Customized Employment Services Values Planning & Management Marketing Consumer Referral Assessment Job Development Work Site Analysis Job Matching Job Placement/Training Person/Job Supports Customer Satisfaction This is an actual program plan. The names have been changed to protect the guilty and the innocent WE WORK, INC. 10 Industry Lane Anytown, Iowa 90210 INDIVIDUAL PROGRAM PLAN Name: Bob Smith Casemanager: Jane Files Program Start Date: 10-31-77 Staffing Date: 7-21-94 Work Schedule: 9:00 to 12:30 Mon.-Fri. Work adjustment program--Work station: Shoes PROFILE: ATTENDANCE 1. Attendance 2. Punctuality 3. Time card usage 4. Break Promptness 5. Absence notification STRENGTHS NEEDS X X X X X WORK SKILLS 6. Initiative to start work 7. On task performance 8. Quantity of work 9. Remains at work station 10. Work area cleanup 11. Communicates production needs 12. Follows safety rules 13. Work attitude 14. Accepts worker role 15. Quality of work 16. Instruction needed X X X X X X X X X X X SOCIAL SKILLS 17. Suitable appearance 18. Co-worker interactions 19. Decision making 20. Interpersonal skills X X X X 2 WE WORK, INC. 10 Industry Lane Anytown, Iowa 90210 INDIVIDUAL PROGRAM PLAN Name: Bob Smith Casemanager: Jane Files Program Start Date: 10-31-77 Staffing Date: 7-21-94 VOCATIONAL GOAL: To obtain competitive employment working food service busing tables or washing dishes. Baseline: Bob is at level C in work skills (he needs to be at level F in order to be eligible for supported employment) Date initiated: 1991 Date of projected achievement: 2005 CURRENT VOCATIONAL PROGRAM: Goal 1: Increase quantity to 30.2% Baseline: 30.14% of standard Process Objective: Bob will increase Next process objective: Bob will increase his quantity to 30.25% Strategy: 1. Bob will work at his fastest pace at all times. 2. Bob will be prompted by case manager if he is noted off task and not working up to goal speed. 3. Bob will be reminded to not stare and keep his mind on work. 4. Bob will receive praise form case manager if noted working at goal speed. Note: Bob is currently 53 years old. 3 his quantity The Association for Persons in Supported Employment Ethical Guidelines for Professionals in Supported Employment Developed for APSE by: Dale DiLeo, Training Resource Network, Rebecca McDonald, UAP of NJUMDNJ and Susan Killam, AcME, Inc. Contribution in the community as a valued, interdependent member occurs when human dignity is respected and opportunities are provided for each individual to pursue their unique path of development and fulfillment. While paid human service professionals cannot create inclusive communities, they can positively impact their emergence and growth. For trainers of staff in supported employment, these basic human principles should be considered: Employment At all times, the individual receiving supports is the central driving force in the development of options and decisions. In the design of training specific to integrated employment, professionals have an obligation to reflect the following principles and accomplishments in an effort to promote services consistent with human dignity. Individuality People receive assistance as unique individuals with varying interests, preferences, and aptitudes. They should not be grouped together on the basis of label, functioning level, or convenience of support. Career Planning Employment should be an option for any person interested in working, regardless of label, support need, or perceived functioning level. Job seekers, or at their invitation, family, friends, or co-workers, are the best source to personally convey information of their personal interests, preferences, skills, aptitudes, and life goals. These considerations are the basis for choices in employment opportunity, rather than program or agency considerations. In accessing information, maximum use of personal networks and situational experiences provides information to help guide career support, rather than focusing on limitations which exclude people from possibilities. Individual rights to confidentiality are observed. Choice There are sufficient options related to each individual’s interests and desires in life in order to exercise control and autonomy over their life’s direction. The choices made by an individual are the result of being fully informed through direct personal experience and/or considering information on potential alternatives. Respect Services are always dignified, age appropriate, and enhancing. Participation People have the opportunity to actively participate in all their chosen pursuits of life. Job Development Approaches for developing employer relations and linking individuals with private and public sector labor needs are respectful and image enhancing. Jobs developed are reflective of personal interests, preferences, and abilities, as well as employer needs. Materials and interactions are professional and businesslike. People are not portrayed in ways which contribute to stereotypes or other misperceptions of individuals with disabilities. At no time is hiring pursued based on charity. Competence Individuals are provided opportunities to develop skills of interest and use in their lives by discovering and expressing gifts and capacities. Social Inclusion People have access to diverse individuals in social contexts in order to build friendships, working relationships, and networks of individuals who go to shared places, have similar interests, or experience other commonalties. Community Settings with Minimal Intrusion Job Acquisition Job placement decisions are made by the individual based on reliable information of job quality, work culture, and employee/employer benefit. Services are designed to support persons in their pursuit of a quality life in natural settings in ways which minimize artificiality or restrictiveness. 4 Jobs are individually arranged to match a person's interests, preferences, skills, aptitudes, and life goals. While some work experiences can be productive for building an employment history and developing skills, these experiences are thought of as initial career steps and not as career fulfillment. Compensation should reflect the norms of the employment market for similar positions and performance. When sub-minimum wages are provided, they are viewed as temporary until more creative job matching, training, or other supports can be developed to enhance productivity. Job placements are not made on the basis of service convenience or availability. perspective of personal future goals but is not contingent upon restrictive program guidelines concerning employment duration. Feedback on the success of positions within a career is dependent on the individual employee, employers, and the input of others important to and chosen by the person. Staff Training Training, both in topic and format, is generated by the needs of service recipients and their trainers and promotes skills and values development which will enhance the quality of life of individuals with disabilities. To this end, the following training principles are endorsed: • Training results in better learning outcomes when it is offered proactively rather than as a reaction to crisis situations. • The best training is an empowerment of individuals or agencies to become competent to provide their own ongoing training. • Training is an interactive process which needs to be ongoing to respond to dynamic needs and to ensure state-of-the-art practices are being conveyed. • There is respect and encouragement for what can be learned from each other from all training participants. • There is an effort to build local training capacity, leverage existing local resources, knowledge, and expertise, and design training sensitive to and effective within local culture. • No one trainer, technique, or approach has the one right answer. A trainer has an obligation to bring in the diversity of approaches from the field and to state when she/he does not have an answer. • Trainers keep current on state-of the-art in the field and do not present dated information. • There is an avoidance of presenting “quick-fix” solutions which go beyond the data presented. • Good adult learning principles are used in training design. • Trainees are active participants in identifying training outcomes and options based on what's needed to enhance the quality of life of individuals with disabilities. • An effort is made to assess the audience's needs and level of Work Support Existing supports natural to the work environment are maximized for training and ongoing support. Artificial training or programs to change behavior considered highly unusual by the work culture of the job setting are minimized. Teaching techniques which may convey poor images, stigma, or devalued status are not used. Best training practices and technology appropriate to the setting and culture are utilized. Appropriate evaluations and outcome measures are provided. Specialized jargon from the disability field is minimized. At all times, the business culture is respected and integrated into the support network for the individual to succeed. Use of accommodations, technology, or other job modifications needed are explored and developed in consideration of their potential for success, non-intrusiveness, and generalization to other life domains. Life Support Efforts to provide a holistic and integrated life service support are made. Individuals have consistent service and community opportunities which connect to the fabric of work, home, social, and recreational needs. Measures are taken to ensure that the individual's family members and friends are involved in planning efforts. Career Advancement Persons have the opportunity and support to advance to other employment opportunities which may provide new and/or greater responsibilities, compensation, and challenge. Advancement is based upon the 5 • Training is structured so that the trainees can apply skills easily and can share the informational content in a meaningful way with others. • The evaluation of training effectiveness is a complex but necessary process that is conducted regularly with trainees. understanding before any training is offered. • Whenever possible, follow-ups to training are done to see how the information presented is being implemented. Trainers need to stay involved in direct services and with the individuals served so their training remains grounded in reality. • Confidentiality of individual's personal life experiences are respected and maintained. • There is a commitment to respond to feedback from the training audience and to consider the evaluative information for future training. • Training is presented only in the areas in which the trainer is qualified. • Skill and value development require application and reinforcement. Trainees are encouraged to participate, reinforced for implementation of new skills, and supported to train others in their organizations and communities. APSE is a national membership organization committed to expanding and improving integrated employment opportunities and outcomes for persons with disabilities. For more information, please write, call, or e-mail: APSE 1627 Monument Avenue Richmond, VA 23220 Phone: (804)278-9187 FAX: (804)278-9377 6 William’s Story How Could This Have Been Avoided? Here’s What Happened: William expressed an interest in working in an office/clerical setting. He completes a job shadowing experience in an insurance office and says he likes it. The work experience coordinator carves out a 20 hour per week position in an insurance/real estate firm and negotiates an employer commitment to hire William if the interview goes well. William interviews for the position, is offered the job and turns it down. The teacher – he thought everything was in place for a good job for William. When he contacts William and his parents, he finds out that William turned down the job because the Friday hours conflicted with his weekly get together with a friend for lunch, going to the library and the YMCA, etc. 7 School to Work Transition Definition School-to-work programs provide ways for students to transition successfully into the economy, either through paid employment with a business or self-employment. Numerous studies reveal that, upon high school graduation, many students who aren't college-bound are neither prepared for nor connected to employment opportunities. Basic Elements In general, building a school-to-work transition program entails the following three approaches: 1. Integrate the long-separated "tracks" of academic and vocational education. From middle school on, schools should orient youth to work, help them explore different types of jobs, provide guidance about career paths, and assist them in finding work relevant to their needs and interests. Vocational education is considered too narrow and specific, outdated by modern technology, and ineffective in building language and math skills. Academic education is criticized for being too conventional, driven predominantly by standardized tests, and ineffective at motivating most students. 2. Link schooling with the demands and realities of the workplace. Through employment-related experiences and on-the-job learning, students can receive significant exposure to the workforce and can prepare for their future work environment. 3. Develop programs to closely coordinate secondary and post-secondary education with employers. Apprenticeships and school-business partnerships are just two of the many ways educators and businesspeople can produce a shared view of youth learning and development. These changes have extensive learning implications, particularly for high schools, including: Curriculum--Develop new models that integrate vocational and academic education, from revamping the guidance counseling system to creating a coherent sequence of courses related to broad occupational clusters. Instruction--Focus on experiential, project-based learning. Also, reduce the "tracking," or segregation, of students into either academic or vocational studies. Assessment--Use portfolios to gauge a student's employability. 8 Assessment Assessment is a tool designed to assist job seekers, their families and support system to develop a profile of skills, dreams, and support needs. Assessment is not used to “screen out people” but to answer the question – “what will it take”. File Review – school, medical, etc Person Centered Planning Community Mapping Work Site Assessment or Internship Talking with Family and friends Assessment or the “big picture of the person Hanging out with purpose Interest Inventories Job Shadows – career exploration 9 Other tests and formal vocational evaluations Community Work Site Assessment (otherwise know as Work Experience) A community work site assessment is a process to identify a person’s work skills, capabilities, interests, strengths and support needs in a business in the community. We have found it to be an effective assessment system that directly relates to individualized career/employment outcome and personalized support strategies. Ultimately the assessment’s goal should lead to answering questions that assist in developing supports that help people with disabilities get and keep jobs. Community work site assessment’s (sometimes know as internships, community-based assessments or situational assessments) are a useful means for gathering information regarding the individual’s employment and support needs and preferences. It allows the individual to perform real work in a real job within a business in the community. The sites are usually prearranged by the employment specialist based on the individual’s preferences. The assessment allows the employment specialist to observe the individual performing job-related tasks in addition to exposing the individual to specific jobs available in his/her locality. Maximizing opportunities for the individual to observe or try out many different types of jobs will greatly assist the person in determining what type of job he/she might desire as well as deciding the type of businesses and environments that are important to them. Assists the job seeker in designing their own future rather than giving them a “prescription” for employment; Family members and person being assessed have choices in designing assessment process and format; Evaluation summary and recommendations should be developed by the team including the person being assessed, family members and in some cases the employees at the assessment site; Assessing the work culture and receptivity of an employment site is as equally important as assessing the individual; Standardized assessment have little predictive validity in determining how successful a person can be in a future work setting; Quality of life outcomes are as important to measure as skills (look at the person holistically) The primary purpose for assessment data is for its inclusion in the job matching and support development process. What areas may be assessed? 1. Work-related behaviors – attendance, punctuality, hygiene, social behavior, cooperation, ability to accept criticism/supervision, initiative, perseverance, meeting work schedule, safety awareness. 2. Interests, attitudes, and knowledge of occupational information; 3. Aptitudes 4. Work skills and tolerances; 5. Learning style – including understanding and responding to various types of instruction; 6. Identification of the need for job site modifications which enhance the person’s employability and productivity; 7. Work environment factors. Guiding Principles of Community Work Site Assessment/Work Experience Emphasizes competencies not deficiencies; Process focuses on identifying supports rather than as a means of screening people out; 10 What do you tell an employer/business about Community Work Site Assessments/Work Experiences? 1. What is it? - A community work site assessment is a partnership between your agency and local businesses to create opportunities for people who are exploring different jobs to learn about the world of work – what they like or don’t like and what sort of help they might need to get and keep a job. They are very similar to internships that the business offers. 2. Discuss the benefits to the business (or what’s in it for you) Access to an untapped labor pool; Low risk test drive of your agencies services; Opportunity for your business to be recognized for its community leadership; A chance to share your expertise with others as they prepare for work; and Who knows you might like what you see. 3. Other area businesses who have partnered with you doing assessments and a brief description of what was done and how it worked. 4. Ask if they have any questions. Always refer them to talk with the work experience coordinator if you don’t know that specific answer. Common questions include: Wages – this will vary based on your agency – typically wages are paid only during the job trials and 11 are paid by your agency through funding received from vocational rehabilitation. Sometimes the business will pay (just like a temporary worker). The least preferred method is that it be an unpaid assessment. (Caution about unpaid experiences – it is difficult to fully assess what a worker will do when they get paid if you go this route.) Hours – this will be base upon the individual assessment that you are developing. Community Work Site Assessments have varied from 5 to 120 hours based upon what is being assessed. There will be no set answer for this since each assessment will be different. Liability – Most agencies have an insurance rider that will cover both the agency staff assessing the person and the worker while at the business. Since both people will be paid by the agency, liability and workers compensation costs are covered. What jobs – You will need to detail what sort of tasks/activities you would like to conduct in that specific business. In some you may only want a tour, while in others you may desire a 2 week job trial/experience. Talk specific with the business. Hiring? – Frequently businesses will want to know if they have either the obligation or the opportunity to hire the person being assessed. Make it clear to the business that the purpose of the assessment is for the person to learn about their business/industry, therefore there is no obligation to hire. But there is nothing stopping them from offering the person a job if they decide that they’d like to. A little exercise . . . . . . . Describe yourself as you would want an employment service to describe you to a perspective employer. 12 The Business of Job Development Businesses’ Perspectives on Working with Employment Agencies that Represent Workers with Disabilities. Overview Iowa Creative Employment Options (ICEO) convened a small focus group of major businesses in the Des Moines Area to explore the perceptions of, experiences with, and recommendations for employment agencies that are assisting people with disabilities to enter or re-enter the workforce. The information gathered is intended to help develop and refine training for community rehabilitation programs, policy, and systems change efforts that will lead to a business-driven model of employment for people with disabilities. On 3/31/00, ICEO staff met with two large corporations. Both businesses have hired workers with disabilities in the past and are reflective of large Iowa businesses in both their hiring practices and perspectives. Specifics of their businesses are not mentioned to protect their anonymity. One is a large insurance company; the other the corporate headquarters for retail and service stores. Both have multi-state operations and between them employee over 20,000 people. Their human resource functions differ as one uses a recruiter approach to bringing employees into the corporation; the other, local store managers have full hiring authority and use the human resource department for support and assistance. Nuggets of Wisdom On building relationships with businesses: The three most important factors in job development are relationship, relationship, relationship. Businesses really need to know about services and available resources. Keep them informed through regular contact. Most businesses are looking for workers and experience a fair amount of turnover at all levels. Stop in regularly to either visit your old contact or introduce yourself and your services to a new one. Similar to what recruiters within the business do, these businesses recommend that you: 1. Establish main contact within the business; 2. Invite that contact to get to know your agency – either tours of your agency or of sites where you are working; 3. Come to the business to learn about jobs/expectations of the business – visit the managers, tour, and job shadow open positions. Get to know how the area really works. Credibility comes with relationships. Show us your success stories. If you simply call, how are businesses to know who the candidate is? Why should they trust you? Charity marketing – many groups approach these businesses (not just for employment), “we have to pick and choose” which thing to get involved in. You will experience much greater success if you sell the benefits to the business and the skills of the worker. On developing a specific job for a specific individual. Do what recruiters within the businesses do – get to know the job and the manager. As one participant said “it has to impact my bottom-line to keep any worker.” 1. Identify open positions 2. Match skills and background of worker with available position 13 3. Look at professionalism, communication, aptitudes, competency and attitudes of worker to see how they’d fit in that area 4. Refer qualified candidates straight to the manager 5. If need be, sell candidate to manager. Things that they’d look for include: Sell skills from past jobs during the interview; How well they interview; Look for transferable skills to share; Trust judgment of others – references, employment agency and recruiter impression. In selling this model of employment, there are three important elements to keep in mind: Give businesses a realistic idea of what time commitment it will take on their part. Every manager expects to spend time training a new worker but if they perceive that a worker will take extra time, it may scare them off. Sell the idea of a job coach but be very clear on what it really is. What the job coaches role is and what the job coach does. Sometimes managers think things like “do I have to hire two people?” “How does that work?” Streamline paperwork – if it requires more paperwork or time, they just don’t get it and it will detract from your candidate. In a nutshell, they were saying was to work with the candidate so that they can: 1. Sell their skills as they related to the job; 2. Offer an up-front explanation of the supports needed; and 3. Offer an up-front explanation of the supports available. On job coaches at the interview: Here the best rule of thumb is no surprises. If a job coach is going to come, let the interviewer know beforehand. One comment from a participant, “if you’re bringing a job coach, tell me. It won’t prejudice me but it will help me to prepare better for the interview.” Sometimes it creates a perception of the person needing “hand holding” when it might not be needed; Sometimes it results in the relationship being established between the interviewer and the job coach rather than the interviewer and the candidate; but It is nice to get additional information and see the support available. On barriers that keep them from hiring. Education, relationship and information. If jobs are open, we need to fill them quickly; Biggest challenge is the hiring manager, educate us on how to accommodate and sell your workers. On disclosing the disability Once again, you hear “no surprises”. This group recommended that individuals sell their skills and how they relate to the job, sell their track record and proven ability to do the job. They felt like it really helped them to understand what sort of accommodations or help that a person might need to do the job for which they are applying. If you need an accommodation for an interview, let us know so that we can give you a fair interview. If you need an accommodation that is important for the job, let us know. Often if an individual is working with an agency, we know that there is some disability involved. So it is best to be open with us regarding what it involves and how it will impact the workplace. 14 One business described a situation where a person was working with an agency. They had applied and come in for an interview. The applicant did not tell the interviewer anything other then, “due to my disability”. The applicant was unable to explain extended periods of time-off and at one point told the interviewer that she did not have to say anything about that as “my job coach said”. The interviewer’s recommendation to job seekers with disabilities was “don’t leave me hanging”. In order to have the confidence and information to sell this individual to the managers, more information or better answers are needed. Situations like these leave interviewers intimidated about interviewing (and perhaps hiring) people with disabilities. On accommodations Here they seem to be saying, tell us so we can help and plan. It is better to know up-front rather than guess. Again minimize surprises. We don’t anticipate that hiring a worker with a disability will cost a lot more. But I think that we need to let everyone know that. Again, educate recruiters and human resource staff so that they can educate the managers. Know how accommodations are done. One business reported accommodations are done through the supervisor who will contact human resources for support, assistance and corporate approval. After the worker is employed Business works on a customer service approach. Here these businesses were looking for service after the sale – a true partnership. Help the employee become comfortable and able to do the job. Serve as a consultant to the manager and business. Check in often for concerns and offer support to the employee and manager to make sure that it is working for everyone. This can be filtered out but at first it is important for both the employee and the manager. Footnotes This offered a number of comments and suggestions for enhancing job development efforts. These recommendations apply whether an individual is looking for a job on his/her own or with the assistance from an employment agency. ICEO sincerely appreciates these businesses candidly sharing their perspectives and recommendations. 15 Assessment Exercise – Samurai Warrior Work Habit Evaluation Work Related Skills 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Job Requirement Regular attendance Arrives on time or calls if late or absent Follows rules Works Safely Follows directions Listens & uses feedback Right pace for job (not too slow or fast) Works accurately Worker Skill What would it take to make this match? O O + + + O + Social Skills 9. Talks right amount (not too much or too little) 10. Behaves appropriately 11. Asks for help 12. Gets along w/co-workers O O + N/A Personal Qualities 13. 14. 15. 16. Works independently Appropriate grooming Positive attitude Shows initiative—looks for things that need to be done 17. Has things needed for work Scoring Key: + + O + + = critically important; Job Duty Evaluation Job Duties O = important but flexible/ok; Worker Skill Job Requirement Duty 1: Wait on customers Speed What would it take to make this match? + OK - Independence + OK - Duty 2: Make sandwiches Accuracy Speed: + OK + OK - Independence + OK - Duty 3: Collect money from customers - = not critical; Accuracy Speed + OK + OK - Independence + OK Accuracy + OK - 16 Speed + OK - Independence + OK Accuracy + OK - Speed: + OK - Independence + OK Accuracy + OK - Speed + OK - Independence + OK Accuracy + OK - Systematic Instruction – Teaching in the Community Work Site and Work Station Analysis The first step is to understand the job and how it is performed. This entails understanding the equipment, environment, work processes, materials, and culture of the workplace. Methods of getting information: Written materials at the workplace Observation Talking with other workers Things to look for: Skills that must be completed successfully to perform the job Tools and machines that will be used and how they work Who do people go to when they need help? Writing a task analysis State steps in observable terms One behavior per step Test drive it to see if it works Go from beginning to end Note the natural cues 17 Job Analysis Form Company Name: _________________________________________________________________ Staff: ________________________________________ Date: ____________________________ (mo) (day) (year) Address: ________________________________________________________________________ (street) (city) (state) (zip) Telephone Number: ___________________________________FAX Number:_________________ Contact Person: ______________________________________Title: ________________________ Job Title: ________________________________________________________________________ Current hourly wage (or wage at last date of employment in this position): ___________________ Did a wage change occur since the last Job Screening or Job Update? _____Yes _____No If yes, complete this section: Hourly rate changed from: $_____ to $_____ on_____ /_____ /_____ Hourly rate changed from: $_____ to $_____ on_____ / _____/_____ Number of Hours per week: ____________________ Month per year: ______________________ If less than 12 months per year, what months is the job not available: _______________________ Number of employees in this company at this location: ___________________________________ Number of employees without disabilities in immediate area (50 ft. radius): ___________________ Number of other employees w/disabilities: In immediate area (50 ft. radius): __________________ Number of other employees in this position: During the same hours: ________________________ General Directions: PLEASE DO NOT LEAVE ANY ITEM UNANSWERED! Indicate the most appropriate response for each item based on observations of the job and interview with employers, supervisors, and coworkers. Record special instructions, regulations or comments under each item for greater detail. 1. Schedule: (check Yes or No for each item) Weekend work required: _____Yes _____ No Part-time job: _____Yes _____No Specifics/Comments: Evening work required: _____ Yes _____No Full-time job: _____Yes _____No 2. Travel Location: (check Yes or No for each item) On public transportation On private transportation route: _____ Yes _____No route: _____Yes _____No Specifics/Comments: 3. Strength — Lifting and Carrying: _____Very light work (< 10 lbs) _____Average work (30-40 lbs) Specifics/Comments: _____ Light work (10-20 lbs) _____Heavy work (> 50 lbs) 18 4. Endurance: (without breaks) _____Work required for < 2 hours _____Work required for 3-4 hours Specifics/Comments: 5. Orienting: _____Small area _____One room _____Building and Grounds Specifics/Comments: _____Work required for 2-3 hours _____Work required for > 4 hours _____Several rooms 6. Accessibility: _____Fully accessible site Specifics/Comments: _____Building wide _____Accessibility issues 7. Work Pace: ____Slow pace ____Average steady pace ____Sometimes fast pace ____Continual fast pace Specifics/Comments: 8. Appearance Requirements: _____Grooming of little importance _____Neat and clean required Specifics/Comments: _____Cleanliness only required _____Grooming very important 9. Communication Required: _____None/minimal _____Unclear speech accepted Specifics/Comments: _____Key words/signs needed _____Clear speech in sentences/signs needed 10. Social Interactions: _____Social interactions not required _____Social interactions required infrequently Specifics/Comments: _____Appropriate responses required _____Social interactions required frequently 11. Attention to Task Perseverance: _____Frequent prompts available _____Intermittent prompts/low supervision available _____Intermittent prompts/high supervision available _____Infrequent prompts/low supervision available Specifics/Comments: 19 12. Sequencing of Job Duties: _____Only one task required at a time _____4-6 tasks required in sequence Specifics/Comments: _____2-3 tasks required in sequence _____7 or more tasks required in sequence 13. Initiation of Work Motivation: _____Initiation of work required _____ Volunteering helpful Specifics/Comments: _____Co-worker support available 14. Daily Changes in Routine: _____7 or more changes _____4-6 task changes Specifics/Comments: _____2-3 task changes 15. Reinforcement Available: _____Frequent reinforcement available _____Reinforcement infrequent (weekly) Specifics/Comments: _____Reinforcement intermittent (daily) _____Minimal reinforcement (pay check) 16. Co-Worker Supports Available: _____None available _____Low to minimum potential _____High potential Specifics/Comments: _____No task change _____Intermittent potential 17. Supportive of Job Accommodations: _____Very supportive _____Supportive w/reservations _____Indifferent _____Negative _____Unknown Specifics/Comments: 18. Employer’s Financial Requirements: _____ Financial incentives not necessary _____ Subminimum wage Specifics/Comments: _____Tax credit or incentive (e.g., TJTC, or OJT) 19. Opportunity for Career Advancement: _____Low to minimum _____Average _____Most probable _____No procedures in place Specifics/Comments: 20 _____Procedures in place 20. Object Discrimination: _____Does not need to distinguish between work supplies _____Must distinguish between work supplies with an external cue _____Must distinguish between work supplies _____Specifics/Comments: 21. Time: _____Time factors not important Must identify breaks/meals/etc. _____Must tell time to the hour Must tell time to the minute Specifics/Comments: 22. Functional Reading: _____None _____Sight words/symbols Specifics/Comments: _____Simple reading _____Fluent reading 23. Functional Math: _____None _____Simple counting _____Complex computational skills Specifics/Comments: 24. Street Crossing: _____None _____Must cross 2 lane street w/out light _____Must cross 4 lane street w/out light Specifics/Comments: 25. Visibility to Public: _____Consumer not visible _____Regularly visible Specifics/Comments: _____Simple addition/subtraction _____Must cross 2 lane street with light _____Must cross 4 lane street with light _____Occasionally visible _____Visible throughout the day/ongoing 26. If individual known, is the job in accordance with individual’s vision, preference goals? _____No _____Close approximation (stepping stone) _____Yes 27. Benefits of Job: 0 = None _____Yes _____No 1 = Sick Leave _____Yes _____No 2 = Medical/health benefits _____Yes _____No 3 = Paid vacation/annual leave _____Yes _____No 4 = Dental benefits _____Yes _____No 5 = Employee discounts _____Yes _____No 6 = Free or reduced meals _____Yes _____No 7 = Other (specify): 21 28. Level of Social Contact: (check one) _____Employment in an integrated environment on a shift or position which is isolated. Contact with co-workers or supervisors is minimal. Example: Night Janitor. _____Employment in an integrated environment on a shift or position which is relatively isolated. Contact with co-workers or supervisors is available at lunch or break. Example: Data Entry Position. _____Employment in an integrated environment in a position requiring a moderate level of interdependent tasking and co-worker interaction. Example: Office Service Aide copying documents. _____Employment in an integrated environment in a position requiring a high degree of interdependent tasks and co-worker interactions and/or high level of contact with business customers. Example: Wal-Mart Greeter. 29. List any job experience (skills) needed for this position: Comments: Rate of employee turnover (annual percentage): _____Overall _____This Position Number of supervisors: _____ Rate of supervisor turnover: _____ Written job description available? _______________ What are the absolute “don’ts” for an employee in this position? (Manager’s pet peeves, reasons for dismissal, etc.) Environmental characteristics (physical barriers, temperature extremes, etc.): Additional Comments: © Virginia Commonwealth University, Rehabilitation Research & Training Center on Supported Employment, 1997 22 Task Analysis Form Student: ________________________________ Trainer: ________________________________ Work Place: _____________________________ Task Trials Data Collection: + independent response - incorrect response v verbal prompt m model or gestural prompt p physical prompt 23 Total +/total trials The Power of EDITH E=Explain Put the task into context – what will be done and why it is important. Brevity and clarity is important here. D=Demonstrate Show them what they are going to do – so that everyone has a common idea of what’s they’re doing. I=Instruct Tell them how to do it. Give them information so that they can complete the task. T=Train Tell them to “do it”. Let them try it. H=Help Help if needed by offering feedback, support, accommodation. ‘Try another way’ until they learn how to do the task. Key pointers: Use specific and consistent instructions – tell them exactly what to do. Be careful to keep them clear and concise. Phrasing – use a positive instructional tone. Avoid “don’t” or “no” as it puts people on the defensive. Tell them what and how to do it. Small increments – if you miss a little step/piece, it could mess things up. Break things down into small enough steps for the learner and other trainers to use. 24 Timing When are you going to provide information? 1. Before learner acts (instruction) a. New learner b. New task 2. After learner acts (correction) a. After learner has performed correctly repeatedly b. If your timing is off 3. During the action a. Facilitates errorless learning b. Timing is critical 4. No information provided – self-correction a. Test to see if learner has mastered task b. It is risky if done too soon but useful when determining fading strategies. 25 Prompting What kind of instructional cues should be provided? 1. Natural cues and consequences 2. Indirect cues – trainer asks a question like “what’s next?”(verbal) or shrugs their shoulders when learner looks to them for prompt (gestural). 3. Verbal cues – trainer tells the next step. a. Early in training – use information packed short phrases; concise description of desired action; use an instructional tone (that does not mean bossy). b. When skill is nearly acquired – more conversational and indirect cues, refer to the natural cues. 4. Gestures/modeling – trainer shows how to do next step by gesture or actually doing. a. Early – exact simulation of desired action; point directly at next action. b. Near acquisition – use questioning gestures 5. Physical assists – touching/guiding the person through the task a. Early – hand over hand b. Near acquisition – touching shoulder Cues should be appropriate for learning style and workplace – if it makes the worker look stupid – try something different. If the cues does not work – TRY ANOTHER WAY 26 How we present information How much and in what order should teaching occur? 1. Total Cycle/Task – teach all steps at once. Works well when learner understands task well and can manage multiple steps. It is more natural to the workplace as well. 2. Clustering – use natural groupings of task to break overall task into smaller chunks. 3. Single step – teach one step at a time. Forward chaining – Present the clusters of the task for training purposed in a typical first to last manner. Backward chaining – Present clusters of task for training purposes starting with the typically occurring final cluster first and then proceeding backward toward the first cluster. A trick of the trade: . if learner is having difficulty, you can use the strategy of pulling out one step and doing it repeatedly until mastered. For repeated errors, use Try another way! Systematic instruction requires us as the teacher to assume responsibility for teaching and skill acquisition. Marc Gold challenged all of us to accept that if a student was not learning, we were not yet teaching it correctly. 27 Reinforcement and Consequences 1. Determine what to use a. Natural -Try to use something that everyone else gets b. Artificial -Be certain that it is reinforcing (ask, observe) c. Artificial -Plan for how to fade before you begin using 2. Decide how often to use a. Natural rate b. Artificial rate i. Continuous – for every correct response ii. Fixed intervals – at the end of a set time iii. Fixed ratio – after the completion of a set number iv. Variable interval – intervals change v. Variable ratio – ratio changes Things to keep in mind – Artificial reinforces must be temporary The more artificial things you introduce; the more you will have to fade. Examples: Natural reinforcer at a natural rate – taking break with the group during scheduled break times or getting your paycheck on payday Natural reinforcer at an artificial rate – taking a break after every three cases are produced or getting $5 at the end of each work day. Artificial reinforcer at a natural rate – going out to lunch with the job coach every payday for doing a good job or someone buys a pop every break for good work. Artificial reinforcer at an artificial rate – getting pop after every three cases are produced or getting a “great job!” after every box. When the work and the environment are reinforcing enough, we’ve done our jobs well. 28 Accommodations When learning is not occuring 1. 2. 3. 4. Begin by modifying how it is being taught, if that does not work – Modify who is teaching it, if that does not work – Modify how the job is being done (introduce a jig or adaptation), if that does not work – Change the tasks that are being done. Try another way. Some pointers that might help Strategies to help with pace issues – Ask other workers what they did to make themselves go faster – they know lots of tricks and shortcuts that are not in the training package. Modeling – set worker up next to a faster worker and assist them in getting a feel for the appropriate pace. Provide some encouragement and visual tracking for the learner to see progress. Set goals – either company quota or individual goals. Use a pacing device (e.g. metronome, music). Keep in mind that you want to minimize the stigma to the worker. 29 Fading – the final frontier 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Cues – change to less intense cues, less frequency, etc. Move from artificial reinforcers to natural reinforcers Assist and empower co-workers and supervisors to take more leadership and ownership of supporting worker. Begin fading from day 1 Back off often Serve as a consultant to the employer – build their capacity Use co-workers as trainers See yourself as a bridge builder. Developing Natural Supports On The Job When people get invited to bowling league, birthday parties and begin to share the friendships that working provides, they have been truly integrated into the workplace. Some tips for helping to support this. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Be aware of the culture of the workplace – customs, roles, leaders, power brokers, joking, etc. Assist the new worker in seeing and participating as much as they’d like. Answer questions of co-workers Give permission to talk to the worker with a disability Assist in making that happen. 30 Sample Job Coaching Plan Shared by the folks at VanBuren Job Opportunities Client Name ____________________________________ Job Goal ________________________ Job Obtained ____________________________________ Job Start Date ____________________ Work site ____________________________ Supervisor/contact at Job ______________________ Job Barrier(s) at Work Site Strategies at Place at Work Site (action step(s) required to address the barrier) Work Behavioral Work Site (Behavior the job coach needs to be aware of what could cause problems) Action Steps (How job coach should address the behavior at the worksite) 31 Job Coach Information Student Name: Jon Janitor Address: 2013 Green Ave, Iowa City, Iowa Telephone: 936-0982 Sample Job Coaching Plan Business Name: Solon High School Supervisor: John Smith /Mike Jones Bus Address: Solon High Phone: 319-889-3928 Job Title: Activities Custodian Schedule: 9 p.m. until finished midnight/1 a.m. after home games Core Job Duties: Clean gym, bathrooms and common areas after basketball games. Trash pick up, dust mopping, rolling mats and other things as assigned by other custodians Goals of Coaching: 1. Learn core job tasks – quality and pace will be key issues for monitoring. He’ll know processes somewhat. 2. Help him get in the habit of filling out his timesheet. Hung in janitorial closet 3. Get him accustomed to asking others “what’s next?” Jon tends to stand around and chat when he’s unclear or nothing is in front of him. 4. Encourage co-workers (Brian, Mark, Richard) to prompt Jon as well. 5. Monitor to assure that he’s doing these things independently 6. Assist in ride to/from work while there (his mom will help him get to and from work after we fade out). This student learns best by: Show and then have him do it; offer feedback; and then have him teach you. Tips for working with this individual: 1. Jon is very easy going – people tend to let him slide. Push him to work and work steadily. 2. Encourage him to tell you what’s next. He will become very prompt dependent if given the opportunity. 3. Lists may help but I suspect he’ll do better if he checks in with the guys. 4. Quality can be an issue for Jon. His notion of clean sometimes needs feedback. Data Collection/Reporting to SS Staff: Weekly e-mail or note to Judy and Anne regarding – overall performance, problems you see or anticipate and progress. Call Judy or Anne immediately if problem arises. Questions, comments or concerns – call or e-mail: Judy Warth 319/936-8290 or Judith-warth@uiowa.edu Anne Crotty 319/400-4146 or acrotty@goodwillseiowa.org 32 The Honeymoon is Over! Situation 1 Melinda is a young woman who is seventeen years old and has severe mental retardation and spastic cerebral palsy. She lives at home with her parents and attends school during the morning hours. Recently Melinda became employed as a laundry attendant at a hotel chain. The first tow days of employment, Melinda cried and refused to continue working after two hours on the job. Her employment specialist coaxed her back to work. The third day, Melinda’s mother called her employment specialist and said that Melinda was sick and unable to go to work . . . Situation 2 Marcy has sustained a brain injury that has resulted in difficulties with memory, sequencing, and orienting. Prior to her injury, Marcy also had a diagnosis of mild mental retardation, and she had completed a post secondary training program as a kitchen assistant. Recently March becomes employed as a salad prep person for a fast food restaurant. She has been able to use much of her kitchen assistant training in her new job, however, the fast food restaurant has specific procedures that require staff to use in preparing salads. Marcy frequently complains, “That’s not the right way to do it!” In addition, Marcy’s employment specialist has never worked in a fast food restaurant before this placement and she knows very little about kitchen work. Marcy frequently refuses instructional cues claiming, “I know more about it than you do!” . . . Situation 3 John is completing an experience with a local grocery store. Coaching data indicates that he is doing his job well. He bags groceries and helps with drive through. He’s been doing so well that a coach has faded out of the picture. The store likes him so much that they hire him. Three months later, John is reportedly bagging in correctly and they’ve got a number of complaints about his work. The employer has asked you to assist or they will have to fire John. His teacher and coach have come to watch him working (with and without him knowing) and he is bagging well. What should we do? 33 The Honeymoon is Over! 1. Assessment of the Situation: __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ 2. Range of Possible Options: __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ 3. Strategy of Choice and Why? __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ 4. Methods to Evaluate Situation: __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ 34 What I would want my job coach to know and do Michael W. Smull (While listening to a gathering of job coaches in Wisconsin I began to think of all of the things that people with disabilities have taught me about what they want their job coach to know and what they want their job coach to do. Some of what follows I learned from 10 years as a community service provider, much of it I learned from listening as I have been doing person centered planning with people from all over North America. The following list of requests represents a summary of what I have been told - with words and behavior.) Understand how I want to live. I know that you are only responsible for helping me with work, but what I do for work has to fit with how I want to live. Please do not divide my life into compartments. Listen to what I say about the rest of life. If I cannot speak for myself, talk to the people who support me where I live. If I am moving to a community job from a workshop or day program, remember that I may be leaving all my friends and someone needs to help me stay in touch with them. Understand the role of work in my life. What work means to me may be different from what work means to you. Work may be how I get status, it may define who I am. What I do may be more important than how much I earn. Alternatively, work may be what I do so that I can afford what I enjoy. Or the role of work may be some mix of status and income. Regardless of whether or not I can put this into words, you need to make an effort to understand the role of work in my life. Learn about my dreams/desires, gifts and capacities. You need to know what I am good at in order to find me a job where I can be successful. You also need to find out what my "fantasy" or perfect job would be. The job that I would really like may not be where I score the highest on your assessments. Help me get a job that I want. If the "perfect job" is beyond my grasp see how close you can help me get. Do not "place" me, offer me a job that you think will make sense for me. Even if it took you six months to develop a job, it ought to be OK for me to say no. Part of respecting me is respecting my decisions. At the same time, if I need encouragement to try something new, if saying no is my way of saying I am scared, encourage me but do not coerce me. Do not try to make me "independent". Help me learn the skills that I will need to do the job. Help my co-workers learn how I learn and how to support me. Help me get to know my co-workers and to have reciprocal relationships with them. The result for you may be that I am more independent of the system. The result I want is the interdependence that all of us have. Help me become part of my work place. Help my co-workers meet me (and get to know me) as a person rather than as a disability. Show them by your example. (They will learn more from how you treat me than they will from what you tell them.) Work on talking about me using respectful, people first language. Use language that empowers me. This will tell my co-workers that I am somebody that they should respect. Learn the culture and the "positive rituals" of the work place. Help me enter the culture and participate in the positive rituals. Remember that your planning meetings may not help me be seen as a co-worker. 35 Be there if I need help because of challenges in other parts of my life, or changes at work. Things that happen at home may affect my work. If people leave my life (e.g. family members who move, are hospitalized, or die; residential staff who leave) I may have problems doing my work. I will need support and understanding, I may need some time off and/or counseling. Remember that I may like my job because of who I work with. When people who are important to me leave my work place, be ready to help me. Keep listening to my words (and behavior) for requests for change - a change in responsibilities, supervision, pay, or where I work. Just like any other worker, I may get tired of my routine. I may no longer find my job satisfying or enjoyable. I may want a raise. Because of how my co-workers and I relate to each other, I may need to change who I work with. I may want a complete change - in who I work for, what I do, and where I work. Changes like these require that you take into account the local job market, but please help me make the changes as I want them and when I want them. Change should occur on my schedule, not on yours. I may not want to wait for my next planning meeting. Help me find new jobs as I want/need them. This is important enough to mention twice. My experience is that if I complain about my job I get counseling. If I act out my unhappy feelings I get a behavior program. I can only get a new job by really screwing up the old job. Please help me build the kind of job history that you want to have. Let me build on success. Help me find new jobs as often (and as seldom) as I ask for them. Michael W. Smull Support Development Associates E-Mail: mwsmull@compuserve.com 36