Fate vs. Free
Will
Es s ay
The issue of fate vs. free will is a topic that has been mulled over since the beginning of time. Some people
believe that things are fated to happen no matter what. On the other hand, others believe that fate can be
overcome by the gift of free will. We have screened three films that portray unique perspectives on this theme
in which the films’ directors have taken a definite stance in this age-old debate.
THESIS = In your opinion, which of the three films (Premonition, The Butterfly Effect, and Sliding Doors)
most accurately portrays the theme of fate vs. free will? To be successful with this, you must establish your
point of view on this topic and then chose the movie that most closely represents your ideals. Please defend
your position using support from this film in conjunction with the other two films we have screened in this unit.
You are responsible for writing a well-thought out essay with ample evidence to support your thesis—not a
diatribe of personal opinion in regards to the quality of the films. We are focusing primarily on the theme and
the expression of that message.
A successful essay will have:
Multiple pieces of evidence to support your opinion
A clear and strong organization featuring multiple well-written paragraphs
All three films represented in this COMPARISON ESSAY
Many mentions of film techniques which further enhanced the message of the theme (minimum
of three discussed)
The following typed format: 12 point, Times New Roman font, double-spaced, one-inch margins
(MLA)
Strong introduction and conclusion paragraphs with multiple body paragraphs
A length of 2-3 pages, with NO SPACING GAMES!
Proper grammar and will be obviously proof-read
Worth: 50 points
Due: Monday, February 8, 2010