DRAFT Higher Learning Commission Application for Change of Control Criterion 1: Mission: The institution’s mission is clear and articulated publicly; it guides the institution’s operations. 1. A. The institution’s mission is broadly understood within the institution and guides its operations. 1. The mission statement is developed through a process suited to the nature and culture of the institution and is adopted by the governing board. Purdue campuses are steeped in the land-grant tradition of serving the citizens of the State of Indiana with a focus on Learning, Discovery, and Engagement. Although this common focus serves as an organizational and cultural core, the campuses within the Purdue System have developed in different ways, serving different constituents and developing different academic programs which serve the needs of these constituents. The Draft Purdue System Plan explains this variation when it states that “Each campus in the Purdue System will be recognized and valued for its unique characteristics and contributions” and that “The administrative structure of the Purdue System will be designed in a way that respects the academic autonomy of the individual campuses.” (citation) While Purdue regional campuses create missions responding to common core values but reflective of unique characteristics, the campuses are also responsive to state expectations of regional campus missions. In 2013, the higher education policy group within the state, the Indiana Commission for Higher Education, set mission-level expectations concerning student profiles, educational responsibilities, graduate programming, geographic reach, and governance structures (The Indiana Commission for Higher Education’s “Policy on Regional Campus Roles and Missions.” October 10, 2013). (citation) It is important to understand this backdrop of historic, system and state expectations as Purdue Calumet (Hammond) and Purdue North Central (Westville) approached the task of developing a common mission for Purdue Northwest. Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet have clearly articulated mission statements1 found on their websites. As Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet move toward unification, a new mission has been crafted, drawing on the land grant mission, the Purdue System Plan, and the Indiana Commission for Higher Education, and also 1 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/?s=Mission 1 DRAFT DRAFT taking into account the unified institution’s new position. This new mission statement will need to be approved by the Purdue Board of Trustees. The new mission was created with input from students, staff, and faculty on both campuses and with input from members of the communities served. Sloan Management consultants convened three focus groups on both campuses in December 2014, with governance groups recommending attendees. Fifty five faculty, staff, and students attended. The process involved reviewing the current Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central Mission and Vision in advance of the meeting. During the meetings, participants were asked to review several draft mission and vision statements and then shared what worked about each statement and what meaning they derived from each. The reactions and improvements to the drafts were then compiled, with a final mission draft being shared with and determined by the Unification Committee. The new mission statement of Purdue University Northwest clearly incorporates ideas from the previous missions while propelling the new, larger institution into a stronger position within Northwest Indiana, the state, and beyond, a position based on a greater Purdue presence as a result of one inclusive and distinct institution rather than two, sometimes competing institutions; a larger geographic reach; and enhanced opportunities due to scale. 2 DRAFT DRAFT Mission: Purdue University Northwest, in the land grant tradition of learning, discovery and engagement, provides high quality, affordable undergraduate and graduate education to students of Northwest Indiana and beyond. We create a welcoming environment that promotes critical inquiry through experiential learning, faculty scholarship, civic engagement and community partnerships (2015) Vision Purdue University Northwest will be the institution of choice in Northwest Indiana and beyond as the center for education, innovation, economic development and culture. 2. The institution’s academic programs, student support services and enrollment profile are consistent with its stated mission. Current and planned academic programs, support for student success and enrollment profile are all encapsulated within the mission and vision statements. “High quality” in the mission statement refers to the world-renowned quality of a Purdue education, the well-developed academic programs, and the outstanding faculty and staff. “Affordable” speaks to the continued sensitivity to the high need of students seeking federal, state, and institutional support to make college graduation a reality with more than 40% of undergraduates at both institutions showing high financial need (defined through Title III institutional eligibility status). (citation) The costs of attendance at Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central are among the lowest for public baccalaureate granting universities in the state [citation needed] and will remain so through the transition to Purdue Northwest. “Graduate” education has been a focal point for Purdue Calumet expansion in the last ten years, and likely will continue to be expanded with the greater resources of Purdue Northwest. “Welcoming” is an important word choice, as 66% of students at Purdue Calumet and 64% of students at Purdue North Central are first-generation college students. (citation) Many students need a college environment that emphasizes extra guidance in learning about higher education, building a career rather than finding a job, developing resilience, and being successful. “Experiential learning,” defined at Purdue Calumet as encompassing the following: service learning, internships, cooperative education, cultural immersion, design projects, practica, and undergraduate research, will continue to be important in Purdue Northwest. Recommendations have been made on experiential learning for Purdue Northwest (citation). 3. The institution’s planning and budgeting priorities align with and support the mission The mission statement--developed by large numbers of faculty and staff during the last year as part of the strategic planning process--will guide strategic priorities for the future. More information concerning planning is provided under Criterion 5.C.1. Through the directive of the Purdue Board of Trustees, savings occurring through the unification (through merging administrative positions and functions, joint software and 3 DRAFT DRAFT other purchases, etc.) should be redirected toward support for students and academic quality. Ongoing planning processes currently focus on how student needs, and academic quality will be addressed in the future. More than a dozen unification committees conducted short and long-term planning including Academic Success (Retention and Advising); Center for Teaching, Learning and Technology; Experiential Learning; Honors; and Graduate Education. (citation) Criterion 1: Mission 1. B. The mission is articulated publicly. 1. The institution clearly articulates its mission through one or more public documents, such as statements of purpose, vision, values, goals, plans, or institutional priorities Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet currently post their mission statements, values and vision on their websites; after unification they will be posted at the Purdue Northwest website. The unification website (a public website)2 contains the PURDUE NORTHWEST mission and vision statements and the draft Strategic Plan for Purdue Northwest. 2. The mission document or documents are current and explain the extent of the institution’s emphasis on the various aspects of its mission, such as instruction, scholarship, research, application of research, creative works, clinical service, public service, economic development, and religious or cultural purpose. Mission and vision documents were developed during late fall 2014 and spring 2015 using focus groups, and by consulting students, faculty and staff, and community members. Sloan Management consultants facilitated this process through broad outreach efforts to over 250 constituents, with 55 individuals attending focus groups held on both campuses. The new mission and vision address Purdue Northwest’s place in the community, the scope of intended constituencies, and overall goals. The new mission and vision can be found on the unification website (citation). 3. The mission document or documents identify the nature, scope, and intended constituents of the higher education programs and services the institution provides. The new mission addresses the greater geographical scope of the combined campuses and renewed purpose to educate students in Northwest Indiana and beyond. The mission delineates Northwest Indiana as the primary region for recruitment for Purdue University Northwest with “beyond” signifying the reach to the northern part of Indiana, and international and out-of-state students seeking the quality, Purdue degree in a smaller, supportive campus environment. The nature of programs and services is 2 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/ 4 DRAFT DRAFT indicated by the focus on “critical inquiry through experiential learning, faculty scholarship, and civic engagement and community partnerships” (citation). Criterion 1: Mission 1. C. The institution understands the relationship between its mission and the diversity of society. 1. The institution addresses its role in a multicultural society. 2. The institution’s processes and activities reflect attention to human diversity as appropriate within its mission and for the constituencies it serves. Purdue Northwest remains committed to serving the regional and area community in which it resides. Northwest Indiana has a long-standing and growing multiculturalism as reflected in the student body. As such, the mission explicitly acknowledges the cultural and ethnic diversity of the northwest Indiana region and seeks to engage with society and focus attention on the community. 43% of the population in the far northwest county in Indiana (Lake) comes from underrepresented groups and approximately 5-16% in the other northern Indiana counties (citation). Both campuses emphasize community engagement as part of attention to human diversity and commitment to constituencies. More information is provided under Criterion 3.B.4. At Purdue North Central, service to diverse constituencies include the Multicultural Club, celebration of Hispanic Heritage Month, minors in Latin American Studies and Ethnic Studies, and faculty research that focuses on minorities. At Purdue Calumet, student organizations and student events reflect the wide range of constituencies served including the Black Student Union, the Brazilian Student Association, the Chinese Student Association, German Club, LGBTS Alliance, Los Latinos, Saudi Student Association, Spanish Club, and the French Club, The International Programs Office (IPO) offers a wide variety of activities each semester for Purdue Calumet students, both on and off campus. On-campus programs include: World on Wednesdays (WOW), International Coffee Corner, Language Circles, as well as other social and special seasonal events. In addition, IPO organizes weekly field trips to local destinations General education outcomes and academic program outcomes also reflect this emphasis, and both institutions seek to make their campuses centers of intellectual and cultural diversity. For example, the LaPorte County Martin Luther King Day breakfast has been held at Purdue North Central for twenty years. This very well attended event has included speakers such as the Tuskegee Airmen. Similarly, the Multicultural Campus Council at Purdue University Calumet supports a variety of cultural events and initiatives to support the emphasis on inclusivity. The emphasis on diversity and service will continue and be strengthened in Purdue Northwest. 5 DRAFT DRAFT Criterion 2: Integrity: Ethical and Responsible Conduct: The institution acts with integrity; its conduct is ethical and responsible. 2. A. The institution operates with integrity in its financial, academic, personnel, and auxiliary functions; it establishes and follows policies and processes for fair and ethical behavior on the part of its governing board, administration, faculty, and staff. Purdue Northwest will operate following Purdue System approved guidelines for ethical behavior. The system-wide Office of the Vice President for Ethics and Compliance oversees these policies, which are regularly reviewed and revised to ensure they are up to date and appropriate. (See Purdue System polities on Conduct, Conflicts, Equal Opportunity, etc.3) The Purdue System has many policies with regard to integrity in financial, academic, and personnel functions. New employees through orientation sessions receive information and university expectations concerning these policies: The University has many policies that support integrity: Protection against Reprisal for Good Faith Disclosures (Whistleblower Protection) (III.A.4) Research Misconduct, (III.A.2) Statement of Integrity and Code of Conduct Student Loan Code of Conduct (III.A.3) Conflicts of Commitments and Reportable Outside Activities Individual Financial Conflicts of Interest (III.B.2) Nepotism, University Policy Concerning (C-37) Political Activities (B-4) Anti-Harassment (III.C.1) Equal Opportunity, Equal Access and Affirmative Action (III.C.2) Nondiscrimination Statement Procedures for Resolving Complaints of Discrimination and Harassment Individual Financial Conflicts of Interest (III.B.2) Budgeting Campaign Expenses (II.B.1) Gift Acceptance (II.B.2) Intellectual Property (I.A.1) Research Misconduct, Policy on (III.A.2) Export Controls and OFAC Regulations (I.A.2) Conflicts of Commitment and Reportable Outside Activities (III.B.1) Purdue Northwest will also follow approved system guidelines regulating Academic and Research Affairs and Business and Finance. The Purdue System has a robust Internal Audit program4 These policies are regularly reviewed and updated as needed. 3 http://www.purdue.edu/policies/ 4 http://www.purdue.edu/ia/ 6 DRAFT DRAFT Criterion 2: Integrity: Ethical and Responsible Conduct 2. B. The institution presents itself clearly and completely to its students and to the public with regard to its programs, requirements, faculty and staff, costs to students, control, and accreditation relationships. Extensive information has been provided to the public on unification, including: · · · · 14 news releases issued jointly by the campuses5, Feb. 2014-May 2015 Chancellors’ joint appearance on Lakeshore Focus television program6 on Lakeshore Public Media, Nov. 26, 2014 Chancellors’ OpEd article7 which appeared in a wide variety of northwest Indiana print and online news media, Various radio programs on WJOB (Hammond), WEFM (Michigan City) and WCOE (LaPorte) providing periodic updates on the unification process There has also been considerable outreach to alumni and the community, including: · · · · · · · · · E-blast to alumni of both campuses providing information about unification – beginning Feb. 26, 2014, at announcement of unification, and continuing. Alumni were included in surveys for naming process, mascot process, and will be asked to give input to PNW website development E-blast to key community members of both campuses providing information about unification – beginning Feb. 26, 2014, at announcement of unification, and continuing. Community members were included in surveys for naming process, mascot process, and will be asked to give input to PNW website development PNC Advisory Board – update on unification at the four meetings held throughout the academic year Purdue Calumet Chancellor’s Advisory Board – update on unification at the meetings held throughout the year Purdue Calumet UpWord magazine – Summer 2014 and Summer 2015 – circulation approximately 30,000 alumni and friends of the university. Both issues include information/updates about unification. PNC Chancellor’s Society Newsletter – brief monthly letters sent to PNC donors to recap significant activities. Unification activities have been included in six issues since March 2014. Both Chancellors, senior leaders, deans, admissions staff, media spokespersons, have been asked to speak about or answer questions about the unification frequently from March 2014-May 2015 at community events, college fairs, etc. 5 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/news/ 6 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/chancellors-on-lakeshore-focus/ 7 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/unified-institution-name-op-ed/ 7 DRAFT DRAFT Purdue Northwest will revise and update all marketing and information materials and venues, including its website and catalog, to represent itself clearly to students and the general public. Purdue Northwest is aligning admission requirements as well as costs. Over the next five years, the various accreditation relationships will be reviewed and revisited by the relevant faculty who will work with the proper agencies to maintain their status as accredited programs. As part of this emphasis on transparency, the Unification Website has tracked all aspects of unification, including the posting of the Higher Learning Commission application as well as detailed information on unification committees. The Website also contains the history and content of many information sessions about unification and the impact on faculty, staff and students. See Unification Website8 Currently both Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central use a variety of communication means to present the campuses to its students and to the public. Source of Communication Prospective or Current Students Method Intent Campus tours Prospective students and families Meet with Purdue Calumet student ambassadors or Purdue North Central student guides who provide tours. Emphasis on tour is support available to students (tutoring, Supplemental Instruction, student activities, financial aid, etc.) Provide high school and transfer students and families with opportunity to ask questions about the university to a current student. Provide tour groups with opportunities to visit selected academic areas of interest. Host IACAC Authorized Regional College Fair Prospective students and families Cohost with local high schools an annual state sanctioned college fair for prospective students and family members. Offer financial aid information sessions and participating college information about enrollment process/campus life. College Goal Sunday Prospective and Current students and families (and to public) Provide one-to-one assistance to students and families on completion of the FAFSA form prior to March deadline. Outreach to low-income students and families on step by-step completion of financial aid application. Provide indepth responses on financial aid process and outcome. Prospective transfer students Meet with prospective transfer students to discuss the transferability of courses, applicability to a major, program articulations, financial assistance and admissions requirements. Provide community college advisors and prospective students information about transferability of courses and the admissions process Transfer Fairs Community College Visits 8 Provide local high schools and their students an opportunity to participate in a larger college fair to attract a greater variety of colleges/universities. http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/ 8 DRAFT DRAFT Source of Communication Prospective or Current Students Method Intent Website Prospective and current students and families Provide current information on programs, courses, accreditation, control, cost, financial aid, Strategic Plans of both campuses. Provide current and critical information about our campus to prospective and current students and the public. Catalog Prospective and Current students and families (and public) Provide current information on programs, courses, accreditation, control, and cost. Provide current and critical information about our campus to prospective and current students and the public. Orientation/ Registration Prospective and current students and families Course Syllabus Current students Academic Advising Open Houses and Receptions Net Price Calculator Provide academic success information for students of all majors. Demonstrate use of Degree Works to empower students to track progress toward degree. Provide in-depth financial aid information. Academic advisors work with students to complete registration. Syllabus template shows student learning objectives, faculty contact information, course requirements, assignments, grading policies, ADA policy, and emergency procedures. Transition students into academic programs through initial meeting with academic advisors. Provide tours for students and families. Communication of student learning objectives and course requirements. Current students Advisors work one-on-one with students on academic planning, course adjustments, referral to other university resources. Advisors guide students in academic planning and effective course scheduling. Prospective students and families Faculty and staff meet with prospective students and families and provide important information on support services to students. Provide information to those students undecided about majors and planning majors. Provide opportunity for students to meet faculty and staff. Prospective students and families The Net Price Calculator helps families plan for educational costs at Purdue University Calumet/North Central. By entering the required information, families can use this tool to receive a financial aid package that includes an estimated Purdue University Calumet/North Central “net price” figure (estimated costs less anticipated need-based scholarship & grant aid). Provide the prospective student with an estimate of the cost of attending university, and the student financial aid resources available to off-set the costs. 9 DRAFT DRAFT Source of Communication View Books and Other College Recruitment Publications Prospective or Current Students Prospective students and families Method Intent The View Books (and other recruitment materials) are shared with prospective students and families to introduce the university and its programs. While these view books have traditionally been written publications mailed to students’ homes, digital and custom versions are now being explored. Introduce the university, its programs, students, faculty and services, to recruit for enrollment Intent: Introduce the university, its programs, students, faculty and services, to recruit for enrollment. K-12 School Counselors’ Workshops For public guidance counselors in K-12 The university hosts counselor workshops that allow for professional development opportunities as well as the sharing of information on the programs and support services available to the college students on campus Preadmissions Counseling Appointments Prospective students and families Admissions staff meets with prospective students and families for one-to-one assistance related to admissions/enrollment process. Provide the counselors with information and materials to share and use with the prospective college students they serve in their respective schools. Provide personalized one-toone appointments to assist first generation and non-first generation students with critical enrollment information Criterion 2: Integrity: Ethical and Responsible Conduct 2. C. The governing board of the institution is sufficiently autonomous to make decisions in the best interest of the institution and to assure its integrity. 1. The governing board’s deliberations reflect priorities to preserve and enhance the institution. 2. The governing board reviews and considers the reasonable and relevant interests of the institution’s internal and external constituencies during its decision-making deliberations. 3. The governing board preserves its independence from undue influence on the part of donors, elected officials, ownership interests, or other external parties when such influence would not be in the best interest of the institution. 4. The governing board delegates day-to-day management of the institution to the administration and expects the faculty to oversee academic matters. The policies of the Purdue Board of Trustees (BOT), as established by the State of Indiana, ensure the autonomy of the board and acknowledge the Board’s ability to 10 DRAFT DRAFT manage all universities within the Purdue system. The BOT website includes information related to conflicts of interest, which helps to guarantee the independence of the board from outside influence. The BOT will provide oversight for Purdue Northwest but will expect the administration and faculty to manage the day-to-day operations of the university and the curriculum. Delegation of authority is clearly outlined in Purdue System policy. The Purdue University Board of Trustees maintains a website with detailed information on its bylaws. The excerpt below provides specific role definition for individual trustees and for the board as a whole in response to HLC Criterion 2C and its sub-parts. (See Board of Trustees Bylaws9) APPENDIX A: Trustee Code of Conduct 1. A Trustee shall devote time, thought, and study to his or her duties as a member of the Board of Trustees of The Trustees of Purdue University. 2. A Trustee shall learn how Purdue University functions — its uniqueness, strength, and needs —and its place in post-secondary education. 3. A Trustee shall carefully prepare for, regularly attend, and actively participate in the Board meetings and committee assignments. 4. A Trustee shall accept and abide by the legal and fiscal responsibilities of the Board as specified in federal and state law, the regulations, rules of procedure, policies, and resolutions of the Board of Trustees, and the University Statement of Integrity and Code of Conduct. 5. A Trustee shall base his or her vote upon all information available in each situation and shall exercise his or her best judgment in making decisions which affect the course of Purdue University. 6. A Trustee shall vote according to his or her individual conviction, and may challenge the judgment of others when necessary; yet a Trustee shall be willing to support the majority decision of the Board and work with fellow Board members in a spirit of cooperation. 7. A Trustee shall maintain the confidential nature of Board deliberations in executive sessions. This includes written and verbal communication concerning the executive sessions. The Chairman shall serve as the 9 http://www.purdue.edu/bot/about/bylaws.html 11 DRAFT DRAFT spokesperson for the Board. Other Trustees shall avoid acting as spokesperson for the Board unless specifically authorized to do so. 8. A Trustee shall understand the role of the Board as a policy making and oversight body and avoid active involvement in administration of that policy unless specifically authorized to do so by the Board. 9. A Trustee shall learn and consistently use designated institutional channels when conducting Board business (e.g., responding to faculty and student grievances, responding to inquiries concerning the status of a presidential search). 10. A Trustee shall comply with conflict of interest policies and requirements prescribed in the Bylaws and under state law. A Trustee shall refrain from accepting duties, incurring obligations, accepting gifts or favors, engaging in private business or professional activities when there is, or would appear to be, a conflict or incompatibility between the Trustee's private interests and the interests of Purdue University. 11. A Trustee shall refrain from actions and involvements that may prove embarrassing to Purdue University. 12. A Trustee shall act and make judgments always on the basis of what is best for Purdue University as a whole and for the advancement of higher education in general Procedure for Responding to Breaches of the Code of Conduct 1. Should evidence or allegations of Code of Conduct violations by a Trustee of The Trustees of Purdue University come to the attention of the Chairman of the Board, which after further review by the Chairman appears to constitute a breach of the Code of Conduct, the Chairman and the Vice Chairmen shall discuss the matter with the Trustee to obtain additional facts and perspective and to seek a mutually agreeable resolution. 2. Should the Code continue to be violated by the Trustee after discussion with the Chairmen and the Vice Chairman, the Chairman shall bring information on the violation forward to the Board of Trustees in executive session. Should the Code thereafter continue to be violated, the Chairman, after appropriate consultation, will place the matter on the agenda for appropriate action by the Board of Trustees. The Board shall discuss the matter in open session, allowing the Trustee whose conduct is at issue to provide an explanation of the conduct. The Board may then by majority vote censure the Trustee. 12 DRAFT DRAFT 3. Should the Board censure the Trustee, formal notification of the censure shall be communicated to the Governor, and to any separate recommendatory or appointive authority of the Trustee, e.g., the Office of the Dean of Students or the Purdue Alumni Association. Criterion 2: Integrity: Ethical and Responsible Conduct 2. D. The institution is committed to freedom of expression and the pursuit of truth in teaching and learning. The Purdue University system-wide policy on Academic Freedom states, “A faculty member shall have full freedom as a researcher, scholar, or artist.” In addition, a faculty member “shall have freedom in the classroom in discussing his/her subject.” (See Purdue Policies10. The Purdue University Board of Trustees recently passed an additional policy emphasizing the freedom of expression within an academic institution11. The revised Purdue System promotion and tenure policy states: “Tenure helps to ensure academic freedom and should promote creative, innovative pursuits.” Students also are assured freedom of expression and support in the pursuit of truth. The Purdue University Bill of Student Rights,12 states that The student shall be free to discuss and express any view relevant to subject matter presented by the instructor or other class members…Within the limitations generally accepted for proprietary and collaborative work, and those imposed by the relevant standards of academic honesty, the student has the right to freedom of inquiry, to exchange findings and recommendations, and consistent with applicable University regulations, to publish. Criterion 2: Integrity: Ethical and Responsible Conduct 2. E. The institution’s policies and procedures call for responsible acquisition, discovery and application of knowledge by its faculty, students, and staff. 1. The institution provides effective oversight and support services to ensure the integrity of research and scholarly practice conducted by its faculty and staff. Purdue Northwest is guided in its research by policies established by the Purdue System including those on academic responsibility. There is an Institutional Review Board that addresses questions about the use of human research subjects and a 10 http://www.purdue.edu/policies/human-resources/b-48.html 11 http://www.purdue.edu/purdue/about/free-speech.html 12 http://www.purdue.edu/studentregulations/student_conduct/studentrights.html 13 DRAFT DRAFT Purdue University Animal Care and Use Committee that addresses questions of animal research. The Joint Office of Research and Graduate Studies at Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central processes proposals and administer grants; supports undergraduate, graduate and faculty research; assists in development of multi-disciplinary research teams and programs; and works with the research board to provide internal faculty grants. 2. Students are offered guidance in the ethical use of information resources. At Purdue Calumet, librarians frequently address classes about the ethical use of information resources, including speaking to the majority of freshmen in the freshmen seminars. Librarians provide this information to students through approximately 150 class sessions a semester. At Purdue North Central, this delivery of information on the ethical use of information resources will be increased from 30 sessions to 50 sessions per semester. 3. The institution has and enforces policies on academic honesty and integrity. Both Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central have and enforce policies on academic honesty and integrity. Purdue Northwest will develop processes, as part of Purdue System policy, on academic honesty and integrity. Purdue academic regulations are undergoing review at present. The Vice Chancellors for Academic Affairs have talked with Purdue legal counsel and the Vice President for Ethics and Compliance about revision of academic regulations, including academic honesty and integrity. It is expected that revision will begin during the 2015-16 academic year. Criterion 3: Teaching and Learning: Quality, Resources, and Support: The institution provides high quality education, wherever and however its offerings are delivered. 3A: The institution’s degree programs are appropriate to higher education. 1. Courses and programs are current and require levels of performance by students appropriate to the degree or certificate awarded. Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet employ a variety of methods to ensure the currency of courses and programs, and that students earning degrees and certificates perform at appropriate levels. External bodies accredit many programs on both campuses, and both campuses have regular program reviews. Both institutions have taken steps to ensure that all modes of delivery maintain consistency and quality as compared with traditional modes. Both institutions work closely with local employers, alumni, the Purdue system, the Higher Learning Commission, and the Indiana Commission for Higher Education to ensure that programs are of high quality and are 14 DRAFT DRAFT appropriate to state, regional, and national aims for higher education. Purdue Northwest will continue and expand these efforts. Faculty members review curricula and programs, with a second level of review for graduate courses through the Graduate Council for the Purdue system, to determine appropriateness of curricula and programs to higher education disciplines. New programs are reviewed and must be approved by the provost and president of Purdue and the Purdue Board of Trustees, and additionally at the state level by the Indiana Commission for Higher Education. At both institutions, faculty within the academic units, many times working in concert with employer and alumni-based advisory councils and responding to feedback from external review teams of peers, create and review program objectives and course objectives appropriate to the degree awarded. Ongoing curriculum review takes place through the work of faculty-based curriculum committees that regularly review courses and programs at the program, department, school, and the university levels. Program goals and student performance in meeting these goals are addressed as part of this ongoing faculty review. All of these efforts will be continued in Purdue Northwest. During the past fifteen years, the Indiana Commission for Higher Education has led a number of statewide curriculum processes. Faculty from Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central have been involved in all three curriculum review initiatives (Core Transfer Library, General Education Core, and Transfer Single Articulation Pathway). In creating the Core Transfer Library (CTL), discipline-based panels of faculty members reviewed curricula across public higher education institutions, and eighty-five courses were deemed equivalent to create the CTL. Students rely on the CTL to transfer credits between state institutions. Both institutions also participated in the creation of Indiana’s Statewide Transfer General Education Core, and aligned their existing general education outcomes with those adopted by the state for this 30-credit core of general education courses. Due to this extensive curriculum review process, students can transfer a block of 30 credit hours across the state to apply toward the general education requirements at any state institution. Information about course transfer is available on the Indiana Commission for Higher Education website13, the Purdue North Central website14 and the Purdue Calumet website15 Additional statewide curriculum discussions have taken place more recently, assuring students of ease of transfer between their associate degrees and selected completion of programs at baccalaureate institutions (Transfer Single Articulation Pathway or TSAP). The TSAP review of curricula in particular addresses the issue of level of performance 13 http://www.in.gov/che/3138.htm 14 https://www.pnc.edu/registrar/core-transfer-library/ 15 http://webs.purduecal.edu/admissions/counselorsadvisors/ 15 DRAFT DRAFT at the completion of an associate degree and the expected higher level of performance at the baccalaureate level. More information is available online16. 2. The institution articulates and differentiates learning goals for its undergraduate, graduate, post-baccalaureate, post-graduate, and certificate programs. At both institutions, academic programs articulate learning goals for the different program levels that are specific to level and discipline. Externally accredited departments meet accreditation standards that are reviewed through periodic selfstudies and external review teams. Programs that do not have accreditation also undergo a formal program review which involves a comprehensive self-study and an internal and (in the case of Purdue Calumet) external peer review process. In this process, there are two sets of peers: in the internal process, peers represent other disciplines at the university; in the external reviews conducted at Purdue Calumet, discipline-specific experts provide input into program objectives and learning goals. Purdue Northwest will have program review with internal and external reviewers. Both institutions also have adopted goals that align with Indiana’s Statewide General Education Core competencies for general education in all bachelor’s degree programs, and, in the case of Purdue North Central, the Association of American Colleges and University’s Essential Learning Outcomes. Discussions are underway to align the general education outcomes and assessment procedures between the two institutions. The Purdue University Graduate School (GS) assures that learning goals for graduate courses and programs are appropriate and distinct from undergraduate learning goals. The Graduate School for the Purdue System sets policies and requirements for all campuses in the system. It has a robust set of policies, guidelines and requirements for assuring that post-baccalaureate study at the graduate level meets minimum requirements that clearly differentiate graduate study from undergraduate study. These policies and requirements can be found online17. Learning outcomes are required for approval of new graduate degree proposals, and are reviewed by the Graduate Council, the Graduate School (GS), and ICHE. In addition, every proposal for graduate curriculum (courses) must demonstrate the following: a) the use of primary literature in conjunction with advanced secondary sources (i.e., advanced textbooks); b) assessments that demonstrate synthesis of concepts and ideas by students; c) demonstrations that topics are current, and; d) components that emphasize research approaches/methods or discovery efforts in the course content area (reading the research, critiquing articles, proposing research, performing research). (Grad Policies and Procedures Manual, Section I, p. 15). This section delineates the requirements for the first level of graduate courses (50000-level). 16 http://www.in.gov/che/files/PPt._TSAP.pdf 17 www.purdue.edu/gradschool/. 16 DRAFT DRAFT Additional requirements are set forth for levels 60000-80000. All new graduate course proposals are reviewed by the Graduate Council for the Purdue system. Graduate School Policies and Procedures Manual18. The GS also requires outcomes for certificate proposals (graduate and postbaccalaureate), concentration proposals, etc. These requests are reviewed either by the Graduate School administration or the Graduate Council (as may be required) to assure that graduate standards are met. The GS also strongly encourages graduate program review (internal and external) approximately every 5 years. In addition, graduate programs that are accredited at the program level are also reviewed by their accrediting bodies (MBA; Education; Marriage and Family Therapy concentration of CDFS and Nursing). Additional sources: · · Graduate Certificate Guidelines19 Concentration Guidelines20 3. The institution’s program quality and learning goals are consistent across all modes of delivery and all locations (on the main campus, at additional locations, by distance delivery, as dual credit, through contractual or consortial arrangements, or any other modality) There are many ways that Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central promote consistency across all modes of delivery and at all locations. Both campuses have always been part of the Purdue System, which has several mechanisms to promote consistent program quality and learning goals, including the use of a system-wide course creation or revision form21 through which all Purdue campuses approve courses. All new programs must be approved by the Purdue Provost’s office and the Board of Trustees. New graduate programs must be approved by the Purdue Graduate School. All baccalaureate and associate degrees will need to be updated with the unified general education core, which has been approved by both faculty senates, with the implementation date of fall semester 2016. Over the next several months, course equivalency review will take place for courses with the same subject/same course number and different content or prerequisites and courses with a different subject/course number that are equivalent. Other ways to assure consistency are 18 https://www.purdue.edu/gradschool/documents/Graduate_School_Policies_and_Procedures_Manual.pdf 19 https://www.purdue.edu/gradschool/documents/gpo/Appendix-E-N-Graduate-Certificate-Guidelines.pdf 20 https://www.purdue.edu/gradschool/documents/gpo/Concentration_Guidelines.pdf 21 http://www.purdue.edu/registrar/documents/forms/Form40_UGwInstruct.pdf 17 DRAFT DRAFT unified program admission requirements, which will be completed during fall 2015, and unified program review and assessment. Both online and dual credit are integrated into the academic programs, promoting consistency across all modes of delivery and all locations. At both institutions, the majority of faculty have participated in a professional development program certifying their effectiveness in using technology to facilitate learning, including a focus on online teaching (using Quality Matters as a standard for certification). Through this certification, faculty members have developed best practices for online courses (and more recently, hybrid or technology-enhanced courses) and have had them reviewed by other faculty with expertise in instructional design. This will continue in Purdue Northwest. Many steps have been taken to assure quality and consistency in dual credit courses, including university faculty reviewing syllabi and overseeing instruction. At Purdue University Calumet, permanent faculty review dual credit syllabi to ensure they are identical to those courses taught on campus, oversee instruction, and assess student learning through blind reviews of high school students' assignments in comparison with assignments of students being taught on campus. Purdue North Central is one of 92 institutions nationally accredited by the National Association of Concurrent Enrollment Partnerships (NACEP)22, which requires evidence that dual credit “students are held to the same standards of achievement as those expected of students in on campus sections”. Institutional Research at Purdue North Central provides data on the performance of students who enter with dual credit. The results demonstrate that students who attend Purdue North Central and bring dual credit with them do very well. For example, fall-tofall persistence rates are higher for students with dual credit entering the university: 73% persistence rate for cohort students with a high school GPA of 3.0 or better who brought dual credit compared with 61% for cohort students with a high school GPA of 3.0 or better who did not bring in dual credit (citation). A committee is working on unifying the dual credit program based on best practices. In Purdue Northwest these efforts will continue to ensure and enhance quality wherever offerings are delivered. Criterion 3: Teaching and Learning: Quality, Resources, and Support 3. B. The institution demonstrates that the exercise of intellectual inquiry and the acquisition, application, and integration of broad learning and skills are integral to its educational programs. 22 http://nacep.org/docs/standards/NACEP-Standards-2011-and-Required-Evidence.pdf 18 DRAFT DRAFT 1. The general education program is appropriate to the mission, educational offerings, and degree levels of the institution. 2. The institution articulates the purposes, content, and intended learning outcomes of its undergraduate general education requirements. The program of general education is grounded in a philosophy or framework developed by the institution or adopted from an established framework. It imparts broad knowledge and intellectual concepts to students and develops skills and attitudes that the institution believes every college-educated person should possess. Purdue Calumet and North Central recognize the importance of broad learning across all disciplines and programs, and of those skills that benefit students no matter what their specific area of specialization. Both institutions have followed national and state conversations on this matter closely, attempting to keep their general education programs abreast of best practices, while also preserving the land-grant tradition of Purdue. The faculty senates from both institutions are working to create a unified general education program. Both institutions have general education programs that are integrated into their missions, and are appropriate to the land-grant mission of Purdue as a whole. Purdue Calumet developed a set of learning competencies internally, based on national best practices; Purdue North Central adopted the Association of American Colleges and Universities’ Essential Learning Outcomes. Both institutions were involved in the development of Indiana’s Statewide Transfer General Education Core and its associated competencies, and have mapped their existing general education programs to those competencies. Faculty from both campuses are working to align general education programs for Purdue Northwest, including a core of required courses and course categories, common outcomes, and a unified and enhanced set of assessment procedures. Faculty involved in this process have attended national conferences on general education and assessment, reviewed professional literature, and consulted with nationally recognized experts. In April of 2015, the first phase of this process was completed with the adoption by both faculty senates of required core courses and course categories. 3. Every degree program offered by the institution engages students in collecting, analyzing, and communicating information; in mastering modes of inquiry or creative work; and in developing skills adaptable to changing environments. General education programs on both campuses emphasize oral and written communication, both in terms of specific coursework and as a broad outcome. Information literacy is taught at all levels of the curriculum, from required first-year experience, writing, and communication courses, up through capstone courses. Firstyear experience courses and courses in composition and communication involve significant information literacy work, giving students tutorials in library resources and research techniques applicable to all disciplines. General education learning outcomes 19 DRAFT DRAFT on both campuses also emphasize facility in multiple modes of inquiry, and intellectual adaptability. Academic program objectives, overseen by faculty governance structures and program review processes, ensure that these areas of learning are developed throughout each program. General education assessment processes require faculty to demonstrate how general education courses fulfill learning outcomes; broad-based measures, including NSSE and the Multi-State Collaborative to Advance Learning Outcomes Assessment, examine student progress more broadly. The proposed new Office of Institutional Effectiveness will aid in continuing and assisting with integration of these measures of general education, and facilitate action and improvement in Purdue Northwest. 4. The education offered by the institution recognizes the human and cultural diversity of the world in which students live and work. As is reflected in current mission statements and the future mission statement of Purdue Northwest, both Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet are strongly responsive to the diversity of communities in which they reside. Both also work to enhance the diversity of educational and cultural experience of students. Forty-three percent of the population in the far northwest county in Indiana (Lake) come from underrepresented groups and approximately 5-16% come from underrepresented groups in the other northern Indiana counties. As campuses that serve a heavily urbanized core (Purdue Calumet) and a suburbanrural mix (Purdue North Central), both campuses emphasize community based learning. Purdue Calumet’s experiential learning degree requirement involves 189 courses through which students do service learning in local nonprofit organizations, work for companies as interns, support area companies with design projects and undergraduate research; and engage in cultural immersion opportunities involving study abroad as well as study within different cultural contexts. Analysis of these courses in 2013 showed that 80% of these experiences were in upper division courses. To broaden these opportunities to freshmen, English faculty now require all 100-level English composition courses to offer community-based writing projects to local, nonprofit organizations. Other examples of experiential learning include the following: construction majors conduct housing audits for the City of Hammond; civil engineering majors work with the Corps of Engineers in flood abatement design work, nursing majors provide health fairs and screenings to high need populations; business majors develop their own leadership philosophy through projects with heads of social service organizations. In 2013, the Dean and the College of Nursing received the 2013 Award of Merit from the Indiana Hospital Association in recognition of the contribution that faculty and students made to patient safety through collaborative projects with local healthcare organizations and the Indiana Patient Safety Center. 20 DRAFT DRAFT Purdue North Central has earned widespread state and national recognition for community engagement, including the Carnegie Foundation community engagement classification in 2010 and 2015. Purdue North Central also has been named to the President’s Higher Education Community Service Honor Roll several times. In 2014 Purdue North Central was named with Distinction as well as on the Education Community Service Honor Roll. The Honor Roll recognizes institutions of higher education that support exemplary community service programs and raise the visibility of effective practices in campus community partnerships. It is the highest federal recognition an institution can receive for its commitment to community, service learning, and civic engagement efforts. Purdue North Central has also received numerous awards from Indiana Campus Compact, including, most recently, the 2015 Brian Douglas Hiltunen Faculty Award for the Outstanding Contribution to the Scholarship of Engagement. This award is given to one faculty member across the state of Indiana. An example of a community partnership that serves very diverse communities is dual credit. Many of the schools that Purdue North Central serves have a large percentage of minority students. For example, 98% of East Chicago students and 49% of Michigan City students are minority (citation). Purdue North Central is committed to dual credit as an important way to better prepare underrepresented minority students for success in college and as an important component of community engagement. General education outcomes and academic program outcomes also reflect this emphasis, and both institutions seek to make their campuses centers of intellectual and cultural diversity. The emphasis on diversity and service will continue in Purdue Northwest. 5. The faculty and students contribute to scholarship, creative work, and the discovery of knowledge to the extent appropriate to their programs and the institution’s mission. As the mission states, Purdue Northwest will promote faculty scholarship. The joint Office of Research and Graduate Studies at both Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central supports faculty in proposal writing and administering grants; supports undergraduate, graduate and faculty research; assists in development of multidisciplinary research teams and programs; and works with the research board to provide internal faculty grants [http://webs.purduecal.edu/orgs/]. Both institutions seek to involve students as much as possible in research and discovery. Students at both institutions are members of research teams in laboratories, work as research assistants, and collaborate with faculty and other students in a wide variety of creative and scholarly projects. The emphasis on student research will continue and increase at Purdue Northwest. Examples of the types of student research are provided below. 21 DRAFT DRAFT At Purdue Calumet, undergraduate research has been defined by the Faculty Senate (2007) as a scholastic or artistic activity that leads to the production of new knowledge. Students engaged in undergraduate research work closely with faculty on industrysupported projects, in University Centers (for example, on projects in Energy, Water, Visualization), and on research teams in laboratories. The campus celebrates this student engagement in discovery of knowledge through multiple showcases for student research through which students present on their work to faculty members and sponsors. More than 300 students from all colleges presented at the April 2015 Student Research Day, with 195 projects representing the work of 240 undergraduate and 89 graduate students. In addition, the Clement S. Stacy Memorial Undergraduate Research Conference is held annually to being students and mentors together from universities and colleges through the upper Midwest for presentations and discussions. At Purdue North Central, faculty and students can apply for collaborative research grants during the academic year, and students can apply for grants to fund work with faculty during the summer months. In addition, undergraduate research is supported at the college and departmental level (for example, in Biology, students work in faculty labs and in Psychology where students work with faculty in the Behavioral Sciences Lab). The Honors program also encourages and funds students to work with faculty on specific research projects. Students present this research at a variety of venues including the Honors Expo at Purdue North Central, Purdue Calumet Student Research Day, the Butler Undergraduate Research Conference, and the National Collegiate Honors Council. Criterion 3: Teaching and Learning: Quality, Resources, and Support 3. C. The institution has the faculty and staff needed for effective, high-quality programs and student services. 1. The institution has sufficient numbers and continuity of faculty members to carry out both the classroom and the non-classroom roles of faculty, including oversight of the curriculum and expectations for student performance; establishment of academic credentials for instructional staff; involvement in assessment of student learning. Both Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet have procedures to assure that faculty and staff are hired and retained in order to maintain high quality in academic programs and student services. Faculty continuity is high on both campuses, with many faculty teaching for 30 or more years. Both institutions have well-developed tenure and promotion processes that promote quality faculty teaching, research, and service to the university. In addition, faculty submit an annual report of their work and activities in these three areas. Faculty oversee the curriculum through program, college, and university curriculum committees, with final oversight provided by the Faculty Senates. Faculty are involved in search committees for new full-time faculty, as well as hiring of limited-term instructors 22 DRAFT DRAFT and approval of dual credit instructors. With large service courses, faculty establish common syllabi and oversee the teaching of continuing and limited-term lecturers. When positions are created, the credentials are identified based on the needs of the discipline in academic departments. Academic departments and tenure-track and tenured faculty set program objectives and course objectives and conduct assessment. Oversight for general education assessment is conducted by faculty members at the Faculty Senate level, with the master teacher/course coordinator providing evidence of course assessment. All of these processes will continue in Purdue Northwest. 2. All instructors are appropriately qualified, including those in dual credit, contractual, and consortial programs. Faculty credentials are kept within the Office of Academic Affairs, and Human Resources keeps academic transcripts. The hiring academic department establishes credentials. Search committees are utilized for the entire hiring process for faculty. HR and the Director of Affirmative Action or Assistant Director of OIE & Training provide guidance to the search process. Search committees send recommendations to Department Chairs/Heads and Deans who make the final hiring decisions. Performance expectations are reinforced throughout the process. On both campuses, the Vice Chancellors for Academic Affairs reinforce expectations through the offer letter to faculty. Both institutions have also taken steps to ensure appropriate qualifications of dual credit instructors. Dual credit instructors have many opportunities for professional development, including day-long workshops and materials available on Blackboard. As part of its commitment to appropriately qualified faculty, Purdue North Central recently received funding from the Indiana Commission for Higher Education to develop several supports for instructors: graduate credential programs in eight disciplines, scholarships for instructors to enroll in these programs, and a resource site on Blackboard for concurrent enrollment instructors based on training materials used for professional development of part-time faculty and graduate teaching assistants. These Blackboard enrichments are provided for Biology, Chemistry, Mathematics, Spanish, English, American History and Communications. Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central do not have contracted arrangements with nonaccredited higher education institutions. Consortial arrangements (for example with other regional campuses within the Purdue System) involve only accredited institutions with appropriately credentialed faculty. 3. Instructors are evaluated regularly in accordance with established institutional policies and procedures. All instructors are regularly evaluated: full-time faculty through annual review and promotion and tenure (promotion for clinical faculty), continuing lecturers through annual review, limited-term lecturers/dual credit instructors through faculty oversight including reviews of instructional materials and classroom observations. All instructors receive 23 DRAFT DRAFT student feedback from every course they teach at Calumet through the IDEA survey, and at North Central through Faculty Senate developed items in a survey via Blackboard. Annual faculty awards at both campuses recognize outstanding teaching, scholarship, and service. 4. The institution has processes and resources for assuring that instructors are current in their disciplines and adept in their teaching roles; it supports their professional development. Full-time faculty at both campuses are expected to remain current in their disciplines and professions, and continue to improve student performance in their courses. Faculty are provided opportunities for professional development including grants and release time for instructional improvements (e.g., course redesign), as well as research. The Office of Instructional Technology at Purdue Calumet, and the Office of Learning Technology at Purdue North Central offer many opportunities for full- and part-time faculty to acquire new skills to enhance student learning. The Senior Leadership Team will consider recommendations to unify these offices through a newly created Center for Teaching and Learning. At both campuses, new tenure-track faculty are supported in their development and given the opportunity to work with mentors. Dual credit instructors have many opportunities for professional development, including day-long workshops, materials available on Blackboard, and (at Purdue North Central) graduate certification programs in their discipline, and scholarships for graduate courses. 5. Instructors are accessible for student inquiry. Instructor availability is required at both campuses. All instructors are expected make themselves available to students, to hold regular office hours, and provide contact information in distance learning courses. Both campuses provide space for full-time and limited-term faculty to meet with students. The policies will continue in Purdue Northwest. 6. Staff members providing student support services, such as tutoring, financial aid advising, academic advising, and co-curricular activities, are appropriately qualified, trained, and supported in their professional development] Staff members in enrollment services and advising at both campuses are appropriately qualified, trained and receive updates on policy changes and changes to federal and state regulations. Advisors meet several times a year to discuss changes in curriculum and tools to assist students with understanding enrollment services dates, service learning and experiential learning opportunities, and career options. All staff members receive tuition remission on courses at any Purdue campus. Staff are supported to attend conferences. For example, staff from Purdue North Central participated in the 24 DRAFT DRAFT National Association of Concurrent Enrollment Partnerships conference in 2014 and staff from both campuses participated in the Banner summit in 2015. This will continue in the new Purdue Northwest. Criterion 3: Teaching and Learning: Quality, Resources, and Support 3. D. The institution provides support for student learning and effective teaching. 1. The institution provides student support services suited to the needs of its student populations. Both Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central have a wide range of services and infrastructure to support student learning and effective teaching. These services and structures have been developed for the specific needs of the student populations at both campuses, which share a number of characteristics. Both campuses have outreach programs through (federal) TRIO funding to first generation and high financial need high school students (including Upward Bound and Educational Talent Search). At both campuses, 21st Century Scholars receive extensive support services (this State of Indiana college scholarship and support program is 25 years old and offers financial incentives for low-income residents to finish high school through funding four years of college).The chart below shows a sampling of the support services at both campuses to high financial need students:: 25 DRAFT DRAFT Purdue Calumet Program/Services Purdue North Central Program/Services 21st Century Scholars Office College Bound Program/Talent Search (TRIO) --Strong relationship building with scholars --Emphasis on relationship building --Seek input from faculty on academic progress --Recruit scholars in 8th grade and work with them through high school --Academic counseling --Inform scholars about opportunities with dual credit and early college --Orientation --One-to-one tutoring --Success Workshops --Financial aid workshops --Financial aid referral and monitoring. Very focused partnership with Office of FA --University provides financial support for what is not met through Frank O’Bannon scholarship or 21st Century Scholarship (financial support) --Opportunities for scholars to participate in “Study Table” through which students have a place during the week for studying (right now close to the TRIO office). --Career awareness through service learning opportunities --Junior and senior scholars mentoring freshmen A majority of students are first-generation (66% at Calumet and 64% at North Central) most commute (92% and 100%), and many work more than 20 hours a week off campus (approximately 40% and 50%, respectively) (citation). Many students and their families are thus new to college, unaware of many of the support services and functions available to them and very busy with jobs and school. With more than 40% of students at both campuses showing high financial aid need as demonstrated by their Title III eligibility status, (citation) students are also very concerned with cost, with many students paying as they go. The two institutions have already taken steps to unify and enhance these programs and services, as with, for example, career services. This work will continue in Purdue Northwest. 26 DRAFT DRAFT 2. The institution provides for learning support and preparatory instruction to address the academic needs of its students. It has a process for directing entering students to courses and programs for which the students are adequately prepared. 3. The institution provides academic advising suited to its programs and the needs of its students. Both institutions start to direct resources to support students before they arrive on campus, by analyzing admissions information and attempting to link students with services that address their needs. Academic advisors work with students to identify their academic goals; where appropriate, students are directed to placement tests to help them enroll in coursework they are prepared for, as well as, in some cases, to obtain academic credit for their existing skills. Academic advisors instruct students in the use of the Degree Works degree audit system, provide up-to-date information from monthly briefings on financial aid, admissions, and registration processes, and act to promote student success in a variety of ways. Both campuses organize campaigns for outreach to students in academic difficulty. Purdue Calumet uses Student Success Collaborative software to track students’ progress using predictive analytics; Purdue North Central has an Early Alert System to identify and direct resources to students in academic difficulty. Discussions are underway about how best to combine and expand these resources and initiatives for Purdue Northwest. 4. The institution provides to students and instructors the infrastructure and resources necessary to support effective teaching and learning (technological infrastructure, scientific laboratories, libraries, performance spaces, clinical practice sites, museum collections, as appropriate to the institution’s offerings. Both institutions maintain comprehensive infrastructure in support of effective teaching and learning. Purdue North Central is in the process of constructing a large new Student Services and Activities Complex that will greatly expand resources for student clubs and organizations, athletics, and cultural and community events on campus, as well as allowing for new up-to-date classroom space to meet the campus’s changing needs. Both institutions have extensive computer and science labs to support student work, study, and research. The libraries of both institutions have already been unified, with the result that more topic-specialist librarians are available on both campuses and extensive tutorials in electronic and print library resources are available. Both campuses have established sim labs and clinical sites for nurses at most of the major health care providers in the area. Student teachers from both campuses are placed in sites throughout Northwest Indiana. Both have internship placements throughout Northwest Indiana for Social Work (Purdue North Central only), English, Psychology, Sociology, History, and other programs. 27 DRAFT DRAFT Both campuses have extensive laboratories, including updated science, technology, and behavioral science (Purdue North Central) laboratories, new engineering labs at Purdue North Central and six centers offering state-of-the-art research opportunities for faculty and students at Purdue University Calumet. Given the large percentage of commuter students, both campuses commit space and remodeling projects for new student lounges, project meeting rooms, and computer access in informal and attractive settings. Unification will improve infrastructure and resources through actions such as collaboration rather than competition for clinical sites and enhanced support for internships. Unification of information services, including the library, has already led to improved services. 5. The institution provides to students guidance in the effective use of research and information resources. Both campuses provide guidance to students in the effective use of research and information resources through instruction by reference librarians, library guides23 , and extensive training and information on effective course design (see, for example, Purdue North Central website on course design24). All faculty and students must adhere to Purdue policies on human research and receive guidance from faculty mentors on becoming certified before engaging in human subjects’ research. Criterion 3: Teaching and Learning, Quality, Resources and Support. 3. E. The institution fulfills the claims it makes for an enriched educational environment. 1. Co-curricular programs are suited to the institution’s mission and contribute to the educational experience of its students. 2. The institution demonstrates any claims it makes about contributions to its students’ educational experience by virtue of aspects of its mission, such as research, community engagement, service learning, religious or spiritual purpose, and economic development] Both institutions have sought to provide an enriched educational environment in line with their missions and student populations, with programs in service learning, support for undergraduate research, experiential learning, and other initiatives aimed at community engagement and economic development. With both institutions these services are attuned to the needs and characteristics of their student populations, 23 http://guides.purduecal.edu/ 24 http://www.pnc.edu/distance/coursedesign/ 28 DRAFT DRAFT helping students make the transition into college, and prepare to succeed after graduation. In the new Purdue Northwest these efforts will be expanded and deepened. Student governments from both campuses have developed a plan for unification, and cocurricular programs at Purdue North Central are about to be given much-needed room for growth in the new Student Services and Activities Complex. Efforts are underway to provide enhanced cultural opportunities for students through unification, including musical and theatrical events, support for creative writing, and international study initiatives. Purdue North Central has been nationally recognized as a Carnegie Engaged Campus, and both institutions focus in a variety of ways on the economic development of their communities. These efforts will continue in Purdue Northwest. Criterion 4: Teaching and Learning: Evaluation and Improvement The institution demonstrates responsibility for the quality of its educational programs, learning environments, and support services, and it evaluates their effectiveness for student learning through processes designed to promote continuous improvement. 4. A: The institution demonstrates responsibility for the quality of its educational programs. 1. The institution maintains a practice of regular program reviews. Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet have established rigorous policies to assure educational quality, including program reviews, curricular review through faculty governance, and reviews of transfer credit, many of which were already aligned by virtue of Purdue system-wide guidelines and Indiana state policies. Both institutions have a variety of programs that have earned external accreditation from established national bodies. Both institutions also use a variety of means to measure the success of graduates. Purdue Northwest will continue these practices, and in some cases, extend and deepen them. Purdue Calumet has been conducting systematic program reviews for the last decade, and Purdue North Central for the last several years. Purdue Calumet has a committee that works closely with Academic Affairs to oversee the reviews, including preparation of self-studies and retention of external reviewers for those programs that do not already have external accreditation. Purdue North Central recently instituted a similar policy, and plans are in development to integrate the two review policies, including the practice of external reviewers meeting with faculty and reviewing their programs in departments without specialized accreditation. 29 DRAFT DRAFT 2. The institution evaluates all the credit that it transcripts, including what it awards for experiential learning or other forms of prior learning, or relies on the evaluation of responsible third parties. 3. The institution has policies that assure the quality of the credit it accepts in transfer. In transcripting credit for transfer students, Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet accept credit only from accredited institutions and use departmental experts to examine individual courses when necessary, a policy that will continue for Purdue Northwest. Both institutions participate in Indiana’s Core Transfer Library (CTL) and Statewide Transfer General Education Core (STGEC). CTL requires regular reviews for its courses to ensure currency and quality. Numerous departmental coordinators and faculty participate in these reviews. Both institutions also took part in drafting competencies for the STGEC, with those competencies now being used to fashion general education policies for Purdue Northwest. Students can also earn credit at both institutions through CLEP and DANTES testing. All of these policies will continue for Purdue Northwest. Purdue has a system-wide form on departmental credit. Purdue North Central has further policies on departmental credit 25to assure that credit is merited for prior learning. 4. The institution maintains and exercises authority over the prerequisites for courses, rigor of courses, expectations for student learning, access to learning resources, and faculty qualifications for all its programs, including dual credit programs. It assures that its dual credit courses or programs for high school students are equivalent in learning outcomes and levels of achievement to its higher education curriculum. Both campuses assure that students have met prerequisites. The registrars run reports three times each year, at the end of each semester after grades are due. These reports analyze whether or not prerequisites have been met for the following term. These reports are sent to department chairs for information and to academic advisors for action. Academic advisors withdraw the students from those courses for which they no longer have the appropriate prerequisite, contact the students to notify them of this action, and work with the students to identify alternative courses to take. In addition, academic advisors can, after the beginning of the withdrawal period each term, run their own reports to see which of their students has withdrawn from a class which is a prerequisite for a course for which they are registered for the following semester. In this way academic advisors can proactively contact students and remove them from classes for which they do not meet the prerequisite and help them find alternative courses. 25 http://www.pnc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2015/04/1-2014-Credit-by-Examination-Etc.pdf 30 DRAFT DRAFT Both institutions have curricular review processes that ensure that new and modified courses are evaluated by faculty, and approved by the Faculty Senate. Among the factors considered are availability of expert faculty and university resources including library resources. Both campuses have a Senate committee responsible for overseeing this process. Faculty are working to build on the strengths of the general education curriculum of both campuses, ensuring that the overall learning outcomes for students are in alignment with state and national standards. Faculty are also working to integrate general education assessment with program and course assessment procedures. The Office of Institutional Effectiveness will be crucial for this. Thus Purdue Northwest will seek to create a culture of continuous improvement, ensuring the quality of individual programs, and that all graduates are measured against such national standards as the American Association of Colleges and Universities’ (AAC&U) Essential Learning Outcomes. Courses listed for general education credit must designate the general education learning outcomes that they address, as well as the assessment procedures they will use, before they are approved by a separate Senate committee. Faculty in charge of general education courses submit to regular review and revalidation. It is anticipated that Purdue Northwest will use similar procedures; faculty on the general education committees and the registrar are working together on plans to streamline the flow of electronic curriculum documents, and to include general education assessment information. With respect to dual credit, Purdue North Central is accredited by the National Association of Concurrent Enrollment Partnerships (NACEP), which has standards that require dual credit courses to be equivalent to courses offered on campus. These standards include the following: · · · The CEP ensures its students meet the course prerequisites of the college/university. The college/university ensures that CEP students are held to the same grading standards as those expected of students in on campus sections. CEP students are assessed using the same methods (e.g., papers, portfolios, quizzes, labs, etc.) as students in on campus sections. See the NACEP Standards26 In addition, institutional research provides annual updates on performance of students with Purdue North Central dual credit who matriculate to Purdue North Central. Data include performance in subsequent courses, retention and degree completion rates, and grade point average. Results have demonstrated that these students have high levels of 26 http://nacep.org/docs/standards/NACEP-Standards-2011.pdf 31 DRAFT DRAFT academic success. The Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs provides updates on this topic to Faculty Senate. At Purdue Calumet, faculty oversight of dual credit courses and high school faculty ensures the quality of the credit awarded. The program is approved by the Indiana Commission for Higher Education. Dual credit quality is assured through: · · · · Syllabus review of high school courses for alignment of student learning outcomes with the course taught on campus, Professional development of high school faculty members to ensure these outcomes, Close supervision of dual credit faculty by Purdue Calumet faculty, And a blind review of dual credit students’ and college students’ assignments by university faculty members to assure consistent evidence of learning. A joint committee has made recommendations on a unified dual credit program. A new Office of Institutional Effectiveness (OIE) has been proposed, which would improve coordination and information sharing for the pursuit of academic excellence. The Office of Institutional Research (IR) would become a unit of OIE. IR will be expanded and strengthened through the unification process (particularly through improvements in data collection and processing methods, and in the ability to provide an ongoing series of research reports). 5. The institution maintains specialized accreditation for its programs as appropriate to its educational purposes. A number of programs at both Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central are accredited externally (citation). Departments are working closely with accreditors to determine the impact of unification and to assure that the requirements of all accreditors will be met by Purdue Northwest. As unification will result in more faculty and resources for accredited programs, unification will strengthen accredited programs over time. 6. The institution evaluates the success of its graduates. The institution assures that the degree or certificate programs it represents as preparation for advanced study or employment accomplish these purposes. For all programs, the institution looks to indicators it deems appropriate to its mission, such as employment rates, admission rates to advanced degree programs, and participation rates in fellowships, internships, and special programs (e.g., Peace Corps and AmeriCorps). Upon graduation, and several years after, students are surveyed about their employment and the effectiveness of their preparation in college, and this information is conveyed back to various units in the university to make improvements. 32 DRAFT DRAFT Both institutions have several sources of data to determine the success of graduates – graduation surveys on employment and graduate school, alumni databases and interviews with alumni, state-level data which shows employment of graduates within the state (merging of State-level Student Information System data with Workforce Development Data) and the national student clearinghouse, which tracks subsequent enrollment of graduates. The unified Career Services office is streamlining the graduate survey instrument to reduce redundancy, assure a greater response rate and to have more focused information to share with academic units. To assess graduates’ perceptions of their education, some departments conduct individual exit interviews with seniors (engineering is one example) using open ended questions about the best part of their academic preparation and what could have been improved. An emerging project at Purdue Calumet that may lead to more widespread use on both campuses is the development of electronic portfolios that will be used for assessment of learning and program objectives, as well as providing a showcase for students transitioning into employment or graduate work. Criterion 4: Teaching and Learning: Evaluation and Improvement 4. B.: The institution demonstrates a commitment to educational achievement and improvement through ongoing assessment of student learning. Both institutions have been actively engaged in assessment and efforts to foster a culture of continuous improvement. Purdue North Central was one of the first institutions in Indiana to adopt the Essential Learning Outcomes of the Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U), and subsequently work to use the associated rubrics to assess general education at the course level and in broad samples of students (through the Multi-State Collaborative to Advance Learning Outcomes Assessment, http://cop.hlcommission.org/Assessment/carnahan2015.html). Purdue North Central’s faculty governance includes an Assessment Steering Committee, as well as a General Education Committee, both of which report on and oversee assessment efforts. Purdue University Calumet’s academic departments report annual student learning assessment and changes made based on that assessment to their college deans who in turn summarize these findings for the VCAA and Provost. The Faculty Senate has long supported assessment committees that oversee the approval and assessment of listed general education courses as well as experiential learning courses. Both campuses have an ongoing programs review process. Program review has led to concrete improvements, such as these at Purdue Calumet: 33 DRAFT DRAFT Department Name External Review Improvement Department of Construction Science and Organizational Leadership: Organizational Leadership and Supervision Program (OLS) The current program educational objectives need to be broadened and refocused on the expectations for graduates several years after obtaining their degrees. The OLS program faculty met to review and revised the program educational objectives. A review of transcripts revealed that OLS 47400: Conference Leadership is taken midway through a student‘s coursework and, therefore, does not draw on a significant portion of the cumulative knowledge or skills that will be acquired when the student‘s course of study culminates. Full compliance with this criterion requires that appropriate changes responsive to these shortcomings be made. The BS Degree Program now contains two (2) required courses that allow students to participate in ―comprehensive projects or experiences based on the cumulative knowledge and skills acquired in earlier course work.‖ These two courses are OLS 47400 – Conference Leadership, and OLS 49700 – Senior Project. 1. The institution has clearly stated goals for student learning and effective processes for assessment of student learning and achievement of learning goals. 2. The institution assesses achievement of the learning outcomes that it claims for its curricular and co-curricular programs. Each year, Purdue North Central’s Faculty Senate Assessment Steering Committee assembles a report on assessment in all academic programs. The report includes student learning outcomes, ongoing assessment efforts, ways that these assessments are used to make improvements, and reflection on how assessment efforts might be improved in the future. Purdue University Calumet’s departments also conduct annual assessment reviews, and the Faculty Senate conducts assessments of general education courses every two years and of experiential learning courses every four years. Both campuses assess co-curricular activities, with community service and experiential learning providing high-impact, enhanced co-curricular learning opportunities for students. In both types of applied learning, faculty gauge the co-curricular learning through evaluations of students’ performance by supervisors of their work and through students’ own reflective blogs, journals, papers, and most recently electronic portfolios (Purdue Calumet). 34 DRAFT DRAFT The Co-Curricular Transcript at Purdue University Calumet is an official University document that helps assess and document co-curricular experiences (those activities that took place outside the classroom) in which students have been involved while being enrolled at the university. It complements the academic transcript by verifying student co-curricular involvement that includes but is not limited to: 1. honors and awards received as an enrolled student, 2. active participation in Student Government and Organizations, a. athletics and intramurals (e.g., serving as a captain, coach, or manager of a Purdue Calumet intercollegiate athletics or intramural team), 3. educational workshops/conferences, community and campus service (e.g., volunteer work, performed while a Purdue Calumet student, that provides service to others such as volunteering for a youth organization, for a healthcare facility, as a reader for an elementary school, at a soup kitchen, etc.), 4. service to the Purdue Calumet campus community (ex: serving as a student representative on a University Committee [the Traffic Appeals Committee, Multicultural Committee, etc.]. Leadership from both faculty are engaged in discussing the best way to combine these assessments and reporting mechanisms for Purdue Northwest. The recommended Office of Institutional Effectiveness will be important for assisting with program assessment, co-curricular assessment, and faculty-driven efforts to coordinate and report on assessment activities. 3. The institution uses the information gained from assessment to improve student learning. Purdue North Central holds an annual Assessment Fest, at which faculty from various programs share and discuss successful assessment initiatives as well as challenges. At the most recent Assessment Fest, Purdue North Central hosted the first gathering of assessment leaders from all Purdue campuses for a panel session and discussion. At Purdue Calumet, departments write annual assessment reports that determine how student learning assessment data informs decisions about curricular improvements. In the seven-year program review process, this annual data feeds into the seven-year report, which then becomes part of the departmental self-study. External reviewers for departments with or without external accreditation provide feedback to the faculty and departments for improvements in student learning. Academic programs use information gained from assessment to improve student learning in many ways. For example, faculty from the College of Business at Purdue North Central were not satisfied with student performance in quantitatively based courses. To address this, the faculty added a second statistics course and replaced the algebra requirement with a finite math course specifically designed with business applications. 35 DRAFT DRAFT Part of the new structure being proposed for the unified Office of Institutional Effectiveness involves an Assessment Oversight Committee that will provide support for assessment and program review. This office will be charged with documenting how the information gained from assessment is used to improve student learning. 4. The institution’s processes and methodologies to assess student learning reflect good practice, including the substantial participation of faculty and other instructional staff members. Both institutions have been a part of lively discussions in Indiana and the region about best practices for assessment. Purdue North Central was part of the Higher Learning Commission’s Academy for Assessment of Student Learning (2009-2013). Both institutions participated in the creation of Indiana’s Statewide Transfer General Education Competencies. Both institutions regularly send faculty and administrators to regional and national conferences on assessment best practices, including the IUPUI Assessment Institute and AAC&U-sponsored conferences. Purdue North Central has been very involved with development and implementation of the Multistate Collaborative on Student Outcomes Assessment. The Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs at Purdue North Central was asked by the Indiana Commission for Higher Education to serve as a member of the national working group that developed this project. Both institutions have participated in the state-wide implementation of the Multistate Collaborative project and have representatives serving on the state leadership committee. A current faculty assessment fellow also serves as a representative on an AAC&U Faculty Collaborative project, which will align initiatives such as the Degree Qualifications Profile, General Education Maps & Markers (an AAC&U project), and Tuning with improving the quality of “signature” assignments in assessing student work, enhancing curricular alignment between secondary and post-secondary institutions and between two-year and four-year institutions, and sharing best practices through intrastate and interstate faculty networks. Efforts to remain up to date with and to provide leadership for best practices will continue in Purdue Northwest. Criterion 4: Teaching and Learning: Evaluation and Improvement 4. C. The institution demonstrates a commitment to educational improvement through ongoing attention to retention, persistence, and completion rates in its degree and certificate programs. 1. The institution has defined goals for student retention, persistence, and completion that are ambitious but attainable and appropriate to its mission, student populations, and educational offerings. 36 DRAFT DRAFT Institutional research provides information on student retention, persistence, and completion of programs. The Purdue system collects this information. Purdue North Central provides a daily enrollment dashboard report that includes retention. The Indiana Commission for Higher Education (ICHE) requires extensive reporting on student retention persistence, and completion. For example, ICHE recently developed a “Total Completion Rate” that includes completions at the same campus and degree level, at a different campus or degree level, and spans an eight-year period. The total completion rate for Purdue Calumet is 48% and at Purdue North Central is 47%, slightly higher than most other regional campuses. This measure is reasonable for the variety of students at regional campuses, given that many complete their degrees on a different campus or at a different degree level and many take more than four years to complete [Indiana Commission for Higher Education Completion Report Handout27] Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet have provided goals for degree completion and student persistence for Indiana residents to the Indiana Commission for Higher Education. Degree completion is more meaningful, as a large percentage of students at both institutions stop out, attend part-time, or have transfer credit (for example, 54% of baccalaureate recipients at Purdue North Central in FY 2013-14 had transfer credit). The goal for Purdue North Central is to increase Indiana resident baccalaureate degrees completed from 399 in FY 2011-12 to 578 in FY 2018-19 and 655 in FY 202526. Purdue North Central is on track to increase baccalaureate degrees conferred, with 431 bachelor’s degrees (IN Resident) in FY 2012-2013 and 482 bachelor’s degrees (IN Resident) for FY 2013-2014. Purdue Calumet tracks retention and graduation rates and seeks a steady increase in fall-to-fall retention as one indicator of improvement. Fall-to-fall retention has improved from 62% in 2007 to 69% in 2011 to 74% in 2014. The degrees awarded by Purdue Calumet have increased significantly in the last ten years, in both number and type. In 2004-2005, 720 students were awarded bachelor degrees; in 2013-2014, 1700 students received bachelor degrees (136% increase). More recently, both campuses have developed or purchased technology to better inform academic advisors about students with potential academic difficulties. Academic advisors instruct students in the use of the degree audit program Degree Works, provide up-to-date information from monthly briefings on financial aid, admissions, and registration processes, and act to promote student success in a variety of ways. Both campuses organize campaigns for outreach to students in academic difficulty. Purdue Calumet uses Student Success Collaborative software to track students’ progress using predictive analytics; Purdue North Central has an Early Alert System to identify and direct resources to students in academic difficulty. 27 http://www.in.gov/che/files/ Completion_Report_Handout_May2015.docx 37 DRAFT DRAFT Discussions are underway about how best to combine and expand these resources and initiatives for Purdue Northwest. 2. The institution collects and analyzes information on student retention, persistence, and completion of its programs. 3. The institution uses information on student retention, persistence, and completion of programs to make improvements as warranted by the data. Both campuses use information on student retention, persistence, and program completion to make improvements. For example, faculty and administrators at Purdue North Central reviewed data on retention on pre-nursing students and found that large numbers left the university. To better serve those students Purdue North Central developed a Health Studies major that will enable pre-nursing students who are not admitted to nursing to have career options of interest to them and in which their prenursing courses will count. Over the last decade, the campuses have implemented or expanded a number of initiatives to increase persistence and degree completion, including supplemental instruction, focused on courses with high DFW rates, and a first-year experience program, with a three-credit course built around connecting students with resources to succeed. Both institutions now require new student orientation, occurring throughout the enrollment period. Both institutions also direct resources to support students before they arrive on campus, by analyzing admissions information and attempting to link students with services that address their needs. Academic advisors work with students to identify their academic goals; where appropriate, students are directed to placement tests to help them enroll in coursework they are prepared for, as well as, in some cases, to obtain academic credit for their existing skills. In 2014 Purdue Calumet received the Data-Driven Impact Award from the Education Advisory Board for use of data to better target student support such as supplemental instruction. Advisors within the colleges have data needed to proactively reach out to atrisk students. Purdue Calumet was recognized for an increase of 4.7 percentage points in full-time, first-year student retention over the past two years. More information is available on the EAB website.28 To encourage price-sensitive students to focus on degree completion, Purdue North Central has recently implemented a tuition discount program to encourage students to increase the number of credit hours taken each semester and graduate in a timely manner. Students receive a 10% rate reduction for each credit hour taken beyond 12. In addition, PNC has recently started a Tuition Incentive Scholarship program for former 28 http://www.eab.com/technology/student-success-collaborative/members/case-studies/building-aculture-of-solution-oriented-advising 38 DRAFT DRAFT students to encourage them to complete their degree. Students who meet eligibility requirements29 receive a 50% scholarship on tuition. In the future, the significant “new market” for Purdue Northwest is the traditional age student who takes fifteen credit hours, who works on-campus rather than off-campus, and who intends to complete the degree within a four-year span. Several factors point to the growth of this “new market:” in the future. In the Fall 2014, 67% of the first time in college freshmen at Purdue Calumet enrolled in 15 credit hours compared to 27% in the Fall 2012, Purdue Calumet continues support for on-campus employment (100 supplemental instructors and tutors were hired in fall 2014); and for both campuses, the push by the State of Indiana is for “on-time completion” through the 15-to-finish campaign and mandated four-year degree maps (citation). In a recently funded grant from the Indiana Commission for Higher Education, both campuses seek to improve the retention rate of entering freshmen receiving some form of state aid. The January 2015 grant funding affirms the unified campuses’ commitment to the success of its students who may have the greatest financial need and that face many barriers in completing their academic programs. The funding to both institutions focuses on the following: provide faculty development for those teaching freshmen seminars, develop advisor training materials to facilitate more in-depth advising, provide summer bridge career preparation support, and offer financial literacy workshops for students and parents as part of new student orientation. 4. The institution’s processes and methodologies for collecting and analyzing information on student retention, persistence, and completion of programs reflect good practice. (Institutions are not required to use IPEDS definitions in their determination of persistence or completion rates. Institutions are encouraged to choose measures that are suitable to their student populations, but institutions are accountable for the validity of their measures. Both campuses report retention and degree completion in a standard method (using the IPEDS definition) as required by the Purdue system and the Indiana Commission for Higher Education. Purdue North Central participates in the Voluntary System of Accountability. Criterion 5: Resources, Planning, and Institutional Effectiveness The institution’s resources, structures, and processes are sufficient to fulfill its mission, improve the quality of its educational offerings, and respond to future challenges and opportunities. The institution plans for the future. 29 Were resident undergraduates, left PNC with a cumulative GPA of 2.0 or higher, earned at least 60 and no more than 119 credits, stopped attending PNC between fall 2010 and fall 2014, are current Indiana residents. 39 DRAFT DRAFT 5. A. The institution’s resource base supports its current educational programs and its plans for maintaining and strengthening their quality in the future. 1. The institution has the fiscal and human resources and physical and technological infrastructure sufficient to support its operations wherever and however programs are delivered. Fiscal resources: Over the next five years the unified institution will be stable financially as the result of modest state appropriation increases, a conservative estimate of enrollments, and tuition and fees adjustments in line with the annual inflation index. The increase in tuition and fee revenue is conservatively projected to be $1.5 million in FY 2017. At the end of Fiscal Year 2013, the Higher Learning Commission financial reporting model reflected a strong Total Composite Financial Indicator (CFI) score for both the Calumet and North Central campuses with similar scores expected for Fiscal Year 2014. These strong scores are the result of both campuses working to build up reserves sufficient to support institutional needs should revenue instability occur. Human Resources and Course and Program Delivery: The faculty development in applying technology in designing or redesigning courses has been purposeful, strategic and long supported by both institutions. The Digital Learning Certificate and other programs at both campuses offer workshops for faculty members in course design or redesign using technology. The Digital Learning Certificate program stresses good pedagogy in course design, and faculty members undergo a certification review through which their courses are evaluated using Quality Matters. Technological infrastructure is robust. Courses and programs at Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet may be delivered online, in hybrid format, or through streaming video. As noted in the Higher Learning Commission institutional statement, both institutions have developed capacity among faculty and through its one Learning Management System (Blackboard) to be flexible in delivery options. This flexibility is important to future students of Purdue Northwest as it provides them with possible options for additional courses and programs across both campuses. Both campuses have developed approaches that assure adequate fiscal and human resources through experience with online courses and programs. Technology capacity building is taking many forms—the piloting of joint courses using the shared Blackboard platform (summer 2014), the eighteen-month project which will create one instance of Banner for seamless enrollment processing between the two campuses, and the administrative alignment of Information Services across the two campuses with job descriptions and functions merged to better serve faculty, staff, and students. 40 DRAFT DRAFT 2. The institution’s resource allocation process ensures that is educational purposes are not adversely affected by elective resource allocations to other areas or disbursement of revenue to a superordinate entity. As public institutions, no resources are allocated to other entities. Resource allocations for both institutions in the past and in the future as PURDUE NORTHWEST will follow the mission with an emphasis on student support and academic quality. The institutional statement contains the budget detail for the unified campus (question #7). 3. The goals incorporated into mission statements or elaborations of mission statements are realistic in light of the institution’s organization, resources, and opportunities. As noted in Criterion 5c, the mission statement for Purdue Northwest emphasizes academic quality, an affordable education, and support for students. Purdue Northwest is organizing itself to realize savings to invest in academic quality and student support, and more than a dozen committees are actively planning how new structures and programs and services will move the unified institution forward. This planning to support mission is being done with the planning assumptions of modest state appropriation increases, tuition and fee adjustments in line with the annual inflation index along with a conservative estimate of enrollments. Two fiscally strong campuses will combine into a stronger unified campus. The financial plan anticipates stable to modest growth in revenue, more than adequate funding to meet debt service and infrastructure plans and to support facility and technology needs into the foreseeable future. 4. The institution’s staff in all areas are appropriately qualified and trained. Staff members in enrollment services and advising at both campuses are appropriately qualified, trained and receive updates on policy changes and changes to federal and state regulations. Advisors meet several times a year to discuss changes in curriculum and tools to assist students with understanding enrollment services dates, service learning and experiential learning opportunities, and career options. Human Resources on both campuses offer an array of staff development opportunities including nine modules on supervisory training, focused workshops on facilitating effective meetings and time management and just-in-time training on conducting performance evaluations. Administrative and Financial Services and Information Services staff members are also appropriately qualified and trained. All job descriptions are reviewed prior to job posting. Performance evaluations are conducted based on these descriptions, and an important part of the performance appraisal is the review of a staff member’s continuing development both using internal training resources and external training resources. This emphasis on qualifying and training staff members will continue in the Purdue Northwest. Information about faculty qualifications and training are available under Criterion 3.C. 41 DRAFT DRAFT 5. The institution has a well-developed process in place for budgeting and for monitoring expense. The Financial Plan under # 7 of the institutional statement provides information about PURDUE NORTHWEST’s well-developed process for budgeting and monitoring expenses. The Purdue system establishes overall budget processes. At both campuses, a budget timetable and process have been established. In addition, both Faculty Senates provide input into the budget. The unification process has continued this emphasis on transparency in budgeting, and savings from this process have been documented on the unification website. Criterion 5: Resources, Planning, and Institutional Effectiveness 5. B. The institution’s governance and administrative structures promote effective leadership and support collaborative processes that enable the institution to fulfill its mission. 1. The governing board is knowledgeable about the institution; it provides oversight of the institution’s financial and academic policies and practices and meets its legal and fiduciary responsibilities. The governing board for Purdue Northwest is the Purdue University Board of Trustees. The Indiana Commission for Higher Education (ICHE) is a coordinating board that provides the overall framework for public institutions in Indiana. The Board of Trustees and the Indiana Commission for Higher Education approve all new degree programs for Higher Education. The Board of Trustees also approves all significant financial and academic polices. For example, changes to academic structure (such as the creation of or changes to the structure of colleges and departments) will need to be approved by the Purdue Board of Trustees. The chancellor, presidents of the faculty senates, and presidents of student government provide regular updates to the Board of Trustees. ICHE is knowledgeable about Purdue Northwest through a meeting of the chancellors and vice chancellors for academic affairs with the Commissioner and her staff members. 2. The institution has and employs policies and procedures to engage its internal constituencies – including its governing board, administration, faculty, staff, and students – in the institution’s governance. Internal constituents have many opportunities to engage in the institution’s governance. Both Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet support shared governance through active Faculty Senates, Administrative and Professional Staff Advisory Councils, and Clerical and Service Staff Advisory Councils, as well as Student Government Associations. In preparation for the unified institution, APSAC and CSSAC groups from both campuses have met, and the Student Government Associations are working on a new representative association. The Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet faculty senates have drafted a new, unified constitution. At Purdue North Central, the Faculty 42 DRAFT DRAFT Senate and the full faculty approved the unified senate constitution. At Purdue University Calumet, the Senate vote was one short of that needed to send the new constitution to a vote of the faculty. The primary remaining issue is representational status. It is anticipated that the faculty senates will resolve remaining issues during fall semester 2015. In addition to shared governance organizations, both campuses hold open forums and convocations that allow all campus community members to receive updates, ask questions, and make suggestions on the institution’s governance. For unification, internal constituents have been engaged and informed in numerous ways. To develop the PNW mission and vision, six focus groups were conducted in the Fall 2014 on both campuses and nine values sessions conducted spring 2015 on both campuses. Approximately 55 faculty and staff participated in these mission and vision development sessions. Chancellor Keon and Chancellor Dworkin have held numerous open forums on both campuses on unification: · · · · · Feb. 26, 2014 PNC (video)30 Feb. 26, 2014 Calumet (video)31 Feb. 9, 2015 (video)32 Feb. 10, 2015 (video) Presentation – Feb. 9-10 201533 Chancellor Keon has addressed the Calumet campus numerous times: · · · · · · · Open Forum with students – Dec. 3, 2014 Monthly meetings with/updates to Calumet Faculty Senate Meeting with Student Senate – Student Government Association leaders plus leadership of all student organizations on campus Forum with Clerical and Service staff Administrative Leadership Team meetings (department heads, AVCs, senior leaders) – reports on status of unification, and group work to give input to unification – bimonthly through Fall 2014 and Spring 2015 Fall 2014 Administrative Leadership Team small group sessions— approximately 12 sessions with 10-15 people in attendance at each session Series of meetings to address unification questions with small groups of administrative leaders – Fall 2014 30 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/open-forum-video-north-central/ 31 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/open-forum-video-calumet/ 32 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/open-forum-video-calumet/ 33 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/chancellors-forums-february-9-10-2015/ 43 DRAFT DRAFT · · In-person meetings, along with Provost Gerard, each semester with faculty and staff in each College – 18 meetings from February 2014 – May 2015 In-person meetings, along with Provost Gerard, with academic leadership (deans and department heads), throughout each academic year Chancellor Dworkin has addressed the PNC campus many times: · · · Chancellor’s Forum – 10/28/14 – report on status of unification Monthly updates to Faculty Senate Several forums open to all and specific forums for faculty and CSSAC). Open Forums for students have been held · · · · Feb. 26, 2014 (both campuses); Dec. 3, 2014 (Calumet); Feb. 9, 2015 (North Central); Feb. 10, 2015 (Calumet). Student media have provided regular coverage of unification. Frequently Asked Questions have been developed34 for current students 9) and prospective students, their guidance counselors and parents (Appendix X). The Joint Senior Leadership Team—the chancellors and vice chancellors from both campuses, with participation by the chairs of both Faculty Senates at some meetings-meets approximately every two weeks to discuss strategic issues. Joint dean meetings have been held monthly for more than a year. Minutes are posted on the Unification website.35 Fifteen memos from the chancellors have been sent to faculty, staff and students from Feb. 2014 – May 2015. · · From the Chancellors36 on the Unification website Updates to Trustees shared with campuses Unification Initiative Update37 Both campuses have newsletters that include information on unification. This Week @ PNC (weekly newsletter) included ten articles on the benefits of unification. The Bridge 34 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/faqs/ 35 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/committee/meeting-minutes/ 36 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/from-the-chancellors/ 37 http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/unification-initiative-update/ 44 DRAFT DRAFT newsletter at PUC includes regular updates38 on unification and addresses questions and issues 3. Administration, faculty, staff, and students are involved in setting academic requirements, policy, and processes through effective structures for contribution and collaborative effort. Both faculty senates are involved in setting academic requirements. The senates are working on possible structures for faculty governance for PURDUE NORTHWEST. Faculty Senate has direct control of the undergraduate curriculum while the Purdue Graduate Council has control over the graduate curriculum (Purdue has one systemwide graduate school). Faculty are also integral in the determination of transfer credit as well as the evaluation of AP, CLEP and other external testing that could lead to academic credit. Faculty work with their department chairs/heads, deans and the office of Academic Affairs to identify priorities for degree programs, faculty hiring, and other related policies. Faculty Senate also is part of the development of system-wide academic regulations. Student government has representation on the Faculty Senate. In addition, the student voice is heard related to academic policies and structures in a number of ways. The Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central Dean of Students Offices work closely with students who have questions and concerns about academic policies. In recent years, there has been increased emphasis on review of the student concerns in an effort to reduce barriers or bureaucracy for students. A good example of one academic policy that is currently under review (by the entire Purdue System) is that of grade appeals. Students at Purdue Calumet voiced concerns that the process was hard to understand, hard to follow, and was not evenly applied across all colleges. The two campuses have different grade appeal processes. A task force at the system level, including representatives from Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central, will study this issue and make recommendations for a system-wide policy with provision for local procedures. Criterion 5: Resources, Planning, and Institutional Effectiveness 5. C. The institution engages in systematic and integrated planning. 1. The institution allocates its resources in alignment with its mission and priorities. A PURDUE NORTHWEST strategic plan is being developed as part of the unification process. The mission statement -- endorsed by large numbers of faculty and staff during the last year-- will direct strategic priorities for the future. 38 http://webs.purduecal.edu/the-bridge/from-the-chancellor-archives/ 45 DRAFT DRAFT Mission Purdue University Northwest, in the land grant tradition of learning, discovery and engagement, provides high quality, affordable undergraduate and graduate education to students of Northwest Indiana and beyond. We create a welcoming environment that promotes critical inquiry through experiential learning, faculty scholarship, civic engagement and community partnerships. The “land grant tradition” signifies service to community of the region and of the State; “high quality and affordable” directs all efforts of cost containment and cost savings to maintain high levels of faculty and staff engagement with students. “Welcoming environment” recognizes the need of the majority of first-generation college students for supportive staff, services and programs to aid in their navigation of higher education. “Critical inquiry” refers to the broad background and emphasis on thoughtful analysis necessary for a twenty-first century college education. Through the directive of the Purdue Board of Trustees all savings occurring through the unification (through merging administrative positions and functions, efficiencies due to joint purchasing and licenses, and so on) should be redirected toward support for students and academic quality. As part of the ongoing planning processes on how student needs and academic quality will be addressed in the future, more than a dozen unification committees have been formed, including Academic Success (Retention and Advising), Center for Teaching, Learning and Technology, Experiential Learning, Honors, and Graduate Education. It is expected that their recommendations will assist with aligning resource allocation with mission and priorities. 2. The institution links its processes for assessment of student learning, evaluation of operations, planning, and budgeting. Processes for assessment of student learning, evaluation of operations, planning, and budgeting are linked in several ways: through the program accreditation process, through program review, by recommendations from the faculty senates, by recommendations of the deans, and by the Senior Leadership Team. A new position has been recommended, Associate Vice Chancellor for Institutional Effectiveness. This is in recognition of the need to better connect assessment of student learning, evaluation of operations, planning, and budgeting. Another linkage between student learning, evaluation of operations and budgeting is the program analysis process at Purdue University Calumet. This process is the result of a three-year effort to determine key performance indicators for academic units (including benchmark data from peer institutions) to determine future funding levels. The first year of developing this process involved faculty and department committees researching and proposing indicators; the second year involved institutional research determining best fit data for these indicators, and the third year has involved a pilot of departments undergoing this review. It is anticipated that this type of program analysis, coupled with 46 DRAFT DRAFT a longer cycle of program reviews, will be an important connection of assessment of student learning, planning, and budgeting in the future. 3. The planning process encompasses the institution as a whole and considers the perspectives of internal and external constituent groups. Traditionally, the strategic planning processes at both institutions have been very inclusive, involving both internal stakeholders – faculty, students, and staff members as well as a wide array of community members. It has been an expected practice at both of these regional universities that the community would be involved in the campus and the campuses’ would be involved in the community. The Purdue North Central Advisory Board, which consists of local government, business, and community leaders, has engaged in ongoing planning with Purdue North Central. College and program advisory committees have also engaged many external constituents. At Purdue Calumet, departmental, college, and university level advisory committees have been active in curriculum advice and development, creation of internship and employment opportunities, and sources of financial support. The planning processes for the unified institution have followed this same pattern. The Unification Committee, which has played a key role in unification planning, includes students, alumni, Faculty Senate representatives, faculty at large representatives, deans, department chairs/heads, and representatives from the Administrative and Professional Staff Advisory Council and the Clerical and Service Staff Advisory Council (both shared governance groups). Minutes of Unification Committee meetings are publicly available at the unification website http://www.unifynorthcentralcalumet.com/committee/meeting-minutes/. The Unification Committee has met nine times March 2014-May 2015. Community members have been engaged and informed about unification through a variety of means – advisory councils, community-based service groups, newspaper articles, radio interviews, and through a public website on the unification process as it unfolds. 4. The institution plans on the basis of a sound understanding of its current capacity. Institutional plans anticipate the possible impact of fluctuations in the institution’s sources of revenue, such as enrollment, the economy, and state support. Within the Higher Learning Commission application, question #7 contains a more detailed business plan for the unified institution. Below are highlights from this full report, which describe how the unified institution will anticipate possible fluctuations in the institution’s sources of revenue and plan for these fluctuations. At the end of fiscal year 2013, the Higher Learning Commission financial reporting model reflected a strong Total Composite Financial Indicator (CFI) score for both the Calumet and North Central campuses with similar scores expected for fiscal year 2014. 47 DRAFT DRAFT These strong scores are the result of both campuses working to build up reserves sufficient to support institutional needs should revenue instability occur In the future (over the next five years), the unified institution will be stable financially as the result of modest state appropriation increases, a conservative estimate of enrollments, and tuition and fees adjustments in line with the annual inflation index. The Purdue University Board of Trustees approves operating budgets and fee increases, which are typically within the recommendations set by the Indiana Commission for Higher Education (ICHE). Operating budgets consist primarily of funds received from state appropriations, student tuition and fees, interest earnings and Facilities & Administrative (Indirect Cost) recovery. Areas outside of the operating budget include dual credit and continuing education programs, classes provided at the Purdue Porter County site, and the Executive MBA program. Savings generated by unification will be reinvested in faculty and student learning opportunities. Much of the savings will be the reduction and elimination of administrative positions with those remaining assuming responsibilities at both locations. Additional savings will be achieved by optimizing purchases, licenses and contractual agreements as a larger institution. The unified campus remains a part of the larger Purdue system. Functions centrally managed for the entire Purdue system, such as preparing the consolidated financial reports and submitting state appropriation requests, will continue to be handled in this manner. 5. Institutional planning anticipates emerging factors, such as technology, demographic shifts, and globalization. The previous planning processes for both institutions anticipated emerging factors. These include the emergence of technology affecting course delivery (the response to this was the development of robust faculty development and quality standards for both campuses) and globalization (support for international students at Purdue Calumet). The demographic shift from predominantly part-time, adult learners to more full-time younger students has led to many changes, including enhanced student support services and activities, housing (residence halls at Purdue Calumet, private apartments at Purdue North Central), more emphasis on parent engagement, and an emphasis on completing fifteen credits per semester. Emerging factors are included in many ways in the unification planning process. Many of the unification committees are benchmarking for best practices as they develop new models for program and service delivery. For example, the Committee for the Center for Teaching and Learning contacted peer and aspirational peer institutions to determine how faculty development supports the strategic planning of these institutions and how these institutions measure success of their faculty development. The strategic planning process incorporated an environmental scan that included the following factors: 48 DRAFT DRAFT economic, political/governmental/regulatory, socio-economic, scientific and technological, and key trends impacting higher education. Criterion 5: Resources, Planning, and Institutional Effectiveness 5. D. The institution works systematically to improve its performance. 1. The institution develops and documents evidence of performance in its operations. In Academic Affairs, deans and department chairs/heads document evidence of performance in operations in their units in many ways. For example, Purdue North Central uses a database, Data 180, for annual documentation of faculty performance. At Purdue North Central each course has end-of term course evaluations, which are submitted through Blackboard and reviewed by individual faculty, chairs and deans. Both campuses have a systematic program review process, which will be modified into one process. Purdue Calumet’s involves each unit conducting a self-study and receiving feedback on all areas of its operations from an external review team. Recommendations are then reviewed by the department head, dean, and Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs for follow up and plans for improvement. This process itself has been studied for improvement. Within Academic Affairs for Purdue Northwest, a new structure has been recommended, Institutional Effectiveness, which would monitor and facilitate improvements overall, with an emphasis on student learning assessment, accreditation/program review reporting and follow-up, and institutional research. This office would have responsibility to support faculty with university level assessment for degree programs and general education as well as initiatives such as First Year Experience. In addition, this unit will assist programs with outside accrediting bodies such as CAPE (formerly NCATE) and ABET. The office of Institutional Effectiveness would also oversee the Center for Teaching, Learning and Technology and the office of Institutional Research. In this way these offices will have access to the unit best able to help improve performance. Enrollment Management and Student Affairs document evidence of performance in a variety of ways. One example is the enrollment dashboard at Purdue North Central that is sent daily to staff, department chairs, and administrators. The dashboard contains information including enrollment, credit hours by student, dual credit (such as the number of incoming students with dual credit and enrollment by course for the six courses with highest enrollment), and new student orientation participation. Another example from Purdue North Central of documenting evidence of performance is tracking of student issues and their resolution using Maxient software. 2. The institution learns from its operational experience and applies that learning to improve its institutional effectiveness, capabilities, and sustainability, overall and in its component parts. 49 DRAFT DRAFT Both Purdue Calumet and Purdue North Central pride themselves in learning from experience and improving. Continuous improvement is built into the culture at Purdue Calumet due to its 14 years as part of AQIP. Purdue North Central values innovation. An example of planning leading to capacity building in program or course delivery is in the area of dual credit. At Purdue North Central, graduate-level credentialing programs are being developed to offer dual credit instructors the discipline-based coursework needed for college-level course delivery. The unification of Purdue North Central and Purdue Calumet provides an opportunity to improve capacity in its student information system. Operational experience has taught campuses’ enrollment management, computing and advising staffs that different instances of the Banner system prevented seamless enrollment across the two campuses. In fact, in some instances, transfer students outside the Purdue System had greater ease of transfer into the Purdue System than did students within the System. As a first step in improvement, both campuses are redoubling efforts to create easy to navigate and supportive processes in all aspects of student enrollment and initial academic planning. Critical to the ease of navigation is the integration of enrollment functions of recruitment, admissions, financial aid, registration, new student orientation and retention efforts into a single holistic system. Currently, the two campuses have solidified the management structure of the enrollment offices and are in the process of converting the two separate computing systems into a single instance of Ellucian Banner. The single instance of Banner will allow Purdue University Northwest (PURDUE NORTHWEST) the ability to provide seamless incorporation of outreach, enrollment services, schedule of classes, academic catalog, student records and degree audits. The consolidation of computing will also involve a Request for Information (RFI) for the purchase of a Customer Relation Management System (CRM), integration of student portal, Education Advisory Board (EAB) retention analytics/interventions and Blackboard learning management system. 50 DRAFT