The Atwood Machine OBJECTIVE To derive the meaning of Newton's second law of motion as it applies to the Atwood machine. To explain how a mass imbalance can lead to the acceleration of the system. To determine the acceleration produced by an unbalanced mass condition. To study how the frictional force and the pulley's inertia affect the behavior of the Atwood machine. INTRODUCTION From Newton's second law: When a net force acts on a mass, acceleration is produced. The Atwood machine takes advantage of this law to produce an acceleration of a set of masses. The Atwood machine is two masses connected to the ends of a string looped over a pulley. In the presence of an unbalanced mass the Atwood machine produces a net force which causes an acceleration of the system. One mass moves upward as the other mass moves downward. Measurements of this acceleration can be determined from time and distance measures which are then compared to theoretical predictions based on Newton's second law. APPARATUS Computer Vernier computer interface Logger Pro Vernier Photogate with Super Pulley Mass set String THEORY Newton's second law is given by: F=m a Equation 1 Where, F [N] is the net force, m [kg] is the mass and a [m/s2] is the acceleration. The Atwood Machine - Page 1 Let us apply Newton's second law to the Atwood machine. We will analyze the forces that are present on each of the masses in the system. Below is a representation of the standard Atwood machine. Figure 1 T T m1 m2 Where, m1 [kg] is mass #1, m2 [kg] is mass #2 and T [N] is the tension in the string (due to gravity acting on the masses). To best analyze the behavior of the two masses we will picture each mass with the forces that act on each respectively. T T Figure 2 m1 m2 m1 g m2 g In a balanced condition (equilibrium) m1 = m2 and the masses remain stationary. This, however, does not allow the study of Newton's second law. Thus, let us consider the case where m1 > m2. This condition gives m1 a greater downward attraction and thus, it accelerates downward while m2 (attached via a light string to m1) will accelerate upward with the same acceleration as m1. The downward acceleration of m1 will not equal the acceleration due to gravity as the string, pulley, and m 2 are inhibiting a free-fall situation. Therefore applying Equation 1 to Figure 1: T = m1 g + m1 a T = m2 g - m2 a Equation 2 Where, a [m/s2] is the acceleration of the system. Equation 2 is derived from the sum of the forces in the y-direction. The Atwood Machine - Page 2 Because the string is connected between m1 and m2, and from Newton's third law, the tension in the string is the same for both m1 and m2. Thus, setting the two equations in Equation 2 equal based on the equal tensions gives: m1 g + m1 a = m2 g - m2 a or m1 g - m2 g = - m1 a - m2 a or m2 g - m1 g = m1 a + m2 a or ( m2 - m1 ) g = ( m1 + m2 ) a Equation 3 Where, (m2 - m1)g [N] is the applied force that causes the acceleration a [m/s 2]. Note, the acceleration of the system, based on Newton's second law, is derived solely from a pair of masses and gravity. To this point we have ignored the friction in and the inertia (tendency to remain at rest) of the pulley. These quantities cannot, however, be neglected. As mass is a measure of inertia, a percentage of the pulley's mass can be used as a measure of the pulley's inertia (one-half the total mass of the pulley). To be more accurate in Equation 3, by including the frictional forces (primarily of the pulley itself) and the pulley's inertia, the following derivation is used: F net = F - f = m a or ( m2 - m1 ) g - f = ( m1 + m2 + m p ) a Equation 4 Where, f [N] is the frictional force (opposite the applied force) and mp [kg] is the mass of the pulley that factors into the inertia of the pulley. Both the frictional force and the inertial mass will be experimentally determined quantities. The Atwood Machine - Page 3 EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE Figure 4 40 cm Part I: Keeping The Total Mass Constant For this part of the experiment you will keep the total mass used constant, but move weights from one side to the other. The difference in masses changes. 1. Set up the Atwood’s machine apparatus as shown in Figure 4. Be sure the heavier mass can move at least 40 cm before striking the floor or table top. 2. Connect the Photogate with Super Pulley to DIG/SONIC 1 of the interface. 3. Open the file “10 Atwoods Machine” in the “_Physics with Vernier” folder. A graph of velocity vs. time will be displayed. 4. Arrange a collection of masses totaling 200 g {50g hanger, 100g, 20g, 10g, 10g, 5g, 5g} on m2 and a 200 g {50g hanger, 100g, 50g} mass on m1. These masses are shown in the data table. 5. Position m1 as high up as it can go and release. What's the acceleration of this system? Is this expected? Record this value in the data table. Move 5 g from m2 to m1. 6. Position m1 as high up as it can go. Click to begin data collection. Steady the masses so they are not swinging. Wait at least one second and release the masses. Catch the falling mass before it strikes the surface or the other mass strikes the pulley. 7. Click the Linear Fit button to fit the line y = mt + b to the data. Slide the brackets, [ ], into place to select the region of the graph where the velocity was increasing at a steady rate (positive acceleration). Record the slope value (acceleration) in the data table. You will need one copy of this graph, with the brackets and data box included, for your laboratory report. You need ONE printout total; NOT one for each trial. Additionally, you will NOT need a second graph for the Part II data collection. The Atwood Machine - Page 4 8. Continue to move masses from m2 to m1 in 5 g increments, changing the difference between the masses, but keeping the total constant. Repeat Steps 6 - 7 for each mass combination. Repeat these steps through a mass difference of 50g. Part II: Keeping The Mass Difference Constant For this part of the experiment you will keep the difference in mass between the two sides of the Atwood’s machine constant and increase the total mass. 9. Put 120 g on m1 and 100 g on m2; these masses should include the mass of the hanger!! 10. Repeat Steps 6 & 7 to collect data and determine the acceleration. 11. Add mass in 20 g increments to both sides, keeping a constant difference of 20 grams. The resulting mass for each combination are shown in the data table. Repeat Steps 6 & 7 for each combination. Repeat the procedure through a total mass of 380g. REPORT ITEMS (To be submitted and stapled in the order indicated below) (-5 points if this is not done properly) COVER PAGE Lab Title Each lab group member’s first and last name printed clearly Date DATA (worth up to 10 points) Data tables available as a downloadable Excel file ONE sample Velocity vs. Time graph from the experimental trials that includes the Linear Fit data box. DATA ANALYSIS (worth up to 20 points) Experimental Procedure Graph -- Place analysis on the graph printout itself - Using your Velocity vs. Time graph, explain what the graph is indicating about the motion of the masses and why the region selected was appropriate. The Atwood Machine - Page 5 Now...Remove the pulley from the assembly & examine it without the string and masses hanging from it. Give it a spin with your finger. Based on this examination, what approximations {large enough to matter = you have to keep the term; small enough to be considered negligible = can set the term equal to zero} can you make regarding the mass of the pulley (mp; just the spinning disk part) and the frictional forces (f) acting on the pulley as they relate to the experiment and the data collected? You’ll use these conclusions from the questions above when discussing the equations for each part below. Part I: Keeping The Total Mass Constant We will begin with the equation: ( m1 + m2 + m p ) a ( m2 - m1 ) g - f Rewrite the equation to reflect the new mp & f approximations you concluded. What quantity in the equation would you consider to be the mass difference, m? Make this substitution and rewrite the equation again. Solve this new equation for "a." It now represents a linear equation that plots the acceleration [y-axis] vs. m [x-axis] o Like This: a = (Slope Stuff) * m + Y-Intercept Stuff. Your "slope stuff" may not literally be multiplied by m. The point is that the "slope stuff" is ANYTHING in that part of the equation that is NOT m! Additionally, the "y-intercept stuff" might be zero. Based on the basic form of the linear equation from the previous step, which quantities in your new equation should correspond to: o The slope? o The y-intercept? The Atwood Machine - Page 6 Part II: Keeping The Mass Difference Constant We will again begin with the equation: ( m1 + m2 + m p ) a ( m2 - m1 ) g - f Rewrite the above in the same way you did previously to reflect the approximations you concluded about mp & f from your pulley examination. What quantity in the equation would you expect to be the total mass, MT? Make this substitution and rewrite the equation again. Solve this new equation for "a." It now represents a linear equation that plots the acceleration [y-axis] vs. 1/MT [x-axis]. o Like This: a = (Slope Stuff) * 1 𝑀𝑇 + Y-Intercept Stuff Your "slope stuff" may not literally be multiplied by 1/MT. The point is that the "slope stuff" is ANYTHING in that part of the equation that is NOT 1/MT! Additionally, the "y-intercept stuff" might be zero. Based on the basic form of the linear equation from the previous step, which quantities in your new equation correspond to: o The slope? o The y-intercept? GRAPHS (worth up to 10 points) Part I: Keeping The Total Mass Constant Unplug the Logger Pro from the computer and open a new, blank data table/graph within the program [New Page Button/Icon]. Plot a graph of acceleration [y-axis] vs. m [x-axis], using your Part I data. Before you print this graph, AUTOSCALE the data and click the Linear Fit button to fit the line y = mx + b to the data; displaying the data box containing the slope and y-intercept data. Part II: Keeping The Mass Difference Constant Again, with the Logger Pro unplugged from the computer, open a new, blank data table/graph within the program [New Page Button/Icon]. Plot a graph of acceleration [yaxis] vs. 1/MT [x-axis], using the Part II data. Before you print this graph, AUTOSCALE the data and click the Linear Fit button to fit the line y = mx + b to the data; displaying the data box containing the slope and y-intercept data. The Atwood Machine - Page 7 GRAPH ANALYSIS (worth up to 20 points) Part I: Keeping The Total Mass Constant -- Place analysis on the graph printout itself - Based on your analysis of the graph, what is the relationship between the mass difference and the acceleration of an Atwood’s machine? How do your previous definitions of the slope and the y-intercept compare to the results that you found experimentally; i.e. what should be the value of the slope (from the equation) you found in the data analysis section vs. the value you actually determined (from the graph)? How do you account for any differences? Part II: Keeping The Mass Difference Constant -- Place analysis on the graph printout itself - Based on your analysis of the graph, what is the relationship between total mass and the acceleration of an Atwood’s machine? How do your previous definitions of the slope and the y-intercept compare to the results that you found experimentally; i.e. what should be the value of the slope (from the equation) you found in the data analysis section vs. the value you actually determined (from the graph)? How do you account for any differences? CONCLUSION (worth up to 20 points) See the Physics Laboratory Report Expectations document for detailed information related to each of the four questions indicated below. 1. What was the lab designed to show? 2. What were your results? 3. How do the results support (or not support) what the lab was supposed to show? 4. What are some reasons that the results were not perfect? QUESTIONS (worth up to 10 points) DO NOT forget to include the answers to any questions that were asked within the experimental procedure 1) How should the tension in the string change from trial to trial for the Keeping The Total Mass Constant cases? 2) How should the tension in the string change from trial to trial for the Keeping The Mass Difference Constant cases? 3) Should the mass of the string be added to the equations you graphed (from page 6) to obtain better accuracy? Explain. The Atwood Machine - Page 8