Buddhism RMPS Intermediate 1 / 2 Course Notes Part 2 The Goal and the Means 1 Contents Introduction (page 2) The goal of Buddhism Nirvana (Page 2 - ) Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism (page 5) The Arahat Theravada Buddhism (page 5) The Bodhisattva in Mahayana Buddhism (page 6) The Means of reaching the goal The Buddha (see Part 1) The Four Noble Truths (see Part 1) The Noble Eightfold Path (page 6 - 9 ) The Five Precepts (page 10) Meditation (page 13 - 14) Samatha meditation (page 14 - 15) Vipassana meditation (page 15) Worship in Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism (page 16 ) APPENDIX Success criteria (page 17) 2 Introduction In part two we are turning our attention to the goal of Buddhism and the means of achieving that goal. Every religion teaches that human existence is flawed in some way and we are all in need of salvation. Buddhism is no different. You have learned already that for Buddhism the flaw in our existence is suffering (Dukkha) cause by our craving (Tanha) which keeps us from every finding lasting peace and happiness and traps us in the endless cycle of Samsara. You have also learned that the Buddha taught that craving (Tanha) can be stopped and that we can find peace and happiness. Every Buddhist believes that reaching true peace and happiness and the perfect state of nirvana is possible for everyone. If we follow the Buddha’s teaching of the Eightfold Path this is where it leads. Remember for Buddhists the belief in the concept of compassion is important. To live a life of compassion means that you are not all self centred in your attitudes. You display a deep feeling of sympathy towards others who are suffering and you have a desire to help them overcome their suffering and find peace and happiness. When talking about the final goal to which the Eightfold Path leads, Buddhists refer to this as reaching Nibbana (Pali) or Nirvana (Sanskrit). The Goal of Buddhism is Nirvana The goal of Buddhism is to reach Nirvana sometimes called Nibbana. This is the perfect state of peace and happiness in which all suffering has come to an end and the individual is set free from the cycle of Samsara. About Nirvana The word Nirvana means to ‘blow out’ Nirvana is reached when the flames of suffering are extinguished, or blown out. This is what the Third Noble Truth states (craving can be stopped). The flames of suffering are fuelled by greed, hatred and ignorance, the three root poisons. Nirvana is NOT heaven. The Buddha was not interested in the question what is it that exists in Nirvana, or where they go? 3 He was more interested in the present here and now. It is easier to explain what Nirvana is not rather than what it is. The Buddha said Nirvana cannot be explained it can only be experienced Nirvana is a state of mind that is free from craving. It is freedom from the driving force or power of greed, hatred and ignorance. It is freedom from the cycle of Samsara, death and rebirth It can be understood as Enlightenment or Liberation. It can be achieved when you are still alive. Summing up Nirvana is about two important things: 1. Waking up to reality. (Seeing clearly the way things are) 2. Becoming one with reality (Acting according to your awareness) Blown Out 1. Nirvana is the goal of the Buddhist religion. The Eightfold Path leads to the destination. Samsara has ended, the wheel has stopped turning The flames of suffering are no longer burning. 2. Craving has ceased, the poisons are no more. Arahat or Bodhisatva they stand at the door. Its something you experience and can’t explain. Nirvana the goal is on a different plain. 3. We all can reach it, if we try very hard. To stay on the path you must watch your guard. For desire is lurking without a doubt. But the flames of suffering can be blown out. 4 Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism Introduction Just in the same as religions such as Hinduism, Judaism and Christianity divide up into different groups such as Protestants and Catholics to use Christianity as an example. The same has happened within Buddhism. These groups emerged because of various disputes about the understanding of the teaching of the Buddha. The two groups or sects as they are sometimes called are Theravada Buddhism and Mahayana Buddhism. The word Theravada means ‘The way of the elders’ and the word Mahayana means ‘greater vehicle’. Mahayana Buddhists refer to Theravada Buddhism as Hinayana Buddhism which mean ‘lesser vehicle’ This is explained below. In this course you will have to know in what ways these two groups are different in their understanding of the Buddha’s teaching. The reason I am mentioning these two groups here, is because they both have different views on how a person can reach Nirvana, although both accept the Noble Eightfold Path is the way. It is also about self help. So what are these groups saying about how to reach Nirvana. Let’s look at the Theravada group first. The Arahat in Theravada Buddhists They believe Nirvana can be reached in this life. It is not something that comes after death. When someone attains Nirvana in their life the Theravadan Buddhists call that person an Arahat (an enlightened person). You are most likely to become an Arahat if you are a monk or nun, rather than an ordinary (lay) person because you have less distractions in your life and can focus more on following the Eightfold Path. This is why they are known as the lesser vehicle. This means that fewer people will reach Nirvana, because not all become monks and nuns. When a person reaches the stage of being an Arahat this is the stage before entering into Nirvana. This is the state of paranirvana. When the Arahat dies he leaves the cycle of Samsara and enters into Nirvana never to be reborn. 5 The Bodhisattva in Mahayana Buddhism The Mahayana Buddhists also believe in following the Eightfold path to reach Nirvana. But they believe that the Theravadan way is too difficult. This is because they say you have to become a monk or nun. The Mahayana Buddhists believe that anyone is capable of reaching Nirvana, and that you do not need to become a monk or a nun to speed things up. This is why they are called the ‘greater vehicle’. More people can reach Nirvana. For them when a person reaches the point where the flames of suffering have been blown out and craving has ceased they become a Bodhisatva which mean ‘a being of enlightenment’. A Bodhisatva is respected because he could leave the cycle of Samsara behind and enter into Nirvana becoming a Buddha. But he chooses not to. Instead he chooses to be reborn in order to help others reach enlightenment. It is this belief in the Bodisattva that sets Mahyana Buddhism apart from Theravada Buddhism. Theravada Buddhists believe that they can pray to a Bodhisattva and get help to progress to a better rebirth. This is called the ‘transference of merit’. This attitude of the Bodhisattva demonstrates the importance of compassion which means that you are not all self centred in your attitudes. You display a deep feeling of sympathy towards others who are suffering and you have a desire to help them overcome their suffering and find peace and happiness. The Dalai Lama often speaks about compassion. M – B T – A Mahayana (Greater vehicle) - Bodhisatva Theravada (lesser vehicle) - Arahat 6 The Noble Eightfold Path The Fourth Noble truth stated that the way to reach Nirvana was to follow the teaching of the Buddha known as the Eightfold Path. The Eightfold Path is therefore the means by which a person can achieve Nirvana. It probably will take many lives, before you reach the goal. But by following the path you can ensure a better rebirth each time. The Eightfold Path is also known as the Middle Way. It is when you live between the two extremes of luxury and poverty. Living your life with everything in moderation is what the Buddha said was the best way. The symbol of Buddhism the wheel is known as the Damma wheel. The wheel began to turn when the Buddha first began teaching his followers. The eight spokes of the wheel stand for the eight steps of the path. There is no order of sequence among the steps. There is not one that comes before any of the others. Some describe them as eight paths all interchanging and mixing with each other. All leading to Nirvana. The eight steps of the path fall into three categories., which are sometimes referred to as the Three Ways. These are Wisdom, Morality and Meditation. Right View Right Intention Right Speech Right Action Right Livelihood Wisdom (Understanding the truth about existence and the effect of this on our actions as we live our lives) Morality (Living by applying the basic Buddhists principles in order to decide what is the right thing to do in any given situation) Right Effort Right Mindfulness Meditation (This is about training your mind to see the Right Concentration truth clearly and get rid of all that will hinder you as you journey along the path) 7 Four Aspects of the Noble Eightfold Path For your purposes in studying Buddhism at Intermediate 2 level, you need to know what is meant by the following: Right Intention Right Action Right Livelihood Right Speech Right Intention. Is found under the grouping which we call the Way of Wisdom. This is about your attitude to life Having the right motivation to follow the path It should be your intention to always to act in a selfless way. Actions that are skilful involve having the right intention It should be your intention to Remove thoughts of a self It should be your intention to banish selfish thoughts and replace them with selfless thoughts It is your intention to focus on reaching enlightenment It should be your intention to live and act in ways that are not influenced by the three root poisons. Right Action. Is found in the grouping called the way of morality This is a practical step and demands application It is about always trying to do the right thing It is about acting in a way that cause least harm or suffering It is about being aware of how actions affect others It is about being in control of one’s actions. It is about thinking about the consequences of your actions Intentional actions carry karmic consequences It about always trying to act in a skilful way It is about trying to avoid acting in an unskilful way 8 Skilful and Unskilful actions An action is skilful if the action is carried out with the right intention. That is to bring about good. Not a selfish and greedy motivated action. It is an action that is done after careful consideration of the consequences. This means thinking how this action will affect others and the will happen as a result of the action. Will this action bring about good? Will it bring harm? It is an action that is your action, that you have decided is a good, helpful, caring, or right thing to do. An unskilful action is an action with wrong or bad intentions, does not consider the consequences and is motivated by the three poisons greed, hatred and ignorance. NOTE It is skilful actions that lead to good karma and a better rebirth and eventually enlightenment Right Livelihood. Is found under the grouping which is the way of Morality. This is a practical step. It is something you do. Its about doing a job or earning a living in a way that does not cause suffering. (e.g. doctor, nurse, vet, joiner, plumber, teacher) Its about not working at a job that exploits animals, children or people’s health and the environment. Some Buddhist’s may have difficulty working in the cigarette or alcohol industry or in the manufacturing of weapons. Also jobs that exploit animals or damage the environment should be avoided. Right Speech. Is also found in the grouping way of Morality. Again this is a practical thing. Avoid telling lies Avoid gossip Avoid boasting Avoid talking behind people’s backs Avoid speech that is hurtful, putting people down. 9 The Always speak in a thoughtful way Speech can cause great harm Speak in a way that is helpful, encouraging and kind Speak in an honest way but do not be cruel Skilful speech is encouraged think about your intention and the consequences of what you say. benefits of following the Eightfold Path are: Helps overcome suffering. Gives guidelines on how to live free from craving Helps to overcome attachment and gain good Karma Helps to free ones self from samsara It brings calm and peace to a person and helps gain wisdom Creates a freer and more tolerant society Some difficulties of trying to follow the Eightfold path are It is hard to keep to the path. Responsibilities of work and family take up time Pressure of work and the time work takes, can keep people from following the path. Other attachments and cravings which we are exposed to in the modern world hinder our progress. Sometimes the path might not seem realistic in the busy modern life. Some Buddhists believe that you have to withdraw to a monastry to progress along the path quicker. The Five Precepts Before we look at the Five Precepts, we need to look at what we call ‘Ethics’ Ethics is a word which refers to thinking about what is right and wrong (morality). Doing the right thing is important to all human beings even those who are not religious. Ethics is something everyone is interested in. Everyone has opinions on what is the right thing or the wrong thing to do. When we take 10 time to sit down and think about what we think is right or wrong, then we are doing Ethics. Most religions set out rules and regulations about what is right and wrong believing that these are the commands of God. But Buddhism says that you have to work out from within yourself what is right and wrong. Doing the right thing is good for all sots of reasons. It makes you as a person feel good when you do what is right. It makes the world a better place to live in when people do good rather than bad. People admire and respect those who do what is right, condemning and punishing those who chose to do what is wrong. Buddhists also believe that doing the right thing and avoiding doing bad creates good karma which will affect a person’s next rebirth. Buddhists know that there are certain right ways to behave. The Eightfold Path lays down the guidelines. But what does this mean in practice? The Five Precepts set out further guidelines on how to live a good life. Any Buddhist can follow these precepts. By doing so you are keeping closely to the Guidelines and spirit of the Noble Eightfold Path. Do not see these as strict rule more as training aids to help you make progress towards enlightenment. The five precepts are K 1. I undertake to refrain from killing 2. I undertake to refrain from stealing S 3. I undertake to refrain from misusing sexuality S 4. I undertake to refrain from harmful speech S D 5. I undertake to refrain from taking drugs So how are they generally interpreted? 1. I undertake to refrain from killing K This could mean avoiding killing an animal, or even an insect. But this does not mean that all Buddhists are vegetarian. Some Buddhists such as the Dalai Lama eat meat. Buddhists monks who carry begging bowls are 11 sometimes given meat which they eat. But the idea behind the precept is that they should not take life or cause unnecessary suffering or harm. All living things are in the cycle of Samsara. We should help them along towards enlightenment, not cut their life short. It also applies to avoiding killing people. Because of this some Buddhist engage in the martial arts which concentrate on defence rather than attack. They want to learn how to avoid killing an enemy. The aim rather to disarm the attacker. Buddhist refuse to support any action that causes harm. They will speak out against war, injustice, cruelty and aggression and any human right abuses.. They encourage environmental protection and the preservation of species. 2. I undertake to refrain from stealing S Obviously this means not taking people’s property that does not belong to you. But it can also apply to giving back change if you have been given to much. Not dodging your fare on the train. Not buying products like clothes from a shop that is cheap because they do not pay their workers a good wage. 3. I undertake to refrain from harmful speech S This obviously means not telling lies. Sometimes we mislead people by not telling them everything they should know. This is also a form of lying. Sometimes if someone asks us if we heard what they said and we say yes, when the truth was actually no, them this too is a form of lying. If we exaggerate a story or when explaining what happened then this too is lying. Sometimes people say one thing to one person and another thing to another. This too is not being truthful. But remember there are some situations when the best thing to do is to lie. It all depends on the situation. Remember what it means to act skilfully. Is your intention good? Are the consequences good? 4. I undertake to refrain from misusing sexuality 12 S This precept obviously suggests that rape, paedophilia and incest are wrong. These are obvious to everyone. But it also refers to using someone selfishly for your own personal pleasure or enjoyment without really caring for them or their feelings. Also some people can be obsessed with sex which distracts them from following the path. 5. I undertake to refrain from taking drugs D Buddhists believe that drugs and alcohol are not healthy because of the way they affect our personalities, and our self control. When under their influence we act in ways that we would not normally do. We lose our concentration and our awareness of what we are doing, to keep to the path. We end up acting in a way that is unskilful. Remember drugs and alcohol can lead to horrible accidents. They can lead to violence and abuse. Buddhists also want people to be aware of reality, drugs cloud reality, distort reality. Ethics for Monks and nuns The moral rules for monks are far more detailed. If you decide to become a monk, then you have further many more rules over and above the Five precepts. The Five further precepts of the monastic life are: 1. To abstain from food after midday; 2. To abstain from a luxurious bed, ie to sleep on a mat; 3. To abstain from frivolous amusements, e.g. music, dancing, shows. 4. To abstain from personal adornments, ie no jewellery, and to wear only the monk’s basic rob; 5. To touch no silver or gold, ie to have nothing to do with money The practice of Meditation Meditation is probably one of the first things that come to mind when people think about Buddhism. We are now going to turn our attention to understanding what the importance of meditation is within the religion of Buddhism. 13 Meditation is the eighth part of the Noble Eightfold Path. So it is not an end in itself, it serves the purpose of helping Buddhist along the path towards enlightenment. Some western non Buddhist practice meditation to calm themselves down or relax, but in Buddhism meditation is much more than this. So what is meditation? It’s a stilling of the mind. Our minds are usually full of thoughts and distractions. Every moment of every day our minds are bombarded by sounds and thoughts. So meditation involves a quieting and stilling of the mind. It’s about perceiving reality. It’s about achieving an altered state of consciousness and becoming aware of the way things are. While meditating a Buddhist is consciously thinking about what is real and true. It’s a training of the mind to focus on specific things rather than fleeting from one thought to the next. During meditation a Buddhist can focus on anything. Some examples may be to focus on the teachings of the Buddha, a Buddha image, a flower, a mandala pattern, a tree or just your breathing. So what are the benefits of meditation? The Buddha taught that there are seven important benefits from meditation. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Getting rid of defilements. (the emotions that keep us from progressing) Putting aside sorrow and worry. (Not allowing these to dominate us) Getting over miseries. (getting over life’s disappointments) Ending physical suffering. Ending mental suffering. Attaining the early stages of Nirvana. Attaining Nirvana itself. All forms of meditation have the same things in common. Mindfulness of the things around you in order to see things clearly. Different attitudes to the importance or centrality of Meditation 14 Some Buddhists think that meditation is very important in the journey towards enlightenment. It is a central part of the Eightfold Path. Theravada Buddhists believe that achieving wisdom is the way to reach enlightenment. It is an important part of the life of monks and nuns as they live in the Sangha (a Buddhist spiritual community) It is necessary for reaching enlightenment, as it helps a person to see things as they really are. It helps to get rid of the three root poisons in one’s life, which hinder one’s journey. Others however regard living a good life and concentrating on right action, speech and livelihood is more important. Having compassion for all beings is important. The Morality aspect of the Eightfold Path which leads to enlightenment is given more priority in the Mahayana tradition of Buddhism. They also believe that you can gain good Karma from a Holy man or a Bodhisattva. This gaining of merit from another is called the ‘Transference of Merit’ leading to good karma. Always acting in a skilful way, they say brings greater peace to the world and the lives of others around you. It helps you gain a better rebirth and progress towards enlightenment. Being compassionate and selfless, caring for others is not so self centred as meditation seems to be. There are two main types of meditation. 1. Samatha meditation: Stilling This is sometimes called ‘calming meditation’. It is linked closely to the Theravada tradition. The aim of this meditation is to still and calm the mind. It helps our minds to be still. To stop the bombardment our minds experience which we spoke of above. It helps us to focus on what really matters. This is the first step to seeing things clearly. When you are mindful of what you are doing, you are in a better position to understand and put into practice the teachings of the Buddha. This will benefit you and others. To gain this stillness is the first step of meditation towards enlightenment. To start Samatha meditation all you will 15 do is focus on your breathing. When stray thoughts enter your mind you should be aware of them but let them pass. Once your mind is still you can concentrate your mind on thinking about: Positive thoughts about all beings. Start with self love and radiate out to others. Think about how you can help others who suffer. Think about sharing the joy of others who are happy. Think about experiencing love for everything equally. Vipassana meditation: revealing Sometimes referred to as ‘insight meditation’. This involves more focusing of the mind on the true reality of things. It is a more intellectual process. It involves the person meditating in analysing his own physical and mental states, and the environment he lives in. It involves deep thinking about the teachings of Buddhism, such as the Four Noble truths, Dukkha (suffering), Anicca (impermanence) and Anatta (No self). The idea is to make these real in your own experience. Once this has happened you gained what is called vipassana (insight) into oneself and the world, and to have increased in wisdom. It is Vipassana meditation that leads to enlightenment because it is helping the person reach a true realisation of the true nature of reality and get rid of the negative hinderances. Worship in the Theravada and the Mahayana traditions It may sound strange to talk about Buddhist worship when you have been told that Buddhist do not believe in God. Well Buddhism a large and varied religion which has developed in different parts of the world over hundreds of years. Their traditions of worship can be quite different. Some Buddhists do believe in gods and in helpful and unhelpful spiritual beings. Worship for them involves keeping on the side of the good spiritual beings. Mahayana Buddhists also believe that appealing to Bodhisatvas can help them progress towards enlightenment. 16 Buddhist worship can involve the following: Showing the Buddha reverence Learning the teachings of the Buddha Reciting key Buddhist ideas Sharing with other Buddhists in your common journey You can use visual aids top help you focus on the teachings of the Buddha. Celebrating special events in the life of the Buddha. Worship in the Theravada tradition of Buddhism For monks and nuns it is rarely more that reciting Buddhist teachings. Lay Buddhists do this too, but will also make offerings to Buddha statues. Focus is often on the image of the Buddha Giving of food to the monks in the Sangha (religious community) Worship in the Mahayana tradition of Buddhism Much more elaborate, colourful and varied. It includes, chanting, special rituals for certain events or times of year. Prayers, mantras chanted or written on colourful prayer flags. The spinning of prayer wheels.(hand held or floor mounted) Praying to Bodhisattva’s to help you on your journey to enlightenment Often involves a mixture of older religious traditions which have been adopted by Buddhism. 17 RMPS Higher: Intermediate 1 / 2 World Religion: Buddhism (Part 2) The Goal and the Means Success Criteria What you need to know in order to pass an assessment You need to be able to: 1. Explain the importance of the law of Karma and how it works. 2. State the Four Noble Truths and explain the connection between them. 3. Give an understanding of the concept of Nirvana 4. Explain the difference between an Arahat in the Theravada tradition and a Bodhisattva in the Mahayana tradition. 5. Explain the purpose of the Noble Eightfold Path. 6. Describe how it divides up into the three sections or ‘ways’ 7. Explain what is meant by Right Intention; Right Speech; Right Action; Right Livelihood. 8. State what the Five Precepts are. 9. Explain what they mean in practical living 10. Describe the two types of meditation 11. Explain the importance of meditation 18 12. Explain what is meant by worship and describe worship practice and experience in both the Theravada and the Mahayana traditions. 19