Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Background Rigid Frame Bridges A rigid frame bridge is one in which the piers and the girder are one solid structure. The cross sections of the beams in a rigid frame bridge are usually I shaped or box shaped. The styles used almost exclusively are the pi-shaped frame, the batter post frame, and the V shaped frame. The batter post rigid frame bridge is particularly well suited for river and valley crossings because piers tilted at an angle can straddle the crossing more effectively without requiring the construction of foundations in the middle of the river or piers in deep parts of a valley. Figure 1. Batter post rigid frame bridge. V-shaped frames make effective use of foundations. Each V-shaped pier provides two supports to the girder, reducing the number of foundations and creating a less cluttered profile. Figure 2. V-shaped frame bridge. Pi shaped rigid frame structures are used frequently as the piers and supports for inner city highways. The frame supports the raised highway and at the same time allows traffic to run directly under the bridge. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 1 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Figure 3. Pi shaped rigid frame bridge. Some Examples… Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 2 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Truss Bridges The truss is a simple skeletal structure. In design theory, the individual members of a simple truss are only subject to tension and compression forces and not bending forces. Thus, for the most part, all beams in a truss bridge are straight. Trusses are comprised of many small beams that together can support a large amount of weight and span great distances. In most cases the design, fabrication, and erection of trusses is relatively simple. However, once assembled trusses take up a greater amount of space and, in more complex structures, can serve as a distraction to drivers. There are both simple and continuous trusses. The small size of the individual parts of a truss make it the ideal bridge for places where large parts or sections cannot be shipped or where large cranes and heavy equipment cannot be used during erection. Because the truss is a hollow skeletal structure, the roadway may pass over (Figure 4) or even through (Figure 5) the structure allowing for clearance below the bridge often not possible with other bridge types. Figure 4. Roadway passing over the truss structure. Figure 5. Roadway passing through the truss structure. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 3 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Trusses are also classified by the basic design used. The most representative trusses are the Warren truss, the Pratt truss, and the Howe truss. The Warren truss is perhaps the most common truss for both simple and continuous trusses. For smaller spans, no vertical members are used lending the structure a simple look (Figure 5). For longer spans vertical members are added providing extra strength (Figure 4). Warren trusses are typically used in spans of between 50100m. The Pratt truss (Figure 6) is identified by its diagonal members which, except for the very end ones, all slant down and in toward the center of the span. Except for those diagonal members near the center, all the diagonal members are subject to tension forces only while the shorter vertical members handle the compressive forces. This allows for thinner diagonal members resulting in a more economic design. Figure 6. Pratt truss bridge. The Howe truss (Figure 7) is the opposite of the Pratt truss. The diagonal members face in the opposite direction and handle compressive forces. This makes it very uneconomic design for steel bridges and its use is rarely seen. Figure 7. Howe truss bridge. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 4 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Some example… Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 5 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Mathematical Concepts Quick Review – Simple Algebra AxB=CxD A= (C x D) / B Sample Problem Set 1. Solving for the given variable. Ax3=2x6 A=_________ A x 4 = 12 x 5 A=_________ 8 x B = 3 x 16 B=_________ Bx9=3x6 B=_________ 11 x 4 = C x 2 C=_________ 45 x 9 = 5 x C C=_________ 100 x 20 = 50 x D D=_________ 55 x 23 = D x 11 D=_________ Sample Problem Set 2. Solve for the given variable (include units) A x 3 in. = 2 lbs x 6in. A=_________ A x 4 lbs = 12in. x 5lbs A=_________ 8N x B = 3m x 16N B=_________ B x 9mm = 3km x 6mm B=_________ 11m x 4N = C x 2N C=_________ 45tons x 9yd = 5tons x C C=_________ 100in x 20lbs = 50in x D D=_________ 55cm x 23N = D x 11N D=_________ Units of Force F=mxa F= Force (Newtons, Pound Force) m = mass (kilogram, slug) a = acceleration (m/s², ft/s², in/s²) Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 6 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Pythagorean Theorem a2 + b2 = c2 Force Balancing The same algebraic expressions can be used to solve for an unknown variable. C A B D Sample Problem Set 3. A 25 Newton block is 5 meters away from center of beam. A 100 Newton man wants to lift the block and balance the beam. How far from the center must the man stand to lift the block? ANSWER:________________________ A 75 lb student wants to balance a beam. A 30 lb block is 4 ft from the center. Where should the student stand to balance the beam? ANSWER:________________________ Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 7 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Point Loads and Moments In a bridge, the sum of all the forces acting on all the members will equal zero. A C B D E Therefore Fa + Fb + Fc = 0 To Find Pin Forces (A,B) use the following: B = (C x D)/ (D+E) A = (C x E)/(D+E) 300 lbs A B 70 ft 30 ft Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 8 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Sample Problem Set 4. From figure above, find the forces at A and B. Force A = _________________ Force B = _________________ Statically Determinate Trusses The Pratt and Howe Trusses are statically determinate. A truss structure is statically determinate if the member forces are determined entirely by the conditions of static equilibrium at the joints. This means that the sum of all the forces at a joint is equal to zero. Figure 8. Bridge Joint. Method of Joints To balance the forces in a truss structure using the method of joints, we begin with a joint at a reaction force and isolate that joint. We then sum the horizontal and the vertical forces on it. The sum of the horizontal forces should equal zero. The sum of the vertical forces should also equal zero. We can now solve for any unknown forces by proceeding joint by joint through the bridge only picking up two new unknowns at each joint until we reach the other reaction. Let us solve the following example using the method of joints. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 9 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Let us assume that W, the weight of the truss, is 15N. The length of side a is 4m and the length of side b is 3m. Angle ABC is equal to the angle formed by line BC and the line of the force F2. First, let us solve for the length of side c. We use the Pythagorean theorem to obtain the following equation: a2 + b 2 = c2 42 + 3 2 = c2 16 + 9 = c2 25 = c2 c = 5 Before we begin examining the joints, let us go over how we indicate direction of forces. A force acts along a line or member. The member will either be in tension or compression. The following illustrate the direction of the force for a member in tension and a member in compression. We can think of a member in tension as something that is being pulled apart. The force is equal on both ends, but in opposite directions. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 10 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges We can think of a member in compression as something that is being pushed, or compressed together from each end. The force is equal on both ends, but, again, in opposite directions. When examining the forces, just as when we graph on the coordinate plane, we have to keep in mind their positive and negative directions. Up and to the right is positive. Down and to the left is negative. We have to indicate their signs when placing them into algebraic equations so that we can solve them correctly. Now, let us examine Joint A. We will begin by summing the forces in the vertical direction: FV = 0 = 12 - FAB(4/5) 12 = FAB(4/5) 12(5/4) = FAB Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 11 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges FAB = 15 Now we will sum the forces in the horizontal direction: FH = 0 = -FAC - FAB(3/5) FAB = 15 (from vertical Joint A analysis) FAC = -15(3/5) FAC = -9 Next we will move on to Joint C. Again, we will begin by summing the forces in the horizontal direction: FH = 0 = FAC – F3 FAC = -9 (from joint A analysis) -9 = – F3 F3 = 9N Next, we sum the forces in the vertical direction: FV = 0 = FBC – W Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 12 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges W = 15 (we were given this) 0 = FBC – 15 FBC = 15 Finally, we move to Joint B. From previous analyses, we know that FAB = 15 and that FBC = 15. We will redraw the diagram to include what we know. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 13 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Now, let us sum the forces in the vertical direction: FV = 0 = -15(4/5) – 15 – F2(4/5) F2(4/5) = 15(4/5) – 15 F2 = -3.75 N (a negative sign in front of the force means that we drew it in the wrong direction) F2 = 3.75 N Finally, we will sum the forces in the horizontal direction keeping F2 drawn in its original direction: FH = 0 = 15(3/5) + F2(3/5) – F1 F1 = 15(3/5) + F2(3/5) F2 = -3.75 N (from vertical Joint B analysis) F1 = 15(3/5) – 3.75(3/5) F1 = 9 – 2.25 F1 = 6.75N Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 14 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges We have now used the method of joints to solve for all the unknown forces in this truss structure. Sample Problem Set 5. Try solving for the unknown forces in the following diagram using the method of joints. Let us assume that W, the weight of the truss, is 20N. The length of side a is 8m and the length of side b is 6m. Angle ABC is equal to the angle formed by line BC and the line of the force F2. The 10N reaction force is along the same line as line AB. Method of Sections Using the method of sections, we consider the forces acting on some larger part of the bridge. In the following diagram, we would analyze the forces acting on triangle ABC, the entire shaded region, rather than the forces acting on each individual joint, as before. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 15 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Let us assume again that W, the weight of the truss, is 15N. The length of side a is 4m and the length of side b is 3m. The length of side c is as we determined earlier, 5m. Angle ABC is equal to the angle formed by line BC and the line of the force F2. We begin by summing the moments about B. MB = 0 = -F3(4) + 12(3) F3(4) = 12(3) F3 = 9N Next, we sum the forces in the vertical direction: FV = 0 = 12 – 15 – F2(4/5) F2(4/5) = 12-15 F2 = -3(5/4) F2 = -3.75 (again, a negative sign in front of the force means that we drew it in the wrong direction) F2 = 3.75 N Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 16 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Finally, let us sum the forces in the horizontal direction: FH = 0 = F3 – F1 + F2(3/5) F3 = 9N (from moment summation) F2 = -3.75 (from vertical force summation) F1 = F3 + F2(3/5) F1 = 9 – 3.75(3/5) F1 = 6.75N As, you can see, we come up with the same results using the method of joints and the method of sections. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 17 Engineering GatorTRAX University of Florida College of Engineering Rigid Frame & Truss Bridges Sample Problem Set 6. Try solving for the unknown forces in the last sample problem using the method of sections. Check to see that you obtain the same results as before. Again, we will assume that W, the weight of the truss, is 20N. The length of side a is 8m and the length of side b is 6m. Angle ABC is equal to the angle formed by line BC and the line of the force F2. The 10N reaction force is along the same line as line AB. Copyright 2004 by GatorTrax. Created, Designed, and Edited for GatorTrax programs. 18