TABLE OF CONTENTS 3 INTRODUCTION 5 Market Trends and New Wisdom 6 7 8 9 10 11 LABELS are in China before they know it Executives must be more accountable BRANDS NEED MORE THAN WEIBO AND WECHAT TRUE ADVOCATES ARE CRITICAL Chinese consumer SPEND IS INCREASING methodology 15 Top 300 BRAND RANKINGS 20 Category Breakdown: Rankings, Insights and Success Stories 20 23 26 29 32 35 38 Luxury Accessible Luxury Contemporary High Street Beauty and cosmetics Jewelry, Watches and Accessories MULTI-BRAND Retailers 41 CONCLUSION 42 About us 42 43 overview of BOMODA GROUP key contributors 44 44 45 45 47 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY INDUSTRY AND MARKET TERMS ALIBABA OPERATED SOCIAL PLATFORMs baidu services For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 2 introduction Welcome to the 2014 Bomoda BRAND INDEX. The Bomoda Brand Index is the definitive guide to brand achievement in China, evaluating both activity and impact among Chinese consumers. The core of the report is an index of 300 prestige brands in China, based on their performance across three major dimensions: brand awareness, brand engagement, and consumer experience. • We built an algorithm that scores a brand’s total aggregate performance in China. •The algorithm incorporates more than 250 unique data points from social media, online fashion press, KOL mentions, mobile, website, and e-commerce sources. •If it’s included, it matters: these data points were selected and weighted through years of research and correlation with brand equity and measurable metrics. We found that extraordinary success with the Chinese consumer is achievable – if brand leaders understand where to focus and which resources to leverage. This report reveals which common brand behaviors do not correlate with growth, while shedding light on those that create measurable accomplishment. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 3 INTRODUCTION Our Approach Overwhelmingly, brands understand the relative value of China to the future of their businesses. But companies often make investments that are too small or based on bad assumptions. Even with thoughtful strategies in hand, unreliable data, outsourcing and siloed planning can undermine operations. Unrealistic expectations at the executive or board level often compound these challenges. Brand reach, engagement, and experience in China are incredibly challenging for brands to measure and track. Each comprises hundreds of supporting data points that varyingly reveal the effectiveness of a brand’s marketing spend, expansion strategy, and product development. The right data and insights can clarify these concepts – and their supporting KPIs – providing a firm foundation for growth. The rankings in this report show the extent to which any single brand has achieved across these KPIs – and where opportunities for improvement exist. Towards a More Profitable Future... As brands look to orient themselves to this critical market, the underlying strategies and tactics must be based on the data that define them. We conducted months of modeled data analysis and research to pinpoint what drives success in reaching, engaging and converting the Chinese consumer into a strong brand advocate. Despite its opacity, China does allow for replicable and significant brand success. The companies that rate highly in our rankings have achieved excellence through flexibility, commitment, and an understanding of China’s unique cultural dynamics. In doing so, they have not sacrificed their brand story. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 4 market trends and new wisdom As China emerges, China changes. Even as brands look to achieve a functional command of the market, the dynamics shift. In a rapidly evolving nation of nearly 1.5 billion, our data shows the extent to which the development of new channels, new demographics and new behaviors is a daily occurrence, undermining even the most well-considered quarterly planning process. The consequence? Brands build and execute strategies atop outdated data, stale positioning, and misaligned initiatives. It’s difficult enough in a stable model to understand reach, engagement and experience. To make these concepts actionable in a continually-shifting, culturally-divergent marketplace is akin to attempting to land a probe on an asteroid, blindfolded. In such a challenging environment, brands look to other brands for guidance. This creates an echo chamber of conventional wisdom that is often at odds with the changing realities on the ground. Here are five notable examples of recent shifts in this conventional wisdom surrounding China... For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 5 MARKET TREnds and new wisdom #1/ LABELs are in china before they know it Conventional Wisdom If a brand is not yet ready to enter China, it can wait until it has figured out its long-term strategic plan before it participates. New Wisdom Even if a brand does not think it is in China, it is. And the costs of ignoring the Chinese market ripple across the globe. • Resellers are selling every single major luxury and fashion brand on Taobao and Tmall, defining market perceptions and creating product dialogue even in the absence of formal brand participation. • Consumers are discussing every brand on social media and searching each brand on Baidu (China’s key search engine). Brands that fail to leverage these channels can be sure that their competitors will. • If brands are not engaged because they are not currently focused on China domestic sales, they will consequently suffer in other Asian markets, in Europe and increasingly in America as the Chinese come to dominate international travel and retail tourism. Chatter over 2 weeks in China around 40 brands in our Index with no visible local investment 8,479,307 KOL IMPRESSIONS * IN THE LAST 2 WEEKS, 40 brands (of 300) with no targeted investments in China have had significant chatter among local consumers and KOLs. 657,575 RESULTS WEIBO SEARCH 13 ,475 ,860 897,482 PRODUCTS ON TAOBAO BRAND MENTIONS IN TOP 6 FASHION DISCUSSION FORUMS We define brands with no targeted investment in China as those that meet ALL of the criteria: no official Mandarin language website, no official Weibo presence, does not ship to China, does not have a Tmall presence, and does not have a Douban presence. *KOL impressions is the product of a KOL’s fan base multiplied by his/her number of Weibo posts about a brand For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 6 MARKET TREnds and new wisdom #2/ executives must be more accountable Conventional Wisdom Brand executives can make strategic decisions from afar, trusting junior teams and agencies on the ground to get it right. New Wisdom Western executives must be fluent in the key channels, in tune with their company’s KPIs, and intimately involved in its strategic direction. • Brands often invest in specific channels without requisite investment in complementary channels, leading consumers down sub-optimal paths as they begin to explore and engage. • Agencies in China frequently optimize for short-term goals but do not understand the unique challenges brands face to build long-term, profitable relationships. • The impact of these missteps is revealed in the data – significantly reduced resonance, awareness, and engagement with the targeted Chinese consumer. New Balance makes targeted investment in Search without Mobile follow-up Step 1: Consumer searches “New Balance” on her mobile (42% of Baidu searches are from mobile). Step 2: New Balance’s Chinese website ranks #1 organically in Baidu when searching for brand name. Step 3: New Balance’s Chinese website is not mobileoptimized. Step 4: Weibo is promoted on brand website, but the link to Weibo is broken (returns an error page). For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 7 MARKET TREnds and new wisdom #3/ BRANDS NEED MORE THAN WEIBO AND WECHAT Conventional Wisdom Weibo and WeChat are the only social channels that brands need to reach the Chinese consumer. New Wisdom Secondary channels such as Dianping, Douban, Meilishuo, Toutiao and even Instagram provide critical, targeted reach to over 500 million Chinese consumers. •Investment and participation in social channels should coincide with the Chinese consumers’ evolving online behavior. • Leading brands like Converse • These secondary channels and Coach understand that pockets of significant value exist outside the obvious channels, representing a profitable arbitrage opportunity. have defined user bases relative to mass channels such as Weibo, providing brands with targeted outreach opportunities to consumers. #5 Four representative secondary social channels delivering large targeted consumer bases DIANPING MEILISHUO DEMOGRAPHICS Educated (80% are college +) Young (over 40% less than 25) Tier 1 Residents DEMOGRAPHICS Young Female (18 to 35) Opinion leaders within social circle Tier 1 Residents WHY THIS PLATFORM IS IMPORTANT China’s version of Yelp; enables brands to monitor user reviews & ensure accurate listing information Similar to Fancy or Polyvore; allows brands to identify organic brand advocates & commerce MOST EFFECTIVE FOR Brands with any retail footprint or location within China MOST EFFECTIVE FOR High Street & Luxury (currently most mentioned categories) NICE DEMOGRAPHICS Majority trendy, affluent females Tier 1 Residents WHY THIS PLATFORM IS IMPORTANT Brand-name focused Instagram model; encourages brands to identify grassroots consumers MOST EFFECTIVE FOR Accessible Luxury, Jewelry, Watches and Accessories, Contemporary WHY THIS PLATFORM IS IMPORTANT HUABAN DEMOGRAPHICS 66% Female, 34% male with males trending upward 20-29 Working professionals WHY THIS PLATFORM IS IMPORTANT China’s version of Pinterest; brands may showcase seasonal collections of products MOST EFFECTIVE FOR Multi-brand Retailers, Beauty & Cosmetics For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 8 MARKET TREnds and new wisdom #4/ true advocates are critical Conventional Wisdom Key Opinion Leaders (KOLs) are an important and necessary mechanism to build relationships with the Chinese consumer. New Wisdom Creating direct relationships with informal brand advocates on user-generated platforms like Meilishuo may be a better path to finding future consumers than costly celebrity endorsers. • Brands often invest in • For brands that are more established • Many KOLs have inflated in China (e.g., Beauty brands that entered China earlier), KOL discussions have diminishing impact on consumer perceptions. audiences with fake fans – comprising mostly bot traffic and faux accounts. Additionally, many have begun feigning legitimate engagement, further reducing their actual correlation with brand revenues. building relationships with certain KOLs based on his/ her perceived fan base size and cachet, yet the returns in terms of reach and awareness have historically proven uneven. Two active Nice app users easily outpace a “KOL” on Weibo with 2 million fans KOL on weibo Nice app users VS. 40 A KOL with ~2M Weibo fans posts Roger Vivier products, generating 40 likes, 159 reposts and 65 comments from her fan base. 483 342 In contrast, two active NICE app users who posted Roger Vivier shoes received 483 and 342 likes respectively. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 9 MARKET TREnds and new wisdom #5/ chinese consumer spend IS INCREASING Conventional Wisdom Domestic consumer growth in China is slowing – we should reduce investment. New Wisdom Chinese consumers are spending more than ever, the majority of it outside of mainland China. Investment must evolve to match their unique spending patterns. • Savvy brands understand that China’s “2%” domestic growth is misleading; when international purchases are considered, that number is significantly higher as China’s spend abroad is 66% of total outlays. • Additionally, Daigou – or unauthorized resellers – are a $15-20Bn business that is growing nearly 33% per annum and is both international in nature and nearly impossible to track effectively. • Holidays like Golden Week yield a significant bridge opportunity to impact consumer spending abroad and build CRM capability to drive loyalty and lifetime value when they return home. Daigou fill the gap between domestic prices and international prices for prestige brands ¥ 30-60% is the typical price markup for luxury goods in China driving consumers to alternative purchasing options (Business of Fashion) 60% 50% (Bain & Company) (Bain & Company) of consumers have made luxury purchases through Daigou channels rather than from brands or department stores of consumers who have never purchased from Daigou would consider doing so in the future GROWTH RATE >285,000 ACTIVE DAIGOU AGENTS CURRENTLY ON TAOBAO 33% 2013 2014 (Jing Daily) $ Billion 10 12 14 16 Daigou market was $12 billion in 2013 and is forecasted to exceed $16 billion in 2014 (China E-commerce Research Center) For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 10 METHODOLOGY Selection The focus of this report is on Western brands – specifically those headquartered in Europe, North America and Australia. Relative to brands based in Asia, we believe those in the West face greater cultural and business challenges in establishing brand relevancy among Chinese consumers. We compiled our final list of 300 companies following our evaluation of hundreds of companies through an algorithmic scan of the market. Those included had the highest degree of impact on the Chinese consumer. Brand Categories The list of 300 brands were placed into 7 categories: Luxury Chanel, Prada, Hermes Accessible Luxury Coach, Marc Jacobs, Kenzo Contemporary Kate Spade, Longchamp, Tory Burch High Street Zara, Adidas, H&M Categorization After compiling our list of 300 brands, we organized them into comparable peer sets, built on three dimensions: •Primary Product Line: We recognize that many of our profiled brands sell multiple product categories like apparel, fragrances and timepieces. However, most brands selling to Chinese consumers are predominantly known for certain product types. Beauty and Cosmetics Clinique, Sephora, Lancôme Jewelry, Watches, Accessories Cartier, Rolex, Swarowski Multi-brand Retailers Asos, Galeries Lafayette, Neiman Marcus •Brand vs. Retailer: Retailers and classic brands have different characteristics and must be evaluated accordingly. •Pricing Category: Many brands have multiple lines at various price points ranging from the most prominent label to diffusion labels (e.g., Burberry Prorsum vs. Burberry vs. Burberry Brit). For the purpose of this report, we considered the most prominent line for the brand (e.g., Burberry) in the context of the Chinese market. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 11 METHODOLOGY Inputs and Outputs About the Algorithm •Incorporating Disparate Data Sets: To control for the many different types of variables in our data set, we normalized all the data points according to the distribution of the variables. Using factor analyses, our Data Science and Analytics team isolated weights for different clusters of variables. •Defining Sub-Categories: Separate factor analyses were run for each of the dimensions (Reach, Engagement and Experience). We then used logistic regression analyses to determine Reach, Engagement and Experience sub-scores for each brand. •Outlier Management: In parallel, we ran a second model that standardized the value of each data point around its mean to account for outliers. We then combined the two statistical models to derive three sub-scores (one for Reach, one for Engagement and one for Experience) for each brand. Data Sources Our scan revealed over 250 discrete data points that provide a cohesive look into how brands are interacting with the Chinese consumer. A data taxonomy was created to map each data point to the most relevant channels. •Social Media: Weibo, WeChat, Youku, etc. •Search: Organic ranking, Baidu Knowledge, Baidu Brandzone, etc. •PR/KOL: Top KOL mentions, Nice app fans, KOL blogs, etc. •Mobile: Availability of mobile app, Quality of mobile experience, Availability of click-to-call feature, etc. •Website: Load time, ICP license, Availability of Chinese language website, etc. •E-commerce: Price markup, Delivery time, Acceptance of Chinese credit cards, etc. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 12 METHODOLOGY DIMENSIONS REACH ENGAGEMENT EXPERIENCE Definition Degree to which the brand has achieved awareness with the Chinese consumer. Cumulative interaction and affinity consumers demonstrate towards the brand. Extent to which the brand is providing a positive platform for target consumers. Sample Evaluative Questions • What is your Baidu Search Index on PC and mobile devices? • How actively engaged are your Weibo fans with the content you provide? • How long does it take to receive your products from order time to delivery? • Are popular KOLs talking about your brand? • How many brand fans do you have on different social media channels? • Do you accept Alipay? • How many (authentic and fake) products related to your brand are on Tmall and on Taobao? • Are consumers currently discussing and generating content on your brand? • Are there any “viral” videos of your brand on Youku? 1 • What do consumers think about your in-store experience? • Baidu Search Index (PC and Mobile) – for a brand’s English and/or Chinese name • Average number of Weibo comments and reposts (over last 100 posts) Sample Data Points • Number of brand mentions by top fashion KOLs • Number of products related to your brand on Taobao and on Tmall 2 • Number of Youku videos about your brand that have generated over 200,000 views • Number of brand mentions on fashion-focused forums such as Melishuo or Nice • Whether brand has an updated Baidu Bai-ke • How much does it cost to purchase your product(s)? • Do you provide Chinese language customer support? • Typical delivery time • Whether the brand accepts Alipay • Average price markup 3 • Availability of Chinese language customer service options (e.g., local phone support, live chat, email) • Average rating on Dianping Footnotes: 1:We define “viral” as any video with over 200,000 views 2: Even though some brand-related products on Taobao are not authentic, the total number of products on Taobao (including fake products) serve as an indicator for the popularity of the brand 3:In calculating this price markup, we took a basket of the most popular products from the brand and determined the average “all-in” price including shipping, duties, etc. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 13 METHODOLOGY understanding the score How we ranked the 300 brands (pages 15-19): For each brand, we first determined 3 sub-scores that independently measure a brand’s Reach, Engagement and Experience with the digital Chinese consumer. To fully reflect the gradations in brand performance, the three sub-scores and final score were individually normalized on a scale from 0 to 1000. Each brand then received a composite final score that factored in the three sub-scores. The composite score determined the brand’s final ranking. We recognize important differences exist among the categories. However, we believe there are some critical, objective measures of success for which all brands can strive. How to interpret the category-specific rankings (see table below for page numbers): We also separated the 300 brands into 7 categories with more comparable peers, and re-ranked them within the category. We then assigned letter grades based on an academic distribution curve to assess each brand’s Reach, Engagement and Experience performance. Category Rankings Page Numbers Luxury p20 Accessible Luxury p23 Interpreting Category Ranking Table RANK 1 BRANDS score 780 Reach A+ Engagement Experience A+ A F Contemporary p26 High Street p29 p32 Beauty Jewelry, Watches, Accessories p35 Brand rank within the category Total composite score Brands received individually normalized scores for Reach, Engagement and Experience. We converted the scores to letter grades using academic distribution curves. p38 Multi-brand Retailers For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 14 Top 300 brand rankings Rank brand Rank brand Rank 1 21 41 2 22 42 3 23 43 4 24 44 5 25 45 6 26 46 7 27 47 8 28 48 9 29 49 10 30 50 11 31 51 12 32 52 13 33 53 14 34 54 15 35 55 16 36 56 17 37 57 18 38 58 39 59 40 60 19 brand LOUIS VUITTON 20 Footnote: Color shading denotes decile For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 15 Top 300 brand rankings RANK brand Rank brand Rank 61 81 101 62 82 102 63 83 103 64 84 104 65 85 105 66 86 106 67 87 107 68 88 108 69 89 109 70 90 110 71 91 111 72 92 112 73 93 113 74 94 114 75 95 115 76 96 116 77 97 117 78 98 118 79 99 119 80 100 120 brand Footnote: Color shading denotes decile For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 16 Top 300 brand rankings Rank brand Rank brand Rank 121 141 161 122 142 162 123 143 163 124 144 164 125 145 165 126 146 166 127 147 167 128 148 168 129 149 169 130 150 170 131 151 171 132 152 172 133 153 173 134 154 174 135 155 175 136 156 176 137 157 177 138 158 178 139 159 179 140 160 180 brand Footnote: Color shading denotes decile For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 17 Top 300 brand rankings Rank brand Rank brand Rank 181 201 221 182 202 222 183 203 223 184 204 224 185 205 225 186 206 226 187 207 227 188 208 228 189 209 229 190 210 230 191 211 231 192 212 232 193 213 233 194 214 234 195 215 235 196 216 236 197 217 237 198 218 238 199 219 239 200 220 240 brand Footnote: Color shading denotes decile For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 18 Top 300 brand rankings Rank brand Rank brand Rank 241 261 281 242 262 282 243 263 283 244 264 284 245 265 285 246 266 286 247 267 287 248 268 288 249 269 289 250 270 290 251 271 291 252 272 292 253 273 293 254 274 294 255 275 295 256 276 296 257 277 297 258 278 298 259 279 299 260 280 300 brand Footnote: Color shading denotes decile For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 19 LUXURY RANKINGS RANK BRANDS score Reach Engagement Experience 1 780 A+ A+ F 2 777 A+ A+ F 3 762 A A+ F 4 739 B+ A- A 729 A A F 6 708 A- A F 7 696 A- A- D- 8 687 B- B- A+ 9 685 A- A- F 10 672 B- A F 11 671 C A F 12 671 B C A 13 650 B B F 14 644 C- A F 15 615 B- B- F 16 602 C- C- A+ 17 586 C- B- F 18 583 C C+ F 19 571 C C F 20 565 C+ D A 21 559 D- A F 22 559 D C A 23 551 C- C- F 24 541 D+ C- F 25 522 D B- F 5 LOUIS VUITTON 1. CHANEL 2. DIOR 3. GUCCI 4. ARMANI 5. LOUIS VUITTON 6. HERMES 7. VALENTINO 8. BALENCIAGA 9. GIVENCHY 10. VERSACE 11. CHLOE 12. DOLCE & GABBANA 13. FENDI 14. PRADA 15. SALVATORE FERRAGAMO 16. BALLY 17. LANVIN 18. VICTORIA BECKHAM 19. BOTTEGA VENETA 20. ALEXANDER MCQUEEN 21. CELINE 22. MONCLER 23. ERMENEGILDO ZEGNA 24. LOEWE 25. SAINT LAURENT 26. ROGER VIVIER 27. MARNI 28. TOM FORD 29. JEAN PAUL GAULTIER 30. ETRO 31. LA PERLA 32. ALFRED DUNHILL 33. EMILIO PUCCI 34. GOYARD 35. MANOLO BLAHNIK 36. CHARLOTTE OLYMPIA 37. CAROLINA HERRERA 38. MAISON MARTIN MARGIELA 39. BALMAIN PARIS 40. MISSONI 41. JIMMY CHOO 42. JIL SANDER 43. LORO PIANA 44. CHRISTIAN LOUBOUTIN 45. OSCAR DE LA RENTA For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 20 LUXURY INSIGHTS Reach: Highest average Baidu Search Index score among all fashion brand categories Luxury brands must pay more attention to their visibility within Baidu. Today, 44% of Luxury brands do not rank first organically for their brand name within Baidu, and 42% of them have yet to establish a Baidu Brandzone. High Correlation (.86) between Baidu Search Index & Baidu Bai-ke Popular channels for Luxury brand research (e.g., Baidu Bai-ke) must reflect the desired brand image—and companies must maintain them. Although all Luxury brands have a Baidu Bai-ke page, 71% have not been updated since 2013. Engagement: Highest correlation between Number of Weibo Fans & Fan Engagement Across the 300 brands, correlation between the “Number of Fans” and “Fan Engagement” on Weibo is insignificant (.49). However, this correlation is much stronger and significant within Luxury brands (.83). Highest correlation between Baidu Search Index & Mentions in Secondary UGC Social Platforms Luxury consumers searching for brands become consumers who show off their products online. There is a strong correlation between Baidu Search Index and social sharing / photo sites such as Topit.me (.84). Experience: 71% of Luxury brands have a Chinese language website Luxury brands have developed localized experiences and performed solidly in this area. The majority (60%) have developed Chinese names and 76% offer Chinese language customer support. Only 28% of Luxury brands currently ship to China and even fewer price effectively After successfully courting fans, Luxury brands leave those fans “at the altar” when they fail to facilitate transactions. Of the 28% of Luxury brands that ship to China, only 4% provide a price markup of 35% or lower. Grey and black market for Luxury goods dwarf other categories on Taobao Average Number of Products per Brand on Taobao Average Number of Sellers per Brand on Taobao SUMMARY Fans in the Luxury category are engaged, loyal and act as brand advocates. Luxury brands must capitalize on opportunities to convert these enthusiasts into buyers. Because Luxury brand loyalists often cannot shop directly online, resellers and non-authorized merchants have profited within China’s e-commerce industry. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 21 LUXURY success STORY Strength OPPORTUNITY REACH Generated the most exposure by leading KOLs on Weibo based on KOL mentions and size of fan base, edging out Christian Louboutin. It’s the #1 Luxury brand sold on Taobao stores – while it demonstrates popularity, this is most likely not how Chanel leadership is looking to promote its brand. ENGAGEMENT Most represented Luxury brand on premier Chinese photo sharing site, Topit.me (Chinese version of Luvocracy), with more than double the number of images of the runner-up, Valentino. Relative to the size of its Weibo fan base, engagement level per follower is well below competitors, with average comments per Weibo fan only 10% of Chloé’s and less than category average. EXPERIENCE One of only a handful of Luxury brands to have both a Chinese language mobile app and a Chinese mobile-optimized site. Chinese mobile optimization is a strong plus, but mixing simplified Chinese with traditional Chinese, news columns in English and YouTube videos are all missteps. Weibo brand impressions for leading luxury players in 2 weeks in August Footnote: Weibo brand impressions is a measurement of KOL contribution to brand awareness. We define it as the number of mentions on Weibo by 154 leading Chinese KOLs multiplied by the number of each KOL’s Weibo followers SUMMARY Chanel is the most desired and discussed brand in our analysis. As in the West, the brand communicates its story and values effectively. However, a lack of commitment to e-commerce will continue to embolden Taobao operators to grow the black market for Chanel’s products. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 22 accessible LUXURY RANKINGS RANK BRANDS SCORE Reach Engagement Experience 1 791 A+ A A- 2 785 A A A+ 3 649 B- C- A 4 642 B B F 5 625 C+ B F 6 619 C B F 7 613 C C+ D- 8 601 D+ C- A 9 557 D+ D+ A+ 10 556 D+ C+ F 11 555 C- C F 12 544 D- B+ F 13 544 D+ C- D- 14 538 C- C- F 15 520 D+ C- F 16 519 D- B F 17 514 D+ D+ F 18 511 D C F 19 505 D+ D+ F 20 482 D- C- F 21 455 D D+ F 22 454 D+ D F 23 453 D D+ F 24 440 D- D+ F 25 429 F C- F 1. BURBERRY 2. COACH 3. ALEXANDER WANG 4. KENZO 5. VERA WANG 6. MARC JACOBS 7. MICHAEL KORS 8. HUGO BOSS 9. STELLA MCCARTNEY 10. TOD’S 11. MOSCHINO 12. MIU MIU 13. 3.1 PHILLIP LIM 14. PORTS 1961 15. PAUL SMITH 16. RALPH LAUREN 17. MAX MARA 18. VIVIENNE WESTWOOD 19. MULBERRY 20. HOGAN 21. JASON WU 22. CARVEN 23. ROBERTO CAVALLI 24. DSQUARED2 25. JEREMY SCOTT 26. Acne 27. ESCADA 28. DEREK LAM 29. HELMUT LANG 30. SERGIO ROSSI 31. TRUSSARDI 1911 32. Viktor & rolf 33. PROENZA SCHOULER 34. AGENT PROVOCATEUR 35. NICHOLAS KIRKWOOD 36. DONNA KARAN 37. SPORTMAX 38. BADGLEY MISCHKA 39. MSGM 40. PREEN 41. REED KRAKOFF 42. JOHN VARVATOS 43. PETER PILOTTO 44. BELSTAFF 45. SMYTHSON . For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 23 accessible LUXURY INSIGHTS Reach: Very strong correlation (.93) between Baidu Search Index & Weibo fan count As search interest increases, this category’s users become more engaged by joining a brand’s Weibo account. Fan interest generally centers around a particular line or product rather than brand itself Consumer interest is narrowly focused on a hot item. For example, the Pashli bag makes up a significant percentage of all 3.1 Phillip Lim products on Taobao and is mentioned 1.6x more than the brand name itself among KOLs on Weibo. Engagement: Luxury fans comment or repost 2.8x more often than Accessible Luxury fans Relative lack of consumer understanding of the brands in this category makes them difficult to discuss. Search indexes have a high correlation (.76) with Nice App As the Nice app focuses on products to tag with brand names, Accessible Luxury brands greatly benefit through their popular “it” items. Experience: High price markups have led to 39% more products on Taobao than their fashion peers Popularity of “it products” and high all-in prices through official channels create a feeding frenzy on Taobao where sellers compete with one another on price. Customers are dismayed about limitations of in-store experience Category has the lowest in-store rating on Dianping (2.9 stars out of 5). Most complaints involve the price differentiation between Chinese and international stores. Accessible Luxury brands trail peers in user engagement and satisfaction on Dianping Average Number of Reviews per Store Listing 7.9 11.5 21.6 CONTEMPORARY LUXURY 92.2 Average Store Star Rating ACCESSIBLE LUXURY HIGH STREET SUMMARY Accessible Luxury brands are, for many Chinese, “the new kid on the block.” They have specific products breaking through consumers’ consciousness. The key is to turn product awareness into overall brand loyalty. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 24 accessible LUXURY success STORY Strength OPPORTUNITY REACH Burberry is the top overall performer in video. Burberry Brit’s 2014 Spring/Summer collection received a high of 5.6M Youku views. WeChat and Weibo posts are sporadic and can go dormant for periods of time. ENGAGEMENT Burberry is the #1 brand on the 6 leading Bulletin Board Systems with 16x more mentions than its category peer average. Can increase fan activity, which is low on a per-fan basis on multiple social channels compared to competitors like Kenzo and Alexander McQueen. EXPERIENCE Out of the 90 Luxury and Accessible Luxury brands in our Index, Burberry alone has an official Tmall store. Tmall store is innovative, but lacking. The same Bloomsbury handbag has 4 styles showing on its Tmall store, but 27 on Burberry’s Chinese website. Top 10 Accessible Luxury brands by number of mentions on 6 leading Bulletin Boards 1.8M JEREMY SCOTT 17.8M COACH 3.9M VERA WANG 8.9M MIU MIU 3.3M KENZO 21.5M BURBERRY 1.3M MOSCHINO 1.6M TOD’S 3.7M MARC JACOBS 2.0M MICHAEL KORS SUMMARY Burberry is the #1 brand overall on our list for good reason; it leverages many channels and has a consistent voice and engaging content. At the bottom of the funnel, it converts the customer via a fully localized website and Tmall partnership. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 25 CONTEMPORARY Rankings RANK BRANDS SCORE Reach Engagement Experience 1 687 D+ A A- 2 681 B- B- A- 3 669 C+ B+ D+ 4 654 C+ A F 5 644 B B F 6 629 C+ B F 7 622 C- C A+ 8 606 C- B+ F 9 604 C B- F 10 602 C- B- F 11 570 C- C F 12 566 C- C F 13 558 D+ C+ F 14 553 D+ B- F 15 544 D+ C F 16 533 D+ D+ B+ 17 519 D+ D+ F 18 515 D C F 19 507 D+ C- F 20 495 D C- F 21 475 D+ D+ F 22 470 D- C- F 23 462 D+ D+ F 24 460 D+ D+ F 25 451 F D+ D 1. UGG 2. LACOSTE 3. JUICY COUTURE 4. ECCO 5. CALVIN KLEIN 6. GUESS 7. TOMMY HILFIGER 8. DIESEL 9. KATE SPADE 10. LONGCHAMP 11. FURLA 12. TORY BURCH 13. ANNA SUI 14. ASH 15. ABERCROMBIE & FITCH 16. 7 FOR ALL MANKIND 17. NAUTICA 18. TUMI 19. STUART WEITZMAN 20. CLUB MONACO 21. DIANE VON FURSTENBERG 22. THEORY 23. AGNES B. 24. ALICE + OLIVIA 25. J.Crew 26. BEBE 27. HUNTER 28. REBECCA MINKOFF 29. MASSIMO DUTTI 30. TED BAKER LONDON 31. REPETTO 32. SANDRO 33. MAX&CO. 34. EQUIPMENT 35. KENNETH COLE 36. VINCE CAMUTO 37. FRENCH CONNECTION 38. COLE HAAN 39. VINCE 40. J BRAND 41. BROOKS BROTHERS 42. AllSaints 43. BANANA REPUBLIC 44. JEFFREY CAMPBELL 45. RAG&BONE 46. DESIGUAL 47. ST.JOHN 48. SAM EDELMAN 49. BCBGMAXAZRIA 50. ANNE KLEIN 51. ANN TAYLOR 52. BETSEY JOHNSON 53. THOMAS PINK 54. DIRK BIKKEMBERGS 55. ELIZABETH AND JAMES 56. REISS 57. L.K.BENNETT 58. VANESSA BRUNO 59. IVANKA TRUMP 60. NANETTE LEPORE 61. NICOLE MILLER 62. REBECCA TAYLOR 63. COMPTOIR DES COTONNIERS 64. GANT 65. WHISTLES 66. AG ADRIANO GOLDSCHMIED 67. LAFAYETTE 148 NEW YORK For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 26 CONTEMPORARY INSIGHTS Reach: Only 58% of Contemporary brands have a Weibo presence and less than 33% have an official Chinese website Contemporary brands have the lowest investment in setting up official brand presences in China across social, search and branding. Exceptionally weak correlation across all major variables Contemporary brands have the lowest correlation among peers due to often unintegrated marketing and their ineffective use of complementary platforms. Engagement: Compared with other fashion brand categories, Contemporary brands see on average 40% less engagement Brand outreach is the main reason: Contemporary brands on average respond less to fan comments on social platforms than their peers. Correlation between KOL mentions and user discussions is virtually non-existent Contemporary brands are often mentioned only by specific shopping-related KOLs who post frequently (~30 posts per day) about deals and promotions. Experience: While over 40% ship to China, over 3/4 of those brands place a high price markup frequently hidden in the form of exorbitant shipping fees Chinese consumers are sensitive to the “all-in” price of a product, which includes any potential shipping and duties costs. Only 19% of Contemporary brands have Chinese language customer service, while only 15% provide email support in Chinese Given the high price markup for products, Chinese consumers need better customer support to understand shipping policies. Yet Contemporary brands offer the lowest service levels. Contemporary brands lag peers in key Reach categories Brandzone Presence Weibo Presence WeChat Subscription Account Presence WeChat Service Account Presence Youku Presence Douban Presence Has An Official Chinese Name Has Chinese Language Website Contemporary 3% 58% 27% 9% 3% 2% 16% 33% Accessible Luxury 7% 61% 29% 5% 5% 10% 21% 34% Luxury 31% 82% 29% 18% 20% 4% 60% 71% High Street 22% 78% 42% 20% 5% 20% 34% 66% SUMMARY Contemporary brands as a whole look to “get married” before the first date — they want consumers to commit first before they make a reciprocal investment. They need more upstream activity to create brand interest and greater investment downstream to turn interest into purchases and loyalty. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 27 CONTEMPORARY success STORY Strength OPPORTUNITY REACH UGG has approximately 4 million Baidu Bai-ke views, 10x the average of its peers. UGG’s number of Nice fans trail category average by 33% and peers like Juicy Couture and Diesel by a wider margin. Nice is the perfect app for UGG’s target consumer base. ENGAGEMENT Very respectable 49 user reviews per location across its Shanghai stores on Dianping, 2.2x higher than the average brand within this category. Weibo user discussion is 10.4x higher than the average brand in this category. But Daigou resellers lead the discussions. They are 15 of the first 20 users displayed when searching for UGG within Weibo; 12 of them have larger fan followings than UGG’s official account. EXPERIENCE Differs from other brands within this category with an editorialized tone of voice on its WeChat. Includes inspirational photos to help illustrate its brand story, which complement its clever use of WeChat features. Most products have a 95%+ price markup in China compared to the U.S. price. Given Chinese consumers’ awareness of foreign prices, the high markup has yielded 24K products on Taobao sold by over 3K unauthorized sellers (2.8x the average). UGG leverages emotional imagery and voice on Wechat to entice user UGG Moment - “Experience the Irreplaceable” Nautica – “Evolution of the Classic Stripes” VS. UGG = Inspirational and emotion focused SUMMARY UGG reflects the common challenge for this category relative to its peers. UGG outperforms its category competitors with a true investment in online and offline markets. Yet, UGG struggles to get consumers to “lean in” and engage at the same level as other category leaders. A common refrain in user feedback is the “lack of differentiation” as either an aspirational line or fast fashion that can consistently excite younger consumers. Nautica = Standard productoriented images For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 28 high street Rankings RANK BRANDS SCORE Reach Engagement Experience 1 789 A A A- 2 787 B A+ A+ 3 770 A- A A+ 4 758 B+ A A 5 721 B B+ A+ 6 714 B B A+ 7 706 C+ B+ A+ 8 698 A- A F 9 693 C A+ F 10 692 A B+ F 11 683 C B+ A 12 681 D+ A- A+ 13 655 B- A- F 14 633 D+ B C 15 571 C- C+ F 16 556 D- B+ F 17 549 D+ B- F 18 539 D+ C- D- 19 517 D C F 20 500 D+ D C- 21 495 D+ D+ F 22 487 D- D A+ 23 486 F B- C- 24 480 D+ D C- 25 471 D C- F 1. ADIDAS 2. NIKE 3. CONVERSE 4. ZARA 5. PUMA 6. LEVI’S 7. MANGO 8. NEW BALANCE 9. LEE 10. VANS 11. FOREVER 21 12. GAP 13. H&M 14. CROCS 15. TOPSHOP 16. VICTORIA’S SECRET 17. NINE WEST 18. AMERICAN APPAREL 19. C&A 20. FREE PEOPLE 21. BERSHKA 22. OLD NAVY 23. NEXT 24. AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS 25. STEVE MADDEN 26. ROXY 27. PULL & BEAR 28. SUPERDRY 29. WILDFOX 30. TOMS 31. HAVAIANAS 32. NEW LOOK 33. QUIKSILVER 34. JOAN & DAVID 35. RIVER ISLAND 36. UNITED COLORS OF BENETTON 37. PRIMARK 38. ANTHROPOLOGIE 39. MISS SELFRIDGE 40. LUCKY BRAND 41. JOE FRESH For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 29 high street INSIGHTS Reach: High Street brands have the highest average number of Weibo fans among fashion brands On average, High Street brands have ~254,000 fans on Weibo, 40% higher than the average brand. High Street brands with a Weibo account have total scores that are 20% higher than competitors without Weibo accounts on key search indexes. High Street brands are not leveraging the full extent of search services Only 28% of High Street brands invested in Baidu Brandzone, and only 7% have used Baidu’s Official Customer Support Listing. Engagement: High correlation between number of physical retail stores and user-generated engagement High Street brands have the highest average number of physical locations, which has a strong and positive correlation to online engagement in areas such as Weibo mentions by users (.79). Although brands without retail locations have a lower fan count, their fans are 1.3x more likely to repost, and 3x as likely to comment as brands with a retail footprint Topics such as cross-border commerce, also known as Haitao, are growing as discussion points. Experience: Only 7% of High Street brands with retail presence provide store directions with a China map plug-in Lack of use of China map plug-ins and other physical location tie-ins confuse the user. High Street brands with a 35%+ price markup have almost twice as many products on Taobao 21% of High Street brands charge over 35% in price markup when shipping into China. However, only half accept Alipay or Chinese credit cards. Price markup compared with level of payment services provided SUMMARY High Street brands that have invested in retail locations in China should pay attention to online/offline integration. Even high-performing brands like Converse—with stores in 31 provinces and an active presence on Weibo, WeChat, Douban and Youku—fail to make references to local store locations across all their digital channels. In the last year, this has led to over 25,000 questions on Baidu Knowledge about where to find Converse stores. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 30 high street success STORY Strength OPPORTUNITY REACH Most Weibo followers in category (6x more than Nike’s main Weibo). Average of 8x the reposts per post and 7x the comments per post of its peers. Currently much lower KOL amplification than other leading High Street brands; Forever 21 has 10x and Converse 8x more KOL impressions than Adidas. ENGAGEMENT Tied with Zara for most brand-related photo posts on leading UGC platform, Meilishuo, with more than 38K pictures, miles ahead of its closest competitor Topshop with 7K. Brand-related content is not getting the same level of reception on Toutiao relative to peers in the category. Adidas has 9.3 saves and 7.3 likes in brand-related articles, which are 75% and 30% lower than the category averages, respectively. EXPERIENCE Provides key options including a highquality, fully mobile-optimized version of its Chinese website, click-to-call in Chinese, and a Chinese-language mobile app. Doesn’t provide consumers estimated delivery time even after placing an order* or accept payment on delivery, unlike other competitors such as Converse and Nike. * Note: our staff attempted to contact via email and Weibo but did not receive a reply Top 5 Brands’ Weibo Engagement Metrics by: Number of comments per post 1 2 3 4 5 Number of reposts per post 244 190 123 96 44 1 2 3 4 5 97 95 75 64 21 SUMMARY Adidas was an early mover in owning its China retail presence, establishing a position that entrenched it against large aggressive challengers (such as Nike) in consumers’ hearts and minds. Consumers have welcomed the move into fashion with Adidas Originals, ensuring fresh positioning and continued brand loyalty. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 31 BEAUTY & cosmetics Rankings RANK BRANDS SCORE Reach Engagement Experience 1 768 A A A 2 753 A- A- A+ 3 752 A- A- A+ 4 750 A A- A 5 736 B A- A+ 6 733 B+ A- A 7 730 B A- A 8 729 C+ A A 9 693 A- A- F 10 686 B- B- A 11 681 C- B+ A 12 673 A B F 13 661 B+ B+ F 14 658 B- C A 15 639 C A- F 16 632 C- C A+ 17 617 D B- A+ 18 600 B- C+ F 19 590 C- D+ A+ 20 580 C- C F 21 551 C- C- F 22 447 D D+ F 23 427 D D F 24 390 F D+ F 25 384 D D- F 1. LANCOME 2. ESTEE LAUDER 3. SEPHORA 4. KIEHLS SINCE 1851 5. CLINIQUE 6. LA MER 7. BENEFIT 8. M.A.C 9. L’OREAL 10. CLARINS 11. ORIGINS 12. MAYBELLINE 13. GUERLAIN 14. SISLEY PARIS 15. FRESH 16. BOBBI BROWN 17. L’OCCITANE 18. MARY KAY 19. CLARISONIC 20. JURLIQUE 21. ELIZABETH ARDEN 22. NARS 23. JO MALONE 24. PHILOSOPHY 25. MAKEUP FOREVER 26. LAURA MERCIER 27. URBAN DECAY For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 32 BEAUTY & cosmetics INSIGHTS Reach: Among all the categories, Beauty has the highest Reach footprint 93% of beauty companies have a Weibo presence compared to only 69% of all companies in our index. Beauty brands have the best known Chinese names Chinese name searches for Beauty brands are 2-3x higher than other categories, reflecting their localization efforts. Engagement: Consumers have greater accessibility and more favorable in-store experiences with Beauty companies, which is reflected in their Dianping rating In Shanghai, there were on average 9 Dianping store listings for Beauty brands - 33% more than all brands. Sephora leads the category with 30 store listings. Consumers also gave beauty brands 39% higher ratings than their peer average. Some user-generated platforms provide less upside for Beauty brands Social channels that focus on highly visual images, such as Meilishuo, Mogujie and Nice, are less effective for Beauty brands since their products are more difficult to display. Experience: Reflecting their maturity in China, Beauty brands provide the greatest level of localization in both positioning and product curation Beauty brands are 2x more likely to have both an official Chinese name and a Chinese website. Both their e-commerce and retail stores cater to their target consumers’ preferences, with a much more tailored offering. Beauty is the dominant category leader in providing a positive e-commerce experience Beauty brands are 2x more likely to have payment and delivery options that are friendly to the consumer (e.g., accepting Alipay, posting prices in RMB, and shipping to China). 48% of Beauty brands have an e-commerce FAQ, and they are 4x more likely to have Chinese live chat options. The strength of Beauty brands in key experience metrics Payment and Delivery Place Orders in RMB Prices Displayed in RMB Accepts Alipay Accepts Chinese Billing Address Ships to China Beauty Brands 52% 52% 52% 52% 52% All Brands 24% 24% 18% 38% 39% Customer Service and Localization Efforts Availability of Chinese Customer Service Line Availability of Chinese Live Chat Chinese E-Commerce FAQ Has Official Chinese Name Has Chinese Website Beauty Brands 81% 30% 48% 81% 93% All Brands 34% 7% 20% 40% 55% SUMMARY Reflecting their tenure in the Chinese market (the first foreign cosmetics company entered China in 1980), Beauty is the clear leader across all 7 categories, with 75% of Beauty brands in the top third of our rankings. This raises the bar for new entrants and smaller brands to compete effectively, as the incumbents have invested significantly in localization and consumer outreach and engagement. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 33 BEAUTY & cosmetics SUCCESS STORY Strength OPPORTUNITY REACH Given its high search volume, Lancôme has invested wisely in its search strategy. It has an optimized Baidu Brandzone that links to popular products and promotions, and its official Chinese website appears 4 times within first page of Baidu (vs. category average of 2.7). Its English-language website (which does not geo-direct China-based users to the Chinese website) appears as the second result on the first page of Baidu search results. This is a disruption to its otherwise good search performance. ENGAGEMENT Strategically enlists different types of KOLs at various points in the consumer journey. Trendsetting bloggers introduce new products, followed by influential beauty bloggers posting tutorials and reviews. Finally, shopping bloggers share promotions. Frequently uses raffles on Weibo for shortterm benefit. From Aug. 28 to Sept. 1, four raffles resulted in growth of 500+ new fans/day. Yet average fan growth dropped 89% the following week. EXPERIENCE Capitalized on Chinese consumers’ habit of giving brand and product nicknames by creating catchy names for its most popular products, such as the translated term “Little Black Bottle” for Advanced Genifique. Lancôme provides subpar customer service for first time and mobile users. Live chat is offered only for members and is not offered on mobile devices. Click-to-call is hidden on a dropdown menu on mobile. Lancôme strategically leverages KOLs to support user journey 1) Inital broadcast to drive Awareness Fashion/beauty focused website Haibao with 587K fans on Weibo posted Lancôme's new summer lip product for wide broadcast. 2) Makeup tutorial to drive Intent to Purchase Beauty blogger 讨厌讨厌 5200 with 115K fans posted a tutorial on how to achieve a highly trendy look using Lancôme’s new lip products. 3) Promotion to drive Conversion Shopping blog Deal Moon frequently posts about the newest Lancôme sales and promotions, both of which stimulate conversion. SUMMARY With a long history in the China market, Lancôme provides a well-rounded customer experience with each element in its digital marketing arsenal. This allows potential consumers to have a holistic, smooth experience throughout the consumer journey. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 34 Jewelry, watches and accessories Rankings RANK BRANDS SCORE Reach Engagement Experience 1 744 B A A- 2 702 A A F 3 693 B B- B+ 4 680 A- A- F 5 677 A- A- F 6 670 A B F 7 665 B+ B+ F 8 658 A B- F 9 640 C C+ B- 10 625 C+ B F 11 620 C- C- A+ 12 618 B C+ F 13 618 C B F 14 599 B- C+ F 15 559 C- C- F 16 558 D+ B- F 17 552 C+ D+ F 18 542 D B F 19 539 D C+ F 20 506 D+ D+ F 21 501 D+ C- F 22 498 D+ D+ F 23 489 D+ D+ F 24 485 D C- F 25 483 D- C- F 1. SWAROVSKI 2. CARTIER 3. RAY-BAN 4. LONGINES 5. OMEGA 6. TIFFANY & CO. 7. BVLGARI 8. PIAGET 9. FOLLI FOLLIE 10. TISSOT 11. FOSSIL 12. MONTBLANC 13. SWATCH 14. VAN CLEEF & ARPELS 15. VACHERON CONSTANTIN 16. PANDORA 17. BLANCPAIN 18. ROLEX 19. CHAUMET 20. TAG HEUER 21. GIRARD-PERREGAUX 22. CHOPARD 23. BOUCHERON 24. TIMEX 25. ZENITH 26. IWC SCHAFFHAUSEN 27. AUDEMARS PIGUET 28. BREGUET 29. HARRY WINSTON 30. PATEK PHILIPPE 31. TUDOR 32. POMELLATO 33. LINKS OF LONDON 34. PAMELA LOVE 35. IPPOLITA 36. TACORI For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 35 JEWELRY, WATCHES AND ACCESSORIES INSIGHTS Reach: Chinese names are better known than English names Most Accessory brand consumers are older and less proficient in English, so these companies have invested more in branding their Chinese names. This yields better reach and brand recall and allows Western brands to compete with domestic brands such as Chow Tai Fook. Accessory brands make a large investment in establishing an official online presence, but they have average scores in Reach Accessory brands are visible on an average of 4.3 Chinese online social platforms (average for all brands is 2.7). However, their average Reach score is ranked third, behind Beauty and Luxury brands. Engagement: Accessory brands have the highest average number of comments per fan on retailer-focused discussion boards and sites Accessory consumers predominantly make purchases at offline retail locations across the country, so fans often leave customer service comments under Weibo posts and want to interact with the brand within their Weibo page. However, even brands that rank in the top 5 often ignore legitimate complaints and questions. While Accessory brands have made a significant investment in creating video assets, consumer views and engagement are relatively low 9 out of 10 Accessory brands have created an official brand channel on Youku. However, only 1% of their videos receive more than 200,000 views. Experience: 75% of Accessory brands have a mobile-optimized Chinese website A majority of Accessory brands have developed a Chinese mobile website to better optimize mobile users’ shopping experience. Despite the high volume of mobile-generated searches, only 44% of the indexed companies invested in mobile search advertising 61% of brands who advertise on mobile provide a link to their store locator via the Google Map plugin, which does not function properly in China. Mobile user investment largely remains superficial OUT OF ALL ACCESSORY BRANDS 75% HAVE CHINESE MOBILE SITE 44% INVESTED IN PAID SEARCH ON MOBILE 27% LINK TO STORE LOCATOR WITHIN PAID SEARCH 0% USE VIEWABLE CHINESE MAP PLUGIN SUMMARY Mobile plays a huge part in how potential Chinese consumers interact with brands, so it is important for companies to deliver a consistent, premium experience. Although some Accessory brands have sought to create great user experiences on mobile, there’s still a disconnect between the online and offline experience. From providing functional directions and store plug-ins to click-tocall opportunities and online customer support, these brands need to better streamline the online shopping experience for Chinese consumers. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 36 JEWELRY, WATCHES AND ACCESSORIES SUCCESS STORY Strength Opportunity REACH One of the best performers across several key Baidu metrics including both PC and mobile Baidu Search Index, Baidu Bai-ke views, and Baidu News mentions. While brand is strong in Baidu, it has not updated its Bai-ke page since 2013. Consumers are willing and eager to engage – only to find outdated products and messaging. ENGAGEMENT Users ask 2.7x more questions about Swarovski on Baidu Knowledge than other brands in the category. Questions involve both the brand and its products. UGC answers typically include “high quality” and “among best in the world.” Highly reviewed on UGC review sites, but the average rating and feedback is less positive compared to peers like Pandora, Tiffany & Co., Chaumet and Van Cleef & Arpels. EXPERIENCE Among our 37 Accessory brands that ship to China, Swarovski is the only brand that offers dedicated Chinese language customer service via live chat, email, and a toll-free line. While Swarovski uses Alipay as a payment option, it should join other leading brands to accept payment via Chinese credit card (i.e., China UnionPay). SUMMARY While Swarovski does an exceptional job with most of the key e-commerce features, to thrive online in China it needs to address the large pricing disparity between their Chinese and Western sites. Our calculated difference for Swarovski is on average greater than 50% vs. prices in the U.S. Swarovski’s high quality customer service page showing various contact method options Two customer service lines, (800-819-0021) one of which is toll free Customer Service Time Email Live Chat Accepts Alipay and pay on delivery For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 37 multi-brand RETAILERS Rankings RANK BRANDS SCORE Reach Engagement Experience 1 667 B- C+ A 2 551 C- C- D- 3 520 D D+ C- 4 472 D D A 5 462 D D D+ 6 454 F C+ F 7 433 F D A 8 420 D D F 9 414 D- D F 10 396 F D+ D 11 387 D- D- F 12 377 F D F 13 375 F D+ F 14 373 F D F 15 367 F D F 16 367 F D F 17 342 F D F 18 341 F D- F 19 339 F D- D 20 339 D- D- F 21 332 F D- F 22 325 D F C- 23 323 D- F F 24 315 D F C 25 311 F D- F 1. ASOS 2. SHOPBOP 3. NEIMAN MARCUS 4. the OUTNET 5. NET-A-PORTER 6. 6PM 7. YOOX 8. GALERIES LAFAYETTE 9. HARRODS 10. MACY’S 11. MARKS & SPENCER 12. HARVEY NICHOLS 13. PRINTEMPS 14. OPENING CEREMONY 15. URBAN OUTFITTERS 16. SELFRIDGES & CO 17. ZAPPOS 18. SAKS FIFTH AVENUE 19. BLOOMINGDALE’S 20. BERGDORF GOODMAN 21. BARNEYS NEW YORK 22. REVOLVE CLOTHING 23. FARFETCH 24. LUISAVIAROMA 25. NASTY GAL 26. BLUEFLY 27. SSENSE 28. MYHABIT 29. DOVER STREET MARKET 30. NORDSTROM 31. LORD & TAYLOR 32. MYTHERESA 33. HAUTELOOK 34. MATCHESFASHION 35. MY-WARDROBE 36. INTERMIX 37. PIPERLIME 38. STYLEBOP 39. FORWARD BY ELYSE WALKER For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 38 multi-brand RETAILERS INSIGHTS Reach: Reach score for Retailers is 2-3x lower than for brands Without such staples as a physical presence or a localized Chinese name, Retailers have difficulty increasing awareness of their unique brand. Working with the right KOLs can help Retailers establish brand awareness, but there must be follow-up engagement Revolve Clothing partnered with a KOL known for his knowledge of “handbags,” delivering 400% of the company’s average daily fan growth and generating more than 800 comments and 1,100 reposts. However soon after, traffic reverted to prior levels. Engagement: Retailers are mentioned on leading BBS more than 400,000 times Despite their difficulties in generating brand awareness, early Haitao adopters have become retailer evangelists, showing off their purchases on social media and BBS. Weibo Fan Count is highly correlated with Search performance For Retailers with physical location, the correlation between Weibo fan count and Baidu Search Index is impressive (0.97). Fan interest on social media definitively drives brand interest as evidenced in search data. Experience: There is a negative correlation between length of brand name in English and Baidu Search Index Chinese consumers have a difficult time remembering unfamiliar English names of Retailers. Currently, only three Retailers have a Chinese name, and on average the Baidu Search Index score of their Chinese name is 33% higher than their English name. Chinese consumers have devised unofficial Chinese names or nicknames for some Retailers that receive 75% higher Baidu Search Index scores than their official English names. Only 12% of Retailers have an official WeChat presence Social platforms help bridge the gap between Chinese consumers and Western Retailers, but very few of them have accounts on social media. This makes it difficult for consumers to engage in a two-way dialogue with the brand. The Benefit and Shortcomings of KOL Involvment Though the KOL generated 400% more new fans after his mention of the retailer’s handbags, fan growth quickly returned to normal volume after 3 days. NUMBER OF NEW FANS / DAY DAY 15 KOL MENTIONS BRAND DAY O DAY 18 SUMMARY Retailers must take advantage of their diverse brands and products to increase consumer awareness, especially about products difficult to access in China. Retailers should also pay attention to Haitaos, a growing phenomenon within China where consumers buy from overseas Retailers as they look for better quality, selection and price. Haitaos are often early adopters and by interacting with them, Retailers can address areas of confusion and help build a future fan base. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 39 multi-brand RETAILERS SUCCESS STORY Strength Opportunity REACH Asos is the most active publisher on WeChat across all 138 brands that have a WeChat account, posting 27 times in July. No dedicated Baidu Bai-ke profile, which is necessary to establish legitimacy with prospective customers. ENGAGEMENT #1 Retailer on leading UGC social platforms Meilishuo and Huaban with over 8K and 12K products displayed respectively. Needs to increase engagement rates. Shopbop has 3-6x higher engagement with its followers on Weibo than Asos. EXPERIENCE Has an excellent e-commerce user experience on its Chinese language website with Chinese live chat, pricing in RMB and Alipay payment option. Chinese website has most local e-commerce features, but limited selection. Has only 80 dresses on the Chinese site, but over 2,000 on each of its U.K. and U.S. sites. Most active brands in Bomoda Brand Index as measured by WeChat Post Frequency per month (July 2014) 25 24 27 23 19 SUMMARY Asos has made a clear investment in China in both localization and social media. However compared to its efforts in site merchandising, Facebook / Twitter user engagement and Google search for its English language site, the overall user experience in China can be improved. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 40 CONCLUSION As more Chinese consumers encounter Western brands, first impressions mean everything. The market is dynamic. But companies that best engage consumers today will emerge on the fast track with the world’s biggest market for decades to come. Through our research and partnerships, we’ve learned several things. The top-ranked companies in our report share five strategic approaches that unite their activities. Generally, brands that enjoy the greatest success in China have the highest alignment with these five principles. 1. They Build for the Chinese Consumer Journey - Chinese consumers have unique paths to discovery, engagement and purchase. Only accurate data and sustained analysis can yield a true view of where, when and how different cohorts buy — and their implications for product and marketing strategy. 2. They Localize - Every element of a brand’s approach must be matched to China’s distinct cultural characteristics. Great brands know how to adapt language, work with neighborhood players, leverage existing platforms and adjust strategy to fit the market. 3. They Price Competitively - Brands must start to compete with their own products’ prices overseas. Chinese consumers research prodigiously; a 30-100% premium is untenable for them. They will simply seek other paths to purchase. 4. They Develop Authentic Brand Advocates - Advocacy overwhelmingly influences consumer behavior in China. Today, most brands seek to buy their way into the hearts of consumers through sponsorship, often to little effect. Savvier brands realize advocacy is best developed through sustained, creative, customized participation across an array of channels. 5. They Embrace Mobile Commerce - Alibaba and WeChat’s dominance have “spoiled” the Chinese consumer, setting an expectation for simple and elegant mobile commerce experiences. Brands must compete as well as partner with these bellwethers to own their own destiny. The Bomoda Brand Index is a blueprint for better brand reach, engagement and experience in China. It is designed to be thoughtprovoking—and to compel you to put these insights into practice. Please contact me to learn more about our data, our brand-specific reports and our services. I look forward to conversing with you about the world’s most important market. Brian Buchwald Bomoda Group Co-Founder and CEO Email: brian.buchwald@bomodagroup.com For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 41 About us overview of bomoda group At Bomoda Group, our mission is to make China simple, clear and profitable for the world’s best brands. Bomoda’s team of market experts, data scientists and strategists help companies make sense of the Chinese market. Our data team partners with brands by pulling and assessing hundreds of data points from digital and retail. Our strategists leverage these insights to create a foundation for profitable growth. SERVICES ANALYTICS PLATFORM Bomoda has built a powerful data platform that holistically measures brand performance in China. Derived from publicly available information, we incorporate hundreds of data points from social media, search, e-commerce, mobile and more. Our dashboard yields a clear view of a brand’s traction in-market and abroad, supported by our algorithms, which helps identify the Key Performance Indicators that match with success. This dashboard and algorithm can focus on brands, product lines and individual SKUs. CLIENT DATA INTEGRATION Fusing our market intelligence with our clients’ proprietary data, our team partners with brands to create a fully-realized view of their performance and opportunity. We integrate with a diverse array of data sources, including CRM, analytics (e.g., GA/ Omniture) and Point-of-Sale systems, gleaning insights that serve as cornerstones for growth. COMPETITIVE TRACKING Moving beyond our clients’ data, we provide critical insight into competitive sets— helping our clients track specific competitor and general industry performance. This information is delivered alongside client data, facilitating simple comparison and trend identification. STRATEGIC ANALYSIS With data as our foundation, we partner with clients to create potent, sustainable approaches to the China opportunity. Our consulting sessions help our customers develop essential, market-specific roadmaps for measurable improvement, supporting better decision-making, customer development and product alignment. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 42 About us key contributors Research and Insights Data Science and Analytics Brian Buchwald Co-Founder & Chief Executive Officer Brian co-founded Bomoda in 2012 after spending over a decade focused on advertising technology and digital media with notable companies like NBC Universal and DoubleClick. As an EVP at NBC, Brian helped oversee the creation of Hulu and led the NBC operations from its conception through beta launch. He began his career as an investment banker with Morgan Stanley. Brian has a BA from Dartmouth College. Lawrence Choi is a Managing Director at YouGov, a preeminent international online market research firm. He holds 5 patents for segmentation modeling, and has over 17 years of experience building statistically-based analytical models to advise senior executives at leading global companies. Prior to YouGov, he co-founded Clear Horizons (later acquired by YouGov), a boutique consulting firm focused on using quantitative methods to support senior marketing executives in financial services, information technology, e-commerce, healthcare, and news/ media. He has published numerous articles on his research and models in Pharmaceutical Executive, Journal of Refractive Surgery, and American Banker. Lawrence graduated summa cum laude from Princeton University. Suki Sun Co-Founder & China Research Lead Suki co-founded Bomoda in 2012, and currently oversees the China Research team. She has over 13 years of executive experience with top Chinese fashion and lifestyle media brands and in digital PR. Suki previously served as Executive Editor-in-Chief of Seventeen Magazine China, Editor-in-Chief of TimeOut Shanghai, and Features Editor of ELLE China. Suki has a BA from Fudan University in Shanghai. Alain Rothstein Co-Founder & Chief Operating Officer Alain co-founded Bomoda and serves as our COO. He brings over 20 years of experience investing in and helping manage high growth businesses. He was a founding member of Vicente Capital Partners, a $165 million growth equity fund. Before Vicente Capital, Alain was a principal at Kline Hawkes & Co. Alain holds a BA from the University of Pennsylvania. Iris Yen International Advisory & Client Services Lead Iris leads Bomoda’s Advisory and Client Services. She has 10 years experience in quantitative strategy consulting. Previously Iris served as an Engagement Manager at McKinsey. She also was employed by Rosetta, leveraging its proprietary algorithm to provide data-driven insights to Fortune 500 clients. She has BA/BS degrees from the University of Pennsylvania and a JD-MBA from Northwestern University. Jessica Yao Insights Lead Jessica is the Insights Lead at Bomoda. An expert in digital marketing on China luxury and retail, Jessica specializes in discovering actionable brand and industry trends. Prior to Bomoda, she oversaw consulting services on social media, search optimization, and digital marketing at Morpheus Media for luxury clients entering China, such as LVMH and Gucci Group. Jessica has a BA from the University of Illinois. Joshua Neckes Chief Revenue Officer Josh brings over 10 years of experience working with major brands on their digital and geographic expansion opportunities. He led strategic planning and brand strategy engagements for companies such as Make Up For Ever, Joe’s Jeans, Danone, Coca-Cola, and FedEx. Previously he served as VP of Marketing at Group Commerce. Josh has a BA from Oberlin College. Greg Hochmuth was employee #7 at Instagram where he served in a variety of roles such as mobile engineer, data analyst and product manager. Before Instagram, he was a product manager at Google for the Chrome & AdSense teams. Greg started his career with Hasso Plattner Ventures in Berlin as the firm’s lead analyst and Entrepreneur-in-Residence. Greg obtained his BS in Computer Science from Stanford University, where he also also studied design. He currently serves as the founder of DADA, a data agency that helps companies build the tools, integrations and internal capacity to better understand and work with their data. David A. Schweidel is Associate Professor of Marketing and Co-Director of Emory Marketing Analytics Center (EmoryMAC) at the Goizueta Business School of Emory University. David’s research focuses on developing statistical models to understand customer behavior and inform managerial decisions. His award-winning research has been published in various leading academic journals, and he has been recognized as a leading scholar by the Marketing Science Institute. In addition, he co-authored Social Media Intelligence, in which he discusses how organizations can leverage social media data to inform their marketing strategies. David received his BA in Mathematics, MA in Statistics, and PhD in Marketing from the University of Pennsylvania. James Weiss is a seasoned marketing and analytics executive and key advisor to Bomoda. He is currently a business leader at Palantir, a worldrenowned big data organization. James has been a Board level advisor to several successful startups and previously co-founded SK Energy, one of the nation’s fastest-growing beverages. Prior to SK Energy, James was a Principal with Bain & Company, where he specialized in media and financial services and counseled many of the nation’s leading companies and private investors. He graduated from Princeton and has an MBA from the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania, where he was an Omnicom Fellow. Siwei Zhu is an expert in the field of Chinese consumer behavior, innovation and digital trends. He co-authored the book Swindlers, Fools and Maniacs (to be published in fall 2014), in which he discusses the rational and irrational financial behavior of Chinese investors. Siwei previously worked for CCTV, the largest national television network in China, where he developed a deep understanding of consumer behavior and trends through audience surveys. He received his BS in electrical and information engineering from Beijing Information Science Technology University, and a MS in information systems from NJIT. He is currently pursuing his PhD in innovation management. Acknowledgements Bomoda Group would like to thank the following members for their invaluable contributions: Yu-Hsuan Huang; Jade Wang; Franny Hsiao; Caroline Chen; Wenna He; Sue Shen; Pengfei Gu; Anna Li; Jueling Li; Michelle Liu; Luna Lu; Kang Ma; Lisa Quach; Qi Shao; Lingxuan Tang; Lily Wang; Elvely Xu; Kimi Yao; Diane Zang; Zhen Zhang; Wenqing Zhuang; and Iris Kong. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 43 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY Industry and market terms DEFINITION BBS Acronym for Bulletin Board System, serves as an online discussion forum focused on a specific topic. Members hold conversations in the form of posted messages (often with images) on message boards. KOL Acronym for Key Opinion Leader, also known as Key Influencer. Often refers to fashion bloggers and celebrities who can have strong impact on fashion and market trends due to their large fan following (often on social media platforms). UGC Acronym for User-Generated Content, referring to content posted by users without direct brand interference. Haitao 海淘 Chinese term for Overseas Online Shopping, which is a growing phenomenon within China where consumers buy from overseas retailers as they look for better quality, selection, and price. Daigou 代购 Chinese term for Unauthorized Independent Resellers, who resell products purchased overseas to the Chinese consumer. Often active on marketplaces such as Taobao, and social platforms such as Weibo & WeChat. Golden Week 十一黄金周 An annual 7-day national holiday in mainland China celebrating National Day beginning around Oct 1. Paid days off are given during Golden Week, which results in greatly increased travel and consumption activities among Chinese residents. Chow Tai Fook 周大福 Chow Tai Fook Jewelry is a jewelry retailer popular in the Mandarin and Cantonese-speaking world. The brand has retail locations in several countries, including over 2,000 retail stores in mainland China. China UnionPay 中国银联 China UnionPay (also known as CUP) is the only interbank network in China and a preferred payment method for Chinese consumers. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 44 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY ALIBABA operated DEFINITION Alipay 支付宝 Paypal equivalent for China Alipay is China’s leading third-party online payment platform used by individuals and businesses. Used commonly for online transactions, Alipay mitigates issues with unsafe online transactions by only releasing payment to the seller once the consumer has received his/her goods. Taobao 淘宝 eBay equivalent for China Taobao is a Chinese consumer-to-consumer online marketplace providing small businesses or individuals online stores that cater to consumers in China and overseas. Tmall 天猫 Amazon Marketplace equivalent for brands Business-to-consumer online marketplace spun off from Taobao. It differentiates from Taobao by recruiting international and local brands and authorized distributors as well as providing privileges to authentic sellers. SOCIAL PLATFORMS DEFINITION Sina Weibo (commonly referred to as “Weibo”) 新浪微博 Similar to Twitter; web and mobile app Sina Weibo is a Chinese microblogging website. Akin to a hybrid of Twitter and Facebook, it is one of the most popular sites in China. WeChat (Subscription account) 腾讯微信 (订阅号) Similar to Whatsapp; mobile app WeChat is a mobile text and voice messaging communication service developed by Tencent in China and is the nation’s largest standalone messaging app by monthly active users. Brands use WeChat subscription accounts to push content. WeChat (Service account) 腾讯微信(服务号) Unique to China; mobile app While subscription accounts are for pushing content, service accounts are for advanced features such as interactive menus and payment. Nice Similar to Instagram; mobile app Nice is a platform for users to share their daily lives and styles through photos and to meet people. Topit.me Similar to Luvocracy; mobile app Topit.me enables users to share and aggregate photos they love and follow the collections they are interested in. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 45 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY Huaban 花瓣 Similar to Pinterest; web and mobile app Members share and collect inspirational images of design, fashion, recipes and more through website and app. Meilishuo 美丽说 Similar to Polyvore and Pinterest; web and mobile app A shopping discovery website and app where young female users who typically shop on Taobao can recommend and discover trendy products. Since Nov 2013, Meilishuo has fully incorporated a marketplace of its own, which combines a shopping guide with e-commerce, and no longer links to Taobao. Mogujie 蘑菇街 Similar to Fancy; web and mobile app Mogujie is a buyer-based social network service that provides services to female internet users in China. Dianping 大众点评 Similar to Yelp; web and mobile app Dianping is a UGC platform designed to share locations, contact information, reviews and ratings for stores and other retail establishments. Youku 优酷 Similar to YouTube; web and mobile app Video hosting service based in China where brands can have individual channels or invest in customizable brand pages. Douban 豆瓣 Unique to China; web and mobile app Chinese social networking service that allows registered users to record information and create content related to film, books, music, recent events and activities in Chinese cities. Toutiao 今日头条 Similar to Flipboard; mobile app Toutiao offers customized news content aggregation based on users’ personal input or their social network activities. For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 46 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY BAIDU services DEFINITION Baidu 百度 Similar to Google or Bing; Baidu offers many services, including a Chineselanguage search engine for websites, audio and images. It has several search and community services and a searchable, keyword-based discussion forum. Bai-ke 百度百科 Baidu’s form of Wikipedia; where users can create, edit, and update information on topics of their choice. Search Index 百度指数 Similar to Google Trends; Baidu Search Index provides insights into a term’s search popularity within Baidu. Video 百度视频 Similar to Google Video; Baidu Video Search enables users to search for and access online video clips that are hosted on third party websites including Youku, Tudou, PPTV, Sina, and 16 other video hosting platforms. News 百度新闻 Similar to Google News; Baidu News aggregates news articles and press releases from the web into a selection of local, national and international news. Users can search and filter news results to their interests. Knowledge 百度知道 Baidu Knowledge provides users with a query-based searchable community to share knowledge and experience. Through Baidu Knowledge, registered members can post specific questions for other members to respond to and answer questions of other members. Official Customer Support Listing 百度官方客服 A free Baidu service that lists company and business customer support phone numbers in Baidu Search Results. Brandzone 百度品牌专区 Baidu’s Brandzone is a paid advertising opportunity where businesses can own a paid placement that dominates over 80% of the “above-the-fold” area. Different from SEM ads, Brandzone allows businesses to further customize what they want users to discover with their brand, including popular link destinations to: Store Locator, Customer Support, Social Channels, or Latest Products. Brandzone delivers an average click-through rate of 50% . For further inquiries, email info@bomodagroup.com This report contains Bomoda Group’s proprietary information which is protected by copyright. All rights are reserved. 47