Thematic/Conceptual Unit Homelessness in Literautre, Film, and in America's Schools Matthew Laamanen ENGL 409 Prof. Tucker Fall 2012 Course: English Language Arts 11 Unit: Exploring the impact of homelessness/difficulties attending school and the pros and cons of the systems set forth by government structures. Also, discuss the role of schools in relation to the issue of homelessness. Texts:Tyrell by Coe Booth Shame by Richard Gregory The Lesson by Toni Cade Bambara The Pursuit of Happyness (film) Form of Intertextual Study: Thematic/Conceptual Purpose: To familiarize students with the impacts of homelessness To help students understand why some people have difficulties attending school To help students understand that some students do not have proper nutrition or food intake on a daily basis To help students understand the rocky relationship with Tyrell and his parents To help students understand the link child welfare systems and family relationships To familiarize students with young adult African American literature. Essential Questions: How does reading about different socio-economic classes alter our understanding of people in those financial situations? How does literature affect our perceptions of people who live in poverty? How does literature reveal cross-culture themes and connections? How do people in hard situations maintain their hope for a prosperous future? What factors influence our point of view of the literary characters we examine? Unit Questions: What are the similarities and differences between Tyrell's life and your own? What was life like for Tyrell and his family while going through their many struggles? How do the characters in Tyrell display their emotions given the situations they are dealt with? Why is Tyrell and other texts about homelessness/poverty important for students to read about and understand? Assessments: Formative: Reading journals, small group work/discussions, reading carousel, reading quizzes, narrative and creative writing pieces. Summative: Craft a Powerpoint within a group, which will use textual evidence and examples from all the texts we have viewed and craft an argument as to why homelessness is something that should be discussed/not be discussed within schools. Learning Activities: Whole class participates in a reading carousel to help familiarize with content that will be discussed in Tyrell Class reads and discusses Tyrell Class reads and compares scenes from The Lesson Students work in groups to discuss excerpts Shame by Richard Gregory (What is it about?, what does it mean?, and why does it matter? Students keep ongoing journals to connect and respond with the sensitive issues within the novel Students respond to prompts in journals each time they read Students write a narrative/creative piece as one of the characters in the book detailing the major events and using impactful quotations from the novel. Students use peer response workshops to craft an improved version of Tyrell's letter which is to be presented in front of the class. Unit Rationale: Tyrell For the upcoming unit, students will be focusing on the thematic/conceptual elements and intertextuality in the novel Tyrell by Coe Booth. Tyrell deals with many issues that are often not discussed in schools such as: homelessness and how it can reflect on a student's literacy, incorporating African American literature into a classroom, and the effect socio-economic status can have on a student and their abilities to learn and comprehend the texts discussed in class. Tyrell is the perfect novel to use for a unit that aims to accomplish all the goals set forth by the instructor. Tyrell and the themes contained within will not only open student's eyes to issues within the community, but also issues that are discussed within the text. A major part of Tyrell, is examining the rocky relationship Tyrell has with his parents and also his peers and also the struggles Tyrell faces being a member of the child welfare system. The intertextuality aspect of the unit, will not only incorporate from The Lesson by Toni Cade Bambara, Shame by Richard Gregory, and the film “The Pursuit of Happyness” starring Will Smith, but it will also examine the texts that Tyrell uses to escape the harsh realities of his every day life. Intertextuality will be fused together with slam poetry and also hip-hop that Tyrell listens to during the course of the novel. Studying texts that Tyrell uses himself will immerse students into the world of Tyrell, and will only enrich their understanding of all the texts they will study during the course of this unit. During the course of the unit, students will keep reading journals to discuss the reading for the day, work in small groups to discuss what is happening within the novel/other texts, take place in a reading carousel, take reading quizzes to make sure all students are comprehending and reading the texts, and create their own pieces of creative writing, but it is important to note that the students will go through an extensive drafting period until a final/polished piece of writing will be assessed. The unit will conclude with students working in groups to create a Powerpoint which will be presented in front of the class. The goal of the Powerpoint is to give textual evidence and examples from all the texts we have read during the unit, and argue as to why homelessness is a problem that should be discussed/should not be discussed in schools, and that school officials should be made aware of students lives and understand that all students lead diverse lives outside of the classroom. This unit is very extensive, but at the conclusion of the unit, students will have a better understanding of the thematic/conceptual/intertextual elements of not only Tyrell, but of all the texts the class will study during the course of the unit. Lesson Plans: First Ten Days: Day One Purpose: Introduce the unit's main text Tyrell by Coe Booth and get students to apply their prior knowledge about the setting and themes contained within Tyrell. Preparation The class will split into groups of five, and each group will start at a poster board posted on the wall's of the classroom, students will also be given a marker color which will correspond with the heading on the poster board. Procedure Students will write down all information they know about the heading at the top of the poster board. The headings will include: Homelessness, New York in the 90s, Welfare systems and single parent homes. After students have written down all they know on the poster board, they will shift to the poster board to their right, and the reading carousel will continue on until all groups have visited each station. Assessment Once students return to their original stations, they will be asked to go over the things contained on their poster boards. The student groups will also be asked to create groupings for all the information on the poster board, and to explain the connections between the diverse things each student group wrote about. Read Chapters 1-3 for the next day's class. Day Two Purpose Students will be reading the short story Shame by Dick Gregory in class within small groups. Preparation Students will have read Tyrell up to chapter three and will be discussing the fact that Tyrell does not have a father, and how that affects his life and his families life. Procedure After reading Shame in class students will be asked to examine the impact of both characters not having a father and how it shapes their experiences in their respective stories. Assessment Groups will record their findings in their daily journals, and they will be assessed by the teacher using audio podcasting to respond to the individual journal entries. The teacher audio snippets will be sent to students emails the night after class. Read Chapters 4-7 and bring in a piece of music (school appropriate) that has helped you in a hard time, or just simply makes you happy. Day Three Purpose Students will share their piece of music with the class and explain why they chose their song. Preparation Students will have chosen the song the night before, and upon entering the class they will share their song with one other student, but not go into the details as to why they pieced a particular song. Procedure After the students have shared their song with a student then they will share it in front of the class and explain why they chose that song. This will continue until all students have shared their song with the class Assessment In their journals, students will compare their musical choice to that of Tyrell. Tyrell uses the music of RUN-DMC and Boogie Down Productions to deal with the stress of his home life, and also to have something normal to discuss with his peers. The reason the students will have chosen a song is the more than likely going to be very different from Tyrell, but point is to show that people like certain music/songs for their own reasons. Journal entries will be assessed by the teacher via podcasts sent to the students. Read chapters 8-11. Day Four Purpose Students will be looking at the effects Tyrell's first eviction has on his family, and what actions did he take that we appropriate/not appropriate. Preparation Students will have read chapters 8-11 and the eviction takes place in chapter 10. Students will be working individually and analyzing the ways in which Tyrell acted as a result of his family being evicted. Procedure The teacher will write down all the actions that Tyrell took because of his family's eviction and students will be asked to decide whether the action Tyrell took was appropriate or not. Some actions include: Smashing his grandmother's urn, going to the housing commission and asking for answers to the situation, screaming at his mother to get a job, blaming the eviction on his father, and going out with friends and getting high. Assessment The lesson is quite simple, but for the assessment, the students will take the role as an outsider giving advice to Tyrell. In their journals, students will explain better ways for Tyrell to deal with his problem, and incorporate textual evidence to show why some of the way Tyrell dealt with his problem was not only inappropriate, but also lacking in maturity as an adult in charge of a household. As for all journal entries, they will be assessed through teacher podcasts. Read Chapter 12-15 and be ready to share about a time that you were charitable. Day Five Purpose Students will examine the idea of charity and how the idea is viewed in both Shame and Tyrell. Preparation Students will answer a prompt given on the board, which is “Describe a time you were charitable, how did it make you feel, and why did you act this way?” Procedure Students answer the prompt in their journals and share with classmates that are seated near them. After the classmates have exchanged, it is the other classmates job, to compare the charitable action described by the fellow classmate in relation to the charitable moment in Tyrell (Gives his last bit of change to his mother, so she can take the bus to a job interview) and Shame (Richard gives 15 dollars to the Community Chest) Assessment Students will exchange journals with each other and they will be asked to brainstorm what they think will be the outcome of the charitable moment in Tyrell. Their ideas must be based upon textual evidence, or knowledgable assumptions about the characters in Tyrell. Students will write until the end of class and then they will turn in their work, which will be assessed by the teacher via audio podcast and sent to students the night after class. Read chapters 16-19. Day Six Purpose Students will be comparing/contrasting the differences between Tyrell and his family and Chris Garderner and his family in the film The Pursuit of Happyness Preparation Students will take out their journals and be ready to answer the prompt after viewing the two key scenes from the film. Procedure The class will view the scene in which Chris Gardener has to argue with the leader of a church to keep his spot in line, in order to receive aid and shelter. Also, students will view the scene in which Chris and his son are forced to live in the bathroom of a subway station. Assessment After viewing these scenes, students will be asked to compare Tyrell and his family to Chris and his son. The comparison piece must feature evidence from the texts, and must also show and explain the psychological effects being homeless has on the people involved in Tyrell and The Pursuit of Happyness. Read chapters 20-23. Day Seven Purpose To talk about and analyze Tyrell's letter that he sends to the New York Housing Commission. Preparation Students will take journals out, and be ready to answer the prompts given by the instructor in reference to Tyrell's letter. Procedure Read the letter out loud to the class, after the first time ask them: What does it say?, second time, what does it mean?, third time, why does it matter? After each step is completed, have the students share their answers either with the class, or with a classmate. Assessment After the discussion has been completed, students will take home Tyrell's letter, and rewrite it, so that it is more clear and readable, both in content and in quality. Read chapters 2427. Day Eight Purpose Students will take place in a peer response workshop (In groups of 3) for their drafts of a revised Tyrell letter. Preparation Students will follow the first two steps of the peer response handout, and work in small groups to learn about and revise aspects of their draft from their peers. Procedure Students will be following the peer response handout, step by step. They will only complete the first two steps in class, and the next two steps will take place at a later time. Worksheet is attached below this lesson plan. Assessment After completing the first two steps of the peer response workshops, students will be given the journal prompt asking them: What were your feelings during the first part of the peer response workshop? Was it hard forming questions for your readers as the author? Journals will be collected at the end of class, and podcasts will be sent to students assessing their journals the night after class. Read chapters 28-31 and be prepared to work through the last two steps of the peer response workshop. 4 Steps for Peer Response to Writing STEP ONE: The Author Re-read your piece. Make whatever changes you would like to make. (You can make these on the paper itself in pen/pencil). What question(s) about the piece would you like to know the answer(s) to? Write your question(s) somewhere on the essay itself so that readers will see it. Pass the piece to Reader #1. STEP TWO: Reader #1 Put your name/email/phone # somewhere on the paper so that the Author can see it. Read through the Author’s piece. Answer the question(s) asked by the Author. Ask your own question(s) to the Author. Write these somewhere on the paper itself so that the Author can see them. Offer other suggestions if you have time. Pass the piece to Reader #2. STEP THREE: Reader #2 Put your name/email/phone # somewhere on the paper so that the Author can see it. Read through the Author’s piece. Answer the question(s) asked by Reader #1 as you think the Author would respond. Make whatever suggestions (as Reader #2, not as ‘the Author’) you can for the next version of this piece. Return the piece to the Author. STEP FOUR: Author Redux Re-read your piece with the questions and comments from Reader #1 and Reader #2. If you have questions for the readers regarding their feedback, take some time now or by email, phone, or in person after class, to confer with them. Consider the feedback from these readers and the feedback from me (on the other copy of this piece). Complete a Y version of this piece to be submitted on Day 11. When you submit this next version include the X versions with comments from your peers and me. (Adapted from a lesson by Professor John Staunton) Day Nine Purpose Students will finish up their work in the peer response workshop, and be given instructors for the final revised Tyrell letter to the New York Housing Commission Preparation Students will be instructed to take out their peer response draft to Tyrell's letter and form into the same groups they were in yesterday to complete the last two steps of the peer response workshop. Procedure Each student will hand their draft to the student who did not see it yesterday and be asked to complete step 3 and and one step 3 has been completed they will be asked to hand it back to the original author. The teacher will instruct the original authors that their completed revised letters will be do on Day 11, and all the necessary steps needed for completing step 4 and the “y version” of the letter can be found on the peer response workshop worksheet. Assessment Students will take out their journals and be asked to answer the following prompt: “After reviewing your draft with all the comments and questions answered, do you think your “y version” will convey what Tyrell was trying to accomplish in his first draft? How will your draft differ from your y-version, and do you see the peer response workshop as a worthwhile process? Why or why not? Complete reading of Tyrell chapters 32- 35. Journals will be collected and podcasts reviews will be sent to students the night after class. Day Ten Purpose Students will read The Lesson by Toni Bambara and decide as a group whether or not Sugar's assessment of society is a correct one, and how it differs from Tyrell's view of society. Preparation Students will break into groups and read The Lesson as a group. Procedure After students have read The Lesson, they will come to a group consensus as to what they believe is Sugar's assessment of society in The Lesson. Using this information, students will debate amongst themselves what they think Tyrell's view of society is and how it differs from Sugar's view. (It is imperative that students reflect on the scene in which Tyrell goes to his school and asks for assistance, and the teachers tell Tyrell that he is not worth their time or when Tyrell and his family receive money from the school as a result of charity donations and one student finds out that the money is going to Tyrell, so he tells the whole school on the morning announcements, and begins being ridiculed by his fellow classmates) Assessment Students will share their findings in front of the class, and the teacher will assess their responses based on the amount of textual evidence/quotations they apply to their arguments from the readings. Students will be asked to find pamphlets from either library/school that discuss the issue of homelessness and the steps that can be done to prevent it (these materials will be used for the summative assessment, and if students cannot find pieces the teacher will offer assistance) Students will also be reminded that y-version of Tyrell's letter is due the next day. Summary Lesson Plans Day Eleven: Students will turn in their “y-version” of Tyrell's letter, and the rest of class will consist of students bringing in the artifacts they found relating to the topic of homelessness. Students will share their artifact with the class, and the teacher will offer some anchor texts in the form of annotated bibliography (attached below) relating to the idea of homelessness . The teacher will explain that the anchor texts can be used during the creation of their summative assessment (last project of the unit) Which will be discussed next class. Homework: Students will be asked to research one of the anchor texts, and be ready to discuss the summative assessment next class. Day Twelve: Students will share with the class the anchor text they decided to research further for homework. After each student has presented, the teacher will create groups for the last project based upon the anchor texts that each student chose to research further. Meaning that, if two students chose to research Care Factor Zero and Almost Home, they would be placed in a group together because their anchor texts correlate with each other. One groups are formed the teacher will explain the last project, which is to create a powerpoint as a group detailing why they believe (as a group) that homelessness is something that should/should not be discussed in schools.Worksheet will be handed out showing guidelines and a rubric for the final project. (worksheet attached below) Day Thirteen The teacher will hand back the y-version of Tyrell's letter and reveal to students that the piece was not graded, but it will be placed into their yearly file, which they can view at the end of the year to see how their writing has improved. Day thirteen will be used to begin working on the presentations in groups. The teacher will take students down to computer lab and help the students with any problems they may be running into either with Powerpoint, group members, or content/argument in their presentation. Homework: Students may choose to work on Powerpoint at home but not required. Day Fourteen Day fourteen is the last day to work on presentations with groups. Presentations will be crafted in the computer lab by all group members and the last ten minutes of class will consist of the teacher choosing the order of the presentations based upon the progress viewed in the lab over the span of the last two days. Homework will consist of finishing presentation, if the group did not finish in class, and coming to class prepared to present the following day Day Fifteen Day fifteen is the last day of the unit and it will consist of all groups presenting their presentations. After all groups have presented their projects, the teacher will then hand out group evaluation forms. The ticker out of the classroom is a completed group evaluation form. No homework. Possible Homelessness Anchor Texts Anonymous. Almost Lost: The True Story of an Anonymous Teenager’s Life on the Streets. HarperTeen, 1996. ISBN# 9780380783410. This is the real-life story of Sam, the torment of his own self-loathing, how he survived on the street, and came home to overcome his negative and dark feelings. Gr. 9-12. Allison, Anthony. Hear These Voices. Dutton, 1999. ISBN# 9780525453536. This non-fiction book presents case studies of teenagers living with homelessness, prostitution, alcoholism, and neighborhood violence. It also includes interviews with staff members from organizations committed to helping teenagers in crisis. Gr. 9-12. Banks, Russell. Rule of the Bone. Vintage, 1996. ISBN# 9780394281650. Rule of the Bone is the story of a troubled fourteen-year-old boy who, upon leaving an abusive home, lives on the edge of society, and struggles to find himself. Gr. 9-12. Bayless, Maureen. No Fixed Address. Scholastic Canada, 1997. ISBN# 9780590123785. Thirteen-year-old Sabie’s Mom has just died, leaving her on the street. Sabie is determined to forge a family, any way she can. Gr. 6-8. *Bedard, Michael. Stained Glass. Tundra Books, 2002. ISBN: 0887766021. While skipping his piano lesson one day, Charles witnesses a stained glass window break in the local church. The window appears to have shattered on top of a homeless girl sleeping in the pew. She has a cut on her forehead and no recollection of who she is or where she comes from. Feeling concerned for her injury, Charles decides to accompany her around the city in the hopes that she will see something that jogs her memory. Over the course of the day he is forced to confront his own memories and in doing so comes to terms with his father’s death. A subplot involves Mr. Berkeley reflecting on his past. After his wife’s death he became a homeless drifter. When he regained his faith and sense of purpose he found a literal home in the church building. Gr. 8-10. Blank, Jessica. Almost Home. Hyperion Press, 2007. ISBN# 9781423106425. Why would anyone choose to live on the streets? The characters of Almost Home examine the answers to this question. There is Eeyore, twelve years old when she runs away from her privileged home, who harbors a secret she’s too ashamed to tell anyone. Rusty is a sensitive gay teen who winds up alone when his older boyfriend ditches him in Hollywood. Squid has gone through too many foster homes to count. Scabius is a delusional punk from Utah who takes the “me against the world” motto to dangerous extremes. Critter is a heroin dealer with movie star looks and a vulnerable heart. Laura should be home studying, but she can’t face another one of her mom’s boyfriends. And then there’s Tracy, the damaged thread that ties them all together, irrevocably changing each person’s life she touches. This unlikely band of characters forms their own dysfunctional family, complete with love and belonging, abuse and betrayal. Each will make their way home, wherever that may be. Gr. 9-12. Bowsher, Melodie. My Lost and Found Life. Bloomsbury USA, 2007 ISBN# 9781599901558. When her mother is accused of embezzling a million dollars and vanishes, spoiled, selfish Ashley must fend for herself by finding a job and a place to live. Gr. 6-8. Brooks, Martha. Being with Henry. Dorling Kindersley, 2000. ISBN# 9780789425881. Kicked out of his house and now homeless, Lake Wyatt meets eighty-three-year-old Henry Olsen, a lonely widower with family troubles of his own. Lake’s stay with Henry leads him to a deeper understanding of the mysteries and difficulties of love. Gr. 10-12. Burgess, Melvin. Baby and Fly Pie: Could a Kidnapped Baby Be The Key to a Better Life for Three Homeless Kids?. Simon and Schuster, 1996. ISBN-13: 9780689804892 In a London of the future, three homeless teens stumble upon a kidnapped baby worth 17 million pounds. They could use her to make all their dreams come true, if only they handle things in the right way. But the three can’t agree on what the “right” approach is. The teens’ struggle with each other and with the harsh society in which they live in is a compelling, and often chilling, tale. *Burgess, Melvin. Smack. Henry Holt and Company, LLC., 1996. Fourteen-year-old Tar decides he can no longer suffer the physical abuse of his father and runs away with his girlfriend, Gemma. The two find company in other homeless squatters who introduce them to drugs; Tar and Gemma quickly become junkies. As their lives spiral out of control, Gemma becomes pregnant and it is only then—after three years of experiencing the streets, drugs, prostitution, and robbery—does she move back home with her new baby girl, and without Tar. Gr. 9-11. Carey, Janet Lee. The Double Life of Zoe Flynn. New York: Aladdin Books, 2007. ISBN: 1416967540. When Zoe’s family has to live in their van for months after moving from California to Oregon so her father can find work, Zoe tries to keep her sixth-grade classmates from discovering that she is homeless. Gr. 6-8. Clark, Margaret. Back on Track: Diary of a Street Kid. Random House Australia, 1995. ISBN# 9780091831622. Fifteen-year-old Simone is lured away from home by her new boyfriend with promises of a better life in a big city. On the run from a dangerous environment and her drug-addicted sister, she arrives in Palmino with stars in her eyes and hope in her heart. Clark, Margaret. Care Factor Zero. Sagebrush Education Resources, 2000. ISBN # 9780613277594. An explosive story of a teen runaway and her life on the streets. Larceny is a wild child. She’s been hassled by cops and shuffled between foster homes. She’s afraid of walls and bars—and of the voices that bring with them the wild, consuming, killing rage that drove her to the streets in the first place. But most of all, she’s afraid of being betrayed by the only person she’s ever been able to trust: herself. Creel, Ann. A Ceiling of Stars. Middleton: American Girl, 1999, ISBN # 978-1562477530. In a series of letters and journal entries, twelve-year-old Vivien describes being abandoned by her mother and struggling to survive on the streets of a big city while searching for her family. *Cooley, Beth. Shelter. Delacorte Press: Random House Inc., 2006. After her father’s unexpected death, Lucy Durbin, along with her mother and younger brother, is forced to live in a homeless shelter. Initially Lucy feels as if she is living a nightmare, but by the time her mother earns enough money to move her family out of the shelter, Lucy has formed close relationships with the other residents and has accepted the reasons for her own homelessness. Gr. 9-12. Criswell, Sara Dixon. Homelessness. San Diego: Lucent Books, 1998. This book discusses the causes of homelessness, life on the streets, homeless children, the shelter system, and help for the homeless. *Cushman, Karen. The Midwife’s Apprentice. HarperCollins Publishers, 1995. One night in medieval England, a girl with no home, no parents, and no name struggles to keep warm in a roadside dung heap. The town’s midwife, Jane, takes the newly named “Dung Beetle” into her home as an ill-used and poorly-fed apprentice. For the first time “Beetle” has the semblance of a home, makes friends, and decides her own identity as “Alyce.” But, she leaves all this behind and runs away to a nearby Inn after failing an assignment—she was unable to help a woman give birth without the midwife. After spending time at the Inn, and learning how to read and write, Alyce realizes she does have a name and a place in the world and returns to be the midwife’s apprentice. Gr. 6-8. De La Pena, Matt. Ball Don’t Lie. Random House Children’s Books, 2005. ISBN# 9780385732321. Sticky is a beat-around-the-head foster kid with nowhere to call home but the street, and an outer shell so tough that no one will take him in. He started out life so far behind the pack that the finish line seems nearly unreachable. He’s a white boy living and playing in a world where he doesn’t seem to belong. But Sticky can ball. And basketball might just be his ticket out . . . if he can only realize that he doesn’t have to be the person everyone else expects him to be. Gr. 9-12 Deuker, Carl. Runner. HMCo Children’ Books, 2005. ISBN# 9780618542987. Chance Taylor and his father live on a boat. But the weather-beaten sailboat Chance Taylor and his father call home is thirty years old and hasn’t sailed in years. One step from both homelessness and hunger, Chance worries about things other kids his age never give a thought: Where will the money come for the electricity bill, grocery bill, and moorage fees? So when a new job falls his way, he jumps at the opportunity. He knows how much he will earn; what he doesn’t know is how much he will pay. Gr. 6-8. Easton, Kelly. Walking on Air. New York: Margaret K. McElderry Books, 2004, ISBN# 9780689848759. In 1931, a young girl travels around the country performing on a tightrope during revival meetings held by her father, and seeking her own answers about God, her family, and her life of poverty and homelessness. Ellis, Deborah. Looking for X. Groundwood Books, 2001. ISBN# 9780888993823. Khyber is an eleven-year-old girl living in poverty with her single mother and autistic twin brothers. When she is falsely accused of vandalism, she must track her friend X, a homeless woman, to verify her alibi. Gr. 6-8. *Ellis, Deborah. Parvana’s Journey. Groundwood Books/Douglas & McIntyre, 2002. ISBN: 0888995148. Parvana and her father have been living in a refugee camp since losing their home in Kabul. After her father dies of pneumonia, Parvana sets off in search of her mother and siblings, who had gone to a wedding out of town when their home was lost. Parvana is joined along the way by three other displaced children, all of whom have suffered from the Taliban and constant warring in Afghanistan. They endure freezing nights, exhaustion, and starvation before finally arriving at a crowded refugee camp. Space is limited because the camp is adjacent to a mine field, but Parvana and her friends decide to remain, relieved to finally be among adults again. One day a relief plane flies over the camp and drops food parcels to the refugees. Many of the parcels fall in the mine field. Leila runs out onto the field to get one and is injured by mine Homelessness in America's schools Final Unit Project Instructions: In your student groups, you will be making a Powerpoint presentation that will argue for or against the question: Should Homelessness be taught in America's schools, why or why not? The group must come to a unanimous decision as to which way they will argue the question. The presentation will be scored based upon the rubric attached. Powerpoints will be due to the teacher on Day 15 and you will have three full class periods to work on the presentation with your group. Make sure to ask the teacher if you have any questions regarding the project. The project is out of a possible 225 points. Group evaluations will be completed after the presentations. Summative Assessment Rubric Criteria x 5 Student used time given in class wisely, turned in presentation on time. Presentation offers direct textual evidence to support argument from Tyrell, The Lesson, and Shame Argument is clearly outlined during the presentation (Groups must choose a side) Scor e Quality of Performance Excellent 5 Student used in class work time wisely, completed product in a timely fashion, and turned in on time. Good 3 Student turned in completed product on time, but did not use class time wisely. Unsatisfactory 1 Student did not complete assessment, or use class time wisely. Excellent 25 Presentation offers 4 examples from each text to support argument Good 15 Presentation offers less than four examples from each text to support argument Unsatisfactory 5 Presentation offers textual evidence that is not related to argument Excellent 5 Argument for or against is displayed in the presentation Good 3 Argument is not clearly defined as for or against in the presentation Unsatisfactory 1 No argument is presented in presentation Presentation details how anchor text was used to strengthen argument presented Presentation is visually appealing (incorporates graphics, bibliography, quotes from texts . Excellent 5 Presentation makes reference to anchor texts and connects it to the argument and the the main texts read during the unit (Tyrell, The Lesson, Shame) Good 3 Presentation makes reference to anchor texts but does not connect it to the argument in a clear manner Unsatisfactory 1 No mention of anchor texts during presentation Excellent 5 Presentation is visually appealing contains minimum of three graphics, completed bibliography, and a minimum of 10 quotes from the various texts Good 3 Presentation is visually appealing but does not contain minimum amount of graphics or quotes, and bibliography is not complete Unsatisfactory 1 Presentation is not visually appealing, not organized correctly, cotains no graphics/quotes or bibliography