Balancing Your Time Online Topic area Excessive internet use Target age group Lesson duration Middle Secondary Lesson Overview Too much time spent online can negatively impact the physical and mental health of children and teens. This lesson addresses those impacts and delivers ways to bring a healthy balance back into the lives of young people. This lesson includes four short activities. Teachers can select a single activity or multiple activities to make up the recommended 45 minutes, depending on what they feel is appropriate to their class. Lesson outcomes Define ways in which time spent online can become excessive Assess the negative physical and mental impacts of too much time online Take steps toward moderating screen time Create internet usage planning Australian Curriculum This lesson plan module supports a number of learning areas in the Australian Curriculum, including Health and Physical Education, Civics and Citizenship and Technologies. Activity 1 Page Subject focus Debate/ Discussion 4 Motivation, impacts and remedies for excessive technology use Activity 2 Page Subject focus Reading / Research / Speaking Activity 6 Facts about excessive internet and technology use Activity 3 Page Subject focus Personal Audit 9 Auditing time spent online Activity 4 Page Subject focus Visual Activity/ Writing Activity 11 Balancing aspects of life Duration Resources required Worksheet 1 Duration Resources requ ired Worksheet 2, internet access Duration Resources required Worksheet 3, Worksheet 4, Worksheet 5, pen Duration Resources required Pen and paper External links included in lesson Nil enquiries@esafety.gov.au Balancing Your Time Online Technology and Terminology referred to in this lesson Internet, television, smartphones, tablets, laptops, online, trending, clan, instant messaging, webcam chatting, word processing, text messaging, multimedia messaging, apps, ringtones, web address. This work is based on materials that constitute copyright of the Commonwealth of Australia and is licenced under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Share Alike 2.5 Australia Licence. See https://esafety.gov.au/about-the-office/privacy-and-legal for more information. 2 3 Balancing Your Time Online Background Between smartphones, tablets and laptops, children and teens are consuming many hours of screen time a day. Unless a good balance of time off and online can be maintained, this use can begin to feel oppressive and excessive, and interfere with a person’s physical and mental health. Studies have shown a range of both positive and negative effects from increased internet use. It is important that young adults learn to make suitable and conscious choices about their level of internet use. Uncontrollable internet use may be a sign of pathological or ‘addicted’ internet use. It is important that students are aware of this issue, and are able to make sound choices in an environment where technology is all around them. Young people often have less supervision and more control in online environments than they would usually experience. It is important to empower younger internet users with the tools to identify and rectify excessive or compulsive internet use, as well as an understanding of potential consequences on their physical or mental health, which they or their peers may experience. Balancing Your Time Online 4 Activity 1: Debating balanced use Activity 1 Page Subject focus Debate/ Discussion 4 Motivation, impacts and remedies for excessive technology use Duration Resources required Worksheet 1 In this activity, students are asked to discuss and debate the motivations, effects and remedies of excessive internet and technology use. The debates can be more or less formal, depending on the group size and other classroom factors. Instructions Print out Worksheet 1, cut out the debate topics and distribute them to groups in your class. If there are specific issues which affect your students, focus on those topics, or feel free to write your own topics and talking points. The debates are designed to be rapid and multi-directional, with more than two groups debating the topics as they appear on the debating cards (with each team advocating the view expressed on one of the cards), rather than simple affirmative/negative debates. This allows more points to be raised and discussed in a shorter period of time. Teams should discuss their topic and key points before beginning and you may choose to allow teams some time to research facts and figures to support their case where time permits. Teacher’s Tip: Remind students that they may not necessarily agree with the statements, but should try to make the best argument to support their allocated perspective. Teacher’s Tip: Students may have insight and opinions on these points and topics without conducting extensive research. In expressing this personal knowledge, students will naturally direct the discussion and debate towards issues and perspectives which are relevant to them. Discussion Points These points are provided on Worksheet 1 for easy distribution to class groups. What motivates excessive use? Modern social life is predominantly online – it is important to be connected and keep up with trending culture and friends in real time. Complex modern entertainment requires commitment to participation. In order to get the most out of online gaming experiences, players must be available and commit to their online friends, teams and clans. The ability to access factual information at any time and in real time is the key to competitive academic and economic success. Staying current with constant updates from friends and celebrities enriches and informs our behaviour in beneficial ways. Balancing Your Time Online What are the impacts of excessive use? The most important impact of excessive internet use is physical. The most important impact of excessive internet use is psychological. The most important impact of excessive internet use is social. The most important impact of excessive internet use is developmental. What are the remedies for excessive internet use? Adults should moderate the internet and technology use of those under 16. It is up to the individual to decide on the best level and balance of internet and technology use to suit their needs and desires. Technology should be designed in a way that blocks excessive use, and internet service providers should support this with limitations on internet access. There is no problem with significantly increased levels of internet use. 5 Balancing Your Time Online 6 Activity 2: Research task Activity 2 Page Subject focus Reading / Research / Speaking Activity 6 Facts about excessive internet and technology use Duration Resources required Worksheet 2, internet access This activity requires students to use the internet for research in order to answer questions and verify the validity of statements about excessive time spent online. Instructions 1. Divide the class into groups of two or three students, each with access to internet search tools 2. Distribute Worksheet 2 directly to all students 3. Allow ten minutes for students to research and record their answers 4. Working through the list as a class, have a representative from each group report their answers. 5. Discuss the possible answers schedule. Answer key and notes for teachers: Number Question Answers 1 What is the difference between excessive and compulsive internet use? Excessive internet use generally refers to an amount of use that is becoming distressing, unsettling or disruptive to the user, whereas compulsive use refers to an inability to control or reduce use at all. 2 What does the term ‘sleep hygiene’ mean? Term most commonly used to describe good sleep habits, especially ways of preparing the room, bed and body for sleep. 3 How might internet use affect sleep? Excessive screen time and absorbing artificial light at night can affect natural body rhythms and hormones such as melatonin; social activity can continue well into the night with no natural end time; social or gaming activity is very stimulating to the brain and can make it hard to ‘wind down’. Balancing Your Time Online 7 Number Question Answers 4 Why is excessive internet use linked to depression and anxiety? A variety of studies link excessive use of the internet, particularly social networking and gaming, with increased feelings of loneliness, isolation, depression and anxiety. The feelings of shame or loss of control experienced by excessive use of anything are enough to promote anxiety. 5 How is physical wellbeing adversely affected by excessive time spent online? In general, excessive time engaged in any sedentary activity adversely affects physical health. Ways specific to excessive internet use include poor posture, potential for repetitive strain injury (RSI), and sleep interference. 6 Why is it important to maintain a variety of relationships and interests? A variety of relationships and interests help individuals maintain good mental health by providing insulation or support if an issue with one group of friends, job, school, activity, or family member becomes difficult to manage. 7 Define the concepts of ‘balance’ and ‘moderation’ with regard to mental and physical health. In general, a balanced or moderate approach allows for a variety of interests and activities so that no single activity, pursuit, food, or relationship becomes problematic through excessive use. Teacher’s Tip: Explain to students that there is no problem with internet use, only excessive use, and the same applies to activities promoted as healthy pursuits such as exercise – it is a lack of balance that is the problem. 8 Who is at risk of spending too much time online? Everyone, from young children to adults, is at risk of experiencing the adverse effects of excessive internet use. Balancing Your Time Online 8 Number Question Answers 9 How would you know if your internet use was affecting your life in negative ways? Feeling out of control, friends or family expressing concern, losing touch with friends or friendship groups except for those online, feeling your physical or emotional health was compromised by many hours spent online, feelings of guilt or shame surrounding internet usage, increasing loneliness, anxiety or depression – there are many ways in which excessive internet use may affect life in a negative way. 10 What’s one way to address an excessive use of the internet in someone’s life? These typically include talking to someone, asking for help, setting achievable goals for gradually reducing time online, keeping a log of actual time spent online, imposing ‘black out’ periods where online usage is stopped and letting friends know when you are cutting back. Teacher’s Tip: Access www.kidshelpline.com.au. Balancing Your Time Online 9 Activity 3: Lifestyle audit and reflection Activity 3 Page Subject focus Personal Audit 9 Auditing time spent online Duration Resources required Worksheet 3, Worksheet 4, Worksheet 5, pen Instructions Distribute Worksheets 1, 2 and 3 and allow students sufficient time (5 to 10 minutes) to fill them out. Discuss the results with the class. Discussion Questions What did your audit reveal? Was any amount of time unreasonable or longer than expected? Which types of activities and interactions lead you towards internet use? When online, which types of activities appeal to you? How important is technology to you compared to other activities? How much time are you spending on the computer for homework or socialising? How do these figures compare to time spent on these activities offline? Teacher’s Tip: Encourage sharing ideas such as search strategies or reputable sites to use the internet effectively for homework. Overall, do you feel you have the right activity balance? How do you know? Is peer pressure a factor in increased online presence and activities? Does this impede your ability to complete other activities? Teacher’s Tip: Explore the fact that everyone is different in terms of study styles. Some people seem to do better with regular breaks from study for social interaction, while others are better off completing larger amounts of study before taking a break. Teacher’s Tip: Encourage the class to share strategies for managing social and homework demands online. What do your friends and family think about the time you spend online or using smartphones? Does anyone feel they are spending too much time on one internet-based activity? What are the indicators that somebody might be spending too much time on one activity? Teacher’s Tip: Explore as a class how to identify what an ‘acceptable time’ would be. What are the key factors? What times of the day or evening are you engaged in these activities? Explore whether there are issues arising for any students because of the timing of online activities. Balancing Your Time Online Are there examples of friends or family who seem to be spending too much time online? What does that look like? How do you help someone who is spending too much time online? You may wish to brainstorm practical strategies to change students’ approach to online activities if the class feels this is necessary. Teacher’s Tip: On the board, supply the class with details of the school counsellor, as well as the web address for the Kids Helpline (kidshelpline.com.au) explaining that they can receive free and confidential online help if they feel lost, out of control or troubled by excessive use of an online technology. Optional Extension You may wish to ask your students to calculate daily or weekly percentages of time spent on each activity. With these percentages established, students can create pie charts, graphs or other visual representations of their activity allocations. This may help some students understand where their time is spent and compare their results with other students. 10 Balancing Your Time Online 11 Activity 4: Balancing aspects of our lives Activity 4 Page Subject focus Visual Activity/ Writing Activity 11 Balancing aspects of life Duration Resources required Pen and paper Instructions 1. Ask students to draw a series of symbols, characters, or other visual representations of the following aspects of their lives: Self (the physical body and the mental state) Friends Family School Job or physical group such as sporting club, band etc. Online friends / groups (this may include online gaming groups or forum populations where the student does not have friendship or interaction with these people outside the online environment) Students should leave plenty of space near or above each visual element. 2. Now ask students to give each of these aspects of their lives a ‘voice’. Students can draw speech bubbles, thought bubbles or other indicators to express the messages they receive from different areas of their lives concerning their internet use. Teacher’s Tip: It may be useful to draw an exemplar on the board. 3. Reflect on the results with students; Is your ‘Self’ saying it needs more time for sleep, exercise and quiet? Does it feel threatened or pressured by your online identity? Or do you engage in creative use of technologies such as blogging or photography that serves the true ‘Self’ and makes you happy? What about ‘Friends’ or ‘Family’? What are these elements saying about your time spent online? Are your friends requiring too much time from you online? Or is their amount of individual time spent with you offline suffering? What about your family? Would you like more offline interaction with them? Are they concerned about how much time you spend online? Does ‘School’ think you are neglecting it or is it congratulating you on using online technologies to find useful information? 4. Ask students to consider and depict how we might respond to those voices. Can we respond to those messages in ways which result in a different balance of internet use? How much influence should we allow each of those voices to have in our decision making about time spent online? Teacher’s Tip: Remind students that balance is key to this exercise, as each of these spheres of our lives are important for us to be healthy and happy. WORKSHEET 1: DEBATING BALANCED USE What motivates excessive use? Modern social life is predominantly online – it is important to be connected and keep up with trending culture and friends in real time. Complex modern entertainment requires commitment to participation. In order to get the most out of online gaming experiences, players must be available and commit to their online friends, teams and clans. The ability to access factual information at any time and in real time is the key to competitive academic and economic success. Staying current with constant updates from friends and celebrities enriches and informs our behaviour in beneficial ways. What are the impacts of excessive use? The most important impact of excessive internet use is physical. The most important impact of excessive internet use is psychological. The most important impact of excessive internet use is social. The most important impact of excessive internet use is developmental. What are the remedies for excessive internet use? Adults should moderate the internet and technology use of those under 16 years. It is up to the individual to decide on the best level and balance of internet and technology use to suit their needs and desires. Technology should be designed in a way that blocks excessive use, and internet service providers should support this with limitations on internet access. There is no problem with significantly increased levels of internet use. WORKSHEET 2: RESEARCH ACTIVITY Using the internet for research, find an article or academic study, which answers the question in the left-hand column. Write a sentence or two for your answer, along with the web address of your source for verification. Number Question 1 What is the difference between excessive and compulsive internet use? 2 What does the term ‘sleep hygiene’ mean? 3 How might internet use affect sleep? 4 Why is excessive internet use linked to depression and anxiety? 5 How is physical wellbeing adversely affected by excessive time spent online? 6 Why is it important to maintain a variety of relationships and interests? 7 Define the concepts of ‘balance’ and ‘moderation’ with regard to mental and physical health. 8 Who is at risk of spending too much time online? 9 How would you know if your internet use was affecting your life in negative ways? 10 What’s one way to address an excessive use of the internet in someone’s life? Answer and web address WORKSHEET 3: LIFESTYLE AUDIT Name: ____________________________________________________ Perform an audit on your daily activities by filling in the table below. Extra spaces have been provided for you to add any other activities you do each day. Activity Eating Sleeping Socialising Working Being active Relaxing Studying Total hours Details of activity Hours per day WORKSHEET 4: TECHNOLOGY AUDIT Name: ____________________________________________________ Estimate how much time you spend on the following activities each week. There are some blank boxes for you to add any activities not listed. Activity Searching online – for fun Searching online – for homework Sending emails Instant messaging Webcam chatting Social Networking Watching and sharing video content Word processing and tasks for homework Playing games Sending texts Sending pics Making phone calls Downloading apps and ringtones Listening to music Taking and editing photos or video Total Hours Time spent on computer Time spent on mobile device WORKSHEET 5: SELF REFLECTION Name: ____________________________________________________ 1. How much time am I spending on these activities for entertainment? 2. How much time am I spending on the computer for homework? 3. Do I sometimes mix homework and entertainment? Does this have an impact on homework? 4. Am I doing other offline activities to balance how much time I am spending online? 5. Am I spending too much time on one internet-based activity? 6. What times of the day or evening am I engaged in these activities? Do I have time to rest, eat and do offline activities? 7. Do I need to change how I allocate my time to online and offline activities? Why?