Redefining Energy Security in the 21st Century « Breaking Defense
Like
1.7k
Follow
http://breakingdefense.com/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-securi...
4,287 followers
Docs (http://breakingdefense.com/documents/)
Events (http://breakingdefense.com/events/)
About (http://breakingdefense.com/about/)
Advertise (http://breakingdefense.com/advertise/)
Send a Tip (mailto:tips@breakingdefense.com)
(http://oasc05134.247realmedia.com
/RealMedia/ads/click_lx.ads/BMEDdefense/government/L22/2099250192/Top1/BBN/BCN2013060122_003c_Pelican/Pelican_BBN_CPM_US_Law_728.html
/526256366146484a474f774142317642)
HOME (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/)
AIR (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/AIR/)
LAND (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/LAND/)
SEA (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/SEA/)
Follow »
CONGRESS (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/CONGRESS/)
INTEL & CYBER (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/INTEL-AND-CYBER/)
STRATEGY & POLICY (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/STRATEGY-AND-POLICY/)
Like
0
Share
0
Tweet
2
Share
Post a comment (http://breakingdefense.com/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-security-in-the-21st-century
/#respond)
CONGRESS (HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/CONGRESS/), STRATEGY & POLICY
(HTTP://BREAKINGDEFENSE.COM/CATEGORY/STRATEGY-AND-POLICY/)
Redefining Energy Security in the 21st
Century (http://breakingdefense.com
/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-securityin-the-21st-century/)
By COLIN CLARK (HTTP ://BREAKIN GD EFEN S E.COM /A UTH OR /COLINCLARK/) on June 24, 2013 at 5:25
PM
Tweets
Follow @BreakingDefense
Breaking Defense
15h
@BreakingDefense
RT @BlogsofWar: Opinion: Russians Fumble
Mistral Construction - flip.it/xnKk7
Show Summary
Breaking Defense
@BreakingDefense
15h
RT @PMCroninCNAS: flip.it/QYZHl ROK-Australia
move to institutionalize top-level 2+2 defenseforeign policy relationship
Show Summary
Sydney Freedberg
21 Jun
@SydneyFreedberg
This week: Paris Air Show #PAS13 bit.ly/11AyeaD
Sen Jeff Sessions bit.ly/11BLTzm & hacking the
F-35 bit.ly/14lyWvF
Retweeted by Breaking Defense
Expand
Sydney Freedberg
20 Jun
@SydneyFreedberg
Sen. Sessions distrusts Obama on everything from
nukes to taxes, but this am he gave a hint of a
sequester deal: bit.ly/11BLTzm
(http://breakingdefense.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2013/06/pentagon2.jpg)
Retweeted by Breaking Defense
Expand
The following commentary appeared in our sister publication, Breaking Energy
(http://breakingenergy.com/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-security-in-the-21st-century/).
While we don’t usually write about the Defense Department’s energy use (except when it’s a
Dr Hassan Rouhani
20 Jun
Tweet to @BreakingDefense
casus belli or a major budget item in aggregate) this piece addresses a fundamental issue of
American foreign and domestic policy: climate change and foreign sources of energy. The
1 of 5
EDITORIAL STAFF
6/24/2013 9:15 PM
Redefining Energy Security in the 21st Century « Breaking Defense
Editor.
http://breakingdefense.com/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-securi...
Colin Clark
Almost forty years ago, President Nixon exhorted the country: “By the year 1980, the United
States will not be dependent on any other country for the energy we need to provide our
jobs, to heat our homes, and to keep our transportation moving.” Today, more than 30 years
later, the United States may actually be on a course to meet this elusive goal. America is
experiencing a surge in energy production. The shale gas boom we see in places like
Pennsylvania and Oklahoma means that the U.S. now has more than a century of gas
(http://breakingdefense.com/author/colinclark/)
Editor
Sydney J. Freedberg, Jr.
(http://breakingdefense.com/author
/sydney-j-freedberg-jr/)
Deputy Editor
reserves. Similar technology has opened up oil fields in places like the Bakken field in North
Dakota and Eagle Ford in Texas. Last month, for the first time since 1995, the United States
produced more crude oil than it imported.
In the four decades since President Nixon’s statement, every Presidential administration has
identified “Energy Independence” as a critical goal. As we approach the elusive goal
however, we are learning that it may not actually deliver on the benefits promised. Oil
remains above $90 per barrel, and gasoline prices continue to hover near $4 per gallon. We
remain tethered to a global price of oil that is determined more by global demand and the
threat of conflict in the Middle East than by production in North Dakota. The Navy’s 5th fleet
remains based in the Persian Gulf and, among other duties, is protecting oil supply lines.
New challenges also reveal how the forty-year-old goal of “Energy Independence” needs
updating. The problems associated with energy insecurity in the 1970s are not those of today.
Climate change, caused largely by the burning of fossil fuels, is real and already affecting
America’s national security. The Pentagon and America’s intelligence community call climate
change a “threat multiplier” and an “accelerant of instability” around the world. This means
over the next several decades, a changing climate will impact access to water and food
(http://engine.adzerk.net
/r?e=eyJhdiI6MjQ0NjksImF0IjoxNjMsImNtIjozMzk5MywiY2giOjk1
s=SVzJ7LD_DzFeVhsj03eBsKEvvC0)
production systems worldwide, increasing the possibility of conflict. The American military will
be called to respond.
AEI's Veuger: IRS Held Tea Party Down in 2012
Elections (http://www.newsmax.com/Newswidget
Together, we three authors share a combined 95 years of experience in America’s military. In
our careers we saw how energy impacts everything America’s armed forces do. In the wars in
/tea-party-irs-election/2013/06/24/id
/511582?promo_code=13731-1&
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
Iraq and Afghanistan, our adversaries knew that the fuel convoy was a soft target – and many
utm_medium=nmwidget&
American lives were lost because of our energy dependence. At home, we saw how major
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
disasters like last year’s super-storm Sandy can knock out power and fuel and disable vast
Priest to Pelosi: Condemn Abortion or Renounce
stretches of the country.
Catholic Faith (http://www.newsmax.com
/Newswidget/Pavone-Pelosi-renounce-abortion
We also know that America’s dependence on oil entwines our foreign policy with regimes
/2013/06/24/id/511554?promo_code=13731-1&
hostile to American values, especially in the Middle East. Even if our production of oil here at
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
home equals our consumption, world markets will ensure that our politics and economic
utm_medium=nmwidget&
welfare stay intertwined.
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
IRS Chief: Screening Broader, Longer Than
All this combines to mean that America must redefine “Energy Security” in the 21st Century.
Energy Security no longer means that all energy produced at home is good, no matter how
Admitted (http://www.newsmax.com/newswidget
/US-IRS-Political-Groups/2013/06/24/id
/511588?promo_code=13731-1&
polluting it is. Instead of focusing on where energy comes from, our country needs an energy
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
policy that considers the real costs and benefits of our energy production and use. Increased
utm_medium=nmwidget&
investment in R&D for renewable energy sources and improvements are essential. We need
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
to realize that economic stability and environmental sustainability are as much a part of
Gandolfini Ignored 4 Signs of Heart Attack
energy security as the threats of supply shortages.
(http://w3.newsmax.com/newsletters/crandall
/video_ob2.cfm?promo_code=13731-1&
We should start by acknowledging climate change risks are real and growing every day. We
cannot afford to ignore them. Even if you choose not to believe that human activity
contributes to climate change, or even that the climate is changing, from our military
experience we know that waiting for certainty on the battlefield can be disastrous. Managing
2 of 5
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
utm_medium=nmwidget&
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
Do You Support Giving Illegals Citizenship? Vote
6/24/2013 9:15 PM
Redefining Energy Security in the 21st Century « Breaking Defense
http://breakingdefense.com/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-securi...
risk requires a prudent response, the first step of which is an energy debate that addresses
Here Now (http://www.newsmax.com/surveys
the challenges of the 21st Century, not one devised for the 1970s. The greatest dangers lie in
/ImmigrationPoll/Do-You-Support-Immigration-
our being unprepared. All of this argues for prudent, no regrets action now to reduce future
risk
Reform-/id/71/kw/default?promo_code=13731-1&
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
utm_medium=nmwidget&
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
The President has called on Congress to address climate change, and now we are told that
he will release a detailed plan tomorrow to move forward because they have not acted. As
Pelosi Booed Over Snowden Comments
(http://www.newsmax.com/newswidget/Pelosi-
the debate over this important proposal moves forward, we ask that all parties engage in a
Snowden-Booed-NSA/2013/06/22
rational, fact-based assessment that fully recognizes the breadth and depth of the risks of
/id/511353?promo_code=13731-1&
energy insecurity.
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
utm_medium=nmwidget&
Our energy system is fatally flawed: it is environmentally unsustainable, economically
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
unstable, and we know it endangers our national security. We need a new conversation
These 6 Things Make Your Arthritis Worse
about energy, one that addresses the challenges of the 21st Century, not the ones that
(http://w3.newsmax.com/newsletters/brownstein
seemed to loom in the 1970s. We should not be misled by achieving what’s called “Energy
/video_arthritis.cfm?promo_code=13731-1&
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
Independence” while creating and using energy in the old ways. Work with us instead on
utm_medium=nmwidget&
building an energy system that reduces risks to our economy, our environment, and our
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
national security.
Trump Iowa Visit Raises 2016 Speculation
(http://www.newsmax.com/newswidget/trump-
Vice Adm. Gunn, (ret.), Brig. Gen. Anderson, US Army (ret.), and Brigadier General Cheney, US
iowa-2016/2013/06/24/id
Marine Corps are affiliated with the American Security Project, a non-partisan think tank
/511512?promo_code=13731-1&
focused on studying issues of national security. They are participating in a panel discussion,
utm_source=13731Breaking_Media&
“Redefining US Energy Security for the 21st Century” on Tuesday, June 25 as a part of New
York Energy Week (http://nyenergyweek.com/).
utm_medium=nmwidget&
utm_campaign=widgetphase1)
What's This? (http://www.newsmax.com/widget/whatsThis)
Topics: biofuels (http://breakingdefense.com/tag/biofuels/), Breaking Energy
(http://breakingdefense.com/tag/breaking-energy/), CapitolHill (http://breakingdefense.com
/tag/capitolhill/), commentary (http://breakingdefense.com/tag/commentary/), NDAA2013
(http://breakingdefense.com/tag/ndaa2013/), op-ed (http://breakingdefense.com/tag/op-ed/)
Sign up and get Breaking Defense
news in your inbox.
Subscribe
Comments
3 of 5
6/24/2013 9:15 PM
Redefining Energy Security in the 21st Century « Breaking Defense
http://breakingdefense.com/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-securi...
What's this?
No Longer Unthinkable: Should US
Ready For ‘Limited’ /
Billionaire Tells Americans to Prepare
For "Financial Ruin"
DoD Sheds First Clear Light On AirSea
Battle: Warfare Unfettered
Kindergarten Teacher Lets Children
Touch and Taste Her Blood
Bipartisan Defense Experts Urge
Congress, Sec Def Hagel /
Secret to a Gorgeous Face: It's the
Eyebrows
Best Case For Sequester Is Still
Disaster, Top Experts Say
VIDEO: Like Nothing I've Ever Seen
Ever
0 comments
4 of 5
Best
Community
★
Share ⤤
0
⚙
6/24/2013 9:15 PM
Redefining Energy Security in the 21st Century « Breaking Defense
http://breakingdefense.com/2013/06/24/redefining-energy-securi...
OUR SITES
Copyright © 2013 Breaking Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Registration or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service (http://breakingdefense.com/terms-of-service/) and Privacy
Policy (http://breakingdefense.com/privacy-policy/).
5 of 5
6/24/2013 9:15 PM