CORPORATE PLANNING CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS (A CASE STUDY OF DANGOTE GROUP OF COMPANY) BY OKECHUKWU REBECCA OBIAGELI PG/MBA/09/53940 DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT FACULTY OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION UNIVERSITY OF NIGERIA ENUGU CAMPUS MARCH, 2011 v CORPORATE PLANNING CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS (A CASE STUDY OF DANGOTE GROUP OF COMPANY) BY OKECHUKWU REBECCA OBIAGELI PG/MBA/09/53940 IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF MASTER’S DEGREE IN BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION (MBA MANAGEMENT) DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT FACULTY OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION UNIVERSITY OF NIGERIA ENUGU CAMPUS SUPERVISOR: DR. E. K. AGBAEZE MARCH, 2011 v CERTIFICATION Okechukwu Rebecca Oby, a postgraduate student in the Department of Management with Registration Number PG/MBA/09/53940 has satisfactorily completed the requirements for the award of masters degree in management (MBA). This work embodied in this project is original and has not been submitted in part or full for any other Diploma or degree of this or any other University. ________________________ _______________________ Prof. UJF Ewurum Dr. EK Agbaeze Head of Department supervisor ______________________ Okechukwu Rebecca O. Student v DEDICATION This work is dedicated to almighty God. To my husband Mr. Arugruor Kenneth and to my Son Chigaemezu Victory Arugmon. v ABSTRACT The research is on corporate planning; problems and Benefits, A case study of Dangote group of company Lagos. The main objective of the research is to determine the problems managers encounter in corporate planning and thus suggest possible solutions. The researcher analyzed the data collected based on the responses from the questionnaire. Chisquare was used to test the hypothesis formulated. The major findings of the research shows that lack of reliable and adequate information, poor structural policy frame work and lack of adequate managerial skills and technical know how are some of the problems managers encountered in corporate planning. Based on the above findings, the study concluded that corporate planning covers every aspects of the organization as it sets long term goals for the organization and it is vital for the growth of the organization. On the basis of the above finding, the study recommends that there is the need for managers to always reassess the set goals in the light of the performance of the corporate plan overtime ascertain if their target is been achieved, and thus set their goals in the light of the prevailing circumstances, which is the essence of emergent approach in corporate planning. v LIST OF TABLES Table 1: What are the Role of Effective and Efficient Corporate Planning an Organisation? 35 Table 2: What are the Problems managers’ Encounters in Corporate Planning 36 Table 3: Do you Think the objective of Long-range Planning? 37 Table 4: What Strategies does the Management of your Organization Adopt in Corporate Planning? 38 Table 5: How Effective has these Strategies Been? 39 Table 6: What are the Strategic Planning Approaches used by Organization? 40 Table 7: What corporate planning approach does your organization adopt? - 41 Table 8: Which of the following include the forecasting method used by organizations? 42 Table 9: Do you think that for any organization to succeed and compete favorably, the organization must plan well? 43 v TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page i Certification ii Dedication iii Acknowledgement iv Abstract v List of Tables vi CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background of the Study 1 1.2 Statement of Problem 3 1.3 Objectives of the Study 4 1.4 Research Questions 4 1.5 Research hypotheses 5 1.6 Scope and Limitation of the Study 6 1.7 Significance of the Study 7 1.8 Brief History of Dangote Group of Company 8 1.9 Definition of Terms 10 References 12 CHAPTER TWO: REVIEW OF THE RELATED LITERATURE 2.1 Meaning of Corporate Planning 13 2.2 Core Areas of Corporate Planning 15 v 2.3 Approaches to Corporate Planning 17 2.3.1 Prescriptive Approach 17 2.3.2Emergent Approach 18 2.4 Corporate Planning and Strategic Management - 20 2.5 Objectives of Corporate Planning 21 2.6 Steps in Long-Range or Corporate Planning 24 2.7 Benefits of Corporate Planning 27 2.8 Problems of Corporate Planning 30 References 33 CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Sources of Data 34 34 3.3 Primary Sources of Date 3.4 Secondary Sources Date 35 3.5 Population of the Study 3.6 Sample Size Determination 35 3.7 Instrument for Data Collection - 37 3.5 Method of Data Analysis 38 3.6 Validity and Reliability of Data 39 References 40 CHAPTER FOUR: DATA PRESENTATION 4.1 Introduction v 4.2 The Chi- square Test(X2) 4.3 Decision Rule 4.4 Analysis of Questionnaires Distributed and Returned 4,5 Hypothesis Testing CHAPTER FIVE: SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 5.1 Summary of Major Findings 65 5.2 Suggestion for Further Research 66 5.3 Conclusion 67 5.4 Recommendations 67 Bibliography Appendix v CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY The development of corporate planning in business is a post World War II Phenomenon. Before the period of the World War II, almost all business enterprises were carrying on their business affairs without stating any formal objectives or formal long range business plans. Usually business planning was confined to the lower organizational levels, mainly the functional or the departmental levels and they had only short-term plans which focused mainly on manufacturing product planning, materials ordering and receiving, and hiring of labor. Most companies used to have annual budgets or yearly financial plans to ensure their liquidity Imaga, (2000:1). Since that period of World War II, higher level that is at the core body of the company level long-range, usually of 3 to 7 years period planning has assumed ever increasing importance. The development of business planning has been a revolutionary movement or as the technological revolution or even the revolution in life-styles due to income demonstration effects from time to time. According to Hberts, (1950), comprehensive business planning now covers long-range in the form of v strategic planning involving the entire fabric of the organization and is the concern of the top-most management from where it descends to all. The scope of corporate planning covers not only the whole organization but every functional aspect of the organization. It takes into account the full environments in which the business operates and is a systematic assessment of a most comprehensive nature, leading to the realistic mapping out of long term objectives, strategic and operational plans Akpala (1990). In corporate planning, top management is concerned with the future direction of the business as a whole, such decisions taken are long-term in nature and are bound to have far reaching implications on employment, the financing of the business and the types of products manufactured. Thus, corporate planning involves major strategic decisions. It is against this background that this study is set to examine corporate planning with a view to determining its benefits and identifying its problems in Dangote Group of Company Nigeria Limited. 1.2 STATEMENT OF PROBLEM Corporate planning often fails to achieve it's objectives in many organizations due to some Militating factors. The problem of poor v planning which are usually defective due to lack of skills and expertise and reliable and accurate information on the sides of the managers, which will often leads to poor forecast and formulation of vague goals and objectives. Also poor policies and implementation strategies is yet another problem which in most cases leads to deviation of results from the sets goals, and poor feedback. Finally, the very dynamic nature of the business environment which makes forecasting practically impossible, some times Jeopardizes the organizational policy. Lack of effective monitoring of plan implementation and review of results usually undermine even the most articulated corporate plan. 1.3 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY The specific objectives of the 1. To determine the problem manager encounter in cooperate study include the following: planning and suggest solution. 2. To determine the strategic planning approach used by organizations and assesses its appropriateness. 3. To evaluate forecasting methods used by corporate organizations. 4. To determine the corporate planning approach use by organization. v 1.4 RESEARCH QUESTIONS The following researcher questions were asked to elicit useful information to be able to deal with the subject matter. 1. What are the problems managers' encounters in corporate planning? 2. What are the strategic planning approaches used by organizations and how appropriate are they? 3. What are the forecasting methods used by corporate organizations? 4. What are the corporate planning approach uses by organization? 1.5 RESEARCH HYPOTHESES H0: The problems managers encounters in corporate planning does not include lack of adequate and reliable information, poor structural policy framework, lack of adequate managerial skill and technical know-how. H1: The problems managers' encounter in corporate planning does include lack of adequate and reliable information, poor structural policy framework, lack of adequate managerial skills and technical know-how. v H0: The strategic planning approach used by organization does not include analyzing the current status, examining the prospects of the future, setting the future course of strategy, putting a strategy to work, and evaluating and controlling strategy. H1: The strategic planning approach used by organizations includes analyzing the current status, examining the prospects of the future, setting the future course of strategy, putting a strategy to work, evaluating and controlling the strategy. H0: Historical trend analysis, quantitative methods, Brain storming, etc are not forecasting methods used by corporate organizations. Hi: Historical trend analysis, Quantitative methods, Brainstorming, etc are forecasting method used by corporate organizations. H0: The corporate planning approach used by organizations does not include prescriptive and emergent approach. Hi: The corporate planning approaches used by organizations include prescriptive and emergent approach. 1.6 SCOPE AND LIMITATION OF THE STUDY The study is on corporate planning: Problems and benefits. A study of Dangote Group of Company. The major constraints of this study include; v 1. Time Constraints: Due to limited time given for the study, the researcher could not visits places where relevant information necessary for the study could be obtained. 2. Financial Constraints: The researcher has not enough money to embark on an in depth study of this magnitude. Because of financial constrain the researcher could not visit places where necessary information needed for the study could be obtained. 3. Attitude of the Respondents: Some of the respondents were not interested in the questionnaire given to them because they feel they have nothing to benefit from the study. 1.7 SIGNIFICANT OF THE STUDY This research derives its significance from it's usefulness to management of small and big organization, governments and students. This work will be of great importance to the following group of people. The potential and prospective managers might find this work useful as a guide to better business initiative and management towards ensuring proficiency, efficiency and effectiveness. 1. The policy making arms of the government could also appreciate this work and thus make good policies in favor of corporate planning development in Nigeria considering the role it plays in Nigeria economic development. v 2. Other researcher could as well find this work very useful for further research work as a reference material. 1.8 BRIEF HISTORY OF DANGOTE GROUP OF COMPANY Dangote group of company was founded in 1977 with the formation of Alco International Limited. Subsequently Dangote Nigeria Limited was incorporated during the 1980s and 1990s, the group ventured into the importation of sugar, milk, flour, fish, rice, cement and iron rods, later, the group embarked on the haulage business, which started with 60 struck under Dangote transport. Dangote industries limited was incorporated in-order to sustain the groups market leadership in trading commodities and to expand into manufacturing of food, clothing and build materials, Focus was placed on the following; sugar refining, flour milling, pasta production, salt processing, bulk cement bagging, oil and gas exportation, real estate, propylene bag manufacturing, haulage, textiles, maritime operations and telecommunications. The Dangote Group includes the following subsidiaries: 1. Alco International Limited 2. Dangote flour mills Plc 3. Dangote Cement Plc v 4. Dangote Transport Limited 5. Dangote Sugar Plc 6. Dangote Oil and gas industries international 7. Dangote Textiles Limited 8. Blue Star Limited 9. Dangote Holding Limited 10. Dansa Food Limited 1.9 DEFINITION OF TERMS 1. Corporate Planning: This is decision support systems that holds and derives knowledge relevant to planning decisions that cut across organizational units and involve the entire fabric of the organization and is the concern of the top most management from where it descends to all, Karl (1998:14). 2. Management: This is defined as the process by which organizations resources of men, material and money are combined in such a way that goals and objectives of the organization are realized in an effective and efficient manner, Akpala (1990:44). 3. Corporation: This is a mechanism by which different parties contribute capital, expertise, and labuor to achieve mutual benefit. 4. Corporate Culture: This is the totality of the shared beliefs, v values, norms and expectations by organizations members which are transmitted from generation to generation. 5. Planning: This is the act of determining in advance possible future work of actions. 6. Strategic Management: This is the process by which top management determine the long run performance of the organization by ensuring careful formulation, proper implementation and continuous evaluation of the strategy. v REFERENCES Akpala. A. (1990:49): Management: An Introduction and the Nigeria Perspective: Enugu, Prevision Publishers. Ewurum, U.J.F (2001): Total Quality Management Unpublished Paper Presented at Workshop Organized by Health System Fund, Enugu. Hammer, M. and Champy, J. (1993): Reengineering the Corporation. A Manifestation for Business Revolution, London Nicholas Brealy Publishers. Imaga, E.U.L. (1996): A Manual of Corporate Planning and Strategic Business Policy, Raye Kere Publishers, Enugu. Onodugo, V. A. and Ezeh J. A. (2002): Business Policy and Strategic Management, Issues and Trends, Kinsman Publisher Limited Enugu. v CHAPTER TWO REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE In this chapter, the research reviews some relevant literature on the subject matter. 2.1 MEANING OF CORPORATE PLANNING Corporate planning can be defined as an organization's sense of purpose and is concerned with an organizations basic direction future. Its purpose, ambitions, resources and how it interacts within the world in which it operates. According to Keith Andrews in Lynch (1997; 8) corporate planning is the pattern of major objectives. Purposes or goals and essential policies or plans for achieving those goals, stated in such a way as to define what business the company is in or is to be in and the kind of company it is or is to be. It should be pointed out that there is no universal definitions of corporate planning some writers include the purpose of the organization as part of strategy, while others make clear distinction between the purpose and the actions that then carry out this purpose. Corporate planning is the planning activity at the top management level v which covers the whole organization. Akpala (1990:49). It is a longterm programmed of actions selected by the top management in order to achieve long-term objectives of the organization. Thus, according to Harvey (1994:6) corporate planning is concerned with the scope of organizations activities. The issue of scope of activity is fundamental to corporate planning because it concerns the way in which those responsible for managing the organization conceive its boundaries. It has to do with what they want the organization to be like and to be about. In his own work, Sisk (1993:96) states that corporate planning involves decisions that affect the long-term direction of the whole organization. It therefore has long-term horizon and/or long-term implications. According to him, corporate planning is concerned with what typed of business the organization, as a whole, should operate, and is therefore concerned with decision of scope. This includes extent of manufacturing, vertical integration and types of business and market it should be involved. Others may be which businesses to acquire or divest, or what resources should be allocated to v which businesses by the corporate headquarters. Corporate planning is therefore also likely to involve questions about the financial structure and organizational structure of the firm as a whole. 2.2 CORE AREAS OF CORPORATE PLANNING The three core areas of corporate planning are strategic analysis, strategy development and strategies implementation. According to Lynch (1997:17) with respect to strategic analysis, the organization, its mission and objectives have to be examined and analyzed. Corporate planning provides value for the people involved in the organization; its stakeholders but it is often the senior manager who develops the view of the organization's overall objectives in the broadest possible terms. They conduct an examination of the objectives and also analyze the resources of the organization. Thus, strategic analysis involves an examination and analysis of organization's objectives and resources. On the other hand, in strategy development, the strategy options have to be developed and then selected. To be successful, the strategy has to be built on the particular skills of the organization and the special v relationships that it has or can develop with those outside suppliers, customers, distributors and government. For many organizations, this will mean developing advantages over competitors that are sustainable over time. There are usually many options available and one or more will have to be selected. According to Lynch (1997:17) in strategy implementation the selected options now have to be implemented. There may be major difficulties in terms of motivation, power relationships, government negotiations, company acquisitions and many other matters. If a viable corporate plan is to be developed each of these three areas should be explored carefully. In practice, the three core areas are interlocking and overlapping. For example, an objective may prove unrealistic once implemented and may therefore need to be modified. 2.3 APPROACHES TO CORPORATE PLANNING There are two approaches to corporate planning prescriptive and emergent approaches. 2.3.1 Prescriptive Approach According to Lynch (1997:44) a prescriptive corporate planning is one where the objective has been defined in advance and the main elements have been developed before the plan commences. v Prescriptive corporate planning starts with the search for an agreed objective, then the environment in which the organization operates is then analyzed and projections made for the future. Based on this work, forecasts then form the background for the organization strategic plan. At this point the objectives may be reviewed. If the forecasts are particularly positive or negative, then the objectives may be changed. Lynch states that after making a forecast of the expected environment, various option are identified to enable the business to achieve the agreed objectives, there is usually more than one way of achieving objectives. One options is then selected which has the ability to meet the objective. The chosen option is implemented by the organization's managers. The prescriptive corporate planning process is claimed to be logical, rational and capable of real insight into the problems of an organization. It focuses on the major issues that each company needs to address. 2.3.2 Emergent Approach Emergent corporate planning is a strategy whose final objective is unclear and whose elements are developed during the course of its life, v as the strategy proceeds. Lynch (1997:52) deriving from the observation that human beings are not always the rational and logical creatures assumed by prescriptive approach, various commentators have rejected the long-term prescriptive approach. They argue that strategy emerges, adapting to human need and continuing to develop overtime. Given this, they argue that there can be only limited meaningful prescriptive strategies and limited value from long-term planning. According to Gayle (1002:136) the advantages of emergent corporate approach are that which takes account of people issues such as motivation, allows the strategy to develop as more is learnt about the strategic situation and provides the opportunity for the culture and politics of an organization to be included in the process. 2.4 CORPORATE PLANNING AND STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT Donald (1994:31) stresses the importance of clarity of the role of corporate planning in an organization. According to him, there is little v evidence to support the idea that corporate planning is an activity of corporate planners as managers in organization are actually responsible for strategic decision being taken. Strategic management and corporate planning are the same in the sense that both study the strategic analysis in my own perspective. Rather, the role of corporate planning appears to be, to contribute to the strategic management in three main ways; 1. Assisting in the adaptation of the organization to its environment, by means of monitoring changes in the environment formulating environmental and strategic scenarios and acting in a consultancy capacity to parts of the organization that wish to examine the implications of environmental change. In this sense corporate planning is carrying out a strategic analysis function. 2. Providing an integration role in an organization in the sense of acting as a communication channel between, for example, a corporate head office and its divisions. 3. Providing a control mechanism to monitor the performance of parts of the organization (e.g. divisions) against strategic priorities. Here corporate planning has a role in the implementation of strategy. The picture emerges of corporate planning as an aid to, rather than as the means of strategic decision making. v 2.5 OBJECTIVES OF CORPORATE PLANNING According to Ola (1995:83) the purposes of corporate planning are; (i) To assess the tread of the international, national industry and company environment (political, social, economic, institutional and technological), (ii) To identify what the business is in. (iii) To set corporate objectives for so many years ahead, and (iv) To determine suitable strategies to achieve these objectives; a. Profitability b. Return on capital employed c. Avoidance of loss In respect of assessment of the international, national and industry environment, Ola (1995:85) explains that this objective is aimed in analyzing the internal and external environments in which the business will operate for long time. Thorough analysis will enable corporate planners' match the activities of the organization to the environment in which it operates. Accordingly, through corporate planning top management aims at making the organization compete effectively in the foreign and home markets given v the existing institutional and technological arrangements. Corporate planning is also aimed at identifying what the business is in. According to Ola (1995:86) corporate planning also aims at providing the framework for long-term decisions on the nature of the business that is, what activities the business will engage in for a longtime. In other words, corporate planning aims at defining the scope of the organization's activities which among other decides whether the organization will concentrate in one area of activity or enter other production line. In respect of setting long-time objectives for the organization, he explains that this objective defines the goal of the organization and how this goal will be achieved in the long run. An important aspect of corporate planning in respect of this objective is that corporate planner now sees the organization as a "complex whole" made up of component units which activities must be co-ordinate effectively to achieve the long-run objectives of the organization. Finally, Ola (1995:87) states that the objective of determining suitable strategies to achieve profitability, returns on capital employed and avoid loss aims at achieving long-term growth for the organization. Gluck (1998:61) in his work, states that the objectives of corporate planning v are; 1. To help the organization achieve efficient use of resources. 2. To help the organization adapt to internal and external changes so that it is organized to achieved its long-term goals. 3. To prevent excessive or poorly planned organization change and 4. To help in linking the organization to national and international markets. 2.6 STEPS IN LONG-RANGE OR CORPORATE PLANNING In his book titled "Top Management Planning" Boyles (1990:72) outlines what he describes as eight phases of the long range planning cycle. These are: Step 1: Determine where the organizations stand today: According to him, the initial starting point for any planning effort is to first determine the current status of the organization. Sound forecasts and plans cannot be made for the future without an accurate assessment of an organizations current strength and weaknesses. Step 2: Develop Planning premises based on current trends and probable future conditions: According to him, this step involves a forecast of political, economic, social and technological trends in the v specific markets the firm competes in, as well as national and world conditions. Projected threats and opportunities needs to be identified with the future lay out before it; the firm can then decide what actions it wants to take. Steps 3: Develop and Reassess Objectives: Sequel to an assessment of the organization's strength and weaknesses and a forecast of market trends, the firm needs to evaluate its current objectives and establish new ones. Step 4: Establish Strategies to Achieve the Objectives: According to him, strategies are to major courses of action a firm needs to pursue if it is to achieve its objective. If a firm has a goal to increase its sales by 20 percent, strategies are the methods it will undertake to attain this objective. Among these strategies are use of more advertising, introduce new product, engage in price-cutting war and redesign its current product. Step 5: Program Activities to Gain Desired Results: According to him, programming is detailed determination of the activities each subunit must pursue if the strategies are to be implemented. Programming is tedious and time-consuming, but in it lies the rewards of planning. v Step 6: Determine the Support Resources needed to conduct the Activities of step 5: According to him, once all the activities are enumerated these are then 'priced out' to determine the resources that will be required to support them. This includes estimating the materials, machinery, facilities, labour and other resources necessary to conduct the activities specified in step 5. Step 7: Execute the Plan: Once the plans are completed, they are then executed (or implemented) in accordance with the established time schedule. Step 8: Control to the Plan: As the plan is executed, measurements are obtained on how operations are progressing. This feedback is provided to management so that they can take appropriate action. 2.7 BENEFITS OF CORPORATE PLANNING Sisk (1993:121) enumerates some of the benefits of corporate planning to organization. First, it enables management to assess and determine the company's real position in respect of its human and material resources. A thorough understanding of the organization's strength and weaknesses will provide the basis for effective forecast and plan of a long-term nature. v Second, it enable management to set realistic objectives, which given the available resources, will not only lead to immediate achievement of the set goals but also in the long-run. According to him, such objectives will exploit strengths of the firm, put it in the right market niche and achieve the desired growth rate. Thirdly, corporate planning enables management to design effective strategies for achieving the set: objectives. According to him, among other things, it will enable assumption to be made about the reaction of competitors and a follow-up action. In his own work, Akpala (1990:49) states that an advantage of corporate planning is that it takes into account the full environment in which the business operate and leads to the realistic mapping-out of long-term objectives, strategic and operational plans. This implies that in corporate planning strategic and operational plans are also designed for the achievement of the overall aim of the company or organization. In his contribution to desirability of corporate planning for mediumscale enterprises, kwakwanso (1999:3) argues that corporate planning, if v effectively designed and implemented, surely leads to efficient utilization of productive resources in the long-run. He also states that effectively implanted corporate plan leads to optimization of returns on capital employed and maximization of profitability over the long-run. Ultimately, it leads to enhanced performance and overall growth in the long-run. Kwakwanso (1999:5) also states that corporate planning also has additional benefit of achieving effective manpower development policy over the years. According to him, it enables the organization to forecast its manpower, needs over the years and develop recruitment, selection and training programmers to achieve these needs. Furthermore, it enables the management to develop and effective compensation scheme for workers based on current business trend and projected future trend. A second factor is deteriorating economic conditions. According to Harvey (1994:96) corporate planners cannot realistically set goals if the political, economic social and technological trends in the market in which it operates as well as national and international environments are unstable and unpredictable. The result is that v unrealistic goals are set. Thirdly, corporate planners sometimes do not reassess set objectives. According to him, reassessing established goals helps in determining their feasibility and failure to do this makes it difficult for planners to determine what future results the organization plans to achieve. In his own work Boyles (1990:89) identifies inability to establish strategies to achieve the objectives and programmed activities to gain desired result as factor militating against effective corporate planning. Other problems include lack of support resources needed to conduct activities to gain desired results, inability to implement the plan judicially as well as control the plan. Similarly Gayle (1992:12) outlines the problems of corporate planning as inadequate information during planning on the strengths and weakness of the organization, faulty definitions of organizational goals, poor plan implementation, control and review. v REFERENCES Akpala, A. (1990:44): Management: An Introduction and the Nigeria Perspective. Enugu Precision Printers. Boyles, A. (1990:72): Policy Strategy and Decision-Making. New York: McGraw Hill Books Inc. Dale B, (1992:29): Long-Term Planning in American Industry. New York: AMA Inc. Donald, H. (1994:31): Principles of Scientific Management. New Jersey: Harper and Brothers Ltd. Grayle, J. (1992:121): Basic Element of Management London: McDonald and Evan Ltd. Harvey, V. (1994:6): Management London: Evan Brothers. Kwakwanso, M. (1999:3): "Corporate Planning in Organization; The case for Medium-Scale Industry" A workshop paper presented in Jos. Lynch, R. (1997:42): Corporate Strategy. London: Pitman Publishing Co. Ola, A. (1995:83): Strategic Decision-Making in Practice Ibadan: v Onibonoje Press. Sisk, M. (1993:96): Corporate Strategy: An Introduction New York: McGraw-Hill Books Inc. Trewartha, R. and Newport, M. (1991:90): Quoted in Gluck, E. (1998:72) op cit. CHAPTER THREE RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3.1 INTRODUCTION The aim of this chapter is to discuss the method adopted by the researcher in carrying out this research investigation. The chapter contains source of data, population and sample size determination, instrument used for data collection, Techniques for data analysis and validity and reliability of data. 3.2 SOURCES OF DATA The sources of data for the study include primary and secondary data. 3.2.1 Primary Sources of Data This refers to data generated at first hand level specifically for the study. To generate this type of data. The researcher employed two research instrument, the questionnaire and oral interview. 3.2.2 Secondary Sources of Data v Secondary data are facts that the researcher collected from already published sources. The secondary sources from which data were generated include text books, Journals, magazine, article and the internet. 3.3 POPULATION OF THE STUDY Dangote group of company has strength of about 10,000 and they are made of 95% Nigerian and 5% expatriates who are either on contract bases or core staff. 3.4 SAMPLE SIZE DETERMINATION The target populations of the study are the senior and management staff of Dangote group of company in the Lagos head office. They include the managing directors, sales, Advert, production manager and all the supervisor of various units. The target population is 162 representing 1.62% of the staff strength nation wide. Based on the target population, the researcher used a normal confidence level of 95% and error tolerance of 5%. Therefore the sample size was determined using Yamen formular. Sample size determination v Where: n = sample size N = Population of workers (162) e = Margin of errors (5% or 0.05). I = Constraint value The result is presented thus, n = n = n = n = n = n = 115. 3.5 INSTRUMENT FOR DATA COLLECTION The various instruments used in collecting data for this study include the following; a. Questionnaire b. Personal interview v c. Observation Questionnaire A total of 115 questionnaires were distributed to the staff of Dangote group of company. It comprises a total of 17 questions which is made up of multiple choice questions and dichotomous questions. 1. Multiple Choice Questions: This requires the respondents to choose from a set of alternative (options provided) some of the multiple choice question requires a choice of more than one alternative option. 2. Dichotomous Question: These are close ended questions that requires respondents to answer Yes or No. 3. Personal Interview: The interview conducted by the researcher on the staff of Dangote group of company gave the researcher quick response which provides a complementary data to the questionnaire. 4. Observation: Observation was made 011 the activities taxing v place in the lead of Dangote group of company Lagos. 3.6 METHOD OF DATA ANALYSIS The data collected were analyzed using tables and percentage. They hypothesis formulated were tested using chi-square(X2) X2 = Where: X2 = Chi-square fo = Observed frequency Fe = = Expected frequency Summation 3.7 VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY OF DATA The questionnaires were made simple and easy so as to be clearly understood by the respondents. The researcher was available to make necessary explanation on the questions where there is need. A lest retest was milled out. The questionnaire were distributed on a second occasion, it was observed that the degree of consistency was quite high. This shows that the questionnaire is reliable. v REFERENCES Goode, W. J. and Hank P. K. (1952), Methods in Social Research; New York, McGraw Hill Publisher. Nwabuoke, P. O. (1986), Fundamentals of Statistics; Onitsha, Korurna Books. Osuala, E. C. (1982), Introduction to Research Methodology; Onitsha, Africa Feb-Publishers Limited. Ozongwu, O. M. (1992), Guide to Proposal writing social and Behavioural Sciences, Snaap Press Ltd. v CHAPTER FOUR DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS 4.0 INTRODUCTION This chapter is designed and aimed at the presentation, analysis and interpretation of various response obtained from the administered questionnaires, using chi-square (X2) as the appropriate statistics tool. 4.2 THE CHI SQUARE TEST (X2) The chi-square (X2) test provides the basis for testing whether more than one population may be considered equal. It provides a means of comparing a set of observed frequencies. The calculated X 2 difference will form the basis for accepting or rejecting the null hypothesis. 4.3 DECISION RULE The rule is to reject Ho (null hypothesis) if the calculated X 2 is greater than the critical value of X2. This means that if the Ho (Null) hypothesis) is rejected the alternative hypothesis (H 1) will be accepted. v 4.4. ANALYSIS OF QUESTIONNAIRES AND RETURNED DISTRIBUTED From the table below, it is necessary to recall that out of 115 questionnaires distributed, 100 copies representing 87 percent were returned and used, while 15 copies representing 13 percent were not returned. QUESTIONNAIRES DISTRIBUTED AND RETURNED Level % No Given % No Returned No not Returned % not Returned Senior staff 40 35 30 26 10 9 Executive 75 65 70 61 5 4 Total 115 100 100 87 15 13 v Table 1 Question 9 What are the Role of Effective and Efficient Corporate Planning to an Organization? Options Respondents Percentage Enlargement of productivities 5 5% Creation of new technology, 7 7% Creation of employment 15 15% All of the above 73 73% Total 100 100% product and service Source: Field Survey, 2010 The above table shows that 5 respondents representing 5% indicated enlargement of productivities. 7 respondents representing 7% indicated creation of new technology, product and services. 15 respondents representing 15% indicated creation of employment. While 73 respondents representing 73% indicated all of the above. Therefore this shows that the role of an effective and efficient corporate planning to an organization include; v (a) Enlargement of productivities (b) Creation of new technology, product and service (c) Creation of employment Table 2 Question 10 What are the problems managers' encounters in corporate planning? Options Respondents Percentage 15 15% 5 5% 5 5% technical know how All of the above 75 75% Total 100 100% Lack of adequate and reliable information Poor structural policy frame work Lack of adequate managerial skills and Source: Field Survey, 2010. The above table shows that 15 respondents representing 15% indicated lack of adequate and reliable information. 5 respondents representing 5% indicated poor structural policy frame work. 5 respondents representing 5% indicated lack of managerial skills and technical know how. While 75 respondents representing 75% indicated all of the above. Therefore this shows that the problems managers encounters in v corporate planning include. (a) Lack of adequate and reliable information (b) Poor structural policy frame work (c) Lack of adequate managerial skills and technical know how. Table 3, Question 11 Do you think that the objectives of long-range planning includes, to define the scope of the organizations activities, set corporate goals for so many years ahead, determine suitable strategies for achieving the set goals and assess the trend of the business environment for the purpose of forecasting? Options Respondents Yes 100 No - Total 100 Percentage 100% — 100% Source: Field Survey, 2010. The above table shows that 100 respondents representing 100% indicated yes while none of the respondents indicated No. Therefore, this shows that defining the scope of the organizations activities, setting corporate goals for so many years ahead, determining suitable strategies v for achieving the set goals and assessing (lie I rend of business environment for UK; purpose of forecasting are the objective of long - range planning. Table 4 Question 12 What strategies does the management of your organization adopt in corporate planning? Options Respondents Percentage Resources strategies 20 20% Environmental strategies 10 10% Adding value 15 15% All of the above 55 55% Total 100 100% Source: Field Survey, 2010. The above table shows that 55 respondents representing 55% indicated very effective. 40% respondents representing 40% indicated effective while the remaining 5 respondents representing 5% indicated not effective. Therefore this shows that the strategy the management of Dangote group of company adopts in corporate planning is very effective. v The above table shows that 20 respondents representing 20% indicated resources strategies. 10 respondents representing 10% indicated environmental strategies. 15 respondents representing 15% indicated adding value while 55 respondents representing 55% indicated all of the above. Therefore this shows that the strategies adopted by the organization in corporate planning include. (a) Resources strategies (b) Environment strategies (c) Adding value Table 5 Question 13 How effective has these strategies been? Options Respondents Percentage Very effective 55 55% Effective 40 40% Not effective 5 5% Total 100 100% Source: Field Survey, 2010. v Table 6 Question 14 What are the strategic planning approaches used by organization? Options Respondents Percentage 12 12% 23 23% 15 15% strategy All of the above 50% 50% Total 100 100% Analyzing the current status and examining the prospects of the future. Setting the future course of strategy and putting and putting a strategy to work. Evaluating and controlling Source: Field Survey, 2010. The above table shows that 12 respondents representing 12% indicated analyzing the current status and examining the prospects of the future. 23 respondents representing 23% indicated setting the future course of strategy and putting a strategy to work. 15 respondents representing 15% indicate evaluating and controlling strategy, while 50 respondents representing 50% indicated all of the above. Therefore this shows that the strategic planning approach used, by organization include; v (a) Analyzing the current status and examining the prospects of the future. (b) Setting the future course of strategy and putting a strategy to work. (c) Evaluating and controlling strategy. Table 7 Question 15 What corporate planning approach does your organization adopt? Options Respondents Percentage Prescriptive approach 48 48% Emergent approach 32 32% All of the above 20 20% Total 100 100% Source: Field Survey, 2010 The above table shows that 48 respondents representing 48% indicated prescriptive approach. 32 respondents representing 32% indicated emergent approach. While 20 respondents representing 20% indicated, all of the above. Therefore, this shows that the corporate planning approach which the organization adopts include, a) Prescriptive approach, v b) Emergent approach. Table 8 Question 16 Which of the following include the forecasting method used by organizations? Options Respondents Percentage Historical trend analysis 17 17% Qualitative method 23 23% Brain storming 15 15% All of the above 45 45% Total 100 100% Source: Field Survey, 2010. The above table shows that 17 respondents representing 17% indicated historical trend analysis. 23 respondents representing 23% indicated quantitative method. 15 respondents representing 15% indicated Brainstorming. While 45 respondents representing 45% indicate all of the above. Therefore this shows that the forecasting methods used by organization include v (a) Historical trend analysis (b) Quantitative method (c) Brain-storming Table 9 Question 17 Do you think that for any organization to succeed and compete favorably, the organization must plan well? Options Respondents Percentage Yes 100 100% No - - Total 100 1OO% Source: Field Survey, 2010. The above table shows that 100 respondents representing 100% indicated yes while none of the yes while none respondents indicated no. Therefore, this shows that for any organization to succeed and compete favorably, the organization must plan well. 4.5 HYPOTHESES TESTING In this section, the hypotheses associated with the study will be tested. The data already presented in this chapter will be uses in testing the hypothesis. This will give the researcher the opportunity to determine whether a change has occurred or whether a real difference exists with a given observed phenomenon. v Hypotheses 1 H0: The problems managers encounters in corporate planning does not include lack of adequate and reliable information, poor structural policy frame work, and lack of adequate manage skill and technical know-how. H I: The problems managers encounter in corporate planning does include lack of adequate and reliable information for structural policy frame work and lack of adequate managerial skills and technical know-how. Tools for computation Using chi-square (x2) Formula X2 £ (Foi-Fei)2 Fei Where Fo = Observed frequency Fe = expected frequency £ = Summation Level of significance = 5% or 0.05 Degree of freedom = (R-1) (C-1) = (4-1) (2-1) = 7.815 Critical value X2 0.05 v Decision Rule The null hypotheses will be rejected if the computed X 2 is greater than the critical value. Accept (Ho) the null hypotheses if the computed value of X2 is less than the critical value. Test of Hypotheses Using X2 = Fe = FOi 7, (Foi-Fei)2 Fei 15 + 5 + 5 + 75= FCl 100 = Foj-Fe! 25 (Fo^FeJ2 (FoirlSii! FCl 4 15 25 -10 100 5 25 -20 400 16 5 25 -20 400 16 75 25 50 2500 100 X2 136 Since the calculated X2(136) is greater than the critical value of (7.815), we reject Ho and accept (Hi) the alternate hypotheses which states that the problems managers encounters in corporate planning include lack of adequate and reliable information, poor structural policy frame work and lack of adequate managerial skills and technical know-how. v Hypotheses II H0: The strategic planning approach used by organizations does not include analyzing the current status and examining the prospects of the future, setting the future course of strategy and putting the strategy to work, evaluation and controlling strategy. Hx: The strategy planning approach used by organization include analyzing the current status and examining the prospects of the future; setting the future course of strategy and putting a strategy to work and evaluating and controlling strategy. What are the strategic planning approaches used by organization? v Options Respondents Analyzing the current status and Percentages 12 12% 23 23% Evaluating and controlling strategy 15 15% All of the above 50 50% Total 100 100% examining the prospects of the future Setting the future course of strategy and putting a strategy to work Tool for computation Using chi-square(x2) = What are the problems managers' encounters in corporate planning? Options Respondents Percentages 15 15% frame 5 5% managerial 5 5% 75 75% 10O 10O% Lack of adequate and reliable information Poor structural policy work Lack of adequate skills and technical know how All of the above Total v Where Foi= Observed frequency Fei= Expected frequency X = summation sign Level of significance 5% or 0.05 Degree of freedom = (R-l) (c-1) H L)(2 L) =3 Critical value X2 0.05 = 7.815 DECISION RULE The null hypothesis (Ho) will be rejected if the computed X 2 is greater than the critical value. Accept (Ho) the null hypotheses if the computed value X2 is less than the critical value. Hypothesis III H0: Historical trend analysis, quantitative methods and brain storming are not forecasting method used by corporate organizations. Hi: Historical trend analysis, quantitative methods and brains storming are forecasting method used by corporate organization. Which of the following include the forecasting methods used by corporate organizations? v Options Respondents Percentages Historical trend analysis 17 17% Quantitative method 23 23% Brain storming 15 15% All of the above 45 45% Total 100 100% Total for computation Using chi-square (x2) Formula X2 = X (ForFei)2 IV TEST OF HYPOTHESE Using X2 = y.(Foi-Fei)2 Fei Fe = 12 + 23 + 15 + 50 = 100 = 25 F0l Fex Fo1-Fe1 (Fo1-Fe1)2 (Fot-Fe)2 Fe, 6.75 12 25 -13 169 23 25 -2 4 0.16 15 25 -5 25 1 50 25 25 625 25 X2 32.91 Since the calculated X2 (32.91) is greater than the critical value of (7.185) we reject (Ho) the null hypotheses and accept (Hi) the alternate hypotheses which state that the strategic planning v approach used by organization include analyzing the current status and examine the prospects of the future, setting the future course of strategy and putting a strategy to work and evaluating and controlling strategy. Where Fo = = observed frequency Fe Expected frequency Summation sign Level of significance = 5% or 0.05 Degree of freedom (R-l) (C-l) (4-1) (2-1) Critical value X2 0.05 = 7.815. Decision Rule The null hypotheses (Ho)than c^cal value. Accept (Ho) null hypotheses if the critical value. TEST FOR HYPOTHESE Using X2 = y. Fei Fe = 17 + 23 + 15 + 45 = 100 = 25 17 25 -8 64 (Fo,-Fe)2 FCl 2.56 23 25 -2 4 0.16 15 25 -10 100 4 45 25 20 400 16 F0l Fe, X2 FOi-Fe! (FcvFeJ2 22.72 v Since the calculated (X2) 22.72 is greater than the critical value of (7.815), we reject Ho and accept (Hi) the alternate hypotheses which state that historical trend analysis, Quantitative method and Brainstorm are the forecasting method used by corporate organizations. Hypotheses IV H0 : The corporate organizations does planning not approach include prescriptive used by and emergent approach. Hx: The corporate organizations include planning approaches prescriptive and used by emergent approach. Corporate planning approach does your organization adopt? Options Respondents Percentages Prescriptive approach 48 48% Emergent approach 32 32% All of the above 20 20% Total 100 100% Tool for computation Using chi-square (X2) Using X2 = Fei v Where Fo = observed frequency Fe Expected frequency Summation sign Level of significance = 5% 0.05 Degree of freedom = (R-l) (C-l) (4-1) (2-1) Critical value X2 0.5 = 7.815 Decision Rule The null hypothesis (Ho) will be rejected if the computed X 2 is greater than the critical value. Accept (Ho) the null hypotheses if the computed value of X2 is less than the critical value. TEST OF HYPOTHESE Where Fo = observed frequency Fe Expected frequency Summation sign 2 Using X = y. Fei Fei = 48 + 32 + 20 = 100 = 25 4 F0l Fex Foj-Fe! (FcvFeJ2 (FoT-Fel2 FCl v 48 25 23 529 21.16 32 25 7 49 1.96 20 25 -5 25 1.25 X2 24.37 Since the calculated X2(24.37) is greater than the critical value of (7.815) we reject (Ho) the null hypotheses and accept (Hi) the alternate hypotheses which state that the corporate planning approach use by organization include both prescriptive and emergent approach. CHAPTER FIVE v SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION 5.1 SUMMARY OF MAJOR FINDINGS The major findings at the ends of this investigation are (1) The problems managers encounter in corporate planning include the following. a) Lack of adequate and reliable information b) Poor structural policy frame work c) Lack of adequate managerial skills and technical know-how (2) The strategic planning approach used by organizations include a) Analyzing the current status and examining the prospects of the future b) Setting the future course of strategy and putting strategy to work c) Evaluating and controlling strategy The forecasting methods used by corporate organization include (4) a) Historical trend analysis b) Quantitative methods c) Brain storming methods The corporate planning approach used by v organizations include a) Prescriptive approach b) Emergent approach 5.2 SUGGESTION FOR FURTHER RESEARCH For the purpose of further research, the researchers should investigate on the role of a manager in corporate planning for business growth and survival in a constrained economy or corporate social responsibility; the unavoidable issue in corporate sustainability in Nigeria with reference to a particular corporate organization. CONCLUSION Based on the research findings, the researcher conclude that corporate planning covers every aspect of the organization as it sets long- terms goals for the organization. It plays a vital role in assessing the trend of business which enables management to make effective business forecast and thus ensures survival and growth of the business if it is well developed and implemented. v 5.4 RECOMMENDATIONS The following are recommended to make corporate planning very effective. (1) Management should always ensure that it evaluate and determine the actual strengths and weaknesses of the organization in relation to its available resources (money and human) and the environment. This will enable it to set the goals that can be achieved within the constraints imposed by the available resources and the unpredictable environment. (2) Management should always ensure that the trend in business is always studied overtime. A comprehensive analysis of the trend will provide a solid basis for forecasting long-run trend in the future. This is the essence of corporate planning. (3) It is one thing to develop a good corporate plan but another thing to implement it. A good plan is only effective when it is effectively implemented. To this end, management should ensure that appropriate strategies are adopted in implementing the corporate plan. If this is done, then long-run targets of the organization should always be achieved through corporate planning. (4) There is the need for management to always re-assess the set goals v in the light of the performance of the corporate plan over-time. If it is found that the targets are not being achieved over time, then management should set the goals in the light of the prevailing circumstance. This is the essence of emergent approach in corporate planning. (5) Those who carry out the planning should have foresight and skill or expertise knowledge in corporate planning. This will enable them to set achievable targets and adopt appropriate strategies to achieve them. (6) Finally since the environment affects the result of corporate planning in an unpredictable way, there is the need to take this factor into consideration when corporate planning is being done. One way to do this is examine the past trend in order to make effective forecast. v BIBLIOGRAPHY Akpala. A. (1990:49): Management: An Introduction and the Nigeria Perspective: Enugu, Prevision Publishers. Boyles, A. (1990:72): Policy Strategy and Decision-Making. New York: McGraw Hill Books Inc. Dale B, (1992:29): Long-Term Planning in American Industry. New York: AMA Inc. Donald, H. (1994:31): Principles of Scientific Management. New Jersey: Harper and Brothers Ltd. Ewurum, U.J.F (2001): Total Quality Management Unpublished Paper Presented at workshop Organized by Health System Fund, Enugu. Goode, W. J. and Hank P. K. (1952), Methods in Social Research; New York, MC Graw Hill Publisher. Grayle, J. (1992:121): Basic Element of Management London: McDonald and Evan Ltd. Hammer, M. and Champy, J. (1993): Reengineering the Corporation. A Manifestation for Business Revolution, London Nicholas Brealy Publishers. Harvey, V. (1994:6): Management London: Evan Brothers. Imaga, E.U.L. (1996): A Manual of Corporate Planning and Strategic Business Policy, Raye Kere Publishers, Enugu. v Kwakwanso, M. (1999:3): "Corporate Planning in Organization; The case for Medium-Scale Industry" A workshop paper presented in Jos. v QUESTIONNAIRES Please kindly follow the instructioncarefully and tick ( V ) where appropriates. SECTION A 1. 2. 3. 4. Sex (a) Male [ ] (b) Female [ ] Marital Status (a) Single [ ] (b) Married [ ] (a) 21-30 [ ] (b) 31-40 [ ] (c) 41-49 [ ] (d) 50 years and above [ ] Age What is your academic qualification? (a) SSCE [ ] (b) OND/NCE [ ] (c) HND/BSC [ ] (d) MBA/MSc/Phd [ ] What is your salary grade level? v 6. 7. 8. 9. (a) 01-04 [ ] (b) 05-08 [ ] (c) 09.12 [ ] (d) 13 and above [ ] How long have you been working in this organization? (a) 0-5 years [ ] (b) 6-15 years [ ] (c) 16-30 years [ ] (d) 37 years and above [ ] What categories of staff are you? (a) Junior staff [ (b) Senior staff [ ] (c) Executive [ ] What is your department in this company? (a) Production department [ ] (b) Finance department [ (c) Marketing department [ ] (d) Sales Department [ ] What is the role of an effective and efficient corporate planning to an organization [ (a) Enlargement of productivity [ ] (b) Creation of new technology, product and services [ (c) Creation of employment [ ] ] ] v (d) 10. All of to above [ ] What are the problems managers' encounters in corporate planning? (a) (b) Lack of adequate reliable information Poor structural policy framework (c) Lack of adequate managerial skills and technical" know how? 11. [ [ [ Do you think that the objectives of long-range planning? Includes the following? (a) To define the scope of the organizations activities [ (b) To set corporate goals for so many years ahead (c) To determine suitable strategies for achieving the Set goods (d) [ [ To assess the trend of the business environment for the purpose of forecasting. (a) Yes [ (b) No ] [ ] What strategies does the management of your organization adopt in corporate planning? 13. (a) Resources strategy [ (b) Environmental strategy (c) Adding value [ (d) All of the above [ [ ] ] How effective have these strategies been? v 14. (a) Very effective [ (b) Effective [ ] (c) Not effective [ ] What are the strategic planning approaches used by organization? (a) Analyzing the current status and examining the prospects of the future (b) Setting the future course of strategy and putting a strategy to work. 15. [ [ (c) Evaluating and controlling strategy [ (d) All of the above [ ] What corporate planning approach does your organization adopt? 16. (a) Prescriptive approach (b) Emergent approach [ ] (c) All of the above [ ] Which of the following include the forecasting method used by organization? (a) Historical trend analysis [ ] (b) Quantitative method [ ] (c) Brain storming [ ] (d) All of the above [ ] v 17. Do you think that for any organization to succeed and compete favorably the organization must plan well (a) Yes [ ] (b) No [ ] v