Week 15 Lecture Student File 1 of 27 Problem 7 – Job Order Costing Jessica Company started operations on January 2, 20x6. The company manufactures custom products and uses a job order system. Overhead is allocated to jobs based on direct labour costs. The budgeted manufacturing overhead for 20x6 was $396,900 and the direct labour costs were budgeted at $567,000. At the end of 20x6, there were two jobs in work in process: Direct material cost Direct labour cost Job A605 $20,000 12,000 Job A608 $36,000 38,000 Actual manufacturing overhead for the year amounted to $350,000 and total direct labour charges for the year amounted to $550,000. The year-end finished good inventory balance was $175,000 and included direct labour costs of $48,000. Cost of goods sold for the year amounted to $1,750,000. Required 1. 2. 3. Prepare a schedule showing the detailed cost of the ending work-in-process, and finished goods inventory. Compute the over/under –applied overhead for the year. Allocate the balance in the manufacturing overhead account using each of the 4 approaches discussed in class. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 2 of 27 Problem 6 – Process Costing Deterra, Inc., uses three departments to produce a detergent. The Finishing Department is the third and last step before the product is transferred to storage. All materials needed to give the detergent its final composition are added at the beginning of the process in the Finishing Department. The company uses FIFO costing. The following data for the Finishing Department for October have been made available: Production data: In process, October 1 (labor and factory overhead, 75% complete) Transferred in from preceding department Finished and transferred to storage In process, October 31 (labor and factory overhead, 50% complete) 10,000 litres 40,000 litres 35,000 litres 15,000 litres Additional data: Work-in-process inventory, October 1: Cost from preceding department Cost from this department: Materials Labor Factory overhead Transferred in during October Cost added in this department: Materials Labor Factory overhead $ 38,000 21,500 39,000 42,000 $140,500 $140,000 $ 70,000 162,500 130,000 $362,500 Required: Calculate the cost of the units transferred out to finished goods inventory and the value of the ending WIP under both the FIFO method and the weighted average method. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 3 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Spoilage! 35 Spoilage Terminology! • spoilage - unacceptable units of production that are discarded or sold at reduced prices! • reworked units - unacceptable units of production that are subsequently repaired and sold as acceptable finished goods! • scrap - material left over when making a product that has low sales value ! 36 1 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 4 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Normal vs. Abnormal Spoilage! • normal spoilage - spoilage as an inherent result of a particular production even under efficient operating conditions -> expected spoilage! – treat as a component of unit cost of good units manufactured! • abnormal spoilage - spoilage that should not arise under efficient operating conditions -> avoidable and controllable! – do not treat as a product cost; write off directly to cost of goods sold! 37 Accounting for Spoilage " Job Costing! • normal spoilage attributable to a specific job - job bears the cost of the spoilage reduced by the current net realizable value of the spoilage! • normal spoilage common to all jobs - treat as manufacturing overhead! • abnormal spoilage - charge to an abnormal loss account and write off directly to cost of goods sold! 38 2 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 5 of 27 Problem 8 – Process Costing with Spoilage Kristina Company, which manufactures quality paint sold at premium prices, uses a single production department. Production begins with the blending of various chemicals, which are added at the beginning of the process, and ends with the canning of the paint. Canning occurs when the mixture reaches the 90% stage of completion. The gallon cans are then transferred to the Shipping Department for crating and shipment. Labor and overhead are added continuously throughout the process. Prior to May, when a change in the process was implemented, WIP inventories were insignificant. The change in the process enables greater production but results in material amounts of WIP for the first time. The company has always used the WA method to determine equivalent production and unit costs. Now, production management is considering changing from the WA method to the FIFO method. Spoilage is detected when the mixture reaches the 60% stage of completion. Normal spoilage is equal to 2% of units transferred out. The following data relate to actual production during the month of May: COSTS FOR MAY Work-in-process inventory, May 1 (4,000 litres 25% complete): Direct materials-chemicals Direct labor Factory overhead May costs added: Direct materials-chemicals Direct materials-cans Direct labor Factory overhead UNITS FOR MAY - Litres Work-in-process inventory, May 1 (25% complete) Sent to Shipping Department Started in May Work-in-process inventory, May 31 (80% complete) $ 45,600 6,250 18,750 228,400 7,000 35,000 105,000 4,000 19,350 21,000 5,000 Required – Calculate the cost of units transferred out and the cost of abnormal spoilage using (a) FIFO and (b) weighted average. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 6 of 27 Problem 9 – Job Order Costing and Spoilage The Dangelo Company manufactures products that often require specification changes or modifications to meet its customers' needs. Still, Dangelo has been able to establish a normal spoilage rate of 2.5% of normal input. Normal spoilage is recognized during the budgeting process and classified as a component of manufacturing overhead when determining the overhead rate. One of Dangelo's inspection managers, obtains the following information for Job No. A604 that was recently completed. A total of 122,000 units were started, and 5,000 units were rejected at final inspection yielding 117,000 good units. Nine hundred of the first units produced were rejected because of a design defect that was considered very unusual; this defect was corrected immediately, and no further units were rejected for this reason. These units were disposed of after incurring an additional cost of $1,200. The inspection department was unable to identify a rejection pattern for the remaining 4,100 rejected units. These units can be sold at $7 per unit. The total costs for all 122,000 units of Job No. A604 are presented here. The job has been completed, but the costs have yet to be transferred to finished goods. Direct materials Direct manufacturing labour Manufacturing overhead Total manufacturing costs $2,196,000 1,830,000 2,928,000 $6,954,000 Required 1. 2. Calculate the unit quantities of normal and abnormal spoilage. Prepare the appropriate journal entry (or entries) to properly account for job No. A604 including spoilage, disposal, and transfer of costs to finished goods control. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 7 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Cost Estimation! 39 Steps in Estimating a Cost Function! • choose the dependent variable -y! – ideally, all the individual items in the dependent variable will have a similar relationship with the cost driver(s), chosen in the next step! – example: cost driver to predict the total cost of health benefits could be the number of employees! 40 1 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 8 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Steps in Estimating a Cost Function cont d! • choose the cost driver(s) - x , x , …, x 1 2 n! – the chosen driver should be economically plausible and accurately measurable! – there should be a cause and effect relationship between the cost driver and the resulting costs! 41 Steps in Estimating a Cost Function cont d! • collect data on the dependent variable and on the cost driver(s) - y, x ! i – the ideal database would contain numerous observations in periods not subject to major technological change! – the time period used to measure the dependent variable and the cost driver(s) should be identical! 42 2 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 9 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Steps in Estimating a Cost Function cont d! • plot the data - a plot will reveal whether the cost relation is indeed linear, and whether there are any outliers! • high-low method: makes use of the costs and activity levels for the high and low activity levels in a set of data! – variable cost = ∆ in cost / ∆ in activity level between the highest and lowest points of activity! – relies only on two data points! • visual fit (scattergraph) method: visually fit a straight line in a scatter plot of data! • regression analysis: most reliable, as it uses all data points in calculating the best fitting line! 43 Cost Estimation - Example! Month MH Material $ Overhead $ 1 175 $4,750 $4,500 2 170 4,600 4,225 3 160 4,200 3,780 4 190 5,900 5,250 5 175 4,600 4,800 6 200 5,250 5,100 7 160 4,350 4,450 8 150 4,350 4,200 9 210 6,000 5,475 10 180 4,950 4,760 11 170 4,450 4,325 12 145 3,800 3,975 44 3 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 10 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting 45 46 4 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 11 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting 47 48 5 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 12 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Cost Driver = Machine Hours! 49 Cost Driver = Material $! 50 6 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 13 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Cost Driver = MH + Material $! 51 Regression Analysis! • criterion 1: Economic Plausibility! – the basis relationship between the dependent variable and the independent variable should make economic sense and be intuitive to both the operating manager and the management accountant! 52 7 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 14 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Regression Analysis - cont d! • criterion 2: Goodness of Fit! – does the independent variable explain a substantial percentage of the variation in the dependent variable?! – the coefficient of determination, r is used to measure the goodness of fit! 2 – the r test is a measure of the extent to which the independent variable explains or accounts for the variability of the dependent variable! 2 53 Regression Analysis - cont d! • criterion 3: Significance of Independent Variable (s)! – the coefficient of the chosen independent variable(s) should be significantly different from zero, implying an important relationship exists between independent and dependent variables - measured by the t-value of the coefficient of the independent variable(s)! 54 8 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 15 of 27 Problem 10 – Cost Estimation The following selected data were taken from the accounting records of Daviault Manufacturing Company. The company uses direct-labor hours as its cost driver for overhead costs. Month January February March April May June Direct-Labor Hours 26,000 25,000 28,000 23,000 30,000 34,000 Manufacturing Overhead $749,250 720,000 772,500 681,000 775,500 879,000 June's cost consisted of machine supplies ($153,000), depreciation ($22,500), and plant maintenance ($703,500). These costs exhibit the following respective behavior: variable, fixed, and semivariable (mixed). The manufacturing overhead figures presented in the preceding table do not include supervisory labor cost, which is step-fixed in nature. For volume levels of less than 15,000 hours, supervisory labor amounts to $67,500. The cost is $135,000 from 15,000-29,999 hours and $202,500 when activity reaches 30,000 hours or more. Required: 1. 2. 3. Determine the machine supplies cost and depreciation for April. Using the high-low method, analyze Daviault Manufacturing Company's plant maintenance cost and calculate the monthly fixed portion and the variable cost per directlabor hour. Assume that present cost behavior patterns continue into the latter half of the year. Estimate the total amount of manufacturing overhead the company can expect in October if 29,500 direct-labor hours are worked. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 16 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Activity Based Costing! 55 Activity Based Costing! • why traditional cost systems fail?! – overhead is typically allocated to products using unit-based measures such as direct labor, materials purchases, processing time or units produced! – the product costs produced by such allocations are distorted because products do not consume most support resources in proportion to their production volumes! • distortions are most severe in organizations producing a diverse product mix! • products that differ in volume, complexity, and age consume support resources in significantly different amounts! 56 1 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 17 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Activity Based Costing - Structural Overview! COSTING SYSTEM Resource Categories Resource Drivers Activity Analysis Activities Activity Drivers Direct Costs Perf Eval for ABM COST MANAGEMENT Cost Objects 57 The Structure of ABCS! • first stage assigns the expenses of support resources to the activities performed by these resources! – assumption is that activities causes costs! • in the second stage, activity costs are assigned to products based on individual products' consumption or demand for each activity! – assumption is that products create the demand for activities! 58 2 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 18 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting Classes of costs: Unit and Batch! • unit cost: costs that vary proportionally with the number of units produced! – examples: direct material, direct labor, machine hours! – these costs are proportional to short-run production decisions! • batch related costs are incurred each time a batch of goods is processed! – examples: setups, material movements, purchase orders, inspection! – the demand for setup resources are independent of the number of units produced after completing the setup! ! 59 Classes of costs: Product and Facility! • product related costs: incurred to enable individual products to be produced and sold! – the expenses of these activities can be traced to the individual products, but the resources consumed by the activities are independent of how many units or batches of the products are produced! – examples: process engineering, product specifications, product enhancements! • facility related costs: costs incurred to create productive capacity for all products! – examples: factory administration, maintenance, heating and lighting! ! 60 3 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 19 of 27 Module 3 - Management Accounting When to Implement Activity Based Costing! • ABCS are likely to report significantly more accurate product costs when...! – the organization uses large amounts of indirect resources in its production processes, and/or! – the organization has significant diversity in products, production processes, and customers, and/or! – the company faces significant competition, especially from more focused competitors! ! 61 Benefits of Activity Based Costing! • improved decisions: w.r.t introduction, pricing and discontinuance of products; ABCS eliminates cross-product subsidies! • continuous improvement activities to reduce overhead costs: managers will now know what activities causes costs and can reduce or eliminate those activities that add little or no value to products or services! • ease of determining relevant costs: product cost data in traditional systems often needs to be analyzed in order to obtain information relevant to a special decision; under ABCS, the data is readily available! ! 62 4 CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 20 of 27 Problem 11 – Activity Based Costing Mona Loa, Inc. (MLI), is a distributor and processor of a variety of different brands of coffee. The company buys coffee beans from around the world and roasts, blends, and packages them for resale. MLI currently has 10 different coffees that it offers to gourmet shops in one kilogram bags. The major cost is direct materials, however, there is a substantial amount of factory overhead in the predominantly automated roasting and packing process. The company uses relatively little direct labor. Some of the coffees are very popular and sell in large volumes, while a few of the newer brands have very low volumes. MLI prices its coffee at full product cost, including allocated overhead, plus a markup of 25 percent. If prices for certain coffees are significantly higher than the market, the prices are lowered. The company competes primarily on the quality of its products, but customers are price conscious as well. Data for the 20x8 budget include factory overhead of $3,500,000, which has been allocated in its current costing system on the basis of each product's direct labor cost. The budgeted direct labor cost for 20x8 totals $700,000. Budgeted purchases and use of direct materials (mostly coffee beans) will total $6,000,000. Budgeted direct costs for one kg. bags of two of the company's products are as follows: Direct materials Direct labor Italian Roast $3.20 0.30 French Roast $2.80 0.30 MLI's controller believes the current traditional product costing system may be providing misleading cost information. He has developed this analysis of the 20x8 budgeted factory overhead costs: Activity Purchasing Material handling Quality control Roasting Blending Packaging CMA Accelerated Program 2011 Cost Driver Purchase order Setups Batches Roasting-hours Blending-hours Packaging-hours Budgeted Activity 1,150 1,750 500 100,000 23,125 30,000 Budgeted Cost $575,000 612,500 150,000 950,000 462,500 750,000 $3,500,000 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 21 of 27 Data regarding the 20x8 production of Italian Roast and French Roast coffee follow. Assume no beginning or ending direct materials inventory for either of these coffees. Budgeted sales Batch size Setups Purchase order size Roasting time Blending time Packaging time Italian Roast 100,000 kg. 10,000 kg. 3 per batch 25,000 kg. 1 hour per 100 kg. .5 hours per 100 kg. .1 hours per 100 kg. French Roast 2,000 kg. 500 kg. 3 per batch 500 kg. 1 hour per 100 kg. .5 hours per 100 kg. .1 hours per 100 kg. Required – 1) Using MLI’s current traditional product costing system: a) Determine the company’s predetermined overhead rate using direct labour cost as the single cost driver. b) Determine the full product costs and selling prices for one kg. of Italian Roast and French Roast coffee. 2) Develop a new product cost, using an activity-based costing approach, for one kg. of Italian Roast and French Roast coffee. Compare the results with those in requirement 1. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 22 of 27 Problem 4 – Job Order Costing Avid Assemblers uses job-order costing to assign costs to products. The company assembles and packages 20 different products to customer specifications. Products are worked on in batches of 30 to 50 units. Each batch is assigned a job number. On October 1, the company had the following balances recorded. Direct Materials Work in process Finished goods $ 7,800 45,726 23,520 Work in process consisted of the following jobs: Job 202 Job 204 Job 205 Direct materials Direct labour Applied overhead $ 4,200 8,500 5,100 $ 3,190 7,210 4,326 $ 2,800 6,500 3,900 Total $17,800 $14,726 $13,200 30 50 35 Job 208 $1,200 2,910 40 Total $ 8,980 20,450 Number of units Finished goods consisted of job 203, with the following costs: Direct materials Direct labour Applied overhead $ 7,200 10,200 6,120 Total $23,520 Number of units 50 Shown below are the direct cost data related to jobs started in October: Direct materials Direct labour Number of units CMA Accelerated Program 2011 Job 206 $4,180 9,200 40 Job 207 $3,600 8,340 50 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 23 of 27 Other information: 1. Direct materials and direct labour added to beginning work in process in October were as follows: Direct materials Direct labour Job 202 $ 950 2,000 Job 204 $ 410 3,500 Job 205 $1,200 4,500 Total $ 2,560 10,000 2. Overhead is applied at a predetermined rate on the basis of direct labour cost. 3. Actual expenses for October were as follows: Supervisory salaries Factory rent Amortization (machines) Indirect labour Supplies (factory) Selling expenses CPP, El, and other benefits* $4,000 2,000 3,000 5,000 1,100 8,500 3,200 *80 percent of employer contributions and benefits relates to factory personnel. 4. Purchases of direct materials during October amounted to $8,500 5. Only Jobs 207 and 208 are still in process at closing on October 31. Finished goods consisted only of Job 205 at month end. 6. Avid writes off any over- or underapplied overhead to Cost of Goods Sold in the month it is incurred. Required: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. What is the predetermined overhead rate used by Avid to apply overhead to jobs? What is the unit cost of Job 204 ? What are the October 31 balances for the following inventory accounts? a. Direct Materials b. Work in Process c. Finished Goods What is the cost of goods manufactured in October? (You do not have to prepare a statement as part of this Requirement.) Determine the over- or underapplied overhead for October. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 24 of 27 Problem 14 - Service Department Allocations Jamieson Steel has two profit centres: Ingots and Stainless Steel. These profit centres rely on services provided by two service departments, electricity and water. Ingots’ and Stainless’ consumption of the service departments’ output (in millions) is given in the following table: Service Departments Service Departments Electricity Water Electricity 2,500 kwh 1,000 gal Water 2,500 kwh 800 gal Profit Centres Stainless Ingots Steel 2,500 kwh 2,500 kwh 1,600 gal 1,400 gal Total 10,000 kwh 4,800 gal The total operating costs of the two service departments are: Electricity Water $80 million 60 million $140 million Required Allocate the service department costs to the profit centres using… (a) the direct method (b) the step method (water first) (c) the step method (electricity first) (d) the reciprocal method Calculate the unit cost per kwh and gallon for each of the 4 methods. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 25 of 27 Accelerated Program Week 15 Suggested study plan for this week: Primary List Secondary List 1. Review what we did in class on Saturday. 2. Spoilage (ch 4) MCQ 7-8, Q9, Q10, Q5, Q6, Q7, Q8 Cost Behaviour (ch 5) MCQ, Q2, Q3, Q4 Q1, Q5, Q6 Activity Based Costing (ch 6) MCQ, Q2, Q3, Q5, Q4, Q1 3. 4. 5. Prepare in-class problems 12 and 13. These will be taken up in class on Saturday. 6. Prepare the Week 15 Quiz CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 26 of 27 Problem 12 – Process Costing For each of the following independent cases, determine the information requested. a. Beginning inventory amounted to 500 units. This period 2,250 units were started and completed. At the end of the period, the 1,500 units in inventory were 30 percent complete. Using FIFO costing, the equivalent production for the period was 2,800 units. What was the percentage of completion of the beginning inventory? b. The ending inventory included $8,700 for conversion costs. During the period, 4,200 equivalent units were required to complete the beginning inventory, and 6,000 units were started and completed. The ending inventory represented 1,000 equivalent units of work this period. FIFO costing is used. What were the total conversion costs incurred this period? c. In the beginning inventory, 1,000 units were 40 percent complete with respect to materials. During the period, 8,000 units were transferred out. Ending inventory consisted of 1,400 units that were 70 percent complete with respect to materials. How many units were started and completed during the period? Assume FIFO costing. d. At the start of the period, 8,000 units were in the work in process inventory and 6,000 units were in the ending inventory. During the period, 19,000 units were transferred out to the next department. Materials and conversion costs are added evenly throughout the production process. FIFO costing is used. How many units were started this period? e. In the beginning inventory 4,100 units were 40 percent complete with respect to conversion costs. During the period, 3,500 units were started. In the ending inventory, 3,250 units were 20 percent complete with respect to conversion costs. How many units were transferred out? Weighted average costing is used. f. The beginning inventory consisted of 4,000 units with a direct materials cost of $14,200. The equivalent work represented by all of the direct materials costs in the WIP Inventory account amounted to 18,000 units. There were 6,000 units in ending inventory that were 20 percent complete with respect to materials. The ending inventory had a direct materials cost assigned of $4,500. What was the total materials cost incurred this period? Weighted average costing is used. g. The WIP Inventory account had a beginning balance of $1,900 for conversion costs on items in process and during the period $18,100 in conversion costs were charged to it. Also during the period, $19,200 in costs were transferred out. There were 400 units in the beginning inventory, and 4,800 units were transferred out during the period. How many equivalent units are in the ending inventory? Weighted average costing is used. h. During the period, 1,050 units were transferred to the department. The 1,600 units transferred out were charged to the next department at an amount that included $3,360 for direct materials costs. The ending inventory was 25 percent complete with respect to direct materials and had a cost of $630 assigned to it. How many units are in the ending inventory? Weighted average costing is used. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011 Week 15 Lecture Student File 27 of 27 Problem 13 - Process Costing Richard Chemical Company manufactures a product that requires processing in two departments. All units from Department A are transferred to Department B. No additional materials are added in Department B. Conversion costs are added continuously throughout the process. The following data pertain to the operations of Department B for the month of July: Transferred from Department A during July: 12,000 units, Department A costs Conversion costs incurred during July $75,000 162,000 In process, July 1, 3,000 units, 60% complete: Department A costs Department B conversion costs $17,300 25,100 In process, July 31, 3,650 units, 80% complete. Units transferred out: 11,000 units Normal spoilage is equal to 2% of the good units transferred out. Spoilage is detected at 90% of the conversion process Required – Calculate the cost of goods manufactured and cost of abnormal spoilage assuming that the Richard Company uses (a) FIFO and (b) Weighted Average. CMA Accelerated Program 2011 © CMA Ontario, 2011