World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Entry ID: NA05-2 COUNTRY: Colorado, USA Permission YEAR: 2005 LANGUAGE: English TITLE: National Institute for Urban School Improvement (NIUSI): Leadership Academies AUTHOR/DEVELOPER: National Institute for Urban School Improvement (NIUSI) CONTACTS/AVAILABILITY: All academy materials available online at: http://urbanschools.org/professional.html National Institute for Urban School Improvement University of Colorado at Denver and Health Sciences Center 1380 Lawrence Street, Suite 625 Denver, CO 80204 NIUSI Phone: 303.556.3990 NIUSI Fax: 303.556.6141 NIUSI Email: niusi@cudenver.edu Shelley Zion Project Coordinator shelley.zion@cudenver.edu Elizabeth B. Kozleski Director & Principal Investigator elizabeth.kozleski@cudenver.edu [About the NIUSI] Mission The mission of the National Institute for Urban School Improvement (NIUSI) is to support inclusive urban schools. NIUSI works with communities and families to build their capacity for sustainable, successful urban education. NIUSI helps develop powerful networks of urban school districts and schools that embrace and implement a data-based, continuous improvement approach for inclusive practices. Products & Outcomes NIUSI's products and outcomes include: Syntheses of research, policy, and reports on the linkage of general and special education reform in urban schools; Action research tools for school improvement; Policy recommendations for achieving restructured inclusive school communities; Leadership Academies focused on expanding inclusive practices in urban schools Urban school & higher education partnerships; A national network of parents, education professionals, community leaders, and advocacy groups interested in ensuring the inclusion of students with disabilities as a component of systemic educational reform in urban school districts. Federal Reports, Accomplishments and Achievements [About the Leadership Academies] NIUSI has developed a set of leadership academies that are designed to support urban schools as they develop inclusive teaching and learning environments for their students. Each academy is designed as a 3-hour learning experience for building leadership teams who come together on a regular basis to explore the process of becoming inclusive. The academies are designed so that team members can build, implement, and explore their inclusive, urban knowledge base together. All academies are based on the National Institute’s assumptions that great schools: 1 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Use the valuable knowledge and experience that children and their families bring to school learning. Expand students’ like opportunities, available choices, and community contributions. Construct education for social justice, access, and equity. Build on the extraordinary resources that urban communities provide for life-long learning. Need individuals, family, organization, communities to work together to created future generations of possibility. Practice scholarship by creating partnerships for action-based research and inquiry. Shape their practice based on evidence of what results in successful learning of each students. Foster relationships based on care, respect, and responsibility. Produce high achieving students. Understand that people learn in different ways throughout their lives; great schools respond with learning opportunities that work. Academies are bundled into modules. These modules are our 2005 releases. As we hear from you and others who use these modules, we will upgrade and improve our products for future 2006 and beyond versions. Don't forget to let us know what worked and what needs tuning. [Modules/Academies] Overview (Modules): MODULE 1: Building Leadership Teams MODULE 2: Mining Data MODULE 3: Inclusive Schools MODULE 4: Co-Teaching MODULE 5: Assessment Overview (Materials): Facilitator Manual Presentation Materials (Materials to use when you conduct training) Overview PowerPoint (Overview of the Leadership Academy; overview of a particular academy; agenda) Lecturette PowerPoint Participant Handouts Timecards (“10minutes” “5minutes” “1minute” signs) Additional material depending on the specific topics of each Academy MODULE 1: Building Leadership Teams Academy 1: Leading Change Academy Objectives: Define Building Leadership Team Roles Identify Building Leadership Team Responsibilities Acquire strategies to run productive meetings Recognize change tensions Develop strategies for easing the change process for individuals and groups 2 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Agenda Introduction & Overview Activity 1: Building Leadership Team Roles and Responsibilities In this activity, participants identify Building Leaderships Team roles and responsibilities, and examine how each participant contributes to effective meetings. Lecturette 1 – Leaders’ Guide to Change This presentation introduces participants to the different personality types (e.g., ‘organizers’ type, ‘actors’ type, ‘analyzers’ type, ‘relaters’ type) they will face when presenting change efforts, and describes how to communicate change efforts. o Things to Remember: Develop trust. Lead change by focusing on the needs of your team members and organization. Know your change audience. Practice communication skills. Be aware of cultural influences and personality traits that affect communication styles. Finally, listen and correct your course according to feedback. Activity 2: Change Persuasion In this activity, participants examine change attitudes to discover possible methods for leading change efforts. Lecturette 2: Components of Effective Change This lecturette introduces the components of effective change and how each component is necessary for change to take place. o Elements of Effective Change: Vision – without it, a change causes confusion Incentives - without it, a change causes slow change Skills - without it, a change causes anxiety Resources – without it, a change causes frustration Action Plan - without it, a change causes false starts Activity 3: Identifying Change Gaps In this activity, participants use tools to implement change at their own sites. Academy 2: Gauging Your Systemic Change Efforts Academy Objectives: Identify levels of systemic change Explore and edit a survey tool for gathering evidence for current status at their site Identify targets within the levels of systemic change Develop strategies for leveraging change Analyze the structural and human side of leading change efforts Agenda: Introduction and Overview Activity 1: Systemic Change In this activity, participants learn about the Systemic Change Framework, and determine how to use systemic levels to instigate change. District effort & support 3 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) School organizational effort Professional effort Lecturette 1: Leveraging Change through Strategic Planning Successful change efforts don’t just happen, they are planned. This lecturette stresses that change efforts are iterative, and the steps are successive. But as new developments arise, change agents must reevaluate their goals and resources to remain focused and ultimately successful. The Planned Change Process Step 1: Exploring Step 2: Assessment and Planning Step 3: Commitment Building Step 4: Implementing Change Step 5: Integrating Change Step 6: Assessing Progress Step 7: Growing Activity 2: Leveraging Change In this activity participants examine effective change measures. Participants then use an organizational tool to plan an effective change effort. Lecturette 2: Planning Change After learning how to implement change, BLTs must have the skills and knowledge to implement the process in their own schools. This lecturette introduces the use of needs assessments and change planning processes. Goals to Outcomes o GOALS: NIUSI Principles o Are we meeting this goal? (If no, move on to next question) o What change should occur? o OUTCOMES: Ideal outcome PATH - Planning for Alternative Tomorrows with Hope (PATH) is a process for planning for the future. Begin with the end in mind. o Step 1: Ideal Outcome o Step 2: What Change Needs to Happen? Use these questions on your proposed change(s) to analyze its likelihood for success. Control: To what degree is this something that we have control to change or address? Priority: How would students, family, and community members rank this challenge in terms of priority? Trend: Based on the data, is this challenge likely to get worse, stay the same or get better? What is the potential cost if not addressing it now? Practicality: What is the likelihood of success? Does your team have access to known solutions? Is there expertise or support available to address this challenge? Urgency: What relevance does this challenge have to your school’s current goals or needs? Scope: What is the breadth and depth of benefits of addressing this challenge? How many students would benefit if you addressed this challenge? Which students would benefit? Big picture: To what extent will addressing this challenge prepare your organization to take on more systemic or long-term goals? 4 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Impact: How likely are we to make a significant difference for students by addressing this challenge? o Step 3: Who Do We Enlist? o Step 4: What Resources Do We Need? o Step 5: Planning Next Steps Activity 3: Planning and Surveying Change In this activity, participants practice effective change measures by using survey and planngin tools. Academy 3: Aligning School Goals and School Work Academy Objectives: Develop a continuous improvement cycle for tracking their change process Synthesize anecdotal, observational, and frequency evidence for making adjustments to support positive climate for change in their building Agenda: Activity 1: Evaluating Change In this activity, participants learn techniques to evaluate change efforts. Lecturette 1: Evidence of Change Use this presentation to teach participants how evidence can be used to develop a goals progress checklist Evidence of Change Anecdotal evidence Observational evidence Frequency evidence Activity 2: Making Progress In this activity, participants create action plans for making change in their schools. Lecturette 2: Continuous Improvement After learning how to implement change, BLTs must have the skills and knowledge to continue the improvement process. Developing a Continuous Improvement Cycle Checking back in Adjusting strategy Modifying goals Adapting behaviors Activity 3: Develop a Continuous Improvement Plan In this activity, participants gain experience in order to implement continuous improvement in their own schools. MODULE 2: Mining Data Academy 1: Mining Meaningful Data Academy Objectives: Clarify their reasons or rationale for using data to change practice. Identify and align meaningful data to renew their school improvement efforts to be more culturally responsive. Determine what data should be used to guide practice. Use school wide improvement survey and other forms of displaying outcomes to analyze data. 5 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Agenda: Activity 1: Mining Report Card Data This activity gives participants an opportunity to evaluate report cards for gathering data about school. Lecturette 1: Mining System-wide Data This presentation outlines issues that influence data collection and use. The lecturette will build on Activity 1. It provides the basis for Activity 2. “If we seek to improve student performance we must focus on the work or learning experiences we provide to students” (Schlechty, 2002). o QUESTION: How are the learning experiences provided by our district, school or classrooms failing these students? Activity 2: Diverse Instructional Data This provides an opportunity for participants to identify various data available to instructors for supporting change in their schools. Lecturette 2: Identifying Evidence that will Change Practice This lecurette outlines change issues that teachers face in the school. It provides the basis for Activity 3. Data Do Not Consist of Only Test Scores o Data are the work students and teachers do every day, collected to serve specific purposes, potential uses, and answer different questions. Activity 3: Using Data to Support School Improvement Strong instruction comes from accurate and timely information about individual students. In the old paradigm, teachers taught the curriculum without the advantage of understanding individual student needs, thus leaving out or gliding over individual differences. In the new accountability paradigm, assessment is about continuously improving the teachers’ performance and, ultimately, improving kids’ access and master of content and learning skills. Academy 2: Identifying School-Wide Patterns of Student Performance Academy Objectives: Identify a set of questions that will continually guide their leadership efforts for culturally responsive practices. Match the kinds of data that can be collected with those questions. Establish an ongoing process for measuring change effects. Understand the impact of progress in the building from a complex framework of change mechanisms. Agenda: Activity 1: Fishbone Activity In this activity participants will identify and discuss issues surrounding the evidence. Lecturette 1: Richness and Complexity of Student Data This lecturette includes strategies for overcoming assessment challenges facing instructors. Activity 2: Understanding the Challenges: Assessing Your School’s Student Achievement This affords the participation the opportunity to examine daily use of data and the challenges that such generation and use present. 6 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Lecturette 2: Using Student Data: Understanding The Challenges This lecturette outlines issues that influence data collection and use. The lecturette builds on Activity 2. It provides the basis for Activity 3. Continuous improvement Educators need a process for data use that supports ongoing, continuous improvement. Quality assessments High-quality school-based assessment systems let educators know what students have learned and what they have not, as well as what is being taught effectively and what needs to be taught better. Assessment and action research Once teachers begin to use assessment techniques that provide information about their classrooms, they can begin to ask questions about the effects of one kind of practice or another. A smorgasbord of data sources Existing Archival Sources Conventional and Inventive Sources Document Review Select a balance of data sources to meet your goals! Activity 3: Tracking Change The activity is designed to assist participation in examining the types of changes that might or should occur, how to identify those changes and how to incorporate them in a school improvement schema. Academy 3: Looking at Student Work to Target Instruction Academy Objectives: Lead a protocol with faculty on student work samples. Assist faculty in defining goals for enhancing their teaching practice with all students. Aggregate information from student work sample meetings to identify new targets for professional development, outreach to families and technical assistance to teachers or programs within the building. Agenda: Activity 1: Student Work Analysis In this activity participants will determine the use and significance of student work in information instructional decision making. Lecturette 1: Looking at Student Work This lecturette provides a means of understanding the ways in which schools have used inquiry and data to make decisions about classroom and school practices. How to Analyze Multiple Sources of Data for Patterns o Describe o Interpret o Reflect Are the Results Expected? Assessments aren’t perfect. Be aware of the results. Are they accurately assessing the situation? Do you need to reassess? Do you need to use a different assessment? Surprises? Assessments sometimes reveal surprises. You may have thought that 7 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) your students understood a particular issue, but the assessment shows otherwise. Take this opportunity to use another assessment to reevaluate this item and be sure that your students are learning what they need to know. Strengths and Weaknesses? An assessment’s data of students’ strengths and weaknesses are a good way to evaluate your instructional strategies. What questions are raised from the data? At this point, what else do you need to know? Do you need further data? Are you ready to move forward? Activity 2: Identifying Patterns in Data to Improve Instructions This activity allows participants to determine how to make better use of student data. Lecturette 2: Steps to Improve Data Use This lecturette provides information on how to gather data from multiple sources to positively change instruction based on reliable measures. Enhance Credibility and Validity of Assessments Provide safeguards. Make the case. Don’t put all of the weight on a single test. Place more emphasis on comparisons of performance from year to year. Consider both value added and status in the system. Recognize, evaluate, and report. Put a system in place. School Culture How do staff members demonstrate high expectations for all students? Who’s Teaching and Learning? Is professional development valued in the school? How do teachers learn to improve their instruction? Questions for Schools to Help Them Use Data Well: How is time used in the building? How often do teachers examine practices? What kind of discussions and observations occur? What are the mentoring practices? How are topics for workshops developed Who does technical assistance? Activity 3: Gathering Data to Inform Practice The activity is designed to assist participation in immediately implementing goals for improving instructional practice. MODULE 3: Inclusive Schools Academy 1: Understanding Inclusive Schooling Academy Objectives: Define inclusive schooling. Distinguish between exemplars of inclusive and non-inclusive practices. Place their own schools on a continuum of growth from “on the radar screen” to “distinguished practice.” Use appreciative inquiry to explore the capacities of schools to do such work. 8 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Agenda: Activity 1: What is Inclusive Education and Why Do We Do It? This activity is designed to open up the discourse about what we mean by inclusive education and the fundamental beliefs that undergird the continued press for a unified system of education that brings together the work of general and special education. Participants will be expected to assess where their schools currently are in terms of inclusive education and interact with a series of vignettes designed to engage their value system and beliefs about students. Lecturette 1 – Defining Inclusion This lecurette covers the historical attitudes toward teaching, the new trend toward including all students in the regular classroom, and personalizing instruction for each student. Systemic Inclusion: A process of meshing general and special education reform initiatives and strategies in order to achieve a unified system of public education that incorporates all children and youth as active, fully participating members of the school community; that views diversity as the norm; and that maintains a high quality education for each student by assuring meaningful curriculum, effective teaching, and necessary supports. Activity 2: Pathways to Inclusive Education Participants inteact with a series of rubrics tha tare organized around the systemic change framework introduced in Module 1. Participants identify anecdotal evidence that will help them place their own school’s progress towards inclusive practices. Lecturette 2: Appreciative Inquiry This lecturette describes appreciative inquiry and the 4 steps it includes: discover, dream, design, and deliver. Appreciative Inquiry: Appreciative Inquiry was developed by David Cooperrider and Suresh Srivastva in the 1980s. The approach is based on the premise that ‘organizations change in the direction in which they inquire.’ o Choose to see possibilities, capabilities and assets o Focus on what's right, rather than what's wrong o Develop questions to uncover moments of top performance o Create the future you desire Appreciative Inquiry vs. Problem-Solving Thinking Problems-Solving Thinking Appreciative Inquiry Problems Possibilities “The glass is half empty” “The glass is half full” Problem-driven Vision-led Money Meaning Scarcity of resources Abundance of Resources Critical thinking Generative thinking Resistance Energy Incremental advances Unprecedented breakthroughs Token promises Full-of-meaning commitments Using others Collaboration with others Transactions Relations Professionally directed Self-directed Taught – as admonitions Learned – by example 4D Model of Appreciative Inquiry 9 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Discover Dream Design Deliver Activity 3: Designing an Inclusive School This activity provides an opportunity for participants to practice leading the process of appreciative inquiry around an arena that they are familiar with. Encourage teams to work together on this process and both engage the act and consider how they might improve their leadership so that their whole faculty could participate. Academy 2: Exploring Inclusive Practices in Schools Academy Objectives: Articulate features of school climates and structures that facilitate inclusive education. Discover how to work with teams (vertical, grade level, content area) to identify staffing and curriculum approaches for inclusive schooling. Agenda: Activity 1: Snowball In this activity, participants get warmed up to learn about inclusion. They draw on background knowledge to discuss current issues and trends on inclusion that interest the group at large. Lecturette 1: Shifts in Thinking and Practice that Support Inclusive Schooling Use this presentation to make the connection between general education school reforms that are consistent with a broader move to more inclusive practices in order to really make the strong point that inclusive schools are inclusive of everybody and that there is a lot already happening in most schools that is already consistent with being inclusive of students with disabilities along with students from different cultures, who speak different languages, and who have different family lives. 5 Key Shifts in Practice o Teaching to Learning: o Classroom Curriculum based on Focus on Learning o Service to Support: o Individual Practice to Group Practice: o Reform to Continuous Improvement and Renewal: o Parent Involvement to Family and Community Linkages Activity 2: Finding the Seeds of Inclusive Change in Your School Once all the kinds of reform practices that are consistent with inclusive schools have been called to the minds of participants, use the “Finding Seeds” handouts to help each school team identify the “seeds of inclusive change” that exist in their school and are ripe for nurturing. Lecturette 2: Using Teams to Achieve Inclusion This lecturette introduces the value of teams and their impact on inclusive schools. It covers three kinds of teams: vertical, grade-level and content area. What is a teacher learning team? A teacher learning team is a small, group of individuals joining together to increase their capacities through new learning for the benefit of students. What can learning teams accomplish for our school? o Support the implementation of curricular and instructional innovations o Integrate and give coherence to a school’s instructional practices and 10 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) programs o Study research on teaching and learning and share with whole staff o Monitor the impact of innovations on students and on changes in the work place 3 Types of Teacher Learning Team o Vertical Teaming o Grade Level Teaming o Content Area Teaming Activity 3: Teaming Toward Goal In this activity, participants use teaming strategies to help schools become more inclusive. Academy 3: Exploring Inclusive Practices in Classrooms Academy Objectives: Identify features of inclusive curriculum design. Identify features of inclusive pedagogy. Identify features of inclusive classroom climates. Agenda: Activity 1: Support Services In this activity, participants identify disabilities at all levels of intensity and the services offered for those students. Lecturette 1: Person-Centered Planning Use this presentation to explain that person-centered planning is a way to bring in a variety of people to make the best decision for a student’s education. Making Action Plan (MAP) - What is a MAP? helps you get from one place to another; a guide; a way to go from here to there. The 7 MAP Questions History Dream Nightmare Who is the student Strengths Needs Ideal day Planning Alternative Tomorrows with Hope (PATH) PATH evolved from the MAPs process. It offers an opportunity to extend the MAPs steps and to put into place a plan of action. Step #1 - Touching the Dream ! Step #2 - Sensing the Goal / Imagine / Tell us what happened! / Positive & Possible Step #3 - Grounding in the NOW Step #4 – Enroll / Who do we need? Step #5 - Recognizing Ways to Build Strength Step #6 - Let’s Do It! / Charting Action for the Next Few Months Step #7 - Planning the Next Month’s Work 11 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Step #8 - Committing to the First Step Circle of Friends (Support) Circle 1: The Circle of Intimacy Circle 2: The Circle of Friendship Circle 3: The Circle of Participation Circle 4: The Circle of Exchange Activity 2: Facilitating a Student PATH In this activity, participants determine a student’s support opportunities within a school. Lecturette 2: Inclusion at the Classroom Level This lecturette provides tips on how to provide inclusive curricula, pedagogy and classroom climate. o Inclusive curricula o Inclusive instruction o Inclusive classroom climates o Discipline plan o Grouping o Assistive technology o Collaborative teamwork o Physical settings in classroom Activity 3: Creating an Inclusive Classroom In this activity, participants use strategies to create an ideal inclusive classroom based on inclusive curricula, climate and pedagogy. MODULE 4: Co-Teaching Academy 1: Working Together: General and Special Education Academy Objectives: Identify expectations for collaboration and consultation between general and special educators Explore the skills that educators need to collaborate successfully Examine the time needed for successful collaboration and how buildings develop schedules that create time for collaborators to plan and evaluate together Examine current practice in their own buildings and identify strengths and needs Agenda: Activity 1: Sharing a Classroom This activity provides a background on co-teaching and gives participants a chance to identify their own feelings about co-teaching. Lecturette 1: Making Co-teaching a Success This lecturette is an overview of the eight components of the co-teaching relationships as given by Susan E. Gately and Frank J. Gately Jr. It also provides an explanation of the common co-teaching issues faced by new co-teachers. 8 Components of Co-Teaching Interpersonal Communication Physical Arrangement Familiarity with the Curriculum Curriculum Goals and Modifications Instructional Planning 12 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Instructional Presentation Classroom Management Assessment Common Co-Teaching Issues Whose students are these? Who gives grades? How do we grade? Whose classroom management rules do we use? What space do I get? What do we tell the students? What do we tell the parents? How can we get time to co-plan? Activity 2: Believing in Co-teaching This activity gives participants a chance to apply their own beliefs to the co-teaching components outlines in the lecturette. Lecturette 2: Scheduling Co-teaching This lecturette reviews many scheduling issues that buildings face when implementing co-teaching. Activity 3: Time for Co-teaching This activity gives participants a chance to analyze their own schools and come up with ideas on how to implement co-teaching. Academy 2: Co-teaching Strategies Academy Objectives: Identify a set of co-teaching strategies and their research base Distinguish between exemplar and non-exemplars of practice Measure co-teaching skills and identify areas for improvement Examine how these models can be expanded to provide blended special and general education opportunities for students Analyze strategies for developing co-teaching skills and practices among their general and special education staff Agenda: Activity 1: Co-teaching: 9 Approaches This activity gives participants opportrunity to apply the given teaching approaches. Lecturette 1: The Foundation of Co-teaching This lecturette covers the pros and cons of each kind of co-teaching approach. It also identified some of the research that has been done on co-teaching. The 9 Co-teaching Strategies Duet Model: Teacher A&B: Both teachers plan and design instruction. Teachers take turns delivering various components of the lesson. Lead and Support Model: Teacher A: Primary responsibility for planning a unit of instruction. Teacher B: shares in delivery, monitoring, and evaluation. Speak and Add/Chart Model: Teacher A: Primary responsibility for designing and delivering. Teacher B: Adds and expands with questions, rephrasing, anecdotes, recording key information on charts, 13 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) transparencies, or boards. Skill Group Model: Teacher A&B: Both teachers share in the design and delivery of instruction. One teacher is primarily responsible for the auditory and visual instructions, the other for tactile and kinesthetic instruction. Station Teaching Model: Teacher A: Responsible for overall instruction. Teacher B: Teaches a small group specific skills they have not mastered. Learning Style Model: Teacher A&B: Both teachers share in the design and delivery of instruction. One teacher is primarily responsible for the auditory and visual instructions, the other for tactile and kinesthetic instruction. Parallel Teaching Model: Teachers A&B; Both teachers plan and design. The class splits into two groups. Each takes a group for the entire lesson. Complementary Instruction Model: Teacher A: Primary responsibility for delivering core content. Teacher B: Primary responsibility for delivering related instruction in the areas of study and survival skills. Adapting Model: Teacher A: Primary responsibility for planning and delivering a unit of instruction. Teacher B: Determines and provides adaptations in the moment for students who are struggling. Activity 2: The Case for Co-teaching This activity gives participants a chance to co-plan. Lecturette 2: Exemplary Co-teaching This lecturette provides a framework for exemplary co-teaching as developed by Marilyn Friend. Characteristics of Exemplary Co-Teaching Philosophy: o Teachers are deeply committed to educating all students. o Teachers believe that two viewpoints create a stronger instructional environment. o Teachers believe the possibilities are endless and that there is always something new to learn/try to help students succeed. Personal Characteristics: o Teachers are flexible and forgiving of each other. o Teachers are strong and highly competent professionals. o Teachers have highly developed skills related to their areas of expertise (e.g., curriculum, individualization.) Collaborations: o Teachers tend to use “we” language in discussing students and instruction. o Teachers share key decisions, but complete many tasks individually. o The contribution of each professional is equally valued, and teachers can discuss differences without becoming defensive. Classroom Practices: o Classroom visitors seldom can tell which educator is a general educator and which educator is a special educator. o Students look to teachers equally for guidance. o Classroom instructional practices are highly differentiated. o Several services are unobtrusive but clearly carried out. 14 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) o A variety of co-teaching approaches are employed. Context: o Teachers use allocated planning time efficiently and effectively, and they create additional planning minutes as needed. o Teachers recognize the place of co-teaching in a larger service delivery system. o Teachers make decisions on services based on student needs, not traditional practices. o Teachers can implement fluid service delivery. Activity 3: Perfecting Co-teaching Participants are given a chance to use the knowledge gained in the lecturette between exemplary and average co-teaching skills. Academy 3: Co-Planning Curriculum Using State Standards Academy Objectives: Provide a rationale for co-curricular planning in inclusive schools Explore the relationship between planning for state standards-based curriculum and IEP goals Tailor a set of planning processes to meet their own building context Identify ways to implement co-planning in their own buildings Agenda: Activity 1: Segregated Planning This is an introduction to co-planning. In this activity, participants are given a chance to start planning a lesson individually; in the next activity, they will cooperate with another teacher to co-plan and develop a richer lesson that includes all students in a given classroom. Lecturette 1: Planning Curriculum in an Inclusive School This lecturette describes the features of IEP and State Standards driven lesson planning. Activity 2: Co-planning a Daily Lesson This activity allows educators the opportunity to co-plan an activity on a real-life situation. Lecturette 2: When Co-Planning Works This lecturette identifies ways that teachers can find additional time to co-plan. Two classes team to release one teacher Use other adults to help cover classes Find funds for substitutes Find “volunteer substitutes” Use instructionally relevant videotapes or other programs to release part of the staff Arrange time during school-based staff development Experiment with a late arrival or early dismissal day Stay late after school once per month Treat collaboration as the equitant of school committee responsibilities In elementary schools, divide labor for instruction to save time Reduce other work Special educators 15 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Activity 3: Implementing Co-planning in Your School This activity gives participants a chance to apply the skills and knwoeldge learned in the Academy to their own school. MODULE 5: Assessment Academy 1: Classroom Assessment Practices Academy Objectives: Create clear learning outcomes for students and explain differences among types of outcomes. List the four main approaches for assessing student learning and explain the tradeoffs with each. Match assessment approaches with learning outcomes. Design a sound assessment Agenda: Activity 1: Identifying Student Assessments In groups, participants make a list of all the types of assessments they can identify, and a master list for the group is created on chart paper. Lecturette 1: Student Learning Outcomes This lecturette explains key features of quality outcomes and discusses different categories such as knowledge, reasoning, skills, products, and dispositions. Diffrerent Types of Learning Outcomes (Bloom’s Taxonomy) Knowledge: Knowledge refers to mastery of subject matter knowledge, such as math or history. Reasoning: Reasoning refers to the ability to use knowledge and understanding to figure things out and solve problems, such as critical thinking or analytical thinking. Performance Skills: Performance skills refer to the development of proficiency in carrying out an activity such as reading aloud or playing a musical instrument. Products: Products refer to the ability to create products such as science fair models, research papers, or software programs. Dispositions: Dispositions refer to the development of certain kinds of feelings or attitudes such as a positive self-concept or motivation. Activity 2: Writing Quality Outcomes Participants individually write one or two learning outcomes and then receive feedback on these outcomes in groups of three. Lecturette 2: Assessments of Student Learning This lecturette highlights four assessment approaches: selected response, essay, performance, and oral communication. It also considers which assessment approach best fits which outcome type. Assessment Categories o Selected Responses Multiple choice True/false Matching 16 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Short answer fill-in Essay assessment Describe Compare and contrast Persuade Take a particular point-of-view Performance Assessment o Demonstrate a skill o Prepare a product Personal communication Desk-side conversations Interviews Conferences Listening during class discussions Activity 3: Designing Sound Assessments Using the outcomes that participants identified in Activity 2, participants identify the type(s) of learning they are targeting and choose an appropriate assessment approach to design. Using the planning guide, they then describe key elements of the assessment task. Finally, they read their assessment planning guide to another group member, who gives responses in the form of critical questions. Academy 2: Rubrics for Assessing Student Learning Academy Objectives: Create a rubric for assessing student learning outcomes. Describe the process for designing a rubric. Apply a rubric in assessing examples of student work. Describe the purposes and conditions for using rubrics. Agenda: Activity 1: Create a Rubric In this whole group experience, participants go through a series of step-by-step activities in which they create a rubric for assessing a particular outcome (i.e., students will be able to deliver an effective public speech or oral presentation). Lecturette 1: Hooked on Rubrics The pros and cons of rubrics are discussed, as well as the purpose and conditions for creating rubrics. Activity 2: Applying a Rubric The participants are given the Delaware Student Testing Program Instructional Guide to Writing and asked to apply the rubric to samples of student work. Lecturette 2: Analyzing a Rubric Several examples of rubrics of different designs, as different grade levels, and in different content areas are presented. Activity 3: Designing Your Own Rubric Participants are asked, as individuals or in groups, to identify an outcome and develop a rubric for measuring that outcome. Academy 3: High Quality Performance Assessment Tasks Academy Objectives: Articulate important features of a high quality performance assessment task Critique a performance assessment task; and 17 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) Develop performance assessment tasks. Agenda: Activity 1: Analyze a Performance Task: Insect Classification Participants will infer goals and objectives from a performance task on insect classification. Lecturette 1: Designing a Quality Performance Assessment Task This lecturette identifies questions for participants to ask themselves when designing an assessment. It also covers possible accommodations for assessment tasks. Questions to guide you in planning, designing, and implementing a performance assessment task. 1. What learning outcomes are targets with this assessment? For example, “Students will be able to write an engaging and literate personal narrative” might be the learning target to be assessed. 2. What is the skill and/or product to be assessed? In this example, the product to be assessed is a written text created by students in writer’s workshop over a two-week period. 3. What is the purpose and audience for the assessment? The purpose and audience in this example is the teacher who is seeking evidence of her student’s achievement level in writing. The teacher will be assessing the performance, though peers are invited to give feedback and the students themselves are asked to rate their performance. Thus, other purposes of the assessment are to promote students self-assessment and peer-to-peer assessment. 4. What are the criteria and level for the performance? The criteria are the six categories of six-trait writing and the three levels are “developing, proficient, and advanced.” Activity 2: Analyzing a Performance Assessment Task: Static Electricity In this activity, participants critique an existing performance assessment task. Lecturette 2: Identify Features of a Quality Performance Assessment This lecturette covers the features of a quality performance task. Features of Quality Performance Tasks o Essential rather than Tangential - The task focuses on the big ideas in the curriculum. o Authentic rather than Contrived - The task resembles real world endeavors. o Rich rather than Superficial - The task generates questions and more investigations. o Engaging rather than Uninteresting - The task is thought-provoking and motivating o Active rather than Passive - The task requires active processing of information. o Feasible rather than Infeasible - The task must be something that can be accomplished in the time allotted and with the resources available. o Equitable rather than Inequitable - The task draws on and develops a variety of ways of thinking. o Open rather than Closed - The task offers multiple solution paths and more than one right answer. Activity 3: Creating Your Own Performance Assessment Task 18 World Bank Teacher Training for Inclusive Education Database SECTION I: Training Manuals, Modules, Packages, Programs, etc. (Last updated on 1/2/2006) This activity allows participants to create their own performance assessment task. TARGET: policy makers school administrators preschool teachers primary ed teachers secondary ed teachers higher ed teachers sped teachers pre-service teachers related service providers families students community members TOPIC: introduction/philosophical understanding of inclusive education/getting started effective teaching/assessment strategies challenging behaviors team work, collaboration family/community involvement networking developing policy dealing with change HIV/AIDS advocacy/leadership skills others PHASE: awareness raising/introduction/advocacy phase on-going support/development follow-up/monitoring others 19