Accredited Standards Committee* NCITS, National Committee for Information Technology Standards Doc. No.: D99129r0 Date: August 31, 1999 Project: Ref. Doc.: Reply to: Gene Milligan To: Membership of T13 From: Dan Colegrove, Secretary T13 and Gene Milligan, Chair T13 Subject: Minutes of T13 Working Group Meeting August 24-27, 1999 Start 9:00am ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ Agenda 1. Opening Remarks .............................................................................................................................................................. 2 2. Approval of Agenda .......................................................................................................................................................... 3 3. Attendance and Membership ............................................................................................................................................. 3 3.1 Members in jeopardy.................................................................................................................................................. 3 3.2 Attendance ................................................................................................................................................................. 3 4. Document Distribution ...................................................................................................................................................... 3 5. Approval of the prior plenary minutes (D99115r0) ........................................................................................................... 4 6. Review of Action Items ..................................................................................................................................................... 4 7. ATA/ATAPI-5 Project 1321D .......................................................................................................................................... 4 7.1 Ultra ATA Implementation Guide (D98109r1) .......................................................................................................... 4 7.2 Review of ATA/ATAPI-5 Draft ................................................................................................................................. 4 7.3 Schedule Review ........................................................................................................................................................ 4 8. EDD v3.0 Project 1386-D ................................................................................................................................................. 4 9. Address Offset Feature Technical Report Project 1407-DT.............................................................................................. 4 10. 11. Method for Booting Reserved Area Boot Code Project 1367-D ................................................................................ 4 Old Business .............................................................................................................................................................. 4 T13 Reflector, ftp, and Web Site Setup [Hanan] ................................................................................................ 4 Items from Open Issues List ................................................................................................................................ 4 11.2.1 Existing operating systems do not respect restriction 1) in 8.21.4, Packet command byte count limit may not be zero. Should ATA/ATAPI-5 be changed to remove this restriction? ....................................................... 4 11.3 Recommendation to withdraw ATA with the Five Year Review ........................................................................ 5 11.4 32-Bit ATA (D98115r0) [Goodfellow] ............................................................................................................... 5 11.5 Really Big LBA (D98142r2) [Rooke][Landis] ................................................................................................... 5 11.6 AV Error Recovery Control (D99123r0) ............................................................................................................ 5 11.7 Identify Column Alignment ATA/ATAPI-4 Errata Status .................................................................................. 5 11.8 Expansion of the SMART Error Log (D99121R0) ............................................................................................. 5 11.9 Multiword DMA Timing [Landis] ...................................................................................................................... 5 11.1 11.2 *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. 1 NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 11.10 11.11 11.12 11.13 12. T13/D99-115R0 Implementer’s Guide ........................................................................................................................................... 5 8bit Data Transfer for CFA ................................................................................................................................. 5 CFA Code Reservation ....................................................................................................................................... 5 Optional Column ................................................................................................................................................. 5 New Business ............................................................................................................................................................. 5 12.1 BC=0 Handling (D99127r0) [Jim Hatfield] ........................................................................................................ 6 12.2 REL Bit ............................................................................................................................................................... 6 12.3 PIO Mode Reporting ........................................................................................................................................... 6 12.4 DST End on Error ............................................................................................................................................... 6 12.5 Partition Tables ................................................................................................................................................... 6 12.6 Cable Detect ........................................................................................................................................................ 6 12.7 Mount Fuji Action Items [Katata][ILI etc.] ......................................................................................................... 6 12.8 CS (0-1) and DA (0-2) ........................................................................................................................................ 6 12.9 Select time and/or mixed PIO modes .................................................................................................................. 6 12.10 UDMA Termination ............................................................................................................................................ 7 12.11 AV (D99128r0) [Bulik] ...................................................................................................................................... 7 12.12 ATA/ATAPI-6 Project ........................................................................................................................................ 7 13. 13.1 13.2 13.3 Liaison Reports .......................................................................................................................................................... 7 T10 ...................................................................................................................................................................... 7 SFF ...................................................................................................................................................................... 7 IDEMA ............................................................................................................................................................... 7 14. Call for Patents ........................................................................................................................................................... 7 15. Open Issues List Summary ......................................................................................................................................... 7 16. Review of Action Items .............................................................................................................................................. 7 17. 17.1 17.2 18. Meeting Schedule ....................................................................................................................................................... 7 Authorization of Working Groups ...................................................................................................................... 7 Long term meeting schedule ............................................................................................................................... 8 Adjournment .............................................................................................................................................................. 8 ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ Results of Meeting 1. Opening Remarks Gene Milligan, the T13 Chairman, called the working group meeting to order at 9:00 a.m., Tuesday, August 24, 1999. He thanked Pete McLean of Maxtor for hosting the meeting. The Chairman briefly reviewed the meeting rules. Discussion is open to all attendees. Principal Membership requires attendance at one meeting and a letter to the Chairman on organizational letter head requesting membership, stating expertise and material interest in the scope of the technical committee. Votes are only allowed to Principal Membership organizations. Membership also requires payment of NCITS administration fees. Maintenance of Principal Membership requires attendance at two out of three successive plenary meetings Current NCITS memberships fees for Observer, Principle, or additional Alternate are $300 (the first alternate is free). A T13 subscription is available to Principal, Alternate, or Observer Members at a fee of $300. *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 2 T13/D99-115R0 Persons with questions or requests regarding membership fees and/or subscriptions should contact Judy Gales at 202-6265741, or fax her at 202-638-4922, or by Email to jgales@itic.nw.dc.us. (Judy is not actually still at NCITS but others will answer her Email and voicemail.) The Chairman noted that a set of Policies and Procedures for NCITS were available at the www.ncits.org site under the standing documents category as SD-2. The committee is operating under these revised policies and procedures augmented by the T13 procedures at the T13 web site www.t13.org. 2. Approval of Agenda The agenda was unanimously approved as reflected in these minutes. 3. Attendance and Membership 3.1 Members in jeopardy Adaptec lost their membership due to failure to attend two out of three succesive meetings and by not attending this meeting after the jeopardy notice. The Chair has thanked them for their contributions in the past. 3.2 Attendance Bob Amy Hale Tom Matt Hitoshi Bob Dan Michael Tim Pete Tony Curtis Robert Greg Mark Wen Ken Jon Gene Marc Ron Masataka Jim Steve David Tasuku Darrin Jonathan Salem Barton Landis Colligan Rooke Ogawa Raicer Colegrove Eschmann Thompson McLean Goodfellow Stevens Raymond Elkins Evans Lin Bovatsek Haines Milligan Noblitt Roberts Ogawa Hatfield Bassett Dickson Kasebayashi Bulik Hanmann CMD Technology Circuit Assembly Corp. Consultant Dell Computer Fujitsu Comp Prod of America Hitachi Ltd. IBM IBM Corp. Intel LSI Maxtor Corp. PDC Phoenix Technologies PowerQuest QLogic Corp. Quantum Corp. STMicroelectronics, Inc. Samsung Seagate Technology Seagate Technology Seagate Technology Sierra-Pac Technology Sony Electronics Inc. Tecmar Technologies Texas Instruments Texas Instruments Toshiba America Electr Comp Western Digital Western Digital Corp. P P P P P O G P G P P P P G P P A A G P A P O G G G P P G 4. Document Distribution The following documents were distributed: T13/DANG18R1-Agenda T13/1321DR1b - ATA/ATAPI-5 Working Draft T13/1386Dr1 - BIOS Enhanced Disk Drive Specification T13/D99123r1 - Proposal for Streaming AV Commands T13/D98109r4 - Ultra ATA Implementation Guide *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 3 T13/D99-115R0 T13/D99121r1 - Expansion of SMART Error Log T13/D1367r0 - Protected Are Run Time Interface Extension Services T13/D99128r0 - Proposal for Audio/Visual Feature Set T13/D99126r0 - CFA Code Reservation T13/D99127r0 Redefine Behavior for ATAPI Devices When BC=0 T13/D98142r3 Really Big LBA In addition diskettes were passed around with the above documents. 5. Approval of the prior plenary minutes (D99115r0) Approved without objection. 6. Review of Action Items 81) Hale Landis to put together list of all things affected by saying that device 0 shall never respond for device 1. (carry over) 7. ATA/ATAPI-5 Project 1321D 7.1 Ultra ATA Implementation Guide (D98109r1) The document was reviewed and will be revised to reflect the suggested changes. 7.2 Review of ATA/ATAPI-5 Draft All changes indicated by change bars were reviewed, accepted, and/or corrected. Security Erase Unit from Unlocked /not Frozen. The Security State Diagram will be updated to show a transition from SEC5:Unlocked/not Frozen to SEC1: Security disabled/not Frozen. 7.3 Schedule Review The schedule for ATA/ATAPI-5 was revised to: Stabilized draft 8/99 Letter ballot 10/99 Forward 11/99 (assuming no letter ballot comments) Public Review 12/99 8. EDD v3.0 Project 1386-D The revision 1 document was reviewed. Curtis Stevens will turn a revision showing the agreed changes with change bars. 9. Address Offset Feature Technical Report Project 1407-DT Revision 0 of the document was distributed for review. 10. Method for Booting Reserved Area Boot Code Project 1367-D The document was reviewed. Curtis Stevens will turn a revision with the suggested changes marked with change bars. 11. Old Business 11.1 T13 Reflector, ftp, and Web Site Setup [Hanan] The web site is now read only with anonymous login. To upload to the web site, upload to the incoming directory login with Username:t13 Password: $tandard$. 11.2 Items from Open Issues List 11.2.1 Existing operating systems do not respect restriction 1) in 8.21.4, Packet command byte count limit may not be zero. Should ATA/ATAPI-5 be changed to remove this restriction? Closed by item 12.1. *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 4 T13/D99-115R0 11.3 Recommendation to withdraw ATA with the Five Year Review In Process. 11.4 32-Bit ATA (D98115r0) [Goodfellow] Carried Over 11.5 Really Big LBA (D98142r2) [Rooke][Landis] The paragraph marked General Discussion will be removed. Queuing with mixed 28 bit addresses and 64 bit addresses will be prohibited. Various scenarios of register writes and mode switches were discussed. 11.6 AV Error Recovery Control (D99123r0) The AV proposals (d99128r0 and D99123r1) were discussed at length. Some of the issues discussed were Splitting off acoustic controls from AV Generic AV drives instead of customer specific firmware Larger than 256 sector count transfers Interface complexity Lack of theoretical basis for AV architecture. The committee requested that an interim working group be held on the video topic. Ron Roberts requested that the group base the definition on the Mtfuji 4 VRSWG proposal. But he indicated the proposal was currently restricted by a NDA. The Chair requested that Ron provide a summary of the VRSWG proposal at the next T13 meeting if the NDA has been lifted. The Chair also stated that he was under the impression that the VRSWG proposal was not restricted by NDA. 11.7 Identify Column Alignment ATA/ATAPI-4 Errata Status This is a PDF column printing error. The correction is out for NCITS letter ballot. 11.8 Expansion of the SMART Error Log (D99121R0) This is the proposed definition of Log Address 02h. Mark Evans moved and Hale Landis seconded that the proposal be included in the ATA/ATAPI-6 document. Passed without objection. 11.9 Multiword DMA Timing [Landis] Hale summarized the timing items that he thinks are no longer readily available in bus specifications and that he is recommending be added to the ATA/ATAPI standard. Pete McLean will prepare timing diagrams for the October meeting. 11.10 Implementer’s Guide A guide to why we did what we did in the specification. Dan Colegrove volunteered to help with this. 11.11 8bit Data Transfer for CFA The 8 bit data ordering will be added back in to ATA/ATAPI-5. 8 Bit related Set Features will be changed from retired to obsolete in ATA/ATAPI-5. Both of these recommendations were approved without objection since they are needed for CFA and other hand held applications. 11.12 CFA Code Reservation D99126r0 documents reserved codes for future CFA commands, Set Features functions and Identify drive data. Hale Landis moved and Dan Colegrove seconded that the changes proposed in D99126r0 be incorporated in ATA/ATAPI5. Passed Unanimously. 11.13 Optional Column Hale Landis will prepare a document designating the optional and mandatory identify device fields. 12. New Business *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 5 T13/D99-115R0 12.1 BC=0 Handling (D99127r0) [Jim Hatfield] There is a conflict between the way Byte Count is presently specified for ATAPI devices with the way a major operating system uses ATAPI tape devices. This proposal requests a change to the Identify Packet command to add a mode indicator so hosts can determine which way the device is configured. The configuration is controlled by a SCSI command (presently vendor unique) transported by the Packet command. Hale Landis moved and Tony Goodfellow seconded that D99127r0 be incorporated into ATA/ATAPI-5. The editor will select the appropriate Identify and Set Features codes. Passed Unanimously. 12.2 REL Bit Pete McLean will change ATA/ATAPI-5 to correct the state of REL after a data transfer in Read DMA and Write DMA and change state diagram pointers for Read and Write DMA. Approved without objection. 12.3 PIO Mode Reporting See 12.9. 12.4 DST End on Error The self-test description was changed so that Self-Test may end when the test finds a test element that does not pass the test criteria. Approved without objection. 12.5 Partition Tables The group agreed to continue to discuss partition tables at the meetings and on the reflector. Robert Raymond agreed to produce a paper for discussion. 12.6 Cable Detect Curtis Stevens would like to standardize on drive side detection. Several people commented that host side detection was superior due detection of ground having more margin than a RC voltage curve. Pete McLean moved that we make it clear in section 6.7 of ATA/ATAPI-5 that host refers to the host determining cable type by detecting the CBLID line grounding. A cross-reference to Annex D will also be added. Dan Colegrove seconded the motion. The motion passed 14: 0:0. Curtis Stevens Moved that annex D be made Normative. Tony Goodfellow seconded. The motion passed 11:2:3. Curtis Stevens moved to strike the last sentence of the first paragraph of Annex D. Failed due to lack of second. Curtis Stevens moved and Matt Rooke seconded that the last sentence of the first paragraph be modified to say that this method not be used exclusively for cable detection. The motion failed 2:12:2. 12.7 Mount Fuji Action Items [Katata][ILI etc.] The Chair reminded the committee of the Email from Katata-san with discussion of issues concerning various bits used as flags by ATAPI. No one at this meeting was prepared to address the issues. The Chair reported that Katata-san was attempting to attend the October meeting of T13, which require a shorter plane ride and hopefully less expense. 12.8 CS (0-1) and DA (0-2) See 12.9 12.9 Select time and/or mixed PIO modes The timing restrictions for mixed speed PIO modes on the same cable will be documented in ATA/ATAPI-5. *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 6 T13/D99-115R0 12.10 UDMA Termination Hale Landis posed the question: Is there a problem if both the host and the device initiate burst termination at the same time? The committee concluded that there is no problem with the host and device terminating a burst at the same time. 12.11 AV (D99128r0) [Bulik] See item 11.6 12.12 ATA/ATAPI-6 Project The group discussed items that should be a part of ATA/ATAPI-6. Gene Milligan will prepare a project proposal for the next plenary meeting. 13. Liaison Reports 13.1 T10 Published on the reflector. 13.2 SFF No business pending that affects T13. 13.3 IDEMA IDEMA is developing a standard on power efficiency in response to Japanese power consumption restrictions on disk drives. A rating based upon Joules per IOPS is being evaluated. The next meeting will be at the IDEMA office in the San Clara on November 5 at 9:30am. For more information contact Kristen Montan <kmontan@idema.org>. 14. Call for Patents The Chair explained the patent policy. A document is available from ANSI, "Procedures for the Development and Coordination of American National Standards", at no charge. This document is also on the WWW at ftp//www.ncits.org/help/ansi_sdo.html. Section 1.2.11 contains the ANSI patent policy. Amy Marasco manages patent issues for ANSI and can be contacted at amarasco@ansi.org or 212-642-4954. The Chair then called for patents and/or patent applications that may be necessary to comply with the requirements in T13 standards, draft standards, technical reports, or draft technical reports. Mark Evans reported that Quantum is working on a response to the call for patents. Mark reminded folks that the contact person is Steve Wilkins 408-894-5235 for information regarding licensing. IBM will write a letter indicating that they will offer licensing for the patent conformant to the ANSI patent policy. . Tony Goodfellow from GSI stated that GSI has a patent application on the construction of the 80-conductor cable. GSI will write a letter indicating that they will offer licensing for the patent conformant to the ANSI patent policy. Circuit Assembly Corporation and Maxtor have already provided letters covering their patents. 15. Open Issues List Summary The list is currently empty. 16. Review of Action Items 81) Hale Landis to put together list of all things affected by saying that device 0 shall never respond for device 1. 94) Gene Milligan to prepare a project proposal for ATA/ATAPI-6. 17. Meeting Schedule 17.1 Authorization of Working Groups *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 7 T13/D99-115R0 An AV issues working group was scheduled for October 1, 1999 in Las Vegas, Nevada. Gene Milligan agreed to host the meeting and will send out information when the meeting arrangements have been completed. 17.2 Long term meeting schedule 1999 Dates October 19-22, 1999* November 30-December 3, 1999* Location Wailea, Maui, HI Irvine, CA Host Quantum Western Digital Contact Mark Evans Darrin Bulik 2000 Dates February 21-25, 2000* April 24-28, 2000* June 19-23, 2000* August 21-25, 2000* October 16-20, 2000* November 11-15, 2000* Location Placerville, CA Longmont, CO Irvine, CA Boulder, CO San Jose, CA Irvine, CA Host Sierra Pac Seagate Phoenix Maxtor Phoenix Western Digital Contact Ron Roberts Marc Noblitt Curtis Stevens Pete McLean Curtis Stevens Tom Hanan 2001 Dates Location Host February 20-23, 2001* Austin, TX Dell April 24-27, 2001* Longmont, CO Seagate June 19-22, 2001* tbd August 21-24, 2001* Boulder, CO Maxtor October 23-26, 2001* tbd December 11-14, 2001* tbd * indicates plenary meeting. + indicates this meeting is tentative and may be canceled. Contact Tom Colligan Marc Noblitt Pete McLean As noted above the next plenary meeting of T13 is 19-22 October hosted by Quantum at the Wailea Outrigger Hotel in Wailea, Maui, Hawaii. 18. Adjournment The meeting adjourned upon completion of all the agenda items. *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 8 T13/D99-115R0 T13 Attendance Database - Enclosure (1) John Lawrence Randy Bob Sam Amy Ben Ken Hale Paul Matt Liza John J. R. Anthony Hitoshi Quang Dan Tim Darrell Renee Tim LeRoy Pete Lam Dan Tony Richard Terence Han Curtis Skip Greg Mark James Wen Ken Litko Kenichi Gene Marc Ron George Yogi Paresh Tasuku Tokuyuki Darrin Tom Masa Dan Buck Lamers Sharp Salem Wong Barton Chang Bush Landis Raikunen Rooke Hunt Moore Sims Yang Ogawa Vuong Colegrove Bradshaw Redford Depew Thompson Leach McLean Dang Salmonsen Goodfellow Harcourt Nelson Zou Stevens Jones Elkins Evans McGrath Lin Bovatsek Chan Kojima Milligan Noblitt Roberts Tun Schaffner Sheth Kasebayashi Totani Bulik Hanan Morizumi Baca ORGANIZATIONAL ATTENDANCE AT LAST THREE MEETINGS ----+ INDIVIDUAL ATTENDANCE ----+ | | | v v AMP G 0 0 Adaptec, Inc. O 13 0 Apple P 0 3 CMD Technology P 4 3 CMD Technology A 1 3 Circuit Assembly Corp. P 3 3 Cirrus Logic Inc. P 9 2 Compaq Computer Corp. O 0 0 Consultant P 18 3 Digital O 9 0 Fujitsu Comp Prod of America P 6 3 Global Engineering Docuement XO 0 0 Hewlett Packard Co. O 0 0 Hewlett Packard Co. O 4 0 Hitachi America Ltd. P 9 3 Hitachi Ltd. O 3 3 Hitachi Storage Products A 0 3 IBM Corp. P 18 3 Iomega Corp. A 4 2 Iomega Corp. P 1 2 LSI A 3 3 LSI P 3 3 Maxtor Corp. A 1 3 Maxtor Corp. P 17 3 Oak Technology O 0 0 Oak Technology O 0 0 PDC P 14 3 PDC A1 3 3 Panasonic Technologies Inc. O 0 0 Panasonic Technologies Inc. O 0 0 Phoenix Technologies P 9 3 QLogic A 0 3 QLogic Corp. P 15 3 Quantum Corp. P 16 3 Quantum Corp. A1 1 3 STMicroelectronics, Inc. A 1 2 Samsung A 1 3 Samsung Electronics P 1 3 Sanyo Electric Co Ltd O 4 0 Seagate Technology P 17 3 Seagate Technology A 16 3 Sierra-Pac Technology P 17 1 Standard Microsystems Corp. O 1 2 Texas Instruments A 6 2 Texas Instruments P 4 2 Toshiba America Electr Comp P 5 3 Toshiba America Electr Comp A 8 3 Western Digital P 5 3 Western Digital Corp. A 15 3 Yamaha O 1 0 Yamaha Systems Tech. Inc. O 0 0 *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 9 T13/D99-115R0 T13 Document Database - Enclosure (2) Doc# D0791R4c D0948R4c D1153R1 8 D1226R7 D1248R5 D1321R0 b D1321R0c D1321R1 D1321R1 a D1321R1 b D1321R1c Description ATA-1 revision 4c ATA-2 revision 4c ATA/ATAPI-4 revision 18 BIOS Enhanced Disk Drive Specification rev 7 1394 to AT Attachment - Tailgate revision 5 ATA/ATAPI-5 revision 0b ATA/ATAPI-5 revision 0c ATA/ATAPI-5 revision 1 ATA/ATAPI-5 revision 1a ATA/ATAPI-5 revision 1b ATA/ATAPI-5 revision 1c Protected Area Run Time Interface rev 0 EDD 3.0 rev 0 EDD 3.0 rev 1 Address Offset Reserved Area Boot rev 0 ATA-3 revision 7b Implementation guide - Ultra DMA Implementation guide - Ultra DMA EDD 3.0 project proposal EDD 3.0 project proposal New timing for Ultra DMA New timing for Ultra DMA New timing for Ultra DMA Protected area locking proposal Protected area locking proposal Protected area locking proposal Really big LBA proposal Really big LBA proposal Really big LBA proposal Proposal for CFA SET FEATURES codes Proposal for CFA SET FEATURES codes Project proposal for protected area extension Project proposal for protected area extension Project proposal for protected area extension 1996-1998 Document Directory Flush Cache mandatory proposal 64-bit LBA alternatives Patent letter from Maxtor Seagate SMART proposal Seagate SMART proposal Seagate SMART proposal WD self-test log modification Minutes of 2/23-26/99 plenary meeting subdir /project /project /project /project /project /project /project /project /project /project /project /project /project /project Pgs Date Mailing Submitto r 66 5/12/94 ---lamers 111 3/18/96 DM9602 finch 342 8/19/98 DM9804 mclean 35 10/23/97 DM9704 stevens 71 10/28/97 DM9704 hanmann 365 12/18/98 DM9806 mclean 368 3/5/99 DM9901 mclean 377 5/11/99 DM9902 mclean 377 5/26/99 ---mclean 378 7/7/99 DM9903 mclean 378 8/31/99 mclean 27 8/23/99 stevens 19 6/24/99 DM9903 stevens 28 8/23/99 stevens 6 8/20/99 colegrove 194 1/27/97 DM9701 mclean 44 6/22/99 DM9903 evans 52 8/24/99 evans 3 2/23/99 ---stevens 3 2/25/99 DM9901 stevens 16 2/23/99 DM9901 evans 17 4/26/99 ---evans 18 4/29/99 DM9902 evans 14 6/22/99 ---goodfello w 19 6/23/99 ---goodfello w 20 7/6/99 DM9903 goodfello 3 2/22/99 DM9901 w landis 3 4/27/99 DM9902 landis 4 8/25/99 landis 2 2/19/99 DM9901 colegrove 2 4/27/99 DM9902 colegrove 3 2/23/99 ---stevens 3 2/25/99 DM9901 stevens 3 4/19/99 DM9902 stevens 6 1/1/99 DM9901 mclean 3 2/23/99 DM9901 colligan 2 1/21/99 DM9901 rooke 1 1/26/99 DM9901 mclean 6 2/8/99 DM9901 haines 4 3/25/99 ---haines 4 4/27/99 DM9902 haines 1 2/11/99 DM9901 hanmann 11 3/15/99 DM9901 colegrove D1367R0 D1386R0 D1386R1 D1407R0 D2008R7 /project b D98109R /technical 3 D98109R /technical 4 D98119R /project 1 D98119R /project 2 D98133R /technical 2 D98133R /technical 3 D98133R /technical 4 D98139R /technical 1 D98139R /technical 2 D98139R /technical 3 D98142R /technical 1 D98142R /technical 2 D98142R /technical 3 D98144R /technical 1 D98144R /technical 2 D98147R /project 1 D98147R /project 2 D98147R /project 3 D99100R /meetings 0 D99101R /technical 0 D99102R /technical 0 D99103R /project 0 D99104R /technical 0 D99104R /technical 1 D99104R /technical 2 D99105R /technical 0 D99106R /meetings 0 *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 10 D99107R 0 D99108R 0 D99109R 0 D99110R 0 D99111R 0 D99111R 1 D99112R 0 D99112R 1 D99113R 0 D99114R 0 D99115R 0 D99116R 0 D99117R 0 D99118R 0 D99119R 0 D99120R 0 D99121R 0 D99121R 1 D99122R 0 D99123R 0 D99123R 1 D99124R 0 D99125R 0 D99126R 0 D99127R 0 D99128R 0 D99129R 0 D99130R 0 D99131R 0 D99132R 0 DM9901R 0 DM9902R 0 DM9903R 0 More words to describe checksum Optional pointer for self-test log Device 0 responses Patent letter from Quantum Project proposal for address offset feature proposal TR Project for address offset feature TR Multiword DMA description proposal Multiword DMA description proposal Improved DEVICE RESET command ATA-6 expanded addressing Minutes of 4/27-30/99 plenary meeting No document Patent letter from Circuit Assembly Sector globs Minutes of 5/19-20/99 working group meeting IDENTIFY DEVICE fields Mandatory Multisector error log proposal Multisector error log proposal Security state diagram Streaming command extensions Streaming command extensions Minutes of 6/22-25/99 plenary meeting Restoration of 8-bit transfers CFA code reservations PACKET byte count = 0 Proposal for Audio Visual feature set Minutes of 8/24-27/99 plenary meeting WD Audio visual presentation Automatic acoustic management Multiword DMA timing diagrams Mailing #1 1999 Mailing #2 1999 Mailing #3 1999 /technical /technical /project /project /technical /technical /technical /technical /meetings /project /meetings /technical /technical /technical /technical /technical /meetings /technical /technical /technical /meetings /technical /technical /mailing /mailing /mailing 1 1 0 0 3 3 1 1 1 8 13 0 1 0 5 0 2 2 1 9 13 12 0 1 2 16 11 4 0 5 70 63 102 T13/D99-115R0 2/23/99 DM9901 evans 2/23/99 DM9901 evans landis evans 2/23/99 DM9901 colegrove 4/5/99 DM9902 colegrove 3/17/99 ---mclean 4/19/99 DM9902 mclean 6/23/99 landis 4/20/99 DM9902 rooke 5/5/99 DM9902 colegrove 4/26/99 5/26/99 DM9903 6/10/99 8/19/99 6/22/99 6/16/99 8/23/99 7/8/99 DM9903 DM9903 DM9903 DM9903 8/24/99 7/9/99 8/24/99 8/31/99 8/25/99 8/31/99 3/12/99 4/24/99 7/9/99 ---------- barton landis colegrove landis rooke rooke mclean noblitt noblitt colegrove landis landis hatfield bulik colegrove hanmann haines mclean milligan milligan milligan *Operating under the procedures of The American National Standards Institute. NCITS Secretariat: Information Technology Industries Council (ITI) 1250 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 200, Washington, DC 20005-3922; Fax: (202) 638-4922 Tel: (202) 737-8888 11