Confidential
Not for public distribution
HBRI IX
Tuesday, 20 April 2010
Microsoft Indonesia, BEJ Building
Jakarta
Kemal Soeriawidjaja, Company-Community Partnership for Health in Indonesia/CCPHI’s
representative introduced himself and welcomed all participants. Mr. Soeriawidjaja thanked
Microsoft Indonesia for being the host of HBRI XI. This is the first time the HBRI meeting held in the
office of its member. Mr. Soeriawidjaja thanked the Ford Foundation for being a donor of CCPHI’s
project. He also extended greetings from Dr. Alene Gelbard, project director and Krista Hendry,
senior technical advisor. They could not attend the meeting due to their activities in the U.S.
Riris Sundrijo, executive director of Pacivis UI, a partner of CCPHI in organizing the HBRI, is
unfortunately unable to attend the meeting. However Ms. Sundrijo sends her apologies and greeting
to the participants.
Mr. Soeriawidjaja welcomed eight new organizations to CCPHI: the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg
(JHUCCP), Mitra Inti Foundation, Peduli Perempuan, Bank Mutiara, Indonesian Planned Parenthood
Association, Tigaraksa Satria, Exxon Mobil, and Indofood Sukses Makmur. Therefore, current
members total 78 organizations, including the government, NGOs, and associations.
Mr. Drajat Panjawi, legal and foreign affairs director of Microsoft Indonesia, welcomed all
participants to Microsoft Indonesia and expressed his pleasure to have meeting for the first time
conducted in one of members’ office.
After the introduction, next program is Partnership Presentation between PT. Pembangunan Jaya by
Mr. Kiki Nugroho and Komseni by Ms. Debra Yatim.
PT. PEMBANGUNAN JAYA ANCOL TBK. AND KOMSENI:
Society can be built because they have potential. The potential is not in the form of a skill, but
rubbish. Ancol in 2003 partner with KOMSENI, working together in Pademangan Sub District in
managing sanitation/environments, also waste recycling. Their campaign called as Ancol Loves
Environment (abbreviation in bahasa is ASL or Ancol Sayang Lingkungan). They have formed an
active team of Environmental Management Cadre.
Q and A
1
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.
Confidential
Not for public distribution
Question:
If possible, Ancol should expand the program to other areas. This problem is also DKI’s problem
[*DKI is an abbreviation of Daerah Khusus Ibukota, meaning: “the special area of the
capital/Jakarta]. We have a waste cooperative in my area, but its program has not started yet.
Another question is: Where will the recycled products go? This is important to motivate people in
joining the program.
Kiki Nugroho (Ancol):
Ancol is still prioritizing the surrounding neighborhood; ASL is still in Kelurahan Ancol. It is not
formed yet in Pademangan Area. Hopefully with Komseni it can be formed. We also have the Teens
Go Green project with the Department. This program is to educate students to be involved as an
agent of change for their community.
Mustofa (community representatives):
There is a commitment that Ancol will give us continuous support. The concept is from the
community, and not about the proposal’s program but it is about the activity. The activity needs to
directly touch the community. Ancol builds, while the community maintains and manages.
Question:
How is the partnership between Komseni and Ancol? Perhaps Ms. Debra Yatim could explain this?
Answer:
Debra Yatim (Komseni): Ancol provides support for the programs. In producing compost, there is
Kembang Pala, an NGO which has the ability to help and teach about medicinal plants and
composting. Ancol hired two teachers to live in the Ancol community to teach how to process
household waste. If there is training, Ancol will provide funds and facilitate the media coverage.
Media coverage in this program makes the community become more interested and it builds their
self confidence. The first is a proposal; the second is ideas; and the last is financial help from Ancol.
Ancol’s willingness to accept the product of the community is the most valuable aspect in this
partnership.
Question:
How did it actually start? Between Ancol and Komseni, who approached who?
Answer:
Debra Yatim: Komseni is the one who submited a proposal to Ancol. We know Ms. Harini Bambang,
she got an award from UNESCO. Coincidentally, UNESCO has designed the “Care for the sea and put
order in the land” book (*in Indonesian: Tata laut dan tertib darat”). We start from there. The
parallel is within the society, if chief of RT and RW are motivated. We submitted the proposal to
Ancol because Ancol defines itself as a wealthy corporation which exists among and surrounded by
poverty. Therefore, friction between Ancol and its surrounding community could explode anytime.
2
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.
Confidential
Not for public distribution
Our proposal is a safety valve for Ancol. It is to promote community assistance. Ancol still has to
spend money on this, but not without results. “ Ancol is not Santa Claus”.
Question:
How long has this collaboration been going? Does Ancol give donations to the community? How
about its sustainability?
Answer:
Kiki Nugroho (Ancol): Assets given to the society will become theirs. Our target this year is “zero
waste”. Up until now, the cost to transport garbage from Ancol to Bantar Gebang has reached four
billion rupiahs. Tomorrow we will have a presentation to request the company to provide 2000
meters of land for garbage processing plants. Leaf waste could contribute 50% of waste overall. We
will provide the technology, people, and after that the community could process the waste
themselves.
Question:
Many NGOs and government representatives started other programs to reduce mortality. There is a
community development program to reduce mortality. However that was not successful, because it
was not supported by the community. What I have heard from this presentation is different; the
community’s willingness starts this. What is the impact on health issues? To what extent is the
Puskesmas [*government-owned clinic] involved in measuring whether there is a decrease of illness
within 5 years before the start of this program?
Question:
This program improves the community’s economy; also there are improvements in MCKs (in bahasa
Mandi Cuci Kakus or Lavatory and wash) which impacts public health. With better MCKs, is there
any data about disease and illness?
Answer:
Mustofa (community representatives):
Before we have better MCKs, we have to face problems with diarrhea. Now the situation is getting
better, our DBD program has Jumantik (mosquito larva monitoring) team.
Question:
As a suggestion, in the future Komseni and Ancol should consider about conducting a data registry.
Answer:
Kiki Nugroho (Ancol): Initially this program has two ideas. First is to create “Hijau Asri” [*green is
beautiful]; the second is community benefits from garbage, growing medicinal plants, and health
[*improving community health]. Hijau Asri and garbage program has started and runs well, but
3
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.
Confidential
Not for public distribution
health program, [*improving community health program] does not run very well. Once there was a
group of farmers who initiates [* program about] medicinal plants, but was not good enough.
Question:
Indonesia has a large community. This brings dynamics to NGOs in reaching their goal. What
difficulty often appears when executing activities? What activities are dominated by females? How
is the relationship between the community and Komseni?
Answer:
Rika Lestari (Ancol): I joined this program at the early stage. Ms. Debra Yatim’s role is very
extraordinary and very much respects the dignity of women. We encouraged women, because the
mothers will have a positive impression on the husbands. We introduced them to medicinal plants
and encouraged them to build Kampung Jamu [Traditional Medicine Village]. They were very excited
to develop this plan. Ancol provides the funds and the medicinal plants. With Ms. Yatim’s
assistance, now there are two women in Ancol community development project. When I first
joined KDU, all its members were men. I tried to keep up and joined the discussion, even staying up
until late at night. Besides Ms. Yatim from Komseni, Jaya Ancol also directly involved. To find the
right concept for this program, Ms. Yatim will share with us about “live in” (participatory approach)
to define a suitable program pattern.
Answer:
Debra Yatim: NGOs typically do not align with a corporation. This needs to be straightened out.
Reciting Microsoft, I can say that: a corporation is part of the society. Moving towards the year of
2015, there should be participation from three other elements to achieve the Global Reporting
Initiative. We have to include “the defable” [or people with different abilities]. There should be
gender equality, it should be 50 percents, but 30 percents is still good. Other minority issues is
about ODHA [*short for Orang Dengan HIV/AIDS, meaning person with HIV/AIDS]. Not many
companies are aware of this. These issues, especially health issues are the tasks for NGOs. There is
a big corporation that allows NGOs to come in, listen to their ideas, and work together for 20 years.
From this we can see that there is a way for the Indonesian women's coalition.
Answering the question on Sustainability: As long as the company guarantees, Mr. Mustofa’s efforts
will sustain. As long as PT. Jaya Ancol still exists, Ancol will help maintain the economy of the
surrounding community. By buying the products of the community, the community will maintain
the quality of their products. Therefore there is mutual cooperation among them. This is the “safety
valve” as I mentioned before [*a safety valve to avoid friction between Ancol and its surrounding
community].
Kemal Soeriawidjaja: Mrs. Debra Yatim’s presentation is very important. Especially when she
mentioned about the development of partnerships between corporations and NGOs. One element
that we could learn from this is case studies, which will be discussed by Ancol and Komseni.
4
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.
Confidential
Not for public distribution
Before the lunch session, I would like to give a report on the CCPH World Wide’s website. CCPHI has
become a unique model. It runs successfully and will become a pilot project for CCPH World Wide.
Right now we are still developing the website’s content and design. We would be thankful if there is
any idea for this website. We are developing a page to view all logos of NGOs and CSR. If possible
we will link these logos to the organization. For case studies that have been sent to us, it could be
accessed by all to learn. All content will be published with the consent from your organization. We
will not publish it without consent.
We wish this website to be an interactive website. This website will be in two languages: Bahasa
Indonesia and English.
AFTERNOON SESSION
Kemal Soeriawidjaja: We will discuss about the role of the government. This topic is from the HBRI
meeting notes from June last year.
Conclusion:
From the discussion, we concluded some points related to the role of the government:
1. When a program aligns with the government (local or central government), the government
will help to accelerate the implementation process.
2. Response and attitude of the local government could be an indicator of whether they can be
involved in the program or not.
3. NGOs and Government have a unique position. This is rather confusing because there are
different opinions on this. The first is: the government’s role is not needed. The second is:
We need the government for policy making. The last is: NGOs should try to link the
government with the private sector.
4. Local Government complements best practices. They will adopt and implement it.
Closing:
Kemal: I would like to thank PT. Microsoft as the host. Thank you to all of the participants. If you
need my assistance, please feel free to contact me thru email or mobile phone.
5
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.
Confidential
Not for public distribution
Annex: List of Participants HBRI IX – 20 April 2010
INDONE SIA
No
Name
Organization
E-mail
1
Ahmad Fauzi
Yayasan Mitra Inti
ahmadfauzi@mitrainti.org
2
Ananta Gondomono
Microsoft
anantago@microsoft.com
3
Anggia Ermarini
LPK-NU
ayufaras@yahoo.com
4
Asmilia Makmur
Ikatan Bidan Indonesia
asmilia@bidan-delima.org
5
Carolina Monteiro
Yayasan Jurnal Perempuan
Olin@jurnalperempuan.com
6
Catharina Widjaja
Gajah Tunggal
cath@centrin.net.id
7
Damaryanti Suryaningsih
ccp-indonesia
d.suryaningsih@ccp-indonesia.org
8
Dave A. Seta
ExxonMobil
dave.a.seta@exxonmobil.com
9
David Hulse
Ford Foundation
D.Hulse@fordfoundation.org
10
Debra Yatim
KOMSENI
dhyatim@yahoo.com
11
Deedee Achriani
Yayasan Jurnal Perempuan
deedee@jurnalperempuan.com
12
Deni Puspahadi
Indofood
deni.puspahadi@indofood.co.id
13
Djoko Soetikno
Jhpiego
dhsoetikno@jhpiego.net
14
Drajat Panjawi
Microsoft
drajat.panjawi@microsoft.com
15
Eneke Arisanti
LKK-NU Jepara
e_arisantie@yahoo.com
16
Esther Parapak
Ford Foundation
e.parapak@fordfoundation.org
17
Esther Sianipar
World Vision
esther_sianipar@wvi.org
6
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.
Confidential
Not for public distribution
No
Name
Organization
E-mail
18
Esty Febriani
LPK-NU
esty_febriani@yahoo.com
19
Farah Rachmat
Médecins du Monde
Hradmin.jakarta.mdmindonesia@gmail.com
20
Harni Koesno
Ikatan Bidan Indonesia
ppibi@cbn.net.id
21
Heri Haerudin
JHUCCP
heri.haerudin@jhuccp.or.id
22
Heru Susanto
KOMSENI
cabekrit@yahoo.com
23
Indah Pratiwi
Ford Foundation
i.pratiwi@fordfoundation.org
24
Ira Aprisiani
Dewhirst
ira.aprisiani@dewhirst.com
25
Iskandar
Project Concern International
iskandar@pci.org
26
Jeffry Rainhard
HOPE Worldwide
jeffry@hopeindonesia.org
27
Joseph landri
Gajah Tunggal
joseph.landri@gt-tires.com
28
Julie Rostina
Peduli Perempuan
julie.rostina@gmail.com
29
Jura Katoppo
Sierad Produce
jura.katoppo@sierad.co.id
30
Katri Krisnati
ExxonMobil
katri.krisnati@exxonmobil.com
31
Kemal Soeriawidjaja
CCPHI
kemal.soeriawidjaja@ccphi.org
32
Kiki Nugroho
Pembangunan Jaya Ancol
gomez@ancol.com
33
Linarti
Koalisi Perempuan Indonesia
sekretariat@koalisiperempuan.or.id
34
Lucy Herny
PKBI
myownlucy@yahoo.com
35
Lucyani Caesaria
Cambodia Trust
jcpoaccount@gmail.com
36
Luki Kurniawan
Ford Foundation
l.kurniawan@fordfoundation.org
37
Lulu Fotuana
Medika Pratama
medika@indo.net.id
38
Mahadi Margiono
GE Healthcare
mahadi.margiono@ge.com
39
Maria Adriyanti
World Vision
maria_adrijanti@wvi.org
40
Marsih Hoar
Yayasan Usaha Mulia
marsih@yumindonesia.org
41
Melani
Yayasan Usaha Mulia
melani@yumindonesia.org
7
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.
Confidential
Not for public distribution
No
Name
Organization
E-mail
42
Mering Ngo
Chevron
meringn@chevron.com
43
Mindo Silaban
HOPE Worldwide
mindo@hopeindonesia.org
44
Nety Riana Sari SN
Pacivis-UI
netyrianasarisn@hotmail.co.uk
45
Petra Wisse
Médecins du Monde
genco_mdmindonesia@gmail.com
46
Rangga Aditya Elias
Pacivis-UI
rangga1903@yahoo.co.id
47
Rika Lestari
Pembangunan Jaya Ancol
rika@ancol.com
48
Riza Pratama
Freeport
riza_pratama@fmi.com
49
Santi Clara
IBCA
santi@ibca.or.id
50
Sri Warasputi
Dewhirst
sri.warasputi@dewhirst.com
51
Taufani Zuliakifli
Bank Mutiara
Taufani@mutiarabank.co.id
52
Tricia Iskandar
Microsoft
i-triska@microsoft.com
53
Troy Parwata
Tigaraksa Satria
troy-parwata@tigaraksa.co.id
54
Yahya Mashum
PKBI
yahyamashum@yahoo.com
55
Yakobus Yuliatmoko
Cambodia Trust
yuliatmokoyakobus@gmail.com
Thank you for MICROSOFT INDONESIA as the host of HBRI IX.
8
These are being provided to you as a member of the Roundtable for distribution only within your organization as a tool to
disseminate the lessons learned. Under no circumstances should these be sent to anyone outside your organization or anyone
affiliated with the press. We trust you will honor the balance between seeking to increase the positive impact of the Roundtable
and continuing to maintain its confidential atmosphere by respecting this policy.