BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Ohio Standards Connection Reading Application: Informational, Technical, and Persuasive Text Benchmark A Use text features and graphics to organize, analyze and draw inferences from content and gain additional information. Indicator 1 Use text features such as chapter titles, headings and subheadings, parts of books, including index, appendix, table of contents and online tools (search engines) to locate information. Benchmark E Explain the treatment, scope and organization of ideas from different texts to draw conclusions about a topic. Indicator 8 Summarize information from informational text, identifying the treatment, scope and organization of ideas. Research Standard Benchmark B Locate and summarize important information from multiple sources. Indicator 2 Identify appropriate sources, and gather relevant information from multiple sources (e.g., School library catalogs, online databases, electronic resources and Internet-based resources). Benchmark C Organize information in a systemic way. Indicator 4 Identify important information found in sources and paraphrase Lesson Summary: Students become members of the BSI in this research simulation. They apply for Biographical Scene Investigator membership, investigate an individual, keep an evidence notebook and write an investigator’s report. As a culminating activity, BSIs appear in a “press conference” to address questions from the members of the media (their classmates) on the individual. Estimated Duration: Approximately 10 hours Commentary: What better way to engage students in research than to put them in charge of their own criminal investigations! In this case, students become members of the BSI, the Biographical Scene Investigators, in an attempt to identify a remarkable or heroic individual from a list of possible suspects. They support their “allegations” with “evidence” from “reliable informants” in order to make the case for their lead suspect. Instructional Tips: The success of this lesson rests upon maintaining the simulation for the duration of the process. Television has made most students familiar with the activities of crime scene investigators. Explain to the class that in this simulation, they can be BSIs (biographical scene investigators) to solve the mystery of their chosen individual. Require students to keep evidence notebooks. If possible, acquire stenographer’s notebooks because of the two-column format. (Students can enter each piece of evidence in the left hand column and note its source in the right hand column.) If the cost would be prohibitive, spend some class time creating evidence folders from inexpensive pronged folders and notebook paper that students have divided into two columns. Pre-Assessment: Introduce the simulation. Ask each class member to complete an investigator application. See Attachment A, Biographical Scene Investigator Application. Ask students to exchange papers and check the qualifications of their peers. 1 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six the findings in a systematic way (e.g., notes, outlines, charts, tables, graphic organizers). Benchmark D Acknowledge quoted and paraphrased information and document sources used. Indicator 7 Use an appropriate form of documentation, with teacher assistance, to acknowledge sources (e.g., bibliography, works cited). Communication: Oral and Visual Standard Benchmark D Select an organizational structure appropriate to the topic, audience, setting and purpose. Indicator 8 Deliver informational presentations (e.g., expository, research) that: a. demonstrate an understanding of the topic and present events or ideas in a logical sequence; b. support the controlling idea or thesis with relevant facts, details, examples, quotations, statistics, stories and anecdotes; c. include an effective introduction and conclusion and use a consistent organizational structure (e.g., causeeffect, comparecontrast); d. use appropriate visual materials (e.g., diagrams, charts, illustrations) and available technology; and e. draw from multiple sources and identify sources used. Generate some discussion about the items on the application. Ask, what makes a good investigator? What things would a good investigator know? Where will the investigation be carried out? Collect the applications. Scoring Guidelines: Explain to students that the chief investigator has accepted all applications. Though some investigators will clearly be investigators-in-training, each student will participate in the simulation. (Sort the applications and make a mental note of students who need more direction. Be sure to be available to them.) Post-Assessment: Students prepare an investigative report on an individual of their choice, using information gleaned from several sources and include a properly formatted bibliography. Students maintain an evidence notebook throughout the research process, noting information and its source. Scoring Guidelines: Use the Research Paper Rubric, Attachment B. Award points for evidence notebooks. Instructional Procedures: Day One 1. Following the pre-assessment, present students with their “official BSI cards” (Attachment C). The cards may be laminated, so students can easily carry and use them as identification and research guides. Be sure each student has a full copy of the attachment for clarification of their duties as a BSI. 2. Inform students that their task is to find remarkable individuals, or heroes. Distribute the List of Possible Suspects, Attachment D. Ask students to choose five primary suspects for their research and circle the names on the handout. Each student must select a different lead suspect, so the more possible suspects chosen, the better. Instructional Tip: Forbid duplication of lead suspects so students take individual responsibility for their investigations. 2 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six 3. Direct students through the preparation of their evidence notebooks. (See earlier Instructional Tip.) If they are not using steno notebooks, allow time for students to divide their paper into two columns. Instruct students to allow 10 pages before the sectioned area for recording information on possible sources (informants). Provide self-adhesive flags or small notes so they may index their notebooks with the letters B-I-O-G-R-A-P-H-Y. Allow 5-10 pages per letter. Stagger the tags so each can be easily seen. See illustration. 4. Relocate class to library media center. Require the marked suspect list and evidence notebook as admission ticket to the room. 5. Instruct students to research all of their primary suspects, if only to see how many informants (reliable sources) are available. Once they have found enough information to satisfy the requirements of the investigation, students should register their lead suspects with the chief investigator (teacher). Announce or post choices as they are made, so students eliminate primary suspects already selected. Instructional Tip: If possible, have all investigators begin with the same source. If computer availability is not an issue, have students begin with an Internet source, like Biography.com. Otherwise, have them begin with an encyclopedia or the card catalog. (It helps to pre-check the suspect list with the media specialist, who can remove names for which material is not readily available.) 6. In this phase of the investigation, have BSIs note possible informants (sources) in the first few pages of their notebooks. Be sure they have enough information to find the source at another time. All students should name a lead suspect before the class time ends. Day Two 7. Inform the investigation team that today they begin their investigations in earnest. As such, they must adhere to proper procedure to validate their information. Explain the point of using a two-column notebook. Emphasize that each piece of information must be accompanied by its source. 8. Generate a list of information to obtain about each source. Explain that no informant is considered reliable without this information. Make this list on the board or on large chart paper. After creating a reasonable list, distribute Reliable Informants, Attachment E. Discuss the importance of verifying sources, which means eventually creating an “evidentiary document,” the bibliography. 3 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six 9. Thoroughly review the terms on the BSI cards. Make sure investigators understand what they hope to learn through their investigation. 10. Present a mini-lesson on using book-length nonfiction sources. Together, identify the parts of a book: the table of contents, chapter titles, headings/subheadings, appendix and index. Discuss the information found in each area. Inform students that their investigation does not necessarily require that they read an entire book. If they use the book’s features appropriately, they can reduce their investigation time. Remind them to take careful notes, listing the source as well as the page numbers where specific information is found. 11. Release the investigation team to continue seeking informants on their lead suspects. Remind them to take meaningful notes that they can decipher later. Remember to use quotation marks whenever they copy words from an informant. In the source column, be sure to note the page number on which the quotation appeared. 12. Close this session by checking Evidence Notebooks to see that each BSI has made progress on the case. Day Three 13. Spend this day continuing the investigation. Make sure BSIs have clear direction and continue to record information and verification for each informant/source. 14. Circulate among the class to provide help and clarification as needed. 15. Ascertain how much additional time the investigation team requires. Announce the number of days left to complete the investigation phase. Days Four through Five Instructional Tip: Motivate the investigation team to use their time efficiently. Reprimand investigators who wander off task. Keep the team motivated so they can complete the investigation phase within two more class days. 16. See steps 13-15. Day Six 17. Make this day a celebration to recognize the importance of the group completing its investigation. Mark their evidence notebooks with a special sticker (a badge or a star) to recognize the completion of the investigatory phase. 18. Indicate that the most important aspect of the investigation has begun, the preparation of the investigator’s report. A properly prepared report makes the case. 19. Ask BSIs to review their notes. If possible, distribute highlighters so important data can be marked. Remind BSIs to look for information that supports recognizing their lead suspect as a remarkable person or hero. 20. Distribute copies of an organizer to use to prepare the investigator’s report. (See Attachment F, Investigator’s Report Graphic Organizer). Review each section. 4 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Take time to find an interesting fact to open the report. This attention-getting device serves to draw readers into your report. Add the customary biographical information to this opening paragraph (¶). Name at least four major points that serve to prove your case. (Distribute additional organizers for those who need them.) Under each point, list the evidence from the notebook that supports it. Consider how to powerfully conclude, making the best statements of your case that the individual is indeed a remarkable person. 21. Allow time for students to complete the graphic organizers. Students submit their organizers as an “exit pass” to leave class. Day Seven 21. Return the graphic organizers to students so they may complete rough drafts of their investigation reports. 22. Remind them that each section of the organizer corresponds to a section of the final paper. Each section must be at least one paragraph long. Caution BSIs to use their own words. If the informant’s words are best, they must use quotation marks to indicate the words are not their own. Within the sentence, state the source of the information. For example: Helen Keller, with all her limitations, wrote in her autobiography, “Life is either a daring adventure or nothing.” 23. Call each BSI, in turn, to confer with the Chief Investigator. Read through each draft and provide direction or help as needed. 24. Aim to complete the drafts during a single day, keeping the BSI staff on task. Students who do not finish a draft in class must finish it for class tomorrow. Day Eight 25. Require students to have evidence notebooks and a rough draft of the investigation report to enter class today. 26. Focus on the issue of reliable informants, asking students to take out their copies of Attachment E, Reliable Informants. 27. Explain that arranging information in a standard form allows all individuals reading the report to understand it. Distribute Attachment G, MLA Documentation Form. 28. Clarify that the Modern Language Association designed this form for use in the humanities. Most English classes use this style. 29. Review the placement of the Reliable Informant information in the bibliography. 30. Require each BSI to prepare a draft of the Works Cited page somewhere in the evidence notebook. Circulate among the students to verify their understanding and clear up any confusion or misconceptions. 31. Assign completion of the full report (Post-Assessment) to be due within a week. All remaining preparation time takes place outside of class. Allow students to add photographs and illustrations to their reports whenever possible. Remind them to be prepared to share their information with the class. 5 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Day Nine through Ten (Begin on the Due Date) 32. For this final phase of the simulation, each investigator answers questions posed by the press (the rest of the class). Establish an interview order ahead of time, so little time is wasted moving from one BSI to the next. 33. Prepare index cards with questions from Attachment C, BSI Card, on them. Write one question on each card. Distribute these questions to members of the class. 34. Each BSI moves to the front of the room, announces the lead suspect and opens the floor to questions. 35. Move from questioner to questioner in a regular fashion until a reasonable number of questions have been satisfactorily answered. Assign a student to collect and shuffle the question cards and redistribute them as the next BSI heads to the front to present. Continue in this fashion until all BSIs have had the chance to face questioning on their cases. Instructional Materials: For the teacher: Library media center access, index cards, self-adhesive flags For the students: Library media center access, steno notebook or folder Differentiated Instructional Support: Instruction is differentiated according to learner needs, to help all learners either meet the intent of the specified indicator(s) or, if the indicator is already met, to advance beyond the specified indicator(s). Each child chooses a lead suspect according to personal interest. Students select their own research materials. Students can get as much help as necessary from peers, the instructor and library media center staff. Students read their materials at their own rate. Students work in a variety of grouping situations to complete the project. Extensions: Create a panel of famous people by category (e.g., authors, artists, adventurers, etc.) Use the question cards so students in the class can interview the group. Require each panel member to wear a hat or a wig to represent the famous person. Keep panel size to no more than five members and limit the time for the panel. The panel then changes to another category of famous people. Take students to an inventor’s hall of fame. Students write a thank you note to the famous person they admire the most for their accomplishments and effect on society. Interested student pairs compare their lead suspects using a Venn diagram. Students write a reflective paper describing the impact of being a member of BSI has had. Home Connections: Students ask their families to help them understand the effect their famous person has had on society. 6 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Students use the Internet, encyclopedia or other resource books to provide multiple sources for comparison information. Interdisciplinary Connections: Content Area: Social Studies Standard: History Benchmark: A. Interpret relationships between events shown on multiple-tier time lines. Indicator: 1. Construct a multiple-tier time line from a list of events and interpret the relationships between the events. Require student pairs whose lead suspects are contemporaries to construct a multiple-tier time line representing both individuals’ lives. Students report orally to class the relationships they see between the events and the individuals. Vocabulary: documentation evidence plagiarism reliable informant research works cited Technology Connections: Students research their suspects using the Internet or CD-ROM encyclopedias. Students word process the rough draft and then the final copy. Students may choose to prepare PowerPoint™ presentations to support their press conference appearances. Research Connections: "BSCS Science: An Inquiry Approach." BSCS Biological Sciences Curriculum Study. 23 Dec. 2003 <http://63.225.114.218/bscsdotorg/curriculum/InquiryFAQs.htm> The BSCS instructional model is characterized by the 5 E’s: engage, explore, explain, elaborate, and evaluate. Each E represents part of the process of helping students sequence their learning experiences to construct their understanding of concepts. 1. Students are engaged by an event or question related to the concept that the teacher plans to introduce 2. The students participate in one or more activities to explore the concept. This exploration provides students with a common set of experiences from which they can initiate the development of their understanding. 3. Students construct their own understanding and the teacher clarifies the concept. 4. The students elaborate and build on their understanding of the concept by applying it to new situations. The student’s complete activities that will help them and the teacher evaluate their understanding of the concept. This 5-E model is based on a constructivist philosophy of learning 7 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Cawletti, Gordon. Handbook of Research on Improving Student Achievement. Arlington, VA: Educational Research Service, 1999 RESEARCH-BASED BEST PRACTICES Incorporate direct reaching and exhibits key features and systematic steps. Utilize advance organizers that show students’ relationships between past learning and present learning. Teach students multiple learning strategies that promote met cognition by providing modeled, guided practice and application. Utilize mastery learning techniques for teaching subject matter. Incorporate cooperative learning. LANGUAGE ARTS (Squire 1995) Incorporate extensive reading of varied kinds of material. Foster interactive learning. Extend students’ background knowledge. Utilizing meaning-making skills and strategies such as summarizing, questioning and interpreting. Organize instruction into broad, thematically based clusters of work. Teach critical reading/writing skills. Emphasize discussion and analysis. Provide balanced attention to different forms of reading, writing, and speaking. Provide early intervention. Expose students to varied kinds of literature. Provide assessment that reflects the content and process of instruction. Attachments: Attachment A, Biographical Scene Investigator Application Attachment B, Research Paper Rubric Attachment C, Biographical Scene Investigator Card Attachment D, List of Possible Suspects Attachment E, Reliable Informants Attachment F, Investigator’s Report Graphic Organizer Attachment G, MLA Documentation Style 8 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment A Biographical Scene Investigator Application Name Grade______ Years experience______________________________________________________ Most valuable location in school for investigation______________________________ Justification:____________________________________________________________ Reliable informants: (sources for bibliographical information) MUST NAME AT LEAST 3! 1.____________________________________________________________________________________ 2.____________________________________________________________________________________ 3. ____________________________________________________________________________________ What does it mean to be charged with the crime of plagiarism?_____________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________ What are the potential penalties? ___________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________ How does one avoid plagiarism? ___________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________ 9 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment B Research Paper Rubric Negative Dull opening Paragraphs provide little information Uses unreliable or unstated sources Weak transitions from paragraph to paragraph Poor, unconvincing case presentation Weak conclusion Limited works cited or incorrectly cited Sloppy or meager evidence Poorly prepared to face press Ineffective or weak overall presentation Point Value 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 5 Positive Attention-getting, compelling opening Paragraphs provide rich, interesting details Names reliable sources within text Effectively transitions from one paragraph to the next Persuasive case made for lead suspect Strong convincing conclusion Cites all sources in proper form Well-organized and complete evidence notebook Prepared and confident in addressing press Effective overall presentation Chief investigator comments: 10 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment C BSI (Biographical Scene Investigator) Card BSI (Name)____________________________ is a member in good standing of the Biographical Scene Investigators Team. The BSI Team regards these pieces of evidence as most important in investigation: Beliefs Influences Observations of Investigator Genealogy Remarkable? Admirable? Pivotal Moments Hero? Years lived Instructional Tip: This membership card serves as a guide to student investigation. See fuller explanations of the categories below: Beliefs—Did this person have a set of beliefs that governed his or her life? What are they? How did they influence his/her decisions? Influences—Whom did this person admire? Did he or she have an older person or mentor who provided direct assistance in life, or did he/she pattern his/her life after someone they actually did not know Observations of Investigator—What qualities distinguish this person? Did these traits cause difficulty or did they benefit the individual? Why? Did the person make any particularly good or bad decisions? How so? What do you think was their effect? Genealogy—Who are this person’s parents? Grandparents? Spouse? Children? How did these persons influence the person’s life? Remarkable?—In what ways was his/her life remarkable? Explain. Admirable?—In what ways was his/her life admirable? Explain. Pivotal moments— What pivotal moments occurred in his/her life? What events led to significant change, positive or negative, for the individual? Hero?—What does it mean to be a hero? Do you regard this person as a hero? Why or why not? Years lived—During what years did this person live? What events were happening in the world at this time? How did they impact his/her life 11 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment D List of Possible Suspects I. Isaac Newton Aristotle Archimedes Neil Armstrong Galileo Galileo Jupiter Harrison Schmitt Nicholas Copernicus Isaac Asimov Edmund Halley Edmund Hubble Louis Agassi Yuri Gagarin Louis Abazziz II. Mathematicians Leonardo Fibonacci Plato Euclid Pythagoras Pascal Fermats Rene Descartes III. Matter/chemistry Marie Curie Alfred Nobel IV. Politicians Alexander Hamilton Richard Nixon Abraham Lincoln John F. Kennedy Patrick Henry Sam Adams George Washington Sam Houston V. Businessmen John Hancock Jefferson Davis John Brown Theodore Roosevelt Franklin D. Roosevelt Herbert Hoover Harry Truman Ronald Reagan Daniel Inouye Thurgood Marshall VI. Industrialists/Businessmen Andrew Carnegie John D. Rockefeller Henry Ford Samuel Gompers Allan Pinkerton VII. Adventurers/Explorers Sacajawea Pocahontas Davey Crockett Daniel Boone Lewis and Clark Kit Carson Buffalo Bill Cody John Glenn Charles Lindberg Amelia Earhart VIII. Inventors James Watt Louis Braille Alexander Graham Bell George Washington Carver Thomas Edison Benjamin Franklin Orville & Wilbur Wright Robert Morse Robert Fluton Eli Whitney Cyrus McCormack IX. Artists Rachel Carson Henry David Thoreau Mark Twain Matthew Brady Langston Hughes Stephen Foster Frederick Remington George Gershwin Carl Sandberg Louisa May Alcott Michaelangelo Maya Angelou Emily Dickson Picasso Vincent Van Gogh Leonard daVinci X. Sports Mickey Mantle Bill Shoemaker Lou Gehrig A.J. Foyt Chris Evert Lloyd Jim Thorpe Jesse Owens Jackie Robinson Shoeless Joe Jackson Hank Aaron Lew Alcindor (Kareem Abdul Jabbar) Wilma Rudolph Cassisus Clay (Muhammad Ali) Roberto Clemente Babe Ruth Josh Gibson XI. Famous Personalities Frank Sinatra Bob Hope Walt Disney Elvis Presley Walter Cronkite Barnum and Bailey Diana Ross Will Rogers Louis Armstrong Mahalia Jackson Harry Houdini Judy Garland XII. Medical Personalities Dr. Sara Baker Edward Jenner Louis Pasteur Hippocrates Charles Darwin Daniel Hale Williams Elizabeth Blackwell Anton Van Leevwenhoek William Devrles Galen Ambroies Pare Harvey Cushing Dr. William Halsted Dr. Jonas Salk Dr. Louis Sabin William Harvey 12 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment D (Continued) List of Possible Suspects Joseph Lister Sanctorius (Rene Laennec) William & Charles Mayo XIII. Scientists/ Environmentalists George Washington Carver Albert Einstein John D. Rockefeller Michail Faraday and Joseph Henry Thomas A. Edison Benjamin Franklin Charles Steinmetz XIV Social Reformers Anne Sullivan Nellie Bly Horrace Mann Harriet Truman Martin Luther King Jr. Frederick Douglass Eleanor Roosevelt Florence Nightingale John James Audubon Thurgood Marshall Clarence Mathews Nelson Mandela XV. Legends Paul Revere Johnny Appleseed Paul Bunyan Pecos Bill XVI. Famous Women Helen Keller Margaret Bourke White Dolly Madison Betsy Ross Shirley Chisolm Susan B. Anthony Golda Meir Rosa Parks Margaret Thatcher Mary MacLeod Bethune Anne Frank XVII. Military Leaders Yitzak Rabin John Paul Jones Benedict Arnold Ulysses S. Grant Robert E. Lee Pontiac Sitting Bull George Patton Douglas MacArthur Dwight Eisenhower John J. Pershing Stonewall Jackson Andrew Jackson Francis Marion Colin Powell 13 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment E Reliable Informants BSI: Maintain complete records on each of your sources. See the lists below for specifics needed on each informant. Informant Book Internet source Magazine Encyclopedia Verification Information Required Title Author Publication city Publisher Year of publication *Pages on which information appears Title of page Author (if available) Title of site (like Biography.com) Complete URL (Internet address) Date of contact Title of article Author of article Title of magazine Issue date Pages on which article appears Name of encyclopedia Title of article Author of article Edition year * required to accompany specific details 14 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment F Investigator’s Report Graphic Organizer 1st main idea Supporting Evidence Introductory ¶: Start off with a BANG! Choose attention-getting information about your suspect to introduce him/her to your readers. Then provide the basic background information everyone expects to learn in a biography. 2nd main idea 3rd main idea 4th main idea Supporting Evidence Supporting Evidence Supporting Evidence Conclusion: What evidence proves your case? Why must any intelligent person conclude that your suspect is indeed a hero, or a remarkable individual? 15 BSI: Biographical Scene Investigators – Grade Six Attachment G MLA Documentation Style Book: Hiram, Joseph. Biography of Swing. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1965. Internet source: Valdez, Juan. “The Real Mr. Coffee.” Biographies for Kids. 13 May 2005. <www.biography.com/valdez/coffe e.html> Magazine: Walker, Susan. “The Underground Railroad.” Atlantic Monthly. September 2004: 31-36. Encyclopedia: Kessler, Robert. “Harriet Tubman.” Encyclopedia Brittanica, 2001 ed. Notice last name first. Underline Titles and use title style capitalization (all words capitalized except a, an, the and prepositions.) Periods after each section except the publisher. Colon separate the city from the publisher. *Notice how second and third lines use a “hanging indent. Place the “Article Title” in quotation marks. Underline The Page Or Site Title . Include the date you consulted the site. Place the complete URL inside < >. Author first. “Title” of article in quotation marks. Magazine Title underlined. Give month and year: page numbers. If an author’s name appears at the end of the article, use it first. Otherwise, begin with the “Name of the Article.” Add the Name Of The Encyclopedia, then the year of the edition (ed.). Add CD-ROM after the name of the encyclopedia if that format was used. Arrange the list of sources alphabetically at the end of the work under the title, Works Cited. Use the first word in the entry to alphabetize it. If the list above were arranged as a Works Cited list, it would appear as follows: Works Cited Hiram, Joseph. Biography of Swing. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1965. Kessler, Robert. “Harriet Tubman.” Encyclopedia Brittanica, 2001 ed. Valdez, Juan. “The Real Mr. Coffee.” Biographies for Kids. 13 May 2005. www.biography.com/valdez/coffee.html Walker, Susan. “The Underground Railroad.” Atlantic Monthly. September 2004: 31-36. 16