UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA EFFECTS OF LOGGING OPERATIONS ON SOIL PHYSICAL PROPERTIES AND SOIL EROSION IN A HILL DIPTEROCARP FOREST OF PENINSULAR MALAYSIA BAHARUDDIN KASRAN FH 1992 3 EFFECTS OF LOGGING OPERATIONS ON SOIL PHYSICAL PROPERTIES AND SOIL EROSION IN A HILL DIPTEROCARP FOREST OF PENINSULAR MALAYSIA By BAHARUDDIN KASRAN Thesis Submitted in Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in the Faculty of Agriculture, Universiti Pertanian Malaysia December 1992 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would l ike to express my gratitude t o my major superv�sor, Mokhtaruddin Universiti bin Abdul Pertanian most sincere and deepest Associate Professor Dr. Hanan, Faculty Malaysia for his of Mohd Ag r i c u lt u r e , helpful advice, encouragement and constructlve criticisms throughout the study. Thanks Professor are Dr. Universiti also Nik due to Huhamad Pertanian my co-supe r v i s o r , A s s o c iate of Forestry, Ha)ld, Halaysla for Faculty his invaluable comments , guidance and encouragement . Special thanks are due to Associate Professor Dr. Siti Zauyah Darus and her laboratory assistants for their help in porosity analysis. I would like to acknowledge the Forest Research Institute Malaysia (FRIM) for giving me the opportunity to undertake this study. My appreciation Leader and comments. I Mohd to D r . Zaki Mohd am indebted to Abdul Rahim Hj Nik, Isa my at FRIM, cOlleagues for my project his Zulkifli valuable ¥usop and Sai fuddin Sulaiman for their cooperation. I and like to express my speclal thanks to the research staff foresters of the stesyen Kec il Jengka, collection and Hydrology FRIM, Section and field staff of for their ass istance in field data laboratory analyse s . They are Rajendran, Mohd Sahat , Ahmad Shahar, Ibrahim, Hashim, Mokhtar, Ranjer Md Nor, Ayoub, Alisbana, Mat Salleh, Mohd Adam and Ahmad Marhani . Last but wife, Tuminah not patience my deepest gratitude and for her understanding, and to my children, and least, Baharina, without which sacrifices love to my and patience; Haizal and Hamiza for their love this completed. iii project would not have TABLE OF CONTENTS Page 11 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS LIST OF TABLES . LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF PLATES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . x LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ABSTRACT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . • . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xi xii xv ABSTRAK CHAPTER I II INTRODUCTION 1 REVIEW O F LITERATURE 5 Logging System in Malaysia 5 Soil Erosion and Surface Runoff in a Tropical Forest 6 Effects o f Logging on Surface Runoff and Soil Loss 11 Effects o f Logging on Surface Runoff Effects of Logglng on Soil Loss Effects of Logglng Properties . . . . . . . . . . . III on . . . . . . . . . . METHODOLOGY . . . . . . . . . 11 . . . . . . 13 . . . . 16 Physical Soil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Experimental S ite 20 Location and Topography 20 Geology, 20 5011 and Vegetation Climate 24 Establishment of Erosion Plots 28 Data Collection 31 Rainfall 31 Surface Runoff and Soil Loss Measurement ... 32 Inf iltration Rate 32 Soil Sampling and Analyses 34 Soil Sampling 34 Soil Physical Properties 35 Statistical Analyses IV 36 38 RESULTS AND DISCUSS ION 38 Rainfall Soil Physical Properties . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . . . . • • . . . Soil Texture Bulk Density 40 40 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 Total Porosity 43 Organic Matter 51 Soil Water Characteristics 53 Infiltration Rate 56 Effects of logging on Surface Runoff and Soil Loss 59 Surface Runoff 59 Soil Loss 68 v v SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION summary . . . . . . . . . . 75 . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . • • • . • .. .. .. . 75 Conclusion 79 REFERENCES CITED 81 VITA 94 vi LIST OF TABLES Page Table 1 2 Soil Erosion and Runoff from Various Land Uses in Sarawak, Malaysia So�l Strength, Infiltration Bulk Density, Rate Air Space of Surface So il and Classified b y Types o f Disturbance . 3 of P hy si ca l Characteristics Experimental Basin . . . . . . . . . of the . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Jengka Experimental Annual Rainfall for Basin, March 1987 to February 1989 9 . . 18 . . . . 23 Study Area . 8 . 25 Climatic Conditions 7 . Jengka . 4 6 10 . . . . . . . . • . 38 Textural Compositl.on of Undisturbed Area, Skid Trails and Logging Roads of Jengka Experimental Basin 41 M.ean Soil Bulk Density of Undisturbed Skid Trails and Logging Roads o f Area, Jengka Experimental Basin 42 Mean Total Porosl.ty of Undisturbed Area, Skid Trails and Logging Roads of Jengka Experimental Basin 44 Mean Values of Total Number of Pores of Skid Trails and Logging .......... Roads of Jengka Experimental Basin Undisturbed Area, 10 11 Total Porosity and Number of Pores in Each Plot at Different Slopes of Undisturbed Area, Skid Trails and Logging Roads Organic Matter Content of Undisturbed Area, Skid Trails and Logging Roads of Jengka Experimental Basin . 12 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mean of Soil Mo�sture Characteristics of Three Different Slopes ( 1 0 , 20 and 30%) of Disturbed and Undisturbed Areas at Dif ferent Pressures vii 46 52 . . . . 53 54 13 14 15 16 Mean Available Water Capacity on Each Plot of Undisturbed and Disturbed S it e s of Jengka Experimental Basin 55 I n f iltration Rates on Undisturbed and Disturbed Experimental Basin 57 Each P l o t of Sites o f Jengka Annual Rainf a l l , Surface Runoff and from Coefficient Rainfall-Runoff Undisturbed and Disturbed Sites of Jengka Experimental Basin .......................... . Runoff Surface Annual Rainfall and Characteristics of Undist urbed Forest in Jengka Experimental Basin . . . . . 17 I. 19 20 22 . . . . and surface Skid Trails in Rainfall Annual Characteristics of Experimental Basin . . . . . . . . . 63 Runoff Jengka 64 and Surface Runoff Annual Rainfall in Jengka Characteristics of Logging Roads Experimental Basin 65 Annual Soil Loss from Control and Treatment Plots of Jengka Experimental Basin 6. Annual Soil Loss from undisturbed Forest on Different Slopes of Jengka Experimental Basin . 21 . 60 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annual Soil Loss from the on Different Slopes of Jengka Basin . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Trails Skid Experimental Annual Soil Loss from the Logging Roads on Different Slopes of Jengka Experimental . . . . . . . . . . .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basin viii 72 73 74 LIST OF FIGURES Page Figure 1 Location of Study Site 2 Layout of Jengka Experimental Basin 3 Mean Monthly Rainfall D istribution of Jengka Experimental Basin Based on Seven Years Data ( 1 981 - 1987) . . ... . . .. . ... . . . . . . . 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • • • Erosion Plots and Jengka Experimental Rainfall Portable I n f i ltration Rate I nstrument Layout Soil Pore Size Trail Monthly . 21 . 26 27 to Measure 33 D istribution for the 1987 39 the 48 for the Skid 49 Distribution for the 50 Rainfall-Runoff of the . 30 Simulator Distribution Soil Size Pore Logging Road . at Basin Monthly Rain fall Distribution During Study Period from March Two-Year to February 1989 Pore Size Soil Undisturbed Forest • 22 Mean Monthly of Some Climatic Parameters of Jengka Experimental Basin Based on Seven Years Data (1981-198 7 ) Variation 12 . Study coefficient Plots Monthly Soil Loss from Undisturbed Forest, Skid Trail and Logging Road of Jengka Experimental Basin ix 66 71 LIST OF PLATES Page Plate 1 Extraction o f Log on the Skid Trail Using Crawler 7 2 Winched Lorry 3 Erosion Plot on the Loggi ng • Regeneration Logging Road one Year After or Tractor 7 "San-Tai-Wong" of Pioneer K Road spec ie s o n Logging 29 the 62 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS FAO Food and Agriculture Organization IAHS International Association of Science IUFRO International Union Organization m.a. s . l . Meter above sea level UNESCO United Nations Educational, Cultural Organization USDA United States Department of Agriculture xi of Hydrological Forestry Research Scientific and Abstract Pertanian of thesis subm1.tted to the Malaysia in fulfillment of Senate of Universiti requirements for the the degree of Maater of Science. EFFECXS OF LOGGING OPERATIONS ON SOIL PHYSICAL PROPERTIES AND SOIL E ROSI ON IN A HILL DIPTEROCARP FOREST OF PENINSULAR MALAYSIA By KASRAN BAHARUODIN December Chairman: Associate Prof. Faculty : Agriculture The effects properti es mainly trail on and and 109g1-ng of soil severely road. Soil logging samples and road amount the plots of upper und1.sturbed area phys ical forest pa rt icu lar ly were on occurred the were of skid es tabli she d surface runoff layer Hanan Abdul soil on log g e d- over ErOS10n the from 1n s011, disturbed logging Mohd Mokhtaruddin operations erOS10n these areas to quantify loss. Dr. 1992 the and skid in soil trail, for soi l properties w e re analyzed physical properties. Significant observed as a increased by logging road, chan ges result of 1n S011 physical 10gg1.ng operat ions. The bulk density 32 percent on the sk1d trail and 42 percent on the and the total porosity 'H reduced by 62 and 69 percent, respectively. total porosity About 82 but percent Logg1ng operat1ons also of changed the tota l the consisted of elongated pores, and 1 1 . 4 percent f issures pores. porosity of 62 consisted transmission and 4 . 9 road, the figures Thus the infiltration rate lS more elongated pores that play pores. undisturbed area pores the total 6.2 pores, pores 2.6 of transmission e l ongat ed and soil than in the skid trail and on percent percent f1ssures 6.4 reduced the On the skid trail, percent are 35, onl y and Slze shape poros1ty 18.2 not percent and on the logging percent, respectively. r a p1d in undisturbed forest road because it is the 10gg10g important an role water in transmission. The higher the 1nf1ltrat1on rate the lower is the surface runo f f . The annual surface trail and undisturbed runoff forest were the total r a inf all , respect1vely. are 1 3 , 3 4 1 , and 450 10,070 major proportion of the originated from erosion occurred less severe the sediment yield skid second trails and the Y1eld 1n logged-over and year year. sk�d after On the was factors 1nfluencing 10gglng roads X III skid Th er efore a respectively. from the und�sturbed areas Slope is one of the the f1rst road, corresponding soil losses The roads logging 1 4 . 5 and 2.3 percent of 20.3, sed�ment the the kg/ha/y, l099�n9 du r1n g dur ing from dur1ng the forest tra�lB. logging other Severe and hand was the insignificant. soil erosion fi rs t year from after The amount of SOll loss in the logged-over logging operations. forest can be reduced l.f gradl ent the of the skid trails and logging roads does not exceed 20 percent. Erosion erosion control from the measures 10gglng focused should roads and skid on controlling trails. Control measures such as con str uct lon of cross drains on logging roads and skid trails must logging operations. logging ro ads condition improve of the and be done Another skl.d option t ra l ls soil such as by infiltratlon lmmedl.ate1y lS fo r to erosion improve SUb-solllng. characterl.stics enhancing regeneration of vegetatl.on. nv completion upon cont r o l the the on surface Such practice of of soils will and Abstrak Pertanian tesis Malaysia ke·pada dikemukakan bagi memenuhi universiti Senat keperluan untuk memperolehi Ijazah Master Sains. KESAK-KESAN OPERASl PEMBALAKAN KE ATAS SlFAT-SIFAT FIZlKAL DAN HAKISAN TANAH 01 HUTAH D1PTEROKAP 8UK1T 01 seMENANJUNG MALAYSIA 01eh BAHARUDDIN KASRAN Desember 1992 Pengerusi Prof. Madya Dr. Mokhtaruddin Abdul Manan Fakulti Pertanian Kesan-kesan operasi pembalakan ke atas sifat-sifat fizikal tanah dan hakisan di hutan yang telah dibalak sering berlaku di tanah yang menga1ami tarik dan ja1an ba1ak. ini bagi menentukan kerosakan yang Petak-pet.ak jum1ah air teruk, terutama hakisan larian dibina permukaan terhakis. Contoh tanah di lap�san atas jalan tarik, dan kawasan tidak diganggu telah dianalisa di di jalan kawasan dan tanah jalan balak untuk menentukan sifat-sifat fizikal tanah. Operasi atas pembalakan sifat-sifat peratus di menyebabkan fizikal tanah. jalan tarik dan berlakunya Ketumpatan 42 peratus perubahan pukal di bertambah jalan ke 32 balak. Sebaliknya jumlah keliangan masing-masing berkurangan kepada 62 ,v dan 69 peratus pembalakan bukan di jalan "tar1k sahaja jumlah keliangan di daripada liang memanjang, peratus 11.4 liang jalan mengurangkan juga mengubah bentuk dan saiz dari dan keliangan. kawasan 18.2 rekahan. jumlah 01 Jalan 82 diganggu penghantaran dan peratus 4.9 balak angka-angka tersebut ialah 35, itu proses penyusupan mudah bel"laku tarik liang peratus terdiri pula, 62 d1 6 . 2 peratus rekahan. hutan dan peratu$ Oi jalan 6 . 4 dan 2.6 peratus. berbanding di jalan tarik dan jalan balak. liang memanjang memainkan peranan bahkan liang penghantaran jumlah keliangan terdiri daripada liang memanjang, liang Operasi keliangan Kira-kira tidak peratus balak. tidak Oleh diganggu Ini disebabkan oleh penting bagi pergerakan air dalam tanah. Semakin tinggi kadar penyusupan semakin rendah air larian permukaan. Air larian permukaan tahunan di dan hutan peratus tanah tidak dari diganggu jumlah hujan" masing-masing jalan masing-masing In1 20.3, bersamaan sebanyak balak, 13, 3 4 1 , jalan 14.5 dengan 10,070 tarik dan 2.3 kehilangan 450 dan kg/ha/tahun. Oleh itu sebahagian besar hasil kelodak dari hutan telah dibalak beraeal dari jalan balak dan jalan tarik. yang teruk terjadi berkurangan pada pada tahun tahun pertama ber ikutnya. selepas Sementara pembalakan kawasan diganggu menyumbangkan sedik1t sahaja hasil kelodak. xvi Hakisan dan tidak Kecerunan mempengaruhi satu hakisan tanah tahun pertama terutama pada terhakis merupakan dari kawasan ini daripada dari faktor-faktor yang ja ' lan se lepas boleh pembalakan. dikurangkan Jumlah jika tanah kecerunan jalan tarik dan jalan balak tidak melebihi 20 peratus. Langkah-langkah mengawal langkah balak hakisan tersebut dan jalan di mencegah jalan seperti tarik kawasan ini ialah balak pembinaan ini akan diutamakan jalan parit tarik. melintang serta-merta Satu lagi cara bagi memperbaiki mengemburkan permukaan tanah di Amalan dan harus harus dilaksanakan operaei pembalakan tama t . di hakisan meningkatkan Langkahdi jalan setelah mengawal hakisan keadaan tanah seperti kawasan-kawasan tereeb u t . Kadar mempercepatkan pertumbuhan tumbuh-tumbuhan. XVlJ. untuk penyusupan dan CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION During the past two decades more than 1 . 5 million hectares of lowland tropical converted rubbe r , to oil reduction agricultural palm of constituted forests and land 75 Peninsular Malaysia have been land cocoa. forested about in mainly for This has in the percent of the planting resulted country. the in In total a massive 1955 land forest area Peninsular Malaysia. This was further reduced to 5 5 percent 1970, 50 percent in 1980 ( Chong, (Malaysia, of in in 1 9 8 5 ) and 47 . 7 percent in 1990 Ministry of primary Industries, 1991) . Most of the forested land in Malaysia today are confined to hilly areas and steep terrains and the lowland dipterocarp forests have almost been totally replaced by agricultural crops. Logging activities in the steepland areas have created a number most of serious environmental obvious areas, downstream increased are soil reservoirs. those such pertaining as erosion, the to deterioration river I n Malaysia, and ecological the in sedimentation effects of problems. hydrology water and timber The of quality, silting of harvesting on soil erosion and sedimentation have been reported by a number of investigators including Burgess ( 19 7 1 ) , Baillie ( 1972 ) , Liew (1974) , Jones ( 197 6 ) , Salleh et al . , 1 (1981a, 1981b ) , Lai and 2 Shams uddin ( 1 985 ) , Lai and Rentap (1986 ) and Baharuddin ( 1988a ) . Most of watersheds. The determining watershed. these studies common approach sediment content ( sheet, rill erosion. The logging activities of to on experimental estimate stream erosion water from by the which is attributed mainly to surface and general gully ) , sediments still stream conclusion of contributed a sediments in the stream water. of is based It provides the general idea o f the treatment effect on sediment production, erosion were remains bank these and studies significant Nevertheless, unknown. It streambed is that amount of the exact source is imperative to indicate the exact location and sediment regime i n the area so that systemat ic erosion control measures could be implemented to minimize sediment content in the streams. I n addition to sedimentation, forest harvesting operations are definitely physical Logging one properties road of and the factors aesthetic constr u c t i o n , transportation during values usage logging that of changed of heavy operations tend the the soil landscape. maChinery to and mOdify the physical properties of the upper layer of forest soil which may significantly affect regeneration growth. The impact of logging operations on soil physical properties in temperate region well documented ( Froehlich study has not been reported, 1972 ) . However , in Malaysia, except by Kamaruzaman ( 1987 ) . is such The 3 alteration of soil physical properties due to timber harvesting is c l os e l y a s s o c iated with soil loss of the area. This relationship characteristics and the soil loss variation should be studied in order to gain a better understanding of the soil erosion problem. This thesis reports a study of the relationship between timber harvesting, soil erosion and Boil physical properties in a logged-over objective forest in P e n i n s u l a r Ma lays i a . determine the is to amount of The surface general runoff and soil loss and to assess the changes in soil physical properties resulting from construction of logging road and skid trails in logged-over forest of Peninsular Malaysi a . The spec i f i c objectives are to: 1. quantify loss the from amount logging of roads, surface runoff skid and trails soil and undisturbed forest, and 2. describe some selected soil density, porosity, soil properties organic such matter, as bulk soil water characteristics and infiltration rate on the logging road, skid trail and undisturbed forest. The study was conducted in a logged-over forest at Tekam Forest Reserve, Pahang, Peninsular Malaysia. Nine erosion plots were established on three dif ferent sites, forest, namely undisturbed skid trails and logging roads. At each site, plots were 4 established on three d i fferent slope categories percent ) . operation The was study commenced completed and six continued months for a ( 10 , 20 and 30 after period years, that i s , from March 1987 to February 1989. logging of two CHAPTER II REVIEW OF LITERATURE Logging system in Malaysia Selective logging method was introduced forest management system since 1948 . in Malaysia as a It was then known as the Halayan Uni form System (MUS) (Wyatt-Smith, 1 9 6 3 ) . A new system known as the Selective Management System (SHS) was implemented in 1970 to replace HUS because the HUS system was found to be unsuitable hill 1986) . to be practiced This new system objectives of sustainability an and in the forest areas ( Thang, was designed to optimize the management economic minimum and efficient forest harvesting, development cost. forest In this system, minimum cutting limits are 45 and 50 cm diameter breast height for the non-dipterocarp and dipterocarp species. respectivel y . The logging system which has been developed in the forests of Halaysia are completely mechanized and (FAO, 1970, operations 1973; E l l i s , include tree and log transportat ion. and forest debris 1 9 7 6 ; Jones, felling, requires low capital 1976). The basic logging construction of During road construction, are pushed aside to ensure forest road the topsoil firm and level footing for the skidding operat ion. The activities during this operation and the usage o f heavy earth-moving equipment 5 such 6 as tractors cause severe soil degradat ion. and skidders In log transportation, the crawler tractor is used for skidding or hauling the logs from the felling site to temporary landing ( P l ate 1 ) . The logs that are skidded are usually largei 100 em in diameter at breast height, heavy equipment are used. to cut into logs of about 5 to 7 m long or sometimes at tree length. only 50 Under such practice, The main vehicle tranporting logs to the logyard is a winch lorry locally known as " San-TaiWong" ( Plate 2 ) . These skidding and transportation activities can cause serious degradation of soil physical properties both during the dry and wet seasons. 50il degradation and compaction resulting from logging will certainly induce surface runoff and erosion. soil Erosion and Surface Runoff in a Tropical Forest In forest the temperate is minimal for the tropical even under that forest amount dipterocarp forest 1 , 5 29 3 m /ha/y however much erosion 1975) . in (Leigh, 1987 ) . of is not true can be detected 1979; Putjaroon and Pongboon ( 19 8 7 ) Saho1nakron and 664 kg/ha/y, undisturbed Fearnside, runoff 1978; in This forest because soil erosion natural the surface (Megahan and King, Putj aroon and Pongboon, found zone , and soil loss in a dry Province of Thailand were respectively . lower when compared to that of The values abandoned are fields 7 Plate 1. Extraction of Log Using Crawler Tractor on the Plate 2. Skid Trail. Winched Lorry or "San-Tai-Wong".