Kate Cuddihy Unit of lessons (5 lessons) Democracy and Parliament Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 CITIZENSHIP SCHEME OF WORK Course : PGCE CITIZENSHIP Subject : CITIZENSHIP Year / Term : YEAR 9 Unit / Topic : DEMOCRACY AND THE POLITICAL SYSTEM Lesson Focus & Key Questions Learning Activities Lesson 1 LAWS AND RULES Table sorting activity: What is a law? And what is a rule? What is a law? Where do laws come from? Who makes our laws? What laws are there? Why are laws made? “Making the law” – class game Plenary – Class discussion on “Do you think it is an easy process for laws to be made?” and “Do you think the Queen would ever refuse to sign a bill?” Homework? Blank words on a summary of parliament Teacher : Kate Cuddihy Learning Outcomes/ Objectives (some/most) Methods of Assessment Curriculum links Most will be able to recognised the difference between a law and a rule Participation in the role play Citizenship PoS 1. c, d and g2. 2. b, c Most will be able to role play basic features of how a law is passed in parliament Some will be able to analyse the process of passing a law in parliament Contribution to the class discussion on what is the difference between a rule and a law KEY SKILLS Communication Working with others Contribution to the plenary discussion on how parliament makes a law THINKING SKILLS Evaluation skills Resources Parliament Game “People in society – modern studies” by Grant and Sinclair, Nelson Thornes (2003) SMSC DEVELOPMENT Social development 1. Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Lesson 2 REPRESENTATION #1 Who represents us? What is an MP? What does an MP do? How can we deal with an MP? Starter: Word search on works related to an MP Most will be able to find words related to the role of an MP Participation in the card sort Card sort on the work of an MP Most will be able to sort our the jobs of an MP Contribution to class discussion Most will be able to discuss ways of approaching an MP Suggestions on card sort extension task Extension task – answering questions related to the work of an MP Teacher – led feedback on card sort Plenary: missing words Some will be able to suggest what kind of people become MPs, who can vote, who pays for MPs and how you should act in front of an MP Citizenship PoS 1. d, e 2. b, c KEY SKILLS Communication Working with others THINKING SKILLS Information processing Creative thinking CBBC Newsround website www.bbc.co.uk /cbbc “people in society – modern studies” (ibid) Exercise books Whiteboard SMSC DEVELOPMENT Social development Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Lesson 3 PRESSURE What is a pressure group? Starter: class discussion on letter the class received from Downing Street Class brainstorm on the impact of our letter and what we could do if we REALLY wanted to change something Short video on “I for involvement” Worksheet on the role of pressure groups - - the work to be written in exercise books Extension task – worksheet on the work of Greenpeace Most will be able to recognise the impact of their letter writing Most will be able to recall information on the role of pressure groups Some will be able to identify actions and the role of specific pressure groups Work in exercise books Citizenship PoS 1. f, g 2. a KEY SKILLS Communication Working with others SMSC DEVELOPMENT Social development A-Z of politics – BBC Lifeschool VCR Worksheets on pressure groups Greenpeace website www.greenpea ce.org.uk Plenary missing words quiz with words put on the board Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Citizenship PoS 1. g 2. a, b Lesson 4 LAWS & JUSTICE How do laws affect us? Starter: class brainstorm on what laws they would like to see Story and discussion on banning smacking Preparing speeches for debate on smacking Plenary: debate and vote on whether smacking should be banned Most will be able to list what laws they would like to see Contribution to class discussion Most will be able to justify why they want these laws Contribution to group discussion on what to put in the group’s speech Most will be able to recall key facts in favour of or against smacking Most will be able to translate the facts into a short speech Some will be able to analyse the debate Contribution to the debate 1. KEY SKILLS Communication Working with others THINKING SKILLS Information processing Reasoning skills Fact sheets on smacking CBBC newsround website for smacking story www.bbc.co.uk /cbbc SMSC DEVELOPMENT Social development Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Lesson 5 REPRESENTATION #2 Who represents us and what do they do? Starter: recall the terms MP, constituency and introduce the term “majority” Students look on the internet to answer the following questions: “Who is my MP?” “What constituency do they represent?” “What is their majority?” and “What party do they represent?” and also one question the student would like to ask based on the MPs work or interests Students create either electronic or paper presentations answering these questions Most will be able to find out who their MP is, what constituency they represent, what their majority is and what party they belong to Most will be come up with a question they would like to ask their MP based on the MP’s work or interests Most will able to present their findings to the class Presentation of findings Question the student would like to ask their MP Email to their MP Citizenship PoS 1. d e KEY SKILLS Communication Improving own learning and performance THINKING SKILLS Enquiry skills ICT suite Access to internet explorer Interactive wipeboard SMSC DEVELOPMENT Some will be able to draft, and eventually send, an email to their MP Social development Plenary: Presentation of the students’ findings Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 PGCE Citizenship Lesson Plan Date/Group Lesson aims/key question Learning outcomes A. Most will be able to recognise the difference between a law and a rule B. Most will be able to role play basic features of how a law is passed in parliament C. Some will be able to analyse the process of passing a law in parliament Key concepts/terms Parliament Bill White paper Law This is the first lesson in a unit of work on the UK political process Participation in the role play Contribution to class discussion on what is the difference between a law and a rule Contribution to the plenary discussion on how a parliament makes a law The plenary will act as an extension task Less able students will be assisted in their contribution to the role-play, there is also a summary sheet of the main aspects of parliament Links to previous learning Assessment opportunities Differentiation To discover where laws come from Homework Resources Parliament Game Modern Studies – People Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Time Teacher activity Student activity 0–5 minutes Settle class Class get settled 5 – 10 minutes Get the class to put a table in their book with “law” on one side, and “rule” on the other. Read out a list of laws and rules and sort them out into rules and laws, ideas include: Class copy down board into their books Towards A Class answer question and copy definition into their exercise books A 10 – 20 minutes Learning outcomes No running the corridor Motorway speed limit of 70 MPH No jeans to be worn in the local sports club The race relations act Teacher asks the question “What is the difference between a law and a rule?” Answer: a rule is a standard that individuals in certain situations e.g. a school are expected to follow a law is a standard that all members of society are expected to follow. The teacher puts these definitions the board Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 20 – 25 minutes Teacher sets up Pupils act accordingly Parliament Game and gets six pupils to sit at the front and distributes the debate envelopes amongst the class. The teacher introduces the game by saying “where do our laws come from?” answer: from parliament and we are going to play a game to demonstrate this! Towards B 25 – 40 minutes Teacher assists in the Parliament Game B 40 – 50 minutes Teacher asks the Pupils take part in the following “brainstorm” discussion questions “Do you think it is an easy process for laws to be made?” and “Do you think the queen would ever refuse to sign a bill?” also any questions the class may have Pupils take part in the game Consolidating A and B and for some C Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 RULES FOR PARLIAMENT GAME 1. Choose six pupils from the class, they sit at the front of the class facing the class. Each of the pupils are given an envelope marked A – F. These pupils form the Clerks of Parliament 2. The other envelopes, marked 1- 15 are distributed amongst the class. These pupils are the Members of Parliament. 3. Pupil “A” reads out the contents of envelope “A”, then the pupils with the relevant envelopes take it in turn to read envelopes 1-3 4. Pupil “B” reads the contents of envelope “B”, then the pupils with the relevant envelopes take it in turn to read envelopes 4 – 5 5. The teacher announces that the bill has now gone to the Select Committee stage 6. The pupils with the relevant envelopes take it in turn to read envelopes 6 – 10 7. Pupil “C” reads the contents of envelope “C” 8. Pupil “D” reads the contents of envelope “D” then the pupils with the relevant envelopes take it in turn to read envelopes take it in turn to read envelopes 11 – 13 9. Pupil “E” reads the contents of envelope “E” 10. Pupils with the relevant envelopes take it in turn to read envelopes 14 – 15 11. Pupil “F” reads the contents of envelope “F” and presents it to the Queen (teacher) for signing. Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 To be put in to envelopes for the members of parliament – but this is a copy of the running order for the teacher 1. I agree with the Government proposal, as I believe that people today, and in particular children spend far too much time indoors listening to musing and playing computer games. This tax would ensure that they would buy less CDs and computer games and would go outside and exercise more 2. I disagree with this Government’s proposal for a tax on CDS and computer games. CD and Computer games are already far too expensive and it is unfair on consumers, especially children, who spend a lot their hard-earned money on these products to be expected to pay more. 3. I propose a compromise. Both speakers have made incredibly good points. Yes, we should encourage people to be more active but at the same time it is not fair to tax people’s leisure time. If the tax is to be fair then we should use it for the greater good. Now goes to second reading, which is read to the class 4. I agree with the bill as it includes both the proposal for the tax and the proposal for the tax to fund community projects 5. I totally disagree with the bill, as it is an unfair tax on people’s leisure time. Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 The bill now goes to the committee stage 6. I am a representative for “Ace records”. I believe that this tax is totally unfair, as it will stop people from buying our music. If our company makes no money then we will not be able to give our customers the music they want to listen to nor will we be able to find new and exciting talent. 7. I am a music teacher who teaches music at Green Fields Community Centre in Wandsworth. Our project depends on funding from the local council and from the government. I support this tax as it means that not only are children listening to music but they will be able to learn how to make music at community centres funded by this tax 8. I am representative from the Consumer’s Association. I believe that this tax is unfair as consumers already pay a lot of money for these products. It is unfair to tax people on their well-earned leisure time. 9. I am a representative from The Treasury we support this tax as it will give us the necessary money yet Government needs to raise funds to support community centres providing music education. 10. I am a representative from “Rightz 4 Kidz” a children’s rights association. I do not necessarily support the tax as children regard their money as precious and do not want to have to pay more for items they would like to buy. However, I do agree with the proposal that the tax will go towards funding community centres providing music education Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 The committee’s recommendations are now read out 11. I fully agree with the proposals set out in the third reading of the white paper. This tax is not unreasonable and it will provide sufficient funding for community music projects 12. I agree with the proposal for the tax on CDs and computer games and that the money raised will go towards funding music education in community centres. However, I do not believe that this is enough, I therefore propose that the tax be raised to 20 pence for each CD and computer game sold in order to provide more funding for these community centres 13. I propose a compromise, I agree with both the tax and the proposed use of the tax. However, I do not believe that 10 pence is sufficient but, neither do I believe that 20 pence is an acceptable amount to put as a tax on CDs and computer games. Therefore, I would like to propose that the tax should be raised to 15 pence. The bill now goes to the Lords 14. I am Lord Summer-Isle, I agree with the proposed tax and whole heartedly agree with the Government’s proposal 15. I am Lord Lucan, I too agree with the proposed tax and I look forward to the music that will be produced by these music centres! The bill is now sent to the Queen Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 The following six sheets are read out by the Clerks of the House of Commons GOVERNMENT WHITE PAPER This government proposes that a new task shall be introduced on the sale of all CDs and computer games This tax will be 20 pence on the cover price of all CDs and computer games sold. This bill will now be debated in the House of Commons. The Government June 2004 Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 SECOND READING AMENDED WHITE PAPER This Government proposes that a new tax will be introduced on the sale of all CDs and computer games. This tax will be 20 pence on the cover price of every CD and computer game sold. The money made from these sales will be used to benefit the community. The Bill will now be debated by Select Committee The Government July 2004 Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 REPORT STAGE REPORT TO THE HOUSE OF COMMONS The Select Committee has heard strong evidence from the many groups that will be affected by this proposed tax. The Select Committee would like to make the following recommendations: That the proposed tax is only 10 pence on every CD and computer game sold That the money made from the sale of the CDs will be used to fund local community and music projects CDs and computer games that are more than 18 months old will not be taxed. These proposals will be considered by the Government and presented to the House of Commons. The Select Committee on the Sale of CDs and computer games July 2004 Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 THIRD READING AMENDED WHITE PAPER This government proposes that a new tax will be introduced on the sale of all CDs and computer games. This tax will be 10 pence on the cover price of all CDs and computer games. Computer games that are more than 18 months old will not be taxed. All money made from the tax will be used to fund local community music projects. The Government July 2004 Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 BILL TO BE PRESENTED TO THE HOUSE OF LORDS This Government proposes that a new tax will be introduced on the sale of all CDs and computer games. This tax will be 20 pence on the cover price of all CDs and computer games. Computer games that are more than 18 months old will not be taxed. All money made from the tax will be used to fund local community music projects. The Government July 2004 Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 FINAL DRAFT Having been debated by the House of Lords, this White Paper will be passed and become law as of September 1st 2004. This government proposes that a new tax will be introduced on the sale of all CDs and computer games. This tax will be 10 pence on the cover price of all CDs and computer games. Computer games that are more than 18 months old will not be taxed. All money made from the tax will be used to fund local community music projects. This Bill will now go to Buckingham Palace to be signed by The Queen. The Government July 2004 Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 SUMMARY The main role of Parliament is to make laws There are many different stages for a Bill to become a Law The House of Commons is very traditional and the procedures for voting are very unusual. Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 PGCE Citizenship Lesson Plan Date/Group Lesson aims/key question Learning outcomes A. Most will be able to find words related to the role of an MP B. Most will be able to sort out the jobs of an MP C. Most will be able to discuss ways of approaching an MP D. Some will be able to suggest what kind of people become MPs, who can vote, who pays for MPs and how you should act in front of an MP Key concepts/terms Member of Parliament Representative Constituent Current unit of work is on the political system, last week’s lesson looked at the process of passing a law Assessment opportunities Participation in the card sort Contribution to class discussion Suggestions on card sort Differentiation Extension task on the card sort Word search Card sort Missing words work sheet Links to previous learning Who represents us? Homework Resources Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Time Teacher activity Student activity Learning outcomes 0 – 5 minutes Settle class and hand out worksheet Class settle 5 – 10 minutes Assist the class with the word search Pupils do word search 10 – 20 minutes Refer to last week’s lesson when we looked at the MP’s role in creating laws but this week we are going to look at other jobs they have in representing us. Give definitions of: Member of parliament: a representative elected to the house of commons. Constituent: someone who has a right to vote for the representative of their electoral area (constituency) Pupils copy down Consolidating definitions and ask A and towards about words in the word B search 20 – 30 minutes Teacher introduces the card sort exercise on what work an MP does. In small groups the pupils take part in the card sort B and C and for some C 30 – 35 minutes Teacher led feedback on the card sort Groups nominate a representative to feedback on their card sort findings Consolidating B 35 – 40 minutes Ask the question “If we have a problem, how can we take it to our MP?” and then the question (if time” “What action can an MP take on our behalf?” Class takes part in the discussion Consolidating B, C and for some D. 40 – 50 minutes Hand out missing words summary of the work of an MP Towards A Pupils fill in missing words Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT WORD SEARCH G I K N C P U G D P J D Y P R D E S C E S A T C S L C Y S E G G C O Q W Z R K I O M W A B Y Y X N V S J A L N L J P Q M I B O S B X T P S I M B P R E W J L T W R M T T E A R U W M E T R I G C I Y P I A M A P R E V I T A T N E S E R P E R K X H Y U U T M Y D M H Z V N W G S E E Z P R E H V K A K T T N R N N Q E I G P Y V P F C N A C V T G M S W Y Y J T H P S Y L D R D K J V W E C X U L L F V U A M E W U C C B D L Z F K S X V O P L O B B Y I N G I CAN YOU FIND THE FOLLOWING WORDS THAT ALL RELATE TO THE WORK OF AN MP? CONSTITUENT CONSTITUENCY LOBBYING MEMBER PARLIAMENT PUBLIC REPRESENTATIVE SURGERY Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Card sort exercise – photocopy and cut up sheet into cards. The job of an MP is mainly to do with politics The letters MP stand for member of parliament 12 10 An MP is paid for by Parliament One of an MP’s main job is to discuss and make laws 3 5 The UK Parliament is based in London The Houses of Parliament are where MPs go to debate decisions 1 4 The job of an MP is mainly to do with entertainment The letters MP stand for mad parrot 2 6 An MP is paid for by “pay as you go” One of an MPs main jobs is to argue loudly on TV 8 9 The UK Parliament is based in Edinburgh The Houses of Parliament are where MPs got to meet tourists. 7 11 Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Extension task – students fill in their suggestions on the following table. Can you suggest what kind of people become MPs? Who can vote for an MP? Can you suggest who an MP might help? If you ever meet an MP can you describe how you would act? Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 SUMMARY FILL IN THE MISSING WORDS USING THE LIST BELOW MPs are involved in work in ____________________. MPs are involved in work in their ________________. People ask their _________ to deal with lots of _______________ problems. MPs use different methods when dealing with ________________________ problems. DIFFERENT CONSTITUENCY PARLIAMENT CONSTITUENTS MPs Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 PGCE Citizenship Lesson Plan Date/Group Lesson aims/key question Learning outcomes A. Most will be able to identify the effect of writing a letter to a politician B. Most will be able to recognise different features of pressure groups C. Most will be able to recognise different methods used by pressure groups D. Some will be able to account for the work of Greenpeace Pressure Pressure groups Lobbying Current unit of work is on democracy and the political system Key concepts/terms Links to previous learning What are pressure groups? And what do they do? Assessment opportunities Work in exercise books in response pressure groups worksheet Differentiation Extension task for more able students is a worksheet on Greenpeace for more able students A – Z of politics BBC Life School Video VCR Work sheets on pressure groups Work sheets on Greenpeace Exercise books Homework Resources Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Time Teacher activity Student activity Learning outcomes 0–5 minutes Aims etc on the board, settle the class Class settle 5 – 15 minutes Read out the letter the class received from Downing Street (only relevant when lesson taught) but ask the class what would they do if they wanted to change something? Class take part in the discussion A 15 – 20 minutes Put on video “I for involvement” Class watch the video Towards B 20 – 35 minutes Hand out worksheet, read as a class, then assist the students with their work and hand out extension as necessary Individually, the students answer questions on the work sheet and take on the extension if necessary B and C for some 35 – 45 minutes Lead feedback on the worksheet Class take part in the discussion Consolidating B Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 WHY DO WE NEED PRESSURE GROUPS? What is a pressure group? A PRESSURE GROUP is a group of people who come together because they feel strongly about an issue and would like to put pressure organisations, such as the government to make changes. Sometimes they want to see new laws being made, or they may simply want to see improved facilities for particular groups of people. Unlike a political party, pressure groups deal with just a single issue. Their main role it to influence decision made by governments or large organisations. Why do we need pressure groups? Pressure groups are important in a democracy. They enable people to speak out for their beliefs. A group of people working together for a cause is much stronger than a protest by an individual. Pressure groups can be very powerful. At a national level they can sometimes for making the government change certain policies. Locally, a pressure group may put pressure on local bodies to change a decision, for example on the closure of a school. What methods do pressure groups use? A pressure group may hold a DEMONSTRATION The group hope their demonstration will be shown on the NEWS ON TELEVISION or be REPORTED IN NEWSPAPERS, as this could bring about more public support The group can organise PETITIONS FOR PEOPLE TO SIGN and hand into the local council or other interested organisations, in order to persuade officials to change a decision. TELEVISION ADVERTISING and INTERNET WEBSITES are a popular way of attracting attention – and donations to a cause – because they reach a large number of people. The group can POST LEAFLETS through doors, put up POSTERS and hold PUBLIC MEETINGS to attract attention to the cause. Members of the group can CONTACT AN MP to speak on behalf of their cause. The MP may be able to take action to help the pressure group outside or inside Parliament. Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 QUESTIONS 1. What is a pressure group? 2. Why can pressure groups be described as powerful? 3. Copy and complete the table below. List three other methods used by pressure groups and say why this method is used. METHOD Demonstration REASON FOR USING THIS METHOD To gain the public’s attention for their cause Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 EXTENSION TASK AN EXAMPLE OF A PRESSURE GROUP Greenpeace is an independent pressure group that uses non-violent and creative ways to expose global environmental problems and their causes. Greenpeace also researches the solutions and alternatives to help provide a path for an environmentally and peaceful future. Greenpeace organises public campaigns on the following area For the protection of oceans and ancient forest, For people to use less fossil fuels, such as coal and oil, and to promote the use of alternative energy sources to stop global warming, For the elimination of toxic chemicals, Against the release of genetically modified organisms into nature. Greenpeace gets its money from donations from the public and from organisations that fund pressure groups. Greenpeace is completely independent and has no enemies. Greenpeace started in 1971 when a small boat of volunteers and journalists sailed into Amchitka, an area north of Alaska where the US Government was conducting underground nuclear tests. This action allowed Greenpeace to start its campaigning process of “bearing witness” which is a non-violent approach to looking at people or governments damaging the environment. QUESTIONS 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Is Greenpeace a pressure group? What kind of areas does Greenpeace campaign for? Where does Greenpeace get its money? Does Greenpeace have any enemies? Describe the term “bearing witness” Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 PGCE Citizenship Lesson Plan Date/Group Lesson aims/key question Learning outcomes Links to previous learning A. Most will be able to list what kind of laws they would like to see. B. Most will be able to justify why they want these laws. C. Most will be able to recall key facts in favour of or against smacking D. Most will be able to translate the facts into a short speech E. Some will be able to analyse the debate. Laws Debate Effect Current unit of work is on democracy and the political system Assessment opportunities Contribution to class discussion Contribution to the class debate Differentiation Based on class contribution Fact sheet on smacking CBBC story on smacking Exercise books Whiteboard Key concepts/terms How do laws affect us? Homework Resources Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Time Teacher activity Student activity 0–5 minutes Settle the class Class get settled 5 – 10 minutes Teacher asks the class what laws the class would like to see and why Teacher led discussion on the board listing the laws the class would like to see. End on the question – do you think this is realistic? Class brainstorm in their books Towards A and B Class take part in the discussion A and B 20 – 25 minutes Introduce class to the story on smacking Class listen to the story Towards C 25 – 30 minutes Then get the class to discuss why smacking should be banned or why shouldn’t it be banned. Make a list in favour and against. Class take part in discussion and put findings into their books C 30 – 40 minutes Explain to the class that we are going to have a debate and tell them the rules. Put the class into two groups. They have to nominate two speakers and then write a oneminute speech. Teacher acts as chairperson of the debate and the class proceed and take a vote on the motion Class follows instructions Towards D Class participate accordingly. D and for some E 10 – 20 minutes 40 – 50 minutes Learning outcomes Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 THIS HOUSE BELIEVES THAT PARENTS HAVE THE RIGHT TO SMACK THEIR CHILDREN We are going to debate whether or not the government should be allowed to ban parents from smacking their own children. Your team has been chosen to argue that parents have the right to smack their children and that the government should not ban parents from doing so. Below are arguments in favour of parents being allowed to smack their children: Parents know what is best for their children and do not need the government interfering in how they discipline their children There is no conclusive proof to suggest that the occasional smack has any long-term effects on the child. Young children need to learn discipline and sometimes a light smack is the best way to teach this. In 2003 the Scottish Parliament attempted to ban parents from hitting children under the age of three. The proposed ban was rejected as it would have been difficult to monitor. “I don’t think smacking should be banned. It is a form of discipline. If there wasn’t smacking a lot more children would be out of control. The Government can’t choose to control how a parent brings up their child.” Gabriella, 14, London Use the above facts to write two short (30 seconds each) speeches outlining why you believe that “This house believes that parents have the right to smack their children” Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 THIS HOUSE BELIEVES THAT PARENTS HAVE THE RIGHT TO SMACK THEIR CHILDREN We are going to debate whether or not the government should be allowed to ban parents from smacking their own children. Your team has been chosen to argue that parents do not have the right to smack their children and that the government should ban parents from doing so. Below are arguments against parents being allowed to smack their children: Smacking can seriously damage children’s health – an estimated 80 UK children a year die from physical abuse. Children rights should be protected by the government. There is no evidence to suggest that a physical reprimand i.e. a smack has a positive effect on children’s behaviour Similar smacking bans are in place in Sweden and the number of children dying from physical abuse by adults has fallen dramatically The current laws enable parents who physically abuse their children to excuse themselves from hitting their children. Use the above facts to write two short (30 seconds each) speeches against the proposal “This house believes that parents have the right to smack their children” Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 PGCE Citizenship Lesson Plan Date/Group Lesson aims/key question Learning outcomes A. Most will be able to find out who their MP is, what constituency they represent, what their majority is and what party they belong to B. Most will be able to come up with a question they would like to ask their MP C. Most will be able to present their findings D. Some will be able to draft, and eventually send, an email to their MP MP Constituency Majority Current unit of work is on democracy and the political system Key concepts/terms Links to previous learning Who represents us and what do they do? Assessment opportunities Presentation of findings Question the student would like to ask their MP Email to MP Differentiation For more able students the opportunity to write an email For less able students they can present their findings using pictures Homework Resources IT Suite Access to internet explorer Interactive whiteboard Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4 Time Teacher activity Student activity Learning outcomes 0–5 minutes Settle class Class get settled 5 – 10 minutes Teacher introduces class and explains key terms – MP, constituency and majority Class act accordingly Towards A 10 – 15 minutes Teacher models the main Class act accordingly activity on the interactive whiteboard to find an MP for a specific area. The four questions are “Who is my MP?” What constituency do they represent?” “What is their majority?” and “What party do they represent?” Also the students must come up with their own question based on “What would you like to ask an MP?” Towards A 15 – 30 minutes Teacher assists individual students with their work Students search on the internet in order to answer the set questions and look at the MPs interests to research a question to ask A 30 – 40 minutes Assist the students with putting their findings into a small presentation and give the extension task to more able students Students prepare their presentations on the computers A and B and for some C 40 – 50 minutes Invite students to present their findings Individual students their findings to the class C Kate Cuddihy – Citizenship PGCE student - Institute of Education 2003/4