For Immediate Release Contact: Jeanie Clapp 10/20/2011 916/366

California Society of Enrolled Agents
3200 Ramos Circle
Sacramento, CA 95827-2513
Tel: 916-366-6646
Fax: 916-366-6674
For Immediate Release
Contact: Jeanie Clapp
916/366-6646 or [email protected]
Franchise Tax Board Urged to Delay Implementation of Tax Form Changes
Sacramento, CA – In an attempt to increase compliance with tax laws and provide instruction to taxpayers, the
Franchise Tax Board (FTB) announced in September its plans to update the Schedule CA (540) form to collect
more detailed information regarding real estate tax deductions. The proposed new form would require
taxpayers to include parcel numbers, addresses, the total amount paid in real estate taxes and the allowable tax
While the proposal is potentially helpful for taxpayers and tax return preparers, the California Society of Enrolled
Agents (CSEA), a nonprofit organization dedicated to serving Enrolled Agents (EAs), sees significant flaws in
launching this program without thorough examination. EAs are licensed by the federal government to prepare
tax returns, assist with tax planning and represent taxpayers before the Internal Revenue Service.
The question with no clear answer is this: What constitutes allowable real estate tax deductions? According to
the FTB’s form, a taxpayer can deduct the portion that is based on the assessed value of the property but cannot
deduct the amounts paid for local benefits, such as Mello Roos taxes. However, Internal Revenue Service (IRS)
documentation suggests that Mello Roos and other California assessments may be deductible.
“Despite its good intentions, the California FTB is attempting to clarify the property tax deduction, which is
determined by federal law and regulated by the IRS,” says Jean Nelsen, EA, President of CSEA. “Until the IRS
ends many years of confusion and controversy by providing clarity on which items on a property tax bill can be
deducted, it is premature for the state to make that determination.”
Furthermore, property tax bills differ in appearance from county to county and some do not clearly delineate
between the deductible and non-deductible portions. Taxpayers will likely direct questions to county assessor
offices, already working with very limited resources. This could easily stretch staffs beyond their capacities to
respond. Answers also may vary from county to county, which will further cloud the issue.
CSEA strongly supports effective tax administration and efforts to assist taxpayers in complying. However, until
negative consequences of FTB’s proposal are analyzed and mitigated, CSEA believes implementation should be
delayed. Premature implementation of a compliance initiative will do far greater harm than good in achieving its
desired goals.
Visit or call (800) 777-2732 for additional information.
About CSEA
CSEA is a nonprofit 501(c)(6) organization with more than 4,200 active Members. It is a professional association
dedicated to serving EAs in California and abroad, enabling them to grow, prosper, and lead as The Tax
Professionals while serving taxpayers in a dynamic, rapidly changing environment with integrity and trust.