Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 WEEKLY PLANNING LISTS Article 27(2), Planning & Development Regulations 2001-2007 (a) Under section 34 of the Act, the applications for permission may be granted permission, subject to or without conditions, or refused. (b) It is the responsibility of any person wishing to use the personal data on planning applications and decisions lists for direct marketing purposes to be satisfied that they may do so legitimately under the requirements of the Data Protection Acts 1988 and 2003 taking account of the preferences outlined by applicants in their applications. Article 32, Planning & Development Regulations 2001 –2007 (a) In deciding a planning application the planning authority, in accordance with section 34(3) of the Act, has had regard to submissions or observations received in accordance with these Regulations” (b) It is the responsibility of any person wishing to use the personal data on planning applications and decisions lists for direct marketing purposes to be satisfied that they may do so legitimately under the requirements of the Data Protection Acts 1988 and 2003 taking account of the preferences outlined by applicants in their applications. PLANNING INFORMATION SESSIONS Qualified staff members are available by appointment to explain the content of current planning applications. The service is being provided to assist members of the public and residents groups in understanding planning applications currently part of the planning process. The service is not intended to provide general planning advice or to assist in the drafting of submissions in relation to planning objections, observations and appeals. All queries in relation to site specific planning guidance or pre-application discussion should be directed to the area planner, Planning Department, Block 4, Floor 3, Civic Offices, Wood Quay, Dublin 8. Please contact the relevant area office number below to make an appointment and to ensure that the relevant documentation will be made available on the day of your visit. Area Central Area South Central Area South East Area North West Area North Central Area Contact Number 2222932 2225189 2225127 2225727 8166710 1 Meeting Location Sean McDermott Street Crumlin Area Office Contact Area Office for location Finglas Area Office Bunratty Area Office Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 AREA 1 COMMERCIAL: Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3124/08/x1 Extension of Duration of Permission Pageflyer Ltd 43-49, Mespil Road, Dublin 4, also including part of nos. 40-42 Mespil Road and no. 1 Burlington Road, Dublin 4. Development consisting of amendments to the previously permitted development (reg ref Dublin City Council 3518/05; ABP Ref PL.29S214096) at a 2.1 ha site approximately. The site is principally bounded by Mespil Road to the north, no. 1 Burlington Road (Connaught House) to the south, Burlington Road to the east and no. 40 Mespil Road (Bank of Ireland Asset Management) to the west. The development will consist of: alterations to the previously permitted development including: the lowering of basement level -2 by 1.3m approximately; internal reconfiguration of the car parking layout and permitted plant (including the omission of the previously permitted staff gym) at Basement Level -2; the provision of an additional 4 no. bicycle spaces and plant at basement level -2; the relocation of 22 no. car parking spaces from basement level -1 to basement level -2; relocation of vehicular access to Connaught House from basement level -2 to basement level -1; the provision of additional plant space in basement level -1; minor alterations to external walls at basement level -1 and -2, resulting in a net reduction in floor space of 71sqm at basement levels; relocation of ESB substation from lower ground floor to ground floor; the creation of an additional 175sqm of office floor space, from first floor level through to sixth floor. The development will also include minor elevational amendments and will not result in any increase in overall height. Vehicular access will be provided as per the previous permission, from the existing vehicular access off Burlington Road also serving the adjoining office scheme as permitted under reg ref 3490/99. 23-Nov-2010 Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3518/05/x1 Extension of Duration of Permission Pageflyer Limited 43-49, Mespil Road, 40-42 Mespil Road and 1 Burlington Road, Dublin 4 Pageflyer Limited intends to apply for permission for development for a new office building with a total gross floor area of 13,528 sq metres at this site at Nos. 43-49 Mespil Road, Dublin 4 also including part of Nos. 40-42 Mespil Road and No. 1 Burlington Road, Dublin 4. No. 1 Burlington Road is a protected structure (Reference No. 1026 under Dublin City Development Plan 2005-2011) The development will consist of 8,374 sq.m of office accommodation over seven floors above ground with a set-back terrace at the sixth floor level, all above three levels of 5.154sq.m gross floor area consisting of 2 basements and lower ground floor consisting of office space, staff gym, terrace area, security barrier, 70 car parking spaces,140 no cycle spaces and internal plant room areas. 2 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal The overall height will be 26.77m above ground level. The proposed development includes the demolition of the existing 5 storey structure over basement level at Nos. 43/49 Mespil Road of primarily office use and 2 no. residential units at ground floor level. Vehicular access will be provided from the existing vehicular access of Burlington Road serving the adjoining office scheme as permitted under Reg. Ref. 3490/99 at No. 1 Burlington Road (a protected structure Reference No. 1026 under Dublin City Development Plan 2005-2011) The proposed development includes for a glazed canopy to the front elevations to Mespil Road, associated signage, boundary treatments, pedestrian routes, changes in level, ancillary plant, landscaping and all other site development works, and the provision of an ESB substation at 43/49 Mespil Road, 40/42 Mespil Road and No. 1 Burlington Road, Dublin 4. 23-Nov-2010 Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3546/10 Permission The Board of Management Scoil Bhride Scoil Bhride, Oakley Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 Development comprising removal of existing single storey prefabricated classroom and yard shelter and erection of new two storey 2 classroom extension of 136 sq.m. to rear of existing two storey building; erection of new single storey extension at first floor level, comprising 3 new classrooms, 2 special tuition rooms, toilets, stairs and lift, and link to existing two storey building, all of area c451 sq.m., on top of existing single storey buildings, with associated site and landscaping works, all on a site of c. 0.34 hectares at Scoil Bhride, Oakley Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6, for the Board of Management Scoil Bhride. 24-Nov-2010 Additional Information Received Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3593/05/x1 Extension of Duration of Permission Bear Creek Ltd 34, Pembroke Lane (rear of 34 Elgin Road), Dublin 4 Permission sought by Bear Creek Ltd. for demolition of existing two storey mews house, currently in two flats, at 34 Pembroke Lane, Dublin 4, rear 34 Elgin Road, Dublin 4, and for construction of 2 storey, 3 bedroom mews residence, with a car parking space off Pembroke Lane, Dublin 4 (no. 34 Elgin Road, Dublin 4 is a Protected Structure unaffected by these works). 24-Nov-2010 Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3631/10 Permission Seamus Doherty Site at Grantham Place, to the rear of 44 & 45, Harrington Street, Dublin 8 PROTECTED STRUCTURE - The development will consist of the construction of a 3 bedroom 2 storey mews dwelling. Proposed works will also include internal balcony & courtyard, 3 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date winter garden, provision of one on-site car parking space, all ancillary site development works and service connections. The site is to the rear of 44 and 45 Harrington Street, which are protected structures. 24-Nov-2010 Additional Information Received Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3647/10 Retention Permission O'Donoghue's (Merrion Row) Ltd 14 & 15, Merrion Row, Dublin 2 RETENTION - PROTECTED STRUCTURE - retention of altered shopfront and for proposed change of use of basement, ground and first floors at 14 Merrion Row, Dublin 2 from licensed restaurant to use as a licensed premises (public house), with a keg store at basement level, a lounge at ground floor and a lounge with toilets at first floor, all by way of extension to the existing licensed premises at 15 Merrion Row, Dublin 2. A Protected Structure. 25-Nov-2010 Additional Information Received Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4014/10 Permission IBI Property Nominees Ltd. Grafton Buildings, Anne Street South/ Grafton Street, Dublin 2 The development will consist of a) the amalgamation of Units 3, 4 and 5 which together with their basements will form a single retail unit of 299.05sqm for use by a High Order Retail user, b) excavation works at basement level to increase the floor to ceiling heights, c) the change of use of unit 5 on Grafton Street for cafe/sandwich bar to retail and change of use of Unit 2 on South Anne Street from retail to cafe/sandwich bar, d) the installation of a new unified shop front to units 2,3,4 and 5 and e) all associated site works. The building is within an Architectural Conservation Area in the Dublin City Development Plan. Registration Date 22-Nov-2010 Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4015/10 Permission James Ryan 10, Wellington Quay and 8 Essex Street East, Dublin 2 PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission at (the Garage Bar within the curtilage of the Clarence Hotel, a protected structure) for (a) the conversion of 1no. existing sash window at first floor level of 10 Wellington Quay, to French doors; (b) for the use of the roof at first floor level over the performance space at the rear of no. 10 Wellington Quay as an outdoor smoking/seating area with raised perimeter wall/handrails; 4 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 (c) for the provision of an escape walkway, with handrails connecting this roof area into first floor level store rooms above the Garage Bar and through an existing door in the east gable of the Clarence Hotel into its stairwell at first floor level. Registration Date 22-Nov-2010 Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4017/10 Permission Axis Specialty Europe Limited 34 & 35, Mount Street Upper, Dublin 2 PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Planning permission for development at 34 & 35 Mount Street Upper, both are protected structures. The development will consist of forming an internal door opening in the party wall between No. 34 & 35 Upper Mount Street at half landing stairs level between the second and third floor levels serving as an access link between the two buildings. 23-Nov-2010 Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4030/10 Permission Pextell Ltd 34-35, College Green, Dublin 2 PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission is sought for development. The development will consist of internal alterations to number 34 College Green as follows a) removal of two non original internal staircases and a number of service inter floor staircases and replacement with two new staircases and balustrades, b) demolition of section of non original mezzanine and erection of two new mezzanines with balustrade to match new staircases, c) remove section of floor to allow for new staircase, d) alterations to non original internal columns to match originals, e) removal of selected sections of and creation of opes in some internal walls, f) replace recently installed roof lights with solid infill at ground floor ceiling level and, g) remove non original partitions and doors from upper floors and replace with some internal partitions and f) repair and reinstate original features where necessary. It is also proposed to refurbish the first, second and third floor of no. 35 College Green including the removal on non original internal partitions, doors and screens. These works are all being carried out in association with the use of this space as a retail unit. Registration Date 24-Nov-2010 Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4033/10 Retention Permission P Kennedy 5 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Location Proposal Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal 10, Saint Clares Terrace, Mount Drummond Avenue, Dublin 6 RETENTION - Change of use of existing single storey structure to artist studio 39sqm. The structure was formerly used as a store. 25-Nov-2010 Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4042/10 Permission Obarac Limited Trinity Capital Hotel Development at corner of Tara Street & Pearse Street, Dublin 2, comprising of Former Tara Street Fire Station Building (Fireworks), Trinity Capital Hotel & Bedroom Block on Cards Lane & 23-26 Pearse Street. PROTECTED STRUCTURE - Planning permission for retention for minor alterations to previously granted applications 3635/04, 6060/04 and 5794/07 as follows: Development works subject of Application for Retention Permission: 23-26 Pearse Street (protected structures) and 7 storey bedroom block to rear and Cards Lane -Retention of minor internal alterations to staff accommodation layout at basement level. -Retention of existing ope formed between hotel foyer and ground floor of no. 23 Pearse Street (Protected Structure). -Retention of relocated 'Hotel Bar' to ground floor of no. 23 Pearse Street (previously 'Hotel Office') -Retention of relocated 'Meeting Rooms' to ground floor level of no. 24 and 25 Pearse Street (Protected Structures - Previously 'Hotel Bar') -Retention of relocated 'Hotel Dining' at ground floor level of no. 26 Pearse Street (Protected Structure - Previously 'Hotel Shop'). -Retention of 'Hotel Dining' at ground floor level of new build hotel extension granted under planning application reference 3635/04 (previously 4no. hotel bedrooms and 'Hotel Gym') -Retention of additional floor area of 92sqm of 'Hotel Dining' to glazed link courtyard to rear of protected structures no. 23/26 Pearse Street -Retention of reconfigured hotel bedroom suites at first and second floor levels of nos. 23/26 Pearse Street (protected structures). -Retention of minor alterations to elevation previously granted under planning permissions 3635/04 and 6060/04. Trinity Capital Hotel - Main Building: Retention of 14no. additional bedrooms and 3no. new window opes to north facade or original hotel building (previously 'hotel restaurant', associated kitchen and wc's - these have been relocated to ground floor level to the rear of nos. 23/26 Pearse Street). Former Fire Station Building (protected structure): -Retention of exercise room with wc and changing room (previously roof void space) at third floor level. -Retention of roof light to centre valley of roof. -Retention of section of roof structure to north facing part of roof to allow access to new exercise room. -Retention of 1no. additional bedroom at third floor level of former fire station building including 2no. flush mounted inline roof lights to west facing roof. -Retention of 3no. additional bedrooms in total at lower first, second floor level of original hotel building to rear of former fire 6 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 station building including one new window ope to north facade (previously) hotel store rooms and toilets). Hotel now comprising 182 bedrooms in building complex above supported by ancillary hotel facilities. Registration Date 25-Nov-2010 DOMESTIC: Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4012/10 Permission Alphonsus Miley 84, Grosvenor Square, Rathmines, Dublin 6 PROTECTED STRUCTURE - Renovation, alteration and extension of an existing dwelling. The works will generally consist of the demolition of an existing single storey extension, the construction of a new single storey extension together with all associated refurbishment works all to the rear. 22-Nov-2010 Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4021/10 Permission Paul and Mary Fitzgerald 60, Palmerston Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6 The development will consist of: 1. New vehicle access with dished foot path, exiting onto Palmerston Road (existing bus stop & lamp post to be relocated to suit). 2. Demolition of existing outhouse. 3. A new ground floor extension with apex roof to existing sunroom at the rear of dwelling, to be used as a dining room. 4. The re-modelling of the existing kitchen & living rooms to incorporate an open plan feature. 5. The re-modelling of the existing front bedroom to incorporate an en-suite & walk-in wardrobe. All drainage, structural and associated site works. Registration Date 23-Nov-2010 Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4038/10 Retention Permission Ms Catherine Raethorne 10, Lansdowne Hall, Sandymount, Dublin 4 RETENTION - And completion of development. The development will consist of a single storey sunroom (10sqm) to the rear of the property and all associated site works. 25-Nov-2010 Area Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 7 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date Area Application Number Application Type Applicant Location Proposal Registration Date 4041/10 Permission Muriel O'Byrne & Paul O'Shea 106, Wilfield Road, Sandymount, Dublin 4 Widen a pedestrian access to create a vehicular access to the front, to include new gates and driveway and associated site works. 25-Nov-2010 Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4044/10 Retention Permission Kyran and Rena McLaughlin 12 & 14, Argyle Road, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Retention of minor re-location of the boundary walls between no. 12 & no. 14 Argyle Road and reduction in overall area of rear garden of no. 12 Argyle Road and increase in area of rear garden of no. 14 Argyle Road of previously approved permission 1562/03. 26-Nov-2010 Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 4567/05/x1 Extension of Duration of Permission Mary McMahon 13, Lansdowne Park, Dublin 4 I Mary McMahon intend applying for permission at 13 Lansdowne Park, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 for single storey extension to the side and rear to provide w.c., new kitchen and living room and associated internal revisions to existing house. 24-Nov-2010 LAWS: ***NONE*** SAWS: ***NONE*** DECISIONS: Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 0253/10 Section 5 Grant Exemption Certificate 22-Nov-2010 Mr. Martin Conway, AIllied Irish Banks p.l.c. AIB ATM Bunker, Lower Stephens Street, Dublin 2 EXPP: The works include the following: Replacement of the existing automated teller machine with similar new automated teller machine. 8 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 0256/10 Section 5 Refuse Exemption Certificate 24-Nov-2010 ESB Shared Services 41, Merrion Square, Dublin 2 Removal of an existing single door and installation of double doors with associated alterations to partition. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 0261/10 Section 5 Refuse Exemption Certificate 25-Nov-2010 Gerard McNamara 9, Sunbury Park, Dartry, Dublin 6 Construction of boundary wall to 3.68 metres on boundary to No. 10 Sunbury Park. Construction of extension to rear of no. 9, including extension at first floor, within 2 metres of party boundary to no. 10. Construction / erection of shed to rear of no. 9 in excess of 25sqm and for human habitation. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 0263/10 Section 5 Additional Information 24-Nov-2010 Colm Torpey 5, Frankfort Avenue, Rathgar, Dublin 6 EXPP: Flue for gas boiler to exit front basement, replacing an old energy inefficient gas boiler with a new worcester conderser boiler. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 0276/10 Social Housing Exemption Certificate Grant Social Housing Exemption Cert 23-Nov-2010 Julie Le Brocquy 18, Eglinton Road, Dublin 4 SHEC: (1unit) 2 Storey over basement Dwelling House 9 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 0277/10 Social Housing Exemption Certificate Grant Social Housing Exemption Cert 23-Nov-2010 Tom and Margaret Moran 8 Gilford Court, Rear of 101, Sandymount Avenue, Dublin 4 Erection of two storey mews dwelling. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 0279/10 Social Housing Exemption Certificate Grant Social Housing Exemption Cert 23-Nov-2010 Terry and Breda Connaughton 2B, Brendanvale, Dunville Avenue, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 The development will consist of the construction of one two storey dwelling to the western side of the existing dwelling at no. 2B as outlined in the site map. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 2121/05/x1 Extension of Duration of Permission ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 26-Nov-2010 Clydewell Investments Ltd, Irwin Drunker 59, Orwell Park and Orwell Bank, Rathgar, Dublin 6 Permission is sought by Brian M Durkan & Co Ltd for a residential development at No 59, Orwell Park and Orwell Bank, Rathgar Dublin 6 comprising the demolition of the existing house; the construction of 21 no residential units in 2 no blocks (A & B) to include 13 no apartments arranged over four floors (12 no 2 bed apartments & 1 no 3 bed apartment) 9 no with balconies 4 no with terrace/patio (Blocks A), 8 no townhouses (2bed & study) with patios (Block B) part over basement carpark (35 no spaces) with bicycle stores, refuse and ancillary stores, boundary walls/fences; new vehicular and pedestrian entrances; ramp; roads; surface car parking (3no spaces) and all associated site and landscaping works on an overall site of area 0.39 Hectares. Area Application Number Application Type Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3093/10 Permission 10 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal GRANT PERMISSION 24-Nov-2010 John Lally 3, Cecilia Street, Dublin 2 PROTECTED STRUCTURE-The development will consist of change of use of existing 120.3sqm ground floor retail unit to cafe/restaurant use. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3110/10 Permission GRANT PERMISSION 22-Nov-2010 Ciaran Hickey 2, Rathmines Road Lower, Dublin 6 PROTECTED STRUCTURE - Restore and renovate 4 no. apartments. The development shall include: forming new basement entrance, including external stairs including wheelchair access from front garden, to basement apartment; renovating existing front and side gardens, including railings and paths; removing existing internal stairs between basement and ground floor; constructing new balconies to the rear to serve ground, first and second floor apartments, including forming new opes in rear wall at those levels; installing new bathroom, sanitary and kitchen facilities throughout; renovating and restoring existing external and internal walls, including existing historical brickwork, stonework, timber joinery and timber and plaster finishes; renovating the roof and chimneys. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3667/10 Permission ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 22-Nov-2010 AYOT Ltd 18, Merrion Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 The development will consist of the construction of a new single storey extension (8sqm) to the rear of the existing structure and change of use of existing ground floor (57sqm) from shop to pizza bakery and restaurant to include sale of hot food for consumption on and off the premises, all associated site and development works including new signage to existing shopfront. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3672/10 Permission GRANT PERMISSION 23-Nov-2010 11 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Applicant Location Proposal Mr. Kieran Kavanagh 39, Raglan Lane, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 The development will consist of a new ground floor extension to the rear with extended kitchen and dining space with 5 no. velux roof windows and new internal changes to open plan living space. Replace existing flat roof to house with new pitched tiled roof structure, also widening of existing vehicular entrance from Raglan Lane to allow easy passage into driveway. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3679/10 Retention Permission REFUSE RETENTION PERMISSION 23-Nov-2010 Mr. Paul Drumgoole 60, William Street South, Dublin 2 PROTECTED STRUCTURE:To retain railings to front. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3682/10 Permission REFUSE PERMISSION 22-Nov-2010 Sandra Lynch 9-13, Terenure Road North, Dublin 6w Planning permission for the change of use of part of the existing property from previous use as office supplies and stationary warehousing, to use as a car wash facility, tyre centre and car sales. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3688/10 Outline Permission REFUSE OUTLINE PERMISSION 24-Nov-2010 Ben McArdle 120, Merrion Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 (corner of) Outline planning permission for development to the rear of no. 120 Merrion Road. The development will consist of: 1no. two-storey mews dwelling extending to 232sqm and car parking for 2no. vehicles, and will include the demolition of the existing rear boundary wall to widen the existing the existing news laneway off Shrewsbury Park to provide vehicular and pedestrian access. The development will also include new rear boundary treatment, landscape works and ancillary site development and services works. 12 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3696/10 Permission GRANT PERMISSION 25-Nov-2010 Dr. Sunhera Ziab & Paul Murphy 7 & 8, Grattan Street, Dublin 2 Planning permission to construct new second floor extensions, including rear facing screened balconies to existing 2 storey terrace houses. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3699/10 Permission REFUSE PERMISSION 25-Nov-2010 Supergroup Ireland Ltd 6-10, Suffolk Street, Dublin 2 The development will consist of the provision of new Illuminated shopfront signage to the retail unit at ground floor / street level. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3700/10 Permission ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 25-Nov-2010 McGarrell Reilly Contractors &, IBI Nominees Ltd Teach Earlsfort, 29, Earlsfort Terrace / Upper Hatch Street and Garryard House, No's 25-28 Earlsfort Terrace, Dublin 2 Planning permission for development of Teach Earlsfort, 29, Earlsfort Terrace / Upper Hatch Street and Garryard House, No's 25-28 Earlsfort Terrace, Dublin 2 which comprises a corner site measuring 3991sqm and fronting onto Upper Hatch Street to the north and Earlsfort Terrace to the East. The site includes an open double deck car park structure to the rear. The proposed mixed use development comprises of a total gross floor area of 24,787sqm (including 1,693sqm of ancillary office use at basement levels) and includes the following: 1. The demolition of all existing structures on the site including a 5 storey building known as 'Garryard House' fronting onto Earlsfort Terrace; a 7 storey building with an 8th floor set back accommodating plant rooms and machinery above roof level known as 'Teach Earlsfort' fronting onto Earlsfort Terrace and Upper Hatch Street ; and an open double deck car park structure located at rear. 2. The construction of a mixed use commercial headquarter building with a maximum height of 9 storeys, composed of a series of three dimensional and fissured cubic elements. The Proposal 13 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 corner element addressing the junction of Upper Hatch Street and Earlsfort Terrace is nine storeys high. In the eastern part of the site, the building height steps down from six to four storeys towards the South of Earlsfort Terrace, where it adjoins existing buildings (protected structures). In the western part of the site, the building height steps down from eight storeys (as fronting onto Upper Hatch Street, providing a 165sqm roof terrace) to five storeys (in the south west part of the site) with a nine storey central element. Building heights, as referred to above contain internally all plant room areas (566sqm located at ground floor, 7th and 8th floor levels). A total of 23461sqm of office space includes 21,568sqm GFA (including 200sqm of possible restaurant / canteen area at first floor level) distributed from ground floor to 8th floor level and 1693sqm of additional ancillary office use located at basement level. Restaurant use is located in the north east corner of the building fronting onto the junction of Upper Hatch Street and Earlsfort Terrace and provides for a restaurant / cafe / retail (214sqm) at ground floor level (with main and second entrances located on both streets). The main office entrance in proposed at ground floor level on Upper Hatch Street, with associated lobby and reception areas. A second entrance to the Corporate Headquarters is provided on Earlsfort Terrace. Other accesses to the building are also provided on the western and eastern elevations and off Adelaide Road through a pedestrian lane. A central atrium links the two main service cores, reception areas and the series of three dimensional and fissured cubic elements which compose the overall building. A double level basement is proposed which provides for 90 car parking spaces, 232 cycle spaces, ancillary office use and storage areas (1,693sqm), shower and changing facilities along with plant room areas (482sqm) and refuse storage. Vehicular access to the development is from Earlsfort Terrace, via a two way ramp down to basement levels. Associated works above and below ground include the provision of 1 no. ESB double substation together with enhancements to the site boundary through hard and sot landscaping. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3701/10 Permission REFUSE PERMISSION 25-Nov-2010 Deirdre Donohue 12, Elgin Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Planning permission is sought for works to the lower ground floor of the existing dwelling to include: (a) demolition of lower ground floor section of existing 4 storey return, associated out-building and store to rear of property; (b) internal alterations to existing layout at lower ground floor level; (c) enlargement of existing opening to rear elevation at lower ground floor level; (d) enlargement of existing opening to front elevation at lower ground floor level; (e) provision of a new single storey extension at lower ground floor level to the rear of the property comprising of new kitchen and living area; (f) provision of screened courtyard at lower ground 14 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 floor level to rear of property; (g) the conservation and repair of existing historical features; (h) all associated site development and landscaping works. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3710/10 Permission GRANT PERMISSION 25-Nov-2010 Kanum Thai Ltd 16-18, Orwell Road, Rathgar, Dublin 6 New ground floor windows to side and new signage and associated lighting to previously approved Thai Restaurant at Kanum Thai. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3772/10 Permission GRANT PERMISSION 24-Nov-2010 Patricia McKiernan 20, Seafort Villas, Sandymount, Dublin 4 Planning permission is being sought to demolish existing single storey flat roofed extensions to rear, construct new single storey flat roofed extension to rear with 2no. roof lights over and to add 1no. velux roof light to rear of existing dwelling. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3973/10 Permission APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID 22-Nov-2010 Catherine Brady and Paul Mitchell Ash Mews, Charleville Close, Rathmines, Dublin 6 The proposed development consists of the following: 1. Construction of new single storey extension to rear of existing structure; 2. Minor modifications to the existing front and rear elevations at ground and first floor level; 3. Minor modifications to the internal layout at ground, first and attic level. The development will include associated drainage, site development work, landscaping and repair works. 15 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3988/10 Permission APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID 25-Nov-2010 Tom and Margaret Moran 8 Gilford Court, Rear of 101, Sandymount Avenue, Dublin 4 The development will consist of demolition of garage and erection of two storey detached mews dwelling with garage, first floor terrace at rear and boundary and landscaping treatment. Area Application Number Application Type Decision Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) WEB1200/10 Permission GRANT PERMISSION 25-Nov-2010 Treasa Walsh 28, Saint Brendan's Cottages, Dublin 4 The development will consist of: the demolition of the existing kitchen and outside toilet and the erection of a new single-storey extension to the rear of the dwelling. APPEALS NOTIFIED: Area Application Number Appeal Type Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 3037/10 Written Evidence The Sisters Of St. Louis Saint Louis High School and, Charleville House, Charleville Road And, No. 1 Grosvenor Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6 Development comprising the redevelopment of lands at St. Louis High School and Charleville House, Charleville Road , and No. 1 Grosvenor Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6. The proposed development consists of the following: (a) Demolition of no. 1 Grosvenor Road and of Cuisle, a former chapel located adjacent to Charleville House. The existing copper spire from Cuisle (c. 15m high) is to be reused in the proposed public park. (b) Construction of a new stand-alone 4-storey, with set back 5th storey convent building incorporating 25no. one bedroom residential units, together with communal areas of c. 345m2 in total. These include a communal recreation room, a room for worship and storage area. (c) Relocation of the existing St. Louis Grotto to a new location in the private garden associated with the new convent building. (d) Construction of a new 2-storey Sports Hall in the north west corner of the site comprising a Department of Education specification 600m2 PE hall, changing facilities storage and two 16 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 flexible use classroom areas; total is c. 1047m2 (e) Construction of 86 no. residential units in buildings of 4 storeys and 5 storeys in height (The 5th storey is set back in all cases except on block F). These buildings will contain 17 no. 1 bedroom apartments, 48 no. two-bedroom apartments, 2no. three-bedroom apartments and 19 no. three bedroom duplexes. Of the 86 units, 6 will be reserved for the exclusive use of the Order of the Sisters of St. Louis. These units will be located in Block D which is the closet one to Charleville House. (f) Construction of 2 no. units on the ground floor level of the Block A. These will have a floor area of 105m2 and 160m2 respectively. One of these units is to be designated for community orientated users, and the other is to be a unit for cultural/recreational use. G) provision of a new basketball court (510m2) on site of a former tennis court to the rear of the St. Louis High school, including part refurbishment of the boundary fence in this location and part new 2.4m high boundary walls including retention of gate access on to the lane of Grosvenor Place together with a new decked recreational area with attractive landscaping and seating. (h) Creation of an area of public open space at the junction of Wynnefield Road and Charleville Road. This is to contain a children's play area, with equipment. (i) Private open space throughout the development is provided in the form of private gardens, or balconies/terraces or roof terraces. (j) Provision of 83no. car parking spaces below a landscaped podium level and a further 18 no. surface car parking spaces to the front of Charleville House (15 spaces already exist in this area). (k) Vehicular access to the development is to be taken from Charleville Road via three access points. One is the existing entrance to Charleville House and will be used to access the convent buildings only, the second is the existing entrance to the school which will be used to access the new sports hall and the existing school buildings. The third is a new access formed onto Charleville Road opposite nos. 15 and 16 Charleville Road. The new access will provide access to the below podium car parking level. All associated site development works, landscaping items the removal of sections of the existing stone wall along Charleville Road and the reduction in height of other sections of the wall together with all other boundary treatments are also included in this application. A masterplan for the entire landholding accompanies the application. All proposed works are to take place on a site of c. 1.45 ha. APPEALS DECISIONS: Area Application Number Appeal Decision Appeal Decision Date Applicant Area 1 - South East 4057/09 GRANT PERMISSION 24-Nov-2010 Radio Teilifis Eireann (RTE) 17 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 Location Proposal The RTE Campus, N11 Stillorgan Road, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 PROTECTED STRUCTURE: Application for a ten year permission to provide a new broadcasting facility at the RTE Campus, N11 Stillorgan Road, Donnybrook, Dublin 4. The proposal measures 103,553 sq.m including basements and 63,554 sq.m excluding basements and has a height from 10.7 metres to 36 metres over double basement. The new Broadcasting Facility provides television and radio studio accommodation; multi-purpose space; news rooms; orchestra accommodation; staff office accommodation and associated facilities; creche; sound stages; set storage; plant areas; broadcasting technology suites; work shops; television production outdoor sets; permanent and temporary internal campus roads; cycle and pedestrian facilities; 800 no. car parking spaces all at basement level; 3 no. coach parking spaces at ground level; 272 no. bicycle parking spaces at ground level; 98 no. motorcycle parking spaces; extensive landscape works, including a new plaza and upgrading of the linear park along the N11 Stillorgan Road; the alteration to the existing 3 arm N11 / Airfield junction to a 4 arm signal controlled junction to provide new vehicular and pedestrian access off the N11 Stillorgan Road to the site; additional pedestrian an access points off the N11 Stillorgan Road and all associated site development works. There area two protected structures on the RTE campus, Montrose House and Mount Errol House (but not included in the application site). The application site measures 6.98ha and the RTE Campus as a whole measures 13.0ha. The proposal is to be built in three interconnected Blocks over five phases. Block 1 comprises the southern most or front element to the N11 Stillorgan Road and is arranged around a centralised atrium and generally accommodates TV news and day time studios, news desk, orchestra studio, general offices, canteen, reception rooms, multi-purpose performance space, a coffee shop, RTE shop, RTE archive portal and the RTE credit union. A number of satellite dishes with maximum diameter 2.4m will be located at roof level. It ranges in height from 28.5m to 36m (at the sloping atrium roof) ; Block 2 is located to the north-east of Block 1 and accommodates five large TV studios with adjoining audience assembly rooms (with cloakroom, WC and bar facilities) two of which are capable of amalgamation, 3 smaller TV studios, 9 radio broadcast studios, actor and presenter accommodation and control room suites. Block 2 has a height generally of 19.5m but with a high point of 28.5m where a vertical sliding studio door is accommodated in structure at roof level. Block 2 is separated from Block 1 by an internal audience street (25.5m high); Block 3 is the northern most (rear) element. It accommodates offices, set storage, work shops, data storage and equipment rooms, server room, broadcasting technology suite, library/archive space, loading bay and service yard. Block 3 is separated from Block 2 by an internal street (21m high) and generally ranges in height from 10.7m to 19.5m. The proposal involves the demolition of the remaining wall of a walled garden formally associated with Mount Errol (Protected Structure), two storey Radio building (5,900 sq.m) a multi-storey car park (2,395sq.m) with 216 no. car parking spaces, a single storey creche (597sq.m) a two storey sound stage/library building (2900 sq.m) a two storey set storage building (1848 sq.m) and an external production set. The proposal is to be built in five phases as follows; Phase One comprising 3 television production studios and young people's 18 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 studio with all associated set management, production and audience facilities, service yard, radio studios, plant and technical support facilities all part of Blocks 2 and 3. Phase two comprising 1 television production studio with all associated set management, production and audience facilities, radio studios, technical support facilities and plant, all part of Blocks 2 and 3. Phase three comprising an orchestra studio, daytime studio, news studio with all associated set management production and visitor facilities, radio studios, edit and dubbing suites and administrative office facilities all part of Block 1. Phase four comprising entrance foyer, visitor facilities, staff canteen, visitor's basement parking, public archive, coffee shop and credit union, all part of Block 1. Phase five comprising 2 television production studios/sound stages with all associated set management, production and audience facilities, service yard, administrative and technical support facilities and plant all part of blocks 2 and 3. The application is accompanied by an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). The EIS will be available for inspection or purchase for a fee not exceeding the reasonable cost of making a copy at the offices of the Planning Authority during its public opening hours. iarratas a dheanamh ar chead pleanala deich mbliana d'fhorbairt chun Saoraid Nua Craolachain a sholathar ag Campus RTE N11 Bothar Stigh Lorgan, Domhnach Broc, Baile Atha Cliath, 4. Beidh an togra 103.553 meadar cearnach le hioslaigh san aireamh agus 63,554 meadar cearnach gan ioslaigh san airmeah agus airde a reimsionn o 10.7 meadar go dti 36 meadar thar ioslach dubailte. Solathraionn an Saoraid Craolachain coiriocht stiuideo teilifis agus radio; spas ilchuspora; seomrai nuachta; coiriocht ceolfhoirne; coiriocht oifige don fhoireann agus saoraidi gaolmhara; creche; staitsi fuaime; storail seite; achair ghleasra teicneolaiocht craolachan; cearlanna; seiteanna leiriuchain teilifis allamuigh; boihtre campais inmheanach buana agus sealadacha; saoraidi rothaiochta agus coisthe; 800 spas pairceala carranna ar fad ag an leibheal ioslaigh; 3 spas pairceala coisti ag leibheal na talun; 272 spas pairceala rothar ag leibheal na talun; 98 spas pairceala gluaisrothar; mor-oibreachta tridhreacha, lena nairtear, lena n-airtear plas nua agus uasghradu ar an bparaic lineach ar feadh bothar stigh lorgan N11; an t-athru ar an N11 3 ghrag / Acomhal Chuirt Bhan an Aeir Chuig acomhal 4 gheag ata a rialu ag comharthrai chun rochtain nua a sholathar d'fheithicil agus do choisithe o Bothar Stigh Lorgan N11 chuig an laithrean; pointi rochtana coisithe breise o Bothar Stogh Lorgan N11 agus gach obair eile a bhaineann leis na hiobreacha forbartha laithreain. Ta dha struchtur cosanta ar Champas RTE Teach Montrose agus Teach Errol (ach nil siad seo san aireamh san iarratas laithreain). Beidh an t-iarratas laithreain 6.98 heict agus beidh campas RTE ar fad 13.0 heict. Togfar an togra i dtri Bhloc idirnasctha thar cuig cheim. Ta bloc 1 comhdheanta den ghne is faide o dheas no an ghne tosach ar Bhothar Stigh Lorgan N11 agus ta se suite timpeall aitriam larnaithe agus go ginearalta bionn nuacht teilifise agus stiuideonnalae, stiuideonna radio, deasc nuachta stiuideo ceolfhoirne, oifigi ginearalta, ceaintin, ionad failtithe, seomrai cruinnithe, spas leirithe ilchuspora, siopa caife, siopa RTE, tairseach cartlainne RTE agus Comhar Creidmheasa RTE le fail ann. Beidh rionnt miasa satailite. le trastomhas uasta de 2.4m lonnaithe ag leibheal an din. Beidh a airde ag reimsiu o 19 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 28.5m go dti 36m (ag barr din aitriam a theann le fana) ; Ta bloc2 lonnaithe soir o thuaaidh de bloc 1 agus ta cuig stiuideonna mora teilifis le seomrai tionol don luacht feachana in aice laimhe (le seomra cotal. leithreas agus saoraidi beair) agus is feidir dha cheann de na seomrai sin a chomhnascadh, 3 stiudeo teilifise nios lu, 9 stiuideo craolachain radio, coiriocht d'aisteoiri agus do laithreoiri agus seomrai rialaithe.Ta airde ginearalta ag Bloc 2 de 19.5m ach ta pointe uasta aige de ait a bhfuil doras stiuideo sleamhnaite ingearach suite i struchtur ag leibheal an din. Ta bloc 2 deighilte amach o Bhloc 1 ag sraid lucht feachana inmheanach (25.5m airde); is e Bloc 3 an gne (cul) is faide o thuaidh. Ta ofigi, storail seite, ceardlanna, storail sonrai agus seomrai treaalamh, seomra freastalai, seomra teicneolaiochta craolaachain, spas leabharlainne/ceartlainne, ba lodala agus clos seirbhise. Ta bloc 3 deighilte o bhloc 2 ag sraid inmheanach (21m ar airde) agus ta se ag reimsiu go ginearalta in airde o 10.7m go dti 19.5m. Airtear ar an togra, balla a bhi mar chuid de ghairdin a raibh baint aige roimhe seo le Mount Errol (Struchtur Cosanta) a leagan, Foirgneamh Radio dha stor (5900 meadar cearnach) carrchlos ilstoir (2395 meadar cearnach) le 216 spas pairceaala carranna, creche aon-urlair (597 meadar cearnach), foirgeamh dha stor staitse fuaime/leabharlainne (2900 meadae cearnach), foirhneamh dha stor storail seite (1848 meadar cearnach) agus seit leiriuchain seachtrach. Togra i gcuig cheim mar seo a leanas. Ta Ceim a hAon comhdheanta de 3 stiudeo leiriuchain teilifis agus stiuideo do dhaoine oga le saoraidi bainstiochta seite, leiruchain agus lucht feachana, clos seirbhise, stiudeonna radio, saoraidi tacaiochta teicniul agus gleasra ata mar chuid de bhloc 2 agus 3. Ta ceim a do radio, saoraidi tacaiochta teicniula agus gleasra ata ar fad mar chuid de bhloc 2 agus 3. ta ceim a tri comhdheanta de stiudeo ceolfhoirne, stiudeo lae, stiuideo nuachta agus le saoraidi lae, stiuideo nuachta agus soaraidi bainisiochte seite, leiriuchain agus cuairteoiri, stiuideonna radio, seomrai eagarthoireachta agus dubala agus saoraidi oifigi riarachain ata ar fad mar chuid de bhloc 1. Ta ceim a ceathair comhdheanta de fhorhalla iontrala, saoraidi cuairteoiri, ceaintin foirne, pairceail ioslaigh do chuairteoiri, cartlann phoibli siopa caife agus comhar creidmheasa, ata ar fad mar chuid de bhloc 1. Ta ceim a cuig comhdheanta de 2 stiuideo leiriuchainteilifis/staitsi fuaime le saoraidi bainsiochta leiriuchain agus feachana, clos seirbhise, saoraidi tacaiochta agus glaesra riarachain agus teicniuil ata ar fad mar chuid bhloc 2 agus 3. Area Application Number Appeal Decision Appeal Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 2783/10 GRANT PERMISSION 25-Nov-2010 Michael Ryan and Bernie McArdle 28, Mount Drummond Square, Harold's Cross, Dublin 6 The development will consist of: The demolition of existing single storey extension to rear and the erection of a single storey extension to rear, the erection of a single storey porch to 20 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 front, the replacement of windows in existing dwelling together with landscaping and other ancillary works. Area Application Number Appeal Decision Appeal Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 2784/10 GRANT PERMISSION 24-Nov-2010 Johnny O'Loughlin 50, Mountpleasant Avenue Lower, Dublin 6 PROTECTED STRUCTURE : Development will consist of demolition of existing 2 storey rear return, chimney and garden shed, construction of new 2 storey extension to rear with lower ground floor level, modifications to rear elevation, internal alterations, replacement of windows to front and associated site works. Area Application Number Appeal Decision Appeal Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 2806/10 ATTACH CONDITIONS 24-Nov-2010 Sheenagh Walsh 133, Meadowbank, Rathgar, Dublin 6 The proposed development consists of the partial demolition of existing single storey elements and the construction of a single storey extension to the rear and a two storey extension to the side of the existing dwelling (with an increase to the existing ground and first floor area of 53sqm), the raising of the pitch of the existing roof to accommodate a new attic bedroom (28sqm), including rear dormer windows, first floor terrace (8sqm), minor alterations to existing structure, hard and soft landscaping and for all associated site works. Area Application Number Appeal Decision Appeal Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 2846/10 GRANT PERMISSION 22-Nov-2010 Ann Clune and Colm Quilligan 35, Heytesbury Street, Dublin 8 PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Planning application sought for permission for a single storey extension to rear with family room, corridor and two storey stairs link to existing return building at first floor level, new bathroom in existing return at 21 Week 47/10 22/11/10 – 26/11/10 first floor level, in a protected structure. Area Application Number Appeal Decision Appeal Decision Date Applicant Location Proposal Area 1 - South East (Nov 09) 2941/10 REFUSE PERMISSION 25-Nov-2010 Gabriel and Patricia Mulligan 9, Pleasants Street, Dublin 8 PROTECTED STRUCTURE-The development will consist of the part demolition of an existing two storey return and construction of a replacement two storey extension to the rear and new internal refurbishment of an existing mid terrace two storey dwelling. 22