) Mandarin, English, Malay and Tamil are the four official languages, but the primary medium of instruction in schools and the language of business in Singapore is English. Due to its relatively small size, Singapore is completely urbanized, with 100% of the population living in urban areas. The Singapore economic model is a mix of free-market policies and practices and government intervention in macroeconomic management. Given that Singapore has a relatively small domestic market, the country’s economic strategy has always been to open its economy to foreign investment, position itself as a hub for companies seeking to do business in South East Asia or the greater Asia-Pacific region, and to attract manufacturing investment that is capital intensive and which requires good infrastructure, rather than industries that are labor intensive. Such policies have attracted numerous multinational companies to establish a direct presence here, enabling Singapore to grow into one of the most advanced and technologically driven economies in the world. In 2010, Singapore was rated as the third fastest growing economy in the world with a real GDP growth rate of 14.47%. It is the only Asian country to have AAA credit ratings from all three major credit rating agencies – Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s and Fitch. According to the 2011 Index of Economic Freedom, Singapore is the 2nd freest economy in the world. Singapore’s business freedom score is exceptionally high – it takes three days to start a business in Singapore compared to the world’s average of thirty-four days. Apart from strong business and regulatory policies, other factors such as the country’s strategic geographic position, a vast natural seaport, a highly skilled workforce and a favorable tax regime have created a conducive business environment for companies and industries. Services (72.8 %) and manufacturing (27.2%) made up the bulk of Singapore’s GDP. Within the manufacturing sector, Singapore has specialized in electronics manufacturing for the past forty years. The petroleum and petrochemicals industry in Singapore is one of the biggest in the world. Singapore imports oil from other countries before refining them for further use to other countries. Singapore is the third largest oil refining center in the world, behind Rotterdam and Houston. Biomedical and FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 6 pharmaceutical manufacturing are relatively newer industry sectors that have developed in Singapore in the last 10 years. There is a current thrust to further develop the aerospace sector. Supporting clusters in precision engineering and metal fabrication to support these industries have also grown in tandem with these clusters. Singapore is also a global leader in services, particularly in finance. The banking system is considered to be among the strongest in the world. Singapore has the fourth largest foreign exchange market in the world after London, New York and Tokyo. The Singapore Government Securities is the only Asian market, besides Japan, to be part of the Citigroup World Bond Index. The Singapore Exchange (SGX) was also the first demutualized, integrated securities and derivatives exchange in AsiaPacific. Singapore is recognized as one of the premier asset management centers in Asia with more than 200 international asset management firms. Apart from finance, tourism is now another major service industry in Singapore. In 2011, tourist arrivals to Singapore hit a record high of 11.638 million visitors with tourist receipts of more than S$18.8 billion. Thanks to government initiatives, tourism has diversified into niche markets such as medical tourism, the gambling industry and the MICE (Meetings, Incentives, Conferencing and Exhibitions) industry. With the advent of the two new integrated resorts, tourism expenditure in sightseeing and entertainment grew by an astonishing 1834% in 2011. International trade is highly important for Singapore, as it has virtually no natural resources. Singapore is the 14th largest exporter and the 15th largest importer in the world. A large percentage of trade is conducted to meet domestic demand for energy, food, and other necessities. Singapore also regularly engages in entrepôt trade, whereby industries and businesses in the country import raw materials, before refining them for re-export. 47% of Singapore’s exports consist of re-exports. According to the WTO, Singapore has the highest trade to GDP ratio in the world at 407.9%. As a strong advocate of free trade, Singapore has relatively few trade barriers. Trade partners with Most Favored Nation (MFN) have zero tariff rates applied to their products apart from six lines for alcoholic beverages. There are however some import restrictions based mainly on environmental, health, and public security concerns. The import of rice also requires import licensing in order to ensure food security and price stability. Source: Geology.com FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 7 3. Consumer Trends Singapore has a diverse demographic base which has impacted consumer trends in the country. This demographic base includes: High Income and Upper-Middle Income Local Consumers – Singapore’s median household monthly income increased from $3,640 in 2000 to $5,000 in 2010. The proportion of resident households earning $6,000 increased from 27 percent in 2000 to 43 percent in 2010 while the proportion earning at least $15,000 more than doubled from 4.1 percent in 2000 to 10 percent in 2010. This segment of consumers is very well educated and ‘westernized’ and is made up of two main groups: middle-aged PMETs (mainly aged 40-64) who have higher disposable income, and whose sophistication of taste comes largely from travel, and a younger group of PMETs (those in their twenties and thirties) who has grown up on modern western cafes, the media and influence from their peers. The Expatriate Community – Singapore’s recent immigration policy of attracting foreign talent has attracted many western expatriates from Europe, the Americas and Australia to relocate to the city state. While many come as high-income employees of multinational firms, a growing number of expatriates are also wealthy individuals who have set up a second home in Singapore as their base in Asia. Yet another group is made up of independent businessmen who have arrived in Singapore on the EntrePass scheme, which is a special resident visa for businessmen who bring capital into the country and employ Singaporeans. Growing Number of Inbound Tourists – Singapore attracted a record of more than 11 million visitors in 2011 according to Singapore’s Tourism Board statistics (not including visitors from Malaysia who travel to Singapore via the causeway). This was a 20.2 percent increase over 2010. The key drivers for this surge of visitor arrivals are: Increasing frequency of flights into the city-state from regional countries The opening of the two casinos (Marina Bay Sands and Resorts World) Increasing number of meetings, incentives, conferences and exhibitions New tourist attractions (Gardens by the Bay, River Safari, Universal Studios) Special high profile events (The Formula One Night Race, The World Gourmet Summit) International Concerts/Visual and Performing Arts events As a result of this demographic base, some clear consumer trends can be seen: Singaporean consumers are increasingly leading hectic lifestyles, and often do not have sufficient time to prepare freshly cooked meals. As such, this group either tends to eat out quite a bit, or they purchase processed and packaged foods which require limited preparation. Due to growing Western influence in the country, a number of households are purchasing foods common to the West such as pasta and roast beef. Households are also consuming more cereals and breads for breakfast instead of traditional breakfast options (i.e. rice porridge). Singaporeans are also increasingly willing to purchase value added food and beverages at a premium due to higher incomes. As Singapore consumers are increasingly aware of health and safety issues, there is a higher demand for healthier products as well as unprocessed and functional foods, and food and beverage items which are packaged and labeled with nutritional information. Items like wholegrain food items, low-fat dairy products and enriched bread, are seen as healthier alternatives. Rising disposable incomes and increased awareness about healthier living have increased the demand for organic products, and decreased the demand for genetically-modified foods. These types of food items have become increasingly popular with high-income households, parents of young children and professionals. There has also been a decrease in the amount of calories and fats consumed, which fell by 1% and 4% respectively, between 2007 and 2010. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 8 While the demographic trends mentioned above should bode well for the consumption of food and drinks, clouds are appearing over the horizon. A major factor that is coming into play is the aging of the local population and the Singapore Government’s plan to limit inward migration and the granting of work permits and employment passes to foreign nationals. The latter is a result of complaints from its electorate over the rapid pace of such migration and employment between 2006 and 2010, and the government’s desire to increase productivity by limiting the number of foreigners companies can hire. Currently, almost 40% of the total population in Singapore comprises non-citizens. This tightening of rules has started to have a visible impact on the consumer confidence of the foreign population, and will lead to slower population growth in Singapore in the future. Consumer confidence is also leaning towards one of growing pessimism. Given the uncertain economic forecasts for 2013 given Singapore’s exposure to the global economy and the uncertainty in the Eurozone, the US and even China, the Singapore Government has predicted a 1-3% growth rate in Singapore in the foreseeable future. Retailers are reporting that consumer confidence in the broader population was low in 2012. This situation has arisen because of the weaker economic conditions. Inflation is reported at be around 5%, which is very high on a historical basis for Singapore. While the government is controlling inflation of basic products, the costs of housing, transportation and power/water continue to increase. Trade sources comment that the lack of consumer confidence has resulted in many consumers becoming involved in “bargain hunting/seeking” in retail channels. This trend is supported by a recent Nielsen survey of on-line shopping in Singapore, which revealed that close to 60% of Singapore’s on-line shoppers are seeking bargains, which is much higher than the Asia Pacific average at around 40%. Retailers comment that in some categories, the bulk of sales are now being made only when a price promotion is run and, that in many cases, only the brand being promoted sells in high volumes. 4. Regulatory Environment 4.1. FOOD INDUSTRY AUTHORITIES The Agri-Food & Veterinary Authority of Singapore (AVA) is the main government agency that ensures food safety and health standards, which governs all food products imported into Singapore. It is a statutory board established in the year 2000 as a result of the restructuring of the country’s Primary Production Department. Some of AVA’s key functions are to ensure food safety, resilience of food supply, the safeguarding of animal and plant health and promoting agro-technology. AVA adopts a stringent science-based risk analysis and management approach based on international standards to evaluate and ensure food safety. Swiss exporters are required to meet AVA approval before exporting their products to Singapore. Some of the key regulations they should be aware of include: 4.1.1. Certifications In addition to looking for AVA approval, Swiss exporters should also have HACCP certification or ISO 22000. HACCP, which stands for “Hazard analysis and critical control points”, is referred as the prevention of hazards instead of finished product inspection. It is defined as a “systematic prevention approach to food safety and pharmaceutical safety that identifies physical, allergenic, chemical and biological hazards in production processes that can cause the finished product to be unsafe, and designs measurements to reduce these risks to a safe level.” HACCP is thus a certification to demonstrate high levels of safety processes and standards. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 9 ISO 22000 deals with food safety and is developed by International Organization for Standardization. ISO 22000 international standard specifies the requirements for a food safety management system that involves interactive communication, system management, prerequisite programs and HACCP principles. 4.1.2. Labeling Labels are required on imported food and must specify the country of origin. A food label should contain core information such as the prescribed food name, list of ingredients, mandatory warning, advisory statements or allergens declarations, net weight or volume, date mark, nutritional information panel, instructions for use or storage, country of origin, the name and address of the business and manufacturer and importer. Repackaged foods must be labeled to show (in English) the appropriate designation of food content printed in capital letters at least 1/16 inch high; whether foods are compounded, mixed or blended; the minimum quantity stated in metric net weight or measure; the name and address of the manufacturer or seller; and the country of origin. Illustrations must accurately describe the true nature or origin of the food. Foods having defined standards must be labeled to conform to those standards and be free from added foreign substances. Packages of food described as “enriched”, “fortified”, “vitaminized” or in any other way that implies that the article contains added vitamins or minerals must show the quantity of vitamins or minerals added per metric unit. The following checklist below was extracted from “A Guide to Food Labeling and Advertisements in Singapore” prepared by the Agri-Food & Veterinary Authority (AVA) in Singapore. It is to assist industry members to self-check food labels and advertisements before sale / publication. This Guidebook aims to provide food importers, manufacturers and retailers with a better understanding of the labeling requirements of the Food Regulations, as well as the permitted and prohibited claims for use in food labels and advertisements. Swiss companies seeking to get a better understanding of the requirements to import food and beverage products into Singapore are strongly encouraged to peruse the AVA website. Some of the key web links have been included below: http://www.ava.gov.sg/ http://www.ava.gov.sg/FoodSector/ImportExportTransOfFood/ReqToImportExportTransshipFood/ http://www.ava.gov.sg/Legislation/ListOfLegislation/ The guide to understanding the labeling and advertisement of food and beverage products can be found on here: http://www.ava.gov.sg/NR/rdonlyres/B96B0EC2-1D1E-4448-9C25ABD8470D2BF4/20119/AGuidetoFoodLabellingandAdvertisementsVersionOctob.pdf Labeling Checklist for Singapore Item Labeling Requirements GENERAL LABELING 1. Product Name: An acceptable common name or description which is sufficient to indicate the true nature of the product 2. Ingredients List: All ingredients and additives used in the product are listed in descending order by proportion of weight. 3. Quantity: The minimum quantity of the food in the package expressed in terms of volumetric measure (for liquid food products) or net weight (for solid food products). 4. Imported Food: Name of the country of origin of the product. Name and address of the importer, distributor or agent in Singapore. 5. Locally manufactured food: Name and address of the manufacturer, packer or local vendor. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 10 Remarks 6. Are item numbers (1) to (5)printed in English 7. Are item numbers (1) to (3) printed in letters not less than 1.5mm in height USE OF CLAIMS ON FOOD LABELS AND ADVERTISEMENTS 8. If the products carry nutrition claims, claims on vitamins and minerals and health claims, are they of the permitted ones? Information found on pages 16 28* of AVA guide 9. If the products carry permitted claims, do they meet the criteria to make the claims? Information found on pages 16 28* of AVA guide 10. Are the claims phrased appropriately? Information found on pages 16 28* of AVA guide 11. If manufacturer would like to apply for use of existing nutrient specific diet related health claims, have they applied for the use of the claims? Information found on pages 24 27* of AVA guide 12. a) Do the products carry non-permitted claims? Information found on pages 15* of AVA guide b) Have they deleted the claims? 13. Did they apply for new health claims which are well substantiated by the current scientific evidence? Refer to page 28* of AVA guide ADDITIONAL LABELING REQUIREMENTS 14. Is the product labeled with the expiry date? Refer to pages 7 - 8* of AVA guide 15. If the product contains artificial sweetener, have they labeled its content based on the specific requirement? Refer to pages 8 - 9* of AVA guide 16. If the product is a special purpose food, have they labeled the product with specific information required? Refer to pages 9 - 11* of AVA guide 17. Does the product need to be labeled with a warning statement? Refer to page 14* of AVA guide 18. If permitted nutrition claims, claims on vitamins and minerals and health claims are used, is the nutrition information panel provided? Refer to pages 11 - 12* of AVA guide 19. Other specific requirements for certain food categories? Refer to page 13* of AVA guide 20. Are there any prohibited claims and have they deleted them? Refer to page 15* of AVA guide Note: The checklist provided served only as a guide and not as any forms of certification or approval of food labels. Source: Agri-Food & Veterinary Authority of Singapore 4.2. IMPORT PROCEDURES Companies must make an inward declaration for all goods imported into Singapore. All imports require an import permit although this is largely a statistical requirement for most goods. Details can be found at: www.customs.gov.sg/leftNav/trad/Permits+and+Documentation.htm . Import of trade samples for which the total value is below US$286 (S$400) is not subject to payment of duty and/or GST. In addition, no permit is required for their import. Bona fide trade samples (excluding liquors and tobacco) may be imported if they are imported solely for the purpose of soliciting orders for goods to be supplied from abroad, for demonstration in Singapore to enable manufacturers in Singapore to produce such articles to fulfill orders from abroad or by a manufacturer for the purpose of copying, testing or experimenting before they produce such articles in Singapore. More information can be found at www.customs.gov.sg/leftNav/trav/Business+Travellers.htm . FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 11 Every imported shipment of meat and poultry is tested by AVA. AVA does not accept raw and uncooked poultry and meat products that contain salmonella bacteria that exceed AVA’s microbiological standards. There have been some complaints that AVA’s standards are unrealistically stringent; in fact, the US Government has indicated on one of their official websites that some of their meat exporters are unable to comply with AVA’s requirements and have highlighted this issue as a potential trade barrier. 4.3. TARIFFS Singapore is generally a free port and an open economy. More than 99% of all imports into Singapore enter the country dutyfree. For social and/or environmental reasons, Singapore levies high excise taxes on beer, wine and liquor, tobacco products, motor vehicles and petroleum products. Singapore levies a 7% Goods and Services Tax (GST). For dutiable goods, the taxable value for GST is calculated based on the CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight) value plus all duties and other charges. In the case of non-dutiable foods, GST will be based on the CIF value plus any commission and other incidental charges whether or not shown on the invoice. If the goods are dutiable, the GST will be collected simultaneously with the duties. Special provisions pertain to goods stored in licensed warehouses and free trade zones. More information can be found @ www.iras.gov.sg and www.customs.gov.sg. For customs clearance, importers are required to obtain an IN Permit through Trade Net®, an electronic trade platform, and to pay 7% Goods and Services Tax before goods are imported into Singapore. The process is usually completed in less than 48 hours. In Singapore, valuation for customs purposes is based on the Customs Valuation Code (CVC). The primary basis for Customs value is the transaction value of the imported goods when sold for export to Singapore. Where goods are dutiable, ad valorem or specific rates may be applied. An ad valorem rate, which is most commonly applied, is a percentage of the Customs value of the imported goods. A specific rate is a specified amount per unit of weight of other quantity. Cost, insurance, freight, handling charges and all other charges incidental to the sale and delivery of the goods are taken into account when the duty is assessed. Exporters are required to ensure that the declared values of goods have not been undervalued or the Customs and Excise Department will increase the values declared. Severe penalties may be imposed on traders attempting to evade duty. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 12 5. Food Industry 5.1. RETAIL 5.1.1. Market Size As Singapore does not produce much food, it imports more than 90% of its food products. It is one of Asia’s largest importers of agricultural products and processed foods. In 2011, Singapore imported US$12.1 billion worth of agricultural products, processed food and drinks. In fact, the country has the highest food consumption levels in Southeast Asia on a per capita basis. Due to high per capita consumption growth, Singapore’s food and beverage industry is expected to continue growing in the near future. Food retail in particular, which represents 40% of total retail spending in Singapore, is expected to increase as a result of higher incomes and rising visitor arrivals. Carbohydrates are a staple item in Singapore cuisine; as a result, bread and cereal products were the most purchased food items in 2010, making up 21% of total food spending. Meat and seafood each comprised 17% of total food spending, while vegetables made up 13% and dairy products accounted for 11% of total food expenditure. Trends in Singapore’s Import of Agrifoods, Processed Food and Drinks (2006 – 2011, in US$ ‘000) 14'000'000 12'000'000 10'000'000 8'000'000 6'000'000 4'000'000 2'000'000 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Source: COMTRADE Singapore’s imports are diverse, largely because its domestic production is not broad based and, additionally, because its reexporters are trading a wide range of products into the Asian region. Beverage imports lead the market because of the strategy of using Singapore as a hub for re-exporting alcoholic drinks. As an example, re-exports of spirits, i.e. whisky, cognac, vodka, etc., comprised around 90% of total imports in 2011. Re-exports also tend to be high in frozen meat, poultry and offal, certain fresh and dried fruits and vegetables, confectionery, canned products, beer and soft drinks and juices. The bulk of many other products categories are consumed in Singapore, e.g. chilled foods, e.g. dairy and meats, perishable fruits and vegetables, and some types of frozen foods. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 13 Singapore Imports of Agrifoods, Processed Food and Drinks in 2011 Processed vegetables & fruits 4% Processed fish & meat 4% Sugar and its products 4% Vegetables, fish / dried 4% Beverages 20% Processed cereal & starch products 4% Cereals, unprocessed 3% Other products 4% Cocoa and its products 5% Oils & fats 10% Coffee, tea & spices 4% Misc processed foods 5% Dairy products 12% Meat & poultry 7% Fish & seafood 7% Fruits, fresh / dried 5% Source: COMTRADE 5.1.2. Market Structure There are 4 major groups of food retailers in Singapore comprising large retailers, convenience stores, petrol stations and traditional stores. According to the government’s 2010 retail industry report, there are about 3,000 supermarkets, hypermarkets, department stores, convenience stores and provision shops in Singapore that sells agrifoods, processed food and drinks. Singapore also has an additional 1,300 specialty food and drinks outlets. About US$9.1 billion total sales was reported in 2010, and about 38,000 people were employed in the sector. Supermarket chains and hypermarkets hold 80% of the market share, with convenience stores and traditional stores holding about 19% of the market share. Traditional stores hold only 3% of market share but comprise of 70% coverage of total food retailers in Singapore. In this category, wet markets, provision shops and sundry shops are included. Wet markets sells fresh meat and produce, provision shops are traditional convenience stores located within public housing neighborhoods, and sundry shops sells traditional Asian cooking ingredients such as preserved goods and spices. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 14 Singapore also has a highly fragmented wholesale industry in the food sector, where its 3,400 firms generated total sales of about US$7.1 billion in 2010. Many are family owned businesses involved in re-exports of products from Singapore. Some of these companies are responsible for multinationals’ regional marketing operations. Currently, only 6% of online shoppers purchase food. This is due to longer operating hours by the major supermarkets such as Cold Storage and NTUC FairPrice. Most Cold Storage supermarkets are open daily from 9 am to 10 pm, and most NTUC FairPrice supermarkets are open from 7am or 8am to 10pm or 11pm daily, depending on the location. Some NTUC FairPrice supermarkets are open 24 hours daily. Due to such long business operating hours and easy access to supermarkets, internet orders have not taken off as much as perhaps in other countries. However more than 80% of the Singapore population has internet access, so online retailing as a channel may increase in future. 5.1.3. Competition The table below provides an overview of competition in the market segments Overview of Competition in the Market Segment Market and Its Size Beef, fresh / chilled and frozen Pork, fresh/chilled and frozen Poultry, frozen Net imports: 102,476 tons. (Note: Chicken Major Supply Countries Strengths of Key Supply Countries Australia – 42% New Zealand – 23% Brazil – 20% Uruguay – 7% Australia and New Zealand (mainly food service, with a low level presence in retail) have full access for all of their products, which local buyers consider as good quality and price competitive. USA – 6% Brazil – 34% Australia – 17% Netherlands – 14% USA – 11% Brazil – 56% USA – 32% Argentina – 9% FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 15 Advantages and Disadvantages of Local Suppliers Beef is not produced in Singapore Brazil price-competes in the frozen beef segment, which now has an expanded presence in supermarkets. It is gradually expanding its market share due to weak market conditions. Brazil dominates the frozen segment with valuefor-money pork of a quality acceptable to local users, some in retail channels. Australia (Australian Pork and AIRPORK brands) dominates the fresh/chilled market on the back of its proximity and ability to export high volumes to Singapore. Netherlands frozen pork is in retail channels packed under private or retailer labels. While there is still consumer resistance to frozen pork, Australia has been gradually losing market share to Brazil due to increased price sensitivity and weaker consumer confidence since 2008 and Brazilian access to the major retailers under their brands, e.g. in FairPrice. Brazilian frozen pork pricing is about 30% less than Australian fresh pork. Indonesian live pigs are imported and slaughtered in Singapore, and the pork is sold through wet markets (chilled retail stalls) and supermarkets. It is acceptable to Singaporeans and is part of the country’s food security for staple foods. Brazil (e.g. Borella, Sadia, Frangosul and Seara) competes on price and its products are acceptable to users in Singapore. The USA is now Malaysian live chickens are imported and slaughtered in Singapore. This fresh chicken is the dominant accounts for 99% of imports. Turkey and duck imports (net of re-exports) are niche markets Offal, frozen (not poultry) Cheese in all forms Butter and dairy spreads Yogurt Liquid milk Australia – 26% New Zealand – 26% Netherlands – 11% Denmark – 10% USA – 2% Australia – 42% New Zealand – 15% USA – 12% France – 7% Italy – 4% Australia – 27% Netherlands – 26% New Zealand – 20% France – 11% USA – 4% Malaysia – 38% Australia – 23% Thailand – 15% Switzerland – 9% Germany – 7% USA – 6% Australia – 42% Thailand – 31% Indonesia – 11% New Zealand – 5% India – 2% USA – 0.3% FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 16 a niche player in retail channels. product in the market and is in high demand based on traditional demand traits. Private or retailer label packed frozen halal certified bovine offal, mainly imported from Australia, is readily available in supermarkets. Offal from pigs slaughtered in Singapore dominates the market for such products. No substantial quantities of bovine offal are produced in Singapore. Fonterra’s brands from Australia and New Zealand are leading players, along with some other Australian brands, e.g. Lactos, Dairy Farmers and Bega. President (France) and Arla (Denmark) also have a strong retail presence, with President making a big marketing push for new share in the processed cheese segment. Singapore does not produce any retail packed cheeses. Australia has a number of brands in the market, e.g. Golden Churn, including some private label products. Anchor (New Zealand), President (France) and some other EU brands (Lurpak) have a strong presence No retail packed butter is produced in Singapore. The strongest imported brands are Alive (Fraser & Neave Malaysia), which is the leading imported brand, Yoplait and Bulla (Australia), Meiji (Thailand) and Emmi (Switzerland). U.S. yogurts are niche players in high Malaysia Dairy Industries produces Marigold yoghurt, which has been tailored to Singaporean local tastes. It leads the yogurt market and is an aggressive competitor for all imported brands in the chilled dairy sections of supermarkets and hypermarkets. The strongest imported products in the market are Farmhouse (local brand), Marigold (local brand) and Pura, all of which are from Australia, and Meiji (Thailand) and Greenfields (Indonesia). The retailer in-house brands of milk are also imported from Australia. The local dairy companies are very strong competitors with good brands and some imported liquid milks in their portfolios. The local brands include Magnolia, Farmhouse, Daisy (Fraser & Neave), and the brands of Malaysian Dairy Industries, namely HL (the market leader) and Marigold. Ice cream Apples and pears Grapes and raisins Soft fruits, temperate varieties Stone fruits, including avocado Edible nuts, temperate climate products Potatoes, fresh table Malaysia – 52% Thailand – 19% France – 5% USA – 4% Indonesia – 3% Australia – 3% China – 49% South Africa – 20% New Zealand – 9% USA – 9% France – 7% Argentina – 3% USA – 45% South Africa – 23% Australia – 12% Chile – 7% Egypt – 5% USA – 54% South Korea – 26% Australia – 8% New Zealand – 5% Egypt – 2% USA – 46% Australia – 23% South Africa – 9% China – 5% New Zealand – 5% Chile – 4% USA – 55% China – 23% Australia – 9% Iran – 7% Italy – 3% China – 35% Bangladesh – 22% FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 17 Wall’s (Unilever), Nestlé and Fraser & Neave are fighting each other for market share in the mass market from their production bases in Malaysia and Thailand. This activity now includes a much larger selection of novelty ice creams than in the past. They are also involved in an expansion into the premium area of the market, where they now compete with Häagen-Dazs (France) and Ben & Jerry’s (USA). Local supply is negligible when compared to imports. The market is generally price competitive due to retailer strategies and preference for lower cost products, e.g. from China and South Africa. In addition to apples (Fuji variety only), China also supplies highly popular Chinese pears. New Zealand and France (EU financed) are supported by strong branded advertising campaigns, promotions and good physical distribution. Singapore does not produce apples and pears. The USA dominates in its season because of its competitiveness on quality, salability, profitability for channel members, promotional support and branding (including in raisins) and supply capacity. In the other season, South Africa and Australia (close to year round supply capability in green grapes) compete, with South Africa winning due to its more competitive pricing. Not produced in Singapore. High quality chilled distribution channels into Singapore, ability to deliver quality, and seasonal promotional activities support all activity in this market. Not produced in Singapore. High quality chilled distribution channels into Singapore and seasonal promotional activities support the USA and Australian positions in this market. Not produced in Singapore. Competition revolves around traditional commodities from China and Iran, and branded snacks (USA mainly under local brands, which are well distributed) and some level of seasonal demand. Not produced in Singapore. This market is generally price competitive, with the USA and, to a lesser extent, Australia involved in marketing higher quality potatoes in Not produced in Singapore. Broccoli and cauliflower, fresh Lettuce headtype, fresh USA – 13% Indonesia – 9% Australia – 7% China – 85% Australia – 10% Malaysia – 3% USA – 1% China – 34% USA – 27% Malaysia – 24% (China took leadership in this market from the USA) Asparagus, fresh Celery, fresh Coffee, ground roasted Thailand – 44% USA – 29% Australia – 15% Peru – 8% USA – 67% China – 22% Malaysia – 7% Australia – 3% USA – 56%* Indonesia – 15% Malaysia – 8% Italy – 3% Germany – 2%* FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 18 supermarkets. China now dominates this market and is increasing its share of a growing market. This situation exists because of its price competitiveness and quality versus Australia. Chinese product quality is now similar in the “eyes of consumers” and its export pricing is between 40% and 50% of Australia’s pricing, a situation that is now reported to be linked to significant subsidies being paid to Chinese farmers. Some concerns are reported to be developing in the consumer market over the safety of Chinese fresh produce in the light of some news that is circulating locally about the contamination of Chinese fresh produce with various types of chemicals, including banned pesticides, found in the Hong Kong market. Not produced in Singapore. China took leadership in this market from the USA for the first time in recent history in 2011. This resulted from a major B2B sales push to expand exports, China’s price remaining at around 75% of the U.S. price and a B2B (mainly retailer industry) perception that Chinese lettuce has now started to match that of the USA’s lettuce, at a time when Singapore’s market has become more price sensitive. Malaysia is mainly supplying hydroponic products which are marketed differently to U.S. products. Singapore does not produce products that compete with U.S. imported products. Thailand, which supplies younger (thinner) asparagus, operates in a different segment to asparagus imported from the USA. Thai products have a mass market target. The USA leads the seasonal premium market. Not produced in Singapore. The USA leads this market because of its competitiveness in terms of price, quality and supply, distribution and marketing capabilities. China has continued to build its market share (up from 15% in 2010), largely at the expense of the USA’s share. It has reached more than 20% for the first time since 2007. Not produced in Singapore. The strong local brands marginalize imported brands to niches or the food service market (a key U.S. target due to corporate demand-pull). The highest profile premium brands in retailers are all from the EU, e.g. Illy, Melitta, Lavazza, Eduscho and Cafe Direct. The highest profile U.S. retail brand is Folger. Nestlé has just started to play in this market. Singapore has a strong coffee producing industry, with the dominant players in the premium segment being Boncafe, the market leader, and Sarika (Suzuki brand). (Mainly imports for use in food service outlets including major modern coffee shop chains.) Processed meats and poultry, not chilled Sausages, not fresh chilled Sugar confectionery, not chewing gum Chocolate confectionery Thailand – 47% China – 22% Malaysia – 15% USA – 6% Brazil – 3% Brazil – 34% France – 30% USA – 17% Denmark – 12% Malaysia – 4% Malaysia – 28% China – 18% USA – 9% Indonesia – 7% Thailand – 6% Taiwan – 5% Germany – 4% Malaysia – 13% USA – 12% Australia – 11% Italy – 10% Switzerland – 6% New Zealand – 4% FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 19 This market is dominated by a range of frozen, pre-cooked chicken, and Asian-style canned products from Thailand (including Chareon Pokphand frozen products) and Malaysia (various brands), and canned products from China. The key non- Asian brands in this market are mainly canned beef and pork-based products, i.e. Spam (USA), Libby’s (Brazil) and Tulip (EU produced). Growing stronger on the new investments in production facilities for processed meats, both chilled and canned, underpinned by a strategy that the products are better quality than imported alternatives. This is a price-driven commodity-type market, which is underpinned by strong physical distribution, gaining good access to retail display space and, importantly, periodic price promotions. The highest profile supplies in frozen sausages are Perdix (Brazil), Doux (France) and Rockingham and Valley Chef, with Tulip (Denmark) being the leader in canned sausages. Retailer in-house labeled frozen sausages (produced in Brazil and Malaysia) are taking market share from imported brands. The USA lost market share to France in 2011 because of its higher pricing than French products. The local sausage industry has a focus on producing premium fresh/chilled sausages and traditional dried Chinese-style sausages. Although a competitive industry, it does not compete directly with imported products, which tend to be either commodity products (frozen or canned frankfurters) or branded better quality “more authentic” chilled products. This market is dominated by products from Malaysia (several brands) and multinational brands with operations in ASEAN and China, including Mars, Wrigley (also supplying its U.S. products, but not chewing gum due to a regulatory restriction), Nestlé, Kraft (Cadbury Adams), Perfetti Van Melle. Some high profile brands are also imported from Germany (Werther’s and Haribo) and Japan. These businesses all support their brands through wide spread distribution and periodic advertising and promotions. Singapore is not a major producer of sugar confectionery, although it has a strong position in the medicated sweets segment. High levels of competition for retail shelf space between Cadbury (Australia and New Zealand), Mars (Australia and China), Hershey (USA and China), Ferrero (Italy), Nestlé (Malaysia, UK Australia and USA), Lindt and Frey (Switzerland) and others from Malaysia. Europe also has high profile and very active brands from Singapore is a chocolate producer but does not operate as a major player in the mass retail market. Germany, Belgium, France, Switzerland and the UK, which tend to operate in the premium food gift market. Cookies (Sweet Biscuits) Malaysia – 42% Indonesia – 13% China – 7% Thailand – 6% UK – 6% USA – 4% China – 40% USA – 16% Philippines – 13% Malaysia – 11% Thailand – 6% UK – 3% Snack foods, extruded types and potato based Malaysia – 65% USA - 15% Thailand – 13% Frozen potatoes USA – 77% Canada – 15% USA – 41% Thailand – 28% China – 9% Japan – 3% Belgium – 3% Malaysia – 27% Indonesia – 16% USA – 14% China – 7% South Korea – 4% Breakfast cereals, including oats Frozen vegetables Fruit juices FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 20 Malaysia is very strong with the branded and wide product portfolios if Kraft (also supply from Indonesia, China and the USA), Munchy’s and Perfect Foods dominating the retailers’ shelves and brand shares. A range of EU brands also have a solid presence with the UK having the largest share with McVities, Burtons, Fox’s and Walkers being its most prominent players. Singapore has a sizeable biscuit producer, Khong Guan, which is involved in this segment, although its clientele are reported to be older Singaporeans. Another key producer, Meiji Seika, operates in the children’s area of the biscuit market. A market with strong and well supported brands dominated by Quaker (China), Nestlé (Philippines), Kellogg’s (Thailand and the USA) and Post (USA). Singapore does not produce breakfast cereals. A market with brands supported by very strong distribution capabilities. Extruded snacks dominate the market with well over 75% of sales. The companies/ brands involved include Kraft Foods (Malaysia), Mamee Double Decker (Malaysia), URC (Malaysia), Pringles (Malaysia), Calbee (Thailand and Malaysia) and Frito-Lay (USA and Mexico). Most snacks marketed under Singapore owned brands are now produced in neighboring Malaysia. French fries and hash browns are marketed under Singapore private labels, e.g. Farmland (U.S. origin), with Ore Ida (USA) and McCain (Canada) also have quite strong distribution access to retailers. Not produced in Singapore. The highest profile brands in supermarkets and hypermarkets today are now retailer in-house branded products. Thailand is a niche player in frozen green soybeans. Simplot (various origins), Emborg (Belgium/EU), and Watties (NZ) are the highest profile independent brands. Singapore is not producing any frozen vegetables. Asian sourced fruit juices tend to be food service products or juice drinks. The USA is the leader in chilled retail-packed fruit juices, due to high quality products, strong brands and very good distribution coverage. Singapore has a strong industry involved in the production of fruit juices, including Fraser & Neave, Malaysia Dairy Industries and Pokka Singapore, all aggressively competing for market share. Canned and bottled vegetables Sauces, nonAsian types Soups Soft drinks Beer Wine, not sparkling China – 26% USA – 19% Thailand – 16% Malaysia – 14% Italy – 8% Spain – 4% USA – 72% Australia – 9% UK – 5% Netherlands – 4% Italy – 2% Malaysia – 55% Australia – 16% USA – 11% Malaysia – 59% Thailand – 9% Taiwan – 6% China – 3% New Zealand – 2% USA – 1% Malaysia – 33% Germany – 10% Netherlands – 10% India – 9% South Korea – 9% Other ASEAN – 5% USA – 1% Australia – 31% France – 26% Chile – 9% Italy – 7% New Zealand – 6% USA – 6% FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 21 China and Thailand have a focus on canned indigenous vegetables. The USA has a strong niche due to good relationships with strong importer-distributors. Malaysia is mainly supplying baked beans. Although Singapore does have a canning industry, it is not involved in this market. Heinz (USA) has a sizeable portfolio of nonAsian sauces on the shelves, along with strong presence from a range of Australian made sauces (including Unilever and Masterfoods), the UK (Lea & Perrins) and Netherlands (HP). Singapore’s industry only produces Asian-type sauces. Campbell Soups (Malaysia and USA) dominate this market, with some competition from Heinz, mainly from Australia. No retail packed soups are produced in Singapore. Malaysia dominates imports with supplies of good quality cordials, fruit juices, sports drinks and Asian soft drinks at very competitive prices, with Fraser & Neave a major importer from Malaysia. Taiwan has a focus on supplying niche Asian-type products, with Yeo Hiap Seng contract packing some of these products there. Imports from the USA and other non-Asian countries operate in very small niches. Singapore has a very strong soft drink industry, which includes Coca-Cola, Pepsico (Yeo Hiap Seng as the bottler) and Pokka. The products of these producers lead the market. Carlsberg (Malaysia) holds second place in the market to the local brewery. The other brands play around the brands of APB and Carlsberg and tend to compete on price or on premium niche status, because they do not have the marketing budgets or the very strong distribution channels of the market leaders. Germany and Netherlands maintain a sizeable presence due to good relationships with strong importer-distributors. South Korea and India are niche players, with India now making a “big play” in the budget and strong beer areas of the market. Asia Pacific Breweries (APB) leads the Singapore market with its high profile and very well distributed brands, withTiger, Heineken, Guinness, Anchor, ABC Extra Stout, plus some niche brands. It competes very aggressively for market share with Carlsberg Malaysia, which also views Singapore as its home market territory. Australia dominates the retail market with a range of products that segment it from “mass market” (very well distributed) to premium. In the mass market, its main competitors are South American and some U.S. wineries. In the premium area, its main competitors are France (subject to high profile promotions), which has a broad range of products, along with niche players like New Zealand, U.S. premium labels Singapore does not produce any grape-based wines. and some other EU countries. Spirits, including brandy, whisky, rum, gin, vodka and liqueurs Pet food in retail packaging UK – 57% France – 25% USA – 4% Ireland - 4% Sweden – 2% Thailand – 35% USA – 34% Australia – 10% Netherlands – 5% UK (Scotland) whisky and French cognac owned by multinationals continue to dominate the market for spirits in an environment where intensive promotion is taking place for vodka and some liqueurs. Other products operate within niches. Although repacking of UK produced whisky is reported on-going in Singapore, it does not produce any alcoholic drinks that compete in this market. This market is dominated by the products of two multinationals, namely Mars Pet Food and Nestle Purina Pet Food that have plants in Thailand and the other supply countries, i.e. the USA for Nestle Purina, that service demand in Singapore. Singapore does not produce any retail packed pet foods. Source: USDA, Singapore Import Statistics 5.1.4. Challenges Singapore has a maturing retail food retail market which is growing but not at a rate as in the past decade. In the supermarket sector, growth is expected to be modest and retailers have resorted to giving discounts to attract consumers. Investment is also likely to focus increasingly on upgrading existing outlets. Commodity food and beverage products that are poorly differentiated or are not well supported by marketing activities in retail channels are facing challenges. Under current weak economic conditions, the market for staples is also weak and mature. For new product launches, marketing and distribution costs are extremely high. There are also high costs involved when companies strive to maintain their market shares and positions. Global changes in commodity and freight prices directly impact retail food sales, and this is a concern for Singapore as it imports most of its food products and Singaporeans are generally price-sensitive. This is especially during periods of economic uncertainty and downturns. A number of other issues pose challenges for the sector. These include global economic uncertainty and downturn elsewhere such as in Europe, slowing US economy, slowing exports, increasing food commodity and crude oil prices, the strong dollar and imported inflation. Singapore consumer confidence also ranges from being neutral to a growing pessimism. Retailers reported a low level of consumer confidence in 2012, as a result of weaker economic conditions. Trade sources reported that Singapore’s lack of consumer confidence has resulted in many consumers becoming involved in “bargain hunting / seeking” in retail channels. According to a Nielsen survey of online shopping in Singapore, almost 60% of Singapore’s online shoppers did so to seek bargains, unlike in the rest of the Asia Pacific region where the average is only around 40%. Retailers have confirmed this trait by revealing that for some food categories, the bulk of sales are being made only during a price promotion. In many cases, the brand being promoted sells in high volumes. 5.1.5. Players The key retail channels are supermarket chains and hypermarkets. They control almost 80 percent of the total retail market. In Singapore, there are three major groups that operate these supermarkets and hypermarkets. They are: The Dairy Farm Group FairPrice Group Sheng Siong Detailed background information on these three groups has been included in Chapter 6 of this report. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 22 The reach and sales of the 3 main retailers in Singapore Retailer Names & Ownership Outlet Types Annual Sales in US$ No. of Outlets Locations FairPrice (Local Cooperative) Supermarkets & Hypermarket $2,033 million FairPrice Xtra (Hypermarket) – 5 FairPrice Finest (High end supermarket) – 10 FairPrice Supermarket – 96 FairPrice Express & Cheers (Convenience stores) – 100+ Island wide Cold Storage group* and Giant (Owned by DFI, a Hong Kong based listed company) Supermarkets and hypermarket $1,510 million Cold Storage supermarkets – 48 The Market Place (High end supermarket) – 7 Giant (Hypermarket) – 7 Giant (Supermarket**) - 61 Island wide Sheng Siong Supermarket Supermarkets $462 million 25 stores, mainly supermarkets. Island wide Note: (*) The Cold Storage group of supermarkets also includes Jason’s and The Market Place banners (**) As of April 1, 2013, all Shop n Save shops had been re-branded to Giant. Source: Singapore Retail Food Annual Report 2012 – USDA Gain Report While these three groups dominate the supermarket / hypermarket sector, there are independent supermarkets present in Singapore as well. Among them are Prime Supermarkets, which has 19 stores located throughout the island. Unlike the 3 chains mentioned earlier, Prime’s stores are more like mini-supermarkets, and do not carry as wide a range of products as the bigger chains. They, too, target the low or low middle-income consumers. Isetan and Meidi-Ya are two well-known independent operated supermarket stores with only one outlet each which primarily targets the upper middle income groups and the Japanese community in Singapore. Both import Japanese products directly from Japan as well as locally from Singapore based importers. Mustafa Department Store is another company that operates its own supermarket which sells products sourced globally as well as of Indian origin and also offers a wide range of products to customers. This channel is often used by importers to sell products that face greater challenges being sold through other more mainstream retail channels. Another channel for retail sales will be convenience stores or traditional stores. These stores are located throughout the country, and in the case of convenience stores, in petrol stations as well. These two types of retailers hold a combined approximately 18 percent of the market share. They typically cater to the low and low middle income consumers, or in the case of convenience stores, fast moving products like bread and snack foods. They would not necessarily be a prime channel for Swiss exporters. 5.2. SPECIALTY AND GOURMET STORES Specialty stores in Singapore selling fine foods at higher prices than large retailers are usually independent single outlet butcheries, wine shops and bakeries. These stores are exclusive, target high income consumers and hold 1% of the market share. Singapore has seen an increase in demand for gourmet products over the last 5 years. This can be attributed to an increasing number of sophisticated diners with discerning palates and rising affluence. Singaporeans are becoming more cosmopolitan, well-travelled and knowledgeable about gourmet produce and products. At the same time, a number of new upscale FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 23 restaurants offering premium food products have also appeared on the scene. The market has responded with the sprouting of new stores and product lines expansion in the gourmet sector. Currently, there are at more than 14 standalone gourmet food retailers and chains with stock of between 100 to over 2,000 products, ranging from truffle oil and fleur de sel, to specialty olives, artisan preserves and boutique pastas. These stores exclude supermarkets, organic markets and online retailers offering gourmet products. Some of the well-known specialty stores frequented by Singapore’s highest income consumer segment are: Culina Cut the Mustard Da Paolo Dean & DeLuca Four Seasons Gourmet Market Hediard Huber’s Butchery & Bistro Jones, the Grocer Le Bon Marche Little Provence Oh Deli Spanish Delicatessen The German Market Place The Swiss Butchery 5.3. ORGANIC & NATURAL FOODS The organic food market in Singapore is small. According to statistics recently obtained by Euromonitor, the retail value of organic products was somewhere in the value of S$11 million. Packaged food took up over 90% of this value, with rice the biggest contributor within this sub-category at about 75%. In terms of growth, however, baby food seemed to show the biggest increase. Market Size of Organic Food & Beverages in Singapore (2007 – 2012, S$ ‘000) Subcategory 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Historic PGrowth % Historic CAGR% Organic Beverages 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 37 6.5 Organic Packaged Food 7.1 7.8 8.3 9.1 9.5 10.1 41.6 7.2 Organic Baby Food 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.7 0.8 0.9 178.8 22.8 Organic Bakery Products 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.6 0.6 23.8 4.4 Organic Frozen Processed Food Excluding Ready Meals, Pizza, Soup and Noodles 0.1 0.2 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 8.4 1.6 Organic Oils and Fats 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 35.5 6.3 Organic Pasta 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 26.7 4.8 Organic Rice 5.9 6.1 6.5 6.9 7.2 7.6 28.1 5.1 Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 24 As far back as five years ago, such products were primarily bought by expatriates who could afford the higher cost of such products. But with the increasing awareness of the worldwide organic movement, growing publicity within the local media about the link between illnesses and potential dangers in pesticides, hormones, chemicals and genetic modifications, and the drop in price of organic and natural foods, the market for organic and natural foods has grown significantly. Previously sold in small grocery stores, organic produce is increasingly available in specialist organic supermarkets and mini marts. Even the mainstream supermarkets – NTUC FairPrice, for instance – are sporting shelves dedicated to organic produce. Perhaps the most telling sign of its growing popularity and acceptance is the shift in distribution channels for organic foods from smaller, specialist retailers to larger supermarket chains and hypermarts, mirroring trends in the UK and U.S. Singapore still imports almost all its organic food. There is no organic certification program within the country, and there is very little organic food grown locally. Consumers are dependent on the certification system established by the country of import. According to the Victorian Government Department of Primary Industries, Australia is the major importer of fresh organic food into Singapore. Its biggest competitor is New Zealand. The USA dominates the processed organic food market. The reason these countries dominate the market is because their countries have well-established systems of organic food certification. Currently, there are over 30 organic shops and 4 supermarket chains selling organic products. There are also restaurants that claim to offer organic menus. Examples of some well-known specialist stores include: Brown Rice Paradise – Like the name suggests, they offer a variety of gluten/wheat/dairy-free products and organic food, and all kinds of brown and otherwise exotic rice (Origin’s organic wild rice blend goes for S$8.90 per kilo). Eat Organic – among their range of products are organic chocolate bars, such as Green & Black’s dark chocolate 85% (S$6.50) and Loving Earth’s crunchy mint raw dark chocolate (S$11.50) Four Seasons Organic Market – One of the largest health food chains in Singapore selling certified organic brands like Yes Natural, Sunview and Organic Harvest. Some of their products include healthy snacks: organic rice chips (S$3.40), organic brown rice rings (S$2.10) and organic corn cakes (S$3.50). SunnyChoice – They offer over 2,000 items in-store ranging from freshly-baked organic bread (from S$5) to organic meat (from S$35 per kilo). SuperNature – Another major organic and health food store selling a variety of products. Brands they sell include Doves Farm cereal flakes (S$11 for 375g) or McCann’s quick and easy steel-cut Irish oatmeal (S$9 for 454g). This store is very popular among those looking for home delivery. While there are many opportunities for the imports of organic products like fruits, vegetables, rice and grain, the main opportunity for Swiss exporters would be in the processed food sector. Though there are already many imports within this food category, opportunities are still there in certain categories, especially organic baby food products, or natural foods like blueberries, wheat germ and flax seeds for their high nutrients. While the organic market may be small, the natural healthy foods market is significantly bigger, with a retail value of under S$200 million. For the purposes of this report, this category includes food and beverages on the basis of naturally containing a substance that improves health and wellbeing beyond the product’s pure calorific value. These products are usually a healthier alternative within a certain sector/subsector. Products included are: naturally healthy high fiber food, soy products, sour milk drinks, nuts, honey fruit snacks, granola / muesli bars, fruit bars, olive oil and olive oil spreads within NH food and 100% fruit/vegetable juice, super fruit juice (including cranberry juice), natural mineral water, spring water, cereal/pulse-based drinks, other Asian specialty drinks, RTD green tea, other naturally healthy RTD tea (e.g. RTD oolong tea) green tea, herbal tea, other naturally healthy tea, malt-based hot drinks, and other plant-based hot drinks. While many of these products are FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 25 marketed on a health basis, this might not always be the case. Naturally healthy foods that are additionally fortified have been categorized within the 'fortified/functional' category. Juices, tea, nuts and breads are the biggest value added products within the natural foods category. Market Size of Natural Food & Beverages (2007 – 2012; S$ ‘000) Subcategory 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Historic PGrowth% Historic CAGR% NH Fruit/Herbal Tea 6.78 6.89 7.27 7.58 7.72 8.07 19.00 3.54 NH Green Tea 8.88 8.75 8.91 8.92 8.78 9.06 2.11 0.42 NH Other Tea 2.65 2.57 2.61 2.57 2.48 2.52 -4.97 -1.01 NH Natural Mineral Water 11.98 11.33 11.31 11.17 11.07 11.09 -7.44 -1.53 NH Spring Water 5.96 5.78 5.76 5.66 5.59 5.60 -6.04 -1.24 NH 100% Juice 35.38 35.51 36.39 36.71 36.68 36.79 3.97 0.78 NH Superfruit Juice 11.06 11.26 11.88 12.11 12.08 12.23 10.61 2.04 NH RTD Green Tea 29.75 33.15 35.42 37.01 38.27 39.22 31.84 5.68 NH High Fiber Biscuits 1.36 1.34 2.30 2.50 2.63 2.71 98.88 14.74 NH High Fiber Bread 22.61 25.12 25.54 25.44 24.88 25.13 11.12 2.13 NH High Fiber Breakfast Cereals 2.37 2.42 2.54 2.60 2.57 2.60 9.98 1.92 NH Soy Milk 9.65 9.56 9.74 9.85 9.78 9.91 2.61 0.52 NH Soy-based Chilled and Shelf Stable Desserts 0.73 0.73 0.85 0.91 0.93 0.98 33.87 6.01 Source: Euromonitor International 5.4. FUNCTIONAL FOODS Functional foods are foods that may provide health benefits beyond basic nutrition. This simple definition is also in accordance with the major selling proposition for functional foods, where functional foods enable the consumer to lead a healthier life without changing eating habits. Based on this definition, functional food products are a non-homogeneous food category; it has expanded to all segments of the food and drink market. They include packaged food and beverages products where the amount of a substance considered to be less healthy (fat, sugar, salt, carbohydrates) has been actively reduced during production. It includes gluten-free, lactose-free and diabetic food. It also includes fortified food and beverages. Due to the complex nature of nutraceuticals and its links to medicines, nutraceutical products can be defined as either food or drugs, depending on their nature, characteristics and effects on consumers. As a result, nutraceutical products can also be considered as functional foods in Singapore due to its ambiguous nature. Functional foods and drinks surfaced in the local market during 1990s when local producers and ASEAN-based multinational food companies competed to introduce new product lines to create new niches, capitalizing on the emerging health trends at that time and market expansion (Stanton, Emms & Sia, 2011). These companies include Nestlé, Danone, Unilever, Kellogg, and Quaker Oats. Today, healthy living is an increasingly important part of the food market and food marketing. Some of commercial products available in the local market include: FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 26 Types Probiotics Description Brand Producer Milk drink containing Lactobacillus Casei Shirota Yakult Japan Vitagen Malaysia Milk Functional Drink Enriched sport drinks with vitamins Gatorade Pepsico Fortified Drink Orange juice contains dietary fiber and vitamins Sunkist 100% Orange Juice F&N Cereal Low fat whole grain breakfast cereal with minerals and vitamins Nestlé Bakery product Wholemeal bread with beta-glucan for cholesterol Gardenia Enriched range of crackers from high fiber, low salt, oat-based Jacob’s Kraft Note: Information compiled through market observations from local hypermarkets and manufacturers’ corporate websites. The market for functional foods is growing steadily worldwide, is intensely competitive and many new products are launched continuously. A report by the Agri-Food Trade Service in 2009 indicates that the annual growth rate for functional foods globally is between about 8% to 14%, but the exact size is difficult to really determine. Singapore seems to offer an attractive functional food and beverage niche as consumers buy more health and wellness products, in tandem with the significant growing trend within Singapore towards healthy eating. The Singapore government, through the Health Promotion Board (HPB), has been working with the food industry to introduce more nutritious meal options for consumers. Customers are advised to seek out the ‘Healthier Choice’ logo, which is awarded to menu items that meet the Health Boards criteria e.g. reduced sugar/salt or added fruit/vegetables. More consumers are paying attention to the labeling on packaged products. The significant segments include infant and other milk formulas, dairy-based drinks, energy drinks, sport drinks, fruit juices, drinks with Asian herbs, cereals, energy bars, biscuits, baked products, and eggs with Omega-3. For example, a significant number of senior citizens have opted to purchase wholegrain food items, low-fat dairy products and enriched bread, as healthier alternatives. Singaporeans are also willing to sacrifice taste in favor of health benefits, and as a result, sales of low-fat and low-sugar products have grown significantly. This trend can mainly be seen with dairy products including cheese, milk, yogurt, and ice-cream. Health conscious consumers are demanding non-carbonated drinks with low-sugar content, such as bottled water, bottled tea and fruit and vegetable juices. Purchases of these products grew by 26% over the past four years. Parents are more willing to purchase quality food items for their children, such as food products with enhanced nutritional qualities. The most popular are DHA-enriched milk formula, salmon, organic cereals and fish oil. Typically, functional foods available to Singapore consumers are distributed through modern trades. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 27 Market Size of Functional Food & Beverages (2007 – 2012, in S$ ‘000) Subcategory 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Historic PGrowth% Historic CAGR% FF Chocolate-based Flavored Powder Drinks 0.07 0.07 0.08 0.08 0.09 0.09 25.16 4.59 FF Plant-based and Maltbased Hot Drinks 54.16 53.60 54.60 55.45 55.30 57.17 5.56 1.09 FF Juice Drinks (up to 24% Juice) 20.21 20.53 21.17 21.11 20.29 20.09 -0.61 -0.12 FF Nectars (25-99% Juice) 26.19 30.40 33.08 35.18 34.30 34.40 31.36 5.61 FF Sugar-free Chewing Gum 1.85 1.76 1.77 1.65 1.41 1.28 -30.45 -7.01 FF Reduced Fat Milk 28.76 27.94 28.15 28.59 28.52 29.24 1.68 0.33 FF Drinking Yoghurt 43.05 44.85 49.04 51.99 53.60 55.48 28.86 5.20 FF Spoonable Yoghurt 2.40 2.40 2.66 2.70 2.67 2.70 12.86 2.45 Source: Euromonitor International 5.5. PROCESSED / PACKAGED FOODS Processed foods cover a very wide category, so for the purposes of this report, information on the frozen and dried processed food, ready meals, and sauces and condiments, have been included in the report. 5.5.1. Frozen Processed Food There is a stable demand for frozen processed food in Singapore due to the convenience of these products as well as their long shelf life and nutritious content compared to products in chilled processed food. Within this category, frozen processed poultry, frozen processed vegetables and frozen pizza have shown the strongest retail value growth of 3% each in frozen processed food in 2012. Private label manufacturers have also made efforts to extend their product ranges in frozen processed food, in particular in frozen processed vegetables, in which they offer a wide range of products at appealing prices. Due to the tropical climate in Singapore, fresh vegetables deteriorate quickly. Also local consumers tend not to eat uncooked vegetables as they prefer cooked vegetables due to food safety. Therefore, products in frozen processed vegetables are very convenient for them due to a longer shelf life than fresh vegetables and the wide range of products available. Burgers continue to account for a dominant retail value share of frozen processed red meat of as much as 91%. Other frozen processed red meat includes beef steak such as sirloin and rib eye steak and beef and pork sausages. In frozen processed poultry, sausages account for the largest retail value share of 39%. Vegetable mix accounts for the largest current retail value share, of 37%, of frozen processed vegetables followed by garden peas, corn and green soybeans. Other frozen processed vegetables include spinach, broccoli and sliced carrots, among others. Due to the convenience of these products, the wide range of products available and their nutritional content, the popularity of frozen processed vegetables has increased among consumers. Due to the hectic lifestyles of consumers in Singapore, demand for convenience and healthy products is expected to be the key driver of growth in packaged food. Frozen processed food offers convenience and nutritional value; thus, demand for frozen processed food is expected to be stable. The major distribution channels of frozen processed food are expected to remain supermarkets and hypermarkets as these retailers are the only retailers that possess large scale freezer storage and which thus have the capacity to store a wide range of FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 28 frozen products. Also various major supermarkets and hypermarkets retailers in Singapore have launched websites as a result of which internet retailing of frozen processed food is expected to register growth over the forecast period due to convenience. Sales of Frozen Processed Food by Volume (2007 – 2012, in tons) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Frozen Bakery 634.66 647.35 634.40 637.58 642.68 649.10 Frozen Desserts 233.98 239.82 236.23 243.31 248.91 253.89 Frozen Meat Substitutes 8.80 8.90 9.10 9.20 9.30 9.40 Frozen Pizza 80.07 82.87 84.11 86.21 87.94 89.35 Frozen Processed Fish/Seafood 2,557.22 2,659.51 2,712.70 2,780.52 2,844.47 2,901.36 Frozen Processed Potatoes 1,640.44 1,689.66 1,731.90 1,783.86 1,828.45 1,865.02 - Non-Oven Frozen Potatoes 1,640.44 1,689.66 1,731.90 1,783.86 1,828.45 1,865.02 Frozen Processed Poultry 2,672.00 2,805.60 2,917.83 2,976.18 3,029.75 3,078.23 Frozen Processed Red Meat 414.59 424.95 454.70 477.44 484.12 490.41 Frozen Processed Vegetables 186.30 191.89 194.76 198.66 203.82 208.51 72.51 74.69 76.18 77.32 78.87 80.37 424.67 437.41 439.60 448.39 452.88 456.95 8,925.24 9,262.66 9,491.52 9,718.67 9,911.20 10,082.60 Frozen Ready Meals Other Frozen Processed Food Frozen Processed Food Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Frozen Processed Food by Value (2007 – 2012, S$ million) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Frozen Bakery 5.20 5.39 5.23 5.28 5.34 5.42 Frozen Desserts 2.99 3.11 3.08 3.19 3.27 3.34 Frozen Meat Substitutes 0.19 0.19 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 Frozen Pizza 1.82 1.92 1.96 2.03 2.09 2.14 Frozen Processed Fish/Seafood 27.96 29.36 29.80 30.70 31.56 32.31 Frozen Processed Potatoes 4.95 5.27 5.37 5.51 5.63 5.73 - Non-Oven Frozen Potatoes 4.95 5.27 5.37 5.51 5.63 5.73 Frozen Processed Poultry 29.75 31.54 32.33 32.81 33.44 34.27 Frozen Processed Red Meat 5.11 5.27 5.53 5.69 5.78 5.86 Frozen Processed Vegetables 1.04 1.07 1.08 1.12 1.15 1.18 Frozen Ready Meals 2.09 2.18 2.23 2.28 2.33 2.39 Other Frozen Processed Food 6.74 7.04 7.11 7.29 7.40 7.49 Frozen Processed Food 87.85 92.33 93.91 96.08 98.18 100.33 Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 29 Sales of Frozen Processed Food by Volume Growth (2007 – 2012, % volume growth) 2011/12 2007-12 CAGR Category 2007/12 Total Frozen Bakery 1.00 0.45 2.28 Frozen Desserts 2.00 1.65 8.51 Frozen Meat Substitutes 1.08 1.33 6.82 Frozen Pizza 1.60 2.22 11.59 Frozen Processed Fish/Seafood 2.00 2.56 13.46 Frozen Processed Potatoes 2.00 2.60 13.69 - Non-Oven Frozen Potatoes 2.00 2.60 13.69 Frozen Processed Poultry 1.60 2.87 15.20 Frozen Processed Red Meat 1.30 3.42 18.29 Frozen Processed Vegetables 2.30 2.28 11.92 Frozen Ready Meals 1.90 2.08 10.84 Other Frozen Processed Food 0.90 1.48 7.60 Frozen Processed Food 1.73 2.47 12.97 Source: Euromonitor International 5.6. DRIED PROCESSED FOOD According to trade sources, while rice is the fundamental staple food among Asian consumers in Singapore, consumption of rice has gradually decreased due to the increasing popularity of alternative staple foods such as noodles, bread and dried pasta. The high level of availability of convenient alternative products such as noodles and dried pasta has made rice less attractive to some consumers. Due to their hectic lifestyles, many Singaporean consumers seek quick and easy meals. Rice is considered to be more time consuming to cook at home than bread, noodles and dried pasta. However, rice is expected to continue to account for by far the largest retail value share of dried processed food in 2012. In response to the growing trend of health consciousness, manufacturers have introduced a wider range of products such as brown rice and organic rice, which appeal to health-conscious consumers. In 2012, pouch instant noodles achieved the strongest current retail value growth, of 8%, in dried processed food. Products in pouch instant noodles are well accepted by local consumers, more so than products in cup instant noodles, due to their price positioning, with the offer of multipacks, and the wide range of flavor variants. Manufacturers of pouch instant noodles have also made continuous efforts to introduce new flavor variants, such as Korean flavor variants among others, in order to constantly appeal to consumers. Supermarkets are expected to remain the leading channel of retail distribution of dried processed food. This is mainly due to the wide selection of products in various price categories and the high level of availability of products through this channel. Also various supermarket retailers offer private label products which are expected to continue to appeal to consumers due to their very affordable pricing. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 30 Sales of Dried Processed Food by Volume (2007 – 2012, in ‘000 tons) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Dehydrated Soup 0.08 0.07 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.05 Dessert Mixes 0.03 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 Dried Pasta 1.98 2.06 2.17 2.24 2.31 2.37 Dried Ready Meals 0.13 0.13 0.14 0.14 0.14 0.15 Instant Noodles 8.25 8.59 9.04 9.42 9.78 10.21 - Cups/Bowl Instant Noodles 1.32 1.38 1.43 1.47 1.51 1.57 - Pouch Instant Noodles 6.93 7.21 7.61 7.95 8.27 8.64 Instant Soup 0.10 0.10 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.12 Plain Noodles 1.95 2.01 2.04 2.08 2.14 2.19 Rice 108.25 110.41 113.18 114.87 116.37 118.00 Dried Processed Food 120.77 123.43 126.77 128.96 130.94 133.12 Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Dried Processed Food by Value (2007 – 2012, in S$ million) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Dehydrated Soup 1.64 1.60 1.41 1.23 1.17 1.12 Dessert Mixes 0.55 0.58 0.58 0.60 0.61 0.62 Dried Pasta 8.31 8.93 9.25 9.62 9.95 10.28 Dried Ready Meals 2.56 2.64 2.73 2.80 2.86 2.93 Instant Noodles 43.13 48.75 56.75 65.68 70.87 76.28 - Cups/Bowl Instant Noodles 16.66 18.58 21.00 23.63 25.19 26.95 - Pouch Instant Noodles 26.47 30.18 35.75 42.05 45.68 49.33 Instant Soup 3.59 3.80 3.92 4.06 4.18 4.29 Plain Noodles 7.43 7.88 8.03 8.27 8.55 8.85 Rice 203.73 295.40 299.83 305.83 311.34 316.32 Dried Processed Food 270.94 369.59 382.50 398.08 409.52 420.70 Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 31 Sales of Dried Processed Food by Volume Growth (2007 – 2012, % volume growth) 2011/12 2007-12 CAGR Category 2007/12 Total Dehydrated Soup -3.50 -7.00 -30.42 Dessert Mixes 1.50 2.25 11.79 Dried Pasta 2.80 3.66 19.67 Dried Ready Meals 2.20 2.14 11.16 Instant Noodles 4.42 4.34 23.67 - Cups/Bowl Instant Noodles 4.00 3.50 18.75 - Pouch Instant Noodles 4.50 4.50 24.61 Instant Soup 2.30 3.17 16.91 Plain Noodles 2.70 2.44 12.80 Rice 1.40 1.74 9.00 Dried Processed Food 1.67 1.97 10.23 Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Dried Processed Food by Value Growth (2007 – 2012, % current value growth) 2011/12 2007-12 CAGR Category Dehydrated Soup 2007/12 Total -4.00 -7.31 -31.57 Dessert Mixes 1.70 2.53 13.30 Dried Pasta 3.30 4.35 23.72 Dried Ready Meals 2.50 2.74 14.47 Instant Noodles 7.64 12.08 76.86 - Cups/Bowl Instant Noodles 7.00 10.09 61.73 - Pouch Instant Noodles 8.00 13.26 86.37 Instant Soup 2.80 3.65 19.65 Plain Noodles 3.50 3.55 19.06 Rice 1.60 9.20 55.27 Dried Processed Food 2.73 9.20 55.28 Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 32 5.7. READY MEALS IN SINGAPORE As the lifestyles of Singaporean consumers become increasingly hectic due to economic growth, consumers have more and more sought easy and convenient meal options in order to save time and ready meals have benefited from this trend. However, at the same time, the extensive range of foodservice outlets such as hawker centers, street stalls/kiosks and home delivery/takeaway means that consumers have easy access to prepared meals that they can take home instead of buying products in ready meals to prepare at home. That is why ready meals have only achieved an average retail value growth of 2% and an average retail volume growth of 2% in 2012. However, current retail value growth is expected to be slightly stronger than retail volume growth. The main reason for this is that consumers like to try innovative new products in ready meals, which often have high prices due to value-added factors such as ease of opening and microwavable packaging among other things. Dried ready meals and frozen pizza registered the strongest retail value growth of 3% and 3% respectively in ready meals in 2012. There is an extensive range of products, in various flavor variants, size formats and price bands available in these categories. Private label manufacturers have also been aggressive in terms of introducing new products and flavor variants in frozen pizza, which has resulted in more choice for consumers and which has made frozen pizza more dynamic. With regard to dried ready meals, dried porridge and dried pasta and sauce are popular among busy consumers due to the ease and convenience of these products. Chilled ready meals are expected to register the weakest current retail value growth in ready meals. As there are many foodservice outlets across Singapore, chilled ready meals are not very attractive to Singaporean consumers. In addition, these products have a relatively short shelf life, and are expensive. Frozen ready meals tend to be more popular among consumers than chilled ready meals due to the former’s longer shelf life. Italian ready meals and western ready meals continue to account for a dominant combined retail value share of 74% of frozen ready meals in 2012, with this share remaining unchanged since 2010. However, Japanese ready meals have increased their retail value share of frozen ready meals in 2012 as Singaporean consumers have become more familiar with Japanese cuisine especially as the number of Japanese foodservice outlets expanded in Singapore over the review period. On the other hand, Chinese ready meals have suffered a decrease in retail value share of frozen ready meals in 2012 as consumers have started to explore other types of ethnic ready meals. International players account for strong retail value shares of frozen ready meals as they tend to offer western ready meals in this category. According to trade sources, Singaporean consumers also prefer to opt for products from international players in frozen ready meals due to the authenticity of these products. Domestic manufacturers account for strong retail value shares of canned/preserved ready meals as the preference of consumers tends to be for Asian ready meals in this category. Domestic players are more knowledgeable than international players in terms of the taste of Asian dishes and they are thus able to offer authentic flavors and products, which are familiar to consumers. With regard to distribution, supermarkets and hypermarkets account for a dominant combined retail value share of 73% of ready meals in 2012. This is because supermarkets and hypermarkets retailers engage in aggressive price promotions and they are able to store and offer an extensive range of ready meals products. This presents consumers with many options when choosing ready meals. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 33 Sales of Ready Meals by Volume (2007 – 2012, ‘000 tons) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 4,508.50 4,643.75 4,806.29 4,926.44 5,039.75 5,145.59 Chilled Ready Meals 263.47 225.26 214.00 209.72 210.35 211.19 Dried Ready Meals 131.69 134.33 138.36 140.43 143.24 146.39 Frozen Pizza 80.07 82.87 84.11 86.21 87.94 89.35 Frozen Ready Meals 72.51 74.69 76.18 77.32 78.87 80.37 5,056.24 5,160.90 5,318.93 5,440.13 5,560.15 5,672.88 Canned/Preserved Ready Meals Ready Meals Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Ready Meals by Value (2007 – 2012, S$ million) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Canned/Preserved Ready Meals 36.04 37.30 38.49 39.65 40.76 41.74 Chilled Ready Meals 2.48 2.13 2.01 1.95 1.95 1.96 Dried Ready Meals 2.56 2.64 2.73 2.80 2.86 2.93 Frozen Pizza 1.82 1.92 1.96 2.03 2.09 2.14 Frozen Ready Meals 2.09 2.18 2.23 2.28 2.33 2.39 Ready Meals 44.99 46.16 47.42 48.70 49.99 51.15 Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Ready Meals by Value Growth (2007 – 2012, % current value growth) 2011/12 2007-12 CAGR 2007/12 Total Canned/Preserved Ready Meals 2.40 2.98 15.81 Chilled Ready Meals 0.20 -4.59 -20.93 Dried Ready Meals 2.50 2.74 14.47 Frozen Pizza 2.50 3.29 17.59 Frozen Ready Meals 2.30 2.66 14.01 Ready Meals 2.32 2.60 13.70 Category Source: Euromonitor International Ready Meals: Vegetarian vs. Non-vegetarian % Breakdown by Type 2012 (% value analysis) Vegetarian Non-vegetarian Total Canned/Preserved Ready Meals 9.10 90.90 100.00 Chilled Ready Meals 3.70 96.30 100.00 Frozen Ready Meals 6.00 94.00 100.00 Category Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 34 Frozen Ready Meals % Breakdown by Ethnicity (2007 – 2012, % retail value resp) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Chinese 12.00 12.00 11.50 11.50 11.00 10.50 Italian 46.00 46.00 46.50 46.00 46.00 46.00 Japanese 7.50 7.50 8.00 9.00 10.00 10.50 Western 27.50 27.50 27.50 27.50 27.50 27.50 Others 7.00 7.00 6.50 6.00 5.50 5.50 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 Total Source: Euromonitor International 5.8. SAUCES, DRESSINGS AND CONDIMENTS IN SINGAPORE The performance of sauces, dressings and condiments in 2012 remained the same compared to 2011. This is mainly due to the unclear global economic condition in 2012, which made consumers reduce their daily spend on grocery items. This was also reflected in the performance of foodservice outlets, which saw slower growth than in 2011. However, compared to other developed countries, the demand in this category remained stable. Wet/cooking sauces saw the fastest value growth of 5% to reach S$14 million in 2012. Due to hectic lifestyles in Singapore, consumers are seeking convenient formats rather than making a sauce from scratch, which led the strong performance in 2012. There are also varieties of flavors of wet cooking sauce available, which leaves little incentive for consumers to prepare a sauce themselves. Busy consumers are willing to pay extra for easy preparation. Soya sauce, wasabi and hoisin sauce are the most popular due to their Asian flavor. On the other hand, western types of sauce, such as garlic, herb purees and Tahini etc. have a presence at high-end supermarkets such as Market Place, and are often considered to be non-essential items among local consumers. Hence, the demand is likely to be limited to foreign expatriates and affluent consumers. Pasta sauce is also expected to see a better performance, with a 2% constant value CAGR. Pasta has become one of the major staple foods, following rice and noodles, for which pasta sauce has contributed to the sales performance of pasta as the manufacturers have introduced a wide variety of flavors. The fast casual dining restaurants such as Pasta Mania have also made pasta familiar to local consumers. Due to the popularity of pasta, pasta sauce is likely to gain further shares over the forecast period. Since the Singaporean government is currently promoting a healthier diet to the nation, low-calorie and low cholesterol mayonnaise and dressing are expected to see room for expansion. The main distribution channels for sauces, dressings and condiments are supermarkets, hypermarkets and small grocery retailers, which will not see a big change in share over the forecast period. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 35 Sales of Sauces, Dressings and Condiments by Volume (2007 – 2012, in tons) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Cooking Sauces 2,927.77 3,067.54 3,154.62 3,244.23 3,360.38 3,471.55 - Bouillon/Stock Cubes 1,163.69 1,203.63 1,242.99 1,274.76 1,311.59 1,346.52 - Dry Sauces/Powder Mixes 67.50 70.87 72.29 73.38 74.26 74.93 - Herbs and Spices 97.31 101.20 103.22 106.84 109.73 112.47 - Monosodium Glutamate (MSG) 331.01 339.28 342.68 349.53 354.42 358.32 - Pasta Sauces 224.38 235.60 248.55 260.49 272.18 281.68 1,043.89 1,116.96 1,144.89 1,179.23 1,238.20 1,297.63 602.67 608.70 617.83 625.86 632.12 637.18 Table Sauces 8,604.59 8,869.91 9,184.29 9,471.82 9,669.80 9,827.37 - Ketchup 1,091.62 1,118.91 1,141.28 1,169.82 1,193.21 1,212.30 - Mayonnaise 217.13 223.21 228.34 233.83 237.83 240.93 - Mustard 197.22 201.16 204.18 206.22 207.87 209.12 - Oyster Sauces 822.09 846.75 876.38 898.29 916.26 930.00 - Salad Dressings 331.66 343.95 352.88 363.81 372.23 378.92 - Soy Based Sauces 4,367.46 4,498.48 4,678.42 4,842.17 4,939.01 5,003.22 - Spicy Chili/Pepper Sauces 1,373.92 1,428.88 1,493.18 1,545.44 1,588.71 1,636.37 - Vinaigrettes 102.83 104.89 105.41 106.99 108.06 108.82 - Other Table Sauces 100.67 103.69 104.21 105.25 106.62 107.68 Tomato Pastes and Purées 13.20 13.46 13.53 13.73 13.90 13.99 Other Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 292.21 298.06 299.55 302.54 304.66 306.49 12,440.45 12,857.68 13,269.82 13,658.18 13,980.86 14,256.58 - Wet/Cooking Sauces Pickled Products Sauces, Dressings and Condiments Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 36 Sales of Sauces, Dressings and Condiments by Value (2007 – 2012, S$ million) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 27,154.30 28,685.00 29,364.36 30,212.16 31,434.42 32,617.11 - Bouillon/Stock Cubes 7,761.66 8,072.13 8,341.87 8,598.34 8,871.50 9,135.80 - Dry Sauces/Powder Mixes 2,059.64 2,172.92 2,205.51 2,227.57 2,245.39 2,267.84 - Herbs and Spices 2,489.80 2,601.84 2,627.86 2,746.89 2,823.80 2,897.22 - Monosodium Glutamate (MSG) 1,642.23 1,675.08 1,683.45 1,708.71 1,730.92 1,748.23 - Pasta Sauces 1,867.28 1,979.32 2,078.28 2,192.59 2,324.14 2,417.11 - Wet/Cooking Sauces 11,333.68 12,183.71 12,427.39 12,738.07 13,438.66 14,150.91 Pickled Products 4,431.04 4,497.50 4,542.48 4,610.62 4,647.50 4,680.03 44,365.94 46,029.35 47,200.23 48,598.30 49,885.09 50,994.57 - Ketchup 2,741.15 2,823.38 2,865.73 2,951.71 3,034.35 3,107.18 - Mayonnaise 1,758.23 1,821.62 1,848.94 1,902.77 1,956.22 2,003.87 - Mustard 2,485.23 2,515.06 2,540.21 2,560.53 2,575.89 2,593.92 - Oyster Sauces 5,785.52 5,988.01 6,077.83 6,248.01 6,435.45 6,564.16 - Salad Dressings 4,556.05 4,748.62 4,847.84 5,021.96 5,160.27 5,278.68 - Soy Based Sauces 19,064.95 19,827.55 20,521.52 21,137.16 21,729.00 22,228.77 - Spicy Chili/Pepper Sauces 5,237.57 5,499.45 5,664.43 5,891.01 6,067.74 6,261.91 - Vinaigrettes 1,723.96 1,767.06 1,784.73 1,820.43 1,842.27 1,857.01 - Other Table Sauces 1,013.28 1,038.61 1,048.99 1,064.73 1,083.89 1,099.07 73.94 75.79 76.55 77.47 78.17 78.79 Other Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 3,931.50 4,029.78 4,070.08 4,131.13 4,164.18 4,193.33 Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 79,956.72 83,317.43 85,253.70 87,629.68 90,209.36 92,563.84 Cooking Sauces Table Sauces Tomato Pastes and Purées Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 37 Sales of Sauces, Dressings and Condiments by Volume Growth (2007 – 2012, % volume growth) 2011/12 2007-12 CAGR Category 2007/12 Total Cooking Sauces 3.31 3.47 18.57 - Bouillon/Stock Cubes 2.66 2.96 15.71 - Dry Sauces/Powder Mixes 0.90 2.11 11.00 - Herbs and Spices 2.50 2.94 15.58 - Monosodium Glutamate (MSG) 1.10 1.60 8.25 - Pasta Sauces 3.49 4.65 25.54 - Wet/Cooking Sauces 4.80 4.45 24.31 Pickled Products 0.80 1.12 5.73 Table Sauces 1.63 2.69 14.21 - Ketchup 1.60 2.12 11.06 - Mayonnaise 1.31 2.10 10.96 - Mustard 0.60 1.18 6.03 - Oyster Sauces 1.50 2.50 13.13 - Salad Dressings 1.80 2.70 14.25 - Soy Based Sauces 1.30 2.76 14.56 - Spicy Chili/Pepper Sauces 3.00 3.56 19.10 - Vinaigrettes 0.70 1.14 5.82 - Other Table Sauces 1.00 1.36 6.97 Tomato Pastes and Purées 0.70 1.18 6.03 Other Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 0.60 0.96 4.89 Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 1.97 2.76 14.60 Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 38 Sales of Sauces, Dressings and Condiments by Value Growth (2007 – 2012, % value growth) Category 2011/12 2007-12 CAGR 2007/12 Total - Bouillon/Stock Cubes 3.76 3.73 20.12 - Dry Sauces/Powder Mixes 2.98 3.31 17.70 - Herbs and Spices 1.00 1.94 10.11 - Monosodium Glutamate (MSG) 2.60 3.08 16.36 - Pasta Sauces 1.00 1.26 6.45 - Wet/Cooking Sauces 4.00 5.30 29.45 Dips 5.30 4.54 24.86 Table Sauces 0.70 1.10 5.62 - Barbecue Sauces 2.22 2.82 14.94 - Mayonnaise 2.40 2.54 13.35 - Mustard 2.44 2.65 13.97 - Oyster Sauces 0.70 0.86 4.37 - Salad Dressings 2.00 2.56 13.46 - Soy Based Sauces 2.29 2.99 15.86 - Spicy Chili/Pepper Sauces 2.30 3.12 16.59 - Tartar Sauces 3.20 3.64 19.56 - Worcester/Steak Sauces 0.80 1.50 7.72 Tomato Pastes and Purées 1.40 1.64 8.47 Other Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 0.80 1.28 6.56 Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 0.70 1.30 6.66 Cooking Sauces Source: Euromonitor International 5.9. CHOCOLATE CONFECTIONARY In a reflection of the health and wellness trend, consumers are gradually moving towards reduced sugar chocolate confectionery as well as dark chocolate because of its antioxidant properties. In addition, there is also a trend towards premium high-quality chocolates as consumers develop a more sophisticated taste for chocolate and the know-how to appreciate premium chocolate products such as those with high cocoa content. Standard boxed assortments seemed to be the fastest growing category in 2012, as the trend of consumers indulging in premium chocolate has led to the growth of standard boxed assortments. In addition, the trend of gift giving during festive seasons such as Mother’s Day and Christmas also drove the growth of the standard boxed assortments sold at hypermarkets and supermarkets. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 39 Although consumers are increasingly purchasing reduced sugar chocolate confectionery, the organic chocolate trend has not taken off in Singapore, and organic chocolate products are expected to have little impact. The product offer remains small, with limited choice available only at selected supermarkets and health food shops. Chocolate confectionery is easily available via various distribution channels including hypermarkets, supermarkets and small grocery retailers. There is likely to be more boutique chocolate outlets, within the confectionery specialists’ category, opening in Singapore as consuming gourmet chocolates is expected to become part of the lifestyle of a growing number of consumers. There is also likely to be raising interest in healthier chocolates among consumers, who are becoming more conscious about their diet and nutritional intake. As such, there is expected to be raising sales for high cocoa content products which contain more antioxidants. Sales of Chocolate Confectionery by Volume (2007 – 2012, in tons) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Bagged Selflines/Softlines 902.12 920.16 947.77 966.72 984.12 1,008.73 Boxed Assortments 771.43 801.80 872.90 933.17 988.44 1,037.29 - Standard Boxed Assortments 755.29 785.51 856.20 916.14 971.10 1,019.66 - Twist Wrapped Miniatures 16.13 16.29 16.70 17.03 17.34 17.64 Chocolate with Toys 36.39 36.76 37.49 38.05 38.55 38.93 Countlines 1,319.85 1,352.84 1,393.43 1,449.17 1,499.89 1,550.88 Tablets 1,307.76 1,327.37 1,393.74 1,442.52 1,485.80 1,527.40 Chocolate Confectionery 4,337.54 4,438.93 4,645.33 4,829.63 4,996.80 5,163.24 Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Chocolate Confectionery by Value (2007 – 2012, in S$ million) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Bagged Selflines/Softlines 17.93 18.65 19.48 20.17 20.91 21.75 Boxed Assortments 29.36 31.40 34.81 37.92 41.41 45.03 - Standard Boxed Assortments 28.92 30.94 34.35 37.44 40.92 44.52 - Twist Wrapped Miniatures 0.44 0.46 0.46 0.48 0.49 0.50 Chocolate with Toys 1.95 1.99 2.05 2.11 2.18 2.25 Countlines 27.17 28.39 29.95 31.75 33.75 35.77 Tablets 20.82 21.55 23.38 25.02 26.52 28.16 Chocolate Confectionery 97.22 101.98 109.68 116.95 124.77 132.96 Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 40 5.10. BISCUITS Biscuits continue to experience a higher current value sales growth. This is largely due to consumers trading up to more expensive products and consumers preferring smaller pack sizes, which helps contribute to a higher value sales growth. Savory crackers and biscuits experienced the highest value sales growth, but as consumers become increasingly health conscious, more have become inclined towards savory crackers and biscuits such as wheatmeal biscuits as compared to sweet biscuits. Within sweet biscuits, filled biscuits registered the highest current value sales. One characteristic of the biscuit market in Singapore, unlike in temperate markets like Switzerland, is that while biscuits are generally packed in quantities of 200-300g, the biscuits are also individually wrapped within the main package in smaller quantities, rather than in loose packaging. Many biscuits are also individually packed, rather than in loose packaging. The primary reason for this is the higher temperature and humidity levels in Singapore, which requires packaging to ensure that these products have a longer shelf life. Sales of Biscuits by Volume (2007 – 2012, in tons) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Savory Biscuits and Crackers 4,818.06 4,914.42 5,037.28 5,238.77 5,395.94 5,530.83 Sweet Biscuits 12,461.84 12,694.55 12,582.60 12,955.58 13,270.25 13,560.03 896.11 921.20 944.23 958.39 982.35 1,004.94 -- Cookies 2,021.79 2,052.12 2,103.42 2,124.45 2,166.94 2,208.12 - Filled Biscuits 2,534.71 2,580.33 2,631.94 2,697.74 2,778.67 2,848.14 - Plain Biscuits 4,356.24 4,421.59 4,510.02 4,758.07 4,877.02 4,989.19 - Sandwich Biscuits 2,652.99 2,719.32 2,393.00 2,416.93 2,465.27 2,509.64 Biscuits 17,279.90 17,608.97 17,619.88 18,194.35 18,666.18 19,090.86 - Chocolate Coated Biscuits Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Biscuits by Value (2007 – 2012, in S$ million) Category 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Savory Biscuits and Crackers 45.22 46.57 48.21 49.65 51.39 53.44 Sweet Biscuits 125.02 128.35 128.91 131.67 135.51 139.82 - Chocolate Coated Biscuits 17.21 17.81 18.52 18.71 19.27 19.75 - Cookies 20.49 21.01 21.95 22.06 22.61 23.40 - Filled Biscuits 23.09 23.56 24.26 24.75 25.49 26.41 - Plain Biscuits 34.68 35.55 36.79 38.63 39.79 40.94 - Sandwich Biscuits 29.54 30.43 27.39 27.52 28.35 29.31 Biscuits 170.24 174.92 177.12 181.32 186.90 193.26 Source: Euromonitor International FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 41 Sales of Biscuits by Total Volume Growth (2007 – 2012, % total volume growth) 2011/12 2007-12 CAGR Category 2007/12 Total Savory Biscuits and Crackers 2.50 2.80 14.79 Sweet Biscuits 2.18 1.70 8.81 - Chocolate Coated Biscuits 2.30 2.32 12.15 - Cookies 1.90 1.78 9.22 - Filled Biscuits 2.50 2.36 12.37 - Plain Biscuits 2.30 2.75 14.53 - Sandwich Biscuits 1.80 -1.10 -5.40 Biscuits 2.28 2.01 10.48 Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Biscuits by Total Value Growth (2007 – 2012, % total value growth) 2010/11 2006-11 CAGR Category 2006/11 Total Savory Biscuits and Crackers 4.00 3.40 18.19 Sweet Biscuits 3.18 2.26 11.84 - Chocolate Coated Biscuits 2.50 2.79 14.78 - Cookies 3.50 2.69 14.20 - Filled Biscuits 3.60 2.72 14.35 - Plain Biscuits 2.90 3.38 18.06 - Sandwich Biscuits 3.40 -0.16 -0.78 Biscuits 3.41 2.57 13.53 Source: Euromonitor International 5.11. BEVERAGES 5.11.1. Alcoholic Drinks In 20121, alcoholic drinks achieved healthy volume growth despite Singapore’s economic slowdown. Consumer spending was positive due to the rising disposable incomes of consumers. A more vibrant social scene with the opening of more restaurants and pubs also boosted sales. Demand for premium products also increased due to the increasing sophistication of choice of alcoholic drinks by consumers. Younger affluent consumers pushed up the demand for beer and cider / perry. The rise of tourist arrivals also meant that companies focused their efforts on meeting foreign consumer need with the introduction of more premium quality products. Different products were imported from different countries as companies sought to diversify their product portfolios. Several off-trade and on-trade retailers also capitalized on the consumers’ willingness to spend, especially young and affluent Singaporeans who continued to embrace the drinking culture and social scene. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 42 Sales of Alcoholic Drinks by Value (2007-2012, jn S$ million) Beverage/ Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 1,394.70 1,474.70 1,572.40 1,704 1,859.90 1,995.4 Cider / Perry 6.2 6.7 8.7 12 15.3 18.1 RTDs / High-Strength Premixes 10.4 10.6 10.7 10.7 10.9 11.0 Spirits 623.3 700.9 752.5 832.2 927.1 1,012.4 Wine 356.5 392.9 374.6 416.6 472.4 515.8 2,391.1 2,585.7 2,718.9 2,975.5 3,285.5 3,552.8 Beer Alcoholic Drinks Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Alcoholic Drinks by Volume (2007-2012, in million liters) Beverage/ Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Beer 85.1 88.7 94.0 101.3 108.2 114.2 Cider / Perry 0.2 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.4 512.2 RTDs / High-Strength Premixes 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 338.7 Spirits 2.8 3.0 3.2 3.5 3.7 3,965.1 Wine 6.8 7.5 7.5 8.2 9.3 10.0 Alcoholic Drinks 95.2 99.7 105.4 113.7 121.9 129.0 Source: Euromonitor International Sales of Alcoholic Drinks by Total Volume Growth (2007 – 2012, % total volume growth) Beverage / Year 2011 / 12 2007-12 CAGR 2007 / 12 Total Beer 5.6 6.1 34.2 Cider / Perry 16.0 20.4 153.5 RTDs / High-Strength Premixes 0.1 0.4 2.2 Spirits 5.9 7.3 41.9 Wine 8.0 7.9 46.4 Alcoholic Drinks 5.8 6.3 35.5 Source: Euromonitor International 5.11.2. Hot Drinks In 2012, the sector for hot drinks retained stable strong growth due to increasing consumers’ disposable incomes. There was a demand for time saving products and premium products as consumers became affluent with busy lifestyles. Due to the expansion of specialty coffee shops, consumers have become more familiar with fresh brewed coffee, and thus are seeking the authentic taste and lifestyle at home, preparing high-quality fresh brewed coffee themselves, such as Italian specialty coffee and Starbucks’s instant coffee. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 43 Consumers in Singapore are also spending more in off-trade channels than on-trade channels, despite the fact that the density of on-trade channels is considerably higher such as in specialty coffee shops, independent cafés, food courts and hawkers. Offtrade channels offer a much wider ranges of products at reasonable prices. As Singaporeans became increasingly health conscious, major manufacturers are introducing healthier beverage options, such as Horlicks 3-in-1 light malt, Nescafe Body Partner 3-in-1 with collagen and high calcium content, and 3-in-1 instant coffee with low sugar and fat, etc. Total Sales of Hot Drinks by Volume (2007 – 2012, in tons) Beverage/Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Coffee 9,535.5 9,696.7 10,042.2 10,515.5 10,980.8 11,329.9 Tea 1,720.9 1,763.7 1,800.8 1,844.0 1,883.2 1,918.5 Other Hot Drinks* 8,923.5 9,110.3 9,348.4 9,684.9 10,051.6 10,396.3 Note: (*) Other hot drinks include (i) flavored powdered drinks (e.g. chocolate-base flavored Milo or malt-base Horlicks), (ii) plant-based hot drinks (e.g. cereal). Source: Euromonitor International Total Sales of Hot Drinks by Total Volume Growth (2007 – 2012, % total volume growth) Beverage/Year 2011 / 12 2006-11 CAGR 2006 / 11 Total Coffee 3.2 3.5 18.8 Tea 1.9 2.2 11.5 Other Hot Drinks* 3.4 3.1 16.5 Note: (*) Other hot drinks include (i) flavored powdered drinks (e.g. chocolate-base flavored Milo or malt-base Horlicks), (ii) plant-based hot drinks (e.g. cereal). Source: Euromonitor International 5.11.3. Soft Drinks There are two interesting trends in the volume and value sales growth of soft drinks. The first trend is the increase in consumption of healthier soft drinks. Rising obesity levels and Singapore’s wellness awareness campaigns have triggered greater health awareness, and consumers are switching to healthier soft drinks, especially organic and natural products. Due to the change in taste, more low-fat packaged food and beverages with fewer calories, including reduced sugar soft drinks, are being sold in the market. Euromonitor reported that retail volume of regular cola carbonates decrease at a CAGR of -2% in 2012/13, while low calorie carbonates increased in retail volume by 11% over the same period. Demand for Asian RTD tea (green tea) increased by a retail value of 7% in 2011 and 100%-juice (i.e. not from concentrate) has its growth rate tripled. The other trend is that while off-trade purchases of soft drinks is fairly stable, on-trade consumption levels of soft drinks is strong. This is as a result of the increasing number of visitors to Singapore that are consuming such products at restaurants and at fast food outlets. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 44 Off-trade vs. On-trade Sales of Soft Drinks (as sold) by Value in 2011, in S$ million Beverage/ Year Off-Trade On-Trade Total Bottled Water 37.9 102.2 140.1 Carbonates 156.7 270.7 427.4 9.8 - 9.8 177.0 161.2 338.2 8.0 - 8.0 RTD Tea 106.1 268.8 374.8 Sports and Energy Drinks 52.0 29.0 81.1 Asian Specialty Drinks 96.9 233.9 330.8 Soft Drinks 561.1 858.7 1,419.8 Concentrates Fruit / Vegetable Juice RTD Coffee Source: Euromonitor International Off-trade vs. On-trade Sales of Soft Drinks (as sold) by Volume in 2011, in million liters Beverage/ Year Off-Trade On-Trade Bottled Water 36.8 41.6 Carbonates 92.1 48.6 1.7 - 68.0 24.6 2.1 - RTD Tea 57.6 65.2 Sports and Energy Drinks 22.0 6.0 Asian Specialty Drinks 51.8 57.1 287.2 193.3 Concentrates Fruit / Vegetable Juice RTD Coffee Soft Drinks Source: Euromonitor International 5.12. PRIVATE LABELS Private labels were perceived to be of lower quality in comparison to branded products when they were first introduced in Singapore. However this has changed and private labels are now perceived to offer value for money. All three main supermarket/hypermarket players in Singapore have their own house brands. 5.12.1. NTUC FairPrice Co-operative NTUC FairPrice has more than 2,000 products under its FairPrice and Pasar brands, which are priced 10% to 15% cheaper than branded alternatives. The Pasar and FairPrice and Pasar labels encompass fresh produce and chilled processed food respectively, while the FairPrice Gold Label belongs to the premium segment. There is also Pasar Organic, a range of organic private label vegetables. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 45 NTUC FairPrice has made strong efforts to market their private label products, and this has resulted in their private labels increasing their share of total products sold within their supermarkets. Consumers are more likely to choose private label products when there is similar quality between their private label and branded products. 5.12.2. Dairy Farm International Holdings Dairy Farm has two private label brands comprising over 1,600 products, called First Choice and No Frills. These products can be found in its hypermarkets, supermarkets and convenience stores. It also carries its Guardian private label brand in its pharmacies. No Frills was developed in 1993 and is an economy range targeted towards price-conscious consumers. First Choice was developed in 1999 and belongs to the mid-priced range of products. A wide range of private label products including beverages and packaged food can also be found in Dairy Farm’s supermarkets and hypermarkets. Overall, Dairy Farm’s share of private label products is growing, are performing well and well-received by consumers in hypermarkets and supermarkets. 5.12.3. Sheng Siong Supermarket Sheng Siong Supermarket has a limited range of private label products which belong to the low price range. Products include oil, frozen food and condiments, and the company is constantly exploring the expansion and introduction of new private label products. Consumers are very receptive when private label products are introduced and they are also very well-received. Private Label / House Brand Portfolio House Brand Category(ies) Notes NTU FairPrice Co-operative Pte Ltd Pasar Vegetables, fruits Mid-priced FairPrice Packaged processed food, nuts Mid-priced FairPrice Gold Label Packaged Food, Rice, Coffee etc. Premium No Frills Cooking oil, bread, snacks, etc. Economy First Choice Snack foods, packaged food (chilled and frozen), vegetables, cheese, drinks etc. Mid-priced Giant Vegetables, canned food, snacks, etc. Economy Shop N Save Sweet and savory snacks Mid-priced Yu Pin King Canned food (e.g. abalone) Premium Royal Golden Grain Rice Premium Matahari Premium Rice Premium Tasty Bites Frozen food Mid-priced FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 46 Happy Family Oil, condiments, rice, canned food, dried food Mid-priced Source: Corporate Websites Penetration of Private Label by Category (2006 – 2010, % retail value rsp) Item / Year 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Bakery 2.9 3.4 4.1 4.8 5.1 Canned/ Preserved Food 3.2 3.2 3.6 3.8 4.2 Chilled Processed Food 11.3 11.2 11.6 11.6 11.7 Confectionery 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.2 0.2 Dairy 2.1 2.2 2.4 2.4 2.4 Dried Processed Food 14.8 14.8 16.9 17.3 17.3 Frozen Processed Food 5.9 6.0 6.2 6.6 6.7 Ice Cream 2.5 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.7 Impulse and Indulgence Products 2.4 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.6 Meal Solutions 5.5 5.5 5.8 5.9 6.1 Noodles 2.2 2.2 2.5 2.4 2.6 Nutrition/ Staples 5.7 5.8 7.4 7.8 7.9 Oils and Fats 6.4 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.4 Packaged Food 4.5 4.6 5.6 5.8 5.9 Pasta 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.2 4.2 Ready Meals 3.7 3.7 4.1 4.1 4.5 Sauces, Dressings and Condiments 4.4 4.4 4.6 4.7 4.8 Soup 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.8 Spreads 2.6 2.6 2.9 2.6 2.5 Sweet and Savory Snacks 3.6 3.6 4.0 4.0 4.1 Source: Euromonitor International 5.13. FOODSERVICE / HORECA Singapore has a large and highly competitive food service industry with a vast array of hotels, restaurants, airline caterers, ship handlers, hospitals, clubs and bars. In 2011, the Singapore food service market was valued at US$3.3 billion. It is expected to reach US$4 billion in value in 2013, growing at a CAGR of 2%, due to the current unclear economic trend. Restaurants and fast food outlets accounted for 38% and 12% of the total revenue in the food and beverage services industry respectively. Food caterers held 13% of the industry. Although the food service sector in Singapore is made up of many small single site establishments, the key players are dominated by large international hotels with western restaurants that serve a growing number of local consumers in addition to in-house guests. Singapore is also witnessing the emergence of a very serious fine dining scene, with two restaurants coming FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 47 into the World’s 50 Best Restaurants list last year – long standing favorite Iggy’s and Jaan at the Swissotel, which swooped into number 39 from nowhere – and two in the top 100 – Les Amis at number 78 and nouveau French diner Gunther’s at 84. Within the integrated resorts – the city’s two new casino complexes – are a host of celeb-chefs that have recently opened satellite outposts. Australia’s Tetsuya Wakuda, Catalan Santi Santamaria, Wolfgang Puck, Daniel Boulud and Guy Savoy now have diners at the Marina Bay Sands. Kyoto- born Kunio Tokuoka and his astronomically priced SGD$750 tasting menu (with 17% taxes on top of that) is amongst the prizes to be savored at Sentosa Resorts World. Joël Robuchon, the world's most decorated chef with 26 Michelin stars, has also opened two dining concepts in Resorts World Sentosa, one of which features a dining concept of French haute cuisine that is similar to the chef's restaurants in Les Vegas, Tokyo and Paris. Legendary New York restaurateur Mario Batali is planning a third restaurant in Singapore, twenty one months after opening Pizzeria Mozza and Osteria Mozza at Marina Bay Sands. Aside from restaurants, there are many fast food chains such as McDonald’s, Starbucks, Burger King, The Coffee Bean and The Coffee Connoisseur (TCC) just to name a few. McDonald’s leads the way with over a hundred outlets, rivaled by Starbucks at approximately 80 outlets. This is followed by Burger King at approximately 45 outlets, TCC at around 31 outlets and The Coffee Bean at nearly 30 outlets. Due to the greater influx of tourists and business arrivals to Singapore, restaurants registered an increased 10% in sales in 2011. As customers are resuming their original preference for quality food ingredients, the food service industry is also reverting back to better quality but higher priced food. As an increasing number of consumers are more health-conscious, major fast food outlets and restaurants are also offering healthier food options. McDonald’s, for example, has a salad menu and Starbucks is offering a healthier breakfast menu. Indeed, many food service operators are trying to differentiate themselves from their competitors by offering a healthier menu as one of the key strategic tools. One major challenge facing the food service sector, which may have an impact on the number of restaurants here in the near future, is the shortage of manpower as labor conditions have tightened. While there are a variety of possible scenarios that could play out with the tight labor conditions, one prevalent thought is that more lower end restaurants may close down while the more upscale and well-located restaurants will survive. 5.14. INDUSTRY TRENDS As consumers in Singapore develop a more sophisticated palate, food and beverage manufacturers will need to cater to this demand and continue to create more new products, and at a more rapid rate. This will therefore have an impact on all segments within the supply chain, from ingredient and additives producers, to packaging, machinery and equipment manufacturers. A summary of these trends and their impact on these various groups is summarized in the table below. Singapore is also facing other issues which are also unique to the Singapore food and beverage industry. Among them are two key trends: food supply and food safety and quality. 5.14.1. Food Supply With climate change, extreme weather events will impact sustainable agricultural production, food safety and food supply resilience. Singapore’s food supply is met largely by imports. Ensuring an adequate and safe food supply, in both normal times and during crises, is a serious issue that the country has to address. Knowledge systems and technologies that enable food safety assurance and sustainable supply, including the regulatory aspects of monitoring both imported and locally produced foods, are essential to the well-being and prosperity of Singapore. Currently, local production provides about 23% of hen eggs, 7% leafy vegetables and 4% fish supply. But Singapore is interested to push the technological boundaries to increase its own food production. At the same time, it needs to figure out how this can be done within the limited resources available in the country, especially land and water. 5.14.2. Food Safety and Quality i) Nanotechnology is a pervasive technology with major impact across a range of economic sectors such as healthcare, cosmetics, textiles, automobile and aerospace industries. The benefits of nanotechnology are broadly acknowledged and consumer products containing nanoparticles in the food industry in particular are rapidly increasing in numbers. The FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 48 novel chemical and physical properties that make engineered nanomaterials beneficial for food packaging, as an example, may give rise to safety concerns such as their potential side effects on human health. Hence, there is an urgent need for proper toxicological data, standardized risk assessment and predictive toxicology models for engineered nanomaterials. ii) For adults between 18 to 69 years in Singapore, the top four disease burdens are hypertension at 24.9%, diabetes at 8.2%, high total cholesterol at 18.7%, and obesity at 10.8%. In addition, 4 out every 10 people are either obese or overweight. Similar trends are observed elsewhere around the world. For example, the obesity rate in the US is at 33.8%, and China has more than 92 million adults suffering from diabetes and nearly 150 million more are well on their way to developing it. Added to the picture, in South East Asia, there are 58 million diabetics. While it is well recognized that an unhealthy diet is one of the most important factors leading to this global problem, many experts are of the opinion that functional foods might hold a key to reducing the risk of certain chronic diseases. Functional foods are defined as foods that provide health benefits beyond basic nutrition. Functional foods are foods, not drugs, which are intended to be consumed as part of the normal diet and contain biologically active components that could enhance health and reduce the risks of certain diseases or address specific nutritional needs. Recent growth rates of various categories of functional foods are estimated to range from 8 to 20% per annum, while the growth rate of the overall food industry is in the range of only 1 to 4% per annum. The total global market of functional foods is estimated to reach a value of at least US$90.5 billion by 2013. However, the current functional foods market is dominated by products that are characterized by simply mixing bioactive ingredients (e.g. vitamins and minerals) with food materials. These products in general lack technological innovation with no propriety protection which results in many similar products in the market and therefore highly varied quality. There is also a lack of scientific understanding of the interactions between the bioactive compounds and their environment i.e. the food matrix and therefore there is a lack of proven efficacy for substantiation of health claims. All these contribute to the huge challenges in the regulation of functional foods. Developing technologies that could produce next generation functional foods which can effectively reduce the chronic disease risk factors presents a grand challenge, but also an immense opportunity for the food industry. iii) In Singapore, there are increasing challenges to meet the country’s stringent food safety standards when the food products come from diversified sources. Over the years, Singapore has experienced crisis and scandals in food supply chains include Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE), salmonella contaminated peanut butter, and food adulteration for economic gains. It is clear that for food safety reasons and to protect consumers' interests, Singapore need a comprehensive food trace system cover food production process from farm to fork. One area being looked at is advanced molecular profiling technologies to meet this need and to trace the intrinsic component of food products via their unique pattern of DNA, proteins or metabolites. Metabolomics, a relatively new post-genomic discipline, has been rapidly embraced by the scientific community owing to its potential in enhancing the understanding of the molecular components, and offer better insight of the dynamic changes of an organism or crop product FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 49 Trends for the food and beverage industry Trend Smaller packs Driver Benefited Segment Examples Single portion biscuits; smaller milk cartons, single portion wine bottles. - Lower income (C and D) for pricing strategy - Machinery producers - Packaging producers - Higher income (A and B) for convenience - Packaging designers Low salt, low trans, less sugar - Legislation Consumer demand (obesity and healthier lifestyle) - Food enhancers Flavors Texturizing agents Margarine with less saturated fat; low sodium ready meals Lighter packs (use of less pack material) Cost reduction and environmental concerns - Machinery producers Packaging producers Packaging designers Water bottles with less plastic; smaller lids; recyclable packs. Focus on innovation Market – need to launch new products and / or new packs on a regular basis The whole industry, in particular packaging producers New drink combinations (coconut water with juice); meal kits. Convenience All segments are affected, in particular people from larger cities - - Packaging Texturizing agents Quality / food safety - Legislation Consumer demand The whole industry, in particular machinery and laboratory equipment manufacturers - Indulgence and pleasure Foodservice Customer demand: customers are not willing to give up on pleasure to eat healthier. Industry needs to change as little as possible the product characteristics (flavor, consistency, crunchiness, etc.) - Lifestyle in large cities, low unemployment rates, increase in income Industry as a whole, specially ingredient and additives suppliers and kitchen appliances producers Source: Osec from desk research FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 50 Food enhancers Flavors Texturizing agents Packaging producers Packaging designers - - - Easy to peel, easy to seal Products with better resistance to temperature variation or that do not need refrigeration Packaging that goes directly into the microwave / oven. Machinery to avoid food manipulation (food safety); machinery that kills bacteria keeping the product nutrients Equipment for faster and more efficient laboratory analysis More attractive packs made with more “noble” materials such as glass, showing appetite appeal on the label / pack Food with a premium and homemade appeal Texturizers to compensate lower use of fat Kitchen appliances and equipment such as industrial stoves. 6. Food Distribution 6.1. ROUTE TO MARKET Singapore’s distribution channels for consumer ready foods are now concentrated around supermarkets and hypermarkets. While there are alternative channels, e.g. the wet and dry markets, small “mom and pop” type shops, mini-marts and some specialty food and drinks shops, trade sources comment that these channels can no longer support imported products from a manufacturing location as far and as expensive as Switzerland if the strategy is to build a sizeable market and share in the long term. Swiss exporters have to accept that their brands and products have to be in Singapore’s main retailing channels, i.e. supermarkets and hypermarkets, if they want to have a successful and sustained future in the Singapore retail channels. As the major supermarket operators are heavily into seasonal gift retailing, premium and specialty products, organics and expatriatetargeted products due to their market segmentation strategies, this position is broadly true for both niche and mass market type products. There are 3 major companies that dominate the Singapore food retail market: NTUC FairPrice, Dairy Farm Group and Sheng Siong. 6.1.1. FairPrice Group The FairPrice group of supermarkets is owned by the co-operative NTUC FairPrice Co-operative Ltd. It was founded in 1973 with the social mission of moderating the cost of living in Singapore by providing competitively-priced products for the low income and lower-middle income consumers. From a single supermarket when it was established, it has now grown to become Singapore’s largest retailer with a network of more than two hundred and thirty outlets including FairPrice Supermarkets, FairPrice Xtra, FairPrice Xpress and Cheers Convenience Stores. Geographically, the FairPrice chain has the most extensive consumer reach and across all income segments. FairPrice supermarkets can be found in almost every residential estate in Singapore. They primarily target the low income to the middle income consumers. But in recent years, FairPrice has also attempted to extend its reach to middle income consumers with higher spending power with the establishment of FairPrice Finest, which sells more fine foods compared to their other outlets. Nevertheless, in determining whether a product should be procured for FairPrice, competitive pricing is still one of the factors taken into consideration given their role as a cooperative. 6.1.2. Dairy Farm Group The Dairy Farm Group, which is headquartered in Hong Kong, runs many supermarket brands. Their target each consumer segment from the highest income consumers in Singapore right down to discount stores. The supermarket brands are as follows: Cold Storage Established in 1903, “Cold Storage” is an iconic name, unique in the history of Singapore, and is the country’s oldest supermarket operator. In 1993, Cold Storage in Singapore was acquired by the Dairy Farm Group. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 51 The Market Place As a premium supermarket, the Market Place supermarkets focus on the high and upper-middle income consumers although some middle income consumers sometimes shop there. Giant Giant offers fresh, groceries and general merchandise, targeting at the value conscious shoppers. Three-Sixty Gourmet Supermarket There is one gourmet supermarket operated by the Dairy Farm Group situated at probably Singapore’s most expensive shopping mall (ION Orchard). It caters to the highest income consumers in the country. They position themselves as the “Epicurean Heaven” for all shoppers. Top luxury food brands and labels from around the world can be found at the Three-Sixty Gourmet Supermarket. They include brands such as Fauchon, Hediard and Dean & Deluca. All types of fine food such as special Italian vinegar, flavored oils, herbs, caviar, wine and specialty cheeses are carried at Three-Sixty. It also has a large organic food section. 6.1.3. Sheng Siong Sheng Siong Supermarket was founded in 1985 by three brothers. They had started out selling chilled pork at a booth in a supermarket chain store, but when the store owner ran into financial trouble, the brothers took the plunge and ventured into retail business by taking over the whole store. Today, they operate more than 25 supermarkets, are listed on the Singapore Stock Exchange and are the 3rd largest supermarket chain in the country. Sheng Siong’s stores are very much targeted at low income consumers. While they sell a whole range of products, not unlike FairPrice and Cold Storage, most of their products are sourced from neighboring countries in South East Asia, and China. Their “Taiwan Food Fair” and “Korean Food Fair” promotions are popular among consumers. The strategies of the retailers in segmenting the market means that it is possible for a shopper to buy a huge range of different products from across the world, including many products that are in the supermarkets or other large format stores in Switzerland. This arises because of consolidated shipments imported either by the retailer, a part of its group, or an independent importer-distributor. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 52 Distribution of Consumer Ready Food and Drinks in Singapore Procurement Method by Major Supermarkets, Hypermarkets and Departmental Stores in Singapore Retailer Names & Ownership Procurement Method FairPrice (Local Cooperative) Direct sourcing preferred with some distributors used for smaller volume supplies. Cold Storage group* and Giant (**) (Owned by DFI, a Hong Kong based listed company) Direct sourcing preferred, together with a number of local distributors Sheng Siong Supermarket Local agents are important, but this company is increasingly sourcing on a direct basis from overseas suppliers. Note: (*) The Cold Storage group of supermarkets also includes Jason’s and The Market Place banners (**) As of April 1, 2013, Shop n Save had been rebranded as Giant. Source: USDA Gain Report 6.2. NATIONAL DISTRIBUTORS Singapore’s distribution channels for consumer ready foods are currently concentrated around supermarkets and hypermarkets. The 2 leading convenience store operators, Dairy Farm and NTUC FairPrice, control most of the supermarkets in Singapore. Local distributors are usually used when exporters bring food products into Singapore. Exporters are also advised to work with only one distributor to avoid a result in price wars and brand dilution, and to appoint a distributor with an established network so as to reach the exporter’s target segment. Distributors manage importing, storage and distribution to buyers, and most distributors are also responsible for marketing and promotion. It is also increasingly common to sell directly through to retailers. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 53 Major F&B Distributors in Singapore Company Type of Product Distributed Brands Represented Interstate Market (2007) Pte Ltd / FairPrice Beverages, cake roll, chocolates, cookies, snacks, desserts, puddings, nuts, biscuits, potato chips, breakfast bars, canned food, cereals, dressings, dried food, instant condiments, instant porridge, honey, noodles, oil, organic health food, pasta and sauce, rice, spread, sugar, seasoning F&N, Yeo’s, Tai Hua, FairPrice, Kraft, Lady’s Choice, Capilano, Nuzeabee, A1, Chng Kee, Lee Kum Kee, Mak Nyonya, Prima Taste, Maggi, Knorr, Koka, Myojo, Nong Shim, Indofood, Maggi, Chief, Duck, New Moon, Sunbeam, Soyalite, Bragg, Black Gold, Natur-Organic, Agnesi, Barilla, Leggo, Prego, San Remo, Double FP, Dragonfly, Golden Phoenix, Royal Umbrella, Heinz, Delmonte, Alphen, Cadbury, Arnotts, Camel, Cowhead, Calbee, Jack & Jill. Q.B. Food Trading Pte Ltd Fruit drinks, yogurt, soda, mineral water, cheese, frozen meat, dessert, frozen bread/ pizza, frozen potato/ vegetable, further processed meat, pasta, seasoning/ condiment, snack Berry up, Buffalowing, Café Aurora, Cape Herb and Spice, Cellone’s, Cholula, Country Prime Dry Pepperoni, Daisho, De Celco, De Nigris, Delicious, Ebara, Ehrmann, Furmano’s, Giovanna Pavarotii Bal Samic, Granarolo, Happy Cow, Healthy People, House, Independent, Jack Ling’s, Johnsonville, Knead it Bakery, La Corvinia, Lemnos, Mc Cormick, Mizkan, Moore’s, Nutino, Pierce Food, Plochman’s, Primo, Route II, Rutherford & Meyer, Saputo, Sealord, Sujon, Sweet Nature, Tatua, Tosa Reihoku, Tradition, Vicenzi, Vittoria,Yamasa Benfoods (S) Pte Ltd Wine & beverages, fresh/frozen seafood, processed seafood, frozen meals and meat cuts, dairy products, edible oil, ready to eat food, others Cowhead, Farmland, Oriental Fortune, Haton, Orchard Fresh, Spices of the Orient Culina Pte Ltd Seafood fresh/frozen/ processed, frozen meals and meat cuts, bakery products, canned food, cereals, confectionary, dairy products, edible oil, frozen food/pastry/ desserts, frozen vegetables, gourmet/ specialty, maple syrup, organic, salad dressings, snacks, wine, juices, mineral water Alain, Milliat, Rangers Valley, Orlienas, Kaviari, Pronto Fresco, Mulocr, Poujauran, Rocklife Seaffoods, FranceFish, Royal Oyster, Kobe, Plantin, Chiteau d’ Estoublon, ceas, de Mont Saint Michel, Ortiz, Tetsuya’s, Kinkawooka Shell Fish, Petuna Auric Pacific Marketing Seafood- fresh/ frozen/ processed, deli Angus, Gourmett, Buttercup, Countre, Pure Pte Ltd meats, frozen meals and meat cuts, Creamy Butter, Baker’s Pride, Delicious, bakery products, canned food, Sunshine, Top-One, Food Junction, Kokor, confectionary, dairy products, frozen Malones, Tetsu, Delifrance Torres, Ruffino, Cakebread Cellars, Sequoia Grove, Inniskillin, Caymus Vineyards, Joseph Phelps, Marimar, St. Francis, Miguel torres, Brown Brothers, Torbreck, Plantagenet Wines, Chateaude Laubade, Vignobles Lesgourgues, Champagne Taittinger, Knappstein, Leroy, Bridgewater mill, food/ pastry/ desserts, frozen vegetables, gourmet/ specialty, health FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 54 Barossa Valley Estate, Castello Banfi, Champagne food, maple syrup/ jams/ spreads, Jacquart, Cono Sur, Cellini, Gerard Bertrand, organic, ready to eat, wine, juices Hardys, Kim Crawford, Nederburg, Robert Mondavi, Tatachilla, Taylors, Placido, Voss, VnC Cocktail and Grolsch Angliss Singapore Pte Ltd Seafood- frozen/ fresh, frozen meals, Dew Fresh, Dew Pride, Catch of the Day, Master bakery products, dairy products, frozen Butchery, Amosco, Garden Cuisine vegetables, organic, ready to eat DKSH Singapore Biscuits, Chocolates, Sweets, Potato Frito Lay, Tulip, Campbell Soup Chips, Confectionary Shiro Corporation Pte Ltd Canned abalone, canned shellfish, Jade frozen lobster, frozen snow crab and crab meat, cold appetizer, finger food, dessert, pastry puffs, pasta 6.3. PRICING The decision in determining the price of a product is heavily dependent on the nature of the product sold. For instance, consumers are more price sensitive to necessities than luxury goods. According to New Zealand Trade and Enterprise’s Food and Beverage Market profile in 2011, the typical mark ups that occur along the supply chain are 10% for shipping cost, 5% to 7% for transportation cost, and 15% to 20% for distribution and retail mark up costs. For comparison purposes, we have added a list of products and their retail prices for comparison purposes. Figure 2 – Examples of imported foods in Singapore Product / Brand EMMI Price S$9.80 Fondue 400g PRESIDENT Product / Brand LINDT Price S$9.90 Milk Hazelnut Gold Bar 300G S$4.80 Grated Emmental Cheese 100g FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 55 Image KAMBLY Butterfly Biscuits 100G S$5.40 Image MOVENPICK S$6.10 Swiss Tub Ice Cream 175ml BAILEYS SOMERSBY S$16.80 Apple Cider 4s 330 ML $67.05 Irish Cream 70cl Source: FairPrice & Cold Storage Corporate Website Swiss exporters must also take into account the listing fees that need to be paid to supermarket retailers here. Trade interviews have indicated that the listing fees are dependent on: 1) 2) 3) 4) Product Category – is the product fast moving or a seasonal item? A fast moving product commands a higher listing fee. No. of store locations the products will be placed at The position of products on the shelves. Products placed at eye-ball level will command a higher listing fee. No. of SKUs When a new product is placed in the stores, importers need to pay a one-time initial listing fee, followed by a monthly placement fee, covering costs such as admin fee, anti-theft fee, etc. Supermarkets may also ask distributors to cover the cost of advertising and promotion. As such, listing fees can range from several ten to hundreds of thousands of dollars. Among the three supermarket / hypermarket chain (FairPrice, Cold Storage and Sheng Siong), Cold Storage has the highest listing fee (by a few percent), followed by FairPrice and Sheng Siong. Importers we spoke to were reluctant to provide an exact amount as to how much they are paying for listing fees due to confidentiality reasons. One importer, however, indicated that a hypermarket he was targeting quoted him S$5000 per product per store. This importer also indicated that in his opinion, shelving fees in Singapore were very competitive and relatively cheap compared with other established markets (e.g. Australia, US, Japan) he has dealt with. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 56 7. Opportunities & Challenges 7.1. OPPORTUNITIES According to Food Export- Midwest, a US government funded agricultural support group helping US food and beverage companies penetrate new export markets, demand in Singapore is and will be driven by the following products: Dairy products Fresh and processed fruits and vegetables Frozen food Healthy/ organic/ specialty food Poultry and red meats Seafood Snack food Wine and beer Other processed food Anecdotally, this trend seems to be confirmed by Business Monitor’s forecasts, which indicates that sales of processed food products, alcoholic drinks, soft drinks and mass grocery retails ranges from a positive 2.8% to 6.5%. Hence, there is potential growth in these sectors which Swiss F&B companies may wish to consider venturing into and to seek new business opportunities here. 2012 BMI CAGR Forecasts to 2016 Product Percentag e (%) CAGR forecast to 2016 Food Consumption +3.1%; +3.2% Alcoholic Drink Value Sales +9.6%; +6.5% Soft Drinks Value Sales +5.0%; +3.5% Mass Grocery Retail Sales +3.0%; +2.8% Source: BMI Industry View - Singapore - Q4 2012 As Swiss exporters consider the opportunities to sell their foods and beverages in Singapore, they should also take the following factors into consideration: Singapore is reliant on imports for virtually all of its food and drink supplies and will always remain this way Singapore is one of the wealthiest markets in Southeast Asia, and it is a key location for expatriate families to reside in East Asia. It also has a very small lower income group, so virtually the whole population is a target market. Singaporeans have a modernized diet that includes a wide range of foreign concept foods, which has expanded on the back of demand from the younger generation (under 40s). Singaporeans are open to products from developed markets that are of high quality and value-for-money. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 57 The population has a large number of single adults who are very clearly indulgent in their spending patterns when economic times are good. This benefits premium imported meats, some dairy products, exotic fruits, confectionery, wines and spirits, gift items and pet foods, segments that fit well with what Switzerland has to offer in terms of exports. 7.2. CHALLENGES A key challenge in Singapore is that it is a highly competitive market. The major supermarket and hypermarket operators control the whole retail market by actively segmenting it around different store concepts (and store brands/banners) and merchandising strategies that target the low income group through to the high income groups and expatriates. As a result, retailers control access to shoppers and have very strong bargaining power over suppliers of all forms of food and drinks, fresh, frozen and shelf stable retail packed. Marketing and distribution costs are extremely high for new product launches and also high for the on-going maintenance of market shares and positions. This situation is further compounded by the fact that retailers are very profit margin driven because of their very high overheads, especially store rentals. This has led to a situation where: Private label products has become more evident on shelves Retailers are buying directly, bypassing the middleman, namely distributors. This is especially so for specialty products like organics and niche products that are specifically demanded by expatriates. Another challenge is that local products now include market leading ASEAN-made products imported from Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines, Vietnam and Thailand. This supply scenario now includes food and drink produced by multinationals that now have factories in the ASEAN region, negating the need for them to import from their home countries where these products were originally imported from. This trend can be clearly seen in products such as ice cream, tea, sugar confectionery, chocolate, cookies, breakfast cereals, snacks of various types, soups and soft drinks. In view of these challenges, importers and distributors now are much more focused and demanding of their suppliers that they want to work with. They expect their suppliers to be fully committed to develop their markets in Singapore, in terms of willingness to: deal with local demands for promotional campaigns develop products and packages that fit local demand requirements have a product and brand that is unique enough to break into the market be flexible in terms of returns and profit goals adopt a medium to long term strategy and action plan to build their market in Singapore. This situation exists because suppliers in Singapore have very little power to deal with the demands of retailers when it comes to accessing retail space for their products. Trade sources comment that everything now revolves around the cost of accessing such space, maintaining a listing (avoid delisting) and so the ability to consistently access shoppers. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 58 8. Export Check List 8.1. READINESS TO EXPORT Is your company already exporting to other countries? Singapore is an open market with very few barriers to entry. While this makes it very attractive to foreign exporters, it also means that Singapore is a very competitive market which requires commitment from a Swiss exporter who is willing to invest in marketing and product promotion to differentiate their products from other suppliers in the market. Is your company willing to invest in product launch, traveling, trade fairs, adaptation of labels and marketing materials, registration process, market research and to find the ideal partner? There are ways to save costs on your internationalization process, but your company will still need to invest in this new market. Using specialists from Singapore (who can assist you from there, avoiding trips) and sharing costs with your Singapore partner are some of the ways to spend less on the initial costs. Will your company focus on a small number of countries? Exporting to a new country is always a challenge, so it is recommended that your company focus on one or only a few countries at a time. Is your company willing and able to make product adaptations if the local market and / or legislation requires so? When learning more about the local market and regulatory aspects you might find out that some product or package adaptations might be necessary. Do you have a strategy for export to Singapore? During the course of the project, your strategy may change, according to the market research findings, for example. It is key, though, that you have in mind a few initial aspects: Are you using Osec’s network in order to take the most of it in your new markets? FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 59 - which products you want to focus on what is your investment budget on this new market - what kind of information you still need before you can take decisions - what is the ideal partner profile Osec and the Swiss Business Hubs with their network of experts can assist you in exporting to Singapore and other countries with a wide range of services that will fit exactly your needs. 8.2. MARKET RESEARCH How much do you know about Singapore? Research and collect as much information as possible about Singapore – always from trusted sources. Useful sources may be Osec and the Swiss Business Hubs and their network of experts, the Chambers of Commerce, your suppliers and customers already present in the market, trade associations, etc. Do you know if Singapore is the right market for your product? Even if you are an experienced exporter, you may need further research in order to understand better how the Singapore market will receive your product. Osec offers a menu of market research services that will provide the basis for making a strategic decision. Do you know the right place to launch your product? While there are no geographic issues with regards to selling your products in Singapore given the size of the country, the market is fragmented in terms of retail channels and a clear strategy is needed as to what is the ideal route to market. Osec’s services can help you decide where to start. Do you know your competitors, their products, strengths, weaknesses and pricing strategy? Competition in Singapore is fierce. It is key to understand who are your competitors, how they are operating in Singapore, what are their prices, who are their customers, what are their product sizes and packages, what is their market position, etc. A customized competition analysis is one of the services offered by Osec and the Swiss Business Hub Singapore and will be tailor made to your company needs. Is your product competitive in Singapore? After you find out your competitors’ prices, how do you know if your own product is competitive? It is recommend having a landed cost analysis, which will show you, starting from your FOB price, how much your product will cost in Singapore after all taxes. This service can be rendered by a local customs broker and will not only help you to understand your price compared to your competitor’s but will be also prove useful in your negotiation with a future local partner (for setting commission, margins, targets, etc.). Osec offers this service counting on the assistance of local experts. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 60 8.3. TRADE FAIRS Do you know the most important Singapore food and beverage trade fairs? There are a few but significant trade shows in Singapore. A list is published at the end of this report. Checking if your competitors are exhibiting and the size of their booth (when a map is available) will give you a good hint if your company should or not be present. Also check if other Swiss companies are exhibiting – maybe you can ask them for their inputs on the fair. Having a booth on a trade fair is a high investment, and ideally you should visit the trade fairs prior to exhibiting to check if it is worth it. Sometimes, due to costs or time, this is not possible, so you may hire local assistance for that. Osec and its network partners can assist you with obtaining further information on trade fairs, including visiting the trade fairs for you and reporting the main findings. Do you know how to save costs on trade fairs? There are a number of ways your company can save costs and time when exhibiting at a trade fair: - if you know other Swiss companies who will be at the fair, why not contact them to share a booth? - in case you have already a local partner, you can try to negotiate sharing the trade fair costs. Just remember that your partner might be exhibiting other products as well. If this is arranged and you will not visit the fair, you should ask your partner for photos, details on the visitors as well as all expenses receipts. 8.4. REGULATORY – REGISTERING PRODUCT IN SINGAPORE Are the ingredients of your product and packaging material allowed? Does your labeling conform to the requirements in Singapore? The Agriculture and Veterinary Authority of Singapore has a comprehensive and detailed website which provides details on what is allowed with regards to packaging and ingredients. It also provides details on what is permissible or required to be stated in labeling. You will also need to check other ingredients of your product, since additives, transgenic ingredients, organics and also packaging materials have specific legislation. Register your trademark Trademark registration can take as long as a year, so it is recommended to start the process as soon as you decide to start business with Singapore. It is recommended to use a specialized trademark registration office / patent law office to conduct the process. You may rely on the Swiss Business Hub for indications of specialized offices. Do you know your product Harmonized System (HS) Code? Check with a Singapore customs broker and with your local partner the most appropriate code as this affects taxes and import licensing. With the HS code, you will be able to check if the product needs an import license prior to shipment. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 61 8.5. FINDING A DISTRIBUTOR / IMPORTER Do you know what kind of partner you are looking for? Name the must have, the nice to have and the don’ts of your ideal partner. This profile may change during search, but it is starting point. Some aspects to think about: - Do you already know candidates for a partnership? level of experience or expertise language skills clients and market served need for exclusivity size (company or one-man-show) need for warehouse for keeping inventory type of import license geographic coverage type of partner: distributor, importer or representative Maybe your company has already done business with Singapore, visited the country a few times or was even contacted by Singapore companies and has a few names of potential local partners. It is highly recommended to check the candidates, be they companies or persons. Checking their background, experience, creditworthiness and comparing their expertise and reputation can avoid future problems. Osec, through its local experts, can provide partner verification services for your company. Identify a number of potential partners – do not consider only one option. The selection of your local business partner is probably the single most important step in your export project. This should not be left to luck. A thorough partner search is highly recommended. Osec and the Swiss Business Hub Singapore have assisted hundreds of Swiss SME in the selection process, through business contact checks. This service extends from the compilation of a checked long list of company addresses to the analysis of which candidates best meet your criteria. The result is a short list of potential partners. Have you considered a partnership with a local manufacturer with complementary products or acquiring a local competitor? Even if you have your pre-set distribution model, you may consider alternatives, including acquiring a local competitor, with expertise and a customer base already established. Osec and the Swiss Business Hub Singapore may indicate M&A experts from their network to you. Meeting the candidates Study your partner candidates’ profiles in advance and make sure you have enough time to meet them. It is not unlikely, if the conversation goes well, that they might invite you for another meeting or dinner, so leave some open spaces on your schedule for such occasions. Osec and the Swiss Business Hub Singapore offer services to help you preparing your schedule, including all trip arrangements. Put an effort on promoting your company / product When meeting the potential partners, have in mind that you might need to persuade them to work with you. Present your company and products well to leave a good impression. Careful when bringing samples of your product (food / beverage) – it is recommended to check if those are allowed to be brought in your luggage. Define with your partner the marketing FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 62 If you found the right partner you need to start negotiating a few aspects budget, sales forecast, client goals and period for reviews. regarding sales goals, product registration, costs sharing, development of promotional materials, marketing budget, financial resources remittance (amount and periodicity), product launching plan, trade fairs, need for additional staff, training program in Switzerland or Singapore, etc. Take advantage of your partner’s expertise and past experiences. Establishing a contract It is recommended that the first contract is signed for a shorter period of time (e.g. one year). It must contain your representative’s / distributor’s obligations and goals, exclusivity clauses (if agreed), financial agreements on commissions, etc. A confidentially clause is also recommended. The contract should be elaborated / analyzed by a lawyer, considering both Swiss and Singapore laws. It is likely that your standard contract is not applicable or valid in Singapore. For lawyers recommendations, contact the Swiss Business Hub. 8.6. REGULATORY – ADAPTING TO THE LOCAL LEGISLATION Labeling Requirements A food label should contain core information such as the prescribed food name, list of ingredients, mandatory warning, advisory statements or allergens declarations, net weight or volume, date mark, nutritional information panel, instructions for use or storage, country of origin, the name and address of the business and manufacturer and importer. Repackaged foods must be labeled to show (in English) the appropriate designation of food content – whether foods are compounded, mixed or blended; the minimum quantity stated in metric net weight or measure; the name and address of the manufacturer or seller; and the country of origin. Illustrations must accurately describe the true nature or origin of the food. Packages of food described as “enriched”, “fortified”, “vitaminized” or in any other way that implies that the article contains added vitamins or minerals must show the quantity of vitamins or minerals added per metric unit. 8.7. LOGISTICS AND IMPORTS How is your product going to be shipped to Singapore? Have you considered the lead time? Depending on the type of transportation and the customs clearance time, goods can take more than a month to arrive at the final destination. Having the documentation clear and containing the correct information will avoid delays. Necessary certificates All imports require an import permit. Make sure you have all necessary certificates according to the Singapore regulations shipped with the export documents. More details can be found at www.customs.gov.sg/leftNav/trad/Permits+and+Documentation.htm. Bona Fide Trade Samples Import of trade samples for which the total value is below US$286 (S$400) is not subject to payment of duty and/or GST. In addition, no permit is required for their import. Bona fide trade samples (excluding liquors and tobacco) may be imported if they are imported solely for the purpose of soliciting orders for goods to be supplied from abroad, for demonstration in Singapore to enable manufacturers in Singapore to produce such articles to fulfill orders from abroad or by a manufacturer for the purpose of copying, testing or experimenting before they produce such articles in Singapore. More information can be found at www.customs.gov.sg/leftNav/trav/Business+Travellers.htm. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 63 8.8. PRODUCT LAUNCH Are you going to launch the product on a trade fair or event? If you are planning a special launch event with your partner, make sure that: - products / samples will arrive on time (consider extra lead time due to customs) you picked a date considering local holidays and hired the venue in advance The Swiss Business Hub Singapore may provide services to assist you in the organization of your product launch. Are your partner and their team well trained and prepared for launch? Your local partner’s staff is your company’s door opener and face in Singapore – they need to be prepared and know your product well. Do you have a clear pricing strategy? Have you thought about warranty and exchange policies and negotiated this with your partner? When launching the product, your clients will expect to know about prices, terms and conditions. Make sure you have discussed and arranged your pricing strategy, warranty, exchange policies, etc. with your local partner. Does your importer have stocks for launch? Launching a product and not being able to sell immediately due to customs delays, for example, will be frustrating to your customer and damage your image. Make sure the products arrive before launch. Have you thought about advertising on specialized publications? Consider this possibility with your local partner, but check first about the target readers of the publication and the expected results. Have you scheduled a program for continuous training? You should train your partner before launch, but it is important that you follow up and organize additional training sessions periodically. Visit some clients with your partner when possible, so you have a feeling of their needs and doubts. FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 64 9. Appendix 9.1. TRADE SHOWS 9.1.1. Food & Hotel Asia 2014 (FHA) This is Asia’s largest international exhibition on food and drinks, hotel, restaurant & catering equipment and supplier & services, which will be held on 8 - 11 April 2014, in Singapore Expo. This event is organized by Singapore Exhibition Services Pte Ltd. A conference is also included. The biennial FHA is powered by its specialized events namely Food Asia, Hotel Asia, Bakery & Pastry, Hospitality Style Asia and Hospitality Technology; and the newly launched Specialty Coffee & Tea. It is estimated that 2,800 exhibitors from 70 countries / regions will be participating in FHA2014. Website: www.foodnhotelasia.com 9.2. TRADE AGENCIES & ASSOCIATIONS Agri Food & Veterinary Authority of Singapore Website: www.ava.gov.sg Health Promotion Board, Singapore Website: www.hpb.gov.sg Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore Website: www.iras.gov.sg Restaurant Association of Singapore RAS Website: www.ras.org.sg Shatec Institute Website: www.shatec.sg Singapore Coffee Association (SCA) Website: www.singaporecoffee.org Singapore Customs Website: www.customs.gov.sg Singapore Food Manufacturers Association (SFMA) Website: www.sfma.org.sg Singapore Fruits and Vegetables Importers and Exporters Association (SFVA) Website: www.singaporefva.com Singapore Hotel Association (SHA) Website: www.sha.org.sg Spring Singapore Website: www.spring.gov.sg FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 65 Swiss Business Association, Singapore Website: www.swissbusiness.org.sg The Food and Beverage Managers’ Association (FBMA) Website: www.fbma.sg 9.3. PUBLICATIONS Appetite Asia Website: www.appetite-asia.com Cuisine & Wine Asia Website: www.asiacuisine.com.sg Epicure Asia Website: http://epicureasia.com/ Expat Living Website: www.expatliving.sg Food and Travel Magazine Website: www.foodandtravel.com/travel/gourmet-traveller/category/republic-of-singapore The Peak Magazine Website: www.thepeakmagazine.com/sg/peak-selections-gourmet-and-travel Wine and Dine Website: www.wineanddine.com.sg 9.4. IMPORT DUTIES Singapore Import Duties HS Code Product Description Customs Duty Excise Duty 21069061 Alcoholic preparations in liquid form as raw material for making composite concentrates of a kind used for the manufacture of alcoholic beverages Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 21069062 Alcoholic preparations in other forms being raw material for making composite concentrates of a kind used for the manufacture of alcoholic beverages Nil $90.00 per kg 21069064 Alcoholic composite concentrates in liquid form for simple dilution with water of a kind used for the manufacture of alcoholic beverages Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 21069065 Alcoholic composite concentrates in other forms for simple dilution with water of a kind used for the manufacture of alcoholic beverages Nil $90.00 per kg FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 66 21069066 Other alcoholic preparations in liquid form of a kind used for the manufacture of alcoholic beverages Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 21069067 Other alcoholic preparations in other forms of a kind used for the manufacture of alcoholic beverages Nil $90.00 per kg 22030010 Stout or porter $16.00 per liter of alcohol $48.00 per liter of alcohol* 22030090 Other beer including ale $16.00 per liter of alcohol $48.00 per liter of alcohol* 22041000 Sparkling wine Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22043020 Other grape must over 15% alcoholic Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22051010 Vermouth & other wine of fresh grape flavored with plants or aromatic substances not over 15% alcoholic in containers of 2l or less Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22051020 Vermouth & other wine of fresh grape flavored with plants or aromatic substances over 15% alcoholic in containers of 2l or less Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22059010 Vermouth & other wine of fresh grape flavored with plants or aromatic substances not over 15% alcoholic in containers of more than 2l Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22059020 Vermouth & other wine of fresh grape flavored with plants or aromatic substances over 15% alcoholic in containers of more than 2l Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22060010 Cider & perry Nil $48.00 per liter of alcohol* 22060020 Sake Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22060030 Toddy Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22060040 Shandy Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22060091 Other rice wine Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22060099 Other fermented beverages mixtures of fermented beverages & mixtures of fermented beverages & nonalcoholic beverages Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22071000 Undenatured ethyl alcohol of alcoholic strength by vol of 80% or more Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22082050 Brandy obtained by distilling grape wine or grape marc Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22082090 Other spirits obtained by distilling grape wine or grape marc Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22083000 Whiskies Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22084000 Rum & other spirits distilled from fermented sugar- Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 67 cane products 22085000 Gin & geneva Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22086000 Vodka Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22087000 Liqueurs & cordials Nil $70.00 per liter of alcohol* 22089010 Medicated samsu not over 40% alcoholic $8.00 per liter of alcohol $70.00 per liter of alcohol* Source: Singapore Customs Note: Formulae for computation of duty payable on liquors: Duty = Total quantity in litre x $70.00 x % of alcoholic strength FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 68 ExportHelp www.switzerland-ge.com/exporthelp exporthelp@switzerland-ge.com T 0844 811 812 Switzerland Global Enterprise Stampfenbachstrasse 85 CH-8006 Zürich T +41 44 365 51 51 Switzerland Global Enterprise Corso Elvezia 16 – CP 5399 CH-6901 Lugano T +41 91 911 51 35 Switzerland Global Enterprise Avenue d’Ouchy 47 – CP 315 CH-1001 Lausanne T +41 21 613 35 70 www.switzerland-ge.com FOOD AND BEVERAGE MARKET SINGAPORE 69