Measure words in English and Chinese Group: 2 Presented by: Candy Chan, Carman Cheung, Joseph Lau Introduction 1. Measure words: refer to the quantities, properties and the reference entities of a noun 2. (i) English Nouns: - Countable nouns: entities which can be counted; have singular and plural forms - Uncountable nouns: entities which cannot be counted and do not vary for number (ii) Chinese Nouns: no clear distinction between countable and uncountable nouns, singular and plural forms Focus - Quantifying nouns - Articles - Demonstratives Body 1. QUANTIFYING NOUNS (CLASSIFIERS) - refer to quantities of both masses and entities - modify shape and property of a noun Differences - The use of classifiers English: classifier is not obligatory e.g. two books, a living Chinese: classifier is obligatory e.g. 兩本書 (grammatical) 兩書 (ungrammatical) Similarities - The use of “of-phrase” e.g. a piece of bread “Piece” is used to describe the shape of the head noun, “bread’. English countable nouns (1) Numerals e.g. three books, twenty girls (2) Quantifying nouns e.g. two sets of books, a group of girls English uncountable nouns: only quantifying nouns e.g. two rice(s) (ungrammatical) a bowl of rice / two bowls of rice (grammatical) - Compare Chinese and English syntactic structure Numeral Classifier/ quantifying noun 一 碗 a bowl Head noun 飯 of rice Difference in syntactic structure - an extra word “of” in English noun phrase to link up the two nouns (i.e. bowl and rice) 2. ARTICLE Articles: Present in English; absent in Chinese A. Indefinite article - to show a new specific entity in discourse Differences - article vs number and classifer English: indefinite article is present e.g. a cat, an activity Chinese: number and classifier are used e.g. 一隻貓, 一項活動 Similarities - specificity is preserved a cat = 一隻貓 - singularity both “a” and “一” show the meaning of “one” -Compare Chinese and English syntactic structure Numeral Classifier/ quantifying Head noun noun 一 隻 貓 A Cat Difference in syntactic structure An extra classifier is needed in Chinese. B. Definite article - to specify the referent of the noun phrase known from the discourse Difference: English: definite article is present e.g. … the accident killed more than 30 people. Chinese: demonstrative and classifier is optional in some cases e.g. … (今次)事件做成超過三十人死亡… Similarities - specificity is preserved the accident = (今次)意外 - quantity is shown …the students are punished = 這些學生被受到懲罰 -Compare Chinese and English syntactic structure Specifier Classifier/ quantifying Head noun noun (今) (次) 意外 The Accident Difference in syntactic structure An extra classifier is needed; numeral and classifier are sometimes optional. 3. Demonstratives The demonstratives are used as determiners to refer to either people or objects. They indicate whether the things are near or far from the speaker . English : This , That , These, Those Chinese: 這 , 那 , 這些 , 那些 Demonstratives with classifiers This , That ( singular nouns or uncountable nouns ) 這 , 那 English: - This/That + noun Eg. This book , That boy. - Specify the unit of the thing this piece of paper that bunch of flowers - Use of classifiers is optional Chinese: - Demonstratives + Classifier + Noun Eg. 這張桌子 , 那本小說 - Sometimes the classifier can be omitted ( eg.那人很討厭 ), but this does not apply to all cases. Eg. ‘這戲很精彩’ and ‘我要買那魚’ sounds unnatural. Eg. 我同呢個人傾計 ( Cantonese ). These, Those ( plural nouns ) 這些 , 那些 The use of these demonstratives are similar in English and Chinese. English: These/ Those + Noun ( Eg. These pens, Those cars ) Chinese: 這些筆 , 那些車輛 - No classifier is needed here and the syntactic structure of these phrases is the same in both Chinese and English. - if we mention the quantity of the objects when we use demonstratives, the classifier will be needed. - For example, ‘ 這三隻小鳥’ or ‘那幾幅畫’. Some distinctive features of Classifiers in Chinese: - There are some special features of Chinese classifiers that cannot be found in English which is the use of reduplication. Repeating the classifiers in various ways can express different meanings. 1. reduplicating the classifier after ‘一’ eg 他把一個個杯放在架上 ( He put many cups on the shelf. ) 2. 一個一個 eg 學生一個一個進入禮堂 ( The students enter the hall one by one .) 3. reduplicating the classifier itself eg. 隻隻貓都好得意 ( All the cats are cute.) Conclusion The use of classifiers in English is optional. In English, the classifiers are used with quantifying nouns or uncountable nouns. The use of classifiers in Chinese is obligatory. In Chinese, a classifier is needed for any noun which is preceded by a numeral or a demonstrative. The use of classifiers with articles and demonstratives in the two languages are different to a great extent. Reduplication of Chinese classifiers can express different meanings.