A REPORT FOR THE LEARNING LEADERS OF THE FOUNDATION TEAMS THAT IDENTIFIES ISSUES RELATING TO WORK-PLACEMENTS FOR THEIR SPECIFIC COHORT OF STUDENTS AND STRATEGIES TO OPTIMISE WORK-PLACEMENTS FOR BOTH STUDENTS AND EMPLOYERS. Report prepared by Veronica Shepperd (M.Ed, IDLTM, Dip. Ed, B.A, CELTA) Date of Report 10th December 2010 This Report was undertaken with funding provided by Skills Tasmania. Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 1 of 23 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary 1. Issues for each specific cohort of students regarding work-placements. 1.1 Connect a. Behavioural b. Time 1.2 Transitions a. Behavioural b. Time 1.3 Migrant Education a. Behavioural b. Time 1.4 Adult Literacy and Numeracy Page 4 Page 5 2. Strategies for successful work-placement Page 8 3. Research into strategies for successful work-placement 3.1 What things are important to learn in order to get a job? 3.2 Embedding literacy, numeracy, and language skills 3.3 Models for embedding literacy a. Fully Integrated model b. Sandwich Model c. Overlapping Circles Model 3.3 Vocational Aids to literacy and work-placement learning Page 10 4. Strategies for the different learning groups 4.1 Learners with profound and complex disabilities 4.2 Long-term unemployed adult numeracy and literacy 4.3 Migrants have cultural as well as language needs Page 15 5. Support for Employers 5.1 Centralised data base 5.2 Research and identify employers 5.3 Getting the right match 5.4 Visiting employers 5.5 Confidentiality 5.6 Health and safety 5.7 Draw up an agreement between all parties 5.8 Specialist support 5.9 Job trainer/job coach 5.10 Supervision, performance monitoring and progression Page 18 6. Employer Education 6.1 Ensuring accessibility Page 23 7. Building relationships with voluntary work providers Page 24 Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 2 of 23 8. Conclusion Page 24 References Page 25 Appendix 1 Case Study – Learner support Appendix 2 Study – Low literacy employment review Appendix 3 Accessibility strategies Page 27 Page 27 Page 28 Table 1 The Skills for Life strategy process Table 2 Post office embedded language skills Table 3 Strategies for good employer relationships Page 11 Page 12 Page 18 Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 3 of 23 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The research project focuses on the issues and strategies related to work-placement, relevant to the Foundation students at the Tasmanian Polytechnic. It also looks at ways to support and educate employers and gives practical ideas for implementing strategies to aid the different cohorts in the study. The views of teachers, employers and the students were sought at various stages. The research findings provide both useful insights and practical steps for developing workplacements for Foundation students. The report identifies the main issues as: Lack of confidence and/or motivation Low literacy and/or language skills Need for social and work skills Need for time to build employer relationships Lack of employer education The strategies employed by teachers and supported by the research include: Match students to employers Effective communication with employers on student capabilities Simplify paperwork for employers Coordinator and employer data base Encourage self-reliance Explicit role Observation and mentoring Reality classroom Visual work visits Workplace and social skills courses Strategy instruction Learning the value of work Research includes recommendations and practical examples of work-placement strategy: Embed literacy and numeracy skills within the learner’s actual or preferred working environments Provide models of embedding and examples Vocational aids to literacy and work-placement learning Centralised data base Strategies for good employer relationships; research, getting the right match, confidentiality, accessibility, health and safety, and efficient paperwork Employer education by providing support through awareness raising, training, and ongoing advice The report will be of relevance to those committed to promoting the social inclusion of a highly marginalised group of people in the Tasmanian community. Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 4 of 23 1. ISSUES FOR EACH SPECIFIC COHORT OF STUDENTS REGARDING WORK-PLACEMENTS 1.1 CONNECT a. Behavioural Lack of motivation and confidence – therefore undersell themselves Low literacy and mental problems Lack of social and work skills – no knowledge from family or contacts on middle class behaviour Lack of training makes placement difficult Lack of a work ethic – some students don’t turn up or excessively use mobile phones. Younger students even in a reality classroom tend to know what to do but don’t do it in the workplace b. Time Certificates take time to organise – in a ten week course the teacher has to organise work-placement in the second week to take into account needed certificates Lack of allocated work-placement organisation time – this affects the relationship with the employers as teachers need to talk to employers to build rapport The information given to employers is rarely read and needs to be minimized Work visit time is difficult if not all students go out together 1.2 TRANSITIONS a. Behavioural Lack of confidence – for parents and carers as well as the students Low literacy, mental and/or physical problems Employer resistance b. Time Not enough time for thorough work-placement pairing – students need careful pairing with sympathetic employers, they also need to be matched according to their skills Unable to function on their own in a workplace Work visit time is difficult if not all students go out together 1.3 MIGRANT EDUCATION a. Behavioural Lack of English skills – lack of familiarity with specific workplace language Little knowledge of Australian workplace skills – interview, selection criteria, resumes, OH&S, work culture Little knowledge of Australian workplaces Lack of confidence – partly due to language difficulties or lack of contact with Australian workers, also cultural differences b. Time Lack of allocated work-placement organisation time – this affects the relationship with the employers as teachers need to talk to employers to build rapport Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 5 of 23 The information given to employers is rarely read and needs to be minimized Work visit time is difficult if not all students go out together 1.4 LITERACY AND NUMERACY These students have not yet experienced work-placement but below are issues identified through research: Older people and others at a disadvantage in the labour market on average have relatively low levels of qualifications and skills Lack of qualifications/work – many lack formal qualifications, which can make it more difficult to compete in the workforce They may lack up-to-date training, or their skills may not match the current labour market demand, particularly where there have been significant changes in the labour market Lack of confidence, particularly in the ability to find work; becomes more prominent with age and duration spent out of employment Attitudes to employment – length of time away from the labour market can also act as a strong attitudinal barrier to work for people who have become used to the benefit system. People who have been out of work for a long time may lack motivation and have low self-esteem May be responsible for a range of dependants Benefit disincentives – these can be a significant barrier to work and arise from the relatively low wages many people are likely to secure. The smaller the income gap between benefit and work, the less likely customers are to see the advantages of moving from the security of benefits into the relative insecurity of work Transport difficulties – these include the cost, time, and availability of public transport. In some places people are unwilling to travel outside their immediate locality to find employment or training opportunities (National Audit Office analysis of published research) 2. STRATEGIES FOR SUCCESSFUL WORK-PLACEMENT The strategies outlined below are mostly applicable to all cohorts except where specifically outlined: Match students with employees. Allow students to choose work place with guidance Students who have ownership of their work place are more likely to perform at their best Encourage self reliance of the students and make work-placement noncompulsory Roles need to be explicit – many of the students lack confidence, and this, allied to confusion about the job, can result in an unsuccessful workplacement Need to have observation and or mentoring of students in the workplace Group work place visits are useful for all groups but are necessary for Transition students and Adult Literacy and Numeracy students. These can include work place visits and visiting speakers Practice in a reality classroom so the classroom mirrors the workplace. punctuality, no mobile calls, neat attire, ring when sick or to explain unavoidable lateness and work hard Co-ordinated data bank of employers that details who, when and what they can provide. Collaboration with workplace coordinator. A dedicated Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 6 of 23 workplace coordinator frees up time for the classroom teacher and makes the programme run efficiently Workplace Skills and Personal Skill course important to build self esteem and knowledge for low achievers and migrants. This should cover: o Strategy Instruction o Finding a job o Keeping a job o At work in Australia o OHS o Basic summary of strengths and weaknesses o Mock interview o Meeting employer expectations o Dealing with instructions o Learning the value of work o Connection to Society o Receive money o Develop skills Social/ Economic o Independence don’t need to rely on the government o Pride and recognition o Meet people – develop friendships and networks o Health issues o Part of the community o Give something back o Improve yourself by developing new skills and understanding Effective communication for employers on capabilities of the students. Need time to build relationship with employers. If the work-placement is organised as one to three days a week then employers and students can be well supported. It enables teachers to obtain and give feedback, and there is time to integrate the work place learning with classroom practice. As a result problems can be minimised Possibility of courses such as Barista, white card, RSA incorporated in workplacement (time and need must be measured here) Preparation like group visits or a familiarization day enables students to see the workplace and meet the employees without the pressure of starting work at the same time Coordinator and data base for work-placement Simplify paperwork Transition students in addition need: Mentoring Repetition Group placements – for example charities, hospitals guest houses Very short placements or tasters valid for this group 3. RESEARCH INTO STRATEGIES FOR SUCCESSFUL WORK-PLACEMENT 3.1 WHAT THINGS ARE IMPORTANT TO LEARN IN ORDER TO GET A JOB? There is broad agreement between learners, providers, and employers as to the skills and abilities needed to be successful at work. Learners consider it is important to be: Willing Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 7 of 23 Reliable Good at time keeping Able to listen to others Consistent Able to do things without having to be told all the time Able to work on [their] own initiative Able to work together Co-operative Able to read and write Able to handle money Able to speak up clearly Able to speak with co-workers (Williams, 2005) Individuals need to develop: Personal skills, such as adaptability and responsibility Social skills including communication and understanding work appropriate behaviour Practical skills which includes basic literacy and numeracy skills and also skills that specifically relate to the job. Cognitive skills such as being able to concentrate and learn. Recognition of work rules such a punctuality and general work routines (Beyer et al., 2004) Many of the skills described above are the literacy, language and numeracy skills sometimes termed ‘Skills for Life’. They cover the skills of: Speaking and listening Reading and writing Interpreting, and calculating and communicating mathematical information In preparing people for work we can also draw on the wider key skills of: Working with others Improving own learning Performance, and problem solving All of these skills, including information technology, are valuable work skills and need to be taught in order to improve employability. Table1. THE SKILLS FOR LIFE STRATEGY PROCESSES. The Skills for Life Strategies Screening For possible literacy language and numeracy needs. Initial assessment Assessment for detailed learner for levels of skill Diagnostic Profile to inform individual learning plan. Formative Summative For regular review of progress to inform learning programme. For national test, qualification or completion of language learning programme Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 8 of 23 3.2 EMBEDDING LITERACY, NUMERACY, AND LANGUAGE SKILLS Best practice suggests that literacy, numeracy, and language skills should not be taught as isolated skills but rather embedded into relevant, engaging materials and learning experiences. Research suggests that people learn best when it is meaningful and they can see how learning a new skill or developing their knowledge or understanding will enhance their lives (Tusting and Barton, 2003). Literacy, language, and numeracy sessions can be developed around the learner’s actual or preferred working environments. Examples of this are using measurement in a supermarket, gardening, post office or warehouse environment. Table 2. Post Office embedded language skills Task Skill Sorting post Recognise alphabetical order Taking post and putting it into correct staff Recognise/read names pigeon holes Type simple team memos Listening/listen and respond Type simple team memos Write simple sentences 3.3 MODELS FOR EMBEDDING LITERACY There are various models for embedding literacy, language and numeracy tasks in practical settings or vocational training. NEICE website has details of materials that have been produced to support teaching and learning and information on the latest research into this challenging area. Three possible models are: a. Fully Integrated model Skills for life are integrated fully into the learning, and in the activity or subject matter, being interwoven with the subject, delivered through the whole activity and, being integral to it. Here, the person/s delivering the subject or main activity will also take on the basic skills work. For example literacy skills can be developed and practised by learners writing up the menu board at the snack counter each day. Learners develop their numeracy skills through collecting the toast money, counting how many slices of toast are needed and spoons of sugar in the tea. (E2E Provider) b. Sandwich Model Here, the Skills for Life are delivered in a calculated and discrete way. Part of the time is allowed for the whole activity or course, but are contextualised to the main subject area. This may work, for example, where specialised facilities, such as photographic dark rooms are only available to learners in a ‘rationed’ fashion. Often, staff other than those teaching the rest of the course, deliver the literacy, language, and numeracy input. Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 9 of 23 c. Overlapping Circles Model In this model, models 1 and 2 (i.e. Fully Integrated Model and Sandwich Model) are combined, and delivered, potentially, in a range of different ways. It may be that some of the literacy, language and numeracy work in this Overlapping Circles Model is not contextualised to the subject, so arguably is not ‘embedded’. Where the circles overlap, it will be embedded. The example below outlines mode and success of an Over-lapping Circles Model. Reading Youth Offender Institute has developed an integrated programme that combines a vocational training qualification (CIBT/CSCS Level 1) with the key skills of Communication, Application of Number and Working With Others. Embedding literacy, language and numeracy in a practical vocational activity helped learners appreciate the value of improving their skills. Employers were invited to visit the training centre and as a result revised their expectations of the skills that can be achieved by young offenders. The learners’ response to the course was very positive. Around 80 gained the industry qualification and some ex-offenders are now employed as kitchen fitters or in other related industries such as plumbing. Many learners who were previously disengaged from education realised, through the practical nature of the course, the value of literacy, language and numeracy learning. (www.niace.org.uk/ projects/Learning from Experience/EBS) 3.4 VOCATIONAL LEARNING AIDS TO LITERACY AND WORK-PLACEMENT 1. TECHNOLOGY CD-ROMs that link literacy to specific vocational areas such as Catering, Retail, and Childcare can be designed for students with low literacy skills. By targeting skills for Catering and Retail courses literacy skills within the specific vocational area are reinforced. For example, the Hospitality (Catering) disk may include Customer Care, Health and Safety Food Hygiene Numbers and tackle the relevant skills that students need to build within literacy, in order to progress into employment within that area of work. 2. VISUAL REALITY Electrical Skills – some of the exercises they could undertake may involve circuit boards with a light switch system where the trainee will need to cut and fit wiring Plumbing Skills – this may involve soldering joints for a bathroom sink. They will need to measure and cut copper piping Health and safety board game – this might consist of a building site, office or commercial kitchen with different safety signs that need placing in the correct location. Questions that may need to be asked are, for example: Can they use a tape measure? Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 10 of 23 Can the trainee read? If the trainee cannot read then the Instructor can read out instructions. Each assessment can be observed and when completed signed off by the instructor Below is an example of a simple scaffolding exercise which enabled a dyslexic student to gain permanent employment. The student was on a work-placement with nationwide clothing retailer. She had a strong chance of being offered a permanent job after just three weeks. During a progress review with her Level 1 literacy and numeracy course tutor, they discussed her progress, particularly in relation to her dyslexia. Together, they decided to create a vocationally related dictionary for the student to use in her placement. (Job Centre Plus) Preparing for job interviews; role-play, preparation and embedding interview skills in the overall course will all serve to increase a learner’s confidence when applying for jobs. A vital part of interview skills training is speaking and listening. You can identify the skills involved and then create opportunities for them to be taught. You can agree specific targets for learners and map these to the curriculum. Role-play and video cameras can be useful tools, if used sensitively, to record and give feedback to learners on their speaking and listening skills. Writing activities can also be linked to job search and interview skills. Embedding literacy tasks in job search skills can help individuals prepare for an interview. For example a literacy session covering adjectives with the focus of the session being attending a job interview. Handouts need to be cross-referenced to the core curriculum and the aim of the session is to give students a working knowledge of adjectives, including their practical applications. Participation and interest is maintained by relating work into the topic of job search by the group producing a list of qualities needed when they attend an interview. 4. STRATEGIES FOR THE DIFFERENT LEARNING GROUPS 4.1 LEARNERS WITH PROFOUND AND COMPLEX DISABILITIES In an earlier report 'Breaking the Barriers' disabled people identified the main barriers to getting employment as: Fear of losing benefits Health issues Lack of confidence Employers' attitudes Transport/location Carer’s concerns While adults with profound and complex learning difficulties may be unlikely to take part in paid employment, they should be offered opportunities to experience the world of work. It is a valid part of their life experience and includes them in society, giving greater understanding of the world in which they live. Some points to consider when setting up work experience are: That the work experience has clear aims and that these are communicated to people involved – looking at what everybody stands to gain from the experience, not just the learner Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 11 of 23 How long the placement will last; what feels good and realistic for everyone involved That the placement is reviewed regularly involving the learner, his/her support worker and the staff at the workplace This means that the learner’s progress and achievements can be celebrated and shared with everyone, and any concerns or problems can be raised and worked through. Sometimes a learner may not manage independent travel to work, but travel training can still be part of their learning programme and contribute to a full and independent life. Structured travel training can help determine the exact nature of the difficulty a learner may have when learning to master a particular route. Sometimes it may be easier to find an employer nearby but still teach the skills for independent travel. Practical work skills such as learning bus routes and times, number skills and communicating with others. (Barnardo’s A Chance to Work) 4.2 FOR THE LONG-TERM UNEMPLOYED ADULT NUMERACY AND LITERACY The Scottish Government introduced an adult training programme. The programme offers training programmes of varying length according to the participant’s length of time unemployed and skills level. The programme includes short job-focused training, longer occupational training, selfemployment training, basic employability training, and short intensive basic skills training. In addition, the programme can refer participants to programme centres and work trials to help them improve their employability and to find and keep jobs. The programme is not mandatory and participants must be aged 25 plus, unemployed for six months or more and claiming benefits. Those unemployed for 12 months can participate in longer courses. This programme has been running for 12 years with encouraging results nationwide. 4.3 MIGRANTS HAVE CULTURAL AS WELL AS LANGUAGE NEEDS Fouad and Bingham (1995, p344) have developed a model for working with minority ethnic students. These include: Establishing rapport Culturally appropriate relationships Listen and observe student's comments Learn how they wish to be related to Respond to their main words Construct and check out statements with the students Identification of the career issues that the student brings Cognitive Social Emotional (e.g. panic attacks at work) e Environmental (e.g. working conditions, co-workers) b Behavioural (e.g. being short-tempered at work) External barriers (e.g. discrimination, oppression, racism, sexism, financial concerns) Critical to the model is the explicit definition of external barriers because, for many minority students, career choice is a matter of balancing those factors within their control with those outside their control: Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 12 of 23 Assess the impact of cultural variables on career issues – for example, the impact a decision might have on the student’s family and consequences if s/he disappoints their parents. The meaning gender might have for the student Set culturally appropriate processes and goals – for example, inappropriate goals may include career choices based on unattainable desires rather than on common sense Determining and implementing a culturally appropriate intervention to address cognitive, social emotional, environmental, behavioural, external barriers – for example, use group intervention with those minority members who operate in a framework that is more collectivistic than individualistic. Involve the family in career decision making. Use race and gender appropriate role models to expand awareness of opportunities Helping the client make a culturally appropriate decision. Students may be making career choices, deciding to adjust their work roles or deciding they need more information. Practitioners need to be open to this process since many minority students will not see their choices as a linear, rational decision-making process 5. SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYERS 5.1 CENTRALISED DATA BASE It is worth investing a considerable amount of time in developing a network of forwardthinking and responsive employers. The relationship building becomes a two-way process, with you providing the advice and support for employers while they extend goodwill and commitment to the learning process that results in a positive and fruitful placement. Building effective relationships with employers is a key success factor in finding and keeping employment. The goodwill that employers extend is essential in providing either a positive and fruitful work-placement. It is important that a coordinator/coordinators manages the database and contact. This would result in responsive employers not being overloaded by different teachers. It would also free the classroom teacher to teach rather than spend time on paperwork and looking for employers. Finally the employer would have one point of contact which would aid the school/employer relationship. Table 3. STRATEGIES FOR GOOD EMPLOYER RELATIONSHIPS What to do Things to consider Research and identify The needs and preferences of the individual employers The needs and preferences of the employer Length of stay Level of English Skills Local employment trends Local employer details – keep a contact list Information on organisation/agencies who can provide support Health and safety check Ensure the learner understands their responsibilities with regard to health and safety Ensure the employer understands any additional requirements of the learner Complete a written health and safety assessment Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 13 of 23 Conduct an individual risk assessment Carry out induction and initial training Job matching using Initial Assessment and Employability Skills Checklist Areas of special concern including medication (with consent), hazards, criminal records How you introduce the learner to the workplace and vice versa Travel training Awareness and accessibility of notices Canteen and toilets Equal opportunities Health and safety training including fire procedures and first aid information Hours of work Procedure for absence Smoking rules Dress code Internet/email policy Draw up an agreement between all parties Written and verbal agreement Agree role of learner in workplace include the learner’s goals/targets for the placement – what they want to achieve Disciplinary and grievance procedures Equal opportunities Induction and training Make adaptations and get support Accessible information and communication Aids and equipment Clothing/uniform Specific support Travel expenses Establish a review process Supervision, performance Training and supporting managers and supervisors monitoring and progression Ongoing accessibility of information and procedures Maintaining a relationship with the employer or setting up ongoing systems of support such as keeping a log book, buddying or mentoring 5.2 RESEARCH AND IDENTIFY EMPLOYERS An understanding of the local needs of the economy is vitally important What jobs are available locally and realistically achievable? The first priority must be the needs and preferences of the individual learner It is a good idea to keep a record of employers contacted Success for All, The UK government strategy for reforming post-16 education, reiterates the increased importance placed on colleges to work with employers to meet the nation’s skills needs. Successful Engagement (Hughes, 2003), published by LSDA, provides good practice guidance, which can be generalised to a range of contexts and providers. This guidance has been written for all learners and does not specifically consider the needs of people who experience difficulties in learning. However, there is much to be learned from the advice Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 14 of 23 offered by Hughes (2003). He advises that Employment Placement Officers keep a ‘Job Contact Book’ to record their calls to employers. This ensures follow-up and avoids duplication. Any visits or successful placements are also recorded. Barnardo’s have large publicity boards aimed at engaging employers and use success stories to encourage employers to work with them. They have produced a promotional video, leaflets and brochures. 5.3 GETTING THE RIGHT MATCH It is advisable to undertake as much of the groundwork and preparation as possible before placement. One key aspect is that of ‘getting the match right’ – matching the job demands with the capabilities and interests of the individual. This may mean that you need to spend time finding out what a job entails, what opportunities there are for adapting the tasks if necessary, and how versatile the worker is required to be. For example, some people need structure and routine and find constantly changing demands difficult. Therefore, a job where orders vary from hour to hour and plenty of initiative is required would not be suitable. If a learner is ready to enter the employment market, you can help them build on their past experiences to identify the right job. (Barnardo’s A Chance to Work) 5.4 VISITING EMPLOYERS In the initial stages when work-placements are being set up, employers need to have relevant and honest information about the person concerned. Often they are prepared to make allowances and adjustments to accommodate an individual but they prefer to have open and honest discussions right from the start. Equally, the learner is entitled to honest and open discussions about their expectations of what is being offered. 5.5 CONFIDENTIALITY It is vital to establish with the learner what information they are happy to share with an employer and what is useful for them to know. For example if an employee needs to take medication at specific times and requires time to do so, it is helpful for the supervisor to be aware of this in order to make suitable arrangements. Equally, the person themselves can provide helpful information. Some employers provide a space on an application form for people to add further information, and this is often left blank. Additional information describing individual strengths and qualities can make a difference. If the client is good at listening to and following instructions or is punctual, encourage them to tell the potential employer so that they are aware of these strengths. 5.6 HEALTH AND SAFETY Once you have identified a suitable employer, it will be necessary to carry out a health and safety check to ensure the learner and employer both understand their responsibilities with regard to health and safety. Employers are often concerned about health and safety risks although it is rare that health and safety problems represent an insuperable obstacle. Risk assessment should: Focus on the individual Not make assumptions Consider the facts Consider the essential elements of the job Identify the length of time/frequency of any hazardous situations Get individual specific medical advice when appropriate Consult on how reasonable adjustments can be made Look at any reasonable adjustments to reduce the risk Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 15 of 23 5.7 DRAW UP AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN ALL PARTIES Providers should draw up a written agreement, which is also agreed verbally, between all the parties involved. This could include: Job role and expectations Hours and conditions of employment Dress code or safety garments Health and safety requirements Disciplinary and grievance procedures Induction process Training and development plan The learner’s goals/targets for the placement – what they want to achieve 5.8 SPECIALIST SUPPORT Sometimes learners may need specialist support, (See Appendix 1 – Case Study). Another way to motivate learners is to introduce peer support, where other learners support and coach each other has trained peer supporters. These are able to empathise with learners and provide the support and encouragement needed to achieve success. 5.9 JOB TRAINER/JOB COACH The role of the job trainer or job coach is to work alongside the individual in the workplace until they can perform tasks independently. Sometimes this may involve negotiating and securing special adaptations, such as allowing someone to take more time or not requiring them to undertake all parts of the job. For some individuals, it may require breaking down the job into simple tasks so they can learn at their own pace, or learners with a disability may require specialist software or equipment. The role of the job coach is to balance the needs of the learner with the needs of the employer and to put in place a strategy for sustained support. The job coach can keep in touch with the students, however, the employer could also nominate a mentor to continue to help the students adapt to different tasks or departments during their work-placement. The role of a mentor is far wider and involves supporting a person to feel comfortable while in the workplace. It can also include the social aspects of work as well as ongoing training and personal development. Employers and work experience providers can provide all the necessary job coaching and mentoring using their own staff, although they may need support or specific training in order to do this. Work with them to share information about a learner’s capabilities and learning styles so the best possible support can be provided. 5.10 SUPERVISION, PERFORMANCE MONITORING AND PROGRESSION Ongoing monitoring of a work-placement is essential and you need to consider the most effective methods to build in review sessions at the start of a placement. Maintaining a relationship with the employer may be through setting up ongoing systems of support such as keeping a log book, buddying or mentoring. Regular monitoring means that you can deal with difficulties swiftly so that they don’t get out of proportion. Learners undertaking work experience were supported by a work-placement log book. This includes: Information on the work-placement/contact info, and so on Details of the placement agreement and the adjustments the employer would undertake to accommodate the learner A personal checklist, including what to wear, number of bus, lunch arrangements Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 16 of 23 An induction checklist Records of staff visits An employer’s report with specific headings, for example ‘Observing and listening relationships with colleagues’ A ‘How did I do’ section (Appendix 2) Diary entries The learners valued this document and faithfully completed entries and recognised the learning journey it described. (Adult and community education provider) The employee must be central to the monitoring and review process and agreement as to their preferred approach should be determined in advance. Some learners and employers find a visual record using a digital camera helpful to the review process. Images, together with text and/or an audio commentary (using, for example a microphone connected to the computer, or an mp3 recorder) can enable learners to put together a multimedia record of what they have achieved (Appendix 2). This can be an empowering process and can help learners further develop their confidence. Discussion should be based around the agreement recorded at the beginning of the placement, as this provides a structure upon which to base judgements on what has been achieved and determine future training needs or challenges. 6. EMPLOYER EDUCATION Employers should be encouraged to look at individuals with Language difficulties or disabilities positively – what can they bring to the organisation and how can they work with them to get the best outcome for both parties? What can the individual do and what skills do they have? Some employers may feel anxious and concerned that they don’t have the knowledge or skills to offer work-placements or employment to a learner or find it hard to see any positive benefits. In such cases, it is helpful if you are able to stress the benefits that have been identified by other employers, such as: Reliable and loyal workers Untapped pool of labour Diverse workforce offering whole range of skills, abilities and perceptions Can help create positive attitudes towards diversity Offers opportunities for managers and other staff to develop communication and management skills Can lead in an area of social responsibility Can be seen as a forward thinking organisation Have a workforce that reflects and relates to the community There are employers willing to give individuals an opportunity to work. You can provide support through awareness raising, training and ongoing advice. Provide information and advice to employers to support them in the adoption of good employment policies and practices in the recruitment, retention, training and career development of Foundation students. (www.niace.org.uk/publications) 6.1 ENSURING ACCESSIBILITY Effective communication is a key success factor in any organisation and for some people, additional attention may need to be given to written material. Appendix 3 illustrates examples of how a job description has been rewritten in clear language so that the requirements are clear to the employee. Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 17 of 23 7. BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS WITH VOLUNTARY WORK PROVIDERS The approaches and strategies required to build constructive relationships with organisations willing to take people on voluntary placements are similar to those when working with employers. Many organisations have extensive experience of working with volunteers and can provide useful information about the process. As with employers, it is important to be honest and open about the individual’s additional needs so that you can ensure adjustments are built in at the beginning. 8. CONCLUSION By understanding the issues that students with difficulties face and implementing the strategies outlined above the students will be able to obtain a meaningful experience in the workplace. Allied to this success is the need to educate employers to accept student placements knowing the students are work ready and support is available. Learners, teachers and workplaces also need to ensure that work-placement, provides an opportunity for learners to ‘learn to negotiate how they learn’ in workplaces, since this is critical to effective workplace performance (Beach and Vyas 1998). Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 18 of 23 INTERVIEWEES AND REFERENCES TEACHERS Debbie Heather- Adult literacy Sarah Howe Edwina Lester Daniel Petrov-Disability Jenny Wood- Migrant Ed Anna Kingston-Migrant Ed Jason – Migrant Ed Veronica Shepperd-Migrant Ed STUDENTS Observation Disability class on work-placement Observation Migrant class on work-placement CSWE 111 Interview Edwina X 3 Connect Gini Ennals X 10 CSWE 111 Lyn By x2 CSWE 1 Barnardo’s A Chance to Work http://www.barnardos.org.uk/actionforinclusion/action_for_inclusion_what_we_do.htm Beach, K. and Vyas, S. (1998) Light Pickles and Heavy Mustard: Horizontal development among students negotiating how to learn in a production activity, paper presented at the Fourth Conference of the International Society for Cultural research and Activity Theory, University of Aarhus, Denmark Beyer, S., Kilsby, M. and Leach, S. (2004) Raising Standards: A Contextualised Guide to Support Success in Literacy, Numeracy and ESOL provision Eraut, M. (1999) Learning in the workplace – a framework for analysis. Paper presented at the EARLI Conference on Working and Learning European Conference on Educational Research, EERA, Edinburgh (ECER Conference Session 12.01, 22/09/2000 Fouad, N. A, & Bingham, K. P. (1995). Career counselling with racial and ethnic minorities. In W. B. Walsh & S. H. Osipow (Eds.), Handbook of vocational psychology: Theory, research, and practice (2nd ed., pp. 331-365). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Guile, D. and Fonda, N. (1999) Managing Learning for Added Value London: Institute of Personnel and Development Handley, C. (2005) ‘Offenders learning journey’, ‘T’ magazine: Training Education and employment, July 2005, pp.31–3 Hemmings and Morris, 2004, Employing People with Learning Disabilities: A Handbook for Employers Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 19 of 23 National Audit Office analysis of published research www.dfes.gov.uk/readwriteplus Tusting, K., and Barton, D. (2003) Models of Adult Learning: a literature review. National Research and Development Centre for adult literacy and numeracy Williams, V. (2005) Learning the Skills for Work: The Views of Disabled People (unpublished): www.dfes.gov.uk/readwriteplus/ learningforliving http://www.socialinclusion.gov.au/Resources/Pages/Compendium.aspx http://www.skills.tas.gov.au/skillstas http://www.polytechnic.tas.edu.au/workplacement/ http://www.worksafe.wa.gov.au/smartmove/index.htm http://www.deewr.gov.au/Schooling/Pages/Roundtable.aspx www.niace.org.uk/ projects/Learning from Experience/EBS Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 20 of 23 Appendix 1. Case Study - Learner Support Jerry wants to find employment after a long absence from work following a work accident which left him with severe back problems. All his attempts to find work have failed when he mentions this problem to possible employers. Through work preparation, the Employment Disability Officer has identified a local factory that is looking for new staff. The EDO visited the Production Manager and described Jerry’s situation. He gave him information about Jerry’s past work skills and an up to date appraisal of his health. The production manager felt that there was an appropriate post and that they should give it a try for a couple of weeks. After a week it became clear that Jerry does have many of the skills required and he is keen to do well. He has the right attitude and things look set for his future employment. (NCC – Employment and Disability Service) Appendix 2. Case Study - Low literacy employment review In the case of Bill, who works with the Ealing Community Team, he completes the Learning Curve employee review form. This forms the basis of a meeting with employment support staff and the employer. In the example following, Bill assesses how things are going and what he wants to do next What’s going well? Getting paid Good time keeping. Learning lots of new skills Lots of different tasks. I get on well with people I work with. What do I want to do next? I would like to work in a music shop What training and support will I need? Help with job search application forms. Support when I start Who will help? Ann Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 21 of 23 Appendix 3 Accessibility strategies To answer telephone calls and pass them on to the right people: • We will teach you how to give callers information about our address, telephone numbers and what we do. • We will teach you how to take messages and pass them to the right people. • You will need To sort out our post each day: • We will teach you how to deal with incoming post and distribute them. • We will teach you how to frank the outgoing post. To book rooms for meetings: • We will show you how to book rooms when staff make requests. To shred the confidential documents: • We will show you how to use the shredders. • We will show you how to empty the bag and where to leave them. To help with the photocopying: • We will teach you how to use the machine. • We will teach you how to put papers in order and how to staple them. Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 22 of 23 • We will show you how to print the right number of copies. • We will show you how to return them in the right order To help file letters, memos, notes and other documents: • You will need to be able to read. • We will teach you how to file documents properly. Report on Work Placement Issues for Foundations Students - Tasmanian Polytechnic December 2010 Page 23 of 23